Chapter 13: The Teacher as Practical Theologian: A Trinitarian Kenotic Praxis of Love
13
The Teacher as Practical Theologian: A Trinitarian Kenotic Praxis of Love
In congregations of the Korean Protestant church, Christian teaching has been often considered an individualized and privatized form of praxis, a one-way transmission of Christian tradition from teacher to learner, and a specialized skill employing pedagogical rationality. The result? Members of the Korean church usually hold a corresponding individualized and privatized faith. Current critique about the Korean churches’ loss of significance in the public square deeply relates to the privatization of Christian faith, which in turn contributes to a loss of communal Christian identity, leaving Christian pedagogy to emphasize human reason at the expense of divine love.
This chapter critiques individualized, privatized teaching in Korean Protestant churches, and seeks a foundation for pedagogy grounded in the divine praxis of love. Richard R. Osmer’s approach to practical theology will guide us, especially as it contributes to a new approach to the teaching ministry of Korean Protestant churches.244
Osmer’s practical theological perspective on teaching emphasizes: 1) a strong theological foundation, 2) theo-praxis as normative for human praxis, 3) three tasks of the teaching ministry for congregations drawn from biblical theology (catechesis, exhortation, and discernment), 4) globalization as a new context for Christian teaching, and 5) a transversal approach to interdisciplinary dialogue. Given the limits of one chapter, these five points—while all important to teaching in Korean Protestant churches—cannot be explored fully here. Instead, I will focus on Osmer’s second emphasis, the normative role of divine action for human action, and specifically will explore trinitarian kenotic praxis as a normative for Christian teaching in Korean Protestant churches.
Theo-Praxis as Trinitarian Kenotic Praxis
Many practical theologians, critical of drawing the norms for Christian praxis from social scientific or other secular sources, have explored the concept of theo-praxis (or divine action) as a basis for guiding human praxis. James Fowler, for example, draws on theologian Sally McFague’s feminist metaphors for a triune God, proposing God as a Mother or Parent, the Son as a Lover, and the Holy Spirit as a Friend. In these metaphors, the trinitarian theo-praxis is respectively revealed as “the Creating praxis,” “the Saving praxis,” and “the Sustaining praxis.”245
In dialogue with Jürgen Moltmann’s trinitarian theology, Osmer presents Christopraxis as normative for the teaching ministry of congregations, understood as marturia, diakonia, doxology, didache, and koinonia. These correspond to Christ’s fivefold offices: the prophetic, the priestly, the transfigured, the royal, and the open fellowship of Christ’s praxis, or Christopraxis.246 Following Osmer’s lead, this chapter also presents the Trinitarian kenotic praxis as a norm for Christian teaching. Thus, Christian teaching as the trinitarian kenotic praxis of love is considered here to be fulfilled through active participation, a view which stands in agreement with Fowler and Osmer’s theo-praxis approach.
To understand teaching as a praxis of love that reflects the trinitarian kenotic praxis of God, we must first unpack what that means. Though kenotic theology was traditionally thought to originate from the self-emptying of Christ proclaimed in Philippians 2:5–11, both testaments bear witness to the idea. In the Old Testament, the literal meaning of the word kenosis is directly related to the Greek verb kenō, meaning “to empty” and “to pour out.” Its Hebrew equivalents are shown in passages such as Genesis 24:20 and Isaiah 32:15. In Genesis 24:20, Rebekah poured out the water from her pitcher into the trough. Isaiah 32:15 uses the Greek verb exekenōsen (LXX): “Until a spirit from on high is poured out on us.”247 In the New Testament, the Christological hymn of Philippians 2:5–11 is a representative passage that proclaims the incarnation of Christ as the kenosis of God. In this case kenosis is understood as “Christ’s voluntary renunciation of certain divine attributes, in order to identify himself with humanity.”248
Some theologians assert divine kenosis within the inner life of the Trinity itself. Russian Orthodox theologian Sergious Bulgakov claims that, in the perichoretic relationship among the three divine persons, each person of the Trinity gives itself to the others kenotically, in sacrificial love:
The Father pours himself out, empties himself in the begetting the Son. The Son, on his part, empties himself by submitting to be begotten from the Father and by being obedient to the Father. The eternal kenosis of the third person of the Trinity consists in divesting himself of his hypostatic self (samost’) and serving as a “bond” (sviazka) or a “bridge of love” between the Father and the Son. 249
In Moltmann’s view, each member of the eternal Trinity makes room for each other through this love-inspired action of self-emptying:
. . . the divine persons of the Trinity become habitable for each other in their mutual perichoresis, giving each other open life-space for their mutual indwelling. Each trinitarian person is then not only subject but also room for the other. In the perichoresis of the eternal Trinity we find therefore not only three persons but also three “broad rooms.”250
Other theologians discuss the kenotic nature of the Trinity in light of God’s actions towards creation. These theologians describe the divine kenosis as the act of creation, incarnation, and pouring out of the Holy Spirit as motivated by God’s sacrificial divine love for all creation:
In creating, God enters into relationship, with creatures by granting them their own being, integrity, autonomy—an authentic existence which is theirs alone . . . Creation is thus an act of the profoundly generous divine love which calls the other into being and sustains it in its particularity and otherness.251
Triune God’s kenotic love is self-limiting as well as self-donating. In creation, God the Father limits divine omnipresence, omnipotence, and omniscience to make room, give time, and grant freedom for God’s creatures. Moltmann links the kenosis of God the Father with the Jewish concept of Shekinah, God’s indwelling or self-humiliation. God’s Shekinah originates from God’s covenant with the Israelites: “I will dwell in the midst of the Israelites.” 252 Later the Shekinah was understood as God’s presence with captured people in the Babylonian exile and with suffering and oppressed people.
In the incarnation, God the Son also demonstrates self-giving, self-limiting love. According to Gordon Fee, the incarnation “presupposes some form of self-limitation on Christ’s part in his human life on earth,” and notes that in Hebrews 5:7–9 the Son “expresses utter dependence on the Father in prayer, and then submits to his will in full obedience—an obedience he learned through suffering.”253 The Son’s kenosis reaches its peak on the cross. “Because of the cross, the meaning of Christ’s self-emptying is qualified in such a way that it is understood to entail radical involvement and identity with . . . human existence in its totality, including its extremes of brokenness and death.”254
The kenosis of the Spirit is shown as she pours herself into the world. The Spirit imparts herself into Creation and shares herself with Creation in perichoretic ways. In John 16:14, the Spirit empties herself by glorifying Christ over herself. But for the Spirit, divine kenosis also can mean being poured into or achieving actualization. The Spirit of God even poured into the ministry of Jesus. “Indeed, the Spirit was poured into Jesus so as to empower Jesus for his crucial ministry of imparting life to the masses, which resulted in Jesus’ own temporal and bodily death.”255 In Jane Linahan’s words, the Spirit is the creative power, saving power, and prophetic power, as well as a kenotic power.256 As a kenotic power, the Spirit allows, empowers, and supports the actualization of the other:
It is the Spirit of God who brings otherness into being, who sustains and empowers otherness, who enables it to stand in the freedom of relationship . . . before its creator. This is the kenotic power of the Spirit: a self-emptying love so profound and generous that it gives everything, it risks its very self for the sake of the authentic being of the other.257
In short, the trinitarian praxis of kenosis results from the triune God’s profound, endless, sacrificial, and self-giving love for one another and for creation. But thanks to the trinitarian praxis of kenosis as creation, incarnation, and actualization, God invites and encourages us to participate in this self-giving, mutually interpenetrating (periochoretic) life in an analogous way. As God’s people, we are called to join in the Father’s praxis of creation, in the Son’s praxis of incarnation, and in the Spirit’s praxis of actualization, which for humans evokes thanks and praise. In fact, the most fitting response to the trinitarian praxis of kenosis is doxology. The question is, how shall Christian teaching reflect this?
Christian Teaching as Trinitarian Kenotic Praxis of Love
This section presents Christian teaching as participation in a Trinitarian kenotic praxis of love, an idea that refers to Osmer’s Trinitarian and dramatological approach to the teaching ministry of congregations. Osmer sees the three tasks of teaching ministry (catechesis, exhortation, and discernment) as participating in “the triune God’s creating, redeeming, and glorifying of the world.”258 So what does Christian teaching look like that is rooted in a trinitarian kenotic praxis of love?
We can begin by saying this much: teaching that participates in God’s trinitarian kenotic praxis of love is experienced as self-sacrifice, self-emptying, and self-limitation that is motivated by love. More specifically, we can understand this kind of teaching as a lifelong interpretive process in which mutual caring by both teacher and learner, whether individual or communal, is enacted through practices of room-making/time-taking, embodiment/modeling, and actualization/involvement. (One point we need to keep in mind is that teachers and learners may be either individual Christians or faith communities—and as we will see, the roles of teacher and learner constantly shift.) These practices help teacher and learner alike live into God’s eschatological reign, while at the same time enacting God’s love in the world.
1) Christian teaching is a lifelong praxis that helps learners live into the eschatological reign of God.
From an eschatological perspective, teaching that participates in a praxis of love is not a short-term process, but a life-long commitment or devotion to the learner. Nor is it confined to the personal or inner lives of the teacher and the learner; participating in a praxis of love means attending to the cultural, social, political, public, and ecological dimensions of learning as well as the inner life of the learner. Christian teaching is thus not an act of domination, enforcement, or invasion by the teacher, but expressed through waiting, inviting, accompanying, empowering, and persuading so that the learner can live under the eschatological reign of God in the power of the Spirit.
Christian teaching does not pretend to generate faith itself. Faith is rather a gift from God through grace, not human enterprise. As Osmer points out, Christian teaching is viewed as an attempt “to create a context in which faith can be awakened, supported, and challenged” by maintaining the eschatological tension of our redemption—faith is both “already” given and “not yet” fully achieved.259 As teachers help learners taste the reality of the reign of God in their daily lives in an anticipatory manner, they also entrust the learner to the Power of the Spirit, referred to as the stage of “release” in Maria Harris’s words.260
2) Christian teaching practices mutual caring between teacher and learner.
Like the periochoretic relationship of the three divine persons of the Trinity, mutual caring between teacher and learner is another essential dimension of Christian teaching. This understanding of teaching corrects the misunderstanding of education as unilateral transmission from the teacher to the learner. In a perichoretic relationship, the three divine persons are mutually dwelling within each other in unlimited divine love. Similarly, trinitarian kenotic teaching views the relationship between the teacher and the learner, whether the learner is an individual or a community, as bilateral and cooperative. The teacher does not always lead, and the student does not always follow. They lead and at the same time are led by each other in the process of teaching-learning, following the perichoretic dance of the three divine persons.
Christian teaching as a process of mutual caring also includes the mutual caring made possible by communal relationships formed within congregations, including relationships between generations. As John Westerhoff argues, Christian faith can be shaped and inherited through the process of continuing interaction or care among three different generations: the generation of vision, the generation of the present, and the generation of memory.261
3) Christian teaching practices room-making/time-taking for presenting and becoming obedient to the subject matter of teaching.
Parker Palmer defines teaching as creating “a space in which obedience to truth is practiced.” 262 Yet, while sympathetic to Palmer, trinitarian kenotic teaching differs from Palmer’s understanding in that it emphasizes the divine perspective more explicitly, and lifts up time-taking and time-consuming as equally distinctive aspects of Christian teaching.
Following the Father’s kenotic praxis of creation as room-making, Christian teaching makes physical, psychological, conceptual, spiritual space for the learner. Christian teaching makes physical space inviting and hospitable, psychological space welcoming and safe; conceptual space is characterized by sharing the subject matter in a sympathetic and dynamic way, and spiritual space leaves room to be filled and activated by the Spirit.
Just as creation by the Father is a praxis of self-limitation as God’s inserts the divine self into time, Christian teaching practices time-taking to present the subject matter and become obedient to it. Both the praxis of room-making and the praxis of time-taking are processes of self-limitation, as teachers grant learners their own being, integrity, and autonomy. They call the learners into being and sustain them in their particularity and otherness.
4) Christian teaching embodies and models the subject matter it’s teaching.
Just as the incarnation of the Son embodies divine redemptive love, Christian teaching embodies Christian faith’s subject matter and content. More than simply transmitting information, trinitarian kenotic teaching engages the learner’s lives and personifies a life shaped by God. At the same time, Christian teaching remains in dialogue with various human developmental theories, such as the psychological, moral, social, spiritual theories, exhibiting (as Osmer suggests) a posture of “priestly listening.”263 This posture of listening requires the practical theologian’s gift of creative interdisciplinary dialogue with various human sciences.
5) Christian teaching actualizes otherness and engages in mutual empowerment between the teacher and the learner.
As seen through the Spirit’s actualizing outpouring of the divine self into creation, Christian teaching also shares power and empowers others through the kenotic love of actualization. As Maria Harris suggests, Christian teaching nurtures: 1) the power to receive, 2) the power to rebel, 3) the power to resist, 4) the power to reform, and 5) the power to love.264 These five kinds of power have two fundamental elements: receiver and agent:
First, power is capacity and ability to act as receiver, in the sense of being receptive, attentive, and aware of the address of Being. Thus power is a capacity schooled by the contemplative and ascetic imaginations, with their attitudes of listening, watching, waiting, and seeing. But secondly, power is also capacity and ability to act as an agent, schooled by the creative and archetypal imagination, with their attitudes of crafting, forming, making, and symbolizing.265
Christian teaching as a process of mutual empowerment is thus based on the kinds of power that actualize the other. Harris describes the relationship of these five kinds of power as dancing, a dance that is essentially perichoretic. We can step into any stage of the dance and be swept up into the next step. As the incarnate Son’s kenotic action favored the poor, the oppressed, and the suffering, the Christian dance of actualization likewise favors the powerless and marginalized. According to Jung Young Lee, incarnation is “a divine marginalization.” He claims, “To be the Son of the living God does not mean to be at the center of centrality. It means to be at the margin of marginality, the servant of all servants.”266 In this sense, Christian teaching participates in a divine marginalization of both the teacher and the learner in order to “remember the dismembered,” as Mary Elizabeth Moore puts it, through core educational practices of loving, truth-telling, mourning and repenting, and reconciling.267
6) Christian teaching is missional praxis.
Christian teaching is inseparable from missional praxis. As stated above, Christian teaching as a praxis of room-making/time-taking, embodiment/modeling, and actualization/involvement not only has personal, individual, and existential dimensions, but also social, political, ecological, and public facets. Teaching that takes part in a trinitarian kenotic praxis of love is not restricted to speculating about the inner life of the Trinity. The kenotic God is a missional or sending God. Correspondingly, Christian teaching participates in the trinitarian kenotic praxis of creation, incarnation, and actualization, through which the triune God sends (missio) God’s people both individually and corporally into the world. Darrell Guder warns against the “the mission-benefit dichotomy”—namely, separating “[t]he benefits of salvation . . . from the reason for which we receive God’s grace in Christ: to empower us as God’s people to become Christ’s witnesses.”268 Avoiding this dichotomy requires Christian teaching to approach room-making/time-taking, embodiment/modeling, and actualization/involvement as missional praxis.
Doxology as the Crux of Christian Teaching
The crux of Christian teaching goes beyond a simple formation of ethical lives, transmission of Christian knowledge through instruction, or faith enculturation. It does not disparage these processes, but encourages the learner to participate in the praxis of giving thanks and praise to the trinitarian God’s kenotic praxis of self-sacrifice, self-limitation, and self-emptying love. According to Osmer, doxology, including marturia, diakonia, didache, and koinonia, is the core praxis of the congregation. Rooted in Christ’s event of transfiguration, doxology participates in “the transfiguration of the risen Christ through the praise and enjoyment of God,”269 giving both teacher and learner a foretaste of an eschatological future in the trinitarian kingdom of God.
In this sense, Christian teaching distinguishes itself entirely from secular or general education. If doxology is the crux of Christian teaching, neither education nor practical theology itself cannot be reduced to a means to an end. Christian teaching in Korean Protestant churches (or any church) cannot be a vehicle to achieve self-actualization, cognitive maturity, or even salvation. If doxology is the crux of Christian teaching, then teaching grounded in trinitarian kenotic praxis of love is a good unto itself, a way to praise God. Learning is not restricted to the cognitive level. Instead, the learner might give thanks and praise to the triune God through various artistic, bodily, corporeal, and performative forms, such as singing, dancing, performing, or drawing. All the characteristics of teaching as trinitarian kenotic practice point to doxology because the relationship between knowledge and worship is inseparable. To know God is to worship God.
Bibliography
Cahalan Kathleen A., and Gordon S. Mikoski. “Introduction.” In Opening the Field of Practical Theology: An Introduction, edited by Kathleen A. Cahalan and Gordon S. Mikoski, 1–7. New York: Rowman & Littlefield, 2014.
Fee, Gordon D. “The New Testament and Kenosis Christology.” In Exploring Kenotic Christology: The Self Emptying of God, edited by C. Stephen Evans, 25–42. New York: Oxford University Press, 2006.
Fowler, James W. Weaving the New Creation: Stages of Faith and the Public Church. San Francisco: Harper San Francisco, 1991.
Gavrilyuk, Paul, L. “The Kenotic Theology of Sergius Bulgakov.” Scottish Journal of Theology 58 (2005) 251–69.
Guder, Darrell L. The Continuing Conversion of the Church. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2000.
Harris, Maria. Dance of the Spirit: The Seven Steps of Women’s Spirituality. New York: Bantam, 1991.
———. Teaching and Religious Imagination: An Essay in the Theology of Teaching. San Francisco: Harper San Francisco, 1991.
Lee, Jung Young. Marginality: The Key to Multicultural Theology. Minneapolis: Fortress, 1995.
Linahan, Jane E. “Experiencing God in Brokenness: The Self-emptying of Holy Spirit in Moltmann’s Pneumatology.” In Encountering Transcendence: Contributions to a Theology of Religious Experience, edited by Lieven Boeve, et al., 165–84. Leuven: Peter, 2005.
McCall, Bradford. “Kenosis of the Spirit into Creation.” Crucible: Theology & Ministry 1 (2008) 2.
Moltmann, Jürgen. “God’s Kenosis in the Creation and Consummation of the World.” In The Work of Love: Creation as Kenosis, edited by John Polkinghorne, et al., 137–51. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2001.
Moore, Mary Elizabeth Mullino. Teaching as a Sacramental Act. Cleveland, OH: Pilgrim, 2004.
Nouwen, Henri J. In the Name of Jesus: Reflections on Christian Leadership. New York: Crossroad, 1989.
Osmer, Richard R. The Teaching Ministry of Congregations. Louisville, KY: Westminster John Knox, 2005.
———. Practical Theology: An Introduction. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2008.
———. Teaching for Faith: A Guide for Teachers of Adult Classes. Louisville, KY: Westminster John Knox, 1992.
Palmer, Parker J. To Know as We are Known: Education as A Spiritual Journey. San Francisco: Harper San Francisco, 1983.
Westerhoff III, John. Will Our Children Have Faith? New York: Seabury, 1976.
244. Kathleen A. Cahalan and Gordon S. Mikoski pose eleven major concerns or features of contemporary practical theologians: 1) attentive to theory-practice complexity, 2) practice and performance oriented, 3) oriented to multidimensional dynamics of social context and embodiment, 4) holistic, 5) interdisciplinary, 6) open-ended, flexible, and porous, 7) theologically normed, 8) hermeneutical, 9) interventionist and critically constructive, 10) teleological and eschatological, and, 11) self-reflective and self-identified. This article reflects those features of contemporary practical theology and loosely employs Richard Osmer’s four tasks of practical theology: 1) descriptive-empirical task, 2) hermeneutical task, 3) normative task, and 4) pragmatic task. See Cahalan and Mikoski, “Introduction,” 1–7.
245. Fowler, Weaving the New Creation, 67–82.
246. Osmer, The Teaching Ministry of Congregations, 221–25.
247. McCall, “Kenosis of the Spirit into Creation,” 2.
248. Ibid., 3.
249. Gavrilyuk, “The Kenotic Theology of Bulgakov,” 255–56.
250. Moltmann, “God’s Kenosis,” 140.
251. Linahan, “Experiencing God in Brokenness,” 173–74.
252. Moltmann, “God’s Kenosis,” 142–43.
253. Fee, “The New Testament and Kenosis Christology,” 36.
254. Linahan, “Experiencing God in Brokenness,” 172.
255. McCall, “Kenosis of the Spirit into Creation,” 3.
256. Linahan, “Experiencing God in Brokenness,” 173.
257. Ibid., 173–74.
258. Osmer, The Teaching Ministry of Congregations, 236.
259. Osmer, Teaching for Faith, 15.
260. Harris, Dance of the Spirit, 74–75.
261. Westerhoff , Will Our Children Have Faith?, 53.
262. Palmer, To Know as We are Known, 69.
263. Osmer, Practical Theology, 31–78.
264. Harris, Teaching and Religious Imagination, 89–96.
265. Ibid., 80–81.
266. Lee, Marginality, 25.
267. Moore, Teaching as a Sacramental Act, 79–88.
268. Guder, The Continuing Conversion of the Church, 120.
269. Osmer poses 1) Sabbath keeping, 2) praise of God, and 3) recreation as three core practices of doxology. Osmer, The Teaching Ministry of Congregations, 223–24.
