Chapter 28 of 38

Chapter 23 Thinking Creatively: Beyond Schooling Perspectives in Curriculum

Chapter 23 Thinking Creatively: Beyond Schooling Perspectives in Curriculum

Chapter 23

Thinking Creatively: Beyond Schooling Perspectives in Curriculum

Duffy Robbins

Do your best to present yourself to God as one approved, a workman who does not need to be ashamed and who correctly handles the word of truth.

—2 Timothy 2:15

The task of the modern educator is not to cut down jungles, but to irrigate deserts. The right defense against false sentiments is to inculcate just sentiments. By starving the sensibility of our pupils we only make them easier prey to the propagandist when he comes. For famished nature will be avenged and a hard heart is no infallible protection against a soft head…

—C. S. Lewis, The Abolition of Man1

Anyone who has had more than a month of youth ministry experience knows the drill: a group of largely disinterested teenagers walk into a typically bland room, listen to an all-too-often hastily prepared Bible lesson, and walk away from the experience sighing in complaint that the whole affair was boring and too much like school. And one more youth worker who graduated from seminary or college thinking, “I have the gift of teaching,” finishes out the evening wondering, “Why don’t my kids have the gift of learning?”

Just like school

Not exactly a recruiting poster for youth ministry, is it? After all, let’s be honest—boring and just like a schoolteacher are not the two phrases we youth workers hope to build into our résumés. And yet, it may well be that behind the words of this adolescent critique is a more serious question: Is there anything distinctive about our mission of teaching the Bible to teenagers? Maybe Christian education, at least in its assumptions, is just like school. Or is there some sense in which teaching Matthew and Mark is wholly different from teaching math or Marx?

If we take seriously the call of God, the Word of God, and the work of God, it seems quite clear that there is a uniqueness in our mission of teaching Christian truth to teenagers. As Zuck explains it, “Christian education is unique because of its subject matter—the Bible, God’s written revelation; because of its goals—spiritual transformation of lives; and because of its spiritual dynamics—the work of the Holy Spirit.” In other words, we are in this enterprise beginning with a distinct and essential set of foundation stones2 that make our task distinctive.

  • We believe that these kids are creations of God, made in his likeness (Genesis 1:26), body and mind, not simply brutes manipulated by bodily impulses or physical and cultural realities, but moral agents with the capacity to think, know, and will.
  • We believe that this God-given capacity has been tragically marred and damaged by sin (Romans 1:18-32), an inherent flaw that affects both the way we learn and what we do with what we learn, especially with respect to truth about the God who made us (1 Corinthians 2:14-16).
  • We believe that the great need of our students is not just information, but transformation, a Spirit-transacted change that comes through a relationship with Jesus Christ (Romans 12:1-2). Apart from this life-giving work of God, the most knowledgeable person on the planet is no more than an educated fool (1 Corinthians 2:12-14).
  • In short, what we are talking about is a strategic and critical alliance between the youth worker and the Spirit of God. It is the teacher who teaches, but without the Spirit to “guide (our students)…into all truth” (John 16:13), to convict our students of sin (John 16:8), and convince them of righteousness (John 16:13), our effort is bankrupt—no more capable of igniting the fires of passion for God than plastic logs in an electric fireplace. The lesson may look good; it may even provide a little light, but don’t expect a lot of warmth from it.3

    Do these basic theological presuppositions affect what happens when 25 junior high kids stumble into the room for Wednesday night Bible study? Unquestionably. Is what happens just like school? By the power and promise of God, no.

    Boring in Jesus’ name

    We need to be challenged, though, that our involvement in a God-given mission does not give us license to ignore good sound teaching technique. What we are doing is not just like school, and hopefully the way we do it will not produce an experience that’s boring. Just as our mission grows out of the Word of God, our methods must be informed by the works of God. And God was not, is not, and will never be boring.

    Ponderable

    Might God not actually call us to walk through the Valley of the Shadow of Boredom on occasion as we follow him? Doesn’t God want to teach us to navigate life’s normalcies, which include boring times? And if he does, shouldn’t we expect that boredom might actually be an important tool to use, explore, and probe now and then in our curriculum? Do I ever need to facilitate Boredom As Learning? Or are these questions just too boring?

    The people who hanged Christ never, to do them justice, accused him of being a bore—on the contrary; they thought him too dynamic to be safe. It has been left for later generations to muffle up that shattering personality and surround him with an atmosphere of tedium. We have very efficiently pared the claws of the Lion of Judah, certified him “meek and mild,” and recognized him as fitting a household pet for pale curates and pious old ladies. To those who knew him, however, he in no way suggested a milk-and-water person; they objected to him as a firebrand…he was emphatically not a dull man during his human lifetime, and if he was God, there can be nothing dull about God either.4

    Teaching that reflects the image of our creator

    The challenge, of course, is to present biblical truth to our students in a way that is neither boring, nor does it stoop to the level of what David Poling describes as “the spiritual babes-in-joyland approach.”5 As Elton Trueblood reminds us, “Holy shoddy is still shoddy.”6 Part of our heritage as people created in the image of God is that we can give glory to our maker through our creative work. Bruce Lockerbie puts it this way:

    We are told that God ceased from all his work and rested on the Seventh Day; but with the dawning of the Eighth Day, the Artist of the Beautiful, the Master Potter, set his Apprentice to work, teaching him to copy the Master’s originals, summoning her to image forth new benedictions of praise.7

    To paraphrase Lockerbie, every time we teach—whether it be through small groups, object lessons, melodramas, lecture, initiative games, role plays, computer graphics, poetry, music, or video, we must view our work as that of a steward rightly using the gifts of God to render him glory. It is a task that brings together new combinations of novelty (thinking in a new way), appropriateness (an approach that does justice to both the topic and the student), transformation (taking something old and making it new), and condensation (taking that which nourishes and serving it in bite-sized, digestible portions).8

    In light of this challenge, it is no wonder that we so often hear—and perhaps voice ourselves—the complaint of the unfaithful servant, “…I was afraid and went out and hid your talent in the ground” (Matthew 25:25). There is a risk and a cost to the creative process. In her book, The Eighth Day of Creation, Elizabeth O’Connor warns:

    When we have not exercised our own capacity to create, we do not know what it is to wrestle with the angel9…If your daily life seems poor, do not blame it: blame yourself, tell yourself that you are not poet enough to call forth its riches; for to the creator there is no poverty and no poor indifferent place.10

    Jesus’ own teaching ministry gives us vivid examples of this sort of creative approach. He used such diverse teaching techniques as—

  • object lessons (John 4:1-42)
  • relational ministry (John 1:35-51)
  • problem-solving (Mark 10:17-22)
  • conversation (Mark 10:27)
  • questions (the Gospels record over 100 questions posed by Jesus in various situations)
  • lecture (Matthew 5-7; John 14-16)
  • parables (John 10:1-21; 15:1-10)
  • teachable moment, teaching through experience (John 4:5-26)
  • contrast (Matthew 5:21-22, 33-34, 38-39, 43-44)
  • illustrations, examples (Matthew 6:26-34)
  • simulation, symbols (John 13:1-20)
  • large and small groups (as many as 5,000 or as few as three)
  • modeling (Luke 18:15-17)11
  • And he did all of this without sacrificing content or calling. Jesus was sent by his Father with an explicit curriculum (John 6:38; 17:6-8), and he was faithful to that task. What an awesome sense of fulfillment he must have felt when he prayed in that high priestly prayer, “I have brought you glory on earth by completing the work you gave me to do” (John 17:4).

    A curriculum that brings glory

    But how do we design a curriculum that is faithful to our content, our calling, and our Creator? Good question.

    Perhaps we should begin by establishing what we mean by curriculum. Originally, the Latin word curriculum meant, among other things, “a racecourse or prescribed path.” In more modern usage, the word has come to mean (1) a prescribed academic program (“The core curriculum of our college includes two Bible courses”), (2) a written plan outlining which topics will be taught within a specific subject area or over a given course of time, and (3) the printed handout materials used to teach the lesson.12 For most youth workers, the major concern with curriculum will be in those latter two areas.

    Jesus and experiential teaching

    It is every bit as fascinating to study how Jesus structured his teaching experiences as it is to study the explicit content of his teaching. For example, there was probably something significant at stake when our Lord chose to use nonformal learning experiences as much as he did. Most agree that the learning closest to the natural patterns of one’s life has the greatest chance to be genuinely transformational.

    Essentially, what we’re talking about is the plan by which we intend to approach our teaching task. Indeed, it is this definition of the role of curriculum that Larry Richards believes has been underestimated and underemphasized in the church.13 Richards argues that curriculum is about much more than just the content to be learned. It is about structuring a teaching/training experience—whether that be in a Wednesday night Bible study, a Sunday night fellowship, a discipleship camp, a mission trip, or a Sunday school—in such a way that the process of learning be given as much attention as the truths to be taught.

    Setting the course: curriculum design

    It is a basic rule of navigation, and appropriate to the teaching task as well: the best way to begin charting the course is by determining the destination. In the lexicon of teaching, we’re really talking about objectives. How do we define our goals and aims for a given teaching opportunity? Before we can design a curriculum, we must ask ourselves, Where do we want to take this lesson?

    The church’s traditional answer to that question has been the transfer of some set of facts:

  • The students will be able to recite all four gospels
  • The students will understand that God accepts them as they are
  • The students will be able to describe in vivid detail how the left-handed Ehud stabbed the obese King Eglon
  • The students will be able to recite from memory each of the Song of Solomon passages that refer to the sex act
  • This schooling approach was essentially based on the general assumption that changed minds lead to changed behaviors.14 Typically, it featured Sunday school classrooms in which all the chairs were facing one way, classrooms in which the vital signs included quiet, attentive students listening to an intent teacher who in a fit of passion might occasionally gesture to a map of the Holy Land.

    Richards summarizes this approach with the following chart:15

    Figure 24.1. Richards’ summary of the schooling approach

    The intent of the approach is a good one. We certainly cannot ignore basic Bible content and be faithful to the one who described himself as truth (John 14:6). The teaching task is much bigger and deeper than merely seeking not to bore. Too many youth workers, fearful of the B-word, fixate only on the process of teaching and lapse into a kind of spiritual vaudeville that leaves students only mildly entertained and acutely (spiritually) illiterate. Curriculum involves more than simply content, but neither should it involve less.

    Ratcliffe and Davies cite research by William McCready (1985) in which he found that religious educators who “identified their work as ministry tended to have unclear goals and unformulated objectives about their work. In marked contrast, those Catholic religious educators who identified their work as education tended to have clear goals and well-formulated objectives about their work.”16 We don’t need more youth workers who know how to communicate “nothing” in an engaging way.

    In fact, it has been the education establishment’s abandonment of this traditional schooling approach that has led to a catastrophic decline in academic performance in America’s public schools, well-documented by Charles Sykes in his fascinating book Dumbing Down Our Kids: Why American Children Feel Good about Themselves but Can’t Read, Write or Add.17 E.D. Hirsch does a remarkable job of describing how present-day education “reformers” have so disparaged content learning and what is described as factory-model schools18 that we have become infatuated with what is now called higher-order skills, discovery learning, or the student-centered approach: “less whole-class teacher-directed instruction, less student passivity, sitting, listening, receiving, less student time reading textbooks, less…rote memorization of facts and details”19

    As one very progressive high school principal put it: “It is more important for me to have students know how to read a map than for them to have any one bit of information about that map. Rather than knowing where Nepal is, it’s more important that they know how to find Nepal.” In other words, students can be taught something called map reading skills or geographical thinking.20

    It’s an interesting analogy, because it is reminiscent of C. S. Lewis’ comment about a conversation he once had with an old crusty RAF officer who complained that he had little need for Lewis’ discussions of theology and doctrine for he had felt God’s presence (emphasis mine). Out alone in the desert at night, he had sensed this mysterious, tremendous presence.

    Now in a sense I quite agreed with that man. I think he had probably had a real experience of God in the desert. And when he turned from that experience to the Christian creeds, I think he really was turning from something real to something less real. In the same way, if a man has once looked at the Atlantic from the beach, and then goes and looks at a map of the Atlantic, he also will be turning from something real to something less real: turning from real waves to a bit of colored paper. But here comes the point. The map is admittedly only colored paper, but there are two things you have to remember about it. In the first place, it is based on what hundreds and thousands of people have found by sailing the real Atlantic. In that way it has behind it masses of experience just as real as the one you could have from the beach; only, while yours would be a single isolated glimpse, the map fits all those different experiences together. In the second place, if you want to go anywhere, the map is absolutely necessary. As long as you are content with walks on the beach, your own glimpses are far more fun than looking at a map. But the map is going to be more use than walks on the beach if you want to get to America.21

    Process versus content

    Those who want us to choose between either process or content are forcing a choice that need not be made. Aren’t we bound to teach biblical truth as content and help persons experience biblical truth as reality? Neither one is sufficient on its own. If you are one who believes that teaching can be content and process, you probably use some form of cooperative learning methods. And if you’re successful at teaching through interdependent collaboration, then the structure alone teaches something important about the way we are to relate to one another in the body of Christ.

    Hirsch cites a good deal of research22 demonstrating that in our repudiation of content learning we may have thrown out the baby with the bath water. As Richards argues, process is an important and critical element of curriculum design.23 But how is no more important than what. We must not forsake schooling, we must go beyond it.

    The Hebrew word for to know helps us understand that knowing goes deeper than mere cognitive learning. The verb to know has a richer, wider meaning that ranges from recognizing good and evil (Genesis 3:22; 39:9; 1 Samuel 28:9), to the ability to perceive accurately (Genesis 19:33, 35; 1 Samuel 12:17), to the ability to discriminate and discern (Jonah 4:11), to growth that comes through experience (Joshua 23:14, Psalm 51:5; Isaiah 59:12).

    Research has shown that teaching religious ideas to teenagers as a mere exercise of passing along knowledge has very little impact on their lives.24 A study of one secondary school in England at which students are given regular classroom religious instruction reported that “relatively few pupils thought that it helped them in self-understanding or regarded it as a personal quest for values and meaning, but most saw it as concerned mainly with the transmission of knowledge, in which they were involved in a passive manner, reading, writing, and listening. Knowledge was indeed acquired, but few saw any usefor it in the future” (emphasis mine).25

    An approach to teaching that gives us this fuller range of knowing is reflected in Robert Gagne’s five varieties of learning capabilities,26 listed below with examples of how these varieties of learning experiences might be relevant for a junior high Bible study:

  • Impart basic intellectual skills (John 3:16—What do the components of this Bible reference mean? Is this a man’s name, his birthday, or a bathroom on the third floor?)
  • Extend verbal information (Where is the Gospel of John? How do I find other Bible verses?)
  • Facilitate development of cognitive strategies (How can I understand these verses when I find them?)
  • Develop attitudes (What difference does God’s love make for me?)
  • Enhance life change (How would my behavior change if I took seriously God’s love for me?)
  • The significance of this approach is that it reminds us that different kinds of curriculum are suited to different kinds of learning.27 There is a sense in which it is completely appropriate to define our teaching objectives in very basic terms: ownable (we might expect the student to be willing to receive this objective—to respond to this truth or lesson), reachable (the student is able to accomplish this response), and measurable (we will be able to evaluate whether or not we have accomplished our objective). Or to put it another way, lesson objectives should be “(1) brief enough to remember, (2) clear enough to write down, and (3) specific enough to achieve.”28

    On controlling outcomes

    How in-charge are we really in our spiritual-formation roles? Most Christian teachers realize they are frankly not in control of the most important transformational outcomes that God may want to accomplish in a young person’s life. Which is why some teachers use process-oriented objectives—believing the results of their efforts will be good and assessing the value of the strategy after the learning experience takes place. When you ask students to reflect on how a certain passage of Scripture relates to their relationships at home, for example, you’re shifting from attempting to control the outcome to managing the learning activities.

    For example, consider this basic lesson plan objective: “Students will identify three ways they can exercise an attitude of servanthood in their homes over the next week.” This kind of basic objective keeps us focused on the fact that our mandate is not simply to hear, but to do (James 1:22). We do not want just to teach; we want the students to learn. But it also keeps us honest. If we never define our objective in measurable terms, we will never know if we have missed it. Perhaps that’s why we don’t!

    On the other hand, defining our objectives strictly in these terms is to possibly miss a significant portion of the teaching process because it doesn’t sufficiently account for the variety of ways that the kids in our youth groups might respond to a truth from God’s Word. Egan hints at this in his book, Teaching as Story Telling:

    If we reflect not just on the diversity of things a teacher might hope to have happen in an average class, but the ways in which all kinds of associations of ideas, particular hobbies or interests, wonder and humor, that might purely incidentally be stimulated, we may consider whether the reality of educational engagements is inappropriately represented as planned means working carefully along a prespecified path to precisely delineated objectives. Of course we can organize our curricula and lessons this way. But such a process seems not to fit some obvious features of education.29

    Nor does it adequately account for the ways the Holy Spirit moves in our midst when we open our lessons to his presence, enlightening, encouraging, convicting, convincing, revealing, confirming, surprising, applying, and clarifying.

    A simple and yet more wholistic approach to the task of designing the Bible study would incorporate all the different facets of the learning/knowing experience:

  • Cognitive (receiving): What content, facts, and ideas do I anticipate my students will learn in this study?
  • Affective (feeling): What sort of feelings might I anticipate this study will invoke in my students?
  • Behavioral (doing): If the students take seriously this truth from God’s Word, how might their behavior be different on a daily basis?
  • Existential (being): How do I anticipate this study might impact the basic values and inner core of individual students?30
  • To be sure, even these broad objectives will have to be adjusted from time to time, even during the course of the lesson. As Habermas and Issler point out, the Scripture gives us at least one occasion when that seems to have happened with Jesus and the disciples (Matthew 16:5-12), and it clearly happened when Paul overestimated the ability of the Corinthian believers to receive some of what he planned to teach (1 Corinthians 3:2).31 But this approach to curricular design will give us the best opportunity to incorporate the intriguing, mysterious, miraculous mix of teacher, student, and Spirit of God.

    It is a dynamic combination that students are rarely exposed to in most schools, and hopefully, if we are diligent in our creative task, it won’t just be one more boring night at youth group.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑