Chapter 14: Intelligible Reasons for Practice
14
Intelligible Reasons for Practice
Osmer’s Contribution to Practical Theology at Princeton Theological Seminary
When not ignoring the past for the sake of the present and the future, practical theologians struggle to nail down the precise origins of their field. One could argue that it has its origins in the mists of time prior to the first scribe who put stylus to clay tablet. One could also point to theologian-practitioners in the medieval period who held out against the rise of Aristotelian scholasticism and the rise of disinterested knowledge in the university. Yet another line of argument would point out that Protestant leaders like Luther and Calvin were consumed by theological passion for the life of faith and the church and had no interest in theological reflection on theological questions of an impractical or speculative nature. The most common line of historical lineage in practical theology connects the rise of the discipline with the arguments that Schleiermacher made for including the three interrelated branches of theological study in the first modern university in the early years of the nineteenth century in Berlin.
A “right” answer to the question of the origins of the field of practical theology is unlikely to exist. Perhaps the complexities of definition and distinction at play when looking back to the field’s elusive origins make a grand, definitive history of practical theology impossible to discern. In lieu of such a comprehensive narrative, focusing on particular institutions and key figures offer another angle from which we can make out some of practical theology’s defining characteristics, current issues, and future possibilities.
Osmer’s Place in Practical Theology at Princeton Theological Seminary
Richard R. Osmer has been in dialogue with and an innovator within the long tradition of practical theology, at Princeton Theological Seminary. Since 1812, Princeton Theological Seminary has served as one of several key loci for the unfolding of the story of practical theology in the modern era. In the mode of “applied theology,” the founding patriarchs of the seminary regularly brought biblical, theological, and historical insights to bear on the practice of pastoral ministry in their lectures to third-year students on their way to becoming pastors of Protestant churches. Combined with a robust commitment to the practices of prayer, testimony, and preaching on campus, their erudite lectures and pastoral wisdom born of years of leadership experience established the school as a matrix of practical theology for generations of students. Princeton Seminary was nothing if not a theological school utterly devoted to the theological formation of leaders for the church whose pastoral practice would be informed by the best and highest principles of the church’s theological inheritance—all of which functioned in the mode of “applied theology” until the midpoint of the nineteenth century.
A remarkable change occurred in the fall of 1854 when Alexander Taggart McGill delivered his inaugural lecture. As the first explicitly designated practical theologian at the seminary, McGill laid out a comprehensive vision for the newly conceived field of practical theology as a consciously thematized intellectual enterprise. McGill observed:
The man of right conduct for himself, is not always the best man to explain even his own conduct, for the benefit of others. In daily intercourse, we often find an incapacity of practical men to give intelligent reasons for the success with which they direct their own business, and meet the challenges and emergencies of life; and in the most elevated spheres of magisterial vocation, the same ineptitude has been frequent and striking.
In other words, expert practitioners are not always in the best position to explain why they do what they do. They can usually demonstrate expertise in practice and can provide useful tips and rules of thumb for responsible or even creative practice. Providing a theoretical framework within which such expert practice makes theological sense, however, can elude the expert practitioner. When teaching toward the development of pastoral expertise, McGill argued, a rigorous intellectual framework that can situate expert practice in relation to theological and philosophical principles empowers the practitioner to move beyond mere imitation of the virtuoso instructor toward becoming a practical theologian-in-residence. Theory is needed in order to support, correct, situate, or recreate practice.
A little more than half a century later, Elmer Homrighausen joined the Princeton Seminary faculty with an appointment in Christian education. One of the first translators and promoters of Karl Barth in the American context, Homrighausen continued lines laid down in practical theology by McGill and developed theological vision and normativity of practical theology at the seminary in a vigorous way. The vision and norms arising from the gospel message and the centrality of the church formed the backbone of Homrighausen’s approach to Christian education and to the wider field of practical theology within which Christian education functioned. For Homrighausen, careful attention to human experience and the use of insights from various secular fields of study had to be set within a theological framework that gave priority to the destabilizing and transformative power of divine revelation, particularly as manifested in the coming, life, death, and resurrection of Jesus Christ. Homrighausen articulated an approach that gave substantive neo-orthodox definition to the theological dimension of practical theology in the middle decades of the twentieth century.
At mid-century, Seward Hilter brought compelling engagement with human science to the enterprise of practical theology at the seminary. Hiltner went further than McGill and Homrighausen in his serious and sustained engagement with the social sciences, particularly psychology. On the basis of his deep engagement with the complexities of human experience, Hiltner claimed that practical theology could bring about a needed rethinking of established doctrines, if not occasionally new theological insight. His rigorous use of social science research and clinical experience to bring critical perspective to traditional theological conviction brought a newfound appreciation for empirical research in practical theology to Princeton Seminary.
While far from an exhaustive inventory of key practical theologians preceding him, even this brief consideration of the contributions of McGill, Homrighausen, and Hiltner provide context for what has made Osmer’s work so important at Princeton Seminary since his arrival in 1989. In his research and teaching, Osmer developed a dynamic theoretical framework for practical theology that provides rich and varied ways to explain pastoral and spiritual practice. Like McGill, Osmer has consistently sought to develop a conceptual framework for practical theology and its related disciplines sufficient to both explain the logic of ecclesial practices and to provide guidelines or something akin to Schleiermacher’s “rules of art” for them. As a skilled practitioner of pastoral skills, pedagogical methods, and spiritual practices himself, Osmer has never been content solely to be a practitioner. Instead, he developed a theoretical perspective that makes it possible to understand, explain, reflect theologically upon, and improve practice. Over the years of his critical engagement with Don Browning’s “revised correlational” approach, Johannes van der Ven’s “empirical theology” approach, or James Loder’s “transformational approach,” Osmer developed a way to do practical theology that provides an optimal, yet flexible balance between diagnosis and prescription on the one hand and engagement with social science and theological disciplines on the other hand. As an indication of his intellectual humility as well as his considerable analytical abilities, Osmer claims that the conceptual approach he articulated represents more of an “overlapping consensus” of current thinking in the field than his own trademarked or proprietary contribution.
The model that Osmer hammered out in his landmark Practical Theology: An Introduction calls for a coordination of four key dimensions or moments: the descriptive, the interpretative, the normative, and the pragmatic. Osmer holds that these four moments—while constitutive of work in practical theology—need not be carried out in a strictly linear fashion. Instead, he argues that one could begin in principle with any one of the key moments and engage in practical theological work as long as one systematically works through all four moments. In practice, students of Osmer often miss this point and treat his approach as a four-step linear process—though often with useful effect. Osmer’s argument that the four moments do and should function in a dynamic, circular process points to the creativity and flexibility of his conceptual framework and demonstrates how far his approach exceeds that of earlier practical theologians like McGill.
Osmer has made it clear that the theological work of practical theology cannot be relegated solely to the normative moment of his schema. In point of fact, each of the four key moments in Osmer’s approach are suffused with theological commitments, insights, and implications. In other words, his framework functions theologically in a fulsome and pervasive sense. Within this more pervasively theological understanding of his approach, Osmer has also made it a priority to ensure that the explicit theological task of reflecting on well-described and deeply-understood human phenomena actually occurs as part of work in practical theology. In both the pervasive and the focused sense, Osmer’s approach to practical theology makes it abundantly clear that this field is not “social science light” nor sociology, which aim at describing and understanding human phenomena without holding them up to the light of revelation and without always moving toward constructively faith-ful intervention.
Beyond providing a credible and creative way to coordinate social science and theology into a dynamic interdisciplinary endeavor, Osmer’s attentiveness to theological normativity locates his work as distinctive among the pantheon of approaches to practical theology. By taking the complexities of human experience seriously and using the best available tools to get a handle on that experience, Osmer signals that he has great resonance with Hiltner, Browning, van der Ven, and several other European approaches to the field. Yet, his theological perspective arising from the Reformed tradition, especially his deep engagement with the theological work of both Jürgen Moltmann and, more recently, Karl Barth, moves well beyond the limits of Hiltner’s correlationalism, Browning’s Niebuhrian moral monotheism, or van der Ven’s post-Vatican II liberal Roman Catholicism. This means that human experience, though taken with utmost seriousness, can never finally overpower or subordinate divine communication and disclosure in the person and work of Jesus Christ in practical theology conducted according to Osmer’s vision.
This weightiness of revelation pushes Osmer more in the direction of the view of one of his predecessors and former colleagues, James Loder. Like Osmer, Loder strongly affirmed a Reformed commitment to the transcendence of God and the radical disruption of the hiddenness of God in the incarnation, death, and resurrection of Jesus Christ. Osmer, however—much more than Loder—seeks a balance between theological normativity and the contours of human experience. The problem with Loder’s heavily-laden theological normativity lies precisely in the fact that it underplays the complexities and vagaries of lived human realities, particularly in relation to social context. This is not to say that Loder ignores human experience; far from it. Yet—unlike Loder—Osmer never allows the theological to overwhelm human experience to the extent that it is merely a foil for divine action. For Osmer, the theological has priority, but not at the expense of the fully and sometimes confoundingly human.
A Singular Voice: Osmer Goes Beyond his Predecessors
Like Homrighausen, Osmer’s theological approach has continued to develop over the course of his career at Princeton Seminary. Both of these Princeton Seminary practical theologians began in the field of Christian education and worked from robust theological commitments, gradually expanding the scope of their work and migrating into other areas of practical theology. Yet Osmer’s recognition of practical theology’s unifying internal logic, his insistence on the importance of qualitative research to elucidate human experience, and his appreciation for practical theology’s global context set him apart from his predecessors, and mark him as a practical theologian shaped by his own moment in history.
The Internal Logic of Practical Theology
While never abandoning his commitment to Christian education, Osmer eventually moved beyond education and formation into the fields of spirituality, evangelism, and church development. Osmer recognized in the concrete particularity of the practical theologian’s work a deep internal logic connecting multiple practices and disciplines. Christian education—like all forms and modes of practical theology—only occurs in specific times and places with particular groups and individuals. There is no abstract educational ministry that hovers above the ground in a pristine atmosphere of unchanging, universal truths. Instead, context and embodiment matter decisively. In order to work effectively in educational ministry and spiritual formation, the academic or ecclesial practical theologians has to use an array of empirical research tools in order to develop a clear and deep read on the context in which one seeks to form people for Christian faith in light of the gospel. Contextualizing the effort to foster faith and mature discipleship eventually leads to broader thinking about the vicissitudes of congregations’ situatedness, and what it takes to help a body of believers in a particular place and time engage the gospel with energy, respect, and commitment.
More than that, this line of thinking leads to disciplined, empirical explorations of the needs and interests of people in a given congregational context who are not currently engaging the gospel in community. For Osmer, and by extension for the rest of us, the ministries of Christian education and spiritual formation, congregational development, and evangelism are indissolubly connected. Indeed, Osmer’s work and vocational development bear witness to the internal logic binding together practical theology’s various subareas, whether in a department of a theological school or in the ministries of a local church. These arenas of practice are not siloed endeavors so much as they are different aspects of one calling: the invitation to people in particular places and times to hear and engage the gospel message of grace, healing, and hope.
If expertise involves the development and coordination of theory, know-how, contextual awareness, and self-awareness as a practitioner, then Osmer is probably responsible for teaching more pastors, educators, and academic practical theologians how to think about practical theology and to move towards pastoral and academic expertise than anyone else in the history of Princeton Seminary. As a teacher, Osmer has consistently brought innovation and creativity into the classroom by requiring students to engage in empirical research and then equipping and coaching them as they carry it out. He also has helped students to develop sophistication in interdisciplinary methods that can be readily transferred to a wide range of ministry settings and portfolios. In the same way that Osmer saw the logic of practical theology at play in multiple theological practices, he also saw fruitful interaction between the practical theologian and multiple fields of inquiry. Moving beyond practical theology’s traditional engagement with psychology and sociology, Osmer’s teaching routinely created dialogues between practical theology and fields like communication, organizational theory, and young adult fantasy literature, to name a few.
The role of empirical research in practical theology
To have maximum credibility, a theory of practice, or a theory of the complexity of theory-practice interplay, requires the one articulating the theory to practice what is being preached. More than any of his predecessors, Osmer promoted both quantitative and qualitative empirical research as integral dimensions of practical theology. His commitment to attending closely to people’s own accounts of their experience—forged while he was still a graduate student at Candler collecting faith histories for James Fowler’s “stages of faith” project—made empirical research increasingly prominent in his work. Osmer designed and carried out dozens of qualitative research projects on three continents, exploring Christian education, spiritual formation, confirmation theory and practice, evangelism, church development, and the problem of evil by using qualitative methods like focus groups, semi-structured interviews, ethnography, and participant-observation. He also worked with a team of practical theologians to develop a five-denomination quantitative empirical study of confirmation practices in the United States that involved thousands of participants. Furthermore, Osmer prioritized teaching pastors, educators, and academics the importance of carrying out their own empirical research in context, while encouraging church leaders and academic practical theologians in South Korea, South Africa, and North America to appreciate the importance of responsible empirical research for theology.
Recognizing Practical Theology’s Global Context
More than any practical theologian at Princeton Seminary to date, Osmer has helped internationalize the field of practical theology, and worked to globalize the thinking of students, pastors, and academics alike. He played a central leadership role in bringing together a group of practical theologians from around the world to Princeton Seminary in 1991 to found the International Academy of Practical Theology. Along with Riet Bons-Storm, Don S. Browning, Camil Menard, Karl Ernst Nipkow, Dietrich Rössler, Friedrich Schweitzer, and Hans van der Ven, Osmer established the institutional instrument that for nearly three decades has provided the setting for sharing ongoing research in practical theology for theorists and practitioners from every continent except Antarctica. No longer a geographically and culturally isolated field of study limited to Germany, the Netherlands, the United Kingdom, or the United States, dynamic work in practical theology today can be found among researchers and practitioners alike in South Korea, Norway, Thailand, South Africa, Brazil, Canada, Belgium, Australia, Finland, India, and Croatia. Meeting every two years for several days, practical theologians in the International Academy of Practical Theology share research, develop professional and social networks, and explore a key theme relevant to the host country. While undeniably rooted in a particular institutional context, Osmer’s work has nonetheless helped catalyze a global network of creative research and engagement in practical theology.
Future Prospects in Light of Osmer’s Contributions
Osmer’s work points toward the future development of the field of practical theology in three ways. One of the most important contributions Osmer has made at Princeton Seminary and to the wider field has been an explicit and vigorous commitment to foregrounding theological reflection in practical theology. Osmer resisted pressure from within the field that he felt would cause practical theology to devolve into a form of merely descriptive social science of religious phenomena, encouraging students, pastors, and academics to implicitly and creatively engage theological norms while explicitly urging academics to wrestle with normativity in practical theology. Mere description of lived realities, however rich and deep, can never be the whole of practical theology. Considering those lived realities in relation to divine revelation, as attested by Scripture and with guidance from ecclesial tradition, provides both interpretive power and leverage for constructive intervention. Said another way, practical theology cannot be reduced to the sophisticated use of social science perspectives and tools; instead, there needs to be at least rough parity in the strength of the use of social science perspectives and theological perspectives.
Methodologically, Osmer’s work helps practical theologians of all kinds to remain open to the use of new tools and frameworks. He never limited his toolkit to traditional psychology and sociology, though he used these tools frequently and well. His work opened out to philosophy, communications studies, and literature as examples of interdisciplinary engagement. The challenge that Osmer places before theologians is one of finding the optimal relationship in interdisciplinary work between theological and non-theological resources.
Finally, the international scope of Osmer’s work points forward in some specific ways. For example, his comparative work with Friedrich Schweitzer on religious education in the United States and Germany opens up many possibilities for coordinated work across two or more cultural contexts, while suggesting the complexity of the current practical theological task. The comparative approach helps to bring clarity to the participating contexts, illuminates common themes and insights, and lays the groundwork for collaborative contextual practical theological research. Yet in a global, instantaneously interconnected universe, comparative work alone cannot suffice. As new technologies, forms of social media, and challenges and opportunities in human communal life emerge, collaborative work in practical theology must address new levels of complexity, starting with how individuals and communities navigate the nexus of the global and the local in relation to religious meaning making, as well as the insidious tendencies of market forces to amalgamate, poach, and bastardize authentic indigenous cultures.
Osmer’s toolkit for practical theology continues to expand. As practical theology confronts hard theological questions about how the interface of the human and the machine shapes human experience; how biotechnology and the possible emergence of cyborgs challenges our notions of life, death, and humanity itself; how shifting climates and migration patterns shape our understanding of, and our physical experience of, earth and neighborhood, there will need to be serious theological reflection around issues like theological anthropology, divine and human agency, and the practice of stewardship, just to name a few. As one who never shrinks from intellectual challenges associated with the engagement of human experience and the gospel, one can easily imagine Osmer rolling up his sleeves and getting to work on such challenges, engaging in practical theological reflection, and providing intelligible reasons for practice.
Bibliography
Browning, Don S. A Fundamental Practical Theology: Descriptive and Strategic Approaches. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1991.
Ericsson, K. Anders, et al. The Cambridge Handbook of Expertise and Expert Performance. New York: Cambridge, 2006.
Hiltner, Seward. Preface to Pastoral Theology. New York: Abingdon, 1958.
Homrighausen, Elmer G. Christianity in America: A Crisis. New York: Abingdon, 1936.
International Academy of Practical Theology: History. http://www.ia-practicaltheology.org/history/.
Loder, James E. The Logic of the Spirit: Human Development in Theological Perspective. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1998.
McGill, Alexander T. “Pastoral Theology: An Inaugural Discourse.” In Discourses at the Inauguration of the Rev. Alexander T. McGill, D.D., as Professor of Pastoral Theology, Church Government, and the Composition and Delivery of Sermons, in the Theological Seminary at Princeton, N.J., Delivered at Princeton, September 12, 1854, Before the Directors of the Seminar, 6–64. Philadelphia: C. Sherman, 1854.
Mikoski, Gordon S. and Richard R. Osmer. With Piety and Learning: The History of Practical Theology at Princeton Theological Seminary: 1812–2012. Zürich: Lit, 2012.
Osmer, Richard R. Practical Theology: An Introduction. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2008.
Osmer, Richard R., and Katherine M. Douglass, eds. Confirming Faith: Faith Formation as Practical Theology. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2018.
Osmer, Richard R., and Friedrich Schweitzer. Religious Education between Modernization and Globalization: New Perspectives on the United States and Germany. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2003.
Schleiermacher, F. D. E. Brief Outline of Theology as a Field of Study. 3rd ed. Translated and edited by Terrence N. Tice. Louisville, KY: Westminster John Knox, 2011.
van der Ven, Johannes A. Practical Theology: An Empirical Approach. Translated by Barbara Schultz. Kampen: Kok Pharos, 1993.
. Schleiermacher, Brief Outline of Theology as a Field of Study.
. For more on Princeton Theological Seminary’s influence on the field of practical theology, see Mikoski and Osmer, With Piety and Learning.
. McGill, “Pastoral Theology: An Inaugural Discourse,” 55. McGill’s groundbreaking work in theorizing practical theology came to light as part of the research that Osmer and the author conducted for their jointly authored work, With Piety and Learning.
. See, for example, Homrighausen, Christianity in America.
. Hiltner, Preface to Pastoral Theology.
. See Schleiermacher, Brief Outline, 100.
. See Browning, A Fundamental Practical Theology; van der Ven, Practical Theology; Loder, The Logic of the Spirit.
. Osmer, Practical Theology, 11.
. Personal conversation with the author.
. For a discussion of the different elements or kinds of knowing that make up expertise, see Ericsson et al., The Cambridge Handbook.
. See Osmer and Douglass, Confirming Faith.
. International Academy of Practical Theology, “History.”
. See Osmer and Schweitzer, Religious Education.
