Intro Theological Rocks—First Things First
Intro
Theological Rocks—First Things First
Kenda Creasy Dean
Therefore everyone who hears these words of mine and puts them into practice is like a wise man who built his house on the rock. The rain came down, the streams rose, and the winds blew and beat against that house; yet it did not fall, because it had its foundation on the rock. But everyone who hears these words of mine and does not put them into practice is like a foolish man who built his house on sand. The rain came down, the streams rose, and the winds blew and beat against that house, and it fell with a great crash.
—Matthew 7:24-26
Most of us have known our share of “beach ministries”—ministries with young people whose foundations are firmly anchored in…sand. Gangbusters one day, gone the next, these ministries just couldn’t weather storms of conflict or the wet blankets of indifference. They couldn’t keep up with the flood of overwhelming need, or withstand the winds of pastoral change. One day they just fell with a great crash. Or, more likely, the youth minister in charge did.
What are your theological rocks?1
Which of your beliefs about God matter the most to you? Which ones would you say are “musts” for youth ministry? Do you have a theological conviction that serves as the hub of your beliefs and practices?
Think of an adolescent you know. If you could share only five things about God over the course of your ministry with this teenager, what would want him or her to hear you say?
Write your theological rocks here:
Storms, wet blankets, floods, and wind are part of ministry. Fortunately, so are sunny days, clear sinuses, and quiet, warm eddies that keep life interesting. The difference between those who thrive in youth ministry and those who collapse under its weight lies in the substance of our foundations: have we built ministry on theological bedrock, or on the shifting sand of cultural relevance? Don’t get me wrong: Jesus didn’t tell the parable about the wise and foolish builders to condemn the sand—and nor should the church condemn efforts to relate to culture. But beach trips and attunement to cultural change take place on the surface of ministry, not at its heart. The problem in this parable isn’t the sand, but the builder: somebody who should have known better chose to forego the hard work of laying a solid foundation for the sake of quick construction, a spectacular view, and bargain prices.
You’ve probably heard the story, repackaged recently by management guru Stephen Covey, about the professor who one day filled an aquarium with large rocks. “Is it full?” he asked his students. Most of them nodded yes. Then he took gravel and poured it into the aquarium, letting it spill between the rocks. “Now is it full?” More cautiously, most students said yes, it was full. Then the professor poured sand into the aquarium, filling in the gaps and crevices left by the gravel. “Now is it full?” he asked the class. The students squirmed—but anyone could see that the aquarium was practically overflowing. Then the professor took a large pitcher of water, and carefully poured it into the sand. At last, the aquarium could hold no more.1
I share this story with you for the same reason Stephen Covey tells it in management seminars: it’s a simple illustration of first things. Had the professor filled the aquarium first with sand and water, the rocks—the aquarium’s main substance, the “big stuff”—never would have fit. Trying to shove rocks in last would be futile (not to mention messy). Of course, that may not stop us from trying. Remember the middle high Sunday school lesson? After you checked in on the week’s highs and lows, after you finished the jelly bean relay (which was more fun than expected, so it took twice as long as planned), after you told the pithy story that seemed to illustrate the day’s Bible text—well, time ran out. Half the class left for choir, the other half dissolved in chaos, and (oops) the Bible lesson never quite got covered. “ Theological rocks ”: first things first. Or what about those disruptive eighth-grade girls at the camp you ran this summer? You knew they were begging for attention, so you meant to arrange some one-on-one time with them once the school year started. But then the school year started with a vengeance. Your workload went from zero to 60 overnight. The camp director wants your input for next summer—tomorrow. You’re still preparing your Thursday small group when the doorbell rings with the first arrivals, every single time. And now there’s a message on your answering machine from some youth ministry publisher reminding you about the free resources your church can have if you show up to Saturday’s training event. Girls? Oh—those girls. “Theological rocks”: first things first.
Or maybe you remember a frantic phone call from a distraught mother whose son, a freshman at the local university, drank himself into alcohol poisoning at a fraternity party. You, another intern, and the pastor met them at the hospital. You brokered counseling sessions with the campus rehab center, contacted university support systems, prayed with both mother and son. In some ways, your crisis intervention skills had never been better. And yet it didn’t occur to you to suggest to this helpless mother that she pray for her child’s recovery. Nor did it cross your mind that she needed you to teach her how. “ Theological rocks”: first things first.
These are real stories from my own ministry, drawn from days I filled with sand and water instead of with the theological “rocks” that brought me into ministry in the first place. I wish there weren’t so many of those days to choose from. Youth ministers are forever filling sacred opportunities with competence, usefulness, busyness, enthusiasm—everything but intentional reflection on God and how our ministries do, and do not, bear out our convictions in our practice.2 The irony is that church professionals usually have theological commitments to spare, and yet we are more apt to develop ministry, and maybe youth ministry especially, in response to a job description or the latest barrage of parental complaints than from careful theological reflection. We seldom take time to reflect on why we do what we do, or whom we do it for—that is, unless something has gone horribly and irrevocably wrong.
Geology 101
The basic premise behind this textbook is this: Practical theological reflection—reflection that connects what we believe about God with how we live as disciples of Jesus Christ—is the first task of ministry with young people. By first, we do not mean that practical theological reflection on youth ministry necessarily precedes everything else. All decent theology begins and ends in practice, so sequence matters little in the ongoing cycle of practical theological reflection. Such reflection comes “first” in the sense that it is primary, fundamental—basic to everything else we do and to who God calls us to be. To fail to think theologically about youth ministry, as Eugene Peterson has pointedly noted, is to risk substituting a religious career for a holy vocation.3 To fail to name our theological priorities in ministry—our “theological rocks,” if you will—tempts both vocational infidelity and professional impotence.
Those of us preparing for ministry with young people must do more than pack a pastoral bag of tricks (at worst) or ready ourselves with models, strategies, and theories relevant to young people and the world in which they live (at best). First we must identify our “theological rocks,” the convictions about who God is and what God is about that are normative for everything we do. These are the convictions that call us to faith and that govern our ministries. Whether we realize it or not, our theological rocks affect how we develop an evening youth program, approach a sermon, handle conflict, engage parents, plan a retreat, counsel teenagers, relate to our own families. Practical theology is concerned with Christian action, with the way we enact faith in the life of discipleship and ministry in the church and in the world. Sometimes, when we begin to recognize the deep connections between our theological convictions and the way we do ministry, we change our actions. Sometimes we change our convictions instead. In either case, we engage in practical theological reflection in order to discover more faithful ways of doing faith.
If, upon reading this book, you begin to see threads between the way you think about God and the way you practice youth ministry, then our mission will be accomplished. Hopefully, you will also lay claim to some of your theological rocks along the way. Theological rocks may be sandstone or granite; some remain constant throughout our lives, others are smoothed by circumstance, personality, education, the Christian tradition in which we worship, our personal experience, and knowledge of God, to name a few possible streams of influence. Since youth ministers must become skilled backdoor theologians—people who can slip theological truth in through the cracks of everyday life, without waiting for a formal invitation to preach4—the first task of ministry must discern those theological rocks we want our lives and our ministries to proclaim. Five minutes with a teenager is a lifetime. Given such a holy window, what above all else would you want that young person to know about God?
Your timing is good
The early 21ST century is an encouraging time to enter youth ministry. Approximately one person in five is between the ages of 15 and 24 years, or 18 percent of the world’s population. Although the percentage of young people will decline in the early 21ST century, in real numbers this represents an increase in the number of youth in the world (see chart).
1 Eighty-five percent of these youth live in developing countries, and this number is expected to rise to 89 percent by 2020. The United Nations defines “youth” as anyone between the ages of 15 and 24. All statistics taken from the United Nations Division for Social Policy and Development (January 6, 1999), www.un.org/esa/socdev/unyin/q-and-a/htm.
According to one estimate, the U.S. teen population will rise in the next decade from 29 million to 36 million. “In other words,” observed Rolling Stone recently, “resistance is futile. Teenagers are driving our culture—and they won’t be giving the keys back anytime soon.”5
Your ministry is taking root while the tectonic plates of intellectual and cultural change are still shifting, altering not only what people think, but how thinking actually happens. Discoveries like quantum physics and the arrival of the information age have sealed the tomb on modernity and toppled the reign of linear reason. Chaos theory demonstrates that science can defy prediction, hermeneutics reveals that there is no such thing as “objective” inquiry. Hyperlinks are teaching us to think in terms of connections, not closure, and the Internet smashes through old paradigms, creating relationships between both people and data that we once thought impossible.
Our culture’s current interest in spirituality is the predictable consequence of these shifts—changes that have led to a period in which we find some of our most basic cultural assumptions on shifting sand. The intellectual atmosphere of the early 21ST century invites comparisons to the climate that gave rise to the Protestant Reformation, the Great Awakening, and even the Pentecostal revivals of the early 20TH century. Historians have long noted a relationship between cultural upheaval and religious revival, as times of uncertainty cause humans to turn to religion to reconstruct the cultural narrative.6
Perhaps, then, we should not be surprised that “God” is experiencing a popular comeback. Teenagers meet at school flagpoles for prayer, corporate executives attend seminars on spirituality, and religion is discussed openly in chat rooms and lunchrooms alike. When pollster George Gallup asked the question, “Have you had occasion to talk about your religious faith in the workplace in the past 24 hours?,” 48 percent of Americans said yes.7 MTV, VH-1, MP3, and prime time all fearlessly invoke religious imagery. Even public policy has cleared the way for religious institutions to proclaim their faith while addressing social concerns from school reform to gang violence.8 For the first
time since 1986, church attendance among teenagers in North America is on the rise—and surpasses adult church attendance—and more teenagers today say they attend church, not because their parents tell them to, but because “they want to.”9 God is clearly “hot.”
The global village of youth
If the world’s youth population in 1995 consisted of a village of 100 people, here is what it would look like:
Could there be a more exciting time to enter ministry, especially ministry with young people? But wait: first things first. After all, in this philosophically unstable but spiritually fertile environment, martyrdom has also reentered the adolescent vocabulary. Nobody counted on a renewed interest in spirituality that included murder in the school library, or gunmen shooting teen worshipers in a Texas church sanctuary. Nobody counted on the fact that God calls youth ministers to pastor the Eric Harrises and Dylan Klebolds of our communities, as well as the Cassie Bernalls, Rachel Scotts, andValeen Schnurrs. Nobody counted on the fact that, despite our high-tech, virtual reality expectations, Christianity always traffics in visceral reality, turning the tables—in the Temple and elsewhere—in ways we seldom anticipate. Nobody counted on the stakes of youth ministry being quite this high. But that’s exactly how high they are.
And so: first things first.
Youth ministry and practical theology
Until very recently, practical theology has been altogether absent from the youth ministry equation. Youth ministry has often been conceived as a junior partner in the Christian education enterprise rather than as a pastoral calling. Clearly, Christian education is one component of our mission with young people—but it is not the only component, nor is it the primary one. Approaching youth ministry from the perspective of practical theology assumes that youth are called to take part in every practice of Christian ministry, to participate in the total mission of the church, for God calls all of us into the divine plan of salvation.
While adolescents’ unparalleled spiritual openness requires intentional ministries on their behalf, youth are practical theologians by virtue of calling, not proficiency. Like you and me, youth must grapple with what it means to be a child of God on a planet marred by sin and redeemed by love. They must reflect on the activities of Christian life in order to construct a faithful one they may call their own. They must listen for and respond to God’s call to them to become ministers in their own right. Their vocation is no different than our own. They simply plough different fields, with (perhaps) less practice and experience.
This book locates youth ministry squarely within the broader theological enterprise called practical theology, or theological reflection on Christian action. Because Christian action unapologetically invites God to use us to transform the world in Jesus’ name, practical theology is intimately connected to the practices of ministry—which is not to say it is limited to the practices of professional church ministers. All Christians are called to be practical theologians, disciples whose obedience to God in the church and in the world puts our truth claims into practice. Theology that goes unnamed and unnoticed is powerless to change lives or ministries. Practical theology assumes that we live our convictions about who God is and how God works in the world, and that we practice our theology most faithfully when we do it on purpose.
How this book works
This book is organized as an example of practical theological reflection on youth ministry and is divided into four sections reminiscent of four tasks within practical theological reflection:10
The Tasks of Practical Theology
The first section of this book explores the nature of practical theology and its significance for youth ministry, and describes how theological reflection affects the way we understand our present context for ministry with young people. This task (Understand) asks, How can we understand a concrete situation using the theological resources of Scripture, Christian tradition (church teachings or doctrine), human reason, and sacred experience? So the first question practical theology poses for youth ministry is How can we describe the concrete situation in which God is calling us to act as youth ministers?
Sections 2, 3, and 4 focus on subsequent questions of practical theology. Section 2 (Reflect) asks: What should the practice of youth ministry look like, given the concrete situation described above? In this book, different authors answer this question in different ways, but together they reflect the landscape of current approaches to youth ministry.
Section 3 (Detect and Evaluate) critically defends various practices of youth ministry according to certain theological rocks or norms held by the section’s authors. These authors suggest that our practices of youth ministry should be guided by theological doctrines like repentance, grace, redemption, and hope. The third task in practical theology makes explicit use of theological rocks by asking How do we critically defend what youth ministry should be like in the concrete situation we have described?
The fourth task in the cycle might be called Project—reconstructing youth ministry to more faithfully and self-consciously communicate the God we know, lest we format God to fit our limited vision, or shrink salvation to the shape of our ministries. This final task of practical theological reflection for youth ministry asks What means, strategies, and forms of persuasion should we use in this concrete situation with young people that best communicate the gospel?11
We have invited a number of different theological perspectives into the discussion in each section. We hope you will test these perspectives against your own, using the supplementary comments along the margins of these pages to help you practice thinking theologically about what you are reading. These marginalia are our editorial fingerprints, and like fingerprints, they give us away. You’ll see my fingerprints in sections 1 and 3, Chap Clark’s in section 2, and Dave Rahn’s in section 4. Take us on. The marginalia are intended to muss up the theological hairs on your head, to provoke conversation and theological reflection, and—most importantly—to help you consider what your own theological foundation for youth ministry might look like. You may even stumble across some theological rocks along the way.
Who are youth?
As you explore this text, you will notice a number of terms for young people: youth, adolescents, teenagers, students. Although we will offer a more differentiated understanding of adolescence in chapter 2, for the most part you may consider these terms synonymous. Each of these terms has its own history, but casual usage over the past several decades has homogenized most of their differences.
Youth ministry for much of the 20TH century meant ministry with high school and, more recently, with junior high students. Today a youth may be any young person between the onset of puberty and fully individuated adulthood.12 During this period in the life cycle, adolescents must acquire an identity, a coherent sense of self that hangs together over time and persists throughout multiple social roles.13 Arbitrary though these boundaries for adolescence may seem, they are really quite fluid. Adolescence in the United States today often begins during late childhood (ages nine or 10) and extends through the mid-20s or sometimes later (when the young person makes enduring commitments relative to vocation and intimacy). Youth ministry, therefore, properly addresses young people in any of these stages.
A word about language
One final observation before we begin. While we have used inclusive language to refer to women and men throughout this book, we have chosen to honor individual conscience in regard to language about God. The use of pronouns for God (male or female) are consciously chosen by each author, and you may assume that these choices reflect something about the author’s theological tradition and personal beliefs that he or she wishes to convey. Their choices do not necessarily reflect the convictions of those of us in the editors’ seats (all of whom, by the way, understand God to be both male and female and, at the same time, to transcend gender—although we each use language differently to express this belief). We hope the different voices represented in this volume will spur your own theological reflection, not only on inclusive language, but on all matters of ministry. We want you to wonder whether your own “God-talk” with young people grows out of your conviction about who God is, or whether it is a byproduct of unexamined assumptions that—until now—you might not have even known you had.
That said, our decision not to force conformity around the issue of inclusive language says something about our own theological convictions—namely, that youth ministry includes, but goes beyond, any single theological discussion or debate. Many of us who have grown up in the United States have learned to approach language with scalpel precision, and this cultural norm makes inclusive language about God an important matter for many people in our culture. Christians growing up in other cultures may just as properly privilege other theological discussions instead. None of us has the corner on divine identity; Christians of all theological flavors need one another in order to critique and embrace possibilities about God that might not occur to us, were we without each other’s differences. Youth ministry is one place our kaleidoscope church comes together to focus on a common mission: Jesus’ call to the church to love young people to him so they can hear Christ’s call to ministries of their own. Theological politics aside, in the end there is always more in our faith to unite than divide us. After all, every Christian calls upon the name of Jesus, and we all do so for the sake of our young. In every Christian community, of every theological tradition, from every conceivable polity, with every possible liturgical form, at the end of the day people go home—parents, grandparents, aunts, uncles, cousins, neighbors, and friends—people go home and pray for their children.
In so doing, perhaps we pray for ourselves.
Kenda Creasy Dean
Princeton Theological Seminary
March 25, 2000
Feast of the Annunciation of the Theotokos
