Chapter 16 of 38

Chapter 13 Focusing Youth Ministry through Innovation

Chapter 13 Focusing Youth Ministry through Innovation

Chapter 13

Focusing Youth Ministry through Innovation

Soren Oestergaard and Simon Hall

One of the few things that doesn’t change about our world is the fact that it is constantly changing. We are aware of many discontinuities between the culture of first century Palestine and our own culture, but one that we are less conscious of is the amazing rate of change we live amongst. In the United Kingdom dance music scene, the fashionable style changes from drum’n’ bass to garage to big beat within a year. I remember first hearing about the terrible corrupting influence that some yellow cartoon character called Bart Simpson was going to have on the youth of the world, but now Bart seems like an angel compared to Beavis and Butt-Head and the kids from South Park. These aspects of youth culture may seem trivial to the average adult observer, but their place in helping to define the culture of adolescence cannot be underestimated.

In this chapter we hope to address the issue of this rapidly changing culture and our response to it as youth ministers. This is not an academic exercise; it has huge missiological significance. As the cultures of our environment change faster and faster, the church seems to be more and more out of touch. If, then, rapid cultural change leads inevitably to decreasing evangelistic effectiveness, where is God in all of this? And what is our creative response to youth subcultures and their rapid division and regeneration—a cultural phenomenon unique to the last century? Unless we begin to take cultural change seriously, the church is going to become just one more cultural group in the huge supermarket of values, neither understanding those around it, nor being understood. This might be acceptable in the United States, where church attendance can still support an “instant” youth ministry of church kids, but in Leeds, U.K., a city the size of Boston, there are only five youth groups (to our knowledge) with more than 12 members. We must address our terrible failure to reach unchurched1 young people, and to do that we need to look at the culture issue and reflect on it biblically and theologically.

Ponderable

How has the culture in your community changed over the past five to 10 years? How has it changed since 1970, when most of today’s youth ministry models were becoming established? How have these changes effected youth ministry programs in your community?

Cultural change is not a new issue; nor is it one on which the Scriptures are silent. One of the Bible’s many miracles is the way in which God’s revelation unfolds over hundreds of years and still remains consistent. Yet as we look at the history of God’s relationships with humankind, we see that while his purpose has remained the same, his plans have changed according to “the times” (1 Chronicles 12:32). From the calling of Abraham and his nomadic family to the establishing of a foothold in Palestine, from the birth of the royal kingdom to the exile of the two kingdoms and the restoration of Judah, from the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus to the phenomenal spread of his followers, God has worked through the people and culture of the time.2 The Bible witnesses to the ways in which God’s redemptive purposes are fulfilled through methods that seem right for the times. The parallels between the stories of Joseph and Daniel (see particularly the dream narratives in Genesis 41 and Daniel 2) indicate that this is not merely about time. For despite the huge time gap, God is calling his followers to live in a similar way when they find themselves in similar situations. In different situations, different solutions are called for: when the early Jewish Christians lay down their beloved law in order to include the first fruits of the gentile mission field (Acts 15), they were led by the Holy Spirit into completely uncharted territory. Their zeal for the law had been supplanted by a zeal for the lost, a miraculous “heresy” that God initiated because the time was right to fulfill God’s promise to Abraham (Genesis 12:2-3).

Babel or Pentecost?

The question we must rightly ask this: Is God altering his plans according to how the culture changes, or is he altering culture to fit in with his plans? The story of the Tower of Babel (Genesis 11:1-9) indicates a clear understanding that God’s lordship extends to cultural matters, but there are other scriptural witnesses, too. For example, how should we interpret Romans 5:6, in which Jesus’ work of salvation is described as having happened at “just the right time” (kairos)? Does that mean that God had set up the universe for Jesus’ arrival or that he was himself somehow waiting for a moment in history that arrived at exactly the time Jesus was born? We do not think there’s any way of avoiding the conclusion that God is working constantly throughout history, but that the exact mechanisms of this are beyond us. Also, we have to admit that God’s people frequently fail to perceive what God is doing in the world. Within our own situation, perhaps our attitude should be an eager desire to know the purposes of God within youth culture—humbly accepting that we might get it wrong!

Is there a global village?

It is clear that we have a global marketplace, a worldwide economy—that we have grown as close in some ways to people on the other side of the globe as we used to feel to people in the next town. Some go a step further, believing that because communication and goods now conveniently cross geopolitical, religious, and cultural lines, that we are becoming a family of happy, compatible, like-minded, and close-knit brothers and sisters.

Or is it more accurate, do you think—and as the authors imply—that things are getting worse between people groups, subcultures, and even clusters of students?

As we look at the fragmentation ofWestern culture, we are left wondering what God might be doing within it. Are we being punished for our pursuit of power and wealth—our desire to be like God—with a Babel of splintering subcultures and tribes? The imposition of globalization by the multinationals may have created a worldwide market, but it has clearly not created a worldwide community. If such a pessimistic and conservative view ofWestern culture is accurate, at least we have the hope of a new Pentecost, in which each alienated tribe heard the good news about Jesus in their own language (Acts 2:6). However, we could choose to see within young people a wonderful spirit of creativity, a sign of God’s image in them—a sign of hope. Either way, we have the chance to see God at work within the varieties of youth cultures that blossom around the western world.

Figure 13.1. Living theology

Theology and praxis in extremis

The situation in Western Europe is calling for radical new approaches in youth ministry if we want to reach out to the many different youth subcultures constituted not by nominal Christians or non-Christians, but by pre-Christians who know nothing of what Christianity is all about. The situation demands what has been called theology and praxis in extremis—a process where we reflect critically on some of the core issues about being the church and our current approaches to youth ministry.3 A process where we dare to ask ourselves tough and basic questions like, What is the good news for teenagers living at the beginning of the 21ST century? What is the nature and function of the church in a postmodern context? What is the role of young people in youth ministry and the church?

To dare to begin this process is very much a matter of life and death for the church in Western Europe—this is a task so important that it should not be a process in which only professional youth workers participate. We need to equip young people to get involved in doing communal exegesis and hermeneutics in and of their specific context. We need to get them involved in doing theology that is relevant and that gives answers to the real questions. We need to create models of ministry that meet the current and future needs of the young people we know as well as their pre-Christian friends. We need to train and challenge them to be the leaders and innovators of the future churches.

Involving young people in doing theology—instead of them simply being influenced by a theology to which they very seldom have any ownership—can be a frightening adventure. Young people ask questions that challenge our thinking and identity as youth workers. It is, however, a necessary process.

Ponderable

To what degree is Soren and Simon’s description of what’s happening in Europe also happening where you live? Should we similarily rethink our assumptions about the kids we want to reach and our models and methods for reaching them? What if there are many different subcultures of kids, even in your city, who need Christian adults to be cultural missionaries to their distinctive culture?

As youth workers in a European context we very much see ourselves as missionaries to foreign cultures. That’s the primary reason we often feel very inspired by the thinking of the mission theologians and the experiences and approaches used by pioneer missionaries reaching the so-called unreached people groups. The following model draws heavily on the insights from missiological thinking and praxis.4

As youth workers we can view our current theology and praxis as a result of what we have read in the Scriptures, the influence of the specific church tradition that we are a part of, our personal journey as human beings and Christians, and the influence and needs of the local context that we are a part of. This can give us an understanding of why we think as we think and do what we do. When we’re honest most of us will admit that the main sources that influence our way of doing youth ministry are tradition and our own personality, pilgrimage, and preferences. Scripture and the needs of our local setting only play a minor role.

Accidental church plant: a case study

A youth pastor in a suburban Baptist church, Simon had a heart to reach unchurched young people. He also had a heart to see Christian young people be effective in mission. When both his visions began to be realized and a number of newcomers started attending the youth ministry, problems began. The church young people began to think about the kind of youth group their friends would wantto come to. They changed the way they dressed and the music they listened to. Inspired by the new young people, they started complaining about how boring church was and they started to write their own worship songs, which were very different from what the church was used to, both lyrically and musically. Eventually, the young people began meeting in the church sports hall, where more people got caught up in the exciting worship and relevant preaching that was happening in the youth service. Lots of young adults came, who said that this was great for them, too.

The problem was that many of the new Christians who had joined this group, had never been to church and never really wanted to. They liked Jesus, they liked us, and they liked “doing church” with the group. Suddenly everyone realized that the group had become a separate church, almost by accident. Simon approached his fellow leaders with this situation, and 18 months later, Revive was born. Now two years old, it is a church made up almost exclusively of people aged 18 to 40, which meets regularly in a bar and in homes. God has used the church to reach young adults who were seeking for God but who would never have dreamed of going into a church. Looking back, the team sees God in all that has happened, apart from one moment when it became clear that the music, art, poetry, and dance of the young people was not welcomed by the “adult” church. Although the young people were invited to do “youth services” each term, the young people felt that these were being used to marginalize their contribution to the church and felt forced into creating their own sacred spaces. Revive is a frightening, challenging, life-changing place to be, and to be honest, it feels a lot more like the body of the One who hung around with prostitutes and other “lowlifes” than the average church.

The above model can be used for evaluation of our current thinking and praxis in youth ministry. We’ve also found it very helpful for getting young people involved in the process of doing theology and rethinking the purpose of the church and youth ministry in a new millennium. The results of such a process in both the United Kingdom5 and Denmark have been challenging and creative. When asking young people from unchurched backgrounds to reflect on these themes, whole new areas of exploration open up.



Scripture

Our experience is that when young people are challenged to reflect on some very basic and some complex theological questions, they obtain a new platform for dealing with matters concerning church and youth ministry. For example, what are the changeable and the unchangeable elements in the gospel? What is the Good News? What does it mean for us today that the Word became flesh? Being open to these questions with young people can be transformative because over time we begin to discover what really matters. Young people find out that church doesn’t need to be static in that our current way of doing church and youth ministry is more influenced by a specific cultural setting than the Scripture. At the same time they find out that God is an active Lord who is so eager to get in contact with his creation that he chose to meet us at our home base, in our specific cultural situation. The significance of the Incarnation grows and grows in this dialogical setting. More and more young people—often inspired by a youth worker who takes on the role of a facilitator, mentor, and project consultant—will frequently choose to act on their communal reflection.



Tradition

Research done all over Europe shows that most of the new churches being planted are so-called new old churches: the same method of preaching, leadership, and structures that didn’t work in the old context, are all uncritically reproduced in a new context. And, naturally, this approach isn’t very successful.6 Consciously or unconsciously we stick to traditional ways of “doing church”—usually because it’s the only approach we know. Sometimes it is also the fruit of a misunderstood respect for “the fathers.” As youth workers we are often reminded that we have to be sensitive to the tradition of the church, but what does tradition actually mean? Usually this means “taking the best of the old and changing it so it fits into a new setting,” but often we confuse tradition with the term traditionalism, which means to take the old things and bring them into a new context without changing a thing.7 It’s been described this way: “Tradition is the living faith of the dead and traditionalism is the dead faith of the living.” Young people in Western Europe are fed up with “dead faith and empty rituals.” However, if you try to introduce them to the context in which the traditions were developed and the original thinking behind certain practices in the church, they very often get inspired by “the fathers” and begin to develop their own traditions. It’s good to be reminded of how we ended up with organs in churches. Once upon a time they were an instrument of the devil that aroused the passions. Primarily used in drinking dens around Europe, the church adopted the organ as a hugely influential vehicle of popular music. The irony is not lost on young people. This is even more true when they discover that the lyrics of many of our favorite traditional hymns were set to drinking tunes.

Cutting Edge: case study

In the early 1990s a young new convert got a job at a Christian recording studio. After learning his trade, he started getting some musicians together for a worship band, and within a few years he was leading worship for thousands of young people every month at an event called Cutting Edge. The key to these events (the worship band eventually became the band Delirious) was the leadership of the local church (Arun Community Church) that lead singer Martin Smith belonged to. The church backed his vision, providing support in a variety of ways. This was particularly brave as Martin soon began to write songs using heavier and heavier rock music and lyrics that began to talk about doubt as well as faith. The Cutting Edge events pioneered a whole new wave of worship music in the United Kingdom and, more recently, America.

Young people have the ability to accept the challenge that faced Paul: to communicate a cross-cultural gospel in language that is both understandable and truthful. It’s fascinating to see tradition—a word that teenagers are supposed to hate—giving them guidelines on how to reflect on their own situation in a way that “honors” the fathers much more than most of our “traditional” activities in the church!



Personal pilgrimage

A common experience among youth workers today is that teenagers are looking for authentic and transparent role models. People who are not willing to simply play a certain role but who live on the outside what they are inside. People who are appropriately open about their struggles, hurts, and doubts—in other words those issues that young people can identify with. When we introduce teenagers to the wide range of people and personalities that God uses in the Bible, they discover that God takes our personality and experiences seriously. When they realize they don’t have to fit into a specific model to be involved in ministry, teenagers receive the freedom to develop a spirituality that reflects who they are—a spirituality that they feel fits them more than “the adult spirituality”—a spirituality that reflects their culture.



The local context

Club in the ‘hood: case study

In 1992 a former black belt karate fighter and professional soldier was converted through the ministry of a new charismatic church in the suburbs of Copenhagen. The church tried its best to “church” him, but after some years he realized that his personality and background didn’t fit into the specific style and spirituality of that particular church. He decided not to leave the church but to go back to his roots and share the gospel in his own neighborhood. He bought a basketball and every Saturday for two years, summer and winter, he invited the local teenagers to come and play basketball with him.

Among the teenagers he soon got a nickname—the guy who can’t hit the basket—but also received tremendous respect on the street because of his background and the way he communicated with them. They soon found out that he was one of their own, that he understood their problems, fears, and many questions—he talked their language. His home soon became a meeting place for the local teenagers where he and his wife touched many lives.

The ministry began to grow and in 1996 they (together with a team of similar church fringe members) decided to establish an alcoholfree nightclub where the teenagers could hang out with their friends, dance, and build relationships in a safe environment instead of hanging out on the street. The volunteers kept the club open every weekend from 8 p.m. to 5 a.m. This was the start of a ministry that today still has the nightclub as the cornerstone of its work, but also cell groups, services, peer counseling, new converts, and contact with approximately 500 suburban teenagers who would probably never have been exposed to Christ had not “the guy who can’t hit the basket” not followed his convictions. In 1998 the Danish Youth Council nominated Power Plant as one of the most innovative youth projects in Denmark.

As youth workers we are always looking for new models and concepts that we can use in our ministry. Often quite uncritically we use ideas that have developed in a totally different context and the danger is that we don’t meet the real needs and address the questions of the teenagers we are working with. But taking incarnation seriously means that we always have to be serious in our search for what kind of “Good News” teenagers in our local context are longing for. For many young people it’s an eye-opener to find out that incarnation is very much about God wanting to meet their specific needs and longings and that he wants to meet them in a way that’s contextually relevant.

Our experience is that many youth workers base their work on assumptions about the needs of the young people they try to reach—assumptions that often don’t match the reality. If we really want to know what’s going on out there, we need to be continuously doing research. We need to read about trends within youth cultures, gather data, talk to resource persons like teachers, social workers etc., do surveys and—most importantly—talk with the young people we know and get them involved in the research process: after all, they are in many way the “real experts”! We have to talk to them about values, worldview, and their felt and existential needs. We have to find out about how they make decisions, gather together, communicate their dreams and fears about the future, etc.

We don’t need to accept their values, belief, and praxis, but it’s crucially important that we understand the background for their thinking and acting, so that we can address both the felt and the existential needs of their lives. For many of us it maybe feels a little bit overwhelming to do this kind of research—we are trained to be youth workers, not sociologists! Yet if we want to be involved in contextually relevant ministry instead of just concept ministry, research should always be a crucial task for us. An introduction to the most basic methods of gathering information and equipping young people to exegete their own culture should probably be an integrated part of our training as youth workers.

Figure 13.2. Contextual ministry

Inhabiting the story

British theologian N.T. Wright has struggled with new approaches to understanding the authority of the Bible and he has come up with a picture that I find most helpful. Imagine a Shakespearean five-act play.8 One is the creation of the universe. Act Two is the fall. Act Three is the nation of Israel. Act Four is Jesus. Act Five is the journey of Jesus’ followers to the eschaton (“final”—refers to the end of time; closely related to eschatology, the study of end-time events). The key to this image is the fact that we are part of Act Five! The first scene of the final act is written in the New Testament, which also tells us how the story is going to end, but in the Bible we have an unfinished script, a drama that is unfolding before our very eyes. As directors, producers, and actors, it is our role to study the script(ure) that we have and to learn the story and the nature of the characters. We must continue this drama in a way that is true to all that has come before, but which also moves the story on to its conclusion. We learn that this story has boundaries over which we cannot step and opportunities for innovation that we can exploit. The first scene of our final act and the knowledge of the drama’s end provide a strong framework for our innovation, but there is still room for the plot to thicken a little. Suddenly we are participants and partners in God’s great narrative, rather than mere observers and imitators of his ancient history.

In addressing our present issue, this approach can help us no end. Because God’s will for his followers in certain cultural situations is the same, we should search the Bible for the analogues we need. We also need to acknowledge where we are in God’s story (between Acts and Revelation and in the early 21ST century). We need to ask ourselves if there is anything unique about our situation that may introduce a new plot twist.9 Finally, we need to be aware of our own place as actors in the drama. We will now attempt to address these issues from our own Western European context.

Compatibility with Scripture

Is what we’re doing compatible with our biblical predecessors?

Ponderable

Are youth ministry programs you know truly compatible with “biblical predecessors”? How tightly should we hold on to historical ministry models in a culture that is changing faster than ever? Are we simply doing what we have always done because it used to work, or are we willing to constantly reevaluate in light of the biblical witness?

The church in Western Europe has been in serious decline for most of the 20TH century. The decline appears to be slowing, but with only 6 percent of Britons claiming weekly church attendance, that’s hardly a surprise—there’s no one left to leave! Most European Christians now live in a post-Christian community in which Christianity has formed the culture of a nation but is now largely forgotten or ceremonial. There is still a trace memory in the national psyche, but it is rarely stimulated by the insecure, irrelevant church.10 Yet the charismatic movement has revived many evangelical churches and over the last 30 years there have been encouraging signs that these churches are “turning the corner.” Perhaps the closest analogue within the Scriptures is the return of the exiles in Ezra/Nehemiah. Here there remained a faithful remnant struggling to survive and maintain its identity. The returning Israelites, attempting to rebuild the temple and the holy city, were under constant attack from neighboring tribes, but the ultimate attack came from within: the temptation to give up the distinctives of Judaism and melt into the cultural milieu of their neighbors. God’s solution was a fearsome ethical holiness and a strict adherence to the rituals of the old temple, carried out while the new temple was being built around them.

If this analysis is correct, we should expect the Western European church to be more in danger of assimilation and syncretism than of “ghetto-ization.” This is generally true, with the exception of the more extreme charismatic/Pentecostal churches, which tend to take their lead from outside Europe. The Bible speaks to us from this story about the need for radical holiness as an important antidote to our loss of identity. In order to say that our witness is compatible with the biblical witness, we need to be challenging young people about the lifestyle choices they are making.

Continuity with tradition

In what way are we part of God’s developing story?

But we are not actually in the seventh century B.C., we are now over 2,500 years away from the return to Jerusalem. We are no longer required to worship daily at the temple, but we are now a worldwide church of followers of Jesus. Not only that but both the authors of this chapter are European Baptists, raised in a Protestant tradition of radical discipleship. This church tradition affects the way we perceive and analyze our situation; it may even restrict the options open to us. We have also been influenced by a variety of theological movements in the 20TH century, including new approaches to mission, spirituality, social engagement, and so on. What is there in our tradition that can help us reflect on our situation?

We would instinctively begin with the insights of missiology, more particularly contextual theology.11 Over the last 100 years Christians from around the world have been reflecting on the communication of the gospel across cultures. Surely their thoughts will have some bearing on our own work of mission across subcultures? This whole awareness of the significance of culture in shaping our beliefs and practice will hopefully prevent us from repeating some of the gravest errors of the early missions. Likewise the thought that has gone into the sociology of postmodernity and its impact on the way our generation sees and judges must affect our approach to reaching out to young people.12 We can choose to disparage the increasing significance of experience as the measure of reality, or we can choose to live up to the challenge: is our faith something that can be seen and touched and heard and tasted and smelled, or is it just some dusty old head-knowledge? A young person today doesn’t just want to hear you talk your talk, she needs to see you walk your walk. Going back to the Bible with this frame of mind shows us that many of Jesus’ words came in response to people’s experience. Very rarely did Jesus offer unsolicited advice or comment to the crowds. He would heal someone or perform a miracle or show compassion on someone, and then people would be gathering around him, asking, “What was that?” And he was then in a place to talk about the kingdom.

Creativity of the Spirit

Is God doing something new here?

The leader

It is easy to get so wrapped up in working for God that we forget he is way ahead of us, leading the way. How do we open our eyes to what God is already doing?

Some of the unique elements about our own situation are those already mentioned: the diversity and rapid change of our situation. This means that for the first time in history, a parent and child can belong to two different (and sometimes conflicting) cultures while living in the same house. The extended end of adolescence means that this is no longer about the teenage years: the six main characters from “Friends” could be any age from 18 to 40. Hence we have to take our own cultural situation seriously, because this problem is going to get worse, not better. In simple terms, if youth ministry culture is renewing itself every 50 years, as Mark Senter suggests,13 and youth culture is renewing itself every five to 10 years (where is grunge/angst now when it spoke for a generation 10 years ago?), then it’s easy to see why there is a significant culture gap between the churched and the unchurched. If we add to that the 19th century culture of many of our churches, then the situation gets doubly serious. The time for what we might term radical discontinuity may have arrived.

Calling from God

Is this what God wants me to do?

Church growth experts such as Peter Wagner often talk about “pioneers” and “home-steaders” to distinguish between those who plant churches and those who maintain them. The Bible has a much more complicated list of giftings. Undoubtedly a test of a groundbreaking ministry must be the calling of those involved. Youth work practitioners tend to be the pioneer types, but this work is not for all. We all get to a place in ministry when we wonder why we are doing it, and unless you can give yourself a clear answer to that question, you will be out of ministry in double-quick time.

Compatibility, continuity, creativity, calling

Reflecting on these four approaches to our context (analogues with biblical history, an understanding of our place in the fifth act of God’s drama, an awareness of our own unique situation both in context and calling), we can perhaps begin to think about ways forward for youth ministry. These ways will need to be true to all that has gone before in the witness of Scripture and the church, but also to speak powerfully to our own generation. In our view, a youth ministry that is going to be effective in reaching young people for Jesus will need to have these characteristics, among many others:

  • Any youth ministry needs to be “in the world and not of it” (2 Corinthians 10:3; 1 Peter 2:11), and needs to check its balance. Many youth ministries are Christian ghettos that protect their members from harm but that are not impacting their local communities with the radical message of Jesus. Likewise, many youth ministries have lost their identity and distinctiveness in their desire to be accommodated within the world they are reaching. Young people, if they are effective in reaching their peers, need to love the world, but love Jesus even more. That is a dangerous route to take, but the New Testament says nothing if it doesn’t tell of the risks that God took to get us back into relationship with him. It means challenging young people to lives of obedience and holiness now, rather than training them to be adult Christians when they grow up.14
  • At the heart of God’s way of keeping us holy is prayer and worship. We would expect that there would be a new psalmody of music and poetry that will reflect the heart of this generation. We see a disciplined life of study, prayer, and worship at the absolute center.
  • We see that the mustard seed has more to teach us than McDonald’s about Christian community.15 The growth of the church in the developing world contexts shows us that in the cross-cultural mission in which we are now engaged, contextual ministry that grows from the bottom up is what will maintain its integrity and last the course. Youth ministry that is shaped, even led, by young people who are part of unchurched youth cultures will redefine the nature of youth ministry over the next few years. Young people who have been brought up in church will need to be unchurched in order to reach the young people of their community who have no interest in being churched, thank you very much.
  • The context of post/late modernity provides youth ministry with a variety of challenges and opportunities. As mentioned above, it means that Christianity will have to be lived out in all its terrifying, world-changing completeness in order to attract experience-based young people. That means that discipling will become more and more important as young people go out on the edge for Jesus. Relational means of discipling and evangelism, such as mentoring and cells,16 will form a bedrock of the new youth ministry.
  • We predict that the church will be transformed over the next 30 years. Either it will accommodate these radical changes in youth ministry, it will quash them and die, or it will force the creation of new churches that will have as much in common with “Friends” and MTV as a traditional church. If youth pastors and senior pastors are both willing to acknowledge the enormous culture gap between their own culture and that of their communities, there is great hope for the future, but if not, we are in for as rocky a ride as an unwanted baby who will probably be born anyway.
  • Small, less, insignificant

    Long-time youth ministry leader Mike Yaconelli has been telling youth workers for years that youth ministry is more about small, not big…about less, not more…about how the insignificant is significant…about the power of quiet. Some think it’s time youth ministry becomes less committed to massive programs and hot models and more committed to building intimate communities of faith. Perhaps the hot idea for the next generation of youth workers will be creating programs that are theologically driven, in which the Spirit leads, where kids are free to love and be loved, and where prayer is central and relationships are genuine.

    What do you think?

    Ora et labora

    Genuine innovation is hard work that demands careful study, critical reflection, courage, and much prayer! In our approach we need to be balanced and holistic, grounded in Scripture. It’s crucial that we get young people involved in both individual and communal careful study of the Scripture so that they find out for themselves what the Good News is in their specific context. We should teach them to be sensitive and learn from the traditional global church as well as the local church and challenge them to generate their own meaningful traditions. We need to challenge them to be authentic and use their gifts and the experiences they have gathered through their own personal pilgrimage in their local context, and we should challenge them to see and meet the specific needs of their own cultures.

    It is also crucial that we continuously evaluate our motives for getting involved in a process of innovation. It’s of the utmost importance that our motivation is based on sound motives, which means that we mustn’t get involved in this process because we don’t like what’s going on in the traditional church or youth ministry. We want to reach out to youth cultures in a contextually relevant way. Mission should always be our main motive!

    The last thing we want to mention is that communication is very important if we want our innovative approach to be successful. We have to explain why we are doing the things we are doing, and our experience is that we can get away with a lot of things and get the blessing of our local churches if they understand that our approach is based on careful study and reflection. Another important area of communication is our communication with our heavenly Father. Genuine innovation has to be a Spirit-filled and Spirit-led process where we have the courage to be still and let him direct us, correct us, and challenge us!

    And if the results aren’t what was expected?

    In his book The Spontaneous Expansion of the Church, Roland Allan describes how much mission history is often the story of an unexpected result of well-planned mission. Of course it’s the same concerning youth ministry. One example from the youth ministry scene in the United Kingdom is the so-called youth congregation movement, which for many church leaders was seen as a bridging strategy from youth cultures into the adult church.

    The pioneering work of Soul Survivor in Watford is a good example of this approach. The project was set up to be a bridge project where the strategy was to reach out to people through a café ministry and worship celebrations. The people who came to faith were then to be transferred to the “mother church,” St. Andrews, Chorleywood, a contemporary charismatic church. The first part of the strategy worked out fine—people got saved—but the second part of the strategy failed totally. The young people didn’t want to leave Soul Survivor, and the final result was a youth church plant.17

    As in Watford many youth congregations that were started as a bridging strategy have now developed into genuine churches with their own leadership, worship, pastoral care, evangelism, and church planting. The output was certainly different from what many had expected and has caused much debate, but more and more church leaders recognize that though youth congregations never became the intended bridge to the “real thing,” they are genuine expressions of the church of Jesus Christ. In a time of cultural transition, youth congregations have helped the church to discover the shape of its future.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑