Chapter 25 of 38

Chapter 20 Seeing Clearly: Social Context

Chapter 20 Seeing Clearly: Social Context

Chapter 20

Seeing Clearly: Social Context

Patricia Davis

Dr. Evil is easily the most memorable comic character of Mike Myers’ Austin Powers spy-adventure movies. He feebly attempts to gain control of the world by demanding one million dollars from the United Nations. His tiny double, Mini-Me, has to be restrained from nibbling the ears of his cat (“We don’t gnaw on our kitty! Not even just a little bit!”). His son, Scott Evil, can barely contain his contempt for Dr. Evil’s inept and overly elaborate plans (“Aren’t you even going to watch them? They could get away!”). But Dr. Evil does one thing very effectively—he knows how to silence Scott.

One of the funniest running jokes of the movies is Dr. Evil’s ability to utterly quiet Scott by interrupting him, talking over him, pointing, motioning, and totally drowning him out—“Zip it!…Shhhh…Ziiiiiiip!…All right, zip it!” “When a problem comes along we must zip it!” “Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, Exzip-it A.” Over and over again Scott is prohibited from speaking, and part of the humor of the moment is watching his totally frustrated eye-rolling response to his goofy and totally out-of-touch evil father.

For the joke to be funny, Mike Myers counts on the audience to identify with Scott. Myers counts on us to remember the feelings from those maddening moments in our own lives when we have been silenced—especially when we knew we understood a situation more clearly or had a better idea than the one keeping us quiet.

Most youth ministers think of ourselves as the opposite of Dr. Evil—we are the ones to whom adolescents can come to tell us their problems and share their pains. And we are the ones they can count on for respectful listening. Most of us wouldn’t like to think that at times we are more like Dr. Evil the silencer than Scott the frustrated son. Unhappily, though, we often function as unintentional silencers to the very kids who need our care and our listening ears the most.

Silence isn’t golden

Can you feel the tremendous difference—in theological values, anyway—between ministry that listens and hears and ministry that silences? While one hopes that much of what effectively silences young people is done unwittingly, it’s hard to think of any defendable reason to silence someone before they are even listened to.

All of the youth with whom we work are susceptible to being silenced (despite the incessant noise of any particular youth group meeting). This is true because of something happening in their psychological development at this time in their lives: they are beginning to relinquish their childhood outlooks and identities and attempting to try to establish stable adult identities for themselves—to leave behind childish ways and to become adults.

Identity development

Adolescents are at a crisis point in their lives. Their bodies are becoming more and more like women and men; their minds are becoming more and more capable of thinking in mature ways; and their emotions are beginning to get more and more complex. Adolescence is a truly stressful time of constant change. The psychological goal for adolescents is to try and establish some kind of adult stability for themselves—to figure out who they are, what they believe, who they want as friends, and who they want to become. For boys this may be mostly about trying to become the independent and autonomous man the culture tells them they should be.1 For girls this will probably be a time of entering complex relationships that will teach them who they are.2

For both boys and girls, this period is about taking risks. Children who are becoming adults choose parts of their childhood to cling to and parts to reject. They watch adults to see what they might want to emulate and make part of their own lives. No adolescent can feel secure while this sorting-out process is taking place. Every morning a new person might appear in the mirror; every night new dreams take the place of yesterday’s dreams. Every day is a challenge. In each piece of clothing, each telephone call, each class period, and each worship service, new things are being added and subtracted. Most importantly, new things are being tested.

In our culture—a culture that demands perfection—most teenagers feel inadequate. It’s hard to make a perfect presentation of one’s self to the outside world even after we’ve attained adulthood. Adolescents make different presentations of themselves depending on where they are and whom they are with. They are different at home with their families than they are at church. They are different in worship than they are on retreat. They are different this year than last—different this afternoon than this morning. Each presentation is an important experiment with identity. But our culture provides a cruel stage for experimentation. Where nothing less than perfection is required, kids are reluctant to stray very far from what seems to them to be perfect (or at least “normal”—which is as close as most can come to perfection).

Adolescents need oases—places where they can go and make mistakes and be imperfect—places where they can test themselves in the presence of safe, caring, and accepting adults and peers. An adolescent who is given the zip-it silencing treatment, learns quickly not to experiment or trust himself. But silencing can also be manifest in more subtle ways than the physical restraining of someone’s voice—a room can be full of noisy teenagers who are silenced nevertheless. How is that so?

Kids are susceptible to being silenced, because they are unsure that they are worthy—unsure that they even are real people. Anytime a teenager, or anyone, feels that his inner world does not match with his outer world—that his deepest feelings are not valued by those in his outer world—that his views are not acceptable or interesting to those with whom he associates (especially people he admires)—he will be more likely to be quiet about his real self and his real beliefs. If he attends a youth group or a church where one point of view prevails all the time—where one way of doing things always wins, where there is no encouragement to question and to be different—he will more than likely act as if he agrees, or believes the same, or doesn’t have questions. Eventually, if he doesn’t quit or act out (Columbine is an extreme example) he will forget the real part of himself that isn’t valued. He will forget his real feelings, questions, and desires in order to be a person who is treated with what appears to be respect. Being silenced means being shut down psychologically—being forced to stop growing and changing, forced to give up on the project of becoming the person God intends him to be.

Ponderable

Does there have to be a clash between a theological commitment to absolute truth that is significantly, if not entirely, knowable and a desire to help students develop their own sense of identity? Say, for example, you’re convinced that unless students build their identity around the exclusive claims of Jesus Christ to be the way, the truth, and the life, their identity construction will be fatally flawed. You come to that conclusion based upon your theological convictions. Does this mean you’re a silencer of kids who are working out their identity formation because you don’t consider all options to be equally worthy?

To what degree should you respect the intensity and personal nature of the identity task that young people must engage in? How can you hold your theological convictions and, at the same time, be genuinely supportive to them in their process?

Silencing a teenager is almost equivalent to asking her to forego salvation—how can she present herself to God when she has been prevented from developing the self she needs to be?—when she has been forced to adopt a style instead of a true identity?

Kids at special risk of being silenced

Some youth are particularly susceptible to being silenced because they are, by definition, not a part of what is considered normal. These include: most girls, youth from outside the majority race or ethnicity (especially if they are attending mixed-racial/ethnic fellowships), youth from lower-income families, youth who are lesbian or gay, and youth who are in other ways different, quiet, or odd. Sadly these kids tend to be silenced even when their youth leaders and teachers are not particularly sexist, racist, classist, or homophobic.

Silencing doesn’t take place because the youth leaders or teachers are evil—more often it is because the leaders have accepted the hurtful cultural norms without thinking about them. Silencing happens naturally because the leaders are who they are—with their own identities at stake, points of view, ways of looking at the world, theologies, and ways of judging what is and is not important and true. Unhappily the leaders themselves—along with the rest of the culture—have been taught to be in compliance with the norms, and even to forget that the norm is an artificial set of potentially and probably hurtful rules.

It is very hard to listen to someone who seems different—and hard to give respect to the ideas of someone we feel has less valid ideas than our own (even if we wouldn’t admit we feel this way). It goes against the grain even to notice those who do not fit the norm—the ones who don’t behave—dress, speak, walk, look—in the ways we are all taught to expect from important people. One example of silencing is the way in which the culture, and even the church, refuses to hear adolescent girls. Similar dynamics take place for kids who are black, Asian, Hispanic, poor, gay, lesbian, or just different in any other major way.

How girls are unintentionally silenced

Silencing a girl is another way of telling her she’s not smart, that her ideas are not good, that her ways of looking at the world aren’t valuable, and—at the deepest level—that she doesn’t really matter. No one who loves kids would intentionally do this to any girl—yet, studies show that we silence girls unintentionally all the time. Adolescent girls live in the same world as their male counterparts, but they experience it much differently. Among other things they are more likely to be depressed, to try to commit suicide, to be the victim of violent sexual assaults, and to experience the consequences of sexual activity (becoming pregnant and losing their social standing). They are less likely than boys to be called on in any class in school, less likely to find role models in their textbooks, and more likely to be told to be content with traditionally female career choices.3

Many girls become confused and depressed around the time they enter high school when gender roles become very rigid and pronounced. They discover that although they used to have the run of the playground, they are now expected to be young women—more sedate and polite. They learn quickly that to attract a boyfriend they must appear to be less intelligent, lose weight—in fact, they must pay excruciating attention to every detail of their appearance, and stuff anger deep inside themselves so that it doesn’t ever show. They must learn to compete with their friends and other girls for boys. They must take care of others’ feelings. Above all they must be nice and perfect.

All of these rules serve to teach girls that they must not talk—at least not about anything that really matters to them. Their emotions may be too intense, and they may actually place themselves in danger by revealing their inner lives. I’ve never met a youth leader who intentionally silenced girls. But youth groups often serve to silence girls by reinforcing the two most powerful cultural messages: girls must be nice and they must be perfect. When a girl hears these messages at church, they seem to be sent to her from God. Does God really value niceness and perfection, as the culture defines it, above all else in girls? Does God expect girls to swallow their anger when it is often a sign that they are being abused or are in compromising situations? Does God want girls to value their appearance to the point that they stop eating and caring for their bodies? Do we send a message to girls that they aren’t important when we call their agonizing over relationships silly, and tell them that they don’t really know what love is? Do we reinforce the cultural sexual double standard for girls when we insist in our sex education classes that the girls should be the gatekeepers and upholders of sexual morality?

Most of us would never intentionally silence girls—or any other member of our youth groups—yet we seem to send them messages that tell them not to speak. Where do these messages originate? How do we learn them? How can we unlearn them?

How we learn to silence others

At a recent youth seminar where a friend of mine was a leader, she was approached by a young man—a youth leader—who wanted to discuss the problem of hypocrisy in his group. He was extremely frustrated with his senior high students, because the ones he called the good kids—the natural leaders, good-looking, good students, well-respected by the adults, and socially-involved—were also the kids who were partying, taking drugs, drinking, and having dangerous sex on the weekends. He was particularly mad that some of them were coming to church on Sunday mornings drunk.

When my friend suggested that perhaps these weren’t really the good kids in his group, and that he might want to consider removing them from positions of leadership, he was shocked. She told him that, in fact, it sounded like the other kids—the ones with less polish and sophistication, less-stylish clothes, not the best grades, and less adult approval—probably had a better chance of deserving the description good than the first group. It seemed as if these more invisible kids were being silenced in his church, and they were learning a hard and bad lesson: those who present themselves in the perfect mode are more likely to be heard and appreciated despite their self-destructive behaviors.

Ironically, in accepting the cultural picture of who is good and important, this youth group leader was hurting the first group as well as the second. In overlooking the first group’s dangerous, dishonest, and ultimately self-destructive behaviors, he was giving his unspoken approval to it. In allowing them to function as leaders in the youth fellowship, he was teaching them that appearances are more important than reality. Isn’t this the opposite of what we should be trying to teach adolescents about their relationships to each other, the church, and to God?

Where did this youth leader learn to silence the invisible kids in his group? Indeed, why were they invisible to him? And why did the other group—the group he called good—seem so important to him?

These kinds of lessons are not taught by our parents or our schools directly. They are not learned like we learned how to tie our shoes, match our clothes, use forks and knives, write in cursive, or take SAT tests. If our shoes don’t stay tied we can return to our father to demand more instruction. If we don’t get a high enough score on our SAT’s, we return to our prep course teachers and demand a refund. But the kind of learning that teaches us to silence others seems almost to come from the air we breathe. Philosophers of knowledge tell us that this kind of learning takes place without specific teachers and without our even being aware of it; this unexamined and unnamable knowledge is called tacit knowledge.4 It’s taught to us in many ways—all of them indirect. It is knowledge overheard in our grandparents’ and parents’ houses, on the street, on television, and in church. It tells us what is true and not true about our lives on the most basic levels—the levels we are taught never to question. We learn such things as: it’s okay to eat meat, not bugs, and never peanut butter sandwiches that have fallen to the ground; that churches are holy buildings; that women need to wear shirts or blouses at all times, but men don’t; that we ring bells when people are married and when they die; that raising our lips at the edges and showing some teeth (smiling) usually is a signal of happiness, but sometimes of threat; that it is a good thing to be married and to have children.

Some of these may seem like silly examples; most of us have probably even violated the peanut butter on the ground rule. But the most powerful tacit knowledge doesn’t seem like knowledge at all—it seems more like “the way things really are and ought to be.” Tacit knowledge as a whole is a vast collection of these kinds of rules and “truths” that shapes and guides the ways we live our lives. Without this kind of very basic knowledge, the world would be chaotic, unmanageable, unintelligible, and essentially meaningless. Children are allowed several years to learn tacit knowledge; adults who don’t seem to have learned it are often considered crazy.

Not all tacit knowledge is harmless or beneficial. Some of the tacit knowledge of this culture includes such harmful beliefs as: the more important gender is male; the most favored race is Anglo; the best body shape is thin; the cultural expectation for its members is perfection; lower economic status is despised; violence is to be tolerated; and silence is to be expected from all those who are not male, Anglo, thin, perfect, rich, and successful. These evil cultural tacit beliefs are harmful for everyone, because they produce oppression and violence—and they are powerful because, for many, they just seem to be true.

A theological spring cleaning

This discussion is key to the central purpose of this book. Patricia Davis writes that we may have to do some massive spring cleaning regarding our theological thinking and identify previously unexamined tacit beliefs, dragging them out in the open for closer scrutiny and submitting them to rigorous tests in the light of God’s word. That’s a lot of work, not naturally or easily done; few things are more important for our lives or ministries.

Christians have a call to be resisters of these evil tacit beliefs. In Jesus’ last prayer for his disciples, he says: “As thou didst send me into the world, so I have sent [the disciples] into the world. And for their sake I consecrate myself, that they also may be consecrated in truth” (John 17:18-19 RSV). Jesus is not asking that his followers be taken out of the world; in fact, the opposite is true. But, he asks that the disciples be “consecrated in truth,” freed from the kinds of tacit “knowledge” that produces sin, hatred, and oppression. The ultimate goal is “that they may all be one” (John 17:21 RSV) and “that the world may know that thou hast sent me and hast loved them even as thou hast loved me” (John 17:23 RSV). Christians are called to uncover tacit beliefs that work in opposition to God’s will, hurt others, and cause violence. Christians are called to resist this kind of evil cultural tacit “knowledge” to bring glory to God’s name.

Part of what it means to resist harmful and untrue forms of tacit knowledge, is to uncover those kinds of accepted beliefs that lead to the devaluing of girls; to racist actions and thoughts; to the devaluing of the poor; to the oppression of gay and lesbian people; and to the disapproval of anyone who seems different from normal. Once these beliefs are uncovered, it’s easy to see that they are false by the standards of God’s love. God empowers us to uncover these beliefs so that we can “all be one.” To uncover falsity, however, is also to uncover our own accountability. We have not often listened to those the culture has devalued; in fact, most often we’ve contributed to silencing them, even though we try not to be sexist, racist, etc.

The youth group leader mentioned above was shocked and saddened to think that he might have contributed to the pain of both groups of youth in his church by unthinkingly affirming what seemed normal to him. The handsome, thin, rich, white kids just seemed better. By the time he left my friend, he had been encouraged—reminded that he wasn’t totally blinded by the cultural tacit belief system. He had at least taken the first step in uncovering some harmful tacit beliefs—he had gotten angry and frustrated by the kids’ behaviors. In the end he was able to see that he also needed to resist and challenge the cultural norms that had hidden the hard truths about his youth fellowship. He left with the hope that when he is able to refocus his attention on the invisible group, they will undoubtedly feel more free to speak and be themselves. Removing the previous leader group from the privileges of leadership will probably help them understand the necessity of changing their behaviors; at the least, it will show them that their actions have consequences. Both groups will have been encouraged to move toward what God intends for them, through the courage of this youth leader who was angered by hypocrisy.

Very few among those of us who call ourselves youth ministers or leaders would intentionally silence any adolescent based on gender, race, sexual orientation, or the economic status of her family. Most of us, however, unintentionally silence some of our youths because we have not adequately uncovered and resisted some of the harmful and hurtful tacit beliefs we’ve inherited from our culture. God calls us to the work of resisting these harmful messages for the sake of our own souls, our youth, our churches, and ultimately for the glory of God. Our goal should be the creation of fellowships where every member can feel free to speak, test, grow, and become what God intended that individual to be.

↑ Back to top

↑