Chapter 19 of 22

Conclusion

Conclusion

Conclusion

Theology’s Place in Practical Theology

Andrew Root with Kenda Creasy Dean

Grandiose? We know. But when we think of those early days of practical theology’s renaissance, as the work of Browning, Fowler, and van der Ven took shape around a journal and academy, we can’t help but imagine Rick Osmer as the Athanasius to these older men’s Alexander. Just as Alexander was the leading voice at the Nicene council, and Athanasius his young secretary, soon to be the great theological mind of the Nicene movement, so we imagine Rick Osmer. In our imagination we can see Osmer sitting through meetings, making points, and working through logistics, at that famous 1991 meeting held in Princeton. Osmer may have been in the shadow of the more established practical theologians back in early 1990s. But as the decades would go on Osmer, would become the great theological mind among them.

We don’t say this just because Osmer was our teacher (though we will admit our bias on that score), but rather because no one in theorizing about practical theology has as consistently and richly drawn from theological voices as Osmer. Osmer has an acute sense that practical theology would lose its center and soul if it lost the ability to speak of God. As Osmer himself observes in his concluding reflections on this book, “Moving beyond correlational models of practical theology and discovering how to engage the other theological disciplines is one of the most important challenges facing practical theology today.”283 As a good student of Fowler, Browning, and van der Ven, Osmer was intent on speaking of human action through the social sciences. But without a distinct theological moment (or method) in which the practical theologian does more than just repeat dogmatic ideas—but instead risks speaking directly and freshly about God—practical theology would be hampered.

In this chapter, in honor of Osmer, we’ll explore the need for this deep theological attention to God’s concrete (and real) action in the world, attending particularly to why, as a field, practical theology has often neglected to follow the model that Osmer embodied. This chapter seeks to contribute to Osmer’s legacy by exploring why the theological moment in practical theology (i.e., the speaking directly and specifically about the act and being of God)—which Osmer dubbed the normative moment—is necessary for robust practical theological reflection. To be clear, Osmer does not consider normativity a point in time as much as an existential posture of the practical theologian, who brings a normative lens to every practical theological consideration. In that light, every moment in practical theological reflection may be properly considered a normative moment, since theologians look for different things when they describe, interpret, and respond to a situation than, say, politicians or plumbers or statisticians. In the spirit of Osmer, the chapter will attend to the role of divine action in practical theology, even pushing the edges of Osmer’s own consensus model to more fully embrace practical theology as a vehicle for noticing and naming ways in which divine action and human action intersect.

The Conundrum of the Core Problematic

As students of Richard Osmer, we (Kenda and Andy) were forced to grapple with what Osmer’s colleague and fellow practical theologian James Loder liked to call “the problematic of practical theology.” God’s Spirit and the human spirit call to one another; they interact. It was therefore the task of practical theologians, Loder believed, to discern the steps in this ongoing divine dance while joining it.284

Loder died in 2001. The following year, in a doctoral seminar that I (Andy) took, Osmer assigned a chapter Loder had written. Osmer credited Loder with seeing something clearly that few in the field of practical theology had recognized. In the chapter Loder writes, “Practical Theology is the generative problematic of divine and human action.”285 We agree—but many do not. In fact, Loder’s definition and mission for the field of practical theology appears to be a minority position among the major branches of the discipline. Yet overlooking the intersection of divine and human action as the primary nexus of the practical theologian’s work has a steep cost. Practical theology has been able to create rich projects on human action in relation to church life, society, and pastoral practice. But these fruitful articulations have not always sailed practical theology into the deep waters of exploring divine action, and therefore miss the generative and problematic nature of practical theology.286

Contemplating divine action next to human experience and agency offers deeply generative possibilities to those interested in studying the “text” of the lived Christian life. And yet it is “problematic,” in Loder’s words—for even if we are to contend that divine action is real, it remains a transcendent mystery. How are we to reflect on mystery from the concrete standpoint of human existence?

This is the possibility and peril in practical theology as we voyage into the waters of divine action. We must contemplate how potentially incongruent forms of action can and do relate, even though they exist in different layers or dimensions of reality (e.g., heaven and earth, eternity and history, omniscience and finitude, etc.). To identify the intersection of divine/human action as practical theology’s core problematic is to confess the possibility of the event of God encountering us in our concrete and embodied lives. It is a statement of purpose. It is a statement of faith.

Two factors contribute to our inability to discuss divine action in practical theology. The first is practical theologians’ erroneous view of divine action as impractical. This is especially true where academic practical theology must function within the scientific norms of the university setting (“a degree in make believe” is how one colleague described my [Kenda’s] PhD in practical theology). Practical theology’s commitment to the lived and embodied realities of concrete persons and communities seems to draw practical theology like a magnet toward conversations with the social sciences and forms of empirical research. The discourse within these fields and disciplines has given practical theology language and dialogue partners that yield reasoned and reflective approaches to human action.

Divine action, on the other hand, is by definition non-empirical; to mix the metaphysical with the physical is a category error from which there is no return, from the standpoint of the scientific paradigm. Thus, with some exceptions, most practical theological perspectives overlook, underplay, or simply seem disinterested in divine action or transcendent reality—which has made it harder for practical theology to attend to the theological.287

The irony is that this perspective flies in the face of Christian theology itself, which confesses God’s radical investment and interaction in concrete, lived human experience. Another possibility exists, therefore, for practical theology: to approach divine action as a deeply practical and lived reality. People who testify to encounters with God experience these encounters as lived realities, either interwoven into the fabric of daily life or interrupting it with decisive force. These encounters have concrete, observable consequences: they direct human life in formative ways, moving people to do one thing or another in their practical life: join a faith community, quit a high-powered job, forgive oneself for parenting failures, adopt a different outlook on life, etc. These very human experiences are bound in a reality that seems beyond the people who report them. They have been to a “thin place,” as the Celts say: they have glimpsed a reality that transcends them, but which is nevertheless real to them in the most practical way.

Of course, even scientific observation is no stranger to “impractical” observations; inference and indirection are accepted means of developing hypotheses. We do not observe the wind; we observe its practical effects. Social science owes much to developmental theorists who—long before modern neuroscience could photograph the brain—inferred cognitive development by observing how younger and older children explained their experiences differently. Likewise, denying practical theology’s practicality just because it attends to the transcendent risks failing to attend to the truly “practical” (i.e., missing the depth of people’s practical experience).

Meanwhile, as a double whammy, overlooking the practical in practical theology has led to a “theological” deficiency as well. As president of the International Academy of Practical Theology in 2011, Bonnie Miller-McLemore wondered aloud about the normative theological nature of the field, even questioning what is theological about practical theology: “For decades, practical theologians have argued that attention to practice as a yield for theology but specifying this or even getting around to it has been difficult.”288 She called discussions around theological normativity a necessary growing edge for the field.289 Practical theology has rightly started with human experience, but it has been uneasy with the possibility that human experience can be bound up with the divine. This failure to acknowledge people’s experiences with God as real prevents practical theologians from wading into conceptions of divine action that would move toward unique and substantive theological contributions. These are big claims. How did the practical and theological deficits in practical theology come to be? To find out we’ll have to step back and examine practical theology’s birth.

Theology’s Bastard

Practical theology has experienced a revival of relevance. Born in the ferocious winds of the arrival of enlightenment modernity, practical theology was the bastard child of another radical transition of theological education: a momentous shift in the location of theological education from monasteries, abbeys, and humanist classrooms to modern research universities. This shift uprooted theological education from places of formation and repotted it in the soil of empirical science. Because of its new environment, practical theology was pushed beyond the church’s protected cloisters into the world.290

But its arrival was never celebrated. Until quite recently, in the ethos of the modern scientific research university, theology reigned as queen. Yet practical theology had no claim to royalty; its bloodlines were too mixed with experience and practice—with the practical as opposed to the theoretical—to claim a place before the throne of science. Belittled and ignored, practical theology was the theological encyclopedia’s bottom feeder that gathered up intellectual crumbs that fell from the table shared by Bible, systematics, and history.291 Practical theology was intended to use these scraps to apply the noble scientific theories of the university’s high table to the peasants out in the practice of ministry. It was believed that if budding pastors had the scientific theory (the true meal) of the classic theological disciplines (dogmatics, history, and Bible), topped off with a few concluding courses (a little sweet and fluffy dessert) on management and liturgical organization, they would be properly nourished and ready to lead.292

This perspective held for centuries. With theological education housed in the brick buildings of universities and the church itself protected by the castles of nobles in Europe and the mono-cultural socialization of North America, the “university” system of theological education was firmly protected from any storm that might blow through.

Winds of Change

But after a few centuries, and leading into the last decades of the twentieth century, the friction created between positivist empiricism and cultural pluralism eroded the brick walls of the university, and the winds of transition began to penetrate the halls of the theology department. These winds brought a bitter chill: empirical fields like the hard or social sciences began to wonder why a university needed a theology faculty at all. As the church lost cultural relevance and faced the challenge of living in a context in which pluralism and doubt met it at every turn, new students—already raw from the winds of transition—stumbled into the cold lecture halls and seminar rooms, shaking their heads as learned professors spoke with little acknowledgment of the state of change, and little concern for how these winds had frozen “applied” theory-to-practice perspectives into irrelevance.

In the 1970s and 1980s a handful of the very scholars teaching in universities made a push for a renewed understanding of practical theology. They would eventually gather in Princeton to stage a renaissance in practical theology. Recognizing the winds of transition and the erosion of the theological encyclopedia, and bolstered by the recovery of practical philosophies (from Aristotle to Marx to American pragmatism to postmodern deconstruction), people like Don Browning, James Fowler, Edward Farley, Mary Elizabeth Moore, Lewis Mudge, Thomas Groome, and Richard Osmer sought to turn the bastard discipline into a prince (or at least mutual sibling).

Arguing that all theology needed to make a turn to the practical, these scholars sought to move practical theology out of the basement of theological education and into a more constructive and essential place within the endeavor. Making a convincing case that concrete communities of practice (whether congregations or other social forms of concrete/lived practice) are the very text of practical theological reflection, they raised the flag on communities as places of embodied theology, contexts where practical wisdom is practiced.

This push gave practical theology a new relevance. Those buffeted by the stiff winds of transition are quick to point to practical theology as a way forward, as a way of connecting theory and practice, theological education and ministry, Christian practice and public engagement. After all, if North American religious institutions are waning, there is nevertheless a potent (though maybe chaotic)293 spiritual propensity—which suggests strongly that theological education would do well to turn toward these concrete organic communities of experienced practice to learn from them as well as shape them.

More Complicated Than It Seems

Thanks to all those Alexanders, practical theology has been ushered out of its basement room, and—if it is not at the pinnacle of theological prestige, it has nevertheless found fresh air. Moving to the concrete, lived contexts and lived theology—leaving behind the stuffy for fieldwork and questionnaires—practical theology has gained ground both in terms of its significance for churches and for theological scholarship. This push, positively, has not been done simplistically. But because it has not been done simplistically, it has not been free from confusion on what exactly practical theology is and how it goes about its work.

While many standing in the squall of transition have pointed to practical theology as a helpful way forward, these very advocates in seminary administrations or denominational offices have often found it hard to actually say what practical theology is and who does it. Is it something done by pastors, professors, or lay people? And what makes a practical theologian different than, say, a biblical scholar who is concerned for the practice of preaching or bible study in her classroom? Is she a practical theologian as well as bible scholar? And what exactly is a practical theologian? Practical theology’s turn to the concrete and lived is essential (and something we deeply affirm), but how is this done?

Moving into Divine Action within Practical Theology

Osmer has provided what he calls his “reflective equilibrium model of practical theology.”294 He explains that this not a method per se, though some have used it that way. Rather, it is a model that seeks to explore the shared operations of those calling themselves practical theologians. While Osmer’s model seeks to provide some traction on what practical theologians do, we think it shows the importance of attention to the theological.

As this book has shown, Osmer describes four tasks of practical theology: the descriptive, interpretative, normative, and pragmatic. Broadly speaking, these four core tasks articulate what practical theology is and does.295 The descriptive task asks the question, What is happening? and uses tools of thick description—case studies, questionnaires, appreciative inquiry, participant observation, etc.—to answer it.

The interpretative task asks Why is it happening? and places the descriptive findings in conversation with frameworks that seek to explain the phenomenon experienced and examined. Typically drawn from the human sciences, these frameworks are often drawn from cultural, sociological, psychological, or anthropological fields.

These two core tasks bind practical theology unequivocally to concrete and lived contexts. Whether it starts with a crisis, established practice, or lived belief, practical theology begins, first and foremost, on the ground. This is a unanimous commitment across the field. Yet it is also what makes the field perplexing to outsiders (and sometimes to insiders). The need for rigorous attention to the descriptive and interpretative DNA of practical theology can makes it appear, to some, as “social science lite.” It can be seen as a kind of sociology in the theological faculty, leading some to wonder about the difference between a sociology of religion and practical theology.

Nevertheless, for practical theology to continue to be concrete and lived it must not expunge these tasks from its operation. At the same time, it must also think of how such moves (in themselves) point to the theological nature of practical theology. After all, it appears en vogue and ruled as good scholarship to nearly take off the theological hat when doing descriptive and interpretative work, before (maybe) putting it on again later.

When this happens, the descriptive/interpretative tasks becomes locked in epistemology (what humans know as constructed and able to be observed) and escapes ontological articulations that touch on concrete and lived ways people lean into the mystery of reality itself, a reality bigger and more than socially constructed constructs. The divine cannot be captured in strict social constructionism without severe reduction. While seeking to avoid reduction but still wed to a hard social constructionism, practical theology runs the risk of avoiding the theological and succumbing to the human agent’s social construction of God. Or more often, it simply stops talking of God and instead turns to religious phenomena—staying only at the level of the congregation for instance, and its interaction with political ideologies. Moving into the next two tasks is where we begin to push Osmer’s perspective.

Two Other Core Tasks

Osmer explains that there are two other core tasks to practical theology, two tasks he calls the normative and pragmatic. The questions that mobilize these two tasks ask respectively What ought to be happening? (the normative) and What then should we do? (the pragmatic). Osmer explains clearly that though the normative is the heart of the specifically theological move in practical theology, it is not to say that theology has not been present prior to the operation of this task. As a matter of fact, in the appendix to his Teaching Ministry of Congregations,296 Osmer explains that the outworking of these four core tasks, which are shared by all practical theologians are nevertheless mobilized in different ways, depending on one’s view of praxis, theological anthropology, or cosmology.

Of these two tasks, the pragmatic, performative moment has been the one to which practical theologians most ardently cling. While practical theology has given its most direct attention to description and interpretation, it has not been shy about claiming its pragmatic mandate, distinguishing itself from pure sociology or anthropology by asserting that it is not only interested in describing and interpreting the world, but in changing it.297 For this change to happen, renewed, reimaged, or newly created forms of action are needed. So practical theology attends to honing the reflection on, and performance of, classic practices of the Christian tradition like liturgy or counseling; or it attends to the pragmatic actions of Christian life that are social, public, and even political. Yet the insistence on changing the world, and not just describing it, leads some to assert that practical theology is simply a normative sociology or political anthropology.

Whether such comments are made disparagingly or appreciatively, they reveal that this attention to pragmatic action takes place within normative commitments. To seek to change things is to make some normative assertion about the deficiency of the present and the new direction change needs to take. Osmer’s question What ought to be happening? has most often been taken in this kind of ethical framework, leading practical theology to be seen by some (particularly Don Browning) as a kind of pragmatically engaged ethics.

While honoring the concrete and lived commitments of practical theology, this perspective on the pragmatic moment of practical theology nevertheless tends to flatten out divine action. Normativity becomes a dialogical engagement with Christian tradition that sets ethical (normative) directions for engagement, but divine action, as an independent and free reality, runs the risk of being lost.

Therefore, from our perspective, it may be better to see Osmer’s normative question What ought to be happening? not solely in an ethical frame, but in a revelatory one. In other words, the normative questions asks, What ought to be happening (what ways should we perceive of reality, ourselves, the church, our practice and conceptions of God) now that God has encountered us? What ought to happen now that we have experienced the event of God’s encounter? We might shift this question to, “Now what?”—after we’ve had an experience with living Christ in our very concrete and lived experience, the practical theologian must ask: “Now what?” now that we’ve called these experiences real?298

The heart of the normative question is to articulate the “ought,” not as defined by a kind of moralistic categorical imperative (Kantian), but as an event of encounter, as an ontological reality, as the unveiling of God’s being next to our own. What ought to happen now that the Spirit has come upon us (Acts 2)? Now what that the Spirit of the living Christ has fallen on us as a very ontological reality? From the experience of this encounter in Acts, Peter and the disciples are pushed to performative action: to preach, in such a way that it is not only a “best practice” (three thousand are added to their number, as all hear them in their own languages) but as the very participation in the continued action of God (the Spirit moves to build Christ’s church by overcoming the curse of Babel in the communion of Word heard and responded to).299

Though there are no unanimous ways on how practical theologians use the descriptive, interpretive, normative, and pragmatic tasks, it seems clear that practical theology needs them to secure its identity as a theological discipline with some value within the faculty and church. Osmer’s consensus model of the four core tasks offers helpful traction as we grapple with both how practical theology misses the depth of divine action and why it must return to it. Without sufficient attention to normativity, which in Osmer’s understanding is shot through the entire process of practical theological reflection, the field of practical theology risks absorption by social sciences, and the practice of ministry risks becoming another helping profession. Reclaiming normativity, on the other hand, restores to practical theology both its “practical” and its “theological” DNA—and paves the way for real, unique, and substantive contributions to theology for our time.

Bibliography

Forrester, Duncan. “Can Theology be Practical.” In Practical Theology: International Perspectives, edited by Friedrich Schweitzer and Johannes van der Ven, 15–25. Frankfurt: Peter Lang, 1999.

Hastings, Thomas John. Practical Theology and the One Body of Christ. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2007.

Loder, James. “Normativity and Context in Practical Theology.” In Practical Theology—International Perspective, edited by Friedrich Schweitzer and Johannes A. van der Ven, 359–73. Berlin: Peter Lang, 1999.

Miller-McLemore, Bonnie. Misunderstanding About Practical Theology: Presidential Address to The International Academy of Practical Theology. At the International Academy of Practical Theology, Amsterdam, July 2011.

———. The Wiley-Blackwell Companion to Practical Theology. West Sussex: Wiley-Blackwell, 2010.

Osmer, Richard. Practical Theology: An Introduction. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2008.

———. The Teaching Ministry of Congregations. Louisville, KY: Westminster John Knox, 2005.

Root, Andrew. Christopraxis: A Practical Theology of the Cross. Minneapolis: Fortress, 2014.

Schweitzer, Friedrich, and van der Ven, Johannes A. Practical Theology—International Perspectives. Berlin: Peter Lang, 1999.

Swinton, John, and Harriet Mowat. Practical Theology and Qualitative Research. London: SCM, 2006).

Taylor, Charles A Secular Age. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2007.

283. Osmer, “Consensus and Conflict,” 220. 

284. By the time Kenda knew Loder, who served on her dissertation committee, he functioned as the Princeton Seminary faculty’s de facto mystic. He insisted on the Holy Spirit’s presence in any deviation from the norm of human existence, which he believed—except for regular divine interruptions—was hurtling toward entropy. Entropy finally caught up with him: James Loder died unexpectedly of a brain aneurysm in 2001.

285. Paraphrased from Loder, “Normativity and Context in Practical Theology.”

286. Some of the material that follows is an adaptation from part one of Root, Christopraxis, 3.

287 For an examination of specific projects in practical theology that do this see chapter four in Root, Christopraxis, 47–62.

288 “Of course, we must have something interesting to say: “‘The primary justification for inclusion is the ability to produce an interestingly different angle on life.’ This is where practical theologians face a challenge. No one says practical theology is not normative, constructive, or Christian. But do we have something theologically interesting to say? For decades, practical theologians have argued that attention to practice has a yield for theology but specifying this or even getting around to it has been difficult. If practical theology has been partly about transforming academic theology, then it has to show what it has contributed to theology as theology.” Miller-McLemore, Misunderstanding About Practical Theology, 58.

289. “Reformulating the final misunderstanding—that practical theology is largely, if not wholly, descriptive, interpretative, empirical—sounds a little like stating the obvious: practical theology is in fact theology. However, there are benefits of a more explicit correction as follows: As theology, practical theology is normative. It makes demands on those who practice it to live by the sacred and transcendent convictions it professes. Greater clarity about our theological and not just our practical contribution is one of our challenges but success in this realm will advance the discipline and its value for religious communities and the common good.” Ibid., 59.

290. Richard Osmer, following Edward Farley and others, has made the point that before the modern research university all theology had a practical edge. Osmer calls such heroes of the faith as Luther, Calvin, Catherine of Sienna, Augustine, and Paul proto-practical theologians, explaining that for them all theology was embedded in concrete communities and was never imagined outside of the lived experience of a people.

291. See Gisbertus Voetius’s seventeenth encyclopedia for an example.

292. Duncan Forrester explains, “In both Protestantism and Roman Catholicism this tradition has continued almost up to the present with little or no critical theological reflection or suggestion that the subject is or may be a systematic and rigorous discipline in volume after volume of good advice to ministers, and in hints and tips on how to perform traditional functions of ministry. F. D. Schleiermacher’s suggestion that practical theology was the completion and ‘crown of theological study’ indicated the possibility of a better integration between practical theology and the other theological disciplines. But Schleiermacher saw practical theology as no more than the craft of church management, the channel through which the theories of biblical and systematic theology flow to nourish the life of the church. The present structures of church and ministry were accepted uncritically, as was the assumption that the subject addressed itself exclusively to the practice of clergy.” Schweitzer and van der Ven, Practical Theology—International Perspectives, 18.

293. Charles Taylor calls this the Nova Effect. See Taylor, A Secular Age, part III.

294. For a critical exploration of Osmer’s perspective see Hastings, Practical Theology and the One Body of Christ, ix–x.

295. Osmer provides a summary of these tasks. “The descriptive-empirical task. Gathering information that helps us discern patterns and dynamics in particular episodes, situations, or contexts. The interpretive task. Drawing on theories of the arts and sciences to better understand and explain why these patterns and dynamics are occurring. The normative task. Using theological concepts to interpret particular episodes, situations, or contexts, constructing ethical norms to guide our responses, and learning from ‘good practice.’ The pragmatic task. Determining strategies of action that will influence situations in ways that are desirable and entering into a reflective conversation with the ‘talk back’ emerging when they are enacted.” Osmer, Practical Theology, 9.

296. Osmer, The Teaching Ministry of Congregations, 303–17.

297. “In [practical theology’s] focus on concrete instances of religious life. Its objective is both to understand and to influence religious wisdom or faith in action in congregations and public life more generally.” Miller-McLemore, The Wiley-Blackwell Companion, 14.

298. This is to shift the normative question closer to what Andy (following others) has called Christopraxis.

299. “While we have suggested that the starting point for Practical Theology is human experience, in fact this is not strictly the case. God and the revelation God has given to human beings in Christ is the true starting point for all Practical Theology.” Swinton and Harriet, Practical Theology and Qualitative Research, 11.

↑ Back to top

↑