Chapter 13 of 22

Chapter 9: Worshipping, Witnessing, and Wondering

Chapter 9: Worshipping, Witnessing, and Wondering

9

Worshipping, Witnessing, and Wondering

Integrating Proclamation, Evangelism, and Catechesis for God’s Mission Today

Thomas John Hastings

Introduction: Preachers and Teachers as Partners in the Mission of God

With some fear and trepidation, I once shared with a well-known New Testament scholar that, based on my reading of Paul’s letters and other relevant parts of the New Testament,186 it seems probable that, while the early itinerant ἀποστόλους (apostles), προφήτας (prophets), and εὐαγγελιστάς (evangelists) travelled from place to place, διδασκάλους (teachers or catechists) were the first “permanent clergy” to settle down in one place. Operating out of the theological conviction that it is “God who gives the growth,” the church’s first itinerant preachers were “planting” and settled teachers “watering” nascent seeds of faith.

I added that it is easy to overlook the implicit missiological reason these embryonic communities of faith required more settled catechists or educators. Namely, Gentile converts who had confessed faith in Jesus as the Christ had no knowledge of Israel’s Scriptures—the only Bible at the time—so they needed teachers who would commit to the time intensive work of catechesis. In time, a “proto-catechumenate” developed that integrated 1) Study of Scripture and confession of faith, 2) Participation in worship, and 3) Moral teaching and ethical discernment, enabling Christian faith to move beyond its original location in first-century Palestinian Judaism and eventually take root in societies within and beyond the Greco-Roman world. By the time of the third century document called the Apostolic Tradition,187 we know that pre–baptismal catechetical instruction often lasted several years, and it seems this educational practice played a significant role in shaping church doctrine, which found expression in early creedal summaries. J. N. D. Kelly claims, “It should be obvious that a wider background must be sought for the brief confessions of faith than the actual ceremony of baptism itself. Their roots lie not so much in the Christian’s sacramental initiation into the Church as in the catechetical training by which it was preceded.”188

I am happy to report that the New Testament scholar enthusiastically agreed with my thesis about the complementary work of itinerant preachers and settled teachers and thought it was a good description of what likely happened in the churches that were a fruit of the Gentile mission. He also confessed that he had never thought of the Jewish-Gentile dynamic in terms of cross-cultural mission, nor had he imagined catechetical practice as an engine driving the development of church doctrine as well as cross-cultural “translation” of Christian faith.

I concluded by telling my New Testament colleague that, had I not spent twenty years as a missionary working with Japanese pastors, congregations, and theologians, I would never have been sensitized to the implicit missional and theological dynamic at work in the communities “in front of” the New Testament writings. That is, I observed in the Japanese churches a missional situation analogous to the churches featured in the New Testament. Initially a result of the efforts of mostly North American missionaries, the 150–year–old Japanese Protestant churches are still struggling to find their distinctive local voice and to put down roots.

Canonical “Ways of Knowing”

Since the Protestant Reformers began with the normative sola scriptura principle, we will begin there, too. Old Testament scholar Walter Brueggemann shows how Israel’s Scriptures embody three distinct yet intimately related ways of knowing which he calls the “disclosure of binding” of the Torah, “the disruption for justice” of the Prophets, and “the discernment of order” of the Wisdom writings.189 Israel’s tripartite canon encompasses epistemic dimensions of continuity (Torah), discontinuity (Prophets), and contemporaneity (Wisdom).

Firstly, in Torah, the intergenerational transmission of Israel’s defining story pivots on the wonder of a child: “Why is tonight (Passover) different from all other nights?” Torah responds to the identity question of “Who are we?” with a “pre-doubt” confidence, reciting the core narrative of the Exodus and confession of faith (Shema Yisrael, “Hear, O Israel: The Lord is our God, the Lord alone”). The Exodus and Shema are the received parameters within which each new generation rediscovers its faith identity as a free gift of Yahweh.

Secondly, the Prophetic literature accompanies God’s people on a disorienting journey into a far country where they urgently ask, “Is there any word from the Lord?” In response to national calamity, moral corruption, external threat, or punishing exile, Israel’s prophets proclaim an unanticipated and subversive Word from the Lord—an “interruption for justice”—that is not easily managed by the priests who guard and teach Torah. The passion of the community is reawakened and renewed by prophets who are called, especially on behalf of the neglected members of the community (i.e., the poor, orphans, widows, and sojourners), to hold fast to the truth of divine justice, even in the face of agonizing experiences of suffering, oppression, marginalization, and loss. Not surprisingly, prophets are often ignored, vilified, or silenced, because they boldly deliver God’s Word, not from the sanctioned centers of power, but from the margins of the community. If Torah comforts the afflicted, prophecy afflicts the comfortable on behalf of “the least of these.”

Thirdly, as counterpoint and complement to the continuity of Torah and discontinuity of prophecy, Brueggemann calls the Wisdom writings the “most self–consciously educational”190 material in the Hebrew Scriptures. Characterized by “contemporaneity,” these writings treat the whole gamut of real problems people confront in their lives together. The Wisdom writings explore the relevance of the community’s knowledge and test the limits of their understanding, especially when they face liminal situations. According to Brueggemann, in these writings “we are in touch with a mystery that cannot be too closely shepherded, as in the Torah, or protested against, as in the Prophets.”191 Here Israel discerns what may be believed with conviction while humbly acknowledging that some answers are known only to Yahweh.

Within this matrix of Torah, Prophets, and Wisdom, Israel’s spiritual life embraces the 1) salvation history taught by priests, 2) disruptive Word of divine justice proclaimed by prophets, and 3) the moral and ethical wisdom of Sage-Kings.

Arising out of Israel’s long experience in transmitting a centered yet dynamic faith that can withstand the scope of human experience, the earliest Christian churches took pains to carefully nurture adult converts and their children in 1) the worship of the God of Israel—revealed in Jesus Christ—who by the power of the Holy Spirit continues to be present to the community of faith through proclamation of the Word and sacramental enactment, 2) the witness of this community called to discern how to live faithfully in the face of variant personal, social, cultural, and political situations, and 3) through the catechetical practices of teaching and learning, the wonder of sharing the evangel and confession of Jesus Christ as Lord.

While the forms of the New Testament canon, of course, do not mimic Israel’s Torah, Prophets, and Wisdom, we can discern—as a heuristic device—an analogous substructure in the kerygma (preaching), parenesis (moral or ethical guidance or advice), and didache (teaching), interwoven within and across the Gospels, Acts, Letters, and Apocalypse. Under the guidance of the complementary work of itinerant preachers and settled teachers, earliest Christian practice recapitulated Israel’s tripartite epistemology, but now with a new focus on Jesus Christ as the one who has opened up God’s promises to Israel to the whole world. 1) In the worship of the community of faith, they heard the preaching of the Gospel of Jesus Christ and participated in sacraments he had instituted, 2) In their daily lives, they bore witness to Jesus Christ as Lord of life, 3) In educational settings marked by wonder, they grew in their understanding of Scripture and confession of faith in Jesus Christ.

Confession of Faith and Catechesis in the Reformed Tradition

Until the late nineteenth-early twentieth century, catechisms were a key feature in the churches rooted in the magisterial reform. As a fruit of the humanist turn to original sources (ad fontes), reformers like Martin Luther and John Calvin had some knowledge of the adult catechumenate in the ancient churches. They knew, for example, of the focus on teaching the baptismal creed, participating in liturgy, and offering moral exhortations. Vexed especially by the moral laxity and ignorance of basic Christian doctrine in their own time, they envied the ancient dictum that linked Christian worship (lex orandi), life (lex vivendi), and belief (lex credendi).

Originally written for clergy and male heads of households, the reformed catechisms were expositions of the Apostles Creed, the Ten Commandments, and the Lord’s Prayer and sacraments, though not necessarily in that order. These catechisms had an enormous impact on subsequent generations. Even as late as 1959, Scottish theologian T. F. Torrance complained that the overall educational level of the Scottish people had fallen with the demise of the Westminster Shorter Catechism.192

As we rethink the place of catechisms today, we should also remember that small editions of the Bible were not common until the eighteenth century. Except for churches, schools, and wealthy households, personal possession of a complete Bible was rare until the early nineteenth century, when the practice of private reading became more common among the laity. With the heightened individualism that accompanied the Enlightenment turn to the self, the practice of private reading eventually led to the novel innovation of the private interpretation of Scripture. The worldwide Sunday School and missionary movements further strengthened this trend toward private biblical interpretation.193 Thus it is hard for us to appreciate that, long before the Bible was in the hands of the faithful, catechisms functioned as an important aid in understanding biblical sermons in worship.

As the Presbyterian Book of Confessions shows, there has always been a strong conviction about the relationship between the church’s confession of faith and catechesis in the reformed stream of Protestantism. For example, the Second Helvetic Confession’s Chapter 25, 5.233, “Youth to Be Instructed in Godliness,” integrates careful instruction from the Ten Commandments on how to live, the Apostle’s Creed on how to believe, and the Lord’s Prayer and sacraments on how to worship.194

While the catechism was too often reduced to a litmus test for orthodoxy in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, the Protestant Reformers had richer and broader educational objectives in mind when they introduced this new genre as an aid in nurturing a more vibrant public worship of God and witness to the gospel. By analogy with the Old Testament, Calvin emphasized the offices of Priest, Prophet, and King recapitulated in the person, message, and work of Jesus Christ. He also depicted Christ as the singular exemplar for the life of faith lived Coram Deo (“in the presence of God”).

While much good work happens in congregations today under the heading of Christian education, many churches have lost the sense of the integral connection between Christ’s work as Priest, Prophet, and King, or the connection between what Christians learn in more explicit educational settings, what Christians learn in worship, and what Christians learn from being sent forth, again and again, to live out their vocation in the world as Christ’s “afflicted but well-equipped witnesses.”195

Because of the unresolved tensions between the traditional reformed approach to catechesis, the Bible–centered Sunday school movement, and the child-centered religious education movement, the educational ministries of Protestant congregations today are confused, tending to emphasize one of the following: 1) church–centered socialization based on teaching of Bible and/or doctrine, 2) individual–centered conversion or spirituality, or (3) society–centered witness and reform. While each of these emphases embodies an important aspect of the Reformed tradition, there is an unfortunate tendency to focus on one dimension while neglecting one or two of the others. One wonders if this fragmented approach to the Christian life may be one reason for the deep and enduring divisions between traditional, evangelical, and liberal churches today.

Confession of Faith and Catechesis: A Contemporary Case

In the mid-1990s, the Presbyterian Church (USA) General Assembly authorized the preparation of two new catechisms. Belonging to God: A First Catechism and The Study Catechism were approved in 1998 as provisional study documents for educational use in congregations and families. These contemporary catechisms, which were prepared by a committee of leading systematic and practical theologians, including Rick Osmer, were intended to strengthen the doctrinal understanding and Reformed identity of Presbyterians.

Here I need to touch briefly on the historical background behind this development. Recognizing that post-World War II America no longer resembled the republica christiana ideal of the Protestant Reformers and that the Westminster Standards were no longer functioning as the de facto basis of Presbyterian confession of faith or catechesis, in the 1960s the PC (USA) drafted and approved a new confession (The Confession of 1967) and expanded its Book of Confessions to include the following ancient, Reformation, post-Reformation, and contemporary documents: The Nicene Creed (381), The Apostles’ Creed (second–eighth centuries), The Scots Confession (1560), The Heidelberg Catechism (1563), The Second Helvetic Confession (1561), The Westminster Confession of Faith, The Shorter Catechism, The Larger Catechism (1647), The Theological Declaration of Barmen (1934), and A Brief Statement of Faith (1983).196

The two new catechisms must be situated within these developments. Given the move away from a “Westminster only” stance, there was a sense among some pastors and theologians that we needed new, contemporary catechisms to help guide the faithful. Five years after their adoption, the denomination’s Office of Theology and Worship reported, “The catechisms have not yet fulfilled their promise in the life of the church. Misunderstanding of the nature of catechisms (confusing them with rote memorization, for example) and insufficient awareness of possibilities for their use in a wide variety of educational, liturgical, and devotional settings, have restricted the catechisms’ use and limited their value in the church. The Office of Theology and Worship urges that renewed efforts be made to incorporate fully the new catechisms into the church’s ministry of the Christian formation of disciples.”197 In spite of some early enthusiasm, these catechisms are either neglected or completely unknown by most Presbyterians today.

While I think that this renewed interest in catechesis reflects a positive acknowledgment of how the lines between the gospel, church, and culture have become so blurred in North America, this new interest is not an unambiguous development—a point well expressed by postliberal theologian George Lindbeck in the final chapter of The Nature of Doctrine. On the one hand, Lindbeck says that “This method [his “cultural-linguistic” view of doctrine] resembles ancient catechesis more than modern translation. Instead of redescribing the faith in new concepts, it seeks to teach the language and practices of the religion to potential adherents.” On the other hand, Lindbeck is gravely pessimistic about any practical application of his proposal in North America. “Western culture is now at an intermediate stage . . . where socialization is ineffective, catechesis impossible, and translation a tempting alternative . . . ” Lindbeck leaves the reader with the paradoxical conclusion that, while his postliberal proposal has a family resemblance to the catechesis of the early church, a renewal of catechesis today is ruled out because the churches today are so completely enculturated. “In the present situation, unlike periods of missionary expansion, the churches primarily accommodate to the prevailing culture rather than shape it.”198

By way of contrast, in 2002 a Japanese translation of the new PC (USA) catechisms was published,199 and they have been used widely in churches and Christian schools. More importantly, in 2004 this translation helped motivate the National Union of Presbyterian Churches to write their own catechism as well as a church school curriculum based on that catechism.200 Given the very different missional situation of the minority Japanese churches, perhaps their interest in catechesis is not surprising.

When I was appointed to serve as a missionary in Japan, a wise Japanese pastor told me, “Welcome to Rome in A.D. 150.” On the surface, the situation of the churches in Japan and the US are very different. We might say that Japan is a “pre-Christendom” and the US is a “post-Christendom” context. In spite of significant differences, Christians in Japan and the US share one deep resemblance: we cannot assume spiritual support and encouragement from our societies. This fact distinguishes us from Christians at the time of the Reformation when the cuius region, eius religio (“whose realm, his religion”) principle held sway, albeit within the smaller unit of nation, principality, or city-state.

Worship, Witness, and Wonder: Integrating Perception, Action, and Thinking Coram Deo

I want to conclude by proposing worshipping, witnessing, and wondering as complementary practices found in communities of faith marked by a turning from self-centeredness to self-giving, “redemptive love” after the kenotic pattern of Jesus Christ and in the power of the Holy Spirit.

Worship as Practice in Loving God

The God revealed in Jesus Christ is glorified in the public worship of communities of faith gathered in the power of the Holy Spirit. As T. F. Torrance says, “when we encounter the Truth in Christ, we discover that we are at variance with the Truth, in a state of rebellion and enmity toward it, so that the way of knowledge is the way of surrender and acknowledgment through self-denial and repentance.”201 The worship of the gathered community is accompanied by other spiritual practices such as prayer, meditation, fasting, spiritual reading, study, self-examination, mutual discernment, hospitality, etc. By participation in practices of worship, our desire to love, follow, and know God is renewed through confession of sin, singing, the preaching and hearing of the Word, prayer, celebration of the sacraments, and being sent forth into the world as Christ’s witnesses. The canonical referents here are prophecy and kerygma, thus the focus in worship is on Jesus Christ as Prophet.

Witness as Practice in Following God

The vocation of Christians as participant witnesses to the ongoing mission of God is formed, renewed, and sustained in self-giving, redemptive interactions with neighbors, especially those in particular need, in and beyond the community of faith. Afflicted witnesses reflect the pattern of “redemptive love” revealed by Jesus as we learn of him in the Gospel narratives. “Redemptive love” may be described in folksy ethical terms in the following way: “You mess up, I clean up your mess, but do not assign any blame.”202 By participation in liberating practices of witness, our determination to follow, know, and love God is renewed by welcoming, loving, forgiving, standing with, and caring for others in the way of Jesus. As St. Francis purportedly said, “Preach the gospel, and if necessary, use words.” The canonical referents here are Wisdom and parenesis, thus the focus in witness is on Jesus Christ as Sage-King.

Wonder as Practice in Knowing God

Scripture, confession of faith, church history, theology, literature, and devotional writings are studied, interrogated, and personalized in the company of other pilgrims and in an awareness of “the great cloud of witnesses” who have come before. By participation in educative practices of wonder, our longing to know, love, and follow God is renewed through sustained study, conversation, and reflection. Here, “wonder” is not simply the sense of “pre-doubt” awe with which the people of Israel approached Torah, but it also embraces the modern sense of interrogation, suspicion, and doubt, as when we say, “I wonder if that is really the case.” The canonical referents here are Torah and didache, thus the focus in wonder is on Jesus Christ as Priest.

It is easy to see how the practices of worshipping, which accent perception, witnessing, which accent action, and wondering, which accent thinking, flow into and support each other over a lifetime of discipleship.

For Jesus Christ to become the center of a person’s or community’s life, that person or community will be transformed in relation to the triune God revealed in Jesus Christ, commitment to God’s mission in the world, and grounding in Scripture and confession of faith. This distinctively Christian epistemology embraces loving, following, and knowing Jesus Christ, and while loving, following, and knowing may seem like unrelated activities, Israel, the church, and other long-surviving religious traditions have intuited from long ago that human perception, action, and thinking are deeply intertwined. In spite of the “disembodied” epistemology of the modern West, which, for the sake of clear, rational, scientific analysis, sought to disassociate thought from feeling and action, ancient peoples knew what contemporary neuroscience is rediscovering, which is the irreducibly embodied confluence of thought, feeling, and action.203

The “ways of knowing” specific to Christian faith are participatory and holistic, encompassing all dimensions of life. Intuiting that the practices of loving, following, and knowing Jesus Christ are deeply interconnected, worshipping, witnessing, and wondering communities engage in proclamation, evangelism, and catechesis204 as fitting responses to God’s mission. Keeping the focus on God’s self–emptying mission in Jesus Christ and in the power of the Holy Spirit, Christian practices of proclamation, evangelism, and catechesis are never seen as ends in themselves and always conducted with humility and assurance.

In our own time, while the settings for worshipping, witnessing, and wondering may be distinct, it is important to reconceive these practices as a unified whole. To do this, it is helpful to see these practices christologically, i.e., in analogy to the unity of Word, person, and act in the God/person Jesus Christ.

What might congregations do in their response to the ever-sufficient grace of God in Jesus Christ to help nurture and sustain a community of worshipping, witnessing, and wondering disciples across a lifetime? While the church’s ministries will embrace all three of these movements, it is important to remember that our efforts are always contingent on Christ who comes to us “clothed with his Gospel” (Calvin) and the mediation of the Holy Spirit. While God’s people may be divided and broken—sometimes desperately so—Christ’s Word, Person, and Act are always inseparably one.205 Since he is the singular focus of our loving, following, and knowing, the church’s preachers and teachers need not obsess about achieving some balance between the various modes of knowing. As we keep the focus on Jesus Christ as he comes to us in the Gospel narratives, we discover that worship is not limited to feelings, witness is not just about moral exhortations to right action, and wonder is not limited to our cognitive function.

We can only touch briefly here on the key question of divine agency. In an article entitled “Practical Theology and Theological Education,” James Fowler pointed out the following “two deep sources of concern and reservation” regarding the leading contemporary approaches to practical theology: 1) Their failure to account for divine agency; and (2) their imprisonment in an Enlightenment rationality.206 Under the sway of the modernist epistemology, practical theologians have been reticent to say much about the decisive role of divine agency in the church’s practices of proclamation, evangelism, and catechesis. Seeking to address this significant omission, James E. Loder wrote, “In practical theology the disciplines that will help us understand human action must be put into a constructive relationship with the disciplines that enable us to understand who God is from God’s self-disclosure. The systematic task of practical theology, then, is to preserve the integrity of such disciplines and . . . relate them so as to gain a more comprehensive understanding of the phenomenon in question than any one such discipline may be able to provide by itself. At the same time, such a relation should enrich both sides of this interdisciplinary endeavor.”207

Theologically, the ordering of the intersecting spheres of worship, witness, and wonder picks up on the ancient pattern of lex orandi est lex credendi et vivendi (“The rule of prayer is the rule of belief and of life”). While we may be reluctant to say too much about divine agency in relation to these ecclesial practices, we must not be silent by saying less than is warranted by Scripture. By refocusing our practices of proclamation, evangelism, and catechesis on the completed work of Christ as Priest, Prophet, and King, we not only keep before us an exemplar of how these ways of knowing interpenetrate and complement one another, but we may also expect the Holy Spirit to lift us continually beyond our natural capacities to seek “our spiritual lives not in ourselves but in Christ, and so find the real truth of our own personal being in union with our Lord and Savior.”208

Bibliography

A Clear Catechism. Sekikawa Yasuhiro and the National Association of Presbyterians. Tokyo: Kirisuto Shinbumsha, 2004–2011.

Barth, Karl. Church Dogmatics: Volume IV/3. Edinburgh: T & T Clark, 1962.

Brueggemann, Walter. The Creative Word: Canon as a Model for Biblical Education. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1982.

Catechisms for All Ages. Translated by Thomas John Hastings, et al. Sapporo: Ichibaku, 2002.

Fowler, James W. “Practical Theology and Theological Education: Some Models and Questions.” Theology Today 42 (1985) 43–58.

Hastings, Thomas John. Seeing All Things Whole: The Scientific Mysticism and Art of Kagawa Toyohiko (1888–1960). Eugene, OR: Pickwick, 2015.

Johnson, Mark. “Embodied Understanding.” Frontiers in Psychology 6 (2015) 875. https://www.frontiersin.org/article/10.3389/fpsyg.2015.00875.

J. N. D. Kelly, Early Christian Creeds. London: Longman, 1972.

Lindbeck, George. The Nature of Doctrine: Religion and Theology in a Postliberal Age. Philadelphia: Westminster, 1984.

Loder, James E. “Normativity and Context in Practical Theology: The Interdisciplinary Issue.” In Practical Theology: International Perspectives, edited by Friedrich Schweitzer and J. A. van der Ven, 359–81. New York: Peter Lang, 1999.

Presbyterian Church (USA). MINUTES of the 215th GENERAL ASSEMBLY, PART I JOURNAL (Louisville: Office of the General Assembly, 2003), 565.

Schaff, Philip. The Creeds of Christendom (Volume III): The Creeds of the Evangelical Protestant Churches. New York: Harper and Brothers, 1877.

Torrance, Thomas F. The School of Faith: The Catechisms of the Reformed Church. London: James Clarke and Company, 1959.

The Constitution of the Presbyterian Church (USA), Part I: The Book of Confessions, in The Second Helvetic Confession, Chapter XXV, “Of Catechizing and Comforting and Visiting the Sick.” Louisville, KY: Office of the General Assembly, 2002.

Westerhoff, John H. and O. C. Edwards, A Faithful Church: Issues in the History of Catechesis. Wilton, CT: Morehouse-Barlow, 1981.

186. 1 Cor 12:28; Gal 6:6; Rom 12:6–8; Eph 4:11; Jude 3; 2 Tim 1:13, 4:3, Titus 1:9; Heb 6:2.

187. There are significant textual problems with this work, but generally scholars agree that it was written around 215 and probably reflects practices common to that period; cf. Westerhoff and Edwards, A Faithful Church, 50.

188. Kelly, Early Christian Creeds, 50.

189. Brueggemann, The Creative Word.

190. Ibid., 68.

191. Ibid., 71.

192. Torrance, The School of Faith, xxix.

193. See “The Doctrinal Basis of the Evangelical Alliance, A.D. 1846,” Article Two: “The right and duty of private judgment in the interpretation of the Holy Scriptures” in Schaff, The Creeds of Christendom, 827.

194. The Constitution of the Presbyterian Church, 110.

195. Barth, Church Dogmatics IV/3, 481.

196. In 2016, the General Assembly also approved the Confession of Belhar (1986), which came out of the South African church’s struggle against apartheid.

197. Presbyterian Church (USA), MINUTES of the 215th GENERAL ASSEMBLY, PART I JOURNAL (Louisville: Office of the General Assembly, 2003), 565.

198. Lindbeck, The Nature of Doctrine, 132–33.

199. ヘイスティングス、田中、神代訳、『みなのカテキズム』、一麦出版社、 2002年 [Catechisms for All Ages, translation by Hastings, Tanaka, and Kojiro].

200 『明解カテキズム』、関川/泰寛と『カテキズム教案』、全国連合長老会、キリスト新聞社, 2004–2011年 [A Clear Catechism, Kekikakwa Yasuhiro with the National Association of Presbyterians].

201. Torrance, The School of Faith, xxxv.

202. This view of “redemptive love” is indebted to the work of Kagawa Toyohiko. See Hastings, Seeing All Things Whole, 48–105.

203. Johnson, “Embodied Understanding,” 875.

204. These days, evangelical traditions use the term discipleship and mainline Protestants opt for spiritual formation, but we have chosen the classical term.

205. Torrance, The School of Faith, xxxii.

206. Fowler, “Practical Theology and Theological Education,” 56.

207. Loder, “Normativity and Context in Practical Theology,” 359–81.

208. Torrance, The School of Faith, xxxvii.

↑ Back to top

↑