Chapter 6 of 22

Chapter 2: Frodo’s Magnificat

Chapter 2: Frodo’s Magnificat

2

Frodo’s Magnificat

Shaping the Imagination through Children’s Fantasy Literature

Amanda Hontz Drury

I’ve spent years reading fantasy literature alongside Rick Osmer, first as a master’s student taking his “Fantasy Literature and Moral Formation” course, then as a doctoral student precepting that same course. Now, our reading alongside of one another consists of occasional emails: “Have you read . . . ?” “Have you seen the latest . . .” Within this past year, however, Rick shifted from sending me titles to sending me his own work—the children’s fantasy literature he spoke aloud to his children while they were growing up. Now, as he shares the stories with his grandchildren, he is putting these stories to paper. Children’s fantasy literature with a bent towards moral formation is not new. What is striking about Rick’s stories, however, is the ways in which his characters embody Christian practices. Strength, wisdom, and courage are not always found in the genie’s bottle or the magic wand. The reader sees transformation of the character taking place through the cultivation of mindful Christian practices. Rick’s stories are, if you will, practical theological fairy tales.

Frodo’s Magnificat: Children’s Fantasy Literature and the Kingdom of God

Fantasy is not mere childish escapism. There is a political aspect to it—we won’t try to change this world unless we are able to imagine another reality. One could say all change starts with fantasy.—Carol Funcke

My favorite Bible story about children is when Jesus overturns the tables at the temple.24 Perhaps it is not often referred to as a story about children, but in Matthew’s Gospel, the story of Jesus turning out the money changers ends with the young. It’s easy to miss this ending with all the donkeys, palm branches, and cheering crowds. It’s easy to get caught up in the transformation of Jesus from parade marshal to rogue protester as he starts yelling and turning over tables. For some reason, however, Jesus the agitator captivates children:

“But when the chief priests and the scribes saw the amazing things that he did, and heard the children crying out in the temple, ‘Hosanna to the Son of David,’ they became angry.”25 Somewhere between the triumphal entry and the table throwing, Jesus loses friends. We went from crowds of people cheering to just children. It sounds like Jesus scared away everyone but the kids. Where the adults were confused, the children were curious. Where the adults showed consternation, the children showed courage.

This shouldn’t surprise us. The kingdom of God, we read over and over again, belongs to children (this is why the phrase, “children are the future of the church” is so maddening—as if the kingdom of God belongs to children, and when they grow up they will inherit the local church as well). Somehow, children are able to see aspects of the kingdom of God that the rest of us cannot. And apparently, this is a good thing: “I praise you, Father, Lord of heaven and earth,” Jesus declares, “because you have hidden these things from the wise and the intelligent and have revealed them to infants.”26

“Truly I tell you,” we read in Matthew’s Gospel, “unless you change and become like children, you will never enter the kingdom of heaven.”27 Much has been written on what it means to “become like children” with people differing on what exactly this means.28 Rather than jumping into these conversations, however, I propose we sneak in a side door and attempt to eavesdrop on a world children often find themselves in: the world of children’s fantasy literature.

Sneaking in the side door of children’s fantasy literature gives us the chance to see the kingdom of God by using our moral imaginations. Using stories in this way makes sense. The “good life” of the kingdom, James K.A. Smith asserts, “captures our hearts and imaginations not by providing a set of rules or ideas, but by painting a picture of what it looks like for us to flourish and live well.” “This is why,” he continues, “such pictures are communicated most powerfully in stories, legends, myths, plays, novels and film rather than dissertations, messages, and monographs.” This attraction to the good life plays out at a “precognitive level . . . it is not primarily our minds that are captivated but rather our imaginations that are captured, and when our imagination is hooked, we’re hooked . . . Attracted by it and moved toward it, we begin to live into this vision of the good life and start to look like citizens who inhabit the world that we picture as the good life.”29 Children’s fantasy literature tills the soil for the kingdom of God—it allows the kingdom of God to germinate through 1) calming the watchful dragons of myopic realism, 2) opening our ears to the testimony of children, and 3) awakening within us a moral imagination to envision a new world.

Become Like Children: Sneaking Past the Watchful Dragons

Is there something we lose concerning the kingdom of God as we grow old? Is seeing God’s kingdom more difficult as we age? “Become like a child” we read over and over again. I wonder when the lips of those cheering children were silenced? At what point in their growing up would they have lost that courageous curiosity?

Not long ago the University of North Dakota released a study on how people might tap into their “inner child.” Psychologists Darya Zabelina and Michael Robinson recruited seventy-six undergraduate students and split them into two groups.30 Both groups were told that school was cancelled and were then instructed to write for five to ten minutes on what they might do with their extra time. One of the groups received an additional instruction: “You are seven years old.” The control group wrote of sleep, work, and other obligations. The “seven-year-olds,” however, came up with more whimsical answers often tied to creativity, spontaneity, and play. The possibilities imagined by the “seven-year-olds” seemed boundless. One of the findings of the study was that simply by pretending to be a child awakened long-dormant parts of our imagination. In order to have a more childlike mindset, try.

While we are capable of trying to act like children, reading children’s fantasy literature moves us to a more unself-conscious state. When we read, our imaginations are stoked in such a way that we catch a glimpse of the delight of a child who sees things her older counterpart cannot. It connects us to that which we’ve lost as we’ve aged; it sneaks us past the guardians our adult sense of realism has stationed at the entrance to our imagination.

If we do have what C. S. Lewis calls “watchful dragons” that stop anything too fantastical or childlike, then perhaps, as Lewis says, fairy tales will enamor us and sneak right past the winged beast.31 Lewis explains:

I thought I saw how stories of this kind could steal past a certain inhibition which paralyzed much of my own religion in childhood. Why did one find it so hard to feel as one was told one ought to feel about God or about the sufferings of Christ? I thought the chief reason was that one was told one ought to. An obligation to feel can freeze feelings. And reverence itself did harm. The whole subject was associated with lowered voices; almost as if it were something medical. But supposing that by casting all these things into an imaginary world, stripping them of their stained-glass and Sunday school associations, one could make them for the first time appear in their real potency? Could one not thus steal past those watchful dragons? I thought one could.32

When fantasy literature sneaks past the “watchful dragon,” it nudges the sleeping imagination along the way. I propose we turn to children’s fantasy literature to help cultivate within us a childlike lens through which we might broaden our understanding of the kingdom of God. If pastors are challenged to preach with the Bible in one hand and the newspaper in another, then perhaps fantasy literature should rest in one’s back pocket.

Certainly, trying to be like a child is an option, but perhaps there is something beyond volition. Yes, we can try harder, but there is also a sense that children’s fantasy literature allows us to simply be—to be caught up in the currents of make-believe and imagination.

Receiving the Testimony of Children

All dreams are not false; some dreams are truer than the plainest facts. Fact at best is but a garment of truth, which has ten thousand changes of raiment woven on the same loom. Let the dreamer only do the truth of his dream and one day he will realize all that was worth realizing it.—George MacDonald

Oddly enough, almost immediately after Jesus calls his followers to “become like children,” he seems to change his story. “Whoever welcomes one such child in my name welcomes me,” he declares.33 Which is it? Do we become like children or are we instead those who welcome children? Matthew gives us a fascinating yet ambiguous shift of personhood. We do not just become children, we also welcome children.

If we want to become more child-like it helps to start by taking seriously the things that children say. The story of Princess Irene in George McDonald’s The Princess and the Goblin traces the tension between the children who see and experience remarkable things and the adults who refuse to believe them. “‘When I tell you the truth, Lootie,’ said the princess, who somehow did not feel at all angry, ‘you say to me ‘Don’t tell stories’: it seems I must tell stories before you will believe me.’”34

Much of children’s fantasy literature revolves around the trope of children speaking truth and the adults not believing them.35 Harry Potter insists on the return of Voldemort. Meg from A Wrinkle in Time maintains her father’s survival despite incredulity from Mr. Jenkins. The Lion, The Witch and The Wardrobe holds within it an unusual reversal in which the elderly professor instructs Lucy’s siblings that they really should believe their little sister’s testimony. Lewis then proceeds to remove children from the adults like the professor in order for them to serve as their own heroes in their stories. This removal implies Lewis’s willingness for children to serve as “trustworthy narrators of their own experiences.”36 Thank goodness for children who insist on sharing their experienced reality, even if it means waking us up three times in a single night when they hear the voice of God.

What is more, testifying is a communal practice. It is not a testimony unless there are hearers to receive the message. When we listen to and take seriously the testimony of children, we are not only showing children that we believe them to be capable vessels of the Holy Spirit, we are also reminding ourselves that the message of God is not the sole property of those who’ve conquered puberty. When children know their testimonies are taken seriously, we are assisting them in articulating and solidifying their identities in Christ Jesus as well as our own in the process.

So often God seems to delight in using the weak instead of the strong. This is quite fitting with our fairy tales as ultimately, the genre of children’s fantasy literature—and fantasy literature in general—is one of subversion. We also see these subversive elements woven throughout the biblical narrative. Before Hobbits defeated dark lords, we had boys slaying giants. A baby in a basket escaped death though the loving act of a mother long before another baby was shielded by his mother’s love and ultimately became known as “the boy who lived.” Repeatedly, we see the gospel proclaimed to the poor, the lame, the widowed, and the weak—it is a story of subversion. And God seems quite well pleased to subvert what is “proper” in favor of entrusting his words to women and children.

We don’t read children’s fantasy literature to become better listeners. As illustrated above, the problem isn’t hearing what children say, it’s imagining their words to be true. One could argue that as we grow, we lose our capacity to imagine. This was certainly the case with Susan who grows up and abandons her belief in Narnia. She becomes a Narnian apostate, claiming that all the stories her siblings tell are the product of overripe imaginations.

J. K. Rowling took issue with Lewis’s treatment of Susan in Lev Grossman’s Time article from July 17, 2005: “There comes a point where Susan, who was the older girl, is lost to Narnia because she becomes interested in lipstick. She’s become irreligious basically because she found sex. I have a big problem with that.”37 Rowling is referring to a conversation from The Last Battle:

“‘My sister Susan,’ answered Peter shortly and gravely, ‘is no longer a friend of Narnia.’

‘Oh Susan!’ said Jill. ‘She’s interested in nothing nowadays except nylons and lipstick and invitations.’”38

If Rowling is correct that Lewis is using Susan to speak out against sex or a particular form of feminism then I too would “have a big problem with that.” Looking at this passage in context, however, Lewis’s critique seems to have less to do with the lipstick and more to do with the problem of abandoning childhood faith in order to become more “sophisticated” as evidenced by Lady Polly’s response to Jill:

“‘Grown up, indeed,’ said Lady Polly. ‘I wish she would grow up. She wasted all her school time wanting to be the age she is now and she’ll waste all the rest of her life trying to stay that age. Her whole idea is to race on to the next silliest time of one’s life as quick as she can and then stop there as long as she can.’”39 Lewis’s critique seems to be less about a woman’s sexuality and more about one’s shunning of childish things and the subsequent refusal to believe. In Susan’s defense, it is quite difficult to hold on to one’s childhood imagination as one grows up—so much so that, in order to take seriously the testimony of children, we must have robust imaginations.

Awakening Imaginations:

What We Knew Before We Knew Too Much

Reality is merely an illusion, albeit a very persistent one.—Albert Einstein

Sometimes we see what is most true with our imaginations. Fantasy is not an escape from reality; rather, C. S. Lewis writes, “we do not retreat from reality: we rediscover it. As long as the story lingers in our minds, the real things are more themselves . . . [D]ipping [things] in myth we see them more clearly.”40 Children see reality in a way that adults cannot (or would not), and we read fantasy literature in an attempt to see as children see.

We need this childlike lens because the older we get the less creative we are. It seems that as we age we lose something that once came naturally to us. We know this is the case with language.41 The older we get, the fewer sounds we can make. While we might acquire new words and understandings of the vernacular, we also lose linguistic abilities to participate in other languages. There are somewhere around 869 identified phonemes—or units of sound that distinguish one word from another. Infants aged six to eight months can discriminate the full range. “After that,” John Dowling writes, infants “use just a subset—those that they hear and thus distinguish. Conversely, young children can imitate virtually any sound an adult makes, but this ability is also lost with age. By one-and-a-half years, babies start to make sounds characteristic of the languages to which they are exposed, and their ability to make sounds characteristic of other languages slowly disappears.”42 As the infant grows, she slowly loses her ability to reproduce the sounds she once gurgled easily. She unlearns sounds in order to speak the words of those around her. As the child grows accustomed to her native tongue, her linguistic abilities are pruned until they are within the boundaries of the surrounding vernacular. Learning to speak means unlearning certain sounds.

Just as we lose the ability to make sounds, so too we lose the ability to think creatively. In 1968 George Land and Beth Jarman of NASA came up with a test to determine “divergent thinking” among rocket scientists and engineers. Land and Jarman applied the test to children as a way to measure their creativity. They were startled to see that 98 percent of the children tested scored at a “genius level.” Amazed by these findings, the duo followed the children, conducting tests as they aged. What they saw was a decline in the children’s ability to think creatively as they aged.

Creativity Scores at Genius Level

George Land’s Creativity Test (1968)43

Amazingly, these results have been replicated over and over again. Both the NASA study and the “School is Cancelled” study listed above assert that while adults tend to lose creativity as they age, that creative spark has not necessarily gone out. Our creativity is not dead; it becomes dormant and simply needs to be awakened. The creative spark is present, as evidenced by the dreams of our subconscious that are often fraught with a creativity unparalleled in our waking hours.44

What does an awakened imagination have to do with the kingdom of God? We will have a difficult time imagining a new world in heaven if we are unable to imagine a new world on earth. Fantasy literature opens us up to that which is other. It pushes against the boundaries of what we see as real and leaves us wondering if perhaps there is more. This is not necessarily an intentional question we ask, like “Is there life outside of earth?” Rather, it is something we are swept up into. We do not consider fantasy literature; it consumes us. In other words, when we read children’s fantasy literature, we move from trying to be like children to being caught up in a childlike state.

With a moral imagination, we cannot help but wonder just how different we are from a character like Tolkien’s Gollum. The creature steals, fights, and perhaps worse, betrays, and yet throughout the books, we follow Bilbo’s lead and are often filled with pity for the creature. Gollum represents the figure we all could become should circumstances play out differently. We are all, as it seems, a simple quarrel away from the path of Gollum. Tolkien stokes our compassion throughout the story, giving us glimpses into almost alternate views of Smeagol. Gollum sees Fordo and Sam asleep and we read:

A strange expression passed over his lean hungry face. The gleam faded from his eyes, and they went dim and grey, old and tired. A spasm of pain seemed to twist him, and he turned away, peering back up towards the pass, shaking his head, as if engaged in some interior debate. Then he came back, and slowly putting out a trembling hand, very cautiously he touched Frodo’s knee—but almost the touch was a caress. For a fleeting moment, could one of the sleepers have seen him, they would have thought that they beheld an old weary hobbit, shrunken by the years that had carried him far beyond his time, beyond friends and kin, and the fields and streams of youth, an old starved pitiable thing.45

When the Gollums appear, we reach a fork in the road and must choose between compassion or disdain. These authors encourage us to maintain strong convictions—yet always with compassion. Characters like these prompt us to approach the kingdom of God with open hands, palms up. We take what we think we know and hold it lightly with the knowledge that God often uses the “foolish things of the world to shame the wise.”46

This is the same imagination that calls us to hold out hope for the good in others. It may look like Snape is muttering incantations to cause you to fall off your broom, but it’s also possible those mutterings are counter-curses keeping you in the air. Fantasy literature opens up the door for us to see the good where everyone else might see the evil. It opens us up to the thought of salvation coming from an unexpected source.

Often at the end of children’s fantasy literature there is revealed an unexplored depth of imagination. And so stories end with “They lived happily ever after,” implying there is more to the narrative and it only gets better from here. Frodo boards the ship for the Grey Havens “where the leaves fall not.”47 And the Narnians take their final journey: “All their life in this world and all their adventures in Narnia had only been the cover and the title page: now at last they were beginning Chapter One of the Great Story which no one on earth has read: which goes on for ever: in which every chapter is better than the one before.”48 Children’s fantasy literature paves the way for an unfathomable kingdom that has no end. “Further up and further in.”49

Conclusion

My favorite Bible story about adults is from Mark 10:13–16, where Jesus blesses the children:

One day some parents brought their children to Jesus so he could touch and bless them. But the disciples scolded the parents for bothering him. When Jesus saw what was happening, he was angry with his disciples. He said to them, “Let the children come to me. Don’t stop them! For the Kingdom of God belongs to those who are like these children. I tell you the truth, anyone who doesn’t receive the Kingdom of God like a child will never enter it.” Then he took the children in his arms and placed his hands on their heads and blessed them.

This is not a children’s story. This is a story for adults. Children don’t need to hear this story—they already know they are welcome on Jesus’ lap (that is why they are in the story in the first place). This story is for the rest of us caught in the myopic reality of adulthood. It is those of us who are closest to Jesus who need to hear this story.

Bibliography

Balthasar, Hans Urs von. Unless You Become Like This Child. San Francisco: Ignatius, 2015.

Bunge, Marcia J. The Child in the Bible. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2008.

Dowling, John. The Great Brain Debate: Nurture or Nature. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2007.

Grossman, Lev. “J. K. Rowling Hogwarts and All.” Time, July 17, 2005. http://content.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,1083935,00.html.

Harwood, Adam, Kevin E. Lawson, Jason Foster, David Liberto, David P. Scaer, and Gregg Strawbridge. Infants and Children in the Church: Five Views on Theology and Ministry. Nashville: B&H Academic, 2017.

Land, George. “The Failure of Success.” TedXTuscon (February 16, 2011). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZfKMq-rYtnc (accessed February 8, 2019). Study originally reported in George Land and Beth Jarman, Breakpoint and Beyond: Mastering the Future Today. Leadership 2000, 1998.

Lewis, C. S. On Stories: And Other Essays on Literature. San Diego: Harvest, 2002.

———.The Last Battle. New York: Harper Collins, 2002.

Nir, Yuval and Giulio Tononi. “Dreaming and the Brain: From Phenomenology to Neurophysiology,” Trends in Cognitive Sciences14 (2010) 88–100. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2814941/.

MacDonald, George. The Princess and the Goblin. Philadelphia: J.B. Lippincott & Co, 1872. net-Library, e-book, pdf.

Smith, James A. K. Desiring the Kingdom: Worship, Worldview, and Cultural Formation. Grand Rapids: Baker Academic, 2011.

Tolkien, J. R. R. The Return of the King. New York : Del Rey, 1986.

———. The Two Towers. Wilmington: Mariner, 2012.

Zabelina, D. L. and M. D. Robinson. “Child’s Play: Facilitating the Originality of Creative Output by a Priming Manipulation.” Psychology of Aesthetics, Creativity, and the Arts 4 (2010) 57–65.

24. Matt 21:12–17.

25. Matt 21:15.

26. Matt 11:25.

27. Matt 18:3.

28. See Balthasar, Unless You Become Like This Child; Bunge, The Child in the Bible; Harwood et al., Infants and Children in the Church.

29. Smith, Desiring the Kingdom, 53.

30. Zabelina and Robinson, “Child’s Play.”

31. It is worth noting there are differences between fantasy literature and fairy tales, however, fairy tales are a subsection of the larger fantasy genre.

32. Lewis, On Stories, 70.

33. Matt 18:5.

34. MacDonald, The Princess and the Goblin, 166.

35. “It’s a longstanding ‘rule’ of child and adolescent literature that in order to free the juvenile protagonists to act independently, the parents/adults must first be removed from the picture: The Boxcar Children are orphans, the Hardy Boys are off camping on their own, the kids in The Mixed up Files move in to the museum, the Peanuts adults are out of the frames and speak in gibberish . . . and so on. So, in addition to the shared childhood experience that adults don’t take us seriously, there is also a writer’s desire to allow for child heroism via obtuse grown-ups.” Randy Dewing, email to the author, January 29, 2018.

36. Ibid.

37. Grossman, “J. K. Rowling Hogwarts and All,”

38. Lewis, The Last Battle, 169. That is not to say that there are not explicit or implicit sexist undertones in Lewis’s stories, simply that there could be an alternative interpretation in this particular case.

39. Ibid.

40. Lewis, On Stories, 138.

41. We go from Susan, the child queen of Narnia, to Susan who has grown and is “no longer a friend of Narnia,” her lived experiences in Narnia reduced to a pretend game she used to play.

42. Dowling, The Great Brain Debate, 64.

43. Land, “The Failure of Success.”

44. Nir and Tononi, “Dreaming and the Brain.”

45. Tolkien, The Two Towers, 366.

46. 1 Cor 1:27.

47. Tolkien, The Return of the King, 252.

48. Lewis, The Last Battle, 228.

49. Ibid., 206.

↑ Back to top

↑