Chapter 8 of 22

Chapter 4: Learning a Way of Life

Chapter 4: Learning a Way of Life

4

Learning a Way of Life

The Catechetical Gift of Newcomers

Jessicah Krey Duckworth

Nearly every night at their bedtimes, my husband and I recite the Lord’s Prayer with each of our children. Give or take the occasional nights missed, we’ve recited the Lord’s Prayer as a family about 13,000 times in fourteen years. Our children have heard the Lord’s Prayer whispered in their ears long before they could speak. More times than I can recall, they’ve interrupted the prayer to ask a reflective question about the world or to remind us about their field trip the next day. We have made up melodies to sing the prayer, prayed the Lord’s Prayer in “pirate”—“arrr-men”—or said the whole prayer in a monotone voice to see who bursts out laughing first. Now that they stay up later, I’m often deeply absorbed in my own evening work when the voice from the second-floor sounds, “Hey Mom.” Like the church bell tolling to remind the workers in the field to stop and pray, I rise from my chair and ascend the stairs to join them in their evening prayers.

Praying is a practice that is learned. Our children were not born praying to God, even though they were certainly surrounded by prayer as they were being born. They learned the posture and words of Christian prayer through their experience with it at mealtime and bedtime and during other celebrations within the institution of our family, in our home. On the flip side, their personalities and interests have shaped what, when, and how my husband and I teach our children to pray. Both of us carried expectations about which traditions from our own upbringings we wanted to pass on to our children and thoughts about what we wanted to do differently. In time, together we created the established practice of prayer that our family engages in today, making adaptations for different stages of life and responding to our children’s observations, their curiosities and their own ideas for how to carry out our prayer practice. And each day, in, with and under this practice, and in spite of our frequent attempts to thwart routine because we are human after all, Jesus’ promised presence, where two or three are gathered, shows up.

When our family’s collective voices join our congregation in the Lord’s Prayer during Sunday morning worship, it is often the eighth time our children have prayed Jesus’ prayer in a week. Thanks to regular participation in Christian worship, our family has a broad repertoire of prayer practices to draw upon, including litanies and liturgies, psalms, hymns and songs, intersessions and communion prayers. The psalms of thanksgiving and lament we recite in worship provide language for the vast range of human experience and emotion, from celebrating life’s joys to grieving life’s tragedies. Experiencing the profound witness of other Christians praying or asking for prayer through intercessory prayer, my children live their lives trusting that God hears the prayers of the faithful even when—or rather, especially when—the opposite appears to be the case. Even though God may not intercede in the way that our prayers demand, God ushers in life in the midst of suffering and despair. In prayer with others we encounter Jesus where Jesus promises to be—in, with, and under the means of grace.

Forming a Way of Life

Learning how to pray is only a part of becoming a disciple of Jesus Christ. Praying is one practice.83 Within the life of a congregation, the practice of prayer is situated among a constellation of Christian practices that include Scripture reading, baptism, holy communion, mutual care and consolation, rites of passage, Bible study for all ages, mission and service, to name a few. Experienced together, over time, these practices make up the congregation’s comprehensive way of life84 or, said in another way, the ethos that reflects and interprets Jesus’ vision for a way of life.85 As practical theologians, pastors and congregational leaders are called to cultivate this life-shaping ethos by establishing, coordinating, and sustaining communal practices, informed by Scripture and Christian tradition, so that families and fellow Christians encounter the promises of God. This attention to a congregation’s identity and ethos, carefully considered in light of contemporary contexts, is what practical theologian Richard R. Osmer calls formation.86

Through formation in Christian practices, individual Christians learn how to practice discipleship through participation in the community’s way of life. Beyond formation, there are also moments when pastors and congregational leaders invite Christians to reflect on specific teachings from Scripture and the tradition. This, Osmer calls education.87 Congregations do both. For instance, congregational leaders create opportunities for Christians to pray the Lord’s Prayer while also creating space to teach the Lord’s Prayer. To teach the Lord’s Prayer is to invite the questions such as, “Who is the Lord?” and “Why did the Lord have a prayer?” To respond to these questions, Christians will likely turn to Scripture itself.

The practice of prayer provides a window on how a way of life is formed that embodies the vision of Jesus. In Luke’s Gospel, the disciples implored Jesus. “Lord, teach us to pray, as John taught his disciples.”88 And Jesus did. Jesus gave his disciples a prayer practice—words to say over time with confidence. And directly after teaching his prayer, Jesus shared a story about a man who shows up at midnight asking his Galilean friend for three loaves of bread—not for himself, but to provide hospitality for a traveler who has just arrived. In spite of the friend’s indifference, he helps anyway because tradition requires, and his neighbor persists. Jesus wraps up his story with a teaching, “Ask, and it will be given you; search, and you will find; knock, and the door will be opened for you.”89 And, “how much more will the heavenly Father give the Holy Spirit to those who ask him!”90 Through the story, Jesus encourages a particular way of life shaped by the practice of prayer and grounded in the promise that God hears and responds to the prayers of God’s children. Through a practice and a parable, Jesus gives his disciples a way that this distinctive way of life can be passed on.

Pastoral leaders are often overwhelmed at the magnitude of formation. How is one to teach the stories and practices of Christian tradition while tending to the daily spiritual needs, not to mention practical urgencies, of an entire flock? Rather than bear the responsibility to be the sole catechists for a church while also attending to the praxis of the congregation, this essay suggests that pastoral leaders may trust the resources for this kind of formation to already exist in what might seem like the least likely vessel: in the flock itself, in congregational members, and more foolishly yet, in the young people and newcomers within congregations.

Catechesis as Response

Traditionally, this way of teaching—enacting a story through practices that can be handed on from one generation to another, much as Jesus taught his own disciples—is called catechesis. Originally, catechesis referred to oral religious instruction or handing on the community’s tradition. In Greek, catechesis means “to sound” or “to echo” in the ear. Rather than dull, doctrinaire learning, however, catechesis involves the rich tapestry of the stories, wisdom, and encouragement to live a particular way of life that are shared through a teacher’s voice and that echo in the learners’ ears. Moreover, catechesis, as Luke’s Gospel story suggests, is deeply responsive to the learner’s experience. When the disciples ask Jesus to teach them as John taught his disciples, they already possess an interpretive lens for prayer. The disciples are rooted in a prayer tradition and ask their question from within the frame of John the Baptizer’s way of life. While Luke’s Gospel does not say exactly how or what John taught his disciples to pray, what is clear is that the prayer Jesus taught likely trusted the formation provided by John’s teaching, and very likely the other common practices of prayer in the first century as well. Biblical scholars confirm that Jesus’ prayer stands in continuity with the tradition of Jewish prayer.91 Nonetheless, the prayer is also a new text and becomes a new tradition birthed in dialogue with, and in response to, Jesus’ disciples and their questions.

Scripture provides various examples of people faithfully pressing Jesus with questions rooted in their own experiences and interpretations of Scripture, tradition, and commitments to a particular way of life. Jesus trusts the life experience of his interlocutors as a resource. He takes their frameworks for a way of life seriously and his responses often contribute to the emergence of a new teaching or practice altogether. A classic example is in Mark’s story of Jesus’ visit to Tyre, when a parent bows down before Jesus to ask him to drive out the demon in her daughter. Jesus tells the woman, who was not from Israel but from Greece, “Let the children be fed first, for it is not fair to take the children’s food and throw it to the dogs.” She replies, “Sir, even the dogs under the table eat the children’s crumbs.”92 Reacting to her testimony, Jesus sends her home to her daughter who now has been healed. The woman professes what she knows to be true in her faith experience—that Jesus can heal and that his promise extends beyond Israel. Her interpretation unexpectedly sounds as gospel in Jesus’ ears and in Mark’s story becomes Jesus’ own tradition—his own way of life. In turn, this Gospel story sheds light on how Christians interpret Scripture and tradition.

Beholding God’s Presence, Proclaiming God’s Promise

Ultimately though, the purpose of encounters with Jesus is not Jesus’ reaction or even the new interpretation of tradition that extends Jesus’ ministry. Rather, the purpose is to proclaim and make evident the presence of God and the promise of God’s steadfast love and peace. The parent from Tyre is not seeking to argue a point in the abstract. She is seeking healing for her beloved child. Her plea is a matter of life and death. Jesus, confronted with the suffering of a mother’s heart, responds with life, with healing and hope. “For saying that, you may go—the demon has left your daughter,” he says (Mark 7:29). Through Jesus’ act of healing, the woman from Tyre and her daughter now have the means to live into the reality of what God has envisioned for their lives—this is the kingdom of God come near, God’s life-filled intention for all of creation. Here catechesis is dynamic, rooted in lived experience yet also pointing away from itself towards something greater—the power and promise of God. For twenty-first century church leaders seeking change and innovation on behalf of their congregation, this is an important point. Catechesis, and the emergence of new traditions or practices that might flow from it, are not ends in and of themselves, but rather are means for beholding divine action.

A dynamic catechesis seeks to interpret the heart of the gospel in light of concrete situations and experiences within the contemporary community of faith in order to facilitate encounter with Jesus Christ. This is evident in the letters passed between Paul and the early churches as each community seeks to figure out what faithfulness to Jesus Christ looks like. In his letter to the churches in Galatia, Paul must confront the fact that some in Galatia are turning to a different gospel. Similarly, Paul’s letters to the church in Corinth respond directly to the arguments arising within the community of faith about how to be a Christian community. Paul does not reify God’s promise of the past to God’s promise in the present or even to God’s promised future in the Sprit. His catechesis, rooted in his own Damascus Road experience, consistently points towards the promise of God that makes all things new.

In his book on the teaching ministry of congregations, Osmer writes:

Paul’s interpretive freedom stems from his overwhelming sense that God did something radically new and different in Jesus Christ . . . Paul also interprets Scripture and tradition with a certain degree of freedom because he believes the Holy Spirit is doing something new and different among his congregations. Walking in the Spirit is not merely a matter of continuing the traditions of the past, but of attending to the signs of new creation in their very midst.93

Paul invites and expects Christians to engage in dialogue with the tradition as it is lived out in their life together through their real-life experiences. Leaning on Paul, Osmer invites contemporary congregations to stand in this interpretive dynamic framework as they engage in catechesis.94 He defines catechesis as “an interpretative activity undertaken by congregations and their individual members who see themselves as participants in the Theo-drama of the triune God and are seeking to better understand their roles in this drama by deepening their understanding of Scripture and Christian tradition.”95 The Theo-drama is God’s present activity in the world today in which Christians are called to participate.

Trusting that experience can interpret the Christian tradition does not seem very wise. Indeed, Osmer encourages congregations as they interpret the present activity of the Holy Spirit to test critically experiences of the Spirit in light of Scripture and tradition. However, as theologian Mary Solberg contends, “Theology is not about God; it is about how it is with us—in the presence of God-in-relation-to-us in the person of Jesus Christ. This is not out-of-this-world theology, this is theology for real life as we live it, in the first, sixteenth, and twenty-first centuries.”96 Theology for real life, Solberg insists, means that pastors and congregational leaders create the conditions that help Christians trust life experience as the core material of theological exploration.

Taking up Martin Luther’s theology of the cross, Solberg describes the kind of knowing that is shaped by the theology of the cross. “An epistemology of the cross describes the movement from lived experience to compelling knowledge, a movement that involves seeing what is the case; comprehending one’s implication in it and coming to accept accountability to act on what is known.”97 Seeing “what is the case” is that moment when a Christian, caught unawares by an encounter responds, “I had no idea . . .”98 Sometimes, disillusionment is so powerful that Christians can’t help but proclaim unbelief out loud. At other times when paradigms to understand the world are disrupted, especially for adults, words of unbelief do not come as easily. Expressing disillusionment seems easier for children. Their curiosity leads them to see “what is the case” through their imagination and play. Too many adults learn to ignore and inhibit their curiosity and wonder. Pastors and congregational leaders are called to create spaces where disillusionment can be confessed so that real life as we live it can be the core material of theological interpretation.

Catechesis happens where meaning erupts from honest encounter between lived experience and the Christian tradition and the gospel can unexpectedly sound in the least likely of places. At the foot of the cross, “God’s foolishness is wiser than human wisdom, and God’s weakness is stronger than human strength.”99 Learning to be a disciple, in community, at the foot of the cross, where real life is trustworthy as an interpretive framework for the Gospel, is a cruciform catechesis.

A Catechetical Moment in Context: Teaching the Lord’s Prayer

Set within a cruciform catechesis, where the gospel is proclaimed by unlikely sources, within the community of faith, the Lord’s Prayer as a practice of prayer in the home and in congregations has shaped the imaginations of Christians across the ages, and even the imaginations of our own children. At five years old, our son pressed us with real life questions rooted in his curiosity and wonder. “Why doesn’t the Lord’s Prayer say God very often? When we pray we should include God by saying God does this, God does that, God is like this, you know. The Lord’s Prayer doesn’t say that,” he said. In his prayers that night we changed the pronouns to God’s name. “Hallowed be God’s name. God’s kingdom come, God’s will be done.” This change satisfied his curiosity for the night.

When he was six, he told us his favorite part of the Lord’s Prayer was, “Give us this day our daily bread.” He immediately followed with a question, “Why doesn’t the Lord’s Prayer include wine? Shouldn’t it be, ‘give us this day our daily bread and wine’?” The connection he made between daily bread and the bread and wine of Holy Communion was not an accident. He had recently participated in first communion classes at our congregation and weekly throughout his life he had seen communion shared. Yet, underneath my son’s questions was the importance of an argument about the norms of faithful practice. In both cases he used the word “should.” At five and six he already had interpretive and normative frames, and was curiously asking questions about the received prayer practice of the Lord’s Prayer as it interplayed with other prayers at home and the prayers and actions in worship that surrounded Holy Communion. In turn, he opened up the imaginations of those adults around him toward new possibilities of God’s acting in the world.

Catechesis is not something experienced by individuals alone. Our son asked these faithful questions within the community of our congregation and of the home. As Osmer points out, “In a very real sense, the praxis of a congregation provides its members with their first interpretation of Scripture and tradition. It is here that they build up habits, perceptions, and expectations about a life of discipleship for better and for worse.”100 Through communal practices, congregations help Christians—like my son—make connections between the tradition, daily living, and the active presence of God. It is pastors and congregational leaders who find themselves tending these connections.

Becoming a Catechetical Community

For much of the twentieth century, mainline Protestant congregational leaders could count on a broad ecology of institutions to inform their ministry decisions with biblical and theological scholarship and resources that supported the congregation’s formation and education practices. This ecology included the scholarly inquiry and theological education of seminaries, colleges, and universities and robust educational resources produced by national and regional denominational leaders. By the beginning of the twenty-first century, this ecology had weakened and the burden of creating or selecting resources to support congregational ministry fell more squarely on the shoulders of congregational leaders, especially pastors.101 Anticipating the weakening of the ecology as early as 1990, Osmer wrote A Teachable Spirit arguing for the rehabilitation of the institutional offices, agencies, and structures that determine the church’s normative beliefs and practices. Faculties, congregational leaders, and denominational leaders should have a shared responsibility to ensure that the biblical and theological tradition of the church are taught to each new generation in the faith. Calling for a strong teaching office of the church, Osmer concludes A Teachable Spirit by placing honest hope in pastors “to lead congregations to an understanding of themselves as centers of teaching and practical theological reflection.”102 As practical theologians, informed by the tradition and carefully considering their ministry context, Osmer calls upon pastors to be catechists.

In his later work, which focuses on the teaching ministry of congregations, Osmer describes four patterns of interpretation and teaching in catechesis. Congregational leaders are called to 1) interpret texts of Scripture and tradition; 2) interpret the present activity of the Spirit; 3) interpret congregational praxis; and 4) interpret continuing creation.103 Osmer’s hope is that as practical theologians, informed by the tradition and carefully considering the praxis of the congregation, pastors and congregational leaders might carry out the role of catechist on behalf of the church.

While many congregational leaders take this role seriously, far too many pastors shoulder the burden of interpretation on their own. If this is how many pastors understand their part in the Theo-drama within the weakened ecology of the teaching office, it is no wonder that they are exhausted. Moreover, pastors are increasingly called to catechesis beyond the congregation, helping homes, schools, sports fields, workplaces, and the public square become formative spaces as well.104

The Catechetical Power of Newcomers

Here is a modest proposal. What if pastoral leaders directed what energy they have towards newcomers in the faith, creating welcome processes that foster relationships between newcomers and established members of the congregation, so that newcomers and established members may become the body of Christ—Christ’s presence—for one another?105 This action affirms that the real lives of people is the greatest resource the church has for catechesis—as foolish as it might sound.

Whether a newborn or a new employee, a new in-law or a new member, a newcomer’s presence reminds the established members of a community that their praxis and meaning making are not clearly evident. And this is by design—a cruciform design. Like younger members of a family, newcomers within a congregation ask questions about the norms of faithful practice because these practices do not yet fit within their interpretive landscape. The real lives of newcomers bring questions, and their questions invite response from established members. In turn, new meaning often erupts. And perhaps, new practices and traditions themselves are born. “Lord, teach us to pray, as John taught his disciples” (Luke 11:1). “Sir, even the dogs under the table eat the children’s crumbs” (Mark 7:27–28). “Why doesn’t the Lord’s Prayer include wine? Shouldn’t it be, give us this day our daily bread and wine?” Newcomers—in families and in congregations—bring real life into the Christian community’s praxis, and this real life awakens new possibilities of gospel promise in the ears of established members and newcomers alike.

Late last year, our home congregation welcomed a new family visiting from a Baptist congregation. The parents take home catechesis seriously. We know this because it is their children who respond first to a question about a Bible story during children’s time in worship. Recently this yet still-new family attended our congregation’s intergenerational faith formation experience called Messy Church.106 Five-year-old Hazel and her older sister Tessa visited the drama station, for which I was the facilitator. That night, children and adults acted out a skit based on John’s version of Jesus feeding the five thousand with a boy’s lunch. At one point in the skit, Jesus (played by older sister Tessa, who can read) says, “Let us pray” to bless the fish and bread. Hazel (playing one of the disciples) immediately bowed her head, closed her eyes and began to recite the Lord’s Prayer aloud. She prayed the whole prayer intently, ending with a big “Amen.” The adults listened with glances and gaping jaws in wonder and awe. At the end of Hazel’s prayer, Tessa said indignantly, “Can I say my actual prayer now?” I nodded reassuringly, and she read the skit’s rather generic meal prayer. Hazel’s response to Jesus inviting prayer was as it should have been. Jesus obviously expected his disciples to pray his prayer. The established member’s eyes all met each other recognizing the holy moment that occurred. The kids kept going with the skit.

As newcomers, young and old, enter into the congregation’s praxis, they tend to disrupt the established members’ established practices and meaning. The Spirit’s disruptive work ushering in newcomers is dizzying. No congregational leader can keep up with the varieties of ways that the Spirit is activating opportunities for formation and education when newcomers and established members encounter one another: “Now there are varieties of gifts, but the same Spirit; and there are varieties of services, but the same Lord; and there are varieties of activities, but it is the same God who activates all of them in everyone. To each is given the manifestation of the Spirit for the common good” (1 Cor 12:4–5). And that is the point. Sharing the responsibility of catechesis with the people of God illuminates the activation of the Spirit’s gifts. Facilitating the relationship between newcomers and established members as they engage in the praxis of the congregation concentrates leaders’ effort and relieves their burden, as God catalyzes the increase in gifts, services, and activities.

God shows up in many and various ways in the world and within the lives of the people and the creation God loves. This much is certain. Yet, Scripture—the norm of faith—points faithful people to look for God in the places God promises to show up: as people read and engage Scripture; as two or three people are gathered in the name of Jesus to pray; as real life in all its pain and joy is confessed; as means of grace are stewarded and distributed by the church to people yearning for mercy and life abundant; as newcomers encounter established members, standing in received truth while also creating new possibilities. In these trusted and unlikely places, God’s power realizes God’s promise, not over against our real lives but through them, for the sake of the world.

Within our real life at home, our children continue to disrupt the comfortable gospel my husband and I are used to—each and every day—with their curiosity and wonder. As practical theologians, and parents, we are called to create spaces in our home where real life encounters the gospel. So, I rise from my chair and ascend the stairs to pray for the 13,001st time so that we might be foolish together, these newcomers to faith and I, as we figure out how to follow Jesus through the power of the Spirit in this world God loves.

Bibliography

Duckworth, Jessicah Krey. Wide Welcome: How the Unsettling Presence of Newcomers Can Save the Church. Minneapolis: Fortress, 2013.

Miller, Patrick D. They Cried to the Lord: The Form and Theology of Biblical Prayer. Minneapolis: Fortress, 1994.

Osmer, Richard R. A Teachable Spirit: Recovering the Teaching Office in the Church. Louisville, KY: Westminster John Knox, 1990.

———.The Teaching Ministry of Congregations. Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 2005.

Osmer, Richard R., and Friedrich Schweitzer. Religious Education between Modernization and Globalization: New Perspectives on the United States and Germany. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2003.

Solberg, Mary M. “All That Matters: What an Epistemology of the Cross Is Good For.” In Cross Examinations: Readings on the Meaning of the Cross Today, edited by Marit Trelstad, 139–53. Minneapolis: Augsburg Fortress, 2006.

———. Compelling Knowledge: A Feminist Proposal for an Epistemology of the Cross.

Albany, NY: State University of New York Press, 1997.

83. “Practices are the discrete, socially shared forms of action that embody . . . praxis.” Osmer, Teaching Ministry of Congregations, 95.

84. “Praxis is the comprehensive way of life of a congregation.” Ibid.

85. Osmer and Schweitzer, Religious Education between Modernization and Globalization, xviii, 54.

86. Osmer, Teaching Ministry of Congregations, 27.

87. Ibid.

88. Luke 11:1.

89. Luke 11:9.

90. Luke 11:13.

91. Miller, They Cried to the Lord, 328.

92. Mark 7:27–28.

93. Osmer, Teaching Ministry of Congregations, 29.

94. Osmer identifies three central tasks of Paul’s teaching ministry, only one of which is catechesis. Exhortation and discernment are the other two tasks. While I appreciate these distinctions of the teaching ministry, I use catechesis broadly to encompass the whole process of learning to be a disciple of Jesus Christ.

95. Osmer, Teaching Ministry of Congregations, 237.

96. Solberg, “All that Matters,” 148.

97. Solberg, Compelling Knowledge, 19.

98. Solberg, “All that Matters,” 151.

99. 1 Cor 1:25.

100. Osmer, Teaching Ministry of Congregations, 244.

101. Osmer, A Teachable Spirit, 178–81.

102. Ibid., 253.

103. Osmer, Teaching Ministry of Congregations, 240.

104. See Osmer and Schweitzer, Religious Education between Modernization and Globalization, part III. In this section Osmer and Schweitzer engage four locations for religious education: paideia and society, congregation, religious dimension of individual, and the family.

105. For more on newcomer welcome processes in congregations see Duckworth, Wide Welcome.

106. Messy Church, as an idea, began at St. Wilfrid’s church in Cowplain, England, to reach children with God’s story. See http://www.stwilfridscowplain.co.uk/. The idea is now a movement—https://www.messychurch.org.uk/.

↑ Back to top

↑