Chapter 1: An Introduction
1
An Introduction
The Four Moments of Richard R. Osmer:
The Making of a Practical Theologian Amidst Consensus and Conflict
This introduction functions as a kind of map for the book you are about to read. Like all maps, introductions must balance adequate detail with appropriate scale. Too much detail overwhelms the reader, rendering the map useless. Scale relates specific places to the bigger picture. Go too big and the map becomes useless. Get too granular and you miss many relationships between salient details. None of us goes on a road trip with either a globe or the architectural renderings of our house.1
What guides us is the story we hope to become part of. Stories and maps are time-honored partners. Robert Louis Stevenson’s Treasure Island was inspired by a map painted by his twelve-year-old stepson. Winnie-the-Pooh’s Hundred Acre Wood was A. A. Milne’s take on part of Ashford Forest in East Sussex. J. R. R. Tolkien (who mapped enemy trenches during World War I) doodled Middle Earth on one of his Oxford examination papers—and then spent years revising its coordinates, gluing new versions on top of old ones. As he explained: “If you’re going to tell a complicated story, you must work to a map; otherwise you’ll never make a map of it afterward.”2
Richard R. Osmer’s influence on the field of practical theology is just that: a complicated story, layered and mildly unpredictable, and this introduction serves as a kind of map to help you navigate the pages ahead. Osmer’s influence on North American practical theology is seismic; his writing and teaching helped re-establish the field as a contemporary theological discipline with immediate relevance for Christian life, especially for congregations. Osmer was central to forming the International Academy of Practical Theology in 1991 and is perhaps best known for conceiving the “consensus model” of practical theology—arguably the most accessible and widely used practical theological model in the world, thanks to the popularity of his book Practical Theology: An Introduction and to a generation of Osmerian protegees now teaching practical theology around the globe. Osmer not only helped reinvigorate an entire field of study that languished in Western theology after Schleiermacher, but his signature insistence that congregational practices like Christian education, youth ministry, spirituality, and evangelism are, in fact, deeply theological enterprises gave these fields new substance as well. By merging practical theology with the contemporary “practices” of Christian life discussion, Osmer’s approach to practical theology holds widespread appeal for scholars and reflective practitioners alike.
Yet when it comes to the study of practical theology, Osmer complicates things. He is more explorer than conqueror, more apt to follow bread crumbs than blueprints. His mark on the field of practical theology is the fruit of curiosity’s winding path to wisdom rather than a systematic effort to prove or disprove hypotheses. Along the way, he posts trail signs for those who follow, indicating paths more than prescribing them. He is famous among his students for becoming captivated by a new intellectual conversation partner (or rediscovering an old one) every two or three years, sometimes from the sciences, sometimes from the arts, sometimes from the theological disciplines (globalization, rhetorical theory, empirical research, children’s fantasy literature, critical realism, spiritual direction, Lesslie Newbigin, and Karl Barth have all had their turns). He takes a childlike delight in introducing this “friend” to his students as he explores every inch of what that conversation partner offers the practical theologian. Osmer’s capacity for intellectual friendship is so vast that he never discards a dialogue partner; he merely adds another seat at the table for the next “friend” to practical theology that he takes under wing.
Like all cartographers, Osmer has dedicated his life to interpreting the terrain of practical theology rather than adjudicating it, poking air vents in disciplinary conversations rather than sealing up their leaky seams. This habit gives his approach to practical theology—like his approach to teaching, scholarship, and Christian life generally—an agility that allows him to tack back and forth between intellectual spheres. Most of the adulation and criticism Osmer received throughout his career stemmed from his refusal to park his theories in the political or intellectual parking spots others imagined for him.3 Some of his books, especially those written for pastors, educators, or students, are direct, penetrating, clarifying. Others invite too many guests to the party: there is too much going on, too many pages, too many layers, too many characters, giving readers a glimpse of Osmer’s own busy imagination as they join him for a joyful, lurching magic carpet ride that lands (it does inevitably land) on a new contribution to practical theology or congregational practice in the final pages. In fact, each of Osmer’s books have gained a loyal following precisely because they reveal signposts to the faithful life that had become overgrown: the marks of the teaching ministry, the practices of congregations, the contours of spiritual direction or evangelism, the architecture of confirmation, and—most notably—the four moments of practical theological reflection.
This introduction, therefore, is intended to orient the reader to this volume and to the life of Richard R. Osmer. These two are related. The chapters ahead cover a number of important aspects of Osmer’s career: 1) his early career, focused on Christian education, 2) the deepening of his mid-career interest in Christian spirituality, 3) his late-career shift towards mission and evangelism, and 4) his persistent interest in practical theology as a field and discipline. These four moments resonate with the four moments of practical theology that Osmer identified and illuminated. But we advise you to approach this “map” to Osmer’s life and career in the same way he approaches his own claims: provisionally, as a take, a “best account” rather than as a final one.4 Maps, after all, tell stories better than they report facts: “Here be dragons,” or “This way to treasure,” or “At this point the water goes deeper.” Osmer views practical theology not simply as a field of inquiry but as a story about the way God and humanity reach for one another—an account of the intersection between divine and human action. The through-line in all of Osmer’s work is his insistence on making discourse about God central to every Christian practice, to the work of churches, and to the task of practical theological interpretation itself. Each author in this volume speculates on Osmer’s influence in this regard, especially as his work comes to bear on the practices of congregations.
Origin Stories
Osmer recalls that while his parents did not “wear their faith on their sleeves,” there was no doubt in his mind as a child that they understood their lives in terms of faith.5 Faith meant living a moral life not in a legalistic sense, but by discerning “the right thing” from evidence and deliberation and then choosing it. Moral choice required knowing who and whose you were. Three years old when his younger brother Kenny passed away from leukemia, Osmer recalls seeing his parents navigate this devastating time while maintaining deep faith. Osmer remembers this tragically transformative experience as instilling confidence in faith’s capacity to sustain people through the most difficult of circumstances. “I didn’t understand faith,” Osmer says, “but I could see it.”6
It has been said that all research is autobiography, and Osmer’s scholarship is no exception. A generation of “Harry Potter” fans in his classrooms led him to develop a course on “Moral Formation Through Children’s Fantasy Literature”—the most popular course he ever taught—awakening in him a former passion. As a pre-teen needing to escape the pressures that he put on himself, Osmer had turned to science fiction and fantasy literature as pressure valves. This literature challenged limits, declared new realities possible, and explored the moral composition of characters required to enter into a given “what if” scenario. Even dystopian science fiction inspired hope, imagining futures that shed new light on the present moment.
While an undergraduate at University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill, Rick began to imagine his own future in a new way when he met his roommate’s twin sister, Sally. While traveling independently in Europe for separate summer educational opportunities, Rick and Sally agreed to meet in Italy. As Rick observes, it’s quite difficult not to fall in love in Venice. A month after graduating from college, they were married.
Rick’s post-graduation plan was to study world religions at Harvard. While in Boston, the Osmers supplemented their income by serving a small church together for two years. This proved to be pivotal period in Osmer’s vocational discernment. Prior to his experience as a pastor, Osmer valued his church and his education, but failed to see how they overlapped. None of the maps he had previously considered for his life combined both his faith and his intellectual interests. As a young pastor, he realized that the study of world religions bore little resemblance to the lived experience of faith—nor would it prepare him to become a faith leader. Harvard had introduced Osmer to James Fowler and his “faith development” research, but he decided to transfer to Yale Divinity School to study Karl Barth under Hans Frei, David Kelsey, and George Lindbeck. Even so, Osmer would ultimately remember his seminary education as unhelpful when it came to practical theology or religious education. Harvard had no tenured faculty in practical theology during Osmer’s time there; apart from being a student in James Fowler’s first class on faith development, he received no encouragement in practical theology there. Yale’s faculty included Randolph Crump Miller—a titan in the Religious Education Movement—but Osmer deemed him “a terrible teacher; nobody took his courses.” (The irony of poor teaching in the Christian education area was not lost of Osmer.) Similarly, he was disappointed in the disconnect between his Yale courses on Barth and the practice of ministry: “I learned a lot of Barth, read a lot of Barth, but when I became a pastor I was clueless. I didn’t know really how to make sense out of what practical theology is, and Barth is really difficult. And how do you connect what he says to what you’re doing? So, I just put Barth on the shelf for a really long time.”7
It was his year of Clinical Pastoral Education (CPE) that decisively shaped Osmer’s vocation. Confronted with what one of his future mentors would call “the living human document,”8 Osmer discovered an approach to education that took human experience seriously. Later, the “lab schools” offered by the Methodists at Lake Junaluska, loosely based on Dewey’s famous lab schools in New York, provided a context for exploring experience-based education. At the lab school, Osmer discovered a way to encourage faith by connecting it to people’s immediate experience, an approach that was particularly useful in the rural congregation he served. Alongside some volunteers, Osmer gingerly introduced a Sunday School program—and discovered his congregants’ hunger, not just for the content of faith, but for a way of life infused and transformed by their walk with God.
This experience whetted Osmer’s educational appetite. By then Fowler had joined the faculty of Emory University and Candler School of Theology in Atlanta. Osmer soon became Fowler’s doctoral advisee, the first student admitted to Candler’s “Theology and Personality” program (he ultimately became its first graduate as well). Beguiled by Fowler’s understanding of how humans appropriate faith throughout the life cycle, Fowler’s desire to push past Kantian categories towards lived experience reinforced Osmer’s lab school discoveries about the importance of experience in religious formation. Fowler captured the dynamism of faith by conducting “faith interviews” (and by training his doctoral students to do the same) for a project called “Stages of Faith.” Osmer became one of Fowler’s most trusted research assistants, and eventually served as acting Assistant Director and Director of Educational Research at Candler’s Center for Research on Faith and Moral Development.
Osmer had begun to form some critiques of Fowler’s approach, concerned about reducing Christian faith to form and content. In Osmer’s view, Christian faith is, above all, a relationship—and a particular relationship at that. The human/divine encounter had to be accounted for. Osmer grappled with this conundrum in his dissertation, investigating the teaching ministry through the Reformed lenses of Shelton Smith’s and James Smart’s neo-orthodox critique of the Religious Education Movement. Fowler supported Osmer’s theological drift away from Methodism towards Reformed theology—a lesson Osmer took to heart, and repeated with his own doctoral students: challenge, but always champion, your students.
With Fowler’s support within the academy and Sally’s support outside of it, Rick’s career began to unfold. Faith and family became the couple’s two foci, orienting every other detail of their lives. Even after they both left pastoral leadership, the Osmers remained dedicated to their church communities, celebrating their children’s rites of passage and sometimes grieving timid pastoral leadership. Long before shifting his focus to evangelism, Osmer sensed its urgency. He was scandalized by what he viewed as mainline leaders’ aversion to proclaiming the scandal of the gospel, “a stumbling block to Jews and foolishness to gentiles” (1 Cor 1:23). One colleague remembers a conversation following an Easter service, when Rick felt that a particular opportunity had been missed. “Of all days!” he exclaimed. “Today I came to church to encounter the Risen Christ, and instead I am leaving discouraged without meeting Jesus.” Then he pointed to some visitors and asked his colleague rhetorically: “And them—what about them? How are they going to meet Jesus with sermons like that?”
The Osmers were committed to cultivating an “equal regard” marriage, to use his friend Don Browning’s phrase, negotiating ways to nurture a family alongside two careers (Sally is an ordained United Methodist pastor and a respected leader in the non-profit sector). Osmer recalls how the birth of their first child led them to rearrange their schedules and reimagine their callings in order to be the kind of parents they wanted to be—a conversation that would be repeated often in the years to come. When they unexpectedly found themselves parenting a child with special needs, Osmer once again refocused his professional commitments, limiting travel and speaking to focus on teaching and writing, which afforded him more time at home. The most recent “reimagining” of Osmer’s calling accompanied the birth of his two grandchildren, who largely set the stage for Rick and Sally’s decision to retire. Of all the mantles Rick has worn throughout his career, the one that gives him the most delight is “Grandpapapapa.”
Practical Theologian in Context
In his consensus model of practical theology, Osmer identified four “moments” in the process of practical theological reflection which he labeled as the descriptive-empirical, the interpretive, the normative, and the pragmatic moments. As Osmer put it, “What is going on? Why is this going on? What ought to be going on? How might we respond? Answering each of these questions is the focus of one of the core tasks of practical theological interpretation.”9
The chapters ahead give an eclectic and broad glimpse of these four moments but missing from most of them is how Osmer’s career has been shaped by the changing religious culture in which his work has been situated. Osmer’s career serves as a kind of barometer for these shifts as they have played out in institutions, in the practice of Christian formation, and in the global significance of practical theology itself. Osmer’s ministerial career spanned forty-one years. He received his M.Div. from Yale Divinity School in 1977 and retired from Princeton Theological Seminary in 2018. He also served on the faculty of Candler School of Theology (1983–1986; PhD 1985) and Union Theological Seminary at Richmond (1986–1990), but his time at Princeton Theological Seminary (1990–2018) most clearly established him as a practical theologian. Osmer himself has given an account of his time at Princeton Seminary, reflecting on the experience of being part of a long line of Princeton practical theologians.10 Any retrospective of Osmer’s career must account for the institutions that have helped shape him, and that he has helped shape, most of all Princeton Seminary.
In a broader sense, the shape of Christian witness and formation in the United States has undergone tectonic shifts during Osmer’s career, especially the mainline denominations with which Osmer has been primarily associated. In 1977 it was still possible to see Christian education as the primary vehicle for enculturating North Americans into the social institution of the church. Today, mainline churches offer little in the way of a recognizable culture into which to socialize young people—and convincing critiques of enculturation models, from both theological and socio-cultural perspectives, call into question many of the educational practices twentieth-century churches took for granted. Instead, many would argue that the appropriate starting point for Christian formation in the early twenty-first century is evangelism, broadly conceived in Osmerian terms as reawakening North Americans, in and beyond existing congregations, to the active presence of God at work in their midst. Osmer’s evolving teaching and research interests reflect this shift; in 2013, he voluntarily relinquished his named chair in Christian education in order to become Princeton Seminary’s Ashenfelter Professor of Mission and Evangelism.
A map that faithfully traces Osmer’s career also must account for the international horizon present in his work. A founding member of the International Academy of Practical Theology, Osmer hosted the Academy’s founding meeting at Princeton Theological Seminary in 1991. He co-edited an early book tracing the effects of globalization on youth ministry and religious education. His work continues to resonate in parts of the global church, especially in South Africa and Korea. Still, Osmer’s focus on congregations as the base unit of Christian practice and as the primary locus of his research makes his signature in the field distinctly American. His global work gives his US focus welcome humility, substantially mitigating the risk of parochialism or of making American church practices normative.
Before going further, we should address a common misconception about Osmer’s consensus model of practical theology, the so-called “four moments” that you will hear echoing throughout this volume. Although these moments in the process of practical theological reflection, as outlined by Osmer, are often interpreted as spiraling around each other in sequence, Osmer maintains that each moment is present in all the others—and that all four moments (not just the normative moment) are “theological” in nature. Influenced by his friendship with Princeton Seminary colleagues Darrell Guder, George Hunsinger, and Bruce McCormack, Osmer returned to reading Karl Barth late in his career. He became drawn to the idea of dialectical inclusion as a way to understand how systematic, biblical, and practical theology relate to one another—and, by extension, to describe how each moment in practical theology relates to all the others. Each moment has a specific focus but necessarily includes the entirety of the other to make sense. Dialectical inclusion not only describes Osmer’s thinking about practical theology; there is a kind of dialectical inclusion at work in Osmer’s life as well. To understand one moment in Osmer’s vocation, it is necessary to include all the others, which are held together in dialectical tension. To be specific, let us briefly outline the four “moments” of Richard R. Osmer’s work that serve as the outline for this volume.
The Educator
For thirty-one of his forty-one years of ministry, Osmer’s job description had the word “education” in his title. Twice he served congregations as the minister of education. In the academy, he served as Instructor in Christian Education at Candler School of Theology while completing his doctorate (1983–1984), Assistant Professor of Christian Education at Candler (1984–1986) and at Union Theological Seminary (1986–1990), and the Thomas W. Synnott Professor of Christian Education at Princeton Theological Seminary (1990–2012). His first five books all addressed the church’s teaching ministry—A Teachable Spirit: Recovering the Teaching Office in the Church (1990), Teaching for Faith: A Guide for Leaders of Adult Groups (1992), Confirmation: Presbyterian Practices in Ecumenical Perspective (1995), Religious Education between Modernization and Globalization (2003, co-authored with Friedrich Schweitzer), and The Teaching Ministry of the Congregations (2005). In short, most of Osmer’s professional life centered around practicing, teaching, and writing about various aspects of Christian education.
Even so, Osmer often found himself at odds with dominant understandings of American religious education in the late twentieth century. He lost little sleep over the dissonance. He considered these “older models” to be “generic” at best, and “shell games” at worst, smuggling in normative theological commitments under the guise of philosophy, modern education, and the social sciences. He countered that theology should determine what counts as “ministry” and “teaching” in congregations, eschewing the phrase “religious education” in favor of “the teaching ministry.”11 He was far more interested in how faith comes alive in the life of the believer than in educational philosophy or technique. Defending the Presbyterian Church (USA)’s new catechism as an instrument for personal exploration rather than a mechanism to ensure that children are “properly indoctrinated,” Osmer criticizes the twentieth-century Religious Education Movement’s tendency to caricature catechetical instruction, and the movement’s explicit prioritization of process over content. Calling the Religious Education Movement “a failure,” he states flatly: “Too much is at stake for the church to accept uncritically a continuation of trends that have undercut its teaching ministry throughout this century.”12
Osmer’s solution is to adopt a broader understanding of discipleship formation than religious educators—not to mention most congregations—practice or even recognize. Writing in 2005, he said: “We cannot think exclusively in terms of formal education offered in class-like settings. Rather, we must also think in terms of relationships and formational practices that shape people as they participate in a way of life.”13 Despite his passionate investment in congregations, the complexities of faithful discipleship capture his imagination more than the dynamics of incorporating people into existing church cultures. Even those aspects of his work that focus largely on enculturation (his role as chair of the PCUSA’s catechism committee and his lifelong interest in confirmation come to mind) were, for Osmer, less about cultivating new generations of church members than about shaping a way of life, embodied in congregations, that would reflect Christ in the world. When asked in 1998 whether the PCUSA’s new catechisms would be considered authoritative, the Los Angeles Times quoted Osmer’s reply: “Only if they enable the contemporary church to confess Jesus Christ today.”14
The chapters of this section reflect some of Osmer’s many interests as an educator. In Chapter 2, Amanda Hontz Drury investigates a largely unexamined aspect of Osmer’s teaching interests—his conviction that children’s fantasy literature shapes moral imagination. Drury believes that this literature opens human imagination in ways that allow us to approach Christ as “little children.” Kenda Creasy Dean argues in Chapter 3 that Osmer’s interest in young people’s theological formation, and his long insistence that youth are necessary to the church’s theological and ecclesial identity, anticipated the so-called “theological turn” in North American youth ministry thirty years later. Jessicah Krey Duckworth explores catechesis as formation into a way of life, and suggests that focusing on the formation of newcomers to faith—new members, children, the newly baptized—can have the effect of forming the rest of the community as well.
The Spiritual Director
It surprises some people familiar with Osmer’s theological work and intellectual bent that he is trained as an Ignatian spiritual director. Former students are more likely to name the spiritual driver of the education faculty at Princeton Seminary as the late James Loder, who coupled theoretical brilliance with charismatic prayer practices and the occasional exorcism. More recently (and less exotically) students might name Kenda Creasy Dean’s warm Methodist pastoral sensibilities, Gordon S. Mikoski’s sacramental inclinations, or Bo Karen Lee’s rootedness in historical and ascetical traditions as the spiritual rudders of the Education and Formation “subarea.” Invariably, Osmer is remembered as the towering intellectual force.
Yet Osmer spent much of his career at Princeton Seminary quietly carving out a Reformed approach to spirituality for both himself and others. True to his upbringing, Osmer’s spirituality was enacted more than professed, but it pervaded his personal life and his teaching. Students recall his habit of praying before class, devoting class time to unpacking their spiritual autobiographies alongside paper assignments, or taking part in spiritual retreats with Osmer and a colleague or two at the beginning or end of a semester.
Osmer was fascinated by the possibility of a spirituality that was genuinely Reformed in both theology and practice. This ruled out many popular understandings (or misunderstandings) of spirituality as an individualistic, emotional, or intellectually vacuous pursuit. Sometimes Osmer’s spiritual interests showed themselves in course material for classes like “Spiritual Awakenings,” co-taught with historian Kenneth Appold. For Osmer, German pietism became an opportunity to talk about small group ministries; the Great Awakening was an occasion to explore Jonathan Edwards’ treatises on discernment and religious affections; the origins of Pentecostalism presented students with opportunities to make sense of personal charismatic experiences. Osmer insisted on contextualizing the personal, spiritual dimension of learning within the academic rigors of history and the discipline of practical theology.
One dimension of Osmer’s understanding of Reformed spirituality is a discerning openness to the “other,” a practice that marked his research as well as his devotional life. “It is important for practical theology . . . always to operate with several perspectives simultaneously and to appropriate them in an intentionally eclectic fashion,” Osmer wrote in his inaugural lecture.15 While perpetually engaging with the social sciences, especially psychology and sociology, Osmer insisted that any empirical dialogue partner with practical theology must approach the human subject as a person and not an object. Profoundly influenced in his doctoral program by Charles V. Gerkin, whose approach to pastoral care understood the subject as a “living human document,” Osmer chose to engage social scientists whose work left room for a theological anthropology. Osmer’s interest in the research of sociologist Christian Smith, for instance, emerged especially from Smith’s meta-theoretical work What Is A Person? and from Smith’s defense of critical realism and personalism.
Osmer understood even qualitative empirical research to be an act of spiritual openness and presence—ultimately, an act of willing vulnerability to the human other and the divine other. In research, wrote Osmer, the practical theologian must be simultaneously open and present to the human “other,” and to the “Other” who is God, listening intently to both.16 His posture acknowledged the possibility of God’s prior action in a given situation—a hallmark of Reformed spirituality, whether the task at hand is cultivating mission (i.e., God is the one with a mission in which you and I may participate) or the spiritual life of the laity.
Ultimately, Osmer’s interest in spirituality took shape in the book Spiritual Companioning: A Guide to Protestant Theology and Practice (2015) penned with his former student Angela H. Reed, and his teacher in spiritual direction, Marcus Smucker. In chapter 5 of the present book, Reed examines how Osmer’s understanding of practical theology aids and contributes to understanding of spiritual companioning as a form of leadership in contemporary Protestant congregations. In Chapter 6, Nathan Stucky wonders how teachers and learners can know a God of reconciliation when the very form of their education embodies the divisions Christ came to heal. He explores new possibilities for ministry and theological education, influenced by Osmer’s insistence that practices carry epistemological weight, taking shape at Princeton Seminary’s “Farminary,” where theological formation and small-scale redemptive agriculture happen side by side. Bo Karen Lee follows suit by exploring the necessary relationship between spirituality and mission in Chapter 7, and describes how co-teaching with Osmer allowed her own awareness of this connection to blossom.
The Evangelist
In many ways, Osmer’s approach to spirituality as openness and presence led directly to his interest in evangelism. While acknowledging the importance of conversion, Osmer prefers to view evangelism as “awakening,” an image that acknowledges God’s prior presence in the world, and in an individual’s life, before the evangelist arrives. The evangelist’s role, for Osmer, is to catalyze the recognition of God’s presence. For Osmer, this is never merely a “church growth” strategy or a defensive posture aimed at pinning people to their pews. He approaches evangelism as he approaches his empirical research—from a position of genuine curiosity about and delight in the “other,” acknowledging that God is already at work.
Several factors led to Osmer’s unexpected 2013 shift from a named chair in Christian education to becoming Princeton’s Ralph B. and Helen S. Ashenfelter Professor of Mission and Evangelism. One obvious factor was the shifting ecclesial landscape. American congregations had changed dramatically since Osmer’s early days as a pastor. Over time, Osmer became convinced that the church could no longer assume an ecology of formative institutions—families, churches, schools, communities—that worked together to nudge people towards faith. While secularization in the United States differs from its counterparts in other parts of the world, it is no less a factor in eroding traditional mechanisms of Christian formation. The task of the Christian educator, Osmer came to believe, was no longer to find more effective ways to nurture nascent faith. It was to bear witness to the possibility of faith, and to live as though God is a plausible option for twenty-first century people who are increasingly, and quite happily, religiously unaffiliated.
Osmer adopted two broad responses to this changing context. The first was to re-evaluate past efforts and methods of handing on the faith. Re-evaluating the church’s educational practices meant examining how practices that had been shaped under Christendom could continue to be relevant in a post-Christendom world. The most notable re-evaluation was a reassessment of churches’ confirmation practices. The mainline churches with which Osmer worked most closely, including the Presbyterian Church (USA), had a history of confirmation, a subject that Osmer had researched and written about in his 1995 Confirmation: Presbyterian Practices in Ecumenical Perspective. Around 2013 the question became, “Is there something in this practice that can respond to the current context?” Osmer marshalled scholars from five denominations to find out, and under the leadership of Osmer and Katherine Douglass, the massive three-year, mixed method, five-denomination Confirmation Project was born.
Osmer’s second response was to focus on a neglected and increasingly urgent practice in mainline Protestantism: evangelism. In the United States, evangelism had fallen prey to Christendom’s assumption that being born into a “Christian” country made one a Christian, making evangelism either irrelevant, or a tool for growing your church. The myth of American Christendom, perpetuated by mainline denominations throughout the twentieth century, tended to equate faithfulness with middle class decency, which meant that whatever passed for evangelism amounted to little more than reclaiming backsliding Christians or convincing lukewarm churchgoers to join a more fervent faith group. Neither represented a true awakening to God.
Osmer had long been convinced that Christian formation and mission went hand in hand; the church makes disciples, not for bolstering its rosters, but for the sake of participating in God’s mission in the world. Osmer’s view of mission as incarnational witness fit easily with his view of evangelism—and Osmer was aghast that, in the ecclesial context of the early twenty-first century, a flagship mainline seminary with over forty-five faculty had no one teaching it. The retirement of Osmer’s colleague Darrell L. Guder, the theologian who made “missional church” a household word, accentuated the problem. Osmer proposed shifting from education to evangelism to address this deficit—forcing yet another re-examination of what Christian education actually means in a context where not only the quality of faith, but the possibility of faith, is in question.
Section Three focuses on Osmer’s interest in mission and evangelism from three distinct theological and cultural perspectives. In Chapter 8, Darrell L. Guder traces the mutual relationship between practical theology and missional theology, especially as they relate to Guder’s articulation of missional theology. In Chapter 9, Thomas John Hastings, a long-time mission co-worker in Japan and now Executive Director of the Overseas Mission Study Center, offers a practical theological analysis of missional theology influenced by his experience in Asia. Hastings demonstrates how Osmer’s work in areas as wide ranging as practical theology methodology to the development of a new catechism has surprising cross cultural relevance. Finally, in Chapter 10, Drew A. Dyson proposes a missional practical theology for American churches working with emerging adults, and demonstrates with case studies how Osmer’s reformulation of evangelism can reframe ministry within a mainline context.
The Practical Theologian
If there has been one identity that has persisted throughout Osmer’s life, it is that of practical theologian. Osmer always found that his identity as educator, spiritual director, and evangelist fit best within the broader, more inclusive identity of a practical theologian. In the Epilogue to Practical Theology: An Introduction, Osmer sketches out a brief history of theological education, and argues that because the context that gave rise to theological education has changed, theological education must now change as well. In contrast to the theological encyclopedia, Schleiermacher’s response to the scientism and secularization encroaching on churches in the late eighteenth century, Osmer advocates a dialogical model of theological education, a cross-disciplinary engagement with human sciences that stops short of adopting science’s abstract, universalizing principles and epistemological methods. Practical theology, for Osmer, moves from “a sharp distinction between disinterested, pure scholarship and applied science to the recognition that scholarship is grounded in and oriented toward practice, reflecting constellations of value, interest, and power.”17
This vision of practical theology led Osmer to abandon guilds oriented around particular sub-fields, like education, in favor of organizations committed to invested, praxis-oriented research. In the North American context, Osmer was an active participant in the Association of Practical Theology (serving as the President in 1991–1992), and his work with the International Academy of Practical Theology led to the founding of the Academy’s journal, The International Journal of Practical Theology, in 1991.18 As interest in practical theology grew, its animating principles, scope and content became more contested—leading to both appreciation and scrutiny of Osmer’s work by members of the organization he helped found, as well as by scholars he helped educate and encourage.19
Yet important as these guild conversations have been, the hot lava core of Osmer’s work remains the North American congregation. Just as shifts in the cultural and intellectual context necessitate new theoretical understandings of practical theology at a theoretical level, so shifting congregational realities require new forms Christian ministry and practice. The four essays in this section posit Osmer’s significance for the field of practical theology as a whole, but also have implications for congregational leaders. In Chapter 11, Blair D. Bertrand notes the importance of Osmer’s alignment with Karl Barth as his main theological conversation partner, accentuating theological norms in practical theology. It is generally acknowledged that Osmer has always had a focus on theology but Bertrand argues that this is true of other practical theologians, including congregational leaders, as well. In Chapter 12, Andrew Root addresses a long-standing division in the academy between those who, like Johannes van der Ven, advocate for a practical theology driven by the empirical and those who, like Osmer, lean towards the theological. Root makes the case for the theological and its importance for congregations. Shin-Guen Jang, in Chapter 13, explains why the perichoretic content of faith can and should determine the form and manner of the teaching ministry, and by extension, practical theology itself. Finally, in Chapter 14, Osmer’s colleague and co-author Gordon Mikoski situates Osmer’s work within the long tradition of practical theology at Princeton Theological Seminary, a tradition of practical theology that has long found its origins in the shaping of congregations.
Consensus and Conflict
Let us close with a word about the title of this book. On one level, the phrase Consensus and Conflict acknowledges an irony. Known for his “consensus” model of practical theology, Richard Osmer’s career nonetheless unfolded against a backdrop of unprecedented ecclesial change and conflict as the descriptions, interpretations, norms, and strategies of faith communities became increasingly contested. When Osmer graduated from Yale Divinity School in the placid spring of 1977 (the biggest conflict in the US that year was Darth Vader’s vendetta against the Force), he could not have suspected the shifting tectonic plates of culture groaning underfoot, or imagined how those shifts would forever change the church he was newly ordained to serve. The “consensus” model of practical theology was born in a moment in history when the church, as Osmer knew it, was experiencing anything but consensus.
On the other hand, this period of ecclesial ferment is what allowed the “four moments of Richard R. Osmer”—educator, spiritual director, evangelist, practical theologian—to emerge. Osmer’s signature “tacking back and forth” between disciplines, conversation partners, and ecclesial interests allowed him to hold loosely a church in transition. He is more interested in the church’s significance and potential for a changing world than in the increasingly polarized skirmishes that have preoccupied mainline congregations throughout his career. For example, while personally sensitive to issues of gender, class, and race, none of these form the spine of Osmer’s research—a frequently noted shortcoming of his work. While engaging multiple disciplines in his work, he avoids various correlational methods that have dominated practical theological interpretation, methods that give two fields of study or practices equal footing as they pose questions to one another.20 Instead, he refers to his preferred theological method as “transversal cross-disciplinarity”21—a method that explores intersections and divergences between two fields with common interests, without attempting to establish their parity.
At the end of the day, in addition to expanding the scope of practical theology’s interests, we believe Osmer will be remembered for bolstering the field in three ways. First, he will be remembered for distilling the field’s methodological architecture into the “four moments” that constitute the consensus model of practical theology. Second, his own breadth of interests demonstrate the flexibility of the consensus model, as well as its usefulness for understanding multiple practices of Christian life and leadership. Finally, Osmer’s insistence on a “normative” moment in practical theological reflection offers an important counterweight to the field’s increasing reliance on social science and empirical research. Osmer openly champions the church’s need to be in conversation with disciplines beyond theology; much of his work has been devoted to modelling interdisciplinary conversations. Osmer steadfastly maintains that theology makes a distinctive and necessary contribution to interdisciplinary work.
In the end, it is not enough that practical theology is ideologically current, methodologically sound, or even practically accessible. For Osmer, identity, methodology, and accessibility in practical theology matter only to the extent that they help the church concern itself with the things that concern God. Thus, Osmer can claim, along with liberationist practical theologians that “the real crisis confronting theology is not one of meaning, but one of human suffering.” 22 Osmer’s primary educational concern has always been how to make practical theology fruitful for congregations’ work that forms people to participate in God’s redemption and transformation of the world. The true test of practical theology’s validity—and the true test of a career as a practical theologian—is its potential to reveal divine grace in the midst of the lived life of human communities. As Osmer puts it: Does practical theology “contribute to social transformation that alleviates suffering?”23 In short, does practical theology matter? Does it make a difference to people who cling to one another in small rural churches in North Carolina, to the daily struggles of communities served by his students, to the urgent concerns of his own son and daughter and grandchildren? The authors in this volume share a conviction: namely, that in Osmer’s case, the answer is unequivocally yes. It matters, Rick. It matters.
Bibliography
Amrhein, John. “Robert Louis Stevenson,” Treasure Island, The Untold Story. http://www.treasureislandtheuntoldstory.com/robert-louis-stevenson.htm.
Baughman, Michael. Flipping Church: How Successful Church Planters are Turning Conventional Wisdom Upside Down. Nashville: Discipleship Resources, 2016.
Bush, Joseph E. Practical Theology in Church and Society. Eugene, OR: Cascade, 2016.
Foster, Charles. “A Review of the Teaching Ministry of Congregations.” Journal of Religious Education 101 (2006) 430–43.
Gerkin, Charles V. The Living Human Document: Revisioning Pastoral Counseling in a Hermeneutical Mode. Nashville: Abingdon, 1984.
Hastings, Thomas John. Practical Theology and the One Body of Christ: Toward a Missional-Ecumenical Model. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2007.
Mikoski, Gordon S., and Richard R. Osmer. With Piety and Learning: The History of Practical Theology at Princeton Theological Seminary. Berlin: LIT Verlag, 2011.
Miller-McLemore, Bonnie J. “Toward Greater Understanding of Practical Theology.” International Journal of Practical Theology 16 (2012) 104–23.
“New Presbyterian Catechism Proposed.” Los Angeles Times, March 28, 1998. http://articles.latimes.com/1998/mar/28/local/me-33510.
Osmer, Richard R. Interview by Amanda Drury, May 18, 2018, telephone interview.
———. Practical Theology, An Introduction. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2008.
———. “Practical Theology as Argument, Rhetoric, and Conversation.” Princeton Seminary Bulletin 18 (1997) 46–73.
———. “Practical Theology: A Current International Perspective.” HTS Teologiese/Theological Studies 67 (2011) 17. https://hts.org.za/index.php/HTS/article/view/1058.
———. “Restructuring Confirmation.” Theology Today 49 (1992) 46–67.
———. The Teaching Ministry of Congregations. Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 2005.
Reed, Angela, et al. Spiritual Companioning: A Guide to Protestant Theology and Practice. Grand Rapids: Baker, 2015.
Sibley, Brian, and John Howe. The Maps of Tolkien’s Middle Earth. New York: Houghton Mifflin, 1994.
Smith, Kevin. “Review of Richard Osmer: Practical Theology, An Introduction.” Conspectus: The Journal of the South African Theological Seminary 10 (2010) 99–113. https://www.sats.edu.za/userfiles/Conspectus,%20vol.%2010.pdf.
Taylor, Charles. Sources of the Self: The Making of Modern Identity. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1989.
van Huysteen, J. Wentzel. “Postfoundationalism and Interdisciplinarity: A Response to Jerome Stone,” Journal of Religion and Science 35 (2000) 427–39.
1. Osmer uses an image very similar to this in Practical Theology, 80–81, 116.
2. Sibley and Howe, The Maps of Tolkien’s Middle Earth, 5–7. For one of many accounts of the origins of Treasure Island, see Amrhein, “Robert Louis Stevenson.” For a discussion of church planters as cartographers, see Kenda Creasy Dean and Mark DeVries’s foreword in Baughman, Flipping Church.
3. Taken as a whole, conservatives wish he were more evangelical and liberals wish he were more progressive; scholars wish he would address the academy and practitioners wish he would be more accessible. Cf. Foster, “A Review of the Teaching Ministry”; Miller-McLemore, “Toward Greater Understanding of Practical Theology”; Smith, “Review of Richard Osmer.” All of these are primarily appreciative reviews; but even fans have critiques.
4. Charles Taylor explains his “best account principle” in Taylor, Sources of the Self, 58–59.
5. Osmer, Interview.
6. Ibid.
7. Ibid.
8. Cf. Gerkin, The Living Human Document, 97–117.
9. Osmer, Practical Theology, 4.
10. Mikoski and Osmer, With Piety and Learning, 31–133.
11. Osmer, The Teaching Ministry of Congregations, xviii.
12. Osmer, “Restructuring Confirmation,” 66, 68–69.
13. Osmer, The Teaching Ministry, 27.
14. “New Presbyterian Catechism Proposed,” Los Angeles Times.
15. Osmer, “Practical Theology as Argument,” 71.
16. Osmer’s explanation of the empirical/descriptive moment in Practical Theology: An Introduction describes a “spirituality of presence” as something typified by a priest attending simultaneously a situation’s complex dynamics, and to the presence of God at work in the world. A priest, argues Osmer (and by extension, a practical theologian), must be open to both this world and to the world to come. The empirical becomes a spiritual act through openness and presence. See Osmer, Practical Theology, 35–36.
17. Osmer, Practical Theology, 237.
18. Cf. Osmer, “Practical Theology: A Current International Perspective,” 1–7.
19. Cf. Miller-McLemore, “Toward Greater Understanding of Practical Theology,” and Hastings, Practical Theology and the One Body of Christ. These colleagues in no way seek to invalidate Osmer’s project, and in fact draw from it substantially. Osmer’s review of Hastings’s book, despite Hastings’s critique, calls it “brilliantly and persuasively argued.”
20. Joseph E. Bush critiques Osmer’s normative task for making practical theology more about meaning-making than emancipatory praxis—although he later quotes Osmer as saying precisely the opposite, as noted in the following paragraph. Bush, Practical Theology in Church and Society,149.
21. For a summary of transversal rationality, see van Huysteen, “Postfoundationalism and Interdisciplinarity.” Osmer’s appropriation of transversal disciplinarity for practical theological method is described in Osmer, The Teaching Ministry, 303–17.
22. See Matthew Lamb, Solidarity with Victims, in Osmer, Practical Theology, 167.
23. Ibid.
