Chapter 3 of 22

Foreword

Foreword

Foreword

Richard Osmer and the New Practical Theology

Friedrich Schweitzer

To introduce—and to highly recommend—a book which is both fascinating to read and honoring a friend and distinguished colleague is a pleasure and an honor for me. The academic work and personal commitment of Richard Osmer truly deserve our appreciation and his many achievements certainly call for a Festschrift that celebrates them by taking clues from Osmer’s work and by building upon his ideas and insights for the future. It is obvious to everyone who is familiar with Osmer and his work that in doing so, the focus must be on practical theology—the theological discipline to which he has contributed so much in his teaching and writing, his organizing and long-lasting leadership in many different capacities. Yet it is also obvious that, in this case, this topic must be approached in a special manner, with a constant eye on Osmer’s characteristic ways of understanding—and of doing—practical theology himself. In other words, the book must be—and in fact, is—about Osmer’s practical theology no less than about practical theology in general.

Not surprisingly, the various chapters in this fine volume often refer to Osmer’s work of teaching and research at Princeton Theological Seminary. With their many facets and different perspectives they testify to the depth and breadth of his work as well as to his unique gift of inspiring, encouraging, and guiding other people—colleagues, junior faculty, as well as students at various levels. Princeton Theological Seminary has been the primary stage on which Osmer’s many activities have been performed. Yet there is also another stage at a national and international level which has been no less characteristic of Osmer’s continued commitment and far-reaching influence. Most of all, in 1991, he was one of the eight founders of the International Academy of Practical Theology (IAPT) which he then, as its first convener, brought to Princeton in 1993, thus giving bone and flesh to the emerging idea of a platform for international exchange and cooperation in practical theology. Without him, this Academy would not have come into existence, and without his leadership it would never have been what is has become.

In order to understand and to appreciate Osmer’s special role in an international context, one has to be aware of the process through which the new practical theology emerged in the 1980s and how it continued to develop in the 1990s as well as into the new century until today. This is why I will offer a few observations concerning this particular dimension of Osmer’s work while not repeating the more encompassing account of his work in general provided so aptly by others in the ensuing introductory chapter.

That practical theology could, or ever should, become a theological discipline of equal standing with the other theological disciplines was not viewed as an option throughout most of the history of theology, especially not in the United States. Although there were major American figures in this history whose work was quite influential nationally as well as internationally—in pastoral counseling, for example, or in the research on religious development in childhood and adolescence—it was not before the 1980s that practical theology could seriously be considered an “emerging field” in the United States.1 Instead, practical theology appeared more like an addition to theology proper or as a useful but not research-oriented conveyor belt transporting the theology produced by the other disciplines into the various fields of church-related practice. Most of all, practical theologians like Osmer’s friend Don Browning and Osmer’s doctoral advisor James Fowler—together with a whole group of colleagues in other countries like Germany, the Netherlands, and South Africa—played a major role in this context.2 From early on in his work which was then strongly focused on Christian education, Osmer placed his views and interpretations into a broader context, by drawing on biblical theology as well as on the theology of the sixteenth-century Reformers but also on practical theology. His groundbreaking book A Teachable Spirit: Recovering the Teaching Office in the Church very clearly testifies to this.3 It also forecasts Osmer’s distinctive approach, which combines practical theology with a strong grounding in other theological disciplines that he considers indispensable interdisciplinary partners for practical theology. There is, to my knowledge, no other contemporary practical theologian who would base his or her work so clearly on in-depth biblical scholarship. Yet Osmer’s practical theology has never been biblical in a one-sided sense or biblicist in any sense. Instead, he manages to bring biblical insights into continued conversation with other perspectives, for example, from the social sciences or from cultural and literary studies. This clearly is the first distinctive characteristic of his approach.

While Osmer first used practical theology as a context that could broaden his views on Christian education, he later developed it as a topic of its own, setting forth his own model of practical theology with its well-known four tasks: the “descriptive-empirical task,” the “interpretive task,” the “normative task,” and the “pragmatic task.”4 This model builds upon the models developed in the 1980s, especially on Don Browning’s A Fundamental Practical Theology.5 Yet, it also takes these earlier understandings of practical theology beyond their original scope and, characteristically for Osmer’s view, puts a much clearer emphasis on the need for a practical theology in the service of praxis, not in any naïve manner but in the sense of normative evaluations and orientations for praxis. It is probably fair to say that it is the normative and the pragmatic tasks which ultimately are decisive in Osmer’s understanding. Yet, it is also obvious to him that the descriptive and interpretive tasks can never be side-stepped. It is the faithful attention to all four moments in the process of practical theology that marks Osmer’s approach—a particular balance between the normative and the empirical in which I see a second distinctive characteristic.

It is easy to see that Osmer’s interest in both praxis and practical theology is closely connected to his commitment to Christian congregations in which he sees an important embodiment of the Christian faith. Most of all, Osmer’s The Teaching Ministry of Congregations makes this evident.6 It also shows how Osmer’s early interest in the congregational task of teaching carries on in his later work but has been enriched and broadened in a number of important ways. First of all, there is a strong grounding in Pauline theology that now provides decisive directions for the understanding of what a Christian congregation needs to be and how the tasks of teaching are part of it. Second, there is the use of empirical approaches along the lines of congregational studies. Third, and not of least importance, there is a worldwide international-comparative perspective bringing experiences from South Korea, the United States, and South Africa into conversation with each other and with practical theology in general. In other words, the very concrete concentration on the congregation as a local form of Christianity goes hand in hand with Osmer’s continued attention to globalization as the horizon in which practical theology has to make sense today and that it therefore has to address even where it refers to local congregations. In a world that has gone global, the local has ceased to be the opposite of the global—an insight which Osmer includes in his approach to congregational research. Practical theology must therefore be rooted in international cooperation and must make use of international comparison, for example, concerning congregations in different parts of the world. Internationalizing practical theology can thus be considered another distinctive characteristic of Osmer’s approach.

International-comparative work of this kind can rarely be completed by one person alone. It is not surprising then that some of Osmer’s contributions concerning international studies were carried out in cooperation with colleagues from other countries, leading to books in joint authorship. This is true, among others, for Religious Education between Modernization and Globalization: New Perspectives on the United States and Germany (published with Friedrich Schweitzer/Germany), as well as for his most recent publication, The Future of Protestant Religious Education in an Age of Globalization (with Hyun-Sook Kim/South Korea and again Friedrich Schweitzer).7 In different ways, both of these books confirm the fruitfulness of Osmer’s understanding of doing practical theology in new ways. This discipline cannot do justice to its tasks anymore if it is not deeply aware of the far-reaching challenges which globalization brings with it not only in terms of the economy but also of culture, religion and education.

Another example of internationalizing research in practical theology is still under way, the major research project on confirmation work in the United States. This project evolved in dialogue with parallel research projects carried out in nine European countries.8 On several occasions the projects in the United States and in Europe crossed hands in joint consultations in Finland and in Germany. It will be most exciting to see the results from these projects and to evaluate these results comparatively and in terms of their implications for practical theology.

So far, I have tried to identify a number of characteristics which mark Osmer’s unique contribution to the advancement of practical theology. This emphasis remains important but it should not lead to the assumption that Osmer has been aiming for making one particular understanding of practical theology prevail, nationally or even internationally. While all scholars tend to favor their own approaches—why else would they maintain them?—Osmer’s way of dealing with the varieties of practical theology has been distinctive. He tries to offer different categories or disciplinary maps that allow for a deeper understanding of the different approaches and that can bring them into conversation with each other.

Two articles from Osmer’s rich bibliography deserve special mention in this context, both published—not by coincidence—in the International Journal of Practical Theology, for which Osmer served as one of the first acting editors for many years. The first of these articles is based on a lecture at one of the first meetings of the International Academy of Practical Theology. It attempts to provide a new kind of typology of different models of practical theology by showing how these models correspond to what Osmer calls different models of rationality: “rationality as argument,” “rationality as rhetoric,” “rationality as conversation,” and “rationality as postfoundational science.” This typology is meant to support international cooperation and dialogue in practical theology. “It is offered as a way of helping participants in the emerging international discussion of practical theology better understand their similarities and differences.”9 In other words, Osmer’s intention is to develop a map of the field in order to make dialogue in practical theology possible.

The second article I want to take up here also comes from the context of the International Academy of Practical Theology. It was developed in response to an address by Bonnie Miller-McLemore, then president of the International Academy. Among others, Osmer describes his understanding of the use of a practical theology framework instead of only doing work in one of the specialized sub-disciplines of, for example, homiletics, pastoral care, or Christian education. According to his understanding, practical theology brings people into discourse with each other who otherwise might not be aware of what they share. Moreover, practical theology has become a major field of ecumenical encounter and cooperation. All this, Osmer concludes, is only possible if the pluralistic character of practical theology is acknowledged: “No practical theologian today can pretend to speak for the whole, that is, for all practical theologians.” What then are they to do? “What they can do is to be forthright about the decisions informing their particular perspectives and locate them in relation to other, alternate perspectives.”10 For this reason Osmer continues by describing no less than six different “strands” in American practical theology alone: “Postmodern transforming practice strand,” “American hermeneutical strand,” “Dutch/South African empirical strand,” “Christo-praxis strand,” “American neo-Aristotelian practices strand,” and “American Barthian strand.”

These two examples can be seen as evidence of what I want to identify as another characteristic of Osmer’s views on practical theology and even more of himself as a person. In a certain way, it can be said that he applies the four tasks of practical theology to this discipline itself—by not only doing practical theology in one particular way (his own) but by reflecting on what is going on in this field, how it can be better understood and interpreted, and most of all, how it can be improved.

I have had the privilege of being in continued conversation with Rick Osmer for more than twenty-five years. Our shared endeavors brought us together in the United States as well as in Germany but also in many other parts of the world, for example, Scandinavia, South Africa, and South Korea, where we co-lectured in a number of places. Our collegial relationship has turned into a long-lasting personal friendship, also including our families. This is why I want to end this foreword by expressing my deep gratitude—not only for the many impulses I have received from him and for his inspiring publications—but also for the many years that we have been in touch and have been able to share so much which is dear to us, personally, academically, and religiously.

Bibliography

Browning, Don S. A Fundamental Practical Theology: Descriptive and Strategic Proposals. Minneapolis: Fortress, 1991.

———. Practical Theology: The Emerging Field in Theology, Church, and World. San Francisco: Harper & Row, 1983.

———. A Fundamental Practical Theology: Descriptive and Strategic Proposals. Minneapolis: Fortress, 1991.

Kim, Hyun-Sook, et al. The Future of Protestant Religious Education in an Age of Globalization New York: Waxmann, 2018.

Osmer, Richard R. Practical Theology: An Introduction. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2008.

———. A Teachable Spirit: Recovering the Teaching Office in the Church. Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 1990.

———. “Rationality in Practical Theology: A Map of the Emerging Discussion.” International Journal of Practical Theology 1 (1997) 11–40.

———.The Teaching Ministry of Congregations. Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 2005.

———. “Toward a New Story of Practical Theology.” International Journal of Practical Theology 16 (2012) 66–78.

Osmer, Richard R., and Friedrich Schweitzer. Religious Education between Modernization and Globalization: New Perspectives on the United States and Germany. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2003.

Schweitzer, Friedrich, and Johannes A. van der Ven, eds. Practical Theology—International Perspectives. Frankfurt: LIT, 1999.

Schweitzer, Friedrich, et al. Confirmation Work in Europe: Empirical Results, Experiences and Challenges. A Comparative Study in Seven Countries. Gütersloh: Gütersloher, 2010.

———. Youth, Religion and Confirmation Work in Europe. The Second Study. Gütersloh: Gütersloher, 2015.

1. Browning, Practical Theology,

2. See for example, Schweitzer and van der Ven, Practical Theology. This book also contains the early papers from the International Academy of Practical Theology.

3. Osmer, A Teachable Spirit.

4. Osmer, Practical Theology.

5. Browning, A Fundamental Practical Theology.

6. Osmer, The Teaching Ministry of Congregations.

7. Osmer and Schweitzer, Religious Education between Modernization and Glob-alization. Also Kim et al., The Future of Protestant Religious Education.

8. Schweitzer et al., Confirmation Work in Europe. Also Schweitzer et al., Youth, Religion and Confirmation Work in Europe.

9. Osmer, “Rationality in Practical Theology,”40.

10. Osmer, “Toward a New Story of Practical Theology,” 67.

↑ Back to top

↑