Chapter 7: The “Double-Pointed Ellipse”
7
The “Double-Pointed Ellipse”
Integrating Spirituality and Mission
Twelve years ago when Princeton Theological Seminary began offering classes in spirituality, it took a risk. It took an even greater risk when it created a degree track that explicitly coupled together spirituality and mission. This second move contained a counterintuitive logic within it, highly unprecedented among theological institutions today. But this instinct has the potential to alter the way seminaries think about their curriculum, and even how the church thinks about itself.
The first risk included the question of whether faculty should teach spirituality-specific courses in an academic setting. At Princeton Seminary, classes on mission were offered since the founding of the institution, but the contemporary turn toward spirituality had not yet been embraced. Our theological forerunners were much more comfortable with cultivating “piety”138 or teaching various devotional practices, but not with the looser term “spirituality,” so prevalent today. Protestants especially worried that “spirituality” might become ingrown, overly focused on a narcissistic “Jesus and me” orientation. Shortly after creating a faculty position in spirituality, however, the faculty in the Education and Formation area at Princeton Seminary decided to link spirituality139 and mission140 explicitly in the curriculum, because of the conviction that growth in spiritual formation and missional formation are intrinsically connected to one another. Significantly, it was Richard R. Osmer who led the way in making this innovative curricular connection, a connection rarely made in other seminaries or in the larger culture.
In this essay, I will argue that Osmer’s coupling of spirituality and mission has potential to revitalize both of these important aspects of the church’s call—namely, the call to follow Christ with passion, and the call to follow him into sacrificial service in the world. The de facto separation of spirituality and mission in both congregations and the academy has enervated both. Osmer’s insistence on integrating these practices not only protects churches and seminaries from becoming enterprises unto themselves; it also enables practical theology to take up its call to empower the church to act in service to the world.
Many scholars have followed Osmer’s seminal work in practical theology through his numerous published writings, but few have had front row access to his thought while designing a brand new curriculum with him. Team-teaching with Rick has been a singular joy for me at Princeton Theological Seminary. Working alongside him strengthened my intuitions about the ways in which spirituality and mission invigorate one another, when properly understood and practiced. Osmer has long insisted that Christian mission and spirituality are to remain tightly tethered in a theology of the church. Though he was not the first to recognize the importance of this connection,141 he has been a pioneer in reintegrating the church’s two-fold call in the field of practical theology.
Osmer reinvents this coupling of spirituality and mission in his chapter for Dwight Zscheile’s volume, Cultivating Sent Communities: Missional Spiritual Formation.142 Drawing on David Bosch’s Transforming Mission, Osmer imagines the church as an ellipse with two foci: the edification of the church and sending it forth into the world.143 The first focal point, or “upbuilding,” roots the church deeply in the “source of its life” through the preaching of the Word, Christian education, pastoral care, and spiritual formation. Vital to this upbuilding is the church’s growth in fellowship as a spiritual community; spiritual friendships are nurtured, and the church experiences a deeper form of knitting together as the body of Christ. The second focal point represents the sending of the church in evangelism, service, social involvement, and social justice, as the church bears witness to the watching world.144 And these two foci cannot thrive without the other. The church lives in tension between these two points that are dynamically related to each other: it is formed spiritually as it is built up as the body of Christ and is simultaneously formed in its mission. In fact, “formation is most powerful when deep connections are created between these two foci.”145 Here Osmer quotes Bosch:
In and around the first [focus] it acknowledges and enjoys the source of its life; this is where worship and prayer are emphasized. From and through the second focus, the church engages and challenges the world. This is a forth-going and self-spending focus, where service, mission and evangelism are stressed. Neither focus should ever be at the expense of the other; rather, they stand in each other’s service. The church’s identity sustains its relevance and involvement.146
Expanding on the way in which spiritual formation serves as a foundation for fulfilling Christ’s call to mission, Osmer draws on Darrell Guder’s work to develop his theory of evangelism,147 but also presses beyond those very insights that had informed his thinking. For example, Guder has written that the church’s work of evangelism is three–fold, involving 1) saying, 2) doing, and 3) being the gospel. The “saying” of the gospel involves preaching and evangelism, where the gospel is shared in words. The “doing” of the gospel embodies the church’s ethical orientation, that is, the manner in which members of the church treat others and act in community, and how they embody the teachings of Christ, both toward one another and in the world. For Guder, “being” the gospel primarily means “being and becoming the witness,” i.e., Christians who as individual persons and communities grow in sanctification and live out the gospel for others to see.148
According to Osmer, the “being” of the gospel (within this three–fold paradigm) needs to be developed more fully, and this is the place where spiritual formation must take center stage. The shaping of the heart and of the life, as well as the disposition of the soul before God, are crucial in spiritual formation and invite more cultivation. Our relationships with others involve not only what we say or do for them, but who we are, both in relation to them and to ourselves as individuals. Who are we before God? What is our character, and what is the wellspring of our affections, as well as of our choices?149 The depth of one’s interior life necessarily influences how one lives out the gospel for others to witness.
In addition to focusing on one’s individual relationship with God, Osmer stresses the importance of communal formation as a vital ingredient in spiritual formation; we are formed in community and for community. In The Invitation, Osmer even argues that a key part of the call we extend to the watching world is an invitation to participate in authentic Christian community. The church does not lead others first into a conversion experience per se, but leads them to a taste of genuine Christian community. Here the church meets a longing that many people in our world experience today, and it sets in motion their desire to learn more about the Christ who holds this community together, eventually leading them to consider becoming a disciple of Christ. 150
Furthermore, Osmer writes that in “the literature of contemporary spirituality, the language of formation is conceptualized almost exclusively in terms of the pole of identity, as the upbuilding of the members of the gathered congregation through spiritual practices and programs.” Osmer’s ecclesiology broadens spiritual formation to include the second point of the ellipse, namely, that the “congregation and its members are formed as they act with and for others beyond the church in partnership, mutual learning, and solidarity with the vulnerable. Missional formation . . . includes, but goes beyond, the typical practices we associate with spiritual formation.”151 The disciple of Christ, then, is formed spiritually as she takes up her missional vocation; in following Christ to serve others, the Spirit continues to form her (as well as the church, communally) into the likeness of Christ.152
The Double Elliptical Classroom
All of these insights and questions, and the connections between spirituality and mission, even in inchoate form, came into play as Rick and I created our new course. We discussed not only our burgeoning ideas, but practices that would support the ideas and how these practices might be embodied—both in the syllabus and in the way we team-taught the course. We chose Ignatian spirituality as the centerpiece of our teaching and practice in spiritual formation because it is particularly adept at representing the double–pointed “ellipse”—i.e., the importance of nurturing both the inner life in Christ and the outer life of mission.153 We also opted for depth in one tradition over breadth in several, which our first course evaluations confirmed was a choice helpful to students’ learning.154 Furthermore, we felt comfortable teaching Ignatian prayer because of our personal training in this tradition.155
There were several ways in which our teaching team embodied, organically (and perhaps fortuitously) some of the elliptical ideals that we espoused. First, a sense of genuine spiritual community arose within the teaching team when we gave ourselves permission to teach not only as fellow professionals, but as members of the body of Christ who cared deeply for one another. We also conducted ourselves in the classroom with evident respect and appreciation for one another, celebrating each other’s gifts as a team.156 And we joyfully began our teaching team meetings in prayer, attending to God’s Spirit among us, listening together for God’s still, quiet voice. This strengthened our understanding of Christ’s call, and how Christ might be calling our students into more vibrant service of others. We also created a class retreat component that was a vital part of the semester’s learning. During this overnight retreat at Loyola Retreat House, students joined in spiritual companioning groups (facilitated by trained group spiritual directors) to process their individual prayer times, formed by Ignatian Gospel contemplation, to which I will return.157 These opportunities to build community reinvigorated individuals in their various calls, and enabled them to process their struggles with that vocation, as well as their wrestlings with the God who called them.
The missional component of the class also informed the focal point of spirituality in several ways. For example, many of our students, while focusing on the academic rigors of a theological education, struggle to discern or deepen their sense of call. Some may have arrived on campus with a clear vision but lose their way when the spring of their interior life dries up. But we saw students, in the very process of grappling with their sense of purpose in the world, reach back into their relationship with God to discover their call afresh.158 Other questions also emerged for the students: if we are called to bear witness to the gospel, have we ourselves experienced the power of this gospel in our lives? How do we even understand this “good news” on a daily basis? What is it that we are proclaiming?159 Students realized over time that we cannot preach or give to others that which we have not experienced ourselves. Alongside these wrestlings, the call to love and serve others (with all of its accompanying challenges) compelled students to draw on resources from that deeper internal spring. Often, it was in the very act of reaching out, whether through field education or other venues of service, that their relationship to God was further revitalized.
Truth be told, I did not understand the full potential of this integrative approach when I started teaching at Princeton Seminary. Having taught at Loyola College for three years, Ignatian spirituality became a part of my wheelhouse, but the way in which spirituality and mission were interwoven throughout Ignatius’s vision initially eluded me. Despite my training in Ignatian spirituality,160 I neither conceptualized nor experienced the power of spirituality and mission’s integration until team-teaching this new course with Rick. Even the title of the course, “Introduction to Spirituality and Missional Formation,” which was birthed in Osmer’s vision to integrate spirituality and mission in the curriculum, kept us grounded in this necessary coupling and challenged me to return time and again to the double-pointed ellipse.
Teaching with Ignatius: Elliptical Pedagogy in Practice
Several years ago, a colleague who had been a Catholic priest for thirty years made the startling comment that he had served his parish for all those years without once ever encountering Christ himself—until he prayed through The Spiritual Exercises. Until then, his sense of mission was often a reaction to external pressures or feedback. Mission was reduced to another task on the humdrum list of rote duties, rather than the irrepressible fruit of gratitude, erupting from an internal wellspring of passion, motivation, and desire.
Confessions from many of our seminary students revealed to me that they too were preaching a gospel that had become increasingly distant to them during their time at seminary. Their passion for mission and service withered as they lost sight of the one who called them. Several spoke of becoming “dry bones” (Ezek 37) and no longer existentially encountering the God that they had once personally believed, or even loved. As Henri Nouwen admitted of himself in The Return of the Prodigal Son, many ministers and theologians in particular, even in proclaiming the love of Christ to others, remain perpetual bystanders to that love—the unhappy plight of the firstborn son in the parable—rather than knowing themselves to be deeply beloved as the prodigal child.161 Ignatius illumines a valuable pathway from bystander to beloved, bringing the follower of Christ into a more immediate encounter with the Christ who passionately loves him/her and the world. This then releases the pastor (and seminarian) into a more vibrant and authentic mode of proclamation and lived expression.
This deep integration of spirituality and mission in Ignatius’s thought can be found in his Spiritual Exercises, the primary prayer manual he bequeathed to the church. Many denominations today, Catholic and Protestant, turn to it to enrich their prayer lives.162 In this guide, Ignatius walks us through four movements (or “weeks”), each of which is designed to bring us into a lived encounter with Christ, which then brings us back into the world with a strengthened heart for service. In the first movement, retreatants ponder the beauty of the created world alongside its brokenness. We focus our meditation on ourselves as profoundly loved of God. And we bask in the compassion of Christ and learn to love ourselves, extending Christ’s compassion to ourselves despite life’s severe wounds. This grounding is essential in the life of any minister. Going out into the world to serve others without this foundation sets us up for discouragement, a relentless cycle of people-pleasing or self-judgment, and burnout. The enduring power of mission is lost when the source of life and love becomes distant.
In the second movement, the retreatant meditates on the incarnation, life, and ministry of Christ, and imaginatively walks alongside Christ as he brought healing and life to others. As seminarians hoping to serve in ministry according to the model of Christ, this movement wields great potential for their participation in Christ’s very own ministry through imaginative prayer, or gospel contemplation.163 In the third movement, the retreatant accompanies Christ through his passion, daring to stay with him in his suffering, remembering the way he suffered alongside others. (Again, this practice can generate endurance for ministry in pastors.) Finally, in Ignatius’s fourth movement of prayer, the retreatant witnesses the resurrection and the power of the risen life and learns to live anew out of that resurrection power. These four movements help to resource the retreatant’s return to the world with renewed vigor, determination, and love. Spiritually strengthened in fellowship with Christ, one’s mission in the world is revitalized.
One of the innovations in Ignatius’s model of prayer is its vivid and powerful use of the imagination.164 In Ignatian prayer, we are invited to place ourselves within the gospel narrative, almost as if part of a motion picture.165 With which character did we relate? Where were we, physically, in relation to the character of Jesus? What might Jesus have said directly to us—to me—in this unfolding scene? With the movie rolling forward, were we one of the disciples trying to protect Jesus from being crushed by the crowd? Were we in the crowd, pressing in, desperate for a loving glance or for healing? Or were we—was I, perhaps—the person Jesus touched or addressed?166
Several years after I experienced Ignatian group spiritual reading for the first time in my classroom, Rick encouraged me to facilitate this form of prayer in our introductory course of sixty students.167 I was accustomed to using the exercise in smaller courses, but I did not know how to create a spirit of shared attentiveness to biblical narrative in such a large group. To my surprise, the lectionary text for the day (Mark 4:35–41, “Jesus calming the storm”) allowed students to confront various kinds of pain: crushing disappointments long buried, anger at God long suppressed. Many identified with the disciples, furiously pouring water out of the boat and pleading with Jesus, “Do you not care that we are perishing?”168 Others spoke of a deep disbelief in Jesus’ power or questioned his compassion. Still others admitted to personal storms in their own lives, and their yearning for calm in the midst of their studies or ministry and family demands. A final group of students experienced Jesus speaking peace into their lives through the text, releasing them from the anxieties they had carried into the classroom. Whatever their engagement with the text (and a few indeed struggled to enter the scene at all; imaginative prayer takes some patience and practice), the opportunity to become engulfed by a biblical scene opened up fresh honesty in conversation with Christ and with each other, by unmasking pain, doubt, and hidden hopes.
Integrating Spirituality and Mission in the Education of Christian Leaders
As I came to appreciate how important the integration of mission and spirituality is for the formation of the church, I stumbled upon something else as well. The ancient recognition that endurance in Christian leadership—not to mention endurance in faith itself—utterly depends on this integration, which is why it is so critical for our students who are studying for ministry. Without this kind of honest encounter with Christ, it becomes all the more difficult for pastors to maintain the kind of perseverance needed to sustain their outreach to their parishioners, or to witness Christ’s love to our watching world. If I have not first received this love, what can I give?
Seen from the other point of the ellipse, when my relationship to God becomes one of vibrant love where divine grace flows freely, mission and service are not things “I do” but rather grateful responses to that love. Mission is then empowered by the Holy Spirit and impossible to stifle. God enters us as love (we inhale God’s breath) and we share that love (exhale into the world). We cannot afford to separate these two. On the other hand, if mission is something that “we do,” it can be exhausting before we even start.
Osmer is convinced that the coupling of spirituality and missional formation requires that disciples of Christ, as Guder puts it, speak, do, and be the gospel. In being the gospel, Osmer stresses that disciples must grow as people of prayer in relation to God. They are also invited into experiences of community, which is one of the church’s most important and powerful means of witness to the gospel of Christ. If we model this integration in the theological classroom, more Christian leaders will be encouraged to drink deeply from the wellspring of love in their own lives, so that they can move out into the world to serve others with confidence, passion and vigor. Their service, in turn, fuels their life of prayer, as the world’s needs and their own limitations bring them to their knees in a mutually informing ellipse.
Bibliography
Anderson, Chris. Light When It Comes: Trusting Joy, Facing Darkness & Seeing God in Everything. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2016.
Bauckham, Richard. The Theology of Jürgen Moltmann. Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1995.
Bosch, David. Transforming Mission: Paradigm Shifts in Theology of Mission. Maryknoll, NY: Orbis, 1991.
Busse, Brendan. “Grace Enough: Andrew Garfield on the Ignatian Journey that Led Him Through ‘Silence.’” America 216 (2017) 42–49.
Dyckman, Kathryn, et al. The Spiritual Exercises Reclaimed: Uncovering Liberating Possibilities for Women. Mahwah, NJ: Paulist, 2001.
Guder, Darrell, L. Be My Witnesses. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1985.
Harter, Michael, ed. Hearts on Fire: Praying with Jesuits. Chicago: Loyola Press, 2005.
Holder, Arthur, ed. The Blackwell Companion to Christian Spirituality. Oxford: Blackwell, 2005.
Hooper, Walter, ed. The Letters of C. S. Lewis to Arthur Greeve. New York: Macmillan, 1979.
Hunter, George. The Celtic Way of Evangelism: How Christianity Can Reach the West . . . Again. Nashville: Abingdon, 2011.
Lee, Bo Karen. “The Compassionate Christ in the Classroom: Ignatian Spiritual Reading.” In The Soul of Higher Education: Contemplative Pedagogy, Research and Institutional Life for the Twenty–First Century, edited by Margaret Benefiel and Bo Karen Lee. Charlotte: Information Age, forthcoming.
Liebert, Beth. “Ignatius of Loyola: The Spiritual Exercises.” In Christian Spirituality: The Classics, edited by Arthur Holder, 197–208. New York: Routledge, 2009.
Martin, James. The Jesuit Guide to (Almost) Everything: A Spirituality for Real Life. New York: HarperCollins, 2010.
McDougall, Joy Ann. Pilgrimage of Love: Moltmann on the Trinity and Christian Life. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005.
Mikoski, Gordon, and Richard Osmer. With Learning and Piety: The History of Practical Theology at Princeton Theological Seminary 1812–2012. Zürich: Lit, 2011.
Moltmann, Jürgen. The Church in the Power of the Spirit: A Contribution to Messianic Ecclesiology. San Francisco: Harper & Row, 1977.
Nouwen, Henri. The Return of the Prodigal Son: A Story of Homecoming. New York: Doubleday, 1994.
O’Brien, Kevin. The Ignatian Adventure: Experiencing the Spiritual Exercises of Saint Ignatius in Daily Life. Chicago: Loyola, 2011.
Osmer, Richard R. “Formation in the Missional Church: Building Deep Connections between Ministries of Upbuilding and Sending.” In Cultivating Sent Communities: Missional Spiritual Formation, edited by Dwight J. Zscheile, 29–55. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2012.
———. The Invitation. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, forthcoming.
Osmer, Richard R., and Bo Karen Lee. “Enriching the Love of Learning with a Desire for God.” Hungry Hearts 17 (2008) 20–21.
Osmer, Richard R., Angela H. Reed, and Marcus G. Smucker. Spiritual Companioning: A Guide to Protestant Theology and Practice. Grand Rapids: Baker Academic, 2015.
Palmer, Parker. “Life on the Möbius Strip.” The On Being Project, February 17, 2016.onbeing.org/blog/life-on-the-mobius-strip/.
———. The Company of Strangers: Christians and the Renewal of America’s Public Life. New York: Crossroad, 1983.
Parish of Trinity Church. Pioneers of the Spirit: Ignatius of Loyola. Worcester, MA: Vision Video, 2005.
Silf, Margaret. Inner Compass: An Invitation to Ignatian Spirituality. Chicago: Loyola, 2007.
Smith, James. You Are What You Love: The Spiritual Power of Habit. Grand Rapids: Brazos, 2016.
Yoder, John Howard. Body Politics: Five Practices of the Christian Community Before the Watching World. Scottdale, PA: Herald, 2001.
138. See Mikoski and Osmer, With Learning and Piety. Prior to 2007, individual classes along the way may have focused on spiritual theology or formation, but an organized curriculum in spirituality had not yet been available to students.
139. For the purposes of this chapter, I am utilizing Arthur Holder’s definition of Christian spirituality. He states, “Although the apostle Paul never used the word ‘spirituality,’ this earnest confession of faith [Rom 8:14–16] suggests that any Christian understanding of that term must necessarily refer to the intimate loving relationship between God’s Holy Spirit and the spirit (animating life force) of believers—a relationship that can be characterized both as kinship and communion. The Christian life is always ‘life in the Spirit’ (cf. Gal. 5:25), in all its variety and unpredictability.” Holder adds that much of the literature on Christian spirituality focuses on “lived Christian experience,” and that this “complex subject” of spirituality “can only be understood and appreciated when approached from a variety of perspectives, and with careful attention to the particular manifestations in an infinite range of historical and cultural contexts.” Holder, The Blackwell Companion, 1–2.
140. For the purposes of this chapter, I define mission according to David Bosch’s understanding. As Osmer writes in his chapter, “Formation in the Missional Church: Building Deep Connections between Ministries of Upbuilding and Sending,” in Cultivating Sent Communities: Missional Spiritual Formation: “Missio Dei, the mission of God, marks a shift in thinking about mission from an ecclesiocentric to a theocentric perspective. Instead of thinking of mission as activities the church does (i.e. outreach programs, evangelism, sending missionaries overseas), it views mission, first and foremost, as something God does in sending the Son and Spirit into the world. David Bosch puts it like this: ‘We have to distinguish between mission (singular) and missions (plural). The first refers primarily to the missio Dei (God’s mission), that is, God’s self–revelation as the One who loves the world . . . Missions . . . refer to particular forms, related to specific times, places, or needs, of participation in the missio Dei.’” Osmer continues, “Missional vocation refers to missions (plural), to the particular ways congregations participate in the missio Dei in concrete times and places. Congregations find their missions within God’s mission.” Osmer, “Formation in the Missional Church,” 30.
141. The Mary and Martha trope, which integrates the contemplative and active life, rather than contrasting the two figures, has a long history in the Christian mystical tradition, for example. And others such as Henri Nouwen, Thomas Merton, Howard Friend, Joan Chittister, Elizabeth O’Connor, Janet Hagberg, and Robert Guelich have also written on this integration, especially as it pertains to combating justice fatigue, or even compassion fatigue. Other religious traditions have stressed this same dynamic, e.g., Buddhist teachers often speak of the interior life’s cultivation so that compassion might flow outwards in acts of courage and service.
142. Osmer, “Formation in the Missional Church.”
143. Parker Palmer uses the idea of a Möbius strip to express a similar idea—that spirituality and mission are intricately tethered together, mutually informing and illuminating: see Palmer, “Life on the Möbius Strip.” Palmer argues that without the cultivation of the interior life, one would all too easily burn out in community organizing efforts and sustained social justice concerns. This insight is also part of Palmer’s thesis in his early work; see Palmer, The Company of Strangers.
144. For more on the “watching world,” see Yoder, Body Politics.
145. Osmer, “Formation in the Missional Church,” 49. In the section entitled “Toward a Theological Conceptualization of Formation” (point 4). We indicated above that Osmer imagines the church as an ellipse with two foci: 1) the edification of the church and 2) sending it forth into the world. More precisely understood (even though all visual analogies have their limitations) the church occupies the space between the two foci and flourishes when the two points interact with and influence one another.
146. Bosch, Transforming Mission, 385. As Osmer explains, “Bosch is drawing here on the missional ecclesiology of the great German theologian, Jürgen Moltmann, who describes the congregation with the bipolar concepts of identity and relevance.” Osmer, “Formation in the Missional Church,” 50. Also see Moltmann, The Church in the Power of the Spirit, and for helpful overviews of Moltmann’s writings in English Osmer recommends Bauckham, The Theology of Jürgen Moltmann, and McDougall, Pilgrimage of Love.
147. Osmer, The Invitation (forthcoming). Thanks to Richard Osmer for sharing pre-published versions of his manuscript with me.
148. Guder, Be My Witnesses, 124–28. While chapter six focuses on “Being the Witness: The Equipping Community As Witness” and emphasizes transformation of the community into God’s will vs. conformity to the world (Rom 12:1–2), Guder also writes briefly about the “inward dimensions of doing the witness” in the next chapter, “Doing the Witness: Christian Action as Witness,” i.e., being formed in love for God and one another.
149. Smith, You Are What You Love.
150. Osmer, The Invitation (forthcoming), chapter one. See also Hunter, The Celtic Way of Evangelism, which Osmer used in our introductory course, and which speaks to this kind of approach. Those invited to the gospel of Christ were first invited into a sense of belonging to the community of Christ. In other words, belonging comes before believing.
151. Osmer, “Formation in the Missional Church,” 51.
152. As Osmer further explains, “The primary actor in spiritual formation is not the congregation. It is the Holy Spirit as she builds up and equips the congregation for mission and as she empowers the congregation to carry out in its particular vocation. Spiritual formation, thus, is the congregation ‘taking form’ in the Spirit, what might be called primary missional formation. This includes the relationships, structures, programs, and practices that emerge as a particular congregation lives into and out of its missional vocation. These, in turn, shape the spiritual lives of those who participate in this missional vocation, what might be called secondary missional formation.” He adds that the Holy Spirit is “the primary actor in formation as a congregation discerns and embodies its missional vocation. A more adequate way of putting this would be to say that the Holy Spirit forms the congregation and its individual members toward the likeness of Christ in ways that are particular to its missional vocation. Christ takes form in the congregation through the Spirit as it embodies its calling in a particular time and place.” Osmer, “Formation in the Missional Church,” 49, 52.
153. Jesuits are also well-known for the outward focus of their ministry, in terms of mission endeavors, the establishing of schools, and their emphasis on social justice. As a religious order, they are highly mobile, non-cloistered, and integrate daily spiritual practices with active service in the world. For more on Ignatius of Loyola and The Spiritual Exercises, see Martin, The Jesuit Guide, and Liebert, “Ignatius of Loyola.” Another helpful introduction is Pioneers of The Spirit, Parish of Trinity Church. An especially helpful volume for personal prayer through The Spiritual Exercises is O’Brien, The Ignatian Adventure.
154. As one exception, we taught from Hunter’s Celtic Way of Evangelism in our course, which provided another beautiful embodiment of the integration of mission and spirituality (see also n. 13 above). In Osmer et al., Spiritual Companioning: A Guide to Protestant Theology and Practice, Osmer reaches back into the devotional practices of the Protestant tradition. He also taught classes at Princeton Seminary on small group movements, small group Bible studies, and the history of various spiritual movements in the Protestant church and their missional impulses (e.g., Pietism, Puritanism, etc. and how their missionary movements grew out of their deeply rooted devotional practices).
155. Rick was trained in Ignatian spirituality through his program in spiritual direction with the Kairos School of Spiritual Formation, including his work with Marcus Smucker. Though I did most of the classroom teaching on these units, Rick was right on board, encouraging my pedagogical instincts. His gracious support was critical for my own exploration and discovery of new teaching methods, and also in my understanding of how spirituality and mission must remain tightly tethered. And with Rick’s sensitivity as a trained spiritual director, it was a joy to witness his skillful guiding of students both in precept discussions and on our class retreat.
156. A hearty thanks to Caleb Maskell, Marcus Hong, Briana Wong and Kelsey Lambright, who were key members of our teaching team over the past several years that we taught this course. In David Bosch’s ecclesiology, Christ has given himself for the world, and so we live, as disciples of Christ, in necessary solidarity with the world and with one another. Furthermore, Christ draws us to himself and to one another, in spiritual companionship and fellowship, and we are formed together into the body of Christ by the Spirit of God. See Bosch, Transforming Mission.
157. One student on retreat commented that though he was in training to be a pastor in the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) he had never once prayed on his own or been taught how to pray. Using Ignatian prayer, he encountered Christ in brand new ways and beamed as he told the story of how he first “learned to pray.” Imagine how this practice would transform this seminarian’s preaching, teaching, and witness to his future congregations!
158. Several students from our introductory class spoke in subsequent semesters about how they were ready to leave the ministry until the connection between spirituality and mission became clear to them. They even mentioned in student focus groups that had it not been for the integration found in this class, they would have left seminary. This new insight may not have given them specific details on where or how to serve, but it gave them hope that the Christ who called them would also faithfully lead them.
159. See Osmer, The Invitation (forthcoming), chapter one, for an excellent exposition of the complexities in how one defines the “gospel.”
160. Coursework in graduate school first introduced me to Ignatian spirituality, which I then expanded through spiritual direction training with the Oasis Ministries program, and numerous other Ignatian retreats and training programs (e.g., at the Jesuit Center [Wernersville, PA], Loyola Retreat House [Morristown, NJ], Bethany Spirituality Center [Highland Mills, NY], Morning Star House of Prayer [Trenton, NJ], and Francis House of Prayer [Westampton, NJ]).
161. Nouwen, The Return of the Prodigal Son, 14.
162. See Liebert, “Ignatius of Loyola,” for the surprisingly wide circulation of The Spiritual Exercises in interdenominational ministries of spiritual direction, community Bible studies, church small groups, etc. See also Dyckman et al., The Spiritual Exercises Reclaimed.
163. This form of prayer goes by various names, such as “Gospel contemplation,” see Martin, A Jesuit Guide, 145–62, or “imaginative prayer.” See Silf, Inner Compass, 12–24.
164. For more on the gift of the imagination, see Anderson, Light When It Comes, 33; cf. Hooper, The Letters of C. S. Lewis, 193.
165. See Busse, “Grace Enough,” 42–49, where the actor Andrew Garfield relates Ignatian meditation to the craft of acting and film-making.
166. See Lee, “The Compassionate Christ” (forthcoming), for details on one such prayer experience with Mark 5:21–34 (the story of the hemorrhaging woman). Parts of this essay also appear in that chapter.
167. I offer deep and personal thanks to Richard Osmer for encouraging this experiment in our classroom, thereby helping me to grow further as a teacher.
168. Mark 4:38.
