Chapter 8: Practical Theology and Missional Theology
8
Practical Theology and Missional Theology
How Are They Related?
The emergence of the conversation about “missional theology” and “missional church” can be dated. It began with the publication in 1998 of the study entitled “Missional Church.”169 In that context, the term was a constructive proposal for the theological challenge confronting the Christian movement in the west (see the sub-title: “A Vision for the Sending of the Church in North America”). That challenge is linked to the much discussed and much analyzed “end of Western Christendom.” The umbrella concept of Christendom includes complex historical developments like the disestablishment of Western Christianity, the secularization of north Atlantic cultures, and the emergence of religious pluralism replacing the hegemony of the Constantinian corpus Christianum. With the decline of Christendom the awareness has grown that the West is now a mission field that presents daunting challenges to the Christian movement. The question driving the discussion is how the church structures and practices of Christendom can become again missionary in their focus and action, since they are now located in such difficult mission fields. As Christendom disintegrates, we are also enabled to recognize God’s faithfulness through the centuries of compromise and captivity. That faithfulness is evidenced, for example, in ancient practices of pastoral care from which we continue to learn and by which we are blessed.
The neologism “missional” also articulates a growing awareness of the absence of “Mission” as a major theological theme in Western ecclesiologies for over a millennium.170 By adding the syllable al to the term mission, the authors of “Missional Church” were making the case that the church’s nature, purpose, and action are defined by God’s mission (missio Dei): the healing of the nations, the salvation of humanity, the inauguration of the kingdom of God, the expectation that God will complete the good work that has begun—all of which are brought about by the life, death, resurrection, and ascension of Jesus Christ. The missional church serves God’s mission as the called, equipped, and sent out witness to Jesus Christ. It is the continuation of God’s called and set apart people who, since Abraham, are blessed by God to be a blessing to “all the families of the earth” (Gen 12:3).171 God’s mission expands outward to embrace all of humanity as Jesus “appointed twelve, whom he also named apostles, to be with him, and to be sent out to proclaim the message” (Mark 3:14). The formation of the disciples in the four biblical Gospels is to be understood as the process of discipleship carried out by Jesus during his earthly ministry in preparation for the expanding mission of the church from Easter and Pentecost onwards. Discipleship in the missional church leads to apostolate, to witness, which in turn gathers the community of witness to be equipped and sent. The missional church is then the continuation of the apostolic mission begun in the first century and documented in the New Testament. It is the outworking of the promise made by Jesus on the Mount of the Ascension: “But you will receive power when the Holy Spirit has come upon you; and you will be my witnesses in Jerusalem, in all Judea and Samaria, and to the ends of the earth” (Acts 1:8).
Thus, missional theology challenges deeply engrained assumptions about what the church is and what is its purpose that have emerged in the course of Western Christendom. The church, from the purview of missional theology, is not an end in itself and is not the reason for the gospel. The church exists for God’s purposes that have all of creation in view. Because of God’s love for the creation, there is gospel. And because there is gospel and the promise of redemption, there is church. That church takes on concrete shape within human history, but its institutional forms are not the reason for its existence. Rather than making its survival its goal, the institutional church serves God’s mission as its first fruits, instrument, and agency.
The missional theological discussion has thus been insistent that the challenges facing Christian witness in the West are not merely strategic or institutional. Course corrections, enhanced efficiency, and improved methodologies will not resolve the crisis of Christendom. The issues are profoundly theological. The critique that Western ecclesiologies remain silent about mission constitutes a call to reclaim the fundamentally missional character of the original apostolic movement. The purpose of that movement was the formation and equipping of witnessing communities. This means that the authoritative role of Scripture for the formation of the witnessing church receives central importance. Biblical scholars are responding to this challenge as they investigate how the scriptural witness has served and must serve the formation of faithfully witnessing communities. These investigations coalesce around the task of “missional hermeneutics.”172 That task engages the biblical witness with some version or aspect of the basic question: How did this text continue the formation of faithfully witnessing communities then, and how does it do so today?
The focus upon “faithfully witnessing communities” represents a point of convergence between the missional discussion and the task and scope of practical theology as represented by the work of Richard Osmer. In the missiological exploration of the church’s nature, purpose, and action during much of the twentieth century, the gathered community (“the local church”) comes to be recognized as the primary instrument of God’s mission. The recent emphasis upon the missional church affirms that priority as it explores how such communities are to be formed for this service. Osmer’s focus on the form and function of congregations provides guidance for the way in which communities should be formed for their missional vocation as witnesses to the gospel.
It is in the particularity of God working out God’s mission through a certain people that missional and practical theologies overlap. Going back to the Abrahamic call and woven through the long and often perilous pilgrimage of God’s called people through time, there is this remarkable and pervasive conviction that God is carrying out healing purposes for creation through the chosen and set apart people. That conviction is taken up in the apostolic mission whose actual purpose was not just the saving of souls but rather the calling, equipping, and sending of communities of witness into the world God loves. Thus, it is essential for the continuing formation of faithfully witnessing communities that they engage in the theological interpretation of their practice to see if they are in fact leading their corporate life “worthy of the calling to which [they] have been called” (Eph 4:1). Missional theology prompts practical questions.
The missional approach that we envision will not tolerate a view of practical theology that, as Osmer critically comments, “views this field as solely concerned with application, with helpful techniques and skills applied to the life of the church.”173 We suspect that the reclamation of mission as the decisive theological interpretation of the church’s nature, purpose, and action, will have a profoundly integrative effect upon theological discourses that have for too long worked in their respective silos—with profoundly problematic consequences for faithful witness. In particular, the division between the doctrine of the church and the disciplines clustered together under the rubric “practical theology” is unworkable if God’s mission does, in fact, define the church’s nature, purpose, and action. What the church confesses about its vocation becomes observable action as the Christian witness unfolds in history.
The theologian who unites this missional reading and the task of practical theology is Karl Barth. His ecclesiology is both unequivocally missional in its concerted focus upon the vocation of the Christian as witness, and practical in trying to think through the shape and form of that witness in the world today. That Barth’s ecclesiology is unequivocally missional is made abundantly clear in his concerted focus that the “vocation of the Christian is witness.”174 This claim comes as the climax of the large and embracing theology of reconciliation which is the theme of volume IV of the Church Dogmatics and which reaches its climax in Barth’s “missional ecclesiology,” especially in paragraph 72: “The Holy Spirit and the Sending of the Christian Community.”175 The gospel of reconciliation is only fully expounded when God’s work of justification and sanctification issues forth in the doctrine and practice of the vocation of the gathered and sent community as Christ’s witness. It is thoroughly consequent, then, when Barth’s argument in paragraph 71 (“The Vocation of Man”) leads into the discussion in paragraph 72 of “the Sending of the Christian Community.”176 The English-speaking reader needs to be reminded that “sending” is the Germanic equivalent of “mission.”
The emphasis upon witness as mission is the theological presupposition for Barth’s detailed exposition of the forms of service in which the gathered community carries out its vocation. This exposition happens in the concluding sub-section of paragraph 72, whose title unnecessarily clericalizes the argument.177 Barth expounds the actions of witness with twelve rubrics that together make up the “service” of the called and sent community. The English translation opts for “ministry” rather than “service,” although up until now the German noun Dienst has regularly been translated as “service.” Be that as it may, the ecclesiological exposition of the Christian vocation as witness becomes practical in twelve actual “forms” and disciplines of service, all of which both equip for and carry out the calling of witness. One could entitle this provocative section of the Church Dogmatics a “missional practical theology,” as a survey of the forms demonstrates:
1. The praise of God (865–67)
2. The preaching of the Gospel (867–70)
3. The Instruction of the Community (870–72)
4. Evangelization (872–74)
5. Mission (874–78)
6. Theology (879–82)
7. Prayer (882–84)
8. Cure of Souls (885–87)
9. Personal Examples of Christian Life and Action (887–89)
10. Diaconate (889–95)
11. Prophetic Action (895–98)
12. Fellowship (898–901)
In the missional exposition of all of these actions, the gathered community is equipped for the practice of witness in the world. These actions communicate and demonstrate the nature and promise of the new creation which the gospel announces. Following through on the biblical injunction to “disciple the ethnicities” (Matt 28:19) in all their linguistic and cultural diversity, these twelve forms of service are all vehicles for the embodying and disseminating of good news for the world. They can be and should be translated into the languages and cultures around the globe. This centered diversity makes concrete what the catholicity of the church is really all about. These forms all can and should find expression, critique, and application in the disciplined tasks of “practical theological interpretation” as expounded by Osmer. Many, if not all of these forms of service will make up the content of research and instruction in the disciplines of practical theology today. As they form communities for faithful practice, they serve the continuing articulation of missional theology in relevant translation in diverse settings.
What Barth’s practical theological formation envisions in his discussion of the twelve forms of service is addressed by Lesslie Newbigin in his magisterial discussion of The Gospel in a Pluralist Society.178 He defines the congregation as “the hermeneutic of the gospel,” whose diverse actions and forms of service “equip the saints for the work of ministry” (Eph 4:12).
Newbigin’s conclusion could be used as a summary of Barth’s discussion of the forms of witnessing service: “The congregation has to be a place where its members are trained, supported, and nourished in the exercise of their parts of the priestly ministry in the world. The preaching and teaching of the local church has to be such that it enables members to think out the problems that face them in their secular work in the light of their Christian faith.”179 If we understand Osmer’s approach to practical theology as the discipline that reflects on Newbigin’s “preaching and teaching of the local church,” and what Barth lays out as the “forms of service,” then we have an interactive resource for the exploration of the question of the ways in which practical theology and missional theology might be related.180
Have we, then, arrived at least at the beginnings of a response to the query, how are practical theology and missional theology related? Defined by the theology of the missio Dei, missional theology contributes the fundamental convictions that determine the church’s nature, purpose, and action. These theological convictions center on God’s action in gathering a people to witness to the healing of all creation. That healing is accomplished for all generations and times in the event of Jesus Christ as reported in the New Testament Scriptures. In response to the proclamation of that event, the Spirit gathers witnesses and forms them into communities to serve God’s mission. The gathered life of witnesses displays, demonstrates, enfleshes the good news by the ways the community communicates the gospel both as narrative as well as action. That communication takes place in and through all the Spirit-empowered forms of service that missionally defined practical theology enables the community to investigate, research, generate, and employ.
The formation of communities for witness takes place through the interaction of all the forms through which God’s Spirit works. The list of twelve forms offered by Barth is a helpful and also debatable summary of the church’s experience over time, traced back to Jesus’ earthly work of disciple formation. The task of rigorous, intentional practical theological analysis is to provide content, structure, and discipline for the formation of such communities, as the process of formation is intentionally addressed. The christocentric focus of missional theology and the practices that constitute its witness determine the cutting edge of the Christian mission in its “sentness” into any cultural context. That christocentric focus replaces the unhelpful dichotomy between theology as theory and practice, as well as the divisiveness of the disciplinary silos of the academy. In their place we encounter in Scripture the many-faceted emphasis upon the integrity of ecclesial action in the world. Centering on God’s mission in Christ generates a life of witness in which the doctrines of the faith are embodied and demonstrated by the actions of the witnessing community. The rigid distinction between theory and praxis becomes pointless, if not distorting. This can be persuasively documented by pursuing the question, “What kind of community did Jesus intend?” This was the provocative question which Gerhard Lohfink raised in the 1980s with his book, Wie hat Jesus Gemeinde gewollt?181 This approach demonstrates how doctrine emerges from practice and shapes its continuing exercise. Lohfink identifies basic convictions of the gathered community serving Christ’s witness that shape it as a visible witness. These include the rejection of all forms of violence, the end of patriarchy as formative of the ecclesial community, the continuing reality of healing within the life of the church, the development of the witnessing community as a “contrast society,” and the intentional formation of the community under the rubric “one-anotherness.” These convictions expressed in the life and practice of the gathered community are the continuing demonstration of what the early church learned from the example and practice of Jesus as he trained his disciples to become his apostles. The “practical theology” that shaped the apostolic communities was the result of following him and becoming “fishers of people” (Mark 1:17).
Paul’s formation of witnessing communities parallels the process of discipleship leading to apostolate in the four Gospels. One can argue that Paul and his missionary colleagues strove to form communities “the way that Jesus intended them.”182 His concern for the faithful witness of the churches he planted is expressed in his constant struggle with the challenges to the integrity of the community’s witness. The problems and temptations that the apostolic communities experienced serve the formation of subsequent generations of churches, as they reflect on their practice in light of the mission of God and their commission to “be Christ’s witnesses.”
For example, at the beginning of 2 Corinthians 3, Paul reflects on the vocation and practice of Christians in Corinth using the image of “Christ’s letters to the world”: “You yourselves are our letter, written on our hearts, to be known and read by all; and you show that you are a letter of Christ, prepared by us, written not with ink but with the Spirit of the living God, not on tablets of stone but on tablets of human hearts.” (2 Cor. 3:2–3).
In this passage, Paul’s formation of the Corinthians for their continuing witness in the mission field into which they are sent is very much focused on the integrative character of their lives and practice as witnesses. He has already sounded his concern when he states bluntly in 2 Corinthians 2:17, “For we are not peddlers of God’s word like so many.” The Corinthians, when they are gathered, are to understand themselves as letters being written by God’s Spirit. They are forms of communication sent out in order to be made available to all in their context who might “read” them—they are, in fact, intended “to be read by all.” So, they are to be legible, clear, faithful, and reliable transmitters of the gospel they are to communicate. It is essential for the formation of faithful witnesses that they are people of integrity whose message and practice are congruent. Paul envisions their life together as the time of their being written as Christ’s letters to the world. The corporate practices of formation (Barth’s twelve forms!) all serve their composition as gospel letters. Their gathered life is not for their benefit alone, but serves God’s greater mission. The life of community formation and witness is characterized by a rhythm of gathering, upbuilding, and sending, to use Barth’s ecclesiological triad. The sending cannot actually happen unless it is prepared and equipped in the shared life of the community. But the gathered life of the church is never an end in itself, never self-justifying. It must prepare for and issue forth in the action of witness in a watching and often resistant world.
Another compelling example of missional community formation is found in the Thessalonian correspondence. Paul reminds his Thessalonian friends about the distinctive witness he and his team brought to them. They were experiencing from the outset the kind of community that Jesus intended. “For our appeal does not spring from deceit or impure motives or trickery, but just as we have been approved by God to be entrusted with the message of the gospel, even so we speak, not to please mortals, but to please God who tests our hearts. As you know and as God is our witness, we never came with words of flattery or with a pretext for greed; nor did we seek praise from mortals, whether from you or from others” (1 Thess 2:3–6). Paul’s exposition of the gospel of Jesus Christ was communicated to the Thessalonians in such a way that the content of the story was totally congruent with the way it was told, the way in which the Pauline community lived the gospel as its witnesses.
Here again, the community Jesus intended was to be formed in Thessalonica as a gathering whose life and message were congruent. The community was to “incarnate” the story of Jesus, so that his mission could continue through their life and practices. Paul underlines the integrity of their message with its transmission when he writes, “We were gentle among you, like a nurse tenderly caring for her own children. So deeply do we care for you that we are determined to share with you not only the gospel of God but also our own selves, because you have become very dear to us” (1 Thess 2:7–8). Certainly there is nothing greater than “the gospel of God,” yet Paul can hyperbolically say “not only the gospel of God” as he reminds them of the new community they had become as a result of the gospel witness.
The formation of the witnessing community takes place as the outcome of practices that shape gospel obedience. Paul describes such conduct with a distinctive phrase that merits much thought as it guides and empowers our response. It occurs five times in the Pauline corpus, first of all further along in 1st Thessalonians: “As you know, we dealt with each one of you like a father with his children, urging and encouraging you and pleading that you lead a life worthy of God, who calls you into his own kingdom and glory” (1 Thess 2:11–12).183 All of the instances in which this emphasis upon worthy conduct is made are plural. This is an admonition directed at the formation of the entire community. The standard of worthiness is multi-faceted: “worthy of the gospel, worthy of God, worthy of the Lord, worthy of the call, worthy of the calling.” It has to do with conduct that communicates, which reminds us that Barth looked upon the first six of his “forms of service” as communication that was an event (e.g., praise, preaching, instruction, evangelization).184 This formative admonition has a dynamic character: all of the instances but one (Phil 1:27) are built upon an imperative of movement: “lead your life” or “walk your walk.” The formative imagery to be learned and experienced is that of a pilgrimage, a movement forward towards a goal. The Christian obedience being learned here anticipates growth, discovery, exploration, and risk. The mission is not reduced to a limited range of verbal events. The entire life of the witnessing community serves this communication.
In the reference to worthiness in Philippians 1:27, the emphasis, although related to the other citations, is different in important ways. We translate it, “Live your life in a manner worthy of the gospel of Christ.” The opening term needs a greater sense of urgency and emphasis. The apostle is calling his readers’ attention to a very important statement, so “listen up now!” The imperative here differs from the other four. It alludes to public life and conduct. One might translate it more freely: “Let the conduct that the world sees be congruent with and properly express the gospel of Christ.” Over against all tendencies to make our faith internal, intimate, private, and withdrawn from the world, this injunction summons us to public presence and action. It is commensurate with the use of the Greek term ecclesia to designate the assembled church. In the Greek-speaking world, an ecclesia was a public assembly, a town hall meeting, a gathering to do public business in behalf of its constituencies. The forms of service of the witnessing community must have public relevance if they are to lay before the world the reign of Christ to whom “all authority in heaven and on earth has been given to me” (Matt 28:18).
These diverse forms of reflection and practice can, of course, serve other theological or ecclesial masters. But if the missional vocation of the gathered community is to be formed and equipped by its engagement in diverse forms of service, then the prior commitment must be to missional vocation and its practice. Such prior (and constantly reaffirmed) commitment constitutes an open invitation to the practical theologian to engage the vocation of the missional church by equipping the saints for the work of service. As the decline of Christendom continues apace, and the challenges to missional faithfulness become more acute, there is undeniably a profound need for marginalized communities of witness to be more faithfully and rigorously formed for their practice. The resources of missionally informed practical theology are crucial for public Christian witness today. Newbigin has framed the challenge with realism and candor:
If the gospel is to challenge the public life of our society, if Christians are to occupy the “high ground” which they vacated in the noontime of “modernity,” it will not be by forming a Christian political party, or by aggressive propaganda campaigns. Once again it has to be said that there can be no going back to the “Constantinian” era. It will only be by movements that begin with the local congregation in which the reality of the new creation is present, known, and experienced, and from which men and women will go into every sector of public life to claim it for Christ, to unmask the illusions which have remained hidden and to expose all areas of public life to the illumination of the gospel. But that will only happen as and when local congregations renounce an introverted concern for their own life, and recognize that they exist for the sake of those who are not members, as sign, instrument and foretaste of God’s redeeming grace for the whole life of society.185
Bibliography
Barth, Karl. Church Dogmatics: Volume IV/3.2. Edinburgh: T. & T. Clark.
Flett, John G. The Witness of God: The Trinity, Missio Dei, Karl Barth and the Nature of Christian Community. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2010.
Gorman Michael, J. Becoming the Gospel: Paul, Participation, and Mission. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2015.
Guder, Darrell L., et al., eds. Missional Church: A Vision for the Sending of the Church in North America. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1998.
Lohfink, Gerhard. Wie hat Jesus Gemeinde gewollt? Vienna: Herder Verlag, 1982.
———. Jesus and Community: The Social Dimension of Christian Faith. Translated by J. P. Galvin. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1984.
Newbigin, Lesslie. The Gospel in a Pluralist Society. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1989.
Osmer, Richard. Practical Theology: An Introduction. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2008.
———. Teaching Ministry of Congregations. Louisville, KY: Westminster John Knox, 2005.
169. Guder et al., Missional Church.
170. Flett, The Witness of God, 30–34.
171. The Revised Standard Version is cited except where I have offered my own translation.
172 Gorman, Becoming the Gospel.
173. Osmer, Practical Theology, ix.
174. Barth, Church Dogmatics, 481–680.
175. Ibid, 681–901.
176. Ibid.
177. Ibid, 830–901. The page numbers of the twelve forms discussed in this sub–section are provided in the text below.
178. Newbigin, The Gospel in a Pluralist Society, 222–23.
179. Ibid., 230.
180. Osmer, Teaching Ministry of Congregations.
181. Lohfink, Wie hat Jesus Gemeinde gewollt?; the English translation by J. P. Galvin received a title that completely obscured the thrust and promise of this remarkable study: see Lohfink, Jesus and Community.
182. Barth, Church Dogmatics, 862–64.
183. See also 2 Thessalonnians 1:11, “that our God may make you worthy of his call . . . ”; Colossians 1:10, “to lead a life worthy of the Lord . . .”; Philippians 1:27, “only let your manner of life be worthy of the gospel of Christ . . .”; and Ephesians 4:1, “I . . . beg you to lead a life worthy of the calling to which you have been called . . .”
184. Barth, Church Dogmatics, 862–64.
185. Newbigin, Gospel in a Pluralist Society, 232–33.
