Chapter 3: Accidental Prophet
3
Accidental Prophet
Richard R. Osmer and the “Theological Turn” in Youth Ministry
The first article I ever read written by Richard R. Osmer was fished out from under an unruly stack on my seminary advisor’s desk. “Here,” she said, emphatically thrusting a slim journal into my hands. She had marked the page, knowing that I—the only seminarian that either of us knew who actually wanted to do youth ministry—would devour it. “You’re going to want to read this,” she said. And then, ominously, indicating the byline: “Keep your eye on that young man. He’s going places.”
It was 1989, the year of Tiananmen Square, the fall of the Berlin Wall, and Madonna’s “Like a Prayer” video. George Herbert Walker Bush was the United States’ forty-first President. The Exxon Valdez bled almost eleven million gallons of crude into the Alaskan sea; Stephen Hawking published A Brief History of Time. Michael Keaton was Batman. Taylor Swift was born. And congregations were beginning to come to grips with the fact that young people, who had been spilling out of North American churches steadily since the 1960s, were not coming back—or, more disorienting to us still, were never really “churched” in the first place.
By 1989, the youth ministry resource industry was in full swing, a testament to the widespread belief that the adolescent exodus from North American churches was linked to lackluster resources and poorly trained leadership. The generally held assumption was that improving the quality of these variables would stem the outgoing tide. Two scrappy American youth ministry resource companies—Youth Specialties and Group Publishing—had come of age, and their user-friendly youth curriculum, flashy program resources, and energetic training conferences underscored the narrative that most churches told themselves: if we can just make youth programs more appealing and attract more professionally prepared leaders, teenagers will stay. By design, most of the available youth ministry literature leaned toward personal reflections on “what works” with teenagers, and could be read in an hour.
Still, research from fields like education, developmental psychology and sociology had begun to make inroads in youth ministry. In 1991, the Carnegie Council on Adolescent Development identified two goals shared by Protestant, Catholic, and Jewish religious youth work in the United States: to impress upon young people a religious identity, and to usher them safely into adulthood.50 For churches, the most common route to both was to address young people’s developmental, sociological, and cultural “needs” in church so youth would not look elsewhere to fulfill them. In other words, religious communities set out to provide young people with optimal conditions for physical, psychological, and spiritual health, and to make the rough places plain as adolescents grew in wisdom and stature and favor with God.51 It was a job most pastors happily outsourced to volunteer or professional youth workers.
Fresh from seminary, newly ordained, and as gung ho as they come, I was one of them.
Little did I know that three years later I would be sitting in Rick Osmer’s office as his first doctoral advisee, exasperated by churches’ easy dismissal of young people—but also exhausted from “meeting adolescents’ needs,” and frustrated by churches’ inability to imagine youth ministers as more than service providers. Theology was seldom discussed by youth ministers beyond hackneyed catch-phrases (helping youth “meet Jesus,” “get saved,” or “grow into mature Christian adults,” depending on your theological tradition).52 Most of us were far too busy meeting teenagers’ needs to reflect deeply on what any of this actually meant, or on whether youth ministry could (or should) accomplish these things. Meeting adolescent needs was important work, after all. Yet what made youth ministry ministry remained elusive. Meanwhile, despite ample scriptural warrant for God’s “preferential option for young people,”53 mainline churches’ leadership systems retained a clear bias for age and experience, and typically overlooked the potential theological contributions of young people and those who served them.
Seeds of a Theological Turn for Youth Ministry54
In the late 1980s Robert Lynn from the Lilly Endowment’s religion division convened mainline Protestant Christian educators—including Union Theological Seminary (Richmond)’s new professor of Christian education, Richard R. Osmer—to discuss the “state of youth ministry.” These gatherings marked the beginning of Lilly’s generation-long emphasis on congregations and young people. Osmer’s prescient piece in 1989, “Challenges to Youth Ministry in Mainline Congregations,” was the culmination of those conversations. Osmer framed the issue squarely: the problem wasn’t youth—it was the church.
It is time to take a new look at the mainline churches’ ministry with youth . . . An important part of the dissatisfaction of today’s youth with the church stems from an absence of a spiritually challenging and world-shaping vision that meets their hunger for a chance to participate in a worthy adventure . . . Ultimately, the spiritual needs of youth transcend the legitimate requirements of wholesome companionship, entertaining events, and even worthwhile service projects. What they ask from the church is no so much something to do as something to be.55
With that, the gauntlet was thrown, igniting an explicit ecclesiological thrust in youth ministry.56
Thirty years later, the dispiriting truth is that every challenge Osmer named in his 1989 manifesto remains true for youth ministry today. This is despite a generation of leaders who have substantially professionalized youth ministry training, launched an active academic “subfield” in Western theological education, and made resources and education in youth ministry readily available. Surely churches’ lack of influence on contemporary young people, despite these substantial changes, requires explanation. Yet my main purpose in this essay is to argue that Osmer’s essay was more prophetic than its author realized. In offering a fresh lens for the ways churches think about young people, Osmer anticipated a shift—still too nascent in 1989 to fully make out—that thirty years later would be called “the theological turn” in youth ministry.
In the years to follow, Osmer sometimes sowed the seeds of a “theological turn” explicitly, but more often he simply assumed them in his teaching and writing. (To my knowledge, he never assigned this article to his students; it remains a hidden part of the Osmer corpus, appearing only once in print.) Yet these seeds grew into a forest of publications from Osmer’s students and their progeny—including many of the authors of this volume—not to mention a generation of pastors and Christian thought leaders who insisted that young people, and therefore any ministry that involves them, are theological subjects worthy of a theological mission . . . and that if the church offers them anything less, we are frauds.
The More Things Change
In his essay, Osmer identified eight characteristics of mainline congregations’ youth ministries that, in his view, castrated churches’ ability to hand on Christian faith to new generations, with devastating effects on adolescent faith (see Figure 1). Several refrains recur throughout the article. Without a “spiritually challenging, world-shaping vision,” avers Osmer, young people experience church as “spiritually innocuous”—and therefore unworthy of their time, attention, or commitment. Without creatively renegotiating Christian practices for new generations (a role Osmer explicitly champions for youth ministry), even youth who value their childhood church experience fail to see its relevance for their futures. When churches avoid the most pressing issues of society (a charge the young Osmer levies with some force), they fail to address matters that daily concern adolescents, leaving youth to conclude that theology has nothing to do with them.
It is striking how little has changed in thirty years. Despite a more professionalized workforce, heightened clergy awareness about young people, and a limited but noticeable theological conversation around youth ministry, churches have failed to foster robust faith in young people, restore them to the fold, or guarantee a central place for youth ministry in North American congregations. In short, the challenges facing youth ministry in 2019 look very much like those enumerated by Osmer a generation earlier. Still absent from most churches is a spiritually challenging and world-shaping vision that meets adolescents’ hunger to participate in a worthy adventure. Still persistent in most congregations is a reluctance to confront the comfortable standards of American culture. Still dwindling is adolescent church participation—in fact, we now have data showing that religious faith among young people is significantly more precarious today than in 1989. So what can we learn from Osmer’s views on youth ministry besides its stubborn resistance to change? What about his understanding of adolescent faith helped inspire a “theological turn” that took almost thirty years to unfold?
The Shackles of Low Expectations
Underlying Osmer’s observations about North American youth ministry is his determination to confront churches with their failure to nurture the potential theological and ecclesial contributions of young people. Osmer believed that failing to prioritize youth ministry placed the church itself in jeopardy, not because youth are “the future of the church” or an antidote to membership losses, but because young people’s absence creates a theological crisis for congregations.
Figure 1
With few exceptions, most advocates of youth ministry in 1989 focused on the risks teenagers faced in a culture that offered them more attractive options than Christian communities. Put another way, adolescents’ developmental “needs” were being met more adequately outside churches than in them. This disjuncture created a chasm between adolescents and congregations that, it was commonly believed, placed youth in spiritual jeopardy and dangerously weakened the membership rosters of the institutional church. Without youth as “the church’s future,” American mainline congregations—whose steep declines in membership and influence had become undeniable—seemed doomed to a speedy demise.
Osmer turns this “problem” of youth ministry on its head. He challenges two implicit assumptions in this narrative: first, the assumption that youth ministry should be strengthened to ensure institutional survival, and second, the assumption that adolescents are wrong to seek meaning and purpose apart from congregations. Osmer wonders if this analysis is backward. What if institutional survival was not all it cracked up to be? What if congregations did not offer ecclesial teaching worthy of adolescents’ allegiance? What if young people searching for a “worthy dream,” to paraphrase Stanley Hauerwas, simply couldn’t find one in church?
To make his case, Osmer does not point to the cultural and demographic trends that might plausibly contribute to adolescents’ increasing absence from North American religious life.57 Nor does he blame young people themselves for abandoning churches in favor of other interests. Instead, Osmer interprets young people’s de facto exodus from mainline Christianity as a stinging rebuke on churches’ refusal to offer youth a compelling counter-narrative to those peddled by the broader culture—and often embodied by congregations. “The mainline churches’ failure to present their own task in more starkly radical terms is an indication of their abdication to the comfortable standards of American culture,” Osmer charges.58 The challenge for churches with young people, says Osmer, is to offer a vision not unlike the one that won teens like Mary, Agnes, Joan of Arc, Teresa of Lisieux, and the Uganda martyrs—a vision that invites “an irrevocable (and therefore fully adult) commitment to God’s work in the world.”59
In their zeal, these [young saints] consented to being thrust immediately into the midst of the ferment that inevitably results when the Spirit of truth confronts the spirit of the age; they asked for and were granted the privilege of moving to the front lines in the battle with sin and evil, where they would be most vulnerable to the action of grace and, in some cases, to martyrdom.60
Osmer contrasts contemporary congregations’ approach to youth ministry with the call to radical self-giving and even martyrdom that punctuates the biographies of history’s young saints, whom history portrays not as victims, but as agents of considerable power. “At no point did these youthful saints see themselves as the ‘church of tomorrow,’” observes Osmer wryly. Meanwhile, contemporary youth ministry focuses on “devising strategies for keeping young people in the church because it is a place they will be ‘safe’ from the terrors of the street or the seductions of the shopping mall.”61 Then he lands his most devastating punch:
Our hopes for [our youth] are modest and reasonable. For the most part, they mirror the expectations we have for ourselves. We ask no more than that they grow up to be ‘good’ people . . . To this end, we program activities which are certainly wholesome, sometimes edifying, and almost always ‘fun.’ . . . Of course, some youth do remain in the church, and most of these do turn out to be ‘good’ people. But many . . . leave the church because it asks nothing significant of them. They leave the church because it is spiritually innocuous.62
In short, as long as churches present Christian discipleship as “manageable and unthreatening, youth will fail to find sufficient scope there for their very considerable zeal.” We should not be surprised, Osmer concludes, if youth look elsewhere.63
Twenty-five years later, Osmer’s analysis of the situation was corroborated by sociologist Christian Smith in the longitudinal National Study of Youth and Religion (NSYR), the largest study of adolescent religiosity ever conducted in the United States. The NSYR concluded that American’s default religion—practiced by young people because they learn it from their parents and their churches—is “moralistic therapeutic deism,” a do-good, feel-good, consumerist religious outlook that reduces God to a divine butler or cosmic therapist.64 Smith and his colleagues believe that moralistic therapeutic deism had “colonized” American churches, having supplanted experiences of the Trinity, holiness, justification, forgiveness, Eucharist, heaven, hell, and so on with the language of happiness, niceness, and earned heavenly reward. “It is not so much that Christianity is being secularized,” writes Smith. “Rather . . . [it] is actively being colonized and displaced by a quite different religious faith.”65 In other words, young people don’t practice moralistic therapeutic deism because they have misunderstood what churches teach them. Rather, they practice it because this is what churches teach them.
Much has been made of these findings’ significance for religious life in North America. A religion whose highest ambition is to meet young people’s needs—to keep them safe (“sober virgins,” in the words of one youth pastor I know) 66 and connected to a church community that supports them—instrumentalizes faith, draining it of theological grit (which does not stop it from being a useful therapeutic or civic exercise). Smith’s research was quickly followed by the Pew Research Center’s discovery of a dramatic drop in religious affiliation among young adults.67 Suddenly a new possibility emerged: if churches had inadvertently colluded with American culture to promote something like moralistic therapeutic deism, would increased church involvement counter pallid faith in adolescents, or contribute to it?
The Theological Significance of Youth Ministry
If moralistic therapeutic deism flattens and homogenizes faith into a generic, interpersonal version of American civil religion, the story of Jesus invites young people into something starkly different.68 Osmer posits the church as “the only institution with an investment in forming a counter–culture awareness in its members.”69 For Osmer, youth ministry is critical for raising the most urgent questions facing the church and world, which at bottom are always theological. Youth ministry inevitably “brings into focus some of the most significant theological issues presently before the church,” says Osmer. “Virtually every issue of central importance to the mainline churches’ future comes to expression in [ministry with young people].”70
For this reason, mainline churches’ ambivalence toward youth ministry reveals for Osmer “a broader theological uncertainty” in the church as a whole.71 In spite of research suggesting that most American adolescents want more time with adults—not less—churches tend to give youth their own “space,” their own minister, their own meeting times and programs (whether this is intended to benefit young people or adults is unclear).72 Such a “one–eared Mickey Mouse” model of youth ministry, as it is sometimes called (see Figure 2), isolates young people from the rest of the church, and marginalizes them from “the real centers of power, responsibility, and commitment in congregational life.”73 When youth are incorporated into the life of the church, on the other hand, they remind us of our theological mission, and force us to confront the disconnect between the story of Jesus and the “comfortable standards of secular culture,” thereby maintaining the church’s truth-telling power. This prevents congregations from falling into what social theorist Ulrich Beck calls a “zombie” category: a social concept that is dead, but kept alive by those invested in continuing the fiction of traditional institutions.74
Figure 2
Five Theological Gifts of Youth Ministry
Osmer does not explicitly outline youth ministry’s theological potential, but he is adamant that young people and youth ministry make contributions that safeguard the church against spiritual impotence. He aims his remarks at congregations, pointing out how youth ministry theologically anchors the broader church.75
Prophetic Witness
The most obvious way youth ministry helps the church remain “the church” is by raising difficult theological issues that congregations would often rather avoid. Because youth ministry dives headlong into adolescents’ lived concerns, there is no skirting issues of race, gender, justice, economics, and institutional mission. All of these are complex, cultural extensions of adolescent questions around identity, belonging, and purpose—questions that point to larger conversations about who we are in relationship to God. Despite its reputation for “fun and games,” youth ministry raises some of the most perturbing questions of human existence. Young people who explore these questions with their faith communities experience faith as a practice field for bearing one another’s burdens while naming and navigating the sins of institutions and societies as a whole.
Missional Vision
Osmer accuses mainline churches of becoming so infatuated with meeting the “needs” of adolescents, as those needs are outlined by developmental psychology, that they become captured by consumerism, reducing youth ministry to one more salve available to apply to the aches and pains of adolescence. Osmer eschews this reductionist interpretation of the church, and of youth ministry specifically. Anticipating his much later emphasis on missional theology, Osmer insists that ministry must not be prescribed by a theory of human development, nor should adolescence be romanticized on the one hand, or viewed as a series of unavoidable lifecycle crises on the other. Osmer’s concern is not simply intellectual misappropriation (though he has strong words for churches that oversimplify social science in order to “apply” it to ministry), but the fact that the developmental paradigm “represents a theologically bankrupt way of using the social sciences in Christian ministry.”76
The language of “needs,” psychologically understood, is used to undergird a view of the church and its ministry as competing in the spiritual supermarket to offer the most satisfying product to religious consumers. The most successful churches do the best job of meeting people’s needs. Youth ministry alone is not guilty of this mentality, for it is widely pervasive in mainline Christianity. Clearly, however, it does come to expression in [youth ministry].77
Osmer’s experience as a pastor in western North Carolina gave him an enduring appreciation for the importance of context in ministering to a person. He saw practical, not just theoretical, costs to organizing youth ministry around assuaging developmental “crises.” Besides diminishing the role of the Holy Spirit in adolescent formation, to assume “crisis” is just part of adolescence has the effect of minimizing many teenagers’ very real pain—pain that congregations could help diminish. Osmer argues that “many characteristics of contemporary youth are not inevitable life cycle crises, but the result of very specific patterns of culture and concrete institutional arrangements.”78 Where those patterns and institutional arrangements create harm, churches must challenge them on young people’s behalf, and offer youth life-giving alternatives.
Theological Agency
Like countless other researchers, Osmer underscores the crucial role of families in shaping youth’s religious identities. Osmer notes that adolescents still identify with their parents’ God-images,79 but he champions young people’s movement toward “owned” faith (i.e., faith as a durable aspect of identity, usually in adulthood). He acknowledges a role for doubt and “searching” as part of this process.80 By helping young people construct a scaffolding for faith, argues Osmer, youth begin to see themselves not as the “church of tomorrow” but as agents of ministry, effective immediately, called by God as “partners” in mission with roles to play in their home churches that extend beyond teen programs.81 Similarly, by offering young people a pool of trusted adults and peers, youth ministry plays an important role in launching those partnerships, giving young people models of mature faith who become exemplars for teenagers’ own emerging faith identities. Congregations that help youth “test drive” these new roles and new God-images help them exercise agency as theologians as they construct a faith that is genuinely their own.
Constructive Practical Theologians
Osmer critiques mainline churches’ failure to recognize youth ministry as an imaginative space for instructing youth in the texts and traditions of Christianity. He is forthright about the importance of teaching Christianity’s historic practices, not for the sake of perpetuating old traditions, but for “helping [youth] develop a deeper and more personal relationship with God.”82 Since Osmer is convinced that the “pressing issues” facing youth and youth ministry—and therefore the church—are theological in nature, he deems it essential, if youth ministry is to be ministry, for congregations to equip young people with robust theological tool kits. These tool kits include practices like prayer and testimony, language for Jesus, and significant adult role models who show young people what cobbling a life together with these tools can look like.
At the same time, Osmer recognizes that such instruction places historic Christian practices in the hands of newcomers to the tradition, which inevitably means new adaptations and uses for those practices. Osmer affirms this innovation as part of young people’s calling, and thus lays the groundwork for understanding youth ministry as a kind of ecclesial laboratory—the “research and development” arm of the church, so to speak. In this R&D space, fresh approaches to theology and practice are welcomed and tested as young people reshape their communities to reflect a God who cares deeply about them, and who invites their creativity.
Barometers of the Human Condition
Many adults enter youth ministry because it’s one of the few places in the church that allows you to rearrange the furniture, metaphorically (and often literally). Congregations are prone to giving young people they love far more room—and more rope—for ecclesial experimentation than, say, pastors who want to switch things up. What is really going on in this laboratory, however, is not simply random ideation: young people are testing to see if the Christianity they have been handed holds water. They wonder: Is God up to the task of helping me figure out what it means to be human—what it means to be me—as I grapple with questions of identity, belonging, and purpose for the first time? Is the gospel of Jesus Christ relevant to the world I experience, and does it make a difference? Is there room for me in this faith community, and what role do I play here? Answering these questions inevitably results in theological and ecclesial renovation as young people form their assumptions about faith, the church, and the world—assumptions they will very likely carry with them into adulthood.
This brings us full circle in terms of the theological importance of youth ministry for Osmer. The most significant experiences in any person’s life are the moments in which we discover what it feels like to be utterly human. These moments of vulnerability, in small and awkward ways, are shards of glass that reflect God’s light into the world. As churches struggle for significance with adolescents, we need look no further than the love story that is the good news of the gospel: this God, in whose image young people are made, thought they were worth dying for, and did. Like every story of true love, the life with God that the church promises is fraught with risk and unknowing; it is a route to death, and a route to life. That is what makes it a worthy dream.
Osmer knows that young people’s search for a worthy dream serves as a proxy for the church’s own search for God in a secular age. At our best, churches also ask the questions of adolescence: Who are we, and why are we here? To whom do we belong, and how do we become grafted into that tribe? How do we make sense of this world, and what are we called to contribute? These questions point toward something approximating the divine, because we answer them differently depending on our degree of confidence in that which is beyond us. We too need a worthy dream, a story to be part of a story with infinite significance, purpose, and grace. Young people will not settle for less. Neither should we.
More Than Meeting Needs
Osmer’s challenges to the mainline churches about youth ministry remind us that what makes ministry matter to young people is not what the church does, but what the church is: an embodiment of a story of life-rattling significance, a body that not only makes room for young people but embraces them as essential limbs. Unless we start from a “worthy dream” of Christ-centered hope, churches will continue to “serve” young people with programs that “meet their needs.” We will retain our modest hopes and reasonable expectations for adolescents and the church. We will remain “spiritually innocuous.”
The last thirty years have demonstrated that this is unlikely to change when we lack the will or clarity to unwind God’s story from its entanglement in the values of North American culture. Osmer forecasts the theological turn in youth ministry by reminding us, in so many words, that the church needs young people—not to bulk up our membership, or to carry on our institutions—but to give the church a “crown to grow into,” as Howard Thurman called it. Osmer believed this is a higher calling than the one churches have settled for. As Osmer admitted, a renewed interest in youth ministry “is not going to save the mainline churches . . . What it can do is serve as an avenue into these broad and complex issues” that challenge the identity and purpose of the church itself. May it be so.
Bibliography
Beck, Ulrich, and Elisabeth Beck-Gernsheim. Individualization: Institutionalized Individualism and Its Social and Political Consequences. Translated by Patrick Camiller. London: Sage, 2002.
Cummings-Bond, Stuart. “The One-Eared Mickey Mouse Model of Youth Ministry.” Youthworker (1989), 76–78.
Dean, Kenda Creasy. “Youth Ministry in Protestant, Catholic, and Jewish Religious Youth Organizations.” White paper. New York: Carnegie Council on Adolescent Development, 1991.
Lipka, Michael, and David McClendon. “Why People with No Religion Are Projected to Decline as a Share of the World’s Population.” Pew Research Center, April 7, 2017, accessed January 28, 2018. http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2017/04/07/why-people-with-no-religion-are-projected-to-decline-as-a-share-of-the-worlds-population/.
Little, Sara. “Introduction.” Affirmation 2 (1989), i–xvi.
———. Youth, World and Church. Richmond: Westminster John Knox Press, 1968.
Ng, David. Youth in the Community of Disciples. Valley Forge, PA: Judson, 1984.
Nichols, Sharon, and Thomas Good. America’s Teenagers: Myths and Realities: Media Images, Schooling, and the Social Costs of Careless Indifference. London: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 2004.
“Nones on the Rise.” Pew Research Center, October 9, 2012, accessed May 15, 2018. http://www.pewforum.org/2012/10/09/nones-on-the-rise/,
Osmer, Richard R. “Challenges to Youth Ministry in Mainline Congregations.” Affirmation 2 (1989) 1–26.
Rood, Lars. Bold Parenting: Raising Kids to Be More than Just Rule-Keepers. Loveland, CO: Group/Simply Youth Ministry, 2013.
Root, Andrew, and Kenda Creasy Dean. The Theological Turn in Youth Ministry. Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity, 2011.
Senter, Mark. “History of Youth Ministry Education.” Journal of Youth and Theology 12 (2014) 83.
Smith, Christian, with Melinda Denton. Soul Searching: The Religious and Spiritual Lives of American Teenagers. New York: Oxford University Press, 2005.
Westerhoff, John. Will Our Children Have Faith? 3rd ed. New York: Morehouse, 2012.
Wuthnow, Robert. After the Baby Boomers: How Twenty- and Thirty-Somethings Are Shaping the Future of American Religion. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2007.
50. See Dean, “Youth Ministry,” n.p.
51. For example, Mark Senter has written: “Youth ministry has always been a transaction between young people themselves or caring adults and young people they perceive to be in need.” See Senter,“History of Youth Ministry Education,” 83. I disagree with the sweeping nature of this statement—much that happens in youth ministry is neither transactional nor necessarily a reaction to young people being “in need”—but Senter’s description is an accurate observation of a common perception about youth ministry, especially in evangelical circles. Osmer uses the language of “needs” in adolescents primarily developmentally.
52. There were rare but notable exceptions to this pattern; cf. Little, Youth, World and Church; Ng, Youth in the Community of Disciples.
53. Little, “Introduction.”
54. The first book to describe this turn was Root and Dean, The Theological Turn in Youth Ministry. The book’s dedication to Richard R. Osmer and Roland Martinson acknowledges their seminal roles in approaching youth ministry theologically.
55. Osmer, “Challenges to Youth Ministry,” 5, 6, 7.
56. I see this as augmenting rather than replacing the evangelical thrust that characterized twentieth-century youth ministry’s evangelical roots.
57. Sociologist Robert Wuthnow, for example, posits demographic and social factors as contributing to young people’s declining presence in churches, including delayed marriage, fewer children born later in life, uncertain economic stability, more higher education, declining civic participation, loose social connections, and the proliferation of options thanks to the internet and globalization. See Wuthnow, After the Baby Boomers.
58. Osmer, “Challenges to Youth Ministry,” 7.
59. Ibid., 6.
60. Ibid.
61. Ibid.
62. Ibid., 7.
63. Ibid.
64. For a discussion of God-images of teenagers who are moralistic therapeutic deists, see Smith with Denton, Soul Searching, 165.
65. Ibid, 171.
66. See Rood, Bold Parenting. “Sober Virgins” is the topic of chapter 4.
67. Pew Research Center, “Nones on the Rise,” par 1–6. See also Lipka and McClendon, “Why People with No Religion,” par 3.
68. Smith with Denton, Soul Searching, 168.
69. Osmer, “Challenges to Youth Ministry,” 10.
70. Ibid., 3.
71. Ibid., 3.
72. Nichols and Good, America’s Teenagers, 246–48.
73. Cummings-Bond, “The One-Eared Mickey Mouse,” 76–78.
74. See Beck and Beck-Gernsheim, Individualization, 203.
75. Early in his career, Osmer plainly questioned the “theological integrity” of parachurch and independent Christian organizations, a position he later softened, particularly in relationship to Young Life.
76. Osmer, “Challenges to Youth Ministry,” 4.
77. Ibid.
78. Ibid, 9.
79. Ibid, 13.
80. The influence of John Westerhoff’s book Will Our Children Have Faith? on North American Christian educators in the 1980s is evident here, as Osmer uses Westerhoff’s paradigm to describe the trajectory toward mature faith, moving from “experienced/received” faith through “searching” faith during adolescence to “owned” or mature faith as an adult. See chapter four of Weserhoff, Will Our Children Have Faith?
81. Osmer, “Challenges to Youth Ministry,” 18.
82. Ibid, 15.
