Chapter 10 of 22

Chapter 6: Re-Grounding Theological Education

Chapter 6: Re-Grounding Theological Education

6

Re-Grounding Theological Education

Nathan T. Stucky

Every fall, a new crop of eager seminary students arrives at Princeton Theological Seminary (PTS). Upon arrival, the new cohort yields to the same fate as generations of students who preceded them: new student orientation. They undergo this orientation to their seminary education in the same space where they will soon take requisite survey courses that are designed to lay a proper foundation for theological education: Intro to Old Testament, Systematic Theology, Church History. They sit in auditorium-style seating, rows of chairs slightly arced, all facing a lectern that sits front and center.

More happens in this space than most realize. Here, the journey of formal theological education begins. The space acts on the learning and the learning community. It encourages certain ways of being and learning. It limits others. Furthermore, the impact of this space goes beyond shaping the learning community. This is, after all, a seminary. The space impacts theologies. It shapes how those in the space understand the life and being of God. Assumptions about theology and theological education necessarily bend depending on the learning environment and how the learning environment is utilized.

Students and faculty sit in lecture halls, seminar rooms, and libraries, studying the God who made the heavens and earth, who wrapped divinity in matter through incarnation, and who invited disciples to remember the incarnate One through bread and wine, grain and grape. But there’s a problem: this learning takes place in a space removed from the very content of the curriculum. This learning happens in lecture halls where interior walls divide one course of study from another and where walls of literal stone often divide learners from the soil, trees, and the ground that surround them.

Of course, formal theological education—either in academy of congregation—has never been reduced completely to a lecture hall (consider dining and fellowship halls, lawns and dorms). Yet the irony remains: Students study Creator, creation, and incarnation while divided from creation, each other, and the very land and people who bear grain and grape in the first place. How can we as teachers and learners in theological education possibly know this God while such a division persists? How did this division come about? What might it look like to heal this division? What new possibilities for ministry and theological education might emerge on this journey to healing?

This chapter wrestles with these questions. In it, I want to explore the history of Christian faith in the West to begin understanding the origins of this division; I want to explore the division as uniquely theological—that is, deeply reflecting and impacting our convictions about the life and being of God; and I want to look at recent examples of theological education at Princeton Theological Seminary. Hopefully, these examples point forward to a theologically robust and less divided future. Ultimately, I will suggest that faithful formation of communities according to the deepest theological convictions of the Judeo-Christian tradition requires an intimate and intentional relationship with creation. Anything less risks obscuring rather than unveiling the very image of the triune God.

How Did We Get Here? Willie James Jennings and The Christian Imagination

In his book The Christian Imagination, Willie James Jennings works primarily to articulate the origins of race. He digs into centuries of history in order to articulate the very beginnings of colonialism. Yet before digging into the depths of this history, Jennings starts his book in the garden of his childhood home. Jennings’s mother knew this garden intimately. It was a source of life for her and her family, yet the story Jennings tells is not one of intimate knowing, but rather of bewildering anonymity.

On a summer day when Jennings was twelve, two men from a local Reformed Church visited Jennings and his mother in this garden. They came on a missionary journey to share about their church and its ministries. Yet even though the men came from a congregation that sat just two hundred yards from the backyard garden where they stood, they arrived as strangers, completely oblivious to the vibrant Christian faith already flourishing in the Jennings home. Spatial proximity failed to predict any accompanying neighborly intimacy. Not only did the men not know the Jennings family, they also failed to inquire about them. They came to talk, not listen, to give, not receive. The strangeness of the encounter lingers with Jennings to this day. He asks, “Why did they not know us?”129 Jennings’ pursuit of answers to this question leads him ultimately to his deep exploration of the genesis of colonialism and the advent of racial logic.

Though the full scope of Jennings’s work is intricate and multilayered beyond what I can cover here, a central part of his argument connects with the aforementioned division in contemporary theological education. Jennings argues that the colonial moment—the moment when racial logic and destruction spread like cancer throughout the world—that moment depended on and grew out of a division between human identity and land in the mind of the colonizer. He writes, “Colonialism established ways of life that drove an abiding wedge between the land and peoples.”130

Jennings recognizes vast political and economic forces at work as colonialism emerges. Empires seek expansion—more land and more resources—yet the full force of Jennings’s argument lies beyond and beneath politics and economics. Jennings doesn’t merely describe the wedge between land and identity that propels colonialism and racial logic. He gets behind the division to the theology that drives it.

Jennings sees supersessionism as the major theological error here, and he traces its beginnings back as least as far as the fifteenth century. Within this view the church replaces Israel as God’s chosen people. Supersessionism then combines with doctrines of papal authority and apostolic succession to bloat the church’s sense of itself. Church and empire conflate, believing Christ has handed all authority over, and ownership of creation, to the church for the purpose of the salvation of the world and the expansion of the empire.131 Thus, there is no such thing as seizing another people’s land because Christ has already given all lands to the colonizer; the colonizer becomes the (white) norm of Christ-likeness; and all lands and peoples are subject to the dominion and judgment of the colonizer. Resistance provokes forced submission . . . in the name of Christ. This, of course, is heresy, and it all coincides with the division between identity and land, space, and place.

More accurately, the division between identity and land, space and place is the theological error. The colonizers fail to recognize God as a “landed” or “placed” God. They forget the geography, culture, ethnicity, and landscape inherent to the identity of the Jewish Jesus, the Galilean. They lose sight of the intimate interconnections among God, people, and land inherent to the faith of the One they profess to represent. They forget that revelation of God’s identity and experience of God’s presence have always been tied to particular lands and places—Adam and Eve in the garden, Abraham and Sarah at the oaks of Mamre, Jacob at Bethel, Jesus at Nazareth.

This theological misperception—the loss of the intimate link between land and God’s identity—yields a twofold anthropological misperception. On one hand, as colonizers lose sight of an intimate connection between land and identity within the life of God, they also lose sight of it within themselves. Their own identity is divided from the land. On the other hand—and of utmost importance for Jennings’s broader argument—the colonizers fail to see themselves as a people adopted by someone else’s God. They fail to see that the gospel has already been transposed from the land, language, and culture of its first audience into their own land, language, and culture.132 They fail to see that the God of Israel has come to them.

This is the error of supersessionism. Church supersedes Israel, oblivious to the fact that the identity of the God they profess to serve utterly depends on Israel. In some sense the very name Israel signals the loss. To say Israel is to express an identity irreducible to either land or people. And when this theological error enmeshes with insatiable colonial hunger, the consequences are devastating. As Jennings notes, we have barely begun wrestling with the consequences of this error. We struggle to even perceive the error because we are buried so deeply inside of it.133

In thinking about the emergence of colonialism, the destruction of lands and peoples that follows in its wake, and the theological error that Jennings describes, a simple question about the incarnation helps clarify the error at work here. The question is, how did Christ enter the world? Some would say the world longed for a conquering emperor—a display of force that would set the world aright. Instead, the all-powerful Creator of the universe comes as an infant child to an unwed teen mother with livestock and lowly shepherds keeping watch. The Lord of the universe comes to a particular land, a particular time, and a particular place, and before engaging any public ministry spends decades learning. Jesus learns the language, the culture and customs, the land and geography, the food and the festivals, and only after these decades of simply being native to his place does he begin a public ministry.

For the purposes of this chapter, we may say that through the incarnation, Christ enters a new land. Contrast Christ’s entry into a new land with that of the colonizers. The contrast is stunning. Rather than immersing themselves in the lands, cultures, and languages of indigenes, colonizers impose themselves and their fractured, landless identities, leaving the bodies of native people and native lands scourged. Jennings casts this tragedy of colonialism in the terms of failed hospitality.

Other peoples and their ways of life had to adapt, become fluid, even morph into the colonial order of things, and such a situation drew Christianity and its theologians inside habits of mind and life that internalized and normalized that order of things . . . Indeed, it is as though Christianity, wherever it went in the modern colonies, inverted its sense of hospitality. It claimed to be the host, the owner of the spaces it entered, and demanded native peoples enter its cultural logics, its ways of being in the world, and its conceptualities.134

Again, consider Christ. Christ arrives in the world as utterly dependent guest. Even in the years of Jesus’ public ministry, we find Jesus again and again a guest at someone else’s table. Yes, Jesus does ultimately extend an invitation to his table, but there again we encounter not a division between the life and work of this God and the created, material world, but rather a most intimate union: teacher, disciples, table, bread and wine inextricably bound together at a meal celebrating God’s deliverance of the Israelites from captivity on a journey to a promised land. The Savior enters intimately into the life and mess of the world in order that the world may know its life in Christ. The contrast with the colonial agenda again stands out starkly. Instead of domination or forced subjugation, the image here is of mutual indwelling rooted deeply in the earth—identities indelibly linked to land, neighbor, Christ, and all the particularities of place.

The comparison of Christ and colonizer should lead those of us in contemporary theological education to ask difficult questions. The mission of both Christ and colonizer is educational. Both seek to shape others into their images, but their methods and their accompanying relationships to land and space could not be more different. We must ask, then, whether contemporary theological education is repeating the errors of colonialist education in its ignorance of land and commodification of land and space, or whether it follows instead the incarnate One. The current separation between theological education and land suggests the colonialist mentality may be more operative than we realize.

If Jennings is right, then the division between creation and contemporary theological education emerges in part from our own failures to recognize and welcome the God of the garden, the God of Abraham and Sarah at the oaks of Mamre, the God of Jacob at Bethel, and the God incarnate in Jesus Christ in Nazareth. If Jennings is right, it is possible that we have separated God’s identity from the material world and in so doing unwittingly put God and creation in separate and unrelated categories.

The tragedies here are multiple. The vast train of exploited people and lands lies in the wake of this error. This may seem like a distant reality in the contemporary lecture hall or sanctuary, but we should not underestimate the risks. The risk is that theological education fails to live up to its own mission. With the error of dividing identity and land, we risk repeating the tragic cycles of unknowing that plague the colonial imagination. Colonizers never really knew the lands or the peoples they colonized, and that failure of knowledge grew logically out of a failure to rightly know the God they claimed to serve.

The opportunities here are also multiple. If the division between land and identity is false and obscures the identity of the triune God, then what extraordinary possibilities might ensue from a reintegration? What insights about and experiences of God, neighbor, and land might emerge if we find a way through this division—if we seek this God not divided from creation, but rather intimately connected to it? How might we know ourselves and this God anew by rediscovering the intimate interconnections of land, space, place, and identity?

Farminary: An Experiment in Re-Grounding Theological Education

Though I didn’t know it at the time, when I arrived as a student at PTS, I was a living example of the division Willie James Jennings describes. I grew up farming in Kansas. After college, I served as a youth pastor for a half-dozen years, and then returned to farming. I loved farming, but I had a problem. While farming, I couldn’t shake a sense of call to ministry. Thus, I moved from Kansas to PTS so I could attend seminary. I left the farm convinced that my love of agriculture and my sense of call to ministry were two different things. God calls people away from land, not into it. Or so I thought . . . and so I lived the division that Jennings describes.

By God’s grace, seminary challenged the division. A good friend learned that I had been farming before coming to seminary and proceeded to share a dream. What would it look like to integrate fully accredited theological education and small-scale sustainable agriculture? It took the better part of a decade for the seed of that dream to germinate, but it finally did. Along the way, PTS realized it already owned a twenty-one-acre farm, and the farm sat less than three miles from the main campus.

In the beginning, the Farminary grew out of a simple conviction. The skills, proficiencies, and sensibilities of the adept agrarian, farmer, or gardener broadly overlap with the skills, proficiencies, and sensibilities of the adept pastor or church leader. Both know how to tend life, pay attention to seasons, mind limits, and ask for help. Both know how to read a context and assess what it can bear. They recognize both vitality and its lack. They know how to respond in ways that restore vitality. They understand the interconnectedness of life and death.

Thus, we began the experiment. I taught a pilot course at the farm that considered how agrarian thought and practice might impact our understandings of education. The course explored how time working a garden, growing food, and sharing meals might influence the aims, goals, curriculum, methods, roles of teacher and learner, context, and assessment of Christian theological education. In the midst of the pilot course, PTS committed to officially embarking on the Farminary journey. We have been teaching courses at the farm ever since.

Now, a few short years into the journey, the conviction regarding overlapping skills and proficiencies remains, yet Jennings’s work opens possibilities and responsibilities that were not initially imagined. I suspected the farm would transform students’ doctrines of creation, Eucharist, and resurrection. I believed it would impact their images of theological education. I did not realize the depth of the division between the seminary community and the land, even as I did not realize the depth of the division within myself. I also could not have anticipated the signs of hope that have emerged along the way.

During one fall semester at the Farminary, I had the privilege of teaching “Text and Terrain,” a one–credit Old Testament course, at the Farminary with Professor and Old Testament scholar Jacqueline Lapsley. As part of the course, we read Old Testament texts that were rich in agrarian imagery; we gardened; and we asked two simple questions: How does our time in the text influence our time in the garden, and how does our time in the garden influence our interpretation of the texts?

Naturally, we read Genesis 2–4. Jacq brought the full force of her scholarly proficiency to the exploration. We considered the intimate relationship between humankind and the soil in Genesis 2:7. God forms adam (the first human) from the adamah (the humus). We also studied Genesis 2:15, where God places the first human in the garden to “till it and keep it,” as it is commonly translated. The terms till and keep struggle to convey the full sense of the Hebrew verbs, abad and shamar. Throughout the Old Testament, scholars more frequently translate abad, for example, as work or serve.135 Furthermore, the Old Testament also uses abad to describe humanity’s proper posture toward God. “Worship [abad] the Lord with gladness; come into his presence with singing” (Ps 100:2).

In other words, the Hebrew uses the same term to describe the posture of humankind to both God and the land. Land and God remain distinct, and worship is reserved for God alone, yet somehow the posture to God and land overlap. Participants in “Text and Terrain” studied all of this, drawing on Jacq’s expertise.

Some weeks later, Jacq—who had warned me of her lack of gardening proficiency before the course began—found herself planting carrots in the garden during our class, side by side with students. She knelt on her hands and knees and meticulously prepared a shallow groove in the soil. She then carefully placed the seeds one by one in the groove. As she worked (abad), it hit her. There in the garden, she embodied Genesis 2:15; her posture was that of service. Scripture for the Old Testament scholar came to life in a new way. Interdependence and interconnection came to light. She served the garden in service to the God who could bring about growth in hopes that she might ultimately receive life from both carrot and Creator.

So much could be said about this moment. It represents both the reality of the division between theological education and creation, and also the possibility of healing. Vast economic, political, and yes, theological forces lead teachers and students to identities divorced from the land. If Jennings is right, those forces have been growing roots for centuries, and they will not be overcome in an afternoon in the garden. Even so, I would like to think that something significant shifted in Jacq that day. The division was healed, even if only a little, and she knew herself, God, and creation in a new and more interconnected way. The shift importantly did not exclude rigorous intellectual engagement or scholarly precision. It did not even exclude the lecture hall. Rather, it depended on them. It just happened to also depend on a renewed and intentional relationship with creation integrated into the scholarly and intellectual pursuits.

Conclusion: Honoring Osmer

More than a decade ago, I arrived at Princeton Theological Seminary as a member of a fall cohort of new students. I underwent orientation in the lecture style room within the grand edifice of Stuart Hall. Having attended a very small undergraduate institution where I doubt I ever had a class with more than thirty students, the sheer scope of a teaching space with over a hundred students brought me up short.

To be clear, good things happen in lecture halls. I experienced faith-shaping, knowledge-building, Spirit-inspired lectures in that space. The deepest conviction of this chapter is simply that we cannot let the lecture hall and seminar room be the only spaces where intentional theological education happens. Theological education reduced to such spaces simply cannot sufficiently bear witness to the God in whose name we teach.

The work of Willie James Jennings and the experiences at the Farminary lead to questions about theological education and space or place. They invite us to consider where, exactly, knowledge of God grows. Where does new insight emerge? In what context does faith flourish? Yes, it can happen in a lecture hall, but God forbid it only happens there. There is knowledge and love of God that grows in the field and at the table that is simply not accessible in a lecture hall.

Jacq learned this in the garden. It is a lesson I first learned from Rick Osmer. I don’t remember reading it in one of his books, though I suspect that I did. It wasn’t an insight that clicked in an instant. As I recall, the insight came together thanks to the combination of two moments. The first moment occurred in a casual conversation, though I don’t remember where. It may have been on a class break during a doctoral seminar. It may have been a chance encounter in the library. I don’t remember the exact words, but it was something like, “There is knowledge and insight that emerges uniquely in the practice of ministry.”

Rick’s comment reflected one of his deep practical theological convictions. Practical theology is not merely applied theology. In that model, systematic theologians and dogmaticians do the theological heavy lifting. They discern the convictions about God’s life and being. Then practical theologians merely apply their insights out in the world.136 Osmer, as pastor, educator, and theologian, knew better. He had experienced better. His research and scholarship as a practical theologian convinced him of better, and he insisted on sharing the insight with his students.

His comment stayed with me not because a light went on in that moment, but because it didn’t. I wanted to understand what this pillar of practical theology was saying, but in that time and space, it eluded me. The insight—true to Osmer’s conviction—emerged later in a second moment. Again, I do not recall the exact time or place. It happened in ministry—while teaching, tending, planting, or maybe composting, and it was a harbinger of Jacq’s experience planting carrots. A light went on. New knowledge burst forth in a way that depended integrally on the teaching, tending, planting, or composting. I knew God in new ways in that moment, and that new knowledge of God depended on my practice of ministry. It never could have emerged in a library or lecture hall.137

My memory flashed back to Osmer’s comment. “There is knowledge and insight that emerges uniquely in the practice of ministry.” And I got it. This was what he meant.

His insight has been guiding me ever since.

I could not foresee anything like the Farminary when I began as a student at Princeton Seminary more than a decade ago. I think it is safe to say that Rick could not foresee it, either. In my mind, the initially unforeseen nature of the Farminary as an expression of vibrant theological education only demonstrates more fully the veracity and vitality of Osmer’s practical theological vision. Attentiveness to context, interdisciplinary exploration, courage to act, and the abiding conviction that the whole of life is the locus of theological reflection—the Farminary exists because of the careful interweaving of these things. So also, Rick’s practical theological vision.

The future of theological education in the church, academy, and world is much like the Farminary when I first arrived in Princeton in 2007 and sat as a student in one of Rick’s classes—completely unforeseen. Yet by God’s grace and Rick’s generosity of intellect and teaching, a practical theological framework exists that carries within itself the hope that the triune God is still at work throughout the whole creation, and new life and redemption, though presently unforeseen, are already coming into being in our midst.

Thank you, Rick. And thanks be to God.

Bibliography

Jennings, Willie James. The Christian Imagination: Theology and the Origins of Race. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2010.

———. “The Colonization of Land.” Class Lecture via Skype, EF 1520: Ecologies of Faith Formation, Princeton Theological Seminary, Princeton, NJ, October 10, 2016.

129. Jennings, The Christian Imagination, 1–4.

130. Ibid., 292.

131. Ibid., 28.

132. Jennings, “The Colonization of Land.”

133. In discussing the displacement at work in colonialism, Jennings notes that both colonizer and colonized are displaced. The critical difference, of course, is that the colonizer willingly leaves his home. This reality leads Jennings to acknowledge the depth of the challenge. “With this leaving [Europeans willingly leaving their homes] . . . one approaches the depths of this theological mistake. It will not be easy to articulate the material reality of displacement because it is the articulation of a loss from within the loss itself.” Jennings, The Christian Imagination, 37.

134. Ibid., 8.

135. For example, “Six days you shall work (abad), but on the seventh day you shall rest” (Exod 34:21).

136. Note the division between theology and creation explicitly at work in the applied theology model of theological education. In it theology happens in a secluded ivory tower, not in the world.

137. To be perfectly clear, the need for library and lecture hall remains. The point is to recognize their limits.

↑ Back to top

↑