Chapter 16 of 22

Chapter 12: Regulating the Empirical in Practical Theology

Chapter 12: Regulating the Empirical in Practical Theology

12

Regulating the Empirical in Practical Theology

On Critical Realism, Divine Action, and the Place of the Ministerial

Andrew Root

Confession of Introduction

I think I did it wrong!238 This is my confession. Back when I was Rick Osmer’s student he encouraged—gently demanded—that I include an empirical moment. My shortcomings are no reflection on Osmer. I actually believe my method was correct (enough). But nevertheless, I believe the interviews that made up the end of part one of my dissertation (published as Revisiting Relational Youth Ministry [InterVarsity, 2007]) were askew. The misalignment is, no doubt, my own responsibility (which is why this is a confession), but the field of practical theology itself also, in part, led me astray.

When it came to my empirical work I was unfortunately able to separate my qualitative methodological pursuits from my concept of divine action. I turned to the social sciences to give my fieldwork direction, but unbeknownst to me, these methods actually made it difficult for me to speak of divine action. They made it much harder to do theology.

In this chapter I explore how empirical methods run the risk of reducing reality, upholding the immanent over the transcendent. I then turn to critical realism as a way to avoid this reduction, making space for the theological, showing how a regulating of the empirical under a realism can make the theological a possibility. My overall objective in this chapter is to show how Rick Osmer was right: the empirical is important, but might be pushed to move deeply to connect to divine action, linking empirical work with a theological vision of ministry.

Empirical Obsessions

It has become nearly paradigmatic for dissertations, monographs, and academic papers in practical theology to begin with, or totally consist of, empirical research studies. And there has been good reason for this; practical theology seeks to reflect on lived and concrete experiences. It examines how practices in church and society impact communities and individuals. Practical theology must describe how ecclesial or cultural practices shape lived commitments, and explicit or tacit theological conceptions. Empirical research studies describe these phenomena. This is all very important.

Since the work of Don Browning, Mary McClintock Fulkerson, and Johannes van der Ven, practical theology has claimed its own distinct research program. Practical theology is not the handmaiden of the other theological disciplines, seeking to turn others’ best academic work into applied performative procedures. Rather, practical theology has its own academic soul, which is to examine lived situations, contexts and episodes with the best of empirical methods borrowed from the social sciences. Fowler uses developmental psychology and structured interviews to examine stages of faith; Browning uses anthropology-inspired congregational studies to analyze the shape of practical wisdom and ethical actions (like sheltering illegal immigrants). Johannes van der Ven turns to the University of Chicago’s late-nineteenth-century push for empirical theology and creates a practical theology that is fundamentally empirical, turning most of Continental practical theology in this direction.239

The Rise of Immanence

Because the practical in practical theology has been most directly defined through taking on social science’s empirical operations, the theological nature of the field has been obscured. Empirical methods, by nature, reduce reality to describe it, seeking immanent causations and descriptions, and therefore making little room for transcendence.240

Charles Taylor, in the 874-page A Secular Age, describes how 500 years ago the Western world saw reality as stratified, making belief in God and transcendence near impossible to deny. Yet, by the year 2000, the Western world is now overtaken by an immanent frame, possessing social imaginaries that understand the world as fully and completely natural and material. The reasons for this cataclysmic shift are numerous, but no small part of the story is the methodological pursuits of the sciences.241

This reductive move is legitimate as long as it remains a methodological move to get a better grasp on a greater reality. A problem arises when the reduction gets confused as the total reality. But this confusion is exactly what occurred, according to Taylor. The methods of social sciences rationalized transcendence through “nothing but” stories, and explained experiences of transcendence inside the methodological reduction of immanence. Conversion became nothing but social conditioning, experiences of Jesus nothing but psychological transference. Coupled with economic and technological transitions, the social sciences played a part in reducing reality to such a level that the world was no longer assumed to be enchanted or mysterious, only natural and material.

In the midst of this radical transition, Schleiermacher redefined theology, addressing the cultural despisers and calling practical theology the crown of the theological tree. Schleiermacher viewed practical theology as the expression of theology’s life because it most directly gave attention to religion in the immanent frame. In Schleiermacher’s mind a Western world without transcendence still needed theology, most particularly practical theology because society, for its own good, needed well trained, professional ministers, just as it needed lawyers and doctors. Practical theology was the crown of the theological tree, I believe, because it was the most immanent, setting practical theology up some 250 years later through Browning, Fowler, van der Ven, and others to link hands with the methods of the social sciences and their empirical pursuits. This linkage makes discussions of transcendence (and therefore theology) more difficult.

Dumb to Transcendence

Sociologist Margaret Archer, in her book Transcendence, has shown how the fathers of the social sciences (Marx, Freud, Durkheim, and Weber) had a bias due to an absence in their own experience. Archer illustrates this by using Max Weber’s own words; Weber was known to say that he was “dumb to religious [transcendent] experience.” Archer argues that because of their own limited experience of reality the fathers of social sciences imagined the social sciences outside of transcendence, taking the methodological shape of attending to only the natural and material realities (immanence) of existence. This bias directed the social sciences to believe that their methodological reduction of reality into only social, cultural, societal, and psychological frames was the totality of reality itself.

Marx, Freud, Durkheim, and Weber were dumb to religious experience; they assumed the results of methodological was reality itself. Transcendence was flattened by the explanations of the natural and material. It is true that these methods of empirical study in the social sciences seek to complicate and nuance the immanent realm. They give detailed interpretation to cultural, gendered, economic, and ideological seams of immanence. But there is little room to actually consider the possibility that the experience of transcendence is real, and not simply reduced to a hiccup in the immanent frame. The empirical methods in practical theology are of great benefit; they allow the practical theologian to delve deeply into forms and shapes of human action. But this becomes problematic for practical theology when these beneficial methods reinforce the immanent frame, making divine action (as a distinct ontological reality) appear illogical.

Taking the methodological shape of the social sciences, much of practical theology has followed the social sciences in believing that to do the empirical is to attend to a world without transcendence; it is to examine and study only the natural or material realities of culture and society. In this view, practical theology makes no assertions about the nature and action of God experienced by human agents in concrete situations, but focuses exclusively on human religious actions bound in immanence. Of course, many practical theologians desire to say something theological. But without a reworking from the start of the practical theologian’s relationship with the methods of empirical study, there will inevitably be a flattening of reality, making transcendence difficult to speak of.

Returning to a Kind of Realism

To break free from the reduction of all human experience to immanence we must tentatively and carefully return to a realism in practical theology. I say that we must do this tentatively because forms of realism that start outside human experience and claim foundational knowledge are deeply problematic in their own sense. Forcing all knowledge onto a predetermined foundation, whether scientific, philosophical, or theological, leads to a kind of violence. Foundational realism contends that reality is stratified, but also possess-able, because a human knower is able to climb to an objective peak and know all of reality. Practical theology since its renaissance in the 1970s has sought, correctly in my mind, to be non-foundational.

The kind of realism that practical theology needs is post-foundational critical realism. This realism acknowledges the hermeneutical nature of reality. It claims that reality is stratified with human beings existing somewhere in the middle of the layers of reality. There is much about reality that the human mind cannot possess or know (even in its best methods); layers above and below that resist empirical observation. Because we cannot reduce reality to our sensory experience, there are ways other than empirical scientific methods that lead us to understand the depth and width of reality. Against the backdrop of a stratified reality we might admit that empirical methods of the social sciences help us to say something reasoned and specific about the immanent layer of reality, but these very methods may be completely blind, reductive, and therefore inappropriate to spotting a person’s experience with transcendence. Practical theology is challenged with needing a critical approach to concrete and lived experience and a way of remaining open to the act and being of a transcendent God.

Therefore, with this kind of critical realism, we claim that empirical methods are helpful, maybe even necessary, but we also must admit from the start that social scientific approaches can never possess the fullness of reality. Reality will always escape any humanly constructed method of observation; naturalism and materialism do not exhaust reality. This means that ontology precedes epistemology. This ordering of ontology over epistemology has not often shaped empirical methods; rather we usually reverse it and have epistemology swallow ontology. We have assumed in our immanent age that only what can be provided by the reductive methods of empirical science can be real, privileging epistemology over ontology. This tentative walk back into realism acknowledges that reality is stratified, all forms of human knowledge are incomplete, and reality itself is more than even the best of human epistemological systems can ever know.

Such a post-foundational realism that claims ontology over epistemology allows, from the start, for divine action to be possible. We are freed from the heavy straightjacket of naturalism and materialism to hear people’s experience with reality. And because this is a post-foundational realism, it is only through human experience that we can grasp the layers of reality. While ontology precedes epistemology in critical realism, it also acknowledges that human epistemologies are relativized. We find our way into the fullness of reality not through a foundation such as positivist science or biblicism, but through our personal experience. We indwell reality and therefore have personal experiences of reality, even transcendent layers. These personal experiences may correlate to the ontological shape of reality or they may not, but experiences of transcendence have not been ruled out from the beginning.

If we begin with this critical realist starting point, that ontology precedes epistemology and therefore people may have real experiences of transcendence, then our empirical research methods must create space for people to testify about such transcendent experiences.242 Empirical research, then, in practical theology seeks to create space for testimony, for it is through these distinct research program of testimony that we take on a disposition apt to explore the stratified nature of reality. Practical theology begins by inviting people to articulate their experiences of transcendence, seeking observations in ethnographic spaces, not simply of practices that give people meaning. How certain actions and experiences draw people into higher layers of reality becomes the question. These personal and communal experiences of testimony must always be heard as possibly true even as we submit them to scrutiny.

Reality may very well have a higher layer(s) of transcendence, but people’s experience of this is always from a lower layer, and therefore there is no way to conclusively claim such experiences as unquestionably true (this is why it is testimony). Paul himself has a transcendent experience that takes the concrete shape of the living Christ coming to him (Acts 9; in 2 Corinthians 12: 1–7, Paul speaks of layers and levels of reality). But having this experience was insufficient. Paul must continue, for the remainder of his ministry, to provide rational reasons why this experience was real. Paul gives intelligible explanations for why this experience was one with transcendence and not something else. The intensity of this experience forces him to justify himself through discourses, debates, and distinct research systems (the Torah and the prophets) intelligible to those around him.

Embracing a critical realist conception of reality means that the tradition lives. With this realist commitment, the tradition is neither a static documentation of rituals and practices nor the socially constructed tradition of a people bound in an immanent construction called the church. Instead, tradition is a resource that has and continues to give insight on an individual’s and community’s experiences of transcendence. Because the tradition is not seen as the foundation but the medium that helps mediate and discern transcendent experience, it too must be reinterpreted next to our new experiences.

But Critical Realism Can Only Take Us So Far

Critical realism allows us to see that reality is stratified, thus making it possible to create a space for transcendence in our conception of the world. This move is invaluable if the empirical methods of practical theology are to escape reduction of all reality into immanence, and if theology (as the articulation of the experience of divine act and being) is ever to be a possibility within the field.

But while taking us this far, critical realism does not solve the heart of the problem for practical theology when it comes to the empirical. Critical realism makes a space for transcendence, but gives us no direction on how empirical methods might attend to divine action itself. In other words, how can we use empirical methods, not to reduce reality, but instead to open us up to the breadth of reality. Critical realism as a philosophy argues that reality always spills over and cannot be captured by human minds. On its own, critical realism cares little for the divine. So, while critical realism gives us a philosophical way of avoiding the reduction of reality by demonstrating that reality is always more than human minds can possess and thus making transcendence a possibility, it tells does not tell us what the structure of this transcendent reality might be.

The Shape of Divine Action

It is here that the shape of divine action itself must lead us. Instead of practical theology taking its empirical shape from the immanent-bound social sciences, we must ask if there is a way for our empirical pursuits to take the shape of divine action. If practical theology shares with the social sciences a desire to speak of lived and concrete realities, it nevertheless, as a theology, believes that these concrete and lived realities encounter the act and being of God. Given this, we must adapt, shift, and regulate our empirical methods to put ourselves in a position to see the possibility of divine action within and next to the depth of human experience. We must evaluate scholars’ empirical studies in practical theology against our normative commitments about the shape of divine action itself and not against the normative immanent assertions of social sciences. We claim these normative commitments in and through our experience of higher layers of reality, drawing from trusted research systems that give us intelligible and rational conceptions of our experience. Normativity then draws from the rhetoric and practices of a tradition, but this tradition is trusted because it, at least in part, resonates with the experience of reality itself.

There are obviously numerous ways to articulate the relation between divine and human action and therefore numerous ways for organizing the empirical within practical theology. I’ll provide my own only as an example of how the theological might shape the empirical from the start.

Divine Action as Ministry

The shape of divine action, which I believe leads to an adapting, shifting, and regulating of empirical study in a generative way, is as ministry. Divine action takes the shape of ministry, and as such, divine action is not a frozen tradition but a living and concrete reality that encounters us in the depth of our experience. We experience God’s action, not as a heavy metaphysical force but as an experience of ministerial encounter in and through our concrete and lived experience. We are pulled into transcendence through the concrete and practical action of ministry taking place in the immanent. We experience God as an encounter of ministry, and this encounter makes our lived and concrete experience central, and therefore able to be described and empirically observed, while not diluting the transcendent encounter of divine action itself.

If our empirical methods take their shape from divine action, what does it mean to claim that God’s act and being comes to us as the experience of ministry? This is to contend that God’s being is given in God’s act and that God’s act is the revealing of Godself for the sake of ministry. So, we can know God (epistemology) only through the priority of encountering God (ontology) as revealed in the act of God’s ministry to humanity.

This ministerial action is not something incidental to God, as if God’s action is some kind of hobby. It is not naively asking, “What is God up to?,” as if it were an obvious catch phrase or trivial knowledge. Rather, ministry as the act of God is the event of God’s being coming to humanity; this being is always becoming, because this being is always moving and active. It is, then, the event243 of God’s moving that makes ministry an ontological encounter of the divine with the human. God’s being as coming to us is God’s very ministry, it is God’s giving of Godself to humanity so humanity might be with God. So, from the level of divine action, ministry is not clerical or institutional but the act(s) of sharing in the life of another, for the sake of love, mercy, and new possibility. We take the form of the divine being not in the way of ontology but through action. By becoming ministers, we join God’s being not through shared essence, but through shared action of ministry. (Matthew 25, again, seems to point in this very direction; the text articulates a direct encounter with revelation, with event of Jesus present, but it happens through ministering to another, sharing in their hunger, homelessness, and imprisonment). Practical theology is a form of human ministerial action that, by reflecting on and moving into ministry, attends to the very being of God through God’s own ministerial action.

Ministry from both the divine and human side is not functional or clerical. For instance, God does stuff, but it is not really the stuff, the functions, that are important, but the unveiling of God’s self (be-coming) for the sake of salvation. It is ontological, shattering trivial knowledge, because having God’s being in ministry is for humanity. God gives God’s very self, and gives it to us at the level of our own ontological personhood, becoming the ministering Christ, who reveals God (revelation) to humanity and transforms this humanity back into union with Godself (reconciliation) through the work of the Spirit (given the salvation of being in Christ). Human forms of ministry too seek to share in the life of their neighbor, sharing in the depth of their experience (homelessness, hunger, and imprisonment) as witness to and participation in the divine being itself. We share in the being of God by taking on the action of God and joining in ministry, led by the Holy Spirit.

All knowledge of God, all theology, is gleaned from encountering the event of God’s ministry; we have theological knowledge because we have been the recipients of God’s ministry. God’s practical act of ministry precedes all formal knowledge we might have. Theology can only be practical, because its epistemological object is God’s ontological state of ministering to creation. Theology is practical because its subject is the practical action of God’s self. This action is practical because it ministers to particular and real persons. Ministry allows us to give attention to divine action as a transcendent reality that nevertheless encounters us at the level of our concrete and lived experience.

Theology as reflection on a transcendent reality, and the empirical as attention to the concrete and lived, are held together through this conception of ministry. Ministry is a divine reality that nevertheless is bound in human experience. Any empirical method must be regulated under the claim of God’s ontological state as minister and any thick description of human experience must be adapted to our call to join the being of this God as ministers.

Therefore, from my perspective empirical research in practical theology can never take the disposition of a scientist, objectively committed to their field and method more than concrete personhood. The practical theologian must see his or her move into the empirical as an act of ministry, which opens up the possibility of transcendence, as an act that joins the very being of God as an ontological reality. We use models and approaches from the social sciences, transforming them through the disposition of ministry, recognizing that inviting others to express their experiences to be ministered to and ministering to others. The invitation to give testimony to the ministerial action of God regulates our empirical methods, transforming research into an act of ministry itself, which takes both interviewer and interviewee into very act and being of God.

The empirical has a place within practical theology, but only through the regulation and adaptation of the theological reality of God. Practical theology is not an empirical form of theology, but is a form of theology that attends to ministry as divine and human reality. It uses the empirical only so far as the empirical methods help us create a space where we might participate in the depth and beauty of human agents as they share their experience of the presence and absence of God in and through their concrete experience. Our invitation for them to share such experiences is itself an event of ministry; their stories of God’s presence and absence minister to us as much as the invitation to share is a blessing to them. So being shaped by seeing divine action as an event of ministry, empirical research can itself be transformed into an act of ministry and therefore must be evaluated as such.

Back to My Confession

Reflecting ten years later on that research, I believe that while it was sound from a social scientific perspective, it was flawed from a theological one and I confess it as so. I had violated the very heart of my theological commitment in the research itself. I was claiming that relationships (ministering to another’s personhood) was not a tool for ministry, but the very act of ministry itself. And yet I went into this research looking for data, seeking proof for a thesis. I was blind to the fact that my act of gathering data needed to be regulated by the possibility that the event of encounter with the humanity of those I was researching would itself bring forth the possibility of ministry, telling me something surely about the actions, perspective, and positions of these people. But also, because this was an event of ministry, the research could reveal the act and being of God. I was blind to the fact that if I invited these people to speak of their experience of God, I was walking into the deepest waters, where proclamation of the Word was wrapped tightly around their most profound experiences of joy and suffering. I was asking them to testify and reflect with me on how their very being experiences the being of God.

At the time, I had no conception that the research itself needed to be framed by the ministerial act of God; the social sciences just asked me to reflect enough to be ethical, leading me to ignore how these people were experiencing the ministerial action of Jesus. I didn’t see that my own empirical approach, if it lacked a disposition of ministerial action, would neglect the depth and breadth of these people’s concrete and lived experience of divine action. I needed to ask questions that would give these people a chance to speak of high layers of reality, not assuming that I could reduce them into cultural categories of immanence (which I did). It, of course, was not my responsibility to see myself as their pastor; I needed to be honest that I was an academic doing research. But, as a theologian I needed to enter this encounter anticipating that their stories might minister to me, that my questions and the ethos of interviews needed to be a blessing to them. I never conceived of my own person or the organizing of my study around the disposition of the event of ministry, and because I didn’t, I would remain always blind to divine action, reducing people’s experience to something solely immanent. If I saw my research as first and foremost an act of ministry (bound in the being of God’s very self that comes to us as the revelation of the ministering Jesus), I believe it would have taken me into deeper insights and maybe even into the privilege of encountering the act and being of God with those I interviewed.

Bibliography

Hart, David Bentley. The Experience of God: Being, Consciousness, Bliss. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2013.

Jungel, Eberhard. God’s Being is in Becoming: The Trinitarian Being of God in the Theology of Karl Barth. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2001.

Root, Andrew. “Regulating the Empirical in Practical Theology: On Critical Realism, Divine Action, and the Place of the Ministerial.” Journal of Youth and Theology 15 (2016) 44–64.

Smith, Christian. What is a Person? Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2010.

Taylor, Charles. A Secular Age Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2007.

238. A longer version of this chapter was published as an article. See Root, “Regulating the Empirical in Practical Theology.” Journal of Youth and Theology, 15, 2016. pp. 44-64.

239. If there was actually someone that was a forerunner to these field-defining scholars it was Seward Hiltner.

240. For more on this see Hart, The Experience of God, 319.

241. See Taylor, A Secular Age, 362.

242. For more on this see Smith, What is a Person?, 153.

243. See Jungel, God’s Being is in Becoming, 30.

↑ Back to top

↑