Consensus and Conflict in Practical Theology: Reflections
Consensus and Conflict in Practical Theology: Reflections
I am deeply appreciative of the work that has gone into this book. Friends, colleagues, and former students have truly honored me with wonderful, evocative, and thoughtful chapters on topics that have been close to my heart over the years. I give special thanks to the editors of the project, who are located in different parts of the world. Thank you, Andy, Kenda, Mandy, and Blair for pulling this all together. And thank you, Friedrich, my longest European friend, for writing the foreword. In these dark days, it is especially important to remain in solidarity with our friends and colleagues around the world. For this reason, I also am very pleased that my former student and, now, colleague and friend, Shin-Geun Jang from South Korea, has been involved in this project. If the gospel is about God’s reconciliation of the world in Jesus Christ and we are called to be Christ’s ambassadors of reconciliation, then today we must keep our international relationships strong to resist the forces of evil that would divide us.
As I read the chapters of this book, I was reminded of the many gifts I received while teaching at Princeton Theological Seminary. Three in particular stand out. I have been very fortunate to teach at a seminary with such a long and strong tradition of practical theology. Excellent scholarship in the service of the church stood at the heart of this tradition. My wife, Sally, and I co-pastored congregations while students at Harvard and Yale, and after graduating from seminary, we co-pastored congregations in western North Carolina. While I pursued doctoral studies at Emory University, we served as pastors in large congregations in Atlanta. It always felt natural to me to think of my teaching, research, and relationships with students as a form of ministry. This was welcomed at Princeton. Many Princeton practical theologians had approached their work in this way before me. And the broader ethos of Princeton Seminary as a Reformed institution was shaped by John Calvin’s belief that professors of divinity are doctors of the church who should be ordained. Scholarship and teaching not only serve the ministries of the church, but are a form of ministry in their own right. My sense of vocation and the institution where I worked fit together as calling and confirmation. For this, I am deeply grateful.
Teaching at Princeton Seminary brought a second wonderful gift: my closest colleagues. These included James Loder, David Wall, and Freda Gardner, and, later, Kenda Creasy Dean, Gordon Mikoski, and Bo Karen Lee. Kenda, Gordon, Bo, and I forged a remarkably collaborative relationship over the years. I was reminded of this especially as I read the chapters of this book by former doctoral students. While I advised the dissertations of a number of these students at PTS, I see the influence of Kenda, Gordon, and Bo in their chapters and, even more, in their vocations. None of these students were my students; they always were our students. This sort of close collaboration was a part of all our work in education and formation and was a special gift in my time at Princeton Seminary.
Reading this book also has made me aware of how fortunate I was to teach in a setting with such wonderful students in all degree programs. This was a third gift of my time in Princeton. I learned from students every bit as much as they learned from me. They challenged and extended my thinking. They forced me to become clearer about what I was trying to say and to take account of the wide range of cultural and ecclesial contexts they represented. Over the years, I came to think of teaching as dialogue. Looking back, I would have to say that learning through teaching supported my scholarship as much as my own empirical research and reading. Almost all of the books I have written were preceded by courses in which I invited students to engage the subject matter along with me.
It felt very natural for me, thus, to engage the chapters of this book as a kind of dialogue. I have no interest in clarifying or defending my own position on this matter or that. Rather, I want to share some of thoughts and questions evoked by the insights of authors I respect. Here are a few things that emerged in the inner dialogue prompted by my reading.
Discovering Practical Theology
The jointly-authored Introduction notes that that my journey as a professor at Princeton Seminary has included the incorporation of new subject areas over the years. I came as a professor of Christian education shaped by my work as a pastor and by my doctoral work at Emory under the tutelage of James Fowler, Charles Gerkin, and Rod Hunter. While at PTS, I later entered the Kairos School of Spiritual Formation and began to include courses that incorporated spiritual companioning: “Spiritual Guidance through the Lifecycle,” “Spiritual Awakening Movements,” and “Introduction to Spirituality and Missional Formation.” Later, at my initiative, I formally gave up my chair in Christian education to become the Ralph B. and Helen S. Ashenfelter Professor of Mission and Evangelism. That journey provides the structure of this book.
The authors are quite insightful to set my engagement of these different ministries against the backdrop of changes taking place in mainline Protestantism. The precipitous decline of mainline congregations during the second half of the twentieth century has, indeed, made the engagement of spirituality and evangelism more important than ever. The Introduction’s authors also note that a constant drumbeat throughout my writing and teaching has been my engagement of practical theology. Why has the practical theology discussion been so important over the course of my career?
As I thought about this question, I was taken back to my own theological education. I studied for two years at Harvard Divinity School, mainly at the Center for the Study of World Religions, although I took four very important courses from Rosemary Radford Reuther and Juan Luis Segundo, who were visiting scholars. My wife, Sally, also was a student at Harvard. After two years, we transferred to Yale Divinity School to complete our Masters of Divinity degrees. While at Yale, I took a number of courses in which Karl Barth was prominent. My future colleague George Hunsinger was the TA in several of these courses, and he was a brilliant interpreter of Barth even as a PhD student. However, I took only one course at Yale that attempted to integrate theology and practice: “Pastor, Prophet, and Priest,” which brought case material from our student placements into dialogue with theology. At Yale, preaching was taught by a person without a background in theology, and pastoral care and counseling were approached from the perspective of the psychology of religion. The professor of Christian Education was known for such poor pedagogy that nobody took his courses—including me. Other courses in “area four” (the so-called application area) were taught by adjunct professors: visiting pastors and expert practitioners in areas like family therapy.
Looking back, what was missing from my education at both Harvard and Yale was any real attention to practical theology as a field of study. There was little attention to practice as a constructive source of theological knowledge, and little effort made to integrate a student’s experience across the theological disciplines. My budding interest in Barth was cordoned off from what I was learning about ministry as a student pastor. This led to a real deficit in my ability to draw on theology to guide, understand, and critique my congregations and leadership when I became a full-time pastor following graduation.
It was only upon entering the “Theology and Personality” doctoral program at Emory that I first encountered practical theology as a field of study. Chuck Gerkin, Rod Hunter, and Jim Fowler were major players in the practical theology discussion emerging during the 1980s when I was a doctoral student. In one of Hunter’s courses, I was introduced to models of pastoral care, examining the ways theology and practice might be brought into conversation along different lines. Hunter also offered a course on the wisdom literature of the Bible, exploring a tradition of knowledge crafted to evoke wise judgments in particular circumstances. Rod believed that we might find clues here about the kind of theological knowledge constructed in practical theology.
Gerkin taught the doctoral seminar on practical theology and a course on Eric Fromm. I resonated strongly with his extensive use of case study material. This approach was prominent in the Clinical Pastoral Education movement in which Gerkin was a leader before beginning his teaching career at Emory. I had learned the case study method during a CPE intern year at Norwich State Hospital, a psychiatric facility for long-term and acute patients. While Gerkin was writing his classic book The Living Human Document, I worked as his research assistant. His approach to practical theology had a lasting impact on my understanding of this field, especially his dialogue with Jürgen Moltmann.
My relationship with Jim Fowler was more complex. Jim’s research in Stages of Faith catapulted him onto the international stage of education, moral philosophy, and developmental psychology. Throughout the apex of his fame, Jim was a warm and caring mentor to me. He offered personal support and guidance, demanded academic rigor, and opened many, many doors. For example, when our second child arrived and my wife decided to step down as a pastor in a large church in north Atlanta, Jim made it possible for me to support our family financially by serving as the assistant director of research in the Center for Faith Development.
The Formation of a Practical Theologian: Emerging Trajectories, Enduring Questions
I have no doubt that my education as a doctoral student at Emory shaped my life-long interest in practical theology. It opened up trajectories that I continue to explore, and posed questions I still ponder. Looking back, I can identify its impact along four lines. First, my graduate education introduced me to practical theology as a field with a history and research focus. Rod Hunter in particular constantly pressed the question of the constructive contribution of the field. If practical theology does more than apply the research of the other theological disciplines to congregations, what is its constructive contribution to the larger theological enterprise and to public life? Gerkin and Hunter gave epistemic weight to practice in answering this question. Certain knowledge emerges from reflective practice that cannot be gained in any other way. Fowler focused on the empirical dimension of practical theology, not only teaching me how to carry out qualitative research, but also introducing me to the robust European discussion of empirical research in practical theology exemplified in the work of Johannes van der Ven and others. This went a long way toward helping me identify the unique contribution of practical theology as a field. My formation by Gerkin and Hunter, who taught pastoral care, and Fowler, who taught Christian education, also provided me with the important insight that practical theology can be a meeting place for the sub-disciplines of Christian education, pastoral care, preaching, leadership, and evangelism.
Second, my time as a doctoral student introduced me to the importance of engaging fundamental theological issues that are inherent to the work of practical theology. Although I didn’t realize it at the time, I was being taught to value practical theology’s dialogue with dogmatics and Christian ethics as much as its dialogue with the social sciences. I was encouraged to read theologians like Paul Tillich, Karl Barth, David Tracy, Gustavo Gutiérrez, and Reinhold Niebuhr, as well as theological ethicists like H. Richard Niebuhr and Paul Lehmann. Jürgen Moltmann was a visiting scholar while I was a doctoral student at Emory, and I had the good fortune of attending some of his classes. Moltmann would prove to become the most important dogmatic theologian I would engage for most of my career. His influence on my work is under-represented in this book, only appearing in the chapter by Shin-Geun Jang. It is Moltmann who represents best, I believe, what transversal rationality looks like in the interdisciplinary work of theology, repeatedly altering his dialogue partners as he takes up different doctrines. Moltmann provided me with theological frameworks for Practical Theology: An Introduction (for example, his inclusion of Jesus as sage in his creative reworking of the threefold office of Christ) and The Teaching Ministry of Congregations (especially his understanding of God’s dealings with the world as a comprehensive narrative with various divine and human actors, which I recast as theo-drama).
Third, as a doctoral student, I was encouraged to think of practical theology as inherently inter- and multi-disciplinary. At Emory, I took courses on John Dewey from John Gowanlock in the philosophy department, and studied human development with Margaret Beale Spencer and Laurie Adamson in the psychology department. I also had the very good fortune of taking a doctoral seminar on Marx, Weber, and Durkheim from sociologist Steven Tipton, one of the primary authors of the then-newly released Habits of the Heart. I took comprehensive exams in psychology and social science and was constantly encouraged by Fowler, Gerkin, and Hunter to reflect explicitly on interdisciplinary method in theology in dialogue with Tillich and Tracy, as well as practical theologians like Don Browning, Rebecca Chopp, Sallie McFague, and Matthew Lamb. This fascination with interdisciplinarity would become a career-long interest that was deepened substantially at Princeton Seminary through regular opportunities to team-teach a doctoral seminar with my colleague Wentzel van Huyssteen, the James McCord Professor of Theology and Science.
Fourth, my relationships with Fowler, Hunter, and Gerkin opened up relationships to colleagues in the practical theology discussion. Through Hunter, for example, I met Seward Hiltner, and through Gerkin, John Patton. Fowler encouraged me to participate in the Association of Practical Theology, where I met Don Browning, who became a generous mentor, inviting me to participate in several multi-authored books. In the Association of Practical Theology, I first met young practical theologians from the University of Chicago, Garrett-Evangelical Seminary, Princeton Theological Seminary, and Claremont School of Theology who would later become leaders in the field: Pam Couture, Bonnie McLemore-Miller, James Poling, Mary Elizabeth and Allen Moore, Daniel Schipani, and others. While at Princeton, my relationship to Fowler opened the door to collaboration with Hans van der Ven, Don Browning, Camil Ménard, Dietriech Roessler, Riet Bons-Storm, Friedrich Schweitzer, and Karl Ernst Nipkow in order to establish the International Academy of Practical Theology. In particular, this collaboration led to a long-term friendship and partnership with Friedrich Schweitzer that led to three books and parallel studies on confirmation in Europe and the United States.
In short, I learned as a doctoral student that practical theology is a fully academic, research-oriented field with dialogue partners in philosophy, the human sciences, and the other theological disciplines. I wrote a (very) long dissertation in which I approached Christian education as a form of practical theology. It is little wonder that I continued to think in terms of practical theology as I began to focus on Christian spirituality and evangelism later in my career.
How My Thinking on Practical Theology Has Changed
In recent years, my continuing interest in practical theology has focused on evangelism, church planting, and mission. I have been surprised that very few scholars draw on the practical theology discussion to think about evangelism and even fewer approach this field with a serious engagement of dogmatic theology. I count myself very fortunate to have had a colleague and friend at Princeton Seminary who engaged both fields: Darrell Guder. Before coming to PTS, Darrell taught evangelism in two seminaries and authored some of the very best books on this practice of ministry. He situates evangelism within a broader discussion of the missio Dei, the mission of God, and changes taking place in Christianity across North America. He argues—rightly, I believe—that one of the best theologians to have explored evangelism is Karl Barth. With George and Deborah Hunsinger as two of my closest colleagues on the Princeton Seminary faculty, I had additional Barthian dialogue partners close at hand. At the time I began seriously exploring evangelism through the lens of practical theology, two doctoral students I was advising, Nate Stucky and Blair Bertrand (both of whom have chapters in this book) were drawing extensively on Barth in their dissertations. The three of us, along with Tom Hastings (also a contributor to this volume), began to share our writings and discuss Barth on an ongoing basis.
This recent encounter with Barth has led me to rethink some of the ways I have written about practical theology in the past. When I wrote Practical Theology, I was trying to offer “An Introduction,” as the subtitle indicates. I focused on some of the key tasks that contemporary practical theologians pursue in their work. While all writing is situated, I tried not to advocate my own theological perspective at that point (Jürgen Moltmann) or my favorite dialogue partners in the human sciences (sociology and psychology). I hoped to introduce readers to a variety of perspectives and potential resources.
The book remains a helpful introduction. As I have focused more of my thinking on evangelism in dialogue with Barth, the way I think about practical theology has changed. I share here a brief summary of my current thinking.
1. I believe it is important for practical theologians to foreground their substantive theological convictions in their research and writing. This is particularly the case in reflecting on evangelism, which draws such highly charged positive and negative responses. Today, I find especially helpful Barth’s understanding of election and reconciliation, which shapes his missional ecclesiology. Evangelism within this framework is one form of the church’s witness, which encompasses the saying, doing, and being of the gospel in the service of God’s reconciliation of the world in Jesus Christ.300 Indeed, all forms of ministry participate in God’s mission of reconciliation. The ministry of practical theology is to study, critique, and guide the missional witness of congregations in particular times and places.
2. An important assumption of my approach to practical theology today is the priority of ontology over epistemology. The being God determines our knowing of God. This is grounded in what many scholars call Barth’s “actualism,” a set of interlocking claims: God has God’s being in God’s acts; there is no hidden God behind the God revealed in the incarnation, life, death, resurrection, and ascension of Jesus Christ; our knowledge of God should take its bearings from God’s self-giving in Christ. The modern and postmodern habit of starting with what we can or cannot know is reversed. We can know God only as God gives Godself to us, and this has taken place in a unique and unsurpassable way in Jesus Christ.
3. Without spelling it out in detail, I believe Barth’s christocentric trinitarianism has important implications for the way we carry out theology. It bids us to give special attention to Scripture, for here God’s reconciliation of the world in Jesus Christ is narrated and reflected on in the context of the story of Israel. Moreover, the inclusion of four, not one, Gospels in the canon, as well as Luke’s story of the early Christian mission and a range of letters to congregations in diverse contexts (including Revelation’s letters to the seven churches and vision of a new heaven and earth) orients us to the source and task of theology. The diverse material of Scripture is the source of our most important knowledge of God, telling us who God is, how God has acted in the past, and what God’s people are called to do and be. Over the centuries, Scripture has been handed down and rehearsed in worship, studied in teaching, and used to comfort and criticize God’s people prophetically. This is the task of theology in all its forms: to bring to mind the God attested in Scripture so that God’s people might worship and serve the Lord in their own time and place. This is not merely a matter of repeating what theologians of the past have said. Nor is it simply a matter of finding the one, true “biblical” position on this matter or that. Rather, it is a matter of listening to Scripture as God’s living Word that addresses God’s people again and again in new times and places.
4. The centrality of Scripture’s witness to God—the center of which is God-with-us in Jesus Christ—leads me to underscore practical theology’s dialogue with various forms of theology that have emerged across the centuries to guide and criticize the church in its worship and service of God. Today, I give priority to practical theology’s dialogue with Christian biblical studies, dogmatic theology, church history, and Christian ethics over its dialogue with philosophy and science. The latter remain indispensable dialogue partners in understanding our context and world. But we should not expect them to be as important to our constructive work in practical theology as the study of Scripture, the doctrines and history of the church, and Christian ethics. Moving beyond correlational models of practical theology and discovering how to engage the other theological disciplines is one of the most important challenges facing practical theology today.
5. My work on evangelism has led me to ask basic questions anew. What is the gospel? What does it mean for the church to bear witness to the gospel? How is the church’s mission related to God’s mission? The more basic these kinds of questions have become, the more I have found it necessary to learn from the other theological disciplines. Much of my most recent thinking about evangelism centers on gaining a better understanding of God’s reconciliation of the world in Jesus Christ. At its most basic, evangelism in the New Testament is the announcement of good news. Jesus announces the good news of the dawning of God’s kingdom in his words and works. Paul announce the good news of Christ’s death and resurrection to all people because he believes it alters the situation of all people.
6. Following Barth, I emphasize Scripture’s portrait of God’s reconciliation of the world in Jesus Christ as an accomplished reality that is universal in scope. Christ dies that all might be pardoned. Christ lives in perfect faithfulness to God that all might be raised to new life in him. The objectivity of God’s reconciliation is followed by its subjective appropriation by persons and communities at different times and places. But the soteriological moment is not when persons make a “decision for Christ.” Scripture is clear that reconciliation is God’s doing, and it has taken place in the events of Christ’s life, death, and resurrection. That is the soteriological moment. Our subjective appropriation of this accomplished reality, moreover, does not follow one experiential pattern in all times and places. Paul’s dramatic conversion is one way this takes place. But Peter’s (and the disciples’) slow unfolding journey toward recognition of Jesus as Savior and Lord is another. Persons and communities, like the Galatian church, may be persuaded to follow a different gospel and need to be re-evangelized. Evangelism is sharing the good news of the gospel. How people respond should not be forced into a cookie-cutter pattern, which ultimately is not Scriptural and overemphasizes human agency as the instrument of salvation.
7. I have come to believe that Lesslie Newbigin is right when he writes that the congregation represents the first hermeneutic of the gospel.301 It is in the shared life of a concrete community of disciples that people first see and hear what is at stake in the gospel. My way of putting this is to say that the congregation is the first evangelist. If the gospel is the good news of God’s reconciliation of the world in Jesus Christ, then congregations must become a reconciled and reconciling people in order to bear witness to the gospel. Congregations must embody a spirituality of reconciliation in their life together, and they must engage the world as a people committed to reconciliation. Barth aptly describes congregations’ engagement of the world as a “revolt against the disorder” of the lordless powers.302 In championing the Prince of Peace, congregations disturb the false peace that normalizes enmity, war, oppression, ethno-nationalism, racism, economic injustice, and violence. As reconciling communities, they stand in solidarity with the world, even as they stand against the world, for the world is loved by God, has been reconciled to God in Christ, and is moving toward the day when this reality will be revealed to all.
8. Evangelism is sharing the gospel of reconciliation with others. It takes place in many different ways: in conversations in families, in relationships at work or with friends, in small groups that welcome seekers, lapsed Christians, or people in crisis, and in one-with-one relationships. The approaches and models of evangelism will change. They are context-dependent. They are not as important as the substance of the gospel that is shared and the ways the gospel is embodied in the life and mission of congregations as reconciled and reconciling communities. Research indicates that mainline Protestant congregations do not engage in much evangelism. This is deeply troubling. The gospel is good news—the very best news possible. Did the mainline lose touch with the gospel somewhere along the way? Do its members prefer niceness and low commitment to the life-giving but demanding transformation inherent to learning a way of life that requires forgiveness, confrontation, deep learning, mutual sacrifice, and identification with the pain of the world? Is the evangelism deficit in the mainline really a gospel deficit? If so, then what might practical theologians have to say to this situation?
Consensus and Conflict: An Appreciative Dialogue
This brief outline of some of the ways my thinking about evangelism have shaped my current understanding of practical theology provides a backdrop to my response to the chapters that come after the Introduction of this book. I view this as a dialogue in which I have much to learn, just as I gained so much from the students I taught at PTS. What I have to share in response is shaped by my thinking in the present more than what I have written in the past.
The Educator: Forming the Faithful
The first section, The Educator: Forming the Faithful, includes three chapters that exemplify the importance of biblical and theological reflection on the ministries of faith formation in the church. These chapters also invite us to recognize that the renewal and transformation of the church is likely to emerge from unlikely sources: children, young people, and newcomers.
Amanda Drury’s beautifully written chapter explores the use of fantasy literature in imagining alternate worlds, especially the strange new world of the kingdom of God. As she puts it: “Children’s fantasy literature tills the soil for the kingdom of God—it allows the kingdom of God to germinate through 1) calming the watchful dragons of myopic realism, 2) opening our ears to the testimony of children and 3) awakening within us a moral imagination to envision a new world.” Drawing on Scripture, she reminds us that more than once Jesus pointed to children to teach adults what it means to enter the kingdom of God. So too, we must consider, not only the ways fantasy literature might form the imagination of children, but also, the importance of the imagination in the discipleship formation of youth and adults.
For most of my life, Christian education has over-emphasized cognitive/moral/faith development and critical reflection. We are challenged here to reconsider. Imagination is not something we leave behind as we grow and develop. It remains important to all forms of creativity. Mandy invites us to consider more deeply how we might engage the imaginations of children, youth, and adults in order to help them see their lives and world differently, from the perspective of God’s kingdom. Jesus’ most characteristic form of teaching used parables to this end. How might we engage the imagination in analogous ways today?
I have experienced Kenda Dean’s magic before and have seen her use it on others. One part emerging insight; two parts Kenda’s thinking and creativity; voilò, something wonderful and interesting suddenly appears. This is what I experienced when reading her chapter on my contribution to the theological turn in youth ministry. This turn is something Kenda and Andy Root are especially well-known for, but I suspect all of the Timothy Scholars303 are contributors to this movement in different ways. The chapter explores why it is not adequate to focus exclusively on young people’s “needs” and to think of Christian ministry primarily as meeting these needs—a common pattern when psychology or cultural interpretation dominate practical theology. The more important task is discerning God’s mission and forming young people to participate in this mission as part of a community of disciples.
Among the many issues raised by this chapter, one is especially important to practical theology: How do we bring theology into conversation with other fields that are helpful in understanding the psychological, biological, and cultural contexts of teens and young adults? Focusing exclusively on their needs is not adequate. But ignoring their context and stage of life is not adequate either. Kenda’s Wesleyan tradition offers a rich resource to reflect on these kinds of interdisciplinary issues, the so-called Wesleyan quadrilateral, which portrays Scripture, tradition, experience, and reason as sources of knowledge of God.304 The relative weight granted to each of these sources is subject to debate. I am hopeful that the movement Kenda and others are championing will continue to take up the full range of theological issues involved in practical theology—from methodology to empirical research to good practice. As the chapter points out so nicely, every issue of importance to theology is at stake in the church’s work with young people.
Jessicah Krey Duckworth’s chapter on catechesis invites us to consider the relationship between formation and Christian education. Formation takes place through learning and participating in the practices of the Christian community, which embody a way of life. Christian education affords opportunities to learn the meaning of these practices, to pose questions about them, and to change them when they are no longer responsive to people’s lived experience and lose the capacity to bring them into a relationship with the living God. As Jessicah points out, formation and education were both present in the catechesis of the early Christian community, which provides us a kind of norm of good practice: “A dynamic catechesis seeks to interpret the heart of the gospel in light of concrete situations and experiences within the contemporary community of faith in order to facilitate encounter with Jesus Christ.” She develops this further in dialogue with the theologian Mary Solberg’s interpretation of Luther’s theology of the cross.
Luther’s portrait of the Christian life emphasized the “ever new” reception of God’s grace. It is not the “more and more” of growth in faith; it is the “ever again” of faith that returns to and depends on God’s grace afresh every morning because it is God’s free gift that is received in its totality day by day—like manna in the wilderness. Jessicah is subtly relocating the entire practices discussion in this theological framework. She does so by sharing examples of catechesis involving children and newcomers in the faith community. Both represent those who “don’t know,” who are situated at the moment of receiving from others. But their receiving is a giving, for their questions and wondering invite adults and long-term members to begin again at the start and see things afresh. This is how the church is renewed, as grace is mediated through those who stand at the beginning and edges of the Christian way of life and remind long-time members that they must become like little children and new members if they are to receive anew the gift of God’s love upon which they always depend.
The Spiritual Director: Testing the Spirit
I have the advantage of reading the chapters of this book after they were written. This allows me to see the three chapters of the second section, The Spiritual Director: Testing the Spirit, as fitting together. Angela Reed focuses on spiritual companioning; Nathan Stucky, on the theological presuppositions of the modern missionary movement during the colonial period as they continue to impact theological education. Too often, spirituality is viewed as inward-looking, focusing exclusively in the spiritual life of the individual, and mission as outward-looking, focusing on social change. As Bo Karen Lee shares in the last chapter of this section, our teaching in the Spirituality and Mission track in Education and Formation at Princeton Seminary has led us to view spirituality and mission as interrelated. You can’t think about companioning ministries without also thinking about mission. You can’t think about mission without also thinking about the spirituality of the church shaping the Christian imagination. It is helpful, thus, to read the three chapters together.
Angela Reed defines spiritual companioning as “a way of accompanying others in intentional relationships of prayerful reflection and conversation that help them notice God’s presence and calling in their personal lives, local communities, and the world.” By definition, thus, spiritual companioning pays attention to calling, the particular task or vocation persons are given by God. The context of this calling is their personal life, the community in which they live, and the broader needs of the world. Spirituality, thus, is not primarily a matter of personal benefit and psychological growth—though these may follow. It involves paying attention to the living God with the help of another person to discern the vocation God is calling a person to do and be.
Angela is somewhat unique in approaching the field of spirituality in terms of practical theology. Focusing on the case of Jason, she explores how this perspective might help us understand the kind of companioning Jason’s spiritual direction group offered him as he worked through the loss of his father. She raises questions about the normative dimensions of spiritual companioning: the adequacy of Jason’s image of God and the congruence of his beliefs, experience, and feelings. She also indicates that the congregation is the proper context of spiritual companioning, for it is only one practice among many that form persons in the Christian way of life, a life that includes “witness and service.” She also raises one of the most important insights of contemporary practical theology: practice has epistemic weight. Learning through practice and studying practice is a source of knowledge that practical theology offers to the larger theological enterprise. How to conceptualize this source of knowledge in relation to Scripture, tradition, and the knowledge of the human sciences remains an important challenge for cotemporary practical theology.
Nate Stucky’s chapter embodies beautifully what Barth calls the church’s revolt against the disorder of the lordless powers.305 Drawing on Willie Jennings’s The Christian Imagination, Nate presses us to engage in a “deep exploration of the genesis of colonialism and the advent of racial logic.” He notes that Jennings argues that “the colonial moment—the moment when racial logic and destruction spread like cancer throughout the world—that moment depended on and grew out of a division between human identity and land in the mind of the colonizer.” Jennings traces the way theological ideas like supercessionism, papal infallibility, and apostolic succession “bloat the church’s sense of itself” and create a Christian imagination that sets the stage for the modern missionary movement in which “the colonizer becomes the (white) norm of Christ-likeness; and all lands and peoples are subject to the dominion and judgment of the colonizer.” Nate raises a simple but fundamental counter-question: How did Christ enter the world?
Some would say the world longed for a conquering emperor—a display of force that would set the world aright. Instead, the all-powerful Creator of the universe comes as an infant child to an unwed teen mother with livestock and lowly shepherds keeping watch. The Lord of the universe comes to a particular land, a particular time, and a particular place, and before engaging any public ministry spends decades learning. Jesus learns the language, the culture and customs, the land and geography, the food and the festivals, and only after these decades of simply being native to his place does he begin a public ministry.306
The chapter ends by returning to issues raised at the beginning. How do the presuppositions of colonialism continue to shape the Christian imagination informing theological education, and what contribution might new ventures, like the Farminary, make to breaking its logic?
Bo Karen Lee’s chapter shares some of the thinking that went into the creation of the Spirituality and Mission track in Education and Formation at Princeton Seminary. She gives me far too much credit. At every step, her gifts as a historian and theologian of spirituality complemented my background in practical theology and Christian education. When I described the wonderful gift of a collaborative relationship with my closest colleagues at PTS, I certainly had Bo in mind. We were determined to bring spirituality and mission together. As Bo notes, I have sometimes drawn on David Bosch’s concept of the church as a two-pointed ellipse in which the upbuilding and sending of congregations are both important. Practical theology informed by this ecclesiology necessarily holds spirituality and mission together and seeks to discover and nurture the deep connections between these constitutive elements of the church.
Bo helps us see why it is important to read Angela’s chapter and Nate’s together. Spiritual companioning cannot be done well without attending to the particularities of person, story, place, and events—as we see in the case of Jason. Yet, these particularities are always interpreted against the backdrop of the church’s understanding of its mission: its calling to worship and serve God in the world. As Nate’s chapter makes so clear, we still inhabit an imagination shaped by colonialism, which is perfectly comfortable with a spirituality focusing on individuals who are not challenged to confront the logic of racism, power, and privilege embedded in the imagination of the church. Discovering deep connections between new, post-colonial understandings of mission and life-shaping spiritual formation is one of the most important contributions practical theology can make in the coming decades.
The Evangelist: Sharing God’s Good News
The third section, The Evangelist: Sharing God’s Good News, is composed of three chapters that place evangelism in comprehensive theological frameworks. This is absolutely crucial to reimagining evangelism today. We cannot take it for granted that we know what evangelism is, for much of the thinking and practice of this ministry took shape during the colonial period and is limited by the kinds of distortions Nate Stucky pointed to in the previous section. We must think anew about sharing the gospel in dialogue with contemporary biblical scholars, dogmatic theologians, and good practice—as we see in this section.
No one has influenced my understanding of evangelism more than Darrell Guder, and I thank him for his generous colleagueship during the years I taught evangelism at PTS. If I left seminary many years ago ill-equipped to relate Karl Barth’s theology to my ministry, Darrell has provided great help in overcoming this lacuna in the latter years of my teaching. His chapter represents an amazingly fine overview of missional theology shaped by Barth’s perspective. Since I agree with so much of what he says here, I simply want to highlight some of the ways this chapter contributes to the current discussion of practical theology.
First and most importantly, Darrell makes it clear that, in the end, how we define the nature, purpose, and methods of practical theology must be shaped our substantive theological commitments. Of course, it is possible to define practical theology as a field and write general introductions, but the real work of practical theology takes place in the context of committed and articulated theological convictions about God, the church, salvation, and so forth. We need to acknowledge this and claim it. We are doing theology, not simply talking about theology. The missional theology articulated in the chapter represents the kind of theological work we should be doing.
Second, Darrell, like Barth, points to the damaging effects of the silo mentality in modern theology. His chapter embodies what it looks like to bring dogmatic theology, biblical studies, church history, and practical theology into conversation. Third, he implies, but does not fully develop, a key challenge in this dialogue: How and why do we choose certain dialogue partners in theology and not others? Biblical studies, today, for example is highly pluralistic. Darrell gives examples near the end of his chapter of the ways Paul’s letters were written to form his congregations for mission. In other writings, he draws on the work of biblical scholars to spell out more fully what it means to approach Scripture with a missional hermeneutic. This has been a topic of discussion in a working group at the American Academy of Religion for several years. Practical theologians need to participate in discussions like this in order to make informed choices about contemporary biblical criticism. How should they negotiate historical, literary, rhetorical, feminist, theological, social science, and other approaches to Scripture?
Finally, Darrell mentions at several points the misleading ways the dichotomy between theory and practice is used to characterize the tasks of theology. This is particularly pernicious when practical theology is assigned the role of application, as if it did not contribute research and theory in its own right. But an important question remains, and it must be pressed to those of us influenced by Barth: what does practice actually contribute to the constructive work of theology? When we practice and study evangelism in particular contexts, for example, how does this shape our understanding of mission or witness or Barth’s twelve forms of ministry/service? Do we learn from practice? If so, how do we describe its contribution? More work is needed on this issue.
My long-time friend and colleague Tom Hastings also offers an extended example of the way practical theology engages biblical studies, church history, and confessional tradition in reimagining the central practices of the faith community. Tom first engages Walter Brueggemann, who portrays the writings of the Old Testament in terms of three distinct kinds of literature that represent different ways of knowing and following God: (1) the intergenerational transmission of the Torah by the priests, (2) the disruptive announcement of judgment and hope by the prophets, who call for justice in the community, and (3) the education of individuals for wise judgment in everyday life by the sages, who also help the community to face up to the mystery of God’s ways. Tom argues that this threefold pattern is appropriated and transformed by the early church in ministries of worship, witness, and wonder. He moves on to explore how these ministries were continued in the catechetical instruction of the Reformation period and their continuing viability today. He concludes by making a constructive proposal in which worshipping, witnessing, and wondering are central. Evangelism finds its proper context within this broader framework. This is a splendid example of constructive work in practical theology in dialogue with a range of theological disciplines.
As a former professor of evangelism at Wesley Theological Seminary and prominent pastoral leader in the United Methodist Church, Drew Dyson helps us see how the study of practice and theological construction go hand in hand. Drew made a highly persuasive case in his dissertation that John Wesley was the first missional theologian of the post-Reformation period. In this chapter, he turns his attention to three congregations’ ministries of evangelism with emerging adults, concluding that a missional ecclesiology “awakens” emerging adults to faith and offers meaningful participation in faith communities. He draws out three threads of theological commitment discovered in these settings: “a clear understanding of individual and corporate Christian vocation, or purposeful work; a strong sense of identity and belonging within the community of faith; and a posture of radical openness and hospitality to the community beyond the church.” These threads do not add up to a model or program that can imitated elsewhere. Rather, they are strands of missional ecclesiology that take on the hues of very particular faith communities located in different contexts.
Drew’s chapter complements nicely the two other chapters in this section and goes a long way toward answering the question of the contribution of practice to the constructive work of practical theology. The study of practice provides us with cases of good practice that help us imagine how ministry in other contexts might be reformed. Moreover, it yields knowledge that poses questions to our colleagues in other fields of theology. Are their ecclesiologies sufficiently attentive to vocation, belonging, and radical hospitality? If not, then perhaps they should think again, for Drew has found these to be especially salient to ministry with emerging adults today, a group at risk of departing the church altogether.
The Practical Theologian: Legacy and Promise
The final section, The Practical Theologian: Legacy and Promise, draws attention to my ongoing interest in practical theology—from my work as a pastor while at Harvard and Yale to my doctoral studies at Emory to my most recent thinking about evangelism. These chapters take up issues of methodology in practical theology. Focusing on methodology exclusively and ad nauseum is problematic. But it is helpful while actually doing constructive work and even necessary in our age of intellectual pluralism. I have been especially blessed by thoughtful colleagues like Gordon Mikoski and excellent students, who later became colleagues, like Blair Bertrand, Andy Root, and Shin-Geun Jang, who took to methodological issues from the very beginning of their time at Princeton Seminary. I am pleased to dialogue with their thinking again.
Blair’s chapter rightly locates me in the Reformed tradition and sets forth beautifully many of the ways this tradition has shaped my thinking. I am very much a Presbyterian pastor and theologian. I was raised in a southern Presbyterian church offering me excellent catechesis up to and beyond confirmation. Blair traces this influence on my work, not to pigeonhole me, but to raise the broader issue of the way traditions shape scholarship. He asks if this should be taken into account more fully in my depictions of “metatheoretical” issues in practical theology. Blair raises a number of important questions, and I can only take up one here: the relationship between theological tradition and what I have called theological rationale.
In light of what Blair writes, I am inclined to agree that tradition is a very good way of characterizing the entire cluster of decisions people make about metatheoretical issues and the way they “hang together” in a person’s actual work. Concepts like “paradigms” and “research programs” have been used in similar ways. Tradition, however, is less restrictive and serves this purpose better. When used to reflect on practical theology, it would allow us to point, not only to higher-order metatheoretical decisions informing our constructive work as scholars, but also to other dimensions of our formation, like our emotions and habits of practice and thinking, that continue to shape our current work. As many have pointed out, it makes little sense to separate rationality from our bodies, dispositions, and history. Tradition is a helpful way for practical theologians to give an account of themselves as embodied beings.
I am not persuaded, however, that we need to abandon the concept of rationale to make this move. In passing, I should note that my brief comments on metatheoretical decisions in practical theology have always been highly tentative. While I point to four kinds of issues, I have never claimed that only these four are important. Rather, they are offered as examples of the kinds of decisions practical theologians make—often implicitly—as they engage in more focused work. If Blair develops a way of thinking about tradition that clarifies why certain metatheoretical issues need special attention, it may be beneficial to think in terms of overlapping and interacting traditions. Practical theology today is highly pluralistic, and one of its strengths since Vatican II is its ecumenicity—Catholics and Protestants in dialogue. From Wentzel van Huyssteen, I learned to view dialogue in pluralistic fields through the lens of “reflective equilibrium”: looking across a field at a certain point in time and articulating what we have in common, as well as our differences. The reality of different traditions in conversation persuades me that something like the category of rationale might continue to be helpful.
Personally, I believe substantive theological commitments should be brought forward to ground one’s understanding of practical theology. I am aware that not everyone works this way; many provide a rationale for their work in terms of the substantive concepts of philosophical, hermeneutical, or feminist traditions and, thus, work differently than I do. Moreover, many draw on theological traditions that are different than my own Reformed tradition. I do not want to argue that “all others must do as I do.” Both dispositionally and intellectually, I am not Barthian in this regard, if this means yelling a loud “No!” towards those with whom I disagree. Mutual respect, conversation across differences, and working together for the common good is badly needed in our world, and practical theology should be one of the places this is practiced. Obviously, the themes of tradition, rationale, and reflective equilibrium deserve further attention, as do many others in the fine chapter that Blair has written.
I have great respect for the highly creative and genuinely constructive work Andy Root is doing in practical theology. He has the gift of addressing both a wide reading public and scholars who are interested in highly technical methodological and theological issues. I am particularly taken with his attempt to bring practical theology into conversation with critical realism and major theological figures like Eberhard Jüngel, Søren Kierkegaard, Dietrich Bonhoeffer, and Karl Barth. He is moving in directions very close to my own. This is why it is easy for me to imagine Andy and I beginning a conversation about issues we are both exploring. In that conversation, I would raise several questions.
First, what is meant by critical realism? There are a wide variety of critical realisms present in philosophy, science, and theology. As Blair would say, it is important to locate ourselves in a particular tradition. Second, what is the relationship between critical realism and theological critical realism? At times, Andy focuses on the latter, as in his discussion of God as act and being, as event, and as ministering presence. At other points, he uses the category of critical realism more generally—which seems to make it a tertium quid, the meeting ground for theology and other fields of study. Does this run the risk of importing an “immanent” or, perhaps better, an “alien” frame and allowing it to set the terms for theology? Taking advantage of critical realism’s depiction of a stratified model of reality and refusing to turn theology into one more “level” within this account (e.g., at the foundation: Alister McGrath; at the top: Nancey Murphy and George Ellis) is one of the more challenging issues confronting theologians in dialogue with critical realism. Personally, I think addressing this issue from a theological perspective requires a forthright discussion of revelation, which I would welcome.
Third, while I agree with Andy’s attempt to locate the empirical in practical theology within a framework shaped by substantive theological convictions, I wonder if the interdisciplinary task might be more complex than he suggests. Paul Ricoeur is reported to have said of Martin Heidegger: “I agree with where he ends up but believe he gets there too quickly; a detour is necessary.”307 A kind of detour might be helpful in thinking about the location of the empirical in practical theology. It is basic to critical realism’s affirmation of a stratified model of reality that different levels of reality must be respected in order to avoid reductionism from the bottom up (explaining the discontents of civilization in terms of the individual psyche, as in Freud) or from the top down (explaining depression and suicide rates exclusively in terms of social integration, as in Durkheim). I believe this makes it impossible to think of empirical research exclusively in terms of concrete lived experience, as portrayed from the perspective of a particular view of divine and human action. Various kinds of empirical research are appropriate to the investigation of different levels of reality. Some of these are far removed from concrete, lived experience. For example, survey research appropriate to the sociological investigation of a large population can provide very helpful insight into general trends, as we see in the National Study of Youth and Religion. A complex interdisciplinary conversation is involved in practical theology’s dialogue with this sort of research, which includes assessing the reliability of the research on social scientific grounds, interpreting the implications of the data for Christian practice in diverse contexts, and appropriating the findings in terms of a framework of divine and human action—to name but a few. Andy’s chapter gives the greatest attention to the last of these, but a “detour” to other levels may be necessary in order to adequately describe practical theology’s dialogue with empirical research. (I am sure Andy has much to say in response—may the conversation continue!)
I was delighted to read Shin-Geun Jang’s chapter on Christian teaching as “Trinitarian Kenotic Praxis.” He builds on and goes beyond my own constructive work in The Teaching Ministry of Congregations, where I draw on the theology of Jürgen Moltmann more directly than in my other books. I am particularly appreciative of Shin-Geun’s ability to draw on this framework to critique and guide teaching in a South Korean church context. He embodies the very best of practical theology that is contextually sensitive and deeply theological.
I have found Moltmann’s view of trinitarian praxis helpful along three lines: (1) it takes seriously the church as a contrast community that is called to embody the kenotic love of the triune God in its shared life; (2) it portrays teaching as a form of participation in God’s praxis and, thus, as dynamic, communal, and participatory; and (3) it portrays the church as following God into the world in mission, a mission of self-giving love that cares for the human and natural world at every level of life. The emphasis is on our present participation in the life of the triune God. In terms of my current theological thinking, I cannot help but wonder if this sort of depiction of divine and human praxis adequately addresses what God and God alone has done on our behalf and in our stead. Where does the gracious work of God in the atonement fit into to this depiction of the Christian life? Where does it acknowledge the uniqueness of Christ’s life of covenant faithfulness to God, upon which our own faithfulness depends? I raise these questions in reflecting on my own appropriation of Moltmann, and they may resonate with Shin-Geun as well.
Gordon Mikoski’s chapter on my contribution to practical theology at Princeton Theological Seminary and beyond is very generous and builds on our common work in writing a book on the history of practical theology at PTS. He has been my primary dialogue partner on methodological issues at Princeton, and I look forward to his future contributions to the field, which I believe will be considerable. Since Gordon is my colleague and friend, he may a bit too complimentary, so I will add several critical comments about my work, especially Practical Theology: An Introduction.
I think this book gives the mistaken impression that theology enters in primarily at the normative moment of practical theological reflection. While it is true that I frame each of the four “moments” theologically (e.g., descriptive empirical work is a form of priestly listening), I do not address adequately the ways theology enters in every step of the way. The descriptive empirical and the interpretive moments, in particular, are portrayed in ways that are too close to social science and as leading up to the real work of theology, which is normative. At the very least, I should have been much clearer that empirical work is informed by theological commitments (Why study this issue? Why ask these particular questions?) and that the interpretation of data is theological as well as social scientific.
I also did not give sufficient attention to the dialogue between practical theology and the other theological disciplines in this book. I have addressed why I believe this is important earlier in this chapter and will say no more here. Finally, I think it is legitimate to ask if the book overemphasizes the tradition of critical reflection that has been so important in twentieth century practical theology. As shared above, I was shaped by Clinical Pastoral Education, the Lab School movement, and other forms of education that placed great emphasis on reflective practice. While I gesture toward other traditions like Christian spirituality, I wonder if practical theology in an increasingly secular West will have to give more attention to practices like prayer, worship, Scripture study, and communal discernment that root reflection in the Christian way of life. Critical reflection is an important second or even third step that must be grounded in formation. It plays a role in discernment, moral action, and the engagement of others in and beyond the church. It may well be that practical theology’s close ties to critical reflection and reflective practice reveal ties to modern Western theology so deep that we will have to jettison this way of thinking about theology altogether as we encounter new patterns emerging in global Christianity.
By way of conclusion, I hope that my deep appreciation for this book has been evident throughout. Each chapter is special to me and has evoked an inner dialogue. The privilege of teaching and learning from so many students, colleagues, and friends has always stood at the heart of my vocation as a teacher. On the occasion of my retirement, I give thanks to those in this book and beyond who joined me on that part of my journey.
Bibliography
Barth, Karl. The Christian Life, Church Dogmatics, Vol. IV, 4, Lecture Fragments.Translated by Geoffrey Bromiley. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1981.
Guder, Darrell. Be My Witnesses: The Church’s Mission, Message, and Messengers. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1985.
Gunter, Stephen, et al. Wesley and the Quadrilateral: Renewing the Conversation. Nashville: Abingdon, 1997.
Newbigin, Lesslie. The Gospel in a Pluralist Society. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1989.
Ricoeur, Paul. Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences. Edited and translated by John Thompson. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1981.
300. Saying, doing, and being the gospel is Darrell Guder’s way of putting this point. See, Guder, Be My Witnesses, 91.
301. Newbigin, The Gospel in a Pluralist Society, 227.
302. Barth, The Christian Life, par. 78.
303. The Timothy Scholars were a cohort of PhD students studying at PTS in the area of Christian education with a special emphasis on ministries with youth and young adults. They were supported by an outside donor seeking to strengthen the church’s ministries with young people by strengthening this subject area in contemporary theological education.
304. Albert Outler coined this term; see Gunter et al., Wesley and the Quadrilateral.
305. See Barth, The Christian Life, par. 78.
306. Stucky, Consensus and Conflict, 84.
307. I first heard this at a conference while I was a graduate student. For discussion of this point, see Ricoeur, Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences.
