Chapter 15 Theological Framework for Youth Ministry: Grace
Chapter 15
Theological Framework for Youth Ministry: Grace
Rodger Nishioka
“I’m not sure I need to be in your class,” said the student as he walked into the first session of the course on ministry with youth and young adults. “But I needed an elective so I took this one.”
“Why do you think you might not need to be here? Aren’t you studying to be a pastor?” I asked, somewhat perplexed.
“Well, yes. But I think I have good instincts in doing youth ministry,” he said. “And I have a lot of fun with kids, and they seem to like me. I guess it’s a no-brainer.”
“Explain to me why your instincts work,” I asked him.
“What?” he replied.
I said it again. “Explain to me why your instincts work.”
He shrugged his shoulders. “I don’t know,” he said. “They just do.”
“That’s why you need to be in this class,” I replied.
“What do you mean?” he asked.
“Instincts are great,” I told him, “especially when they work in your favor. But as a youth director or pastor or church educator, your job is to not only depend on your instincts, but to be able to help others who don’t have such instincts develop them. You have to be able to teach others—and to do that, you have to know why you make the choices you do. And you have to be able to articulate all of that in ways that young people and adults can understand. Otherwise you end up doing a Lone Ranger-style of ministry that’s of little value to anyone. That’s why you need to be in this class.”
It’s a common indictment of youth ministry professionals: too often we appear to be flying by the seat of our pants or just running on instincts without taking the time to articulate why we are doing what we are doing. Too often we are so busy jumping from activity to activity that we appear more concerned with entertaining young people than engaging them in the gospel of Jesus Christ.
That’s why this conversation about grace as a theological framework for youth ministry is so important. We owe it to young people, parents, stepparents, church leaders—whomever—to be able to articulate the theological framework in which we carry out the ministry to which we have been called. It’s one of the key reasons burn out is so prevalent in youth ministry—because we neglect to construct a theological framework upon which we can build the various programs and events that make up a balanced ministry with youth and their families.
To my thinking, the first theological framework for Christian ministry with youth is grace. This framework is primary because it separates Christians from other belief systems. This framework begins not with our measuring up but with a remarkable decision by the God of the universe to reach out to us.
Understanding grace
Calvin and Hobbes is a comic strip about a young boy named Calvin and his stuffed tiger named Hobbes. Hobbes comes to life only in Calvin’s experience. The author of the strip named the characters for the Reformed theologian John Calvin and the English philosopher Thomas Hobbes.
Where does grace come from?
Dutch theologian Edward Schillebeeckx points out that the New Testament contains “the beginnings of a theology of grace,” rather than a full-blown religious doctrine.1 Jesus never talks about grace. The concept is altogether absent from the Gospel of Mark and is used only as a greeting in the Gospel of John. Matthew and Luke use the term sparingly, usually without a theological meaning. Perhaps this was because the Greek terms charis (something that brings joy, favor, and grateful response) and eleos (gracious mercy) originally were associated with the favor of Greek gods, but were not central to either Greek religion or philosophy.
Paul, on the other hand, gave the term charis a thorough Christian baptism. The word charis occurs about 100 times in the Pauline corpus, 60 of them in the authentic letters of Paul.2 Paul found the concept of grace useful in many ways that still influence our vocabulary. Grace could mean thanksgiving (we say grace before meals), works of mercy on behalf of the poor (being gracious to others), or a demonstration of God’s favor (as in gifts and graces). It wasn’t until Augustine used the concept of grace to disarm Pelagius—who incensed Augustine by teaching that good works led to salvation—that a theology of grace began to take shape. Theologically, grace represented a new way God saves us, by divine favor, not by human action.
Hobbes, a soporific sort of feline, settles in for an afternoon’s nap. Calvin, who spots his friend sleeping, comes over and scratches him behind the ears, rubs his belly, pets his back, and so on. Hobbes stretches luxuriously and gives a sigh of bliss. In the last frame Calvin says, “That sigh ought to get me out of a few years’ purgatory.” As we consider grace as a theological framework for youth ministry, we must acknowledge that most young people think of grace as Calvin does. For Calvin, God’s saving grace is only possible if we do good things like scratching our pet tiger’s back. Thus, God’s grace is dependent upon our being good or faithful. In truth, this is not at all what the doctrine of grace is about.
Augustine and the doctrine of grace
The doctrine of grace came to its fullest understanding through the writing and thinking of Augustine, one of the great fathers of the Latin Church. For Augustine, grace was “unmerited divine favor.” Grace was not a human idea. Grace came from the mind of God and was accordingly bestowed upon God’s people. One of the great theological debates during Augustine’s time set the doctrine of grace against the doctrine of human free will. If God is sovereign and decides to offer us God’s grace, where does human free will fit? Some theologians argued that while God does offer grace to us, human nature already is predisposed to serve and love God. Others said God has given humankind the power to choose to be saved or not be saved.
Augustine rejected these ideas and cited the fall of Adam as an example that humankind was indeed able to turn away from God. Therefore, salvation was not our own doing or even our own choosing—all salvation came from God. For Augustine, even the so-called decision to follow God came at God’s invitation, and the ability to believe in God (let alone choose God) was a gift of divine grace to the believer. Augustine’s doctrine of grace dominated the church for several centuries. But by the Middle Ages, the late medieval church viewed grace more as a quality flowing from the church’s authority rather than as a gift from God. Further, the church had drifted so far from Augustine’s doctrine of grace that priests began to teach that the ability to believe at all, and to persevere in the faith, were fruits of human will rather than signs of God’s grace. Thus, persons turned to the church to purchase “indulgences” for the forgiveness of sins and the insurance of salvation.
The Reformation called the purchase of indulgences theological malpractice, and brought about a revival of Augustinian theology with the key phrase: sola fides, sola gratia, sola scriptura (faith alone, grace alone, Scripture alone). Martin Luther, Jan Hus, and John Calvin are important theologians who helped the church reclaim Augustine’s doctrine of grace. Their work was continued by modern theologians like Karl Barth, who reminded the church that salvation is God’s gift from beginning to end, and it is not dependent upon works or the church or the sacraments.
Scripture and grace
Vehicular grace
Somebody once described the different traditions of grace stemming from Wesleyan, Presbyterian, and Baptist traditions as a car racing to save a man who was about to commit suicide from a bridge. The Wesleyan grace car races up to the man, throws the door open, somebody reaches out a hand, and then waits for the man to get in. The Presbyterian car races up to the man, somebody leaps out, throws the man into the car, buckles him up, locks the door, and speeds off. The Baptist car races up to the man, somebody leaps out and preaches a sermon, and then asks the man if he wants a ride.
The point of these (admittedly distorted) descriptions of grace is that Christians have debated for centuries whether God’s gift of grace is something we can refuse. Is God’s grace irresistible? Can we lose God’s grace once we accept it? What difference do your answers make in your approach to teenagers?
In the Old Testament, grace is viewed first as divine favor toward humankind. God’s grace is shown through the creation, through the redemption and election of the Hebrew people, through the freedom from slavery in Egypt to the discovery of the Promised Land to the establishment of the kingdoms. But grace is also viewed as favor between humans. It is an undeserved gift or favor that is freely and unilaterally given and not coerced. In most human interactions in the Old Testament where the Hebrew word for grace is used, grace is characteristically given for a specific occasion from a person of greater authority to a person of lesser authority. In the Old Testament, the Hebrew words that occur most often are hesed and hen meaning mercy and favor. In the New Testament, the Greek word most often used is charis. Charis appears most often in Acts and in Paul’s letters.
Throughout the Old Testament, grace comes from God to humankind and from humankind to each other. In the New Testament, grace is exclusively descriptive of God and God’s relationship to humankind. For instance, in the New Testament, grace is only seen as an attribute of God or of Jesus Christ. Perhaps the best example of this comes in John 1:14 where Jesus is described as full of “grace and truth.” Then the writer quotes John the Baptist in comparing Moses and Jesus: “For the law was given through Moses; grace and truth came through Jesus Christ” (John 1:17). Only God and Jesus Christ, then, exhibit the characteristic of grace. Grace is not a human invention. In the old way, people were saved through the law of Moses by keeping the law. In the new way, people are saved through grace—an undeserved gift in the person of Jesus Christ. Obviously this is a huge shift in the culture and mindset of the Hebrew people. This verse summarizes well the battle between theologians. Can we be saved through keeping the law, or are we saved simply through the grace of God?
Grace upon grace
John Wesley—the Anglican priest who started the Methodist movement in the mid-1700s, and who described himself as “only a hair’s breadth away from Calvin”—believed that regeneration, or recovering the holiness God intends for us, was made possible by three kinds of grace, given to us one on top of the other, “grace upon grace”: prevenient, justifying, and sanctifying grace.
Wesley had a different view of grace than Luther or Calvin. He thought conversion was both a conscious awakening to God and a lifelong process that actually begins before repentance, through prevenient grace. Wesley thought that even before we turn to God, the Holy Spirit is at work in us, tilling the soul-soil, readying us for reconciliation with God.
When we repent, or wake up to our need for God’s forgiveness and justification, God imparts a second kind of grace—justifying grace. Justifying grace pardons sinners and receives us into God’s favor. At the moment of justification, God bestows upon us yet a third kind of grace—sanctifying grace. Sanctifying grace is what makes it possible for Christians to resist sin and do good. Sanctifying grace, is what gives us the strength to lead a holy life.
As a result, Wesley insisted that holiness—the state of avoiding all known sin and doing all possible good (which he also called perfection or entire sanctification)—was not only possible in this life, but that every Christian is called to it. Furthermore, Wesley contended that, thanks to sanctifying grace, we have no excuse to live otherwise.
Take a stand: Is conversion a moment or a process? Does regeneration begin before repentance? Does grace make holiness (or “perfection”) possible in this life?
The letter to the Church at Ephesus gives a clear answer, reflecting the thinking of the early church that grace is a divine gift, completely undeserved: “For it is by grace you have been saved through faith—and this is not from yourselves, it is the gift of God—not by works, so that no one can boast” (Ephesians 2:8-9). Paul’s letter to the Romans notes that sinners are “justified by his grace freely through the redemption that came by Christ Jesus” (Rom. 3:24). And the author of Acts likewise focuses on God’s grace as salvation. At the Jerusalem council, Peter clearly states a new order has been established for Christians (even Gentiles!), setting aside the need for Mosaic law: “We believe it is through the grace of our Lord Jesus that we are saved, just as [the Gentiles] are” (Acts 15:11).
For Peter and for all of the new believers, God’s grace through Jesus Christ is the focus for salvation. These texts point out the huge transformation taking place among these Jewish Christians. At first the thinking was that people earn salvation by keeping the Jewish laws—which made salvation possible only for Jews. Then, through Jesus Christ, the Messiah, the church began to view salvation as God’s freely offered gift; keeping the law no longer would save people. Finally, amazing as it may seem, salvation through the Messiah was no longer limited to Jews. We see Peter, Paul, and others being led by the Holy Spirit to recognize that God’s grace is for all people. Again, it is Paul who seems the most concerned that the reader understand that salvation is only by God’s grace, and not in any way merited by works. In Romans 4:16, Paul writes, “the promise comes by faith, so that it may be by grace.” And again, Paul writes in Galatians 2:21, “I do not set aside the grace of God, for if righteousness could be gained through the law, Christ died for nothing.”
Paul goes to great pains to remind the reader that it is God’s grace made known to us through Jesus Christ that saves us. We are not saved (or justified) by keeping the law or by various works. If that were the case, then why did Jesus Christ die for us? As if to remind his readers of this key idea, Paul uses grace in every salutation and benediction throughout the New Testament. In each case, Paul wants to emphasize that it is God’s grace, not Paul’s, bestowed upon those to whom Paul is writing.
Characteristics of grace
So then, having looked at the historical and biblical viewpoints of grace, let’s summarize by looking at the characteristics of grace.
Grace is undeserved. There is nothing you can do to earn grace. Grace happens when you receive a gift you did not deserve. Nothing is paid back here. Nothing is owed here. You cannot do anything to be worthy enough of the gift. You simply receive it.
Grace is given by God. Grace is given only by God. Can human beings be kind and gracious to one another? Of course. But the nature of grace described in the New Testament is made even more extraordinary because it describes a relationship between the divine and humanity. God does not need to save us. God does not have to sacrifice God’s only son. But God chooses to do so out of a love and kindness that we cannot grasp or understand.
Grace is unexpected. Clearly this kind of grace is completely unexpected. There is no logic and no reason as to why God, who is the maker of the universe, should love us so incredibly that God would send Jesus to die for us. There is no logic and no reason—no explaining—except to say that God, out of God’s amazing love, chose to give us this remarkable gift.
Grace is irretrievable. There is nothing in Scripture to indicate that God ever removes God’s gift of grace from us. If this were so, then God would be capricious and fickle. This is not the nature of God. It appears that God’s decision to offer grace to humankind through Jesus Christ is the final word to us that defines our relationship to God.
Costly grace
“Cheap grace is the deadly enemy of our church. We are fighting today for costly grace.
“Cheap grace means grace sold on the market like cheap-jack’s wares. The sacraments, the forgiveness of sin, and the consolations of religion are thrown away at cut prices. Grace is represented as the church’s inexhaustible treasury, from which she showers blessings with generous hands, without asking questions or fixing limits. Grace without price, grace without cost! The essence of grace, we suppose, is that the account has been paid in advance; and, because it has been paid, everything can be had for nothing…
“Cheap grace means the justification of sin without the justification of the sinner…Cheap grace is the preaching of forgiveness without requiring repentance, baptism without church discipline, Communion without confession, absolution without contrition. Cheap grace is grace without discipleship, grace without the Cross, grace without Jesus Christ, living and incarnate.
“Costly grace is the treasure hidden in the field; for the sake of it a man will gladly go and sell all that he has. It is the pearl of great price to buy which the merchant will sell all his goods. It is the kingly rule of Christ, for whose sake a man will pluck out the eye which causes him to stumble, it is the call of Jesus Christ at which the disciple leaves his nets and follows Him.
“Costly grace is the gospel which must be sought again and again, the gift which must be asked for, the door at which a man must knock.
“Such grace is costly because it calls us to follow, and it is grace because it calls us to follow Jesus Christ. It is costly because it costs a man his life, and it is grace because it gives a man the only true life. It is costly because it condemns sin, and grace because it justifies the sinner. Above all, it is costly because it cost God the life of His Son…Above all, it is grace because God did not reckon His Son too dear a price to pay for our life, but delivered Him up for us.”1
In your experience, has youth ministry been more likely to offer youth cheap or costly grace?
Grace is costly. Dietrich Bonhoeffer, a 20TH century martyr and theologian, coined the phrase cheap grace when he described Christians who saw little cost in Jesus dying for believers.1 After all, while Jesus was fully human, he was also fully divine. Some people conclude that this must mean that Jesus didn’t really suffer or hurt because he knew God would be victorious in the end. As a result, we take sin lightly, since God apparently overcame it with ease. Bonhoeffer warned against such cheap grace by reminding us that we have been saved through the very real suffering, death, and resurrection of God’s only son. Jesus felt every pain we have ever felt and even more—felt the ultimate pain in being rejected by his father.
Grace begets other gifts. “Each one should use whatever gift he has received to serve others, faithfully administering God’s grace in its various forms” (1 Peter 4:10). Peter reminds us that just as we have each received God’s grace (charis), we have also received gifts for ministry (charisma or charismata). These gifts seem to be a consequence of God’s grace. Our task is to use them to build up the body of Christ. It’s important to remember that we use these gifts in grateful response to God’s grace, not in order to earn or be worthy of God’s grace.
Grace is never finished. John Calvin wrote—
It behooves us to consider the sort of remedy by which divine grace corrects and cures the corruption of nature…God begins his good work in us, therefore, by arousing love and desire and zeal for righteousness in our hearts; or, to speak more correctly, by bending, forming, and directing, our hearts to righteousness. He completes his work, moreover, by confirming us to perseverance.2
Calvin reminds us that God’s gift of grace does not happen once in our lives and is over forever. Rather, God’s gift of grace is a continuing work in us, calling us to be more righteous and even to persevere. This is in keeping with Calvin’s emphasis not only on the act of salvation, but even more on the life lived in response to God’s grace—a life of righteousness and piety.
The challenge of grace for youth ministry in the 21STcentury
While the word grace appears to float freely through conversations and song lyrics these days, careful readers and listeners will discover it means different things to different people. Furthermore, few young people seem to believe that they’ve ever experienced grace at all. Therefore, the great challenge for leaders who choose to take grace seriously as a theological framework for youth ministry is that few young people will be able to relate to it.
In fact, most young people today are rather skeptical about the idea of grace. We minister to a generation that believes they have experienced very little grace. Most postmodern young people are driven by issues of performance.3 Most have tied their self-esteem, whether they know it or not, to how well they do on tests, report cards, recitals, and games. The link to performance is easy to understand. Many young people today, from very early on, have been rewarded most when they perform. Many have been paid for receiving A’s and B’s on report cards. Most are part of school systems that use standardized testing as a key determination for graduation from high school. Teachers, coaches, administrators, parents, stepparents, and others in their lives all reinforce this.
If you cannot measure up, many believe it’s best to drop out and stop trying. These dropouts find little reason for hope in their lives. No one seems to care about them. Some school administrators and teachers are just as ready to write them off, as they are to suspend or expel them.
Ponderable
Rodger Nishioka claims that young people today are rather skeptical about the idea of grace. Do you agree? Why or why not?
Remarkably, many parents and stepparents are convinced that too little is asked of this generation of teenagers. Ironically, while their children and stepchildren are caught up in a performance orientation for their self-esteem, most parents and stepparents think their children know they are unconditionally loved and that more often than not they take advantage of that.
Ponderable
Tony Campolo once told youth leaders in a seminar, “We will not lose this generation of young people because we ask too much of them. We will lose them because we ask too little.” Stack this up beside Rodger Nishioka’s claim that young people are too performance-oriented. Are these statements contradictory? If so, who is right? If not, how does the church ask more of young people without reducing their importance to how well they perform?
For a healthy self-esteem to be formed, young people need a sense of performing well on various tasks as well as a sense of unconditional love in their lives. Young people base their entire self-esteem on how well they perform at tasks when no one in their lives is delivering a consistent message of unconditional love. As youth ministers, we must be careful about how we talk with young people. Unknowingly, we may be contributing to a fragile form of self-esteem based only on performance. When youth ministry leaders only ask, “How did you do on your paper?” we inadvertently reinforce the idea that a young person’s value depends only upon how well they perform.
Ponderable
Is there a difference between selfesteem and God’s esteem? Is one more important than the other for healthy adolescent development? Is one more important than the other for youth ministry?
The same message is sent when churches create youth ministry bulletin boards with only clippings from the local paper about who scored highest on their Scholastic Aptitude Tests or who is a National Merit semi-finalist or who won at last week’s track meet or basketball game. When winning or achieving is the only way to be noticed by the church, then the not-so-subtle message is that the church also only values you as much as you perform. The decision to focus on grace as a key theological framework means ministry with young people and their families must look radically different from the culture.
Leading from a doctrine of grace
The doctrine of grace forms a key theological basis for youth ministry because it is the basis for our relationship with God and the cause for our discipleship in Jesus Christ. Salvation is God’s gift. Our job is to live a life in response to that remarkable gift. Furthermore, the doctrine of grace serves as a key theological basis for youth ministry because adolescents, more than people at any other age, desperately need to know they are loved for who they are without ties to performance or condition. When young people experience unconditional love, they are strengthened to face life’s struggles and to endure in the face of pain and suffering. The doctrine of grace does this. The very idea that God loves you not because of how you perform but rather because you are a child of God is a relief.
Addicted to achievement?
Christian educator James E. Loder has theorized that achievement functions like an addictive drug in American society. The more we achieve, the more insatiable our desire becomes to achieve even more. Loder writes that in cultures where “work and worth are confused…achievement becomes addictive because it is trying to solve a problem it was not originally designed to solve.” The obsessive quality of the achievement-addicted personality does not mean that these youth are socially maladjusted—on the contrary, it means that they have adjusted perfectly to what our society prizes and affirms.
Do you see this achievement orientation in the youth you work with? Are today’s young people addicted to achievement? What about those young people who seem to lack motivation to achieve anything—how does grace speak to them?1
This is the essence of the gospel message. You are loved! You don’t have to do anything or not do anything! In a world that seems to measure, compare, and rank you from the moment you are born, the good news is that you belong to God and are loved by God, and there is nothing you can do to remove yourself from God’s love. If this message is not the reason for our ministry, then what is? Why else do we gather? Anyone can get together to play games, watch movies, cook in soup kitchens, go on retreats, and even read the Bible. But if we are not gathering to tell each other and to live out the good news—the news that we are loved unconditionally by the God who made the whole universe—then what is our message?
Certainly young people need community and care, but more importantly, they need to know that they are loved unconditionally. It is important to their very survival as a human being. With the rising violence in schools in particular and culture as a whole, many researchers have been looking more intensely at how young people emerge from their adolescent years with a relatively healthy self-esteem and positive outlook on life. Scholars call this the resilience factor—the degree to which young people can bounce back from disappointment and risk as mature, responsible, and healthy adults.
This resilience factor asks that a young person think about the worst possible thing she can imagine herself doing. For some, this means robbing a store; for others it means shooting someone or beating up someone. Then the young person is asked to identify the adults in her life whom she knows she could tell that she did this horrible thing and the adults would still love her. Most studies agree that the minimum number of adults needs to be five. The young person must name at least five adults in her life that would love her unconditionally. These five adults seem to act as the foundation for the young person’s life. They seem to form the ground upon which these young people can grow and build their lives. They act as mentors and guarantors for the young person’s very survival. What happens to those youth who cannot name at least five adults in their lives? Many either die or are in jail before they reach the age of 21.
This idea of grace, then, is not simply some important theological paradigm. This idea of grace is a matter of life and death. If the church is to take the doctrine of grace seriously, we will have to place more emphasis on loving young people than on how well they perform.
Practices of grace
A ministry with young people that grows out of a foundational doctrine of grace looks very different from the culture that places more value on performance than on unconditional love. These eight practices provide youth ministers with a place to begin:
The practice of acceptance
Ponderable
Can you name five adults from your own adolescence who still would have loved you, even if you did something unspeakably wrong?
Acceptance takes hard work. Using grace as a theological framework for youth ministry means first and foremost that everyone practices acceptance. This does not mean that anyone who shows up is automatically a part of the ministry. That’s not acceptance. Acceptance is active rather than passive. Practicing acceptance means we invite people to become part of us and we become part of them. It means we resist judging their makeup, hairstyle, clothes, tattoos, and body piercings. It means, at first and last glance, we see a child of God in each human being and we treat them accordingly. Practicing acceptance means we are aware of our own biases, prejudices, and nonverbal cues. Unconditional love means just that—unconditional.
The practice of welcome
Most groups who use grace as a theological framework have developed a process of welcoming people to their group. They do this in such a way that all persons are affirmed for who they are as children of God. Some groups use rituals of welcoming words. One youth group I know has a “welcoming wall,” and throughout the year anyone who visits the group is invited to autograph the wall and to add something about themselves. Other groups use their bulletin board space to take digital photos of group members and visitors. They download the photos, print them up on their color printer, and post them for all to see—and then follow up by using the photos as the basis for a prayer chain.
The practice of remembering
“Take, eat. Do this in remembrance of me.”
—Jesus, at the Last Supper
Being accepted into a group of people can be especially difficult because newcomers do not know the rituals, expectations, or the history of the group. Not knowing the group can be a barrier to experiencing the grace of unconditional love. In every group of young people, some do better than others at bringing new persons to the group, or reminding the group of its foundational goal to live out the grace God offers to us in Jesus. When someone new enters the group process, pair the newcomer with a veteran who takes time to explain some of the group’s norms and history. Each time the group gathers, take time to “remember”—to join together again by sharing what has happened since you were last together. In this way you continue to build a history together, a history that includes new persons as well as long-time members.
The practice of solidarity
There are times when unconditional love must be demonstrated. In one youth group, when a member testified before a school board committee on school violence, the whole youth group made a point to attend the meeting as a sign of pride and solidarity. They sought to show support to their group member on an issue that was important to her. She knew that not everyone in the youth group agreed with her; that wasn’t the issue. The issue was solidarity and unconditional love. Because she was part of the group, they were with her. They were indeed proud of her, but they did not attend to approve her performance. They were proud of her because she belonged to them, just as they belonged to her.
The practice of justice
What if there is no youth group?
Rodger assumes the presence of a stable youth group as a context for ministry with young people. Youth ministry does not require a youth group, however. Can you think of an example of ministry with young people that is not based in an ongoing youth group? What do practices of grace look like in this setting?
A theology of grace calls us to focus on each person as an individual human being with particular concerns, hopes, and needs. Sometimes leaders, seeking justice, make decisions on the basis of treating everyone in the same way. This, after all, is a common notion of fairness in our culture. Thanks be to God that God does not treat us fairly. Justice and fairness are not the same thing. God looks at each heart to know what we need. Grace is not bound by precedent or the need to view everyone the same way. Grace applies to each person individually as the Holy Spirit works with us in our uniqueness. One common complaint from young people is that adults often fail to see the individuals; they just see a group of “kids.” As youth ministers, we must take time to appreciate and consider the needs of each young person as an individual.
The practice of humility
Sometimes our own well-meaning structures can hinder grace as a theological framework in our own programs. Experiencing grace means every person experiences acceptance for who they are. One church had an elaborate system of privileges and chores for the group. The older you were, the more privileges you had. The younger you were, the more chores you had assigned to you. Yet grace ignores human divisions of classes, age levels, or even experience in the church. Jesus Christ showed us the ultimate model of humility by taking on our sins. The radical call for grace is a call for humility of the most privileged to become “as the least” so that everyone shares in the privileges and chores together.
The practice of self-control
Grace as a theological framework for youth ministry does not mean that we accept everything and anything anyone wants to do. An important practice of youth ministry and of each individual is self-control. Doing whatever you want and then demanding that you be accepted no matter what is not grace—it’s selfishness and manipulation. Even grace—even unconditional love—involves important elements of self-control. Unconditional love does not allow people to hurt themselves or others, or to be abusive or mean. God accepts us for who we are, sin and all. That is true. But in this divine acceptance—in God’s grace shown to us in Jesus—we are transformed. We are given the grace necessary for self-control. People who seek total acceptance by a group also need to practice self-control.
The practice of witness
It’s important that we remember that grace is a gift from God—a fact true for everyone in the church, young and old alike. The ability for ministry to accept young people with unconditional love is a gift from God and it is God who is to be thanked and praised; not just the participants in the group. This is an important witness. Throughout the Old and New Testaments, the Hebrew people are reminded that God is the giver of community and God alone is the giver of grace; we as Christian people are to bear witness to God’s power in our lives. We are not witnessing about ourselves. We are witnessing about God.
The challenge for youth leaders
In my mind, a ministry predicated on divine grace brings with it at least two particular challenges for youth leaders. First, if we truly believe that salvation is offered as a gift from God, then we must also believe that it is God who saves, not us. Further, if we believe that grace is the primary theological paradigm for our work, then we must temper the temptation to judge. All too often I hear youth ministry leaders talking as if they are the ones who “saved” this person or that person. To my mind, such talk is idolatry. No one can save but God. Surely we can be the instruments—the empty vessels—for God to use, but the subject in the story of salvation is always God. We are not the ones who save. We are the ones who are saved by God.
I am often troubled by how I hear youth ministry leaders talk about others and especially their young people. Judgment comes easily and quickly. This person is bound for trouble, or that person is a bad kid, or she is so selfish and he is such a manipulator. If grace is our theological framework, we must think differently and act differently toward those with whom we minister. If grace is our theological framework, then every interaction with our young people is new and fresh. We are not called to be naive. But nor are we called for our preconceived judgments that cloud our vision of God’s grace. The second challenge that a doctrine of grace presents youth ministers is the fact that many of us are rescuers by nature. We want to make “everything right.” If something is wrong between young people, we’ll get in there and try to make it better. We’ll drop whatever we’re doing to step in. If grace is our theological framework for youth ministry, we have to learn at times not to step in but to step aside. If we are honest with ourselves, many of us trust ourselves more than we trust God.
Ponderable
Does youth ministry predicated on the doctrine of grace allow youth to fail? Why or why not?
Several years ago I received a phone call from a pastor. She was distraught over one of her brightest and best young people. The young woman had fallen in love with a young man six years older. They were sexually active, getting married in a month, and moving across the country. She had dropped out of the youth group entirely and was going to leave high school early. She fought with her parents until they threw her out of the house.
The pastor and I talked about keeping communication lines open. We talked about words to use and words to avoid. Then she said something that chilled me. She said: “I’m just so worried. I’m afraid we’re going to lose her forever.”
“Who is ‘we’?” I asked.
“You know, we…the church…God…we’re going to lose her,” said the pastor, exasperated.
“But she belongs to God,” I said. “You told me that years ago she received Christ as her Lord and Savior.”
“I know,” said the pastor. “But I’m so afraid.”
“I am, too,” I confessed. “I’m afraid because I worry she’s making some bad decisions that will affect the rest of her life. But one thing I am not afraid of she is not going to be lost to God. God will never let her go. God’s grace knows no boundaries—no limits. There will come a time when she will need God desperately and God will be there.”
“I hope you’re right,” said the pastor.
We prayed together that day, and I sent a follow-up note of encouragement. It is hard for us to see beyond young people’s immediate decisions, but if grace truly is the theological framework for youth ministry, then we must trust that the God of grace will sustain us—all of us, youth and youth leader alike. We must trust and live with the conviction that God cares for all and that no one can be lost to God. We must trust more in God than we do in ourselves.
