Chapter 28 Assessing Honestly: Spiritual Readiness
Chapter 28
Assessing Honestly: Spiritual Readiness
Chap Clark
“Youth workers never die…they just get a new T-shirt!”
I saw this slogan on an elderly counselor at a conference, and I had to smile. There’s something about this thing called youth ministry that, after you have been in it a while, is like a vaccine that stays forever in your blood.
I’ve been in and around youth ministry for three decades—as a student, a junior high leader, a Young Life staff person, a director of student ministries in a church, and a professor. I have seen programs and models come and go. I have heard the great speakers and danced to the hottest bands. I’ve been hit with a pie, and I’ve cried in the mud. I can’t drive by a 7-11 without wondering aloud who is loving those kids to Jesus Christ. I cry when I see precious ballerinas and seven-year-old Joe Montanas, because I know what the next 10 years will do to their souls. I am, and will always be, a youth worker.
Modern perceptions of youth workers include ideas that we are a fun-loving, wild, mildly irreverent (but appropriately so), passionate, energetic, and a hip bunch. And there is a great deal of truth to that. We are typically not hired because of our effervescent spirituality, and in fact the majority who read this will never be asked in an interview about their interior walk with Christ or what spiritual disciplines they use. People want and expect us to be a bit different—a bit odd. We are hired, after all, to run a program, ensure some semblance of perceived spiritual growth in a group of students, and basically keep the congregants happy. Strategy, vision, and experience are sometimes also valued, at least a little, in choosing and evaluating a professional youth worker, but for the most part, the bottom line in this vocational calling is we will always be measured against the perceived response of the students. And adults and students alike want us to be the one happy-go-lucky, on-the-edge person on a church staff. It’s the name of the game.
But there is also a frightening cancer lurking just beneath the surface of that youthful facade of youth work. For youth ministry is ultimately not about running events or casting a programmatic spell over students and their parents. Ministry in a missional context, of penetrating a disenfranchised and disconnected subculture, goes far beyond and far deeper than program planning and implementation. Our ministry is not just knowing the latest songs, hanging out for hours at the high school, and being the most proficient Webmeister in the church. Youth ministry is not a game. It’s a strategic calling of God’s church.
Youth ministry that makes a difference is theologically driven youth ministry. The intense kind of incarnational ministry that youth ministry requires (see chapter 18) is fundamentally not something we do, but rather something we are.Youth ministry ultimately emanates from the very core of the youth worker’s life. In God’s economy, it really doesn’t matter much what you know about youth culture, programmatic philosophy, or modern technology. As the culture around us cranks up the music and throws life into overdrive, more than ever a ministry to and about adolescents needs to be simple, direct, and straightforward. Our message and our motive is the same as it was for Paul and the Corinthian church:
So from now on we regard no one from a worldly point of view. Though we once regarded Christ in this way, we do so no longer. Therefore, if anyone is in Christ, he is a new creation; the old has gone, the new has come! All this is from God, who reconciled us to himself through Christ and gave us the ministry of reconciliation: that God was reconciling the world to himself in Christ, not counting men’s sins against them. And he has committed to us the message of reconciliation. We are therefore Christ’s ambassadors, as though God were making his appeal through us. We implore you on Christ’s behalf: Be reconciled to God. God made him who had no sin to be sin for us, so that in him we might become the righteousness of God.
—2 Corinthians 5:16-21
This is the essence of our message, and therefore needs to be at the core of our life in ministry. We must be constantly on the lookout for anything and everything that would seek to divert us from the beauty of God’s plan of reconciliation. You as a youth worker are God’s ambassador, and you therefore are called to implore those students and families you serve to be reconciled to the God who loves them. This is the essence of our message, and this is the central mandate and motivation for the youth ministry task.
Cultivating spiritual readiness
So how does one cultivate a vibrant, or even adequate, spiritual readiness in youth ministry? How can a youth worker keep her heart and life cleanly devoted to Jesus Christ, and at the same time run an efficient, popular program that is universally valued? Even the framing of this question, however, brings the issue into the programmatic realm, which implicitly misses the point. When all is said and done, authentic ministry is an inside-out sense of focus and calling. The how is not nearly as important as having the will to go after it. The mystery of our faith, “Christ in you, the hope of glory” (Colossians 1:27), is the seedbed of our ministry, indeed our very lives. Cultivating a spiritual readiness for the task of youth ministry is to see that you are committed to ensuring that your ministry comes from someplace deeper than your history, training, and experience. Ministry must come from deep within in order to sustain the focus necessary to be labeled ministry. As Len Kageler writes—
If we are going to successfully survive our first five or 10 years in youth ministry, we must learn the secrets of renewal. A renewed heart and spirit make it possible for us to not be blown away by criticism. A renewed heart keeps us going when we are starved to see results and go hungry instead. A renewed heart makes it possible to keep perspective when it seems like our world is falling apart.1
Doing and being
Does this make you wonder if our greatest enemy is the assumption—the first, biggest rock—that we have to do something before we can be somebody? After all, it’s a lot easier to monitor someone’s job effectiveness than it is to get a handle on her life faithfulness. Training, interviews, assessment—all of the socializing determinants of our profession—push us toward doing ministry. Chap Clark is saying that we can’t do identity; high achievers among us need to let that truth wash over them.
But more importantly, our ministry must flow from our deepening walk with Christ in order to continually remind ourselves that God is far more concerned about our character than the number of students who like our program. It is not so much about how many quiet times we schedule, or whether or not we regularly fast, but rather the condition of our hearts. Paul Borthwick, in Feeding Your Forgotten Soul, entreats us to pursue a tenacious honesty in taking spiritual inventory of our lives: “We need to ask questions (of ourselves) about matters of character, because fulfilling external disciplines (reading the Bible, personal worship time, and service) can become mundane and empty if they are not penetrating our spirits.”2
Five areas of focus for healthy spiritual readiness for ministry
The following five areas of focus for the healthy spiritual readiness of the authentic youth worker are summed up in the Great Commandment:
“The most important one,” answered Jesus, “is this: ‘Hear, O Israel, the Lord our God, the Lord is one. Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind and with all your strength.’ The second is this: ‘Love your neighbor as yourself.’ There is no other commandment greater than these.”
—Mark 12:29-31
These words of Jesus provide the definitive and final job description for the youth worker—and for anyone in Christian ministry. We are to be guided by love, and only guided by love. What is our role with students? To love each one as we would be loved. What, then, is our job concerning leaders and staff? To love each one as we would be loved. What is our calling with respect to the senior pastor, elder board, or school principal? To love each one as we would be loved. As Werner Kummel points out, these two related commandments represent the summation of the call to Christ:
[The] coordination of [these two commands] by Jesus unmistakably has the intention of naming all that [humanity] has to do in the sight of God: the response to the encounter with God in Jesus and to the promise of the kingdom of God can only be love for God which is actualized in love for one’s neighbor. If love for one’s neighbor grows out of the encounter with God’s love and is inseparable from the love for God, then such love for one’s neighbor knows no limits.3
So what does this mean when it comes to spiritual readiness for youth ministry? How does loving God and loving others summarize a youth worker’s job description? This is explored by looking at the terms Jesus uses in these two commandments from the viewpoint of the youth worker.
“With all of your heart”—readying the heart
As is true today, the word heart (kardia) in the Bible is used to describe not only the physical organ, but also is seen as “the center of the physical, mental, and spiritual life of humans.”4 The Bible declares that the heart is the source of understanding (Matthew 13:15) and of thinking (Proverbs 23:7), and it is somehow involved in introspective meditation and reflection (Luke 2:19), the will (2 Corinthians 9:7), and even in our propensity to worry (1 Samuel 9:19-20). “The word came to stand for (humanity’s) entire mental and moral activity, both the rational and the emotional elements. In other words, the heart is used figuratively for the hidden springs of the personal life.”5
But in both the Old and New Testaments, and for many contemporary believers, the heart is the most appreciated metaphor for describing the emotional aspect of our faith. The Psalms alone, for example, are filled with dozens of emotional references of the heart.6 Throughout the Scriptures emotions like joy (Psalm 4:7; Isaiah 65:14), fear (1 Samuel 25:37), depression (Proverbs 12:25), hate (Leviticus 19:17), and love (1 Timothy 1:5) all are described in terms of the heart.
So how does one cultivate a spiritual readiness in loving God with the heart? One way to think about readying your heart is to allow enough spacefor the spiritual romance God wants with you as his beloved child.7 Although few talk about the intimacy of faith in these terms, in both the Old Testament (Isaiah 62:5) and the New (Revelation 19:7) our relationship to God and to Jesus Christ is spoken of in romantic terms.8 Our devotion to God is an emotional devotion: “Go and proclaim in the hearing of Jerusalem: ‘I remember the devotion of your youth, how as a bride you loved me and followed me through the desert, through a land not sown’” (Jeremiah 2:2). And this emotional aspect of the faith journey is not just the one-sided expectation of a distant-yet-powerful deity. The all-loving, supreme, and mighty architect of Creation also experiences powerful and overwhelming emotion toward those he loves. The Scriptures consistently affirm the Great Romance of the cosmos—God longs to woo us to himself:
“For your Maker is your husband—the Lord Almighty is his name—the Holy One of Israel is your Redeemer; he is called the God of all the earth. The Lord will call you back as if you were a wife deserted and distressed in spirit—a wife who married young, only to be rejected,” says your God. “For a brief moment I abandoned you, but with deep compassion I will bring you back. In a surge of anger I hid my face from you for a moment, but with everlasting kindness I will have compassion on you,” says the Lord your Redeemer.
—Isaiah 54:5-8
In response to this rush of passion and longing, we are invited into the intimacy of the Trinitarian fellowship. That is the central theme of the Christian journey—allowing ourselves to encounter the incredible love that God personifies. This is the final and only source of true life.
To be equipped and prepared for the various demands of adolescent ministry, then, the primary focus of love you cultivate must never be primarily a love of the students. Rather, love for students, and leadership, and parents must flow out of a healthy, authentic, inside-out romantic affection for the Savior. Youth work is not youth ministry without this being the focus. Many people who love students do not make room for a relationship with God as the motivating and sustaining force. Loving Jesus is the central, most fundamental calling in the life of every believer (John 8:32; 14:15). Loving others flows from this emotive fountain of an intimate joyful relationship with the God who created you.
Mortal danger
We who have been professionally employed in youth ministry can’t let professionalization squeeze out our first love. (Professional lovers, after all, are whores, right?) Our love for Jesus should lead us to daily put our job on the line, to be willing to give up the career move in order to be authentic lovers of the Lord Jesus. Whenever one can be bought and sold by those who want to define the priorities of the job, that person’s heart is in mortal danger.
To make space to love God with the heart, then, is the key. For some the classic daily devotional is sufficient to remember that a wildly romantic dance is just a brief prayer away. For most of us, however, we need to be shaken out of our routines by setting time aside for a half day a month or more. But the point is for ministry to be authentic and to maintain perspective, you must never allow the demands of the job, the excitement of the event, or the response of the students to crowd out your intrinsic thirst for a lover to comfort you by satisfying the deep longings of your heart.
“With all your soul”—readying the soul
In the Scriptures there is an intrinsic link between the body, the spirit, and the soul. To the Hebrew mind there is no mistaking that all three are clearly woven together into an intimate tapestry called the human person. W. E. Vine describes the distinction this way: “The spirit (pneuma) may be recognized as the life principle bestowed on (humanity) by God, the soul as the resulting life constituted in the individual, the body being the material organism animated by soul and spirit.”9 The soul is the essence of the unique person, what John Calvin called the “best part.”10 For our purposes, then, the soul (psuche) can be described as the core of the human person. The soul is what receives salvation (1 Peter 1:9) and is the emanating source of praise from the deepest part of who we are: “Praise the Lord, O my soul; all my inmost being, praise his holy name” (Psalm 103:1).
Because the soul makes up the center of who we are, we cannot separate our souls from our work. The soul of the youth worker belongs to God, and it is therefore central to our calling to ready our souls as we assess honestly what it means to serve in Christian ministry to adolescents. Loving God with all my soul implies a willingness to reach into the depths of my being and surrender all that is there to the God who first loved me. This type of responsive love means that I am willing to go to any lengths, or depths, no matter how difficult, uncomfortable, or painful that search may be, to place at the feet of the Creator anything and everything that is buried within me. This can be what is in my past or what is in my present. It can affect the thoughts I carry as well as the plans that I make. In readying my soul to love God, I must be willing to do the work it takes to be honest with who and what I am. For some reason, this kind of call to honesty has been an Achilles heel for many in youth ministry.
Few youth ministers are open to input about the areas of their lives that get in the way of ministry. Whether it’s because we tend, as a lot, to be overly insecure about our jobs, or in our youthful zeal the thought of perceived organizational interference seems stifling, or because we are frankly unsure of how we are doing and that makes us nervous, youth ministers are seldom known for their teachability. But loving God with all my soul means that I must be willing to regularly and freely take who I am to the throne of God, appealing to his mercy for my failures and receive his “grace to help in the hour of need” (Hebrews 4:16 Phillips). This means that I must not only be open to—but proactively seek out—critique and input about both my job and my character. It means we must be willing to go to counseling if needed, and, at the very minimum, to allow a few friends, supervisors, and co-workers into the core of our lives.
“With all your mind”—readying the mind
The mind (dianoia) “represents the intellectual, reflective faculty” of humanity.11 To love God with the mind is to meditate and carefully consider our life and faith. This involves one of the significant reasons for this book—we (the editors) carry a deep conviction that youth workers are far better at emotively and programmatically reacting in our lives and ministries than theologically reflecting on who we are and what we are about subject to the lordship of Jesus Christ.
Ponderable
Is Chap suggesting that when we love God with all of our minds, every action (thought, etc.) will be intentional, deliberately chosen with a theological motivation in mind—even for an expression of, say, personal fashion? Is this reasonably ambitious or unfeasible? What do you find in the Bible that permits or forbids such practices?
For example, a few months ago I asked a junior high worker seminary student who had just gotten his lip pierced, “What was your theological motivation for getting the lip ring?” Because we have a great relationship, he knew I was not intending to trick or insult him, but rather wanted to see where he was coming from. As we talked, he admitted that he got it because it was cool and he had always wanted one and his parents had finally given in. Clearly, this is not exactly a prime example of loving God with all your mind.
The lack of theological thinking and decision-making has been one of the most destructive markers of youth ministry over the past several decades. Many programs, games, events, illustrations, shirt designs, and any number of other youth ministry staples have been advanced and promoted without the slightest nod given to theological reflection—and sometimes these have inadvertently hurt people in the process. My friend ultimately admitted that his work with junior high students had only been considered as a side issue in deciding to pierce his lip, and only the positive side at that. (“Kids will trust and like me more.”) It had never occurred to him to consider what this might model for the students or how this may impact legitimate family concerns in the church. These are but examples of how we are called to love God with our mind.
To love God with our mind we must continually ask the three most foundational questions relating to all theological decision-making:
It is possible that someone could do a careful theological reflection around those three questions and still come to the same kind of conclusions they would have reached had they not done the work of loving God with their mind. But just the disciplined commitment to caring about these questions leaves the Holy Spirit room and time to work. Readying your mind to love God in your life and ministry means committing to the discipline of thinking before acting.
“With all of your strength”—readying the strength
Youth ministers are often perceived as lazy by people who do not understand their world. In my experience this is too sweeping a generalization, for youth workers typically work hard at the tasks that they deem vital or most important. But in our decision-making regarding such mundane and “nonspiritual” tasks as time management, informing the office support staff of our schedule, keeping good expense records, and driving safely, the perception that is out there may be closer to the truth than we would like to admit. It is almost always in our power to be diligent in all aspects of our job. For the person who longs for a ministry that flows out of an intimate love for Jesus Christ, self-discipline and responsibility are important components of our devotion.
Loving God with all my strength describes an individual’s willful decision to do her part in pursuing a love relationship with God. Strength (ischus) is concerned with follow through and has to do with the “ability to enforce one’s will.”12 It is not just wanting to love God with my heart, soul, and mind, it is about accessing and then implementing the Holy Spirit’s indwelling power to live out my convictions.
“The second commandment is like it”—loving others as we would like to be loved
It is here in this second command where Jesus puts our personal devotion for him into action. The Apostle Paul picks up on this and goes straight to the heart of issue of love when he states, “The entire law is summed up in a single command: ‘Love your neighbor as yourself’” (Galatians 5:14). The word used for love here and in Mark 12, agape (agapao), is the highest form of the word in the Greek. This love, “whether exercised toward the brethren, or toward (people) generally, is not an impulse from the feelings, it does not always run with the natural inclinations, nor does it spend itself only upon those for whom some affinity is discovered. Love seeks the welfare of all.”13
Each of us is called to love anybody and everybody, whether or not they agree with us, threaten us, help us, make us look good or bad, or deserve our love. We are not called to destroy ourselves in the process, or to deny when we have been hurt or unjustly treated. But, even with those who seek to harm us, we are still called to love.
The source of this kind of love is the intimacy we experience with God. It is not an either/or love, where we have to choose between loving God and loving others, but rather a because of love. As I love God, so I love others, as I am called to love myself. Love is therefore a package where the power and motivation is fueled by God’s initiative to first love us (1 John 4:19). This is the definition of ministry—to love others.
The bottom line: the theological task of youth ministry
Jesus Christ has redeemed and called men and women into intimate relationship with himself. He is the consummate romantic, in that his love is piercing, penetrating, and forever seeking out the object of his love. We in youth ministry, then, are invited to participate in God’s redeeming work by responding to his love for us, and in so doing to nurture those who are placed in our care, including ourselves. This summarizes the theological task of youth ministry.
A practical theology of the youth ministry task, then, involves putting together a careful and decisive set of vocational parameters for staying personally healthy and spiritually vital as we engage in the difficult task of ministering to and caring for students and families.
10 keys to healthy living in youth ministry
The following keys to healthy living in youth ministry represent a practical response to many of the issues presented in this chapter. This is not an exhaustive list, but rather it is intended to help the student put practical wheels on the concepts offered.
Ponderable
What Chap prescribes here makes some Christians nervous. It’s like saying that humans really ought to eat, sleep, exercise, and rest—not exactly a job issue, it it? Rather essential for life itself, right?
By the same token, everyone who names the name of Jesus needs to pray, be quiet, etc.
On the other hand—and perhaps more to the author’s point—vocational ministers of the gospel do have leadership obligations that heighten the consequences if they do not practice spiritual disciplines.
