Chapter 24 of 38

Chapter 19 Seeing Clearly: Organizational Context

Chapter 19 Seeing Clearly: Organizational Context

Chapter 19

Seeing Clearly: Organizational Context

Dave Rahn

After directing Campus Life clubs for eight years, I decided it was time to pursue my master’s degree. The decision made for an easy escape from the gnawing dissatisfaction I had been experiencing as our ministry was growing. My history with Fort Wayne’s Youth for Christ chapter had included being part of a rebirth of this organization. A new executive director had come to town at the same time I started college down the road. It was natural for me to connect my own efforts to begin Campus Life with the larger organization, and I grew professionally under the direction of a capable and caring veteran. After leading clubs for four years while attending school, I immediately accepted the full-time responsibility of coordinating Campus Life in the area when I graduated. After a few years we had established a solid ministry focused on helping teens that were not church-oriented to discover the hope of new life through Jesus Christ.

Our organization had grown significantly larger, but the expansion didn’t always feel right. When I began as a part-time club director, about 20 of us—almost all volunteers—would meet regularly for training and encouragement. We met in our executive director’s home, enjoying the camaraderie of that personal setting. It wasn’t unusual to be belly laughing about the antics of Rody’s overly stimulated poodle one minute and immersed in misty-eyed prayer about the difficult situations of kids in our clubs the next. Such experiences helped us feel like we were part of a team, that our mission was great, and that each one of us mattered deeply.

By the time I became full-time, our work had expanded to include Youth Guidance, an evangelistic effort targeted at kids in trouble with the law. Our professional team was now a trio, as I joined Rody and Larry, our Youth Guidance division coordinator. Ministry volunteers had grown to around 50, and a couple of office location moves helped us all feel more stable as an organization. The sense of pride in who we were, how we were expanding, and what God was doing through us, helped us develop confidence in our future. We could squeeze our professional staff meetings around a booth near an Azar’s breakfast bar; we were very comfortable with one another.

Over the next few years we began more aggressive expansion efforts. Both Larry and I added full-time staff to our respective divisions of the ministry, and our total volunteer numbers doubled. We became a little more sophisticated in our training efforts and a little more specialized in how we worked with those under us. Policies, paperwork, and accountability became more important as the operation grew. Systems were created to ensure that we took care of audio-visual equipment, vans, camping gear—all resources we felt fortunate to have. It became trickier to get people together for meetings if there wasn’t advance notice. We locked formal planning days and goal-setting retreats into our schedules early each year. Much of my time was spent in organizational strategy meetings and problem solving. I had to track the progress of our youth evangelism efforts and develop new staff while still working in direct ministry myself. My job had changed in some significant ways, but my awareness that more kids were being reached with the gospel made the extra burden well worth it.

Except for the grumblings.

I first learned that our aggressive organization wasn’t as healthy as I thought when some staff complained that they didn’t feel a part of the decision-making process. Mistrust began to creep into our workplace environment, as junior staff would frequently see the leadership team huddle in an office for a meeting, or grab exclusive lunches together. “What was the agenda all about, and why can’t we join in?” they would wonder.

Our volunteers felt like they were part of a big system; it seemed impossible for all of the professional staff to know everyone who was part of our mission, let alone care for everyone. This was especially true for our harried executive director, who had his hands full trying to raise the money to keep our operation moving forward. To be fair, some volunteers appeared well cared for by their ministry staff leader; others grew disenchanted. Volunteer turnover became a huge problem. I was personally quick to write them off as not dedicated and began to wonder if volunteer recruitment, training, and development were worth the considerable effort. I couldn’t understand why they had such difficulty owning the mission and ministry to which I had so obviously committed myself.

That’s when I left for grad school. I was feeling more frustration than fulfillment and couldn’t clearly understand what was going on. Within a month after leaving I was introduced to the concept that every organization, large or small, has a distinct culture of its own. I learned that such cultures could be explored and analyzed using skills of observation and research.

Our underminded values

The simple fact that many Christians experience a disconnect between clearly Christian values (as described in the Sermon on the Mount, or the “one anothers” of the New Testament) and their organizational home base ought to sound the alarms on our theological sensors. We have issues that need exploring! And before moving to the host of organizational gurus (Covey, Senge, Peters, Maxwell, etc.) for an explanation, we’d be smart to reflect more specifically on what theological values seem to be undermined. We may discover that there’s more than effectiveness at stake in our practical ministry designs.

In particular, I could identify the reasons for my recent ministry frustrations. Fort Wayne YFC’s growth had resulted in an organizational structure, communication patterns, and a goal-setting process that undermined the kind of Christ-honoring operation we wanted to be. These insights brought about an immediate transformation in my attitude toward my YFC experience; they allowed me to return to Fort Wayne 15 months later with a surprising optimism about our chances to correct ourselves. I realized that we had not become ugly Christians while we were leading our organization. We were simply naive about the fact that our organization’s culture had changed—inevitably—during our growth and, in so doing, had hindered, rather than furthered, our most important values.

It is understandable that many volunteers and staff who were part of our youth ministry during those days left disappointed with the degree of Christianness they had experienced in our organization. I have since learned just how common it is for persons in churches and parachurch settings alike to experience considerable disenchantment with their organizations. Churches are torn apart over power struggles, changes in methods, and leadership styles.

My own experience has led me to consider the ministry leadership in such places with considerable charity. It’s often unfair to question the depth of their Christian faith. It may, however, be fair to wonder about the extent of their understanding about the nature of their organizational culture, and whether they’ve engaged in the theological reflection necessary to shape the ministry’s structures toward greater faithfulness.

Ponderable

Can organizations be faithful? If it’s possible to lay such a designation on an organization, it will be because its people recognize the places in the organizational culture that are vulnerable to biblical corruption. When we do accurate sociological analysis it’s more likely we can do penetrating theological reflection about our organizations.

As Howard Snyder explained in The Problem of Wineskins,1 the church has often been slow to adjust our man-made organizational structures to the fresh work that God wants to do in our lives. As is true in Jesus’ parable, the wineskins of our own design sometimes become too inflexible to accommodate the wine of the always-renewing gospel of Jesus Christ. When clear theological thinking is married to insightful sociological analysis we can identify the changes that need to take place and ensure that our organizational cultures serve the purposes of God nobly.

On the continuum between organizational innovators and traditionalists, those of us who are in youth ministry likely lean toward the creative and flexible side. Without insights about what’s at stake in our structural revisions, we may unwittingly employ ministry strategies, programs, and operations that result in undesirable outcomes. Organizations-as-culture are educational powerhouses, tapping into the transformational nature of socialization to help us catch values. I have such genuine respect for the Clydesdale nature of the learning that takes place in organizational cultures that I have sometimes wondered if a youth ministry graduate’s first full-time job couldn’t undo much of the educational good that I am committed to as a professor. That’s why we must be alert. If we don’t see potential outcomes clearly, we may unintentionally misrepresent the Christian faith through our organizational culture.

Ingredients in the mix of an organizational culture

Whether we’re trying to understand the culture of our overall youth ministry, or that of a particular small group of teens, there are certain elements to which we may want to pay attention. Analyzing each of these individual parts will give us a picture of the ministry structure that is sharper than what we might derive by thinking about the operation as a whole. It’s not unlike how we determine our health status. Symptoms convince us that something is wrong, perhaps because we have less energy than we once did, feel unusual aches or pains, or notice uncommon variations in our digestive system, etc. In order to understand the true picture of our health, we may need to scrutinize parts of our body—including the various systems that form our physical make-up. Those who have tried to understand the development of organizations have found it useful to examine values, beliefs, goals, history, environment, leadership styles, methods or technologies, and various forms of power.2 Taken together, these different aspects of a ministry offer a pretty good picture of its organizational culture.



Values

An organization’s values can be understood as that which is considered important by those within the ministry. Sometimes these values are openly identified, as in the case when a group chooses to promote their core values through training and other forms of public declaration. In other settings values may not be openly championed, but are nonetheless woven throughout the observable behaviors of the ministry.

For instance, a youth group might explicitly state that worship is a central value in their ministry, but implicitly choose to value the quality of the worship programming over, say, the broad participation of lots of kids during their meeting times. Both explicit and implicit values contribute to the organizational culture and, as can be seen by this example, both need to be reflected upon so they can be measured against biblical values.



Beliefs

How are an organization’s beliefs different from its values? Beliefs are operational assumptions that are building blocks for ministry strategies. Some youth ministries are built around the belief that there is nothing adults do that can’t be done better by well-trained students. It’s easy to see how significant this single belief might be to the organizational culture of the ministry. The same can be said for all kinds of operating beliefs that inform ministry practices.

Note that beliefs may or may not be rooted in an accurate understanding of truth and can often even reflect the nuances of a group’s particular theological orientations. Consider the difference between youth groups from Pentecostal and Presbyterian backgrounds. It would be a mistake to underestimate how important the Pentecostal youth ministry’s beliefs about the activity of the Holy Spirit would likely contribute to the distinctiveness of their organizational culture.



Goals

Like both values and beliefs, an organization’s goals can be either explicitly or implicitly pursued. In addition, it’s possible for one’s personal goals to conflict with the group’s goals, having relevant impact upon a ministry culture. However, one of the most telling observation points about goals is when we see the process by which goals were formulated and distributed throughout the organization. Sometimes youth ministers operate like Moses coming off the mountain (or out of their study) with goals revealed to them by God and already written in stone. The only thing that others are expected to do, in such situations, is dutifully pursue these divinely ordered directions.

Whether the goals are worthy or not is beside the point I’d like to make. The organizational culture that results from this type of goal-setting process is very different from that which is felt when the group participates in formulating the goals they will subsequently be asked to achieve. As participants in the body of Christ, spiritually mature people can be expected to help understand the Lord’s directives for their ministry.



History

A church youth ministry in our area has been rocked in recent years by the successive hiring of two youth pastors convicted on charges of molestation. With such a traumatic history as an example, it shouldn’t be a surprise that this element can be—at times—a dominating influence on an organizational culture. Of course, a ministry’s history doesn’t have to be catastrophic to impact the overall culture of the youth group. While conducting research about student leader effectiveness,3 I asked small groups within larger leadership teams to agree on the most significant experience of their youth ministry’s previous three years. It was enjoyable and insightful to hear these clusters—without benefit of interacting with other groups—identify the same important experiences. Clearly these collective memories had made a positive impact on the culture of these youth ministries.



Environment

Is there any question that a youth ministry that operates in a wealthy suburban context has a different organizational flavor than that which is nestled in a more impoverished urban area? We will help ourselves if we reflect about how the environment in which we minister may, at the same time, be both a strength and a limitation to our work. If a youth ministry is located in the ‘burbs, it may be difficult to attend to the priority of ministry among the poor. The environment will have contributed a natural, though not insurmountable, barrier that is a significant factor in the organizational culture of the ministry.

Socioeconomic status is not the only demographic worth paying attention to. Some youth ministries are located in rural settings where kids live miles away from one another. There are no common or convenient hang-outs where kids comfortably collect. This environmental reality also contributes to a youth ministry’s culture.



Leadership styles

Youth pastors and others who serve in leadership roles exercise an impact on the culture of an organization that dare not be underestimated. At one end of the continuum, leaders may exercise an authoritarian leadership style; others are more laid-back and laissez-faire. In between are styles that may be characterized as participatory, consulting, and democratic.4 Each style adds a distinctive imprint on the ministry’s culture. Just yesterday I had a conversation with an adult youth ministry volunteer at a local church. She was frustrated to the point of quitting. Her description of the part-time youth director, a young man in his early 20s, painted the picture of a guy who would tell his team what they would each do without inviting any participation in the planning. (This style is almost always frustrating to competent people.) Add to this particular authoritative style the fact that this young man was also poor in his preparation and still developing his own skills, and it’s not hard to see the source of frustration for this 35-year-old mother of three. If I would have asked her to color the culture of their youth ministry, I’m not sure she could have reported anything different than the red she was seeing right then! And the rookie youth director’s leadership style was supplying scads of scarlet for her vision!



Methods or technologies

Some youth ministries are designed around small cell groups that grow and multiply as their outreach is effective. Others are committed to frequent retreats or mission trips. Still others employ an aggressive strategy of alternative worship forms. Some have begun to develop Internet-based ministry strategies. The list is practically endless when we think about methods used in various youth ministries: concerts of prayer; car wash fundraisers; lock-ins; outreach parties; inductive Bible studies; confirmation classes; newsletters; student leader training; altar calls. Each of these methods or ministry technologies wield influence on an organizational culture.

Some ministries have found it useful to list every method they employ in their work with youth, whether it relates to their direct ministry or the organization of their work. They might then circle the five methods that seem to have the greatest impact on their collective experience. For example, though Campus Life staff insist that there are nine points of concentration to their ministry, one program may be dominated by the weekly large group meetings while another program emphasizes interpersonal appointments. The differences in the resulting organizational cultures are worthy of consideration.



Forms of power

One of the more fascinating considerations of any ministry comes about when we take a closer look at one of the five ways (at least?) power is located in organizational forms.

If we look at the organization’s formal structure, we are typically checking out a chart that describes lines of authority and accountability. Some charts point to a classic pyramid structure, and others look like a 20th-century matrix variation of this model.5 In each case it’s not hard to locate the power in the organization. Others, in order to diffuse this power, have advocated a cellular organizational structure. In the case of Larry Richards, it is his theological commitment to servant leadership, the priesthood of all believers, and the exclusive role of Jesus as head of the church that has led him to advocate this more responsive and consensual structure for the church.6

Communication patterns are also a form of power within an organizational culture. Imagine that you were an invisible researcher, recording every instance of communication that took place within your ministry. Who talks to whom? How often? Over what topics? Who seems cut off from communication patterns? After some time you would be able to draw these patterns and locate the persons who wield the most power as a result of their place in the communication process. For example, many youth ministries employ prayer chains. If the strategy is designed so that everyone passes the info on to one person who also passes it on to another, then those at any place in the chain have the power to disrupt accurate communication to those who follow. On the other hand, if five persons are called and each of these is also responsible for calling five others, the communication power is more concentrated in these first recipients of information.

The first is a grapevine, the next is a gatekeeper.7 Locating the power points through these patterns need not be confined to the ministry’s formal communication agenda to be instructive. When gossips are well-connected, their power—and destructive impact—on the organizational culture is important to understand.

The key to faithfulness

How can getting keys to adult volunteers be a theological issue? It’s certainly true that it doesn’t have to be. On the other hand, if we are missionally focused on empowering others for ministry, distributing church keys to our team makes perfect sense. When a policy (or person) insists that limiting key distribution is central to organizational effectiveness, the ensuing power struggle may contain some actual theological dimensions. Granted, we’re not talking about Micah 6:8 here, but there are still faithfulness issues at stake.

Rules and procedures can be standardized in many youth ministries, often resulting in a manual that is intended to govern common, or tricky, situations. The power in this instance is located with those who know, or can change, these standard operating procedures. When a youth minister friend called earlier this week for counsel on how to confront the key distribution policy at his church, he was really experiencing the unwelcome use of power by some who used standard procedures to keep him from giving building keys to some of his youth leadership. Part of the embarrassment for him was that he hadn’t realized he was in violation of a policy when he handed out church keys. For those new to a ministry, this is called learning the ropes. I watched a veteran youth minister stumble in the first year of a new responsibility because he did not realize the relationship between his reporting procedure, planning, and the budget process. His organizational power—along with his budget—grew the next year when he learned the system.

Paying attention to decision-making processes can also be useful in locating power. What decisions—large or small—are made related to youth ministry? Who makes them? How are they made? Listing these three headings (What? Who? How?) at the top of a paper and filling in the columns may help map the decision-making processes and serve to locate those with power. This can also help leaders understand ways they may unthinkingly exclude others from the process. For example, if real plans take place at the “informal” breakfast after early-morning small groups, then the more formally designated times for making decisions can be extremely frustrating for those who weren’t part of the bacon-and-eggs strategy sessions. Sometimes our favorite kids wield power in ministry because they actively lobby us in our decision-making. We can’t decide if this is a good thing or a bad thing if we don’t recognize its existence.

Control of resources is yet another way that power can be located, and like decision-making processes, mapping is a useful way to see where the power resides. List every organizational resource you can think of—from expertise to gifts to money to time—down one column and try to put the name of the person who exercises the most control over that resource in an opposite column. This exercise can help us see who holds this form of power within the organizational culture. It can be enlightening to learn just how much power one person in a small group holds because of the number of resources he or she controls (location, meeting time, biblical expertise, food distribution, etc.). Do you see how this information could help you understand why the particular group has yet to cultivate healthy interdependence?

Intentional eyes and minds

The fact that culture is so often unexamined is one reason that theological reflection—an underused discipline itself—is seldom applied to our organizational life. We don’t have much hope at all unless we’re intentional in both our seeing and our thinking.

Why is it so difficult to be aware of the impact of organizational culture? Culture in general is like the air we breathe. We are often unaware of its quality unless there are problems. The same is true for the atmosphere of the youth ministries in which we are immersed.

Seeing organizational culture clearly and theological usefulness

When we see clearly, we have an opportunity that is not otherwise available to us. We can reflect upon what we see. Armed with solid theological grounding, such reflection can help us uncover areas where our organizational efforts are getting in the way of our faithfulness. We can understand the connection between what God wants to do and the organizational (in)flexibility that may hinder him.

Consider the historical example of John Wesley. While his perseverance, godliness, discipline, and passion for Jesus Christ were quite remarkable, there are others in history possessing similar qualities who did not achieve what he did. His organizational creativity was an additional genius he offered the Lord. He preached in the fields because that’s where the masses could be reached. He empowered lay preachers because there was so much to do. Class meetings provided settings for accountability and discipleship. Love feasts were celebrations that the common people could understand.8

When we’re overly pragmatic…

The statement that “organizational vision was driven by theological necessity” really affirms the priorities for which this book was written. Unfortunately, our organizational designs are often exclusively shaped by pragmatic concerns, without regard for the theological implications. We end up stumbling away from faithfulness, ignorant of not only the damage that was done, but the opportunities that may have been lost.

None of these innovations were sanctioned by Wesley’s Anglican Church. He proceeded to innovate because he recognized that the organizational forms of the church could not be bent to the work to which God had called him. His organizational vision was driven by theological necessity. Like many of us, he realized that his previous ministry was simply not meeting the expectations of faithfulness that the Lord has for us. Seeing clearly paved the way for his radical changes. Jim Petersen has said that Christians ought to always be revising our organizational structures for the cause of Christ.9

To help you see your organizational culture more clearly, try using the following 10 questions to reflect upon the youth ministry that you know the best. Ask the Lord to guide the response to what you discover.

  • What are the three most important values that can be deduced from your behavior, and how do they align with the most important biblical values for ministry?
  • What three core beliefs seem to have the greatest impact on your approach to ministry? What faith-based beliefs need to have a greater impact than they currenly do?
  • Who participates in setting goals? Are they openly reported for all to see? How does the goal-setting process reflect your uniquely Christian identity?
  • What stories in your youth ministry’s history are you proudest of? What stories are sources of sorrow? What has God been doing in your history?
  • How does your environment contribute to how your ministry has been formulated? Are there any biblical priorities—perhaps not natural to your environment—that may need to be recovered for your ministry?
  • What three methods or technologies are most deeply connected to how this ministry operates? Is change possible? How could you contextualize Psalm 20:7 for your ministry?
  • What is the testimony of the leadership? What are the conflict management styles of those who lead? Is it clear that Jesus is head of this organization by their leadership styles and patterns, or does he seem to be a figurehead?
  • What does the organizational chart look like? Is it more of a tribute to biblical faithfulness or organizational efficiency?
  • Who communicates to whom? How does Jesus want this to be answered?
  • Where is the power in your ministry? Do those who hold the power honor the Lord with the way they use it? How can you influence this balance of power with out violating biblical values in the process?
  • Theological truth compels us to order our lives and ministries around God’s priorities. None of us want to thwart God’s agenda by failing to see how our organizational cultures hinder his work.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑