Chapter 5: Practical Theology and Spiritual Companioning
5
Practical Theology and Spiritual Companioning
Not long after I arrived at Princeton Theological Seminary to begin doctoral studies, Richard R. Osmer invited me to read a few sections of his working manuscript, Practical Theology: An Introduction. He encouraged me, a fledgling PhD student, to comment on his discussion of the spirituality of congregational leaders. I felt both honored and overwhelmed at the invitation from this theological visionary and wise practitioner who seemed to think I might have something to offer about the intersection between congregational spiritual formation, a topic I had a passion for, and practical theology, a field of study I was just coming to know. With generous hospitality, he welcomed my few, hesitating insights.
I soon discovered that Osmer has a spirit of humble curiosity that drives him to be a lifelong student. He sought recommendations for spiritual direction training programs and ultimately studied with Dr. Marcus Smucker, who had been my professor and instructor in the practice. The three of us met together to explore questions about spirituality, theology, and congregational life. These conversations culminated in a book entitled Spiritual Companioning: A Guide to Protestant Theology and Practice.107As we engaged in the work, I began to notice that the communal process of reflecting and writing seemed to take on qualities of the companioning relationships we were describing. The relational process that evolved as we wrote somehow mirrored the content. Like many who have come before and after me, I was intellectually and spiritually companioned and guided by Dr. Richard Osmer in a manner that has profoundly shaped my work as a teacher, scholar, and minister.
The Intersection of Practical Theology and Spiritual Companioning
One of Osmer’s most important contributions to practical theology is a commitment to exploring cross-disciplinary questions for the benefit of the church. The Western Christian tendency to separate the scholastic from the monastic and pastoral work from mysticism continues to shape our thinking and practice. Even areas of study such as Christian spirituality and practical theology, which bend traditional disciplinary lines, can suffer from the “silo effect” when they do not interact easily or frequently. Students of spiritual practices such as spiritual direction and companioning are likely to read historical spiritual masters such as Teresa of Avila but ignore theories that raise important questions about spiritual formation in relation to a congregation’s theology and practice. In a similar way, training in practical theology may emphasize theological reflection on congregational activities while giving little attention to historical Christian spirituality and spiritual practices that shape formational community and encounters with God. Each area of study is driven by its own resources, methods, and questions.
Whether or not we readily acknowledge it, the fields of practical theology and Christian spirituality and their respective tasks and practices necessarily interact in congregational ministry. In Practical Theology: An Introduction, Osmer notes that leadership in Christian community is “inherently a spiritual matter” which requires openness to the guidance of the Holy Spirit and transformation toward the image of Christ.108 All of the tasks of practical theology require divine engagement and discernment. It is also true that historic Christian practices like spiritual companioning and direction necessarily involve practical theological reflection because companioning arises out of theological and ethical convictions. Osmer’s work in practical theology and spiritual direction offers a road map that enables church leaders to be intentional about defining and shaping the art and skill of spiritual companioning in light of essential practical theological concerns.109
In this chapter, we explore the value of Osmer’s practical theological tasks for one dimension of Christian spirituality, the ministry of spiritual companioning. As we have already seen in this volume, Osmer identifies four core tasks: descriptive-empirical, interpretive, normative, and pragmatic. Each one has a role in a hermeneutical spiral of practical theological interpretation enabling congregational leaders to return repeatedly to the various tasks in a pattern of ongoing growth and deepening understanding.110 These tasks provide insight into the development of spiritual companioning ministries in congregational life.
What is Spiritual Companioning?
In order to consider these intersections, we must give brief attention to what we mean by relationships of spiritual companioning. This seems especially important given the wide variety of “spiritual practices” within and beyond the church in our time. Forms of spiritual companioning arise from a long and rich history in the Christian tradition. These practices are especially evident among various groups across the spectrum of Christian traditions, including Jesus and his followers, the New Testament Church, the desert mothers and fathers of the fourth and fifth centuries, various historical monastic orders, early Anabaptist communities, and Methodist bands and classes. Contemporary relationships of spiritual companioning have particularly strong roots in the practice of spiritual direction, a one-with-one relationship between a trained spiritual director and a directee seeking to grow in the spiritual life.111 A growing number of programs in theological schools and independent institutes provide educational instruction and preparation in this one-with-one practice.
Spiritual companioning can be described as “a way of accompanying others in intentional relationships of prayerful reflection and conversation that help them notice God’s presence and calling in their personal lives, local communities, and the world.”112 Companioning relationships provide support and accountability for responding to the invitations of God. The term “companioning” is used “in verb form because these kinds of relationships are much more than casual connections—they require an intentional, active commitment to a way of being with others and with God.”113 Intentional relationships of spiritual companioning in congregations can be shaped according to the needs of the community, taking various forms including one-with-one spiritual direction, peer spiritual friendships, small groups, family and congregational connections, and other types of relationship.
Spiritual companioning or direction is one among many ancient Christian practices being retooled for contemporary life to support the formation of faith. As faith communities seek to recover ancient forms of practices such as spiritual companioning or direction, the goal is not to identify one definitive approach to the practice that all must engage in, but rather to adapt the practice for specific contexts as congregations articulate ways in which the practice may support faith formation.114 Bringing the tasks of practical theology to bear on the use of the practice allows congregational leaders to do this with integrity in light of the community’s theological commitments and the needs and calling of the congregation. One way to enter into practical theological reflection on spiritual companioning is to consider a case study in light of Osmer’s four tasks—the narrative of Jason Wells, a seminarian in his mid-twenties exploring spiritual companioning at Cedar Springs Community Church.115
Jason’s Story of Spiritual Companioning
Jason had just completed his first semester in seminary when he received a call that his father had passed away unexpectedly. The news was staggering for Jason, and he struggled to come to terms with the reality of the family’s loss and the immediate need to provide solace and support to his mother and brother. Jason began to make frequent trips to his home town several hours away, and he became increasingly overwhelmed by the demands of school and work alongside family commitments. Jason was also deeply disappointed that he had not been close to his father in recent years, and he felt significant guilt over it. This disappointment was compounded by his desire to understand God’s presence and guidance in the midst of the loss. Just when he most longed for divine comfort, God seemed truly absent. Jason chose to participate in worship in spite of the inner emptiness and did appreciate the congregation’s reflections on loss particularly in the season of Lent.
Just before his father’s death, Jason had begun participating in a new spiritual direction group at Cedar Springs Community Church led by Kristen Terry, a trained spiritual director. During Jason’s times of sharing, he reflected on his journey through grief. After a few months, Jason was final able to admit that he could not pray about his father. In all honesty, he could barely pray at all. It was difficult to acknowledge this broken dimension of his life with God, and Jason wondered what the inability to pray might say about his future in ministry. The group listened carefully to Jason’s story over time and prayed on his behalf when he could not pray for himself.
Other concerns arose as Jason moved through the grief, including difficulties in his family relationships. Jason’s brother, Paul, urged their mother to sell land and other assets. Jason disagreed with this idea, and tension arose between the brothers. As Jason told these parts of his story, group members were occasionally tempted to offer practical suggestions. With Kristen’s gentle guidance, they were able to remain focused on the key purpose of the group process: attending to the presence and activity of God in everyday life. Jason found the group to be a spiritual community of healing and hope during an especially difficult season in his life. He could not imagine getting through that time without them. Jason remained with the group for two years after his father’s death, and then went on to graduate from seminary and serve in pastoral ministry.
The Descriptive–Empirical Task: A Call to Listen
As we consider Jason’s experience of group spiritual direction, it is evident that the descriptive-empirical task is a foundation for spiritual companioning. The core question of this task is, “What is going on?” Osmer suggests that a spirituality of presence involving priestly listening is an essential dimension of practical theology.116 This may be the task in which the work of practical theology and spiritual companioning interacts most clearly. In both cases, the emphasis is upon taking a posture of attending to the presence of another in a way that is prayerful, focused, and engaged, offering empathy and warmth. This kind of listening is truly rare and demanding. Neither spiritual companioning nor the tasks of practical theology can be accomplished without it.117 The listening process involves attending to narrative, allowing the participants to tell the stories of their everyday lives. The process requires listening and responding to assist the storyteller in clarifying a representation of their life experiences as they attempt to interpret them through spiritual, social, cultural, psychological, and other frameworks.
As pastors and spiritual companions listen and long for the healing and guidance of God in another’s life, they may be tempted by a sense of urgency to bring quick resolution. This was certainly a temptation in Jason’s group. In emergency situations, quick responses are necessary. More often, attempting to “fix” what is wrong in people’s lives by offering simplistic solutions or hasty advice blocks the ability to offer a genuine spirituality of presence. If Jason’s group had focused on solving relational problems between the brothers, they would have been distracted from the true intent of spiritual companioning.
In order to attend adequately to the interpretive and normative tasks, spiritual companions must wait patiently and watch for the broader scope of the narrative to unfold. Prayerful listening is required to move past the reflexive desire to “help” and enter more deeply into encounter and engagement with God and with another while listening for the presence and activity of God. In the words of priest and spiritual director, Margaret Guenther, “This ministry of presence is a living out of intercessory prayer, as the holy listener waits and watches. Sometimes the listening takes place in the warmth of the stable, sometimes in the pure white light on the high mountain apart, sometimes in desolation at the foot of the cross, and sometimes with fear and great joy in the encounter with the risen Christ.”118
There are many ways in which the field of practical theology contributes to a deepening understanding of waiting and watching in the descriptive-empirical moment. To begin, the practical theologian has a broad range of elements to explore in the greater “web of life.”119 Spiritual direction gives primary attention to the religious dimensions of human experience. Companioning may take on a form of “research” by attending to the larger life stories of others, acknowledging that the relationship with God is shaped by family life, societal pressures, congregational engagement, physical health and well-being, and many other influences. Practical theology recognizes that spiritual frameworks interface with social constructs such as race and gender.
Few resources in spiritual companioning literature recognize or address these concerns as an element of holy listening. The experience of prayer and relationship with God may be influenced by a call to justice in a sermon, by interactions with co-workers that bring gender issues to the fore, or by shame over mounting debt and financial instability. Understanding the descriptive-empirical task of practical theology opens up the possibility of exploring unexpected elements rooted in societal systems that influence life experiences and impact spiritual formation. In the case of Jason’s group, it is essential for them to recognize the complex web of life in which he is engaged. His spiritual journey is impacted by relationships with his living family members and his deceased father, his preparation for ministry in seminary, and his sense of call. Creating space for the larger web of life enables participants to wait and watch, recognizing that God engages human beings in every dimension of life.
Within the congregation, a focus on spiritual companioning for individuals or small groups alone may be limiting when leaders consider the broader “web of life” that connects the entire community’s system. This may involve creating a culture of spiritual companioning by exploring together what it means to provide language and tools for spiritual guidance through various ministries. Growth may begin with congregational leaders who view their ministries through the lens of spiritual guidance in order to support the entire congregation as it seeks to discover the presence of God. Congregational leaders grow in this role as they carry the community in prayer and watch for signs of God’s presence and guidance.120 At Cedar Springs, several ministers and lay people are training in spiritual direction programs in order to shape various ministries including worship, pastoral care, administration, and mission according to the vision of spiritual companioning.
The Interpretive Task: A Call to Use Our Tools with Care
Jason’s spiritual companions also benefit from attending to the core question of the interpretive task: “Why is this going on?” Osmer argues that a spirituality of sagely wisdom is necessary for the interpretive task, and it requires that congregational leaders continue to love God with their minds beyond the walls of seminaries and theological schools.121 The interpretive task contributes to deepening clarity about the evolution of an individual’s images of God, experiences of prayer, and life within the church. The task involves offering space for companions to be conscious of the ways in which they are influenced by various psychological and sociological theories alongside other arts and sciences. This requires a faith that is willing to engage with the world, recognizing that we will never be fully removed from the culture we inhabit, and we can learn from the intellectual resources of culture to interpret what we hear and observe as practical theologians and spiritual companions. An essential element of sagely wisdom is the ability to discern which theories are persuasive for a given episode, situation, or context. We must also be aware of the audiences we draw upon to help us determine the theories we choose to employ.122
The gifts of the interpretive task for spiritual companioning are numerous. Some practitioners of spiritual direction have already made good use of the resources of psychology and sociology to inform spiritual companioning relationships. Psychologist and spiritual director David Benner advocates for psychospiritual preparation among spiritual directors.123 It is impossible for human beings to separate spiritual and psychological aspects of functioning. What we learn from the interpretive task of practical theology is to judge wisely when we select and employ psychological and other theoretical tools for the sacred calling of walking alongside people on the spiritual journey. We must own the interpretive resources we engage and understand their foundations and frameworks in light of our theological and ethical commitments.
The benefit of a breadth of knowledge in psychology and related disciplines is certainly evident in Jason’s case. His experience of God, particularly his struggles in prayer, are probably intertwined with the grief and guilt he feels about his relationship with his father. A spiritual companion who interprets Jason’s relationship with God in light of his loss will recognize that processes like this cannot be rushed or controlled by others. Jason may experience a variety of thoughts and emotions as he contemplates the loss, and wise spiritual companions will serve Jason well by creating hospitable spaces for any “negative” emotions such as anger with God. The interpretive task also raises questions about other resources Jason may benefit from at this time, including psychological or pastoral counseling.
The Normative Task: A Call to Claim Our Roots
One of the most important elements of Jason’s spiritual work in the companioning group is theological. Who is the God that Jason struggles to pray to and what is God’s role in Jason’s life? The normative task addresses theological commitments by asking the core question: “What ought to be going on?” Osmer posits that the normative task includes theological interpretation, ethical reflection, and good practice. Practical theology is a form of theology, not social science “lite.” Methods, concepts, and sources of theological discourse are necessary to create constructive theological perspectives. The work of practical theology, then, is to bring these perspectives us into conversation with other fields, including the classical theological disciplines.124 As we do this, however, we must recognize that there are multiple trajectories to interdisciplinary conversation. There are numerous perspectives on the relationship between theology and experience in spiritual direction. I believe that practices of spiritual companioning are well suited to the confessional trajectory that gives priority to theology in interdisciplinary dialogue. In this approach, theological roots ground us. Human experience is highly valued but is not equal to theological understandings of divine revelation.125
The normative moment is central to the entire process of practical theological reflection and to the ministry of spiritual companioning. This task addresses the essential reality that every person seeking spiritual guidance has theological commitments that may not be clearly articulated or even recognized. For example, a directee might say, “I believe God loves me, but . . .” Moments like this may require exploration of both theology and human experiences in everyday life to see how they may or may not coincide. This is certainly true for Jason. His spiritual companions encouraged him to consider his image of God, recognizing that what Jason believes about God and about prayer may not match what he perceives about daily life experiences. A belief that God is always present and benevolent can be sustaining in periods when God seems more absent than present. Jason’s group can help him explore any disconnect between what he believes and what he experiences in relationship with God. He may not be able to trust what he feels about God at this time, depending instead upon what he believes to be true.
The normative task helps us recognize that spiritual guidance or direction relationships alone are not enough for a life of faith. In my perspective, they do not provide adequate biblical and theological resources or the critical theological language needed for discernment.126 Spiritual guidance practices belong together with a wider group of formational practices including worship, fellowship, Christian formation and education, witness and service, and a personal devotional life. In our cultural context, it is possible to seek out a spiritual guide to meet one’s own spiritual needs and avoid the church altogether. Spiritual formation is personal and communal, and it ought to attend both to interiority and outward action. Spiritual companioning rooted in the practices of healthy congregational life may contribute to spiritual growth and development. In Jason’s case, participating in public worship during Lent creates space for theological reflection on suffering and loss in a way that cannot be fully accomplished through spiritual companioning practices alone.
Another important contribution of the normative task is the belief that spiritual companioning itself has the potential to be one normative practice generating new understandings of God and the Christian life.127 This plays out regularly when a directee offers a confession and hears a word of forgiveness and acceptance or is named aloud in prayer and encouraged to receive God’s loving compassion. Time and again spiritual companioning reshapes and redefines theology by creating spaces for struggling with concepts of divine and human action and learning to use the tools and skills of discernment. Spiritual guides must also be doing their own theological reflection in order to companion others with integrity. These commitments influence approaches to attentive listening and the manner in which questions are posed. While our theologies may not seem central to priestly listening, we are deeply rooted in our convictions as we engage with those we companion.
The Pragmatic Task: A Call to Action
As Jason and his group members grow in the life of faith, they will frequently ask the core question of the pragmatic task: “How might we respond?” This task provides us with the opportunity to shape and reshape plans for practice and then to embrace action. The invitation is missional, prophetic, and it may involve confession and a call for change and growth. The work of spiritual companioning necessarily results in action. It is not a process of contemplation alone. Jason found that his group regularly invited him to consider how he might act in the world in light of his relationship with God.
Jason recalls one particular experience that involved a specific response. After he shared about tensions with his brother, Kristen invited the group to pause, and she encouraged Jason to enter into a practice of imaginative prayer. He pictured himself sitting with Jesus in his family home. His brother, Paul, entered the room. Kristen encouraged Jason to talk with Jesus about Paul, exploring what Jesus saw when he looked at Paul. After a period of silence, Kristen asked Jason about the experience of prayer. Jason noted that Paul seemed to be under considerable strain, fearing for the future in the midst of his own loss and grief. It was a profound experience for Jason to attempt to look at Paul through the eyes of Jesus with the compassion of Christ. Some weeks later, Jason returned to the group and reported that he had reached out to Paul, and the brothers had taken a hopeful step toward repairing their relationship. The group rejoiced with Jason and promised to continue praying for ongoing restoration.
The pragmatic task of practical theology can be painfully prophetic at times, and it requires the commitment of servant leaders who are willing to call for change. A spirituality of servant leadership coincides beautifully with the roles of spiritual companions who avoid telling another what to do in the spiritual life and instead come alongside as the individuals they serve set the agenda and seek God for themselves.128 But companions must also raise difficult questions at times, holding others accountable for right living and acting. If Jason had not chosen to show love toward his brother, group members may have felt a call to gently raise the issue. The work of the pragmatic task reminds us that growth and change must be the result of prayer and reflection, something that is not always assumed in contemporary spiritual direction practice. If we hold a theology of redemptive action and solidarity in suffering, we will choose to live out the consequences of the encounter with God in the world. Spiritual companioning relationships create space for reflection on the pragmatic steps we might take as we discern a way forward.
Concluding Thoughts
Even as ancient Christian practices like spiritual companioning resurface and draw the attention of contemporary church communities, we need practical theologians to raise important theological questions in order to develop our practices faithfully. The vision and wisdom of Dr. Richard Osmer will continue to guide these essential conversations and form practical theologians and spiritual companions for many years to come.
Bibliography
Benner, David. Sacred Companions: The Gift of Spiritual Friendship and Direction. Downer’s Grove, IL: Intervarsity, 2002.
Guenther, Margaret. Holy Listening: The Art of Spiritual Direction. Cambridge: Cowley, 1992.
Lunn, Julie. “Paying Attention: The Task of Attending in Spiritual Direction and Practical Theology.” Practical Theology 2 (2009) 219–29.
Osmer, Richard R. “Empirical Practical Theology.” In Opening the Field of Practical Theology: An Introduction, edited by Kathleen Cahalan and Gordon Mikoski, 77–94. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield, 2014.
———. Practical Theology: An Introduction. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2008.
Reed, Angela H., Richard R. Osmer, and Marcus G. Smucker. Spiritual Companioning: A Guide to Protestant Theology and Practice. Grand Rapids: Baker, 2015.
Rice, Howard. The Pastor as Spiritual Guide. Nashville: Upper Room, 1998.
Richter, Don. “Religious Practices in Practical Theology.” In Opening the Field of Practical Theology: An Introduction, edited by Kathleen Cahalan and Gordon Mikoski, 233–52. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield, 2014.
Ruffing, Janet. Uncovering Stories of Faith: Spiritual Direction and Narrative. Mahwah, NJ: Paulist, 1989.
107. Reed et al., Spiritual Companioning.
108. Osmer, Practical Theology, 27.
109. A major impetus for Spiritual Companioning was the goal of bringing wisdom from these two fields of study together in order to encourage and strengthen congregations and their leaders. While it was not explicitly discussed in the book, we drew upon components of Osmer’s four tasks of practical theology to describe and shape practices of spiritual companioning in the church. This becomes evident in the following headings found in most chapters: “Understanding the Cultural Context,” “Listening to Scripture,” “Mining the Protestant Tradition,” “Practicing Spiritual Companioning,” and “Exploring the Stories of Congregations.” See Reed et al., Spiritual Companioning.
110. Osmer, Practical Theology, 11.
111. Janet Ruffing explores six typological historical models of spiritual direction beginning with the desert fathers and mothers, in Ruffing, Uncovering Stories of Faith, 2–17.
112. Reed et al., Spiritual Companioning, xx.
113. Ibid.
114. Richter, “Religious Practices in Practical Theology,” 235–36.
115. For the purposes of anonymity, names and details have been changed in the case study.
116. Osmer, Practical Theology, 34.
117. Lunn, “Paying Attention,” 219.
118. Guenther, Holy Listening, 145.
119. Osmer, Practical Theology, 15–17.
120. Rice, The Pastor as Spiritual Guide, 62.
121. Osmer, Practical Theology, 81–82.
122. For example, Osmer chose life course theory, a concept of human development rooted in sociological research, to identify essential issues and questions for spiritual companioning throughout the journey of life. Osmer argues that life course theory serves spiritual companions better than life cycle theory because human growth and development does not necessarily follow consistent patterns and predictable crises. Osmer goes on to explore the importance of storytelling in spiritual guidance as it applies to life course theory through the witness of God’s interaction with the people of Israel in scripture. In this way, the interpretive moment is shaped by normative commitments. See Reed et al., Spiritual Companioning, 125–50.
123. Benner, Sacred Companions, 155–56. Some spiritual direction theorists have given less attention to psychological theories, focusing primarily on other resources including the historical writings of Christian spiritual masters such as St. Ignatius in order to understand the inner workings of the human soul.
124. Osmer, Practical Theology, 163.
125. Osmer, “Empirical Practical Theology,” 89–90.
126. The particular normative commitments that are placed in conversation with spiritual companioning practices will vary depending upon faith traditions and specific communal and individual theological perspectives and practices.
127. Osmer, Practical Theology, 152–53.
128. Osmer, Practical Theology, 196–97.
