Parallel Passages
Parallel Passages
The following passages in Aquinas’s other works parallel the articles of his Quodlibetal Questions. For the full titles of these works, see the Abbreviations.
Quodlibet VII
Article 1: In Sent. III, d.14, a.1, qla. 3; In Sent. IV, d.49, q.2, a.1; QDV, q.8, a.1; SCG III, 49 & 51; CT I, 105; In 1 Cor., c. 13, lect. 4; ST I, q.12, a.1, 2 & 5; ST II-II, q.175, a.3, ad 2; In Iohan., c. 1, lect. 11.
Article 2: In Sent. II, d.3, q.3, a.4; In Sent. III, d.14, a.2, qla. 4; QDV, q.8, a.14; QDV, q.13, a.3; SCG I, 55; SCG II, 101; QDA, q.18, ad 5; ST I, q.58, a.2; ST I, q.85, a.4.
Article 3: In Sent. II, d.3, q.3, a.3; QDV, q.8, a.10 & 11; QDV, q.10, a.5; SCG II, 98 & 100; QDA, q.20; ST I, q.57, a.2; ST I, q.89, a.4; DSS, c. 13 & 16.
Article 4: QDV, q.10, a.8, ad 14; QDV, q.24, a.4, arg. 14 & ad 14 (cf. ST I, q.93, a.7, arg. 2 & ad 2).
Article 1: In Sent. III, d.15, q.2, a.1, qla. 3 & a.3, qla. 2; QDV, q.10, a.11, ad 3; QDV, q.26, a.3, ad 1; QDV, q.26, a.9 & 10; CT I, 232; ST III, q.46, a.7 & 8.
Article 2: In Sent. I, d.8, q.5, a.2; In Sent. II, d.3, q.1, a.1; In BDT, q.5, a.4, arg. 4 & ad 4; QDV, q.20, a.2, ad 4; SCG II, 50–52; QDA, q.6; QDSC, a.1; ST I, q.50, a.2; ST I, q.54, a.3. Cf. QDQ IX, q.4, a.1; QDQ III, q.8, a.1.
Article 1: In Sent. IV, d.10, a.2; In 1 Cor., c. 11, lect. 5; SCG IV, 62–64; In Matt., c. 26; In Iohan., c. 6, lect. 6; ST III, q.76, a.1–5.
Article 2: In Sent. IV, d.11, q.1, a.3, qla. 2; ST III, q.75, a.7.
Article 3: In Sent. IV, d. 12, q. 1, a. 1, qla. 3; SCG IV, 63 & 65; ST III, q.77, a.2.
Article 1: In Sent. IV, d.44, q.3, a.2, qla. 2 (= Suppl., q.86, a.2); SCG IV, 89; CT I, 177; De 43 art., a.25–26; De 36 art., a.20.
Article 2: In Sent. IV, d.44, q.3, a.1, qla. 1 (= Suppl., q.86, a.1); SCG IV, 89; In 1 Cor., c. 15, lect. 8.
Article 3: In Sent. IV, d.50, q.2, a.3, qla. 2 & 3 (= Suppl., q.97, a.2 & 3); SCG IV, 90; CT, I 175; QDP, q.5, a.9, arg.13 & ad 13; De 43 art., a.41.
Article 1: In Sent. I, prol., a.5; In Sent. IV, d.21, q.1, a.2, qla. 1, ad 3; In Gal., IV, lect. 7; QDP, q.4, a.1; ST I, q.1, a.10; QDQ III, q.14, a.1.
Article 1: CIDC, c. 5; SCG III, 132 & 135; In Eph., c. 4, lect. 9; In 1 Thess., I, lect. 1; In 2 Thess., c. 3, lect. 1 & 2; CDR, c. 14, arg. 6; CDR, c. 16; In Iohan., c. 6, lect. 3; ST II-II, q.187, a.3.
Quodlibet VIII
Article 2: In Sent. I, d.36, q.2, esp. a.3, ad 3; QDV, q.3, esp. a.8; ST I, q.15.
Article 1: QDV, q.10, a.6; CT I, 81–83; ST I, q.84, a.6 (cf. In Sent. II, d.3, q.3. a.1, sol. & ad 2; QDV, q.19, a.1; QDA, q.15).
Article 2: In Sent. I, d.17, q.1, a.4; In Sent. III, d.23, q.1, a.2; In Sent. IV, d.9, q.1, a.3, sol.2; In Sent. IV, d.21, q.2, ad 2; QDV, q.10, a.9 & 10; In 2 Cor., c. 12, lect. 1 & c. 13, lect. 2; ST I, q.87, a.2; ST I-II, q.112, a.5.
Article 1: In Sent. II, d.30, q.2, a.1 & 2; In Sent. IV, d.44, q.1, a.2, qla. 4 (= Suppl., q.80, a.4); ST I, q.119, a.1 & 2.
Article 1: QDQ VI, q.5, a.3; QDQ IV, q.8, a.4; QDQ IV, q.12, a.1, ad 12; ST II-II, q.63, a.2; ST II-II, q.185, a.3; In Iohan., c. 21, lect. 3.
Article 2: In Sent. III, d.9, q.2, a.3; QDQ X, q.6, a.1; ST II-II, q.63, a.3; ST II-II, q.103, a.2.
Article 2: In Sent. IV, d.45, q.2, a.4, qla. 1 (= Suppl., q.71, a.12); QDQ II, q.7, a.2.
Article 3: In Sent. IV, d.38, q.1, a.3, qla. 2 & 3 (= Suppl., q.53, a.1 & 2); QDQ X, q.5, a.3; QDQ III, q.7, a.1.
Article 1: In Sent. IV, d.25, q.3, a.2, qla. 2; ST II-II, q.100, a.3.
Article 2: In Sent. IV, d.15, q.2, a.1, qla. 4 & a.3, qla. 2, ad 1; QDQ VI, q.7, a.1; ST II-II, q.32, a.5 (cf. q.66, a.7; q.71, a.1; q.87, a.1, ad 4; q.118, a.4, ad 2).
Article 4: In Sent. III, d.38, q. un., a.3 & 4; In Ethic. IV, 15; ST II-II, q.110, a.3 & 4; In BDT, q.3, a.1; ST II-II, q.69, a.1 & 2; In Dec. Prae., 28–29.
Article 1: In Sent. IV, d.50, q.2, a.2, qla. 3 (= Suppl., q.98, a.9).
Article 2: In Sent. IV, d.50, q.2, a.1, qla. 4 (= Suppl., q.98, a.4).
Article 1: In Sent. IV, d. 50, q.2, a.3, qla. 1 (= Suppl., q.97, a.1); In Sent. IV, d.21, q.1, a.1, qla. 2, arg. 2 & ad 2; SCG III, 145; In Iob, c. 24, 19; QDA, q.21, arg. 18; ST I, q.10, a.3, ad 2; ST I-II, q.67, a.4, ad 2.
Article 1: In Sent. IV, d.49, q.1, a.1, qla. 2; SCG III, 26; CT I, 107; ST I, q.26, a.2, ad 2; ST I-II, q.3, a.4; ST I-II, q.4, a.1 & 2; QDM, q.16, a.6, ad 6; QDVIC, a.5, ad 8; In Ethic. X, 6; In Iohan., c. 17, lect. 1.
Quodlibet IX
Article 1: In Sent. I, d.43, q.1, a.2; In Sent. II, d.1, q.1, a.5, ad s.c.3, 4, 5, & 6; QDV, q.2, a.2, ad 5; QDV, q.2, a.9 & 10; QDV, q.20, a.4, ad 1; QDV, q.29, a.3; QDQ X, q.2, a.1; SCG II, 38; SCG II, 80–81; ST I, q.7, a.2, 3, & 4; ST I, q.25, a.2; ST I, q.46, a.2, ad 7 & 8; ST I, q.50, a.2, ad 4; In Phys. I, 9; In Phys. III, 6–13; In Phys. VIII, 9; DUI, c. 5; DEM; In Meta. XI, 10; QDQ XII, q.2, a.1; QDQ III, q.10, a.3, ad 2; In De cael. I, 9–15.
Article 1: In Sent. III, d.6, q.1, a.1, qla. 1; In Sent. III, d.7, q.1, a.1; CEG I, 20; SCG IV, 38–39; CT I, 210–211; QDQ I, q.2, a.1; In Rom., c. 1, lect. 2 & 3; In Iohan., c. 1, lect. 7; QDUV, a.2; ST III, q.2, a.3–6.
Article 2: In Sent. III, d.6, q.2, a.2 (cf. d.4, q.1, a.2, qla. 1; d.14, q.1, a.1, qla. 1; d.18, q.1, a.1, ad 3); CT I, 212; QDUV, a.4 (cf. a.1, ad 10); ST III, q.17, a.2.
Article 3: In Sent. III, d.8, q.1, a.5; CT I, 212; QDQ I, q.2, a.1; ST III, q.35, a.5.
Article 1: In Sent. I, d.47, q.1, a.4; In Sent. IV, d.12, q.1, a.1, qla. 1–2; SCG IV, 62; SCG IV, 65 & 66; DRF, c. 8; In 1 Cor., c. 11, lect. 5; QDQ III, q.1, a.1, arg. & ad arg.; In Matt., c. 26, 26; ST III, q.75, a.5; ST III, q.77, a.1.
Article 1: In Sent. I, d.8, q.5, a.2; DEE, c. 5; In Sent. II, d.3, q.1, a.1; SCG II, 50 & 51; CT I, 74; QDSC, a.1; ST I, q.50, a.2; DSS, c. 2–8 & 19.
Article 2: In Sent. II, d.12, q.1, a.3, ad 5; QDV, q.8, a.16; ST I, q.58, a.6–7 (cf. q.12, a.10; q.62, a.1, ad 3).
Article 3: In Sent. II, d.5, q.2, a.2 (cf. d.3, q.2, a.1; d.4, q.1, a.1 & 3); ST I, q.62, a.1–5.
Article 4: In Sent. I, d.37, q.4, a.3; QDQ XI, q.4, a.1; ST I, q.53, a.3.
Article 5: In Sent. II, d. 7, q.3, a.1; QDV, q.5, a.8; QDV, q.11, a.3; SCG III, 103; In lob, c. I; In Gal., c. 3, lect. 1; QDP, q.6, a.3; ST I, q.65, a.4; ST I, q.91, a.2; ST I, q.110, a.2 & 3; ST I, q.111, a.1; QDM, q.16, a.1, ad 14; QDM, q.16, a.9.
Article 1: In Sent. II, d.18, q.2, a.3; SCG II, 86; CT I, 93; QDP, q.3, a.2; ST I, q.118, a.1.
Article 2: In Sent. IV, d.15, q.4, a.1, qla. 1, sol. & ad 3; QDV, q.22, a.12, arg. 4 & ad 4; ST I-II, q.17, a.1; ST II-II, q.83, a.1.
Article 1: In Sent. I, d.17, q.2, a.1 & 2; QDM, q.7, a.2; QDVIC, a.11; ST I-II, q.52, a.1; q.66, a.1; ST II-II, q.24, a.4 & 5.
Article 1: In Matt., c. 26, 74; QDC, a.6, arg. 2 & ad 2; QDC, a.13, arg. 2 & ad 2; QDCF, a.1, arg. 11; ST II-II, q. 24, a.12, arg. 2 & ad 2.
Article 2: QDQ VIII, q.6, a.3.
Quodlibet X
Article 1: In Sent. I, d.24, q.1, a.3 (cf. q.1, a.1, ad 1 & 2); QDP, q.9, a.7; ST I, q.11, a.1; ST I, q.30, a.3; In Meta. IV (1003b32–33); In Meta. X (1054a13–19).
Article 2: In Sent. IV, d.48, q.1, a.4, qla. 4 (= Suppl., q.88, a.4); SCG IV, 96; CT I, 244; In Matt., c. 14, 31–46; ST III, q.59, a.2.
Article 3: In Sent. IV, d.12, q.1, a.2, qla. 6; ST III, q.77, a.8.
Article 1: In Sent. II, d.2, q.1, a.1; ST I, q.10, a.5 (cf. In Sent. I, d.8, q.2, a.2; d.19, q.2, a.1; QDP, q.3, a.14, ad s.c.9; QDQ V, q.4, a.1).
Article 1: In Sent. I, d.3, q.4, a.2; QDA, q.12; QDSC, a.11; ST I, q.54, a.3; ST I, q.77, a.1; ST I, q.79, a.1.
Article 2: In Sent. II, d.19, q.1, a.1; In Sent. IV, d. 50, q.1, a.1; SCG II, 79–84; CT I, 84; QDA, q.14; ST I, q.75, a.6; ST I-II, q.85, a.6.
Article 1: QDV, q.8, a.7, ad 13; QDV, q.10, a.6, arg. 6 & ad 6; SCG III, 47; ST I, q.12, a.11, arg. 3 & ad 3; ST I, q.16, a.6; ST I, q.84, a.5.
Article 2: In Sent. IV, d.44, q.3, a.3, qla. 1 & 2 (= Suppl., q.70, a.1 & 2); In Sent. IV, d. 50, q.1, a.1; QDV, q.26, a.1; SCG II, 80–81; QDA, q.19; ST I, q.77, a.8; ST I-II, q.67, a.1, arg. 3 & ad 3; QDVC, a.4, ad 13.
Article 1: In Sent. IV, d.38, q.2., a.4, qla. 2, arg.2 & ad 2; QDQ III, q. 6, a.2; In Matt., c. 8, 22; ST II-II, q.101, a.4, ad 4; ST II-II, q.189, a.6.
Article 2: In Sent. II, d.44, q. 2, a.3; QDQ I, q.8, a.1; ST II-II, q.104, a.5.
Article 3: In Sent. IV, d.30, q.2, a.1. qla. 2, ad 1; In Sent. IV, d.32, q.1, a.2, qla. 2 (= Suppl., q.64, a.2); In Sent. IV, d.38, q.1, a.3, qla. 2, ad 3; QDQ III, q.7, a.1.
Article 1: In Sent. III, d.9, q.2, a.3; QDQ VIII, q.4, a.2; ST II-II, q.63, a.3.
Article 2: CIDC, c. 14; QDQ V, q.13, a.1; ST II-II, q.108, a.1, ad 2 & ad 4; ST II-II, q.188, a.3, ad 1.
Article 3: CIDC, c. 8 (esp. ad 9); In 1 Tim., c. 2, lect. 2; In Matt., c. 11, 8; ST II-II, q.169, a.1; ST II-II, q.187, a.6.
Article 1: In Sent. IV, d.13, q.2, a.3; In 1 Cor., c. 5, lect. 3; In Matt., c. 13, 29; ST II-II, q.10, a.9.
Article 2: ST II-II, q.11, a.4.
Article 1: In Sent. IV, d.49, q.2, a.1 (= Suppl., q.92, a.1); QDQ VII, q.1, a.1; QDV, q.8, a.1; SCG III, 51–57; CT I, 104–105; ST I, q.12, a.1; ST I, q. 12, a.4, arg. 3 & ad 3; QDQ I, q.1, a.1; In Matt., c. 5, 8; ST I-II, q.3, a.8; ST I-II, q.5, a.1; In Iohan., c. 1, lect. 11; CT II, 9–10.
Quodlibet XI
Article 1: In Sent. I, d.37, q.2, a.2; SCG III, 68; In DDN, c. 3, lect. 1; ST I, q.8, a.4.
Article 1: In Sent. I, d.36, q.1, a.2; QDV, q.2, a.15; SCG I, 71; ST I, q.14, a.10; ST I, q.15, a.3, ad 1; ST I, q.18, a.4, ad 4.
Article 1: In Sent. I, d.40, q.3, a.1; QDV, q.6, a.3; ST I, q.23, a.6; QDQ XII, q.3, a.1.
Article 1: In Sent. I, d.37, q.4, a.3; QDQ IX, q.4, a.4; ST I, q.53, a.3 (cf. q.63, a.6, ad 4).
Article 1: In Sent. IV, d.44, q.1, a.1, qla. 1, ad 4 (= Suppl., q.79, a.1, ad 4); SCG II, 58; SCG IV, 80, arg.2; SCG IV, 81, ad 2; CT I, 90; QDP, q.3, a.9, ad 9; QDA, q.11; QDSC, a.1, ad 9; a.3; In De An. II, 1; ST I, q.76, a.3; QDQ VI, q.4, a.1; QDQ XII, q.7, a.1; DSS, c. 5–8.
Article 1: In Sent. IV, d.44, q.1, a.1 (= Suppl., q.79, a.1–3); SCG IV, 80–81 & 84; CT I, 153–154; In lob., c. 19; In 1 Cor., c. 15, lect. 5, in v. 35; In 1 Cor., c. 15, lect. 9, in v. 53; QDA, q.19, arg. 5 & 13, ad 5 & 13.
Article 1: In Sent. IV, d.7, q.3, a.1 (cf. d.13, q.1, a.1, qla. 2, ad 2); SCG IV, 60; DAF II, 188–190; ST III, q.72, a.11 (cf. q.65, a.1, ad 3; q.65, a.3, ad 3).
Article 1: In Sent. IV, d.13, q.1, a.3, qla. 3 (cf. d.24, q.1, a.3, qla. 5, ad 3); ST III, q.82, a.9 (cf. q.64, a.9, ad 3).
Article 2: In Sent. IV, d.18, q.2, a.4 (= Suppl., q.23, a.1–3); ST II-II, q.31, a.2, arg.3 & ad 3; ST II-II, q.39, a.4, arg. 2 & ad 2.
Article 1: In Sent. IV, d.34, q.1, a.3 (= Suppl., q.58, a.2).
Article 2: In Sent. IV, d.34, q.1, a.2 (= Suppl., q.58, a.1); In Sent. IV, d.36, q.1, a.1, ad 4 (= Suppl., q.52, a.1, ad 4).
Article 1: In Sent. IV, d.19, q.2, a.3, qla. 1; In 1 Tim., c. 5, lect. 3; QDQ I, q.8, a.2; QDCF, a.2; In Matt., c. 18, 15–18; ST II-II, q.33, a.7 & 8.
Article 2: In Sent. IV, d.19, q.2, a.3, qla. 1, arg. 4 & ad 4; QDQ I, q.8, a.2; In Matt., c. 18, 16; QDCF, a.2, arg. 6 & ad 6; ST II-II, q.33, a.7, arg. 3 & ad 3.