Chapter 10: Meaning, Belonging, and Being Open
10
Meaning, Belonging, and Being Open
Missional Theology and the Evangelization of Emerging Adults
In the spring of 2011, Richard Osmer delivered an important series of lectures, the Princeton Lectures on Youth, Church, and Culture, entitled “Evangelism in an Age of Religious Diversity” and “Interreligious Dialogue in an Age of Diversity.” In the first lecture, drawing on the work of Karl Barth, he defines evangelism as “the ministry by which the Holy Spirit uses the members of the church to awaken others to the gospel, to the good news of God’s gracious love toward the world in Jesus Christ.”209 He uses a missional framework for his interpretation of evangelism, noting that evangelism is not about “promoting one pattern of religious experience or gaining new church members,” but is centered in “giving witness to the gospel” following the prompting of the Holy Spirit.210
In developing this definition, Osmer draws on the work of Karl Barth, particularly a section of Dogmatics called “The Awakening to Conversion.” On Osmer’s view, Barth emphasizes Christ’s representative nature, noting that “In turning away from sin and toward his Father in faith and obedience, he is doing what humanity cannot do for itself.”211 Christ is able to do for humanity what humanity is unable to do; namely, to break the power of sin and death, turning to God in a restored relationship through grace alone. Conversion is therefore our participation in the conversion of Christ—awakening and reawakening from the slumber of sin to new life and restored relationship with God through Christ.
This definition of evangelism leads Osmer to offer three practical implications for the church’s ministry of “awakening” others to the gospel. First, Osmer contends that the ministry of evangelism can no longer be focused solely on those “out there,” beyond the walls of the church.212 The notion of awakening—and reawakening—faith in Christ leads to the important notion that evangelism is a continuing act in the life of the Christian. In a diverse cultural milieu, Osmer contends, there is no single program or method for effective evangelism. Rather, faithful Christians and communities of faith must be open to the leading of the Holy Spirit in order to identify opportunities for witness and discern an appropriate approach. Finally, Osmer challenges the church to be open to the ministry of witnessing to its faith in Christ because of the church’s need for conversion, not solely for the “other.”213 The church needs itself to experience an awakening to fresh insights into the gospel that derive from being in ministry with those who are newly awakened to life in Christ.
The insights that arise in Osmer’s work are particularly important for the church contending in the midst of such a diverse context as in North America. Osmer’s work serves as a challenge to the church to “awaken” itself to the ministry of evangelism, and to experience the Holy Spirit’s awakening and empowering movement to engage people—especially young people—beyond the church’s walls. At the same time, one is left to wonder, what does this holy engagement look like in practice? In addition to requiring the church to be open to its own conversion under the Spirit’s guidance, how does a community of faith go about engaging young people in the current cultural milieu in order to “offer them Christ”?
Effective Evangelism with Emerging Adults
This essay examines Osmer’s challenge to reclaim evangelism as a congregational practice in mainline congregations, by exploring the evangelization of emerging adults in three local congregations in radically different contexts. Ample empirical evidence underscores the commonly held assumption that young adults are churches’ “invisible generation.”214 But churches do not need empirical data to know they have a problem with emerging adults. The evidence for emerging adult faith drift is borne out anecdotally every Sunday morning in mainline churches whose pews are filled with older congregants wondering where all the young people have gone.
The truth is that most young people simply do not care that mainline Protestant denominations are rapidly declining, or that congregations struggle to remain connected and influential in their lives. Our goal as church leaders , therefore, must not be to salvage our institutions, but to become the communities of authentic belonging and missional engagement that emerging adults crave—and in so doing create an approach to evangelism that effectively engages them. To better understand this kind of evangelism, I went in search of congregations who effectively practiced it. I then completed qualitative case studies of three of them—congregations recognized by regional leaders as having successful ministries of evangelism with emerging adults.215 The question I sought to answer was what made these churches successful in addressing emerging adults within and beyond the church community? What did these congregations do that called emerging adults into the life of Christian faith, and integrated them meaningfully into the life of the faith community?
By exploring three “best practices”216 congregations, it is not my intent to offer you three models of ministry with young people to be tweaked and cloned to fit other situations. In fact, a clear danger in case study research is highlighting a few specific cases and making broad theoretical generalizations or applications.217 Instead, we can make “petite generalizations” that offer insight into how these communities, in their specific contexts, have effectively connected emerging adults with a life of faith and life in community. The pages that follow highlight how three communities wrestled to discern unique, contextualized ministry pathways that effectively engage disconnected young adults with faith and a faith community.
Young People with Passion: Outreach Red Bank (The ORB)
Outreach Red Bank (ORB) began as a ministry reaching out to un-churched youth in the shore community of Red Bank, New Jersey. Many of the members of the founding group of ORB were young adults that were serving as volunteer youth leaders for a large mainline church in the neighboring town. A conflict arose in that ministry about the leaders’ desire to reach out to youth who weren’t already a part of the church. Many of the parents of the church kids resisted their outreach efforts and the interim pastor supported the desires of the parents for a more internally focused ministry. As a result of the conflict, some of the leaders and other interested adults began to meet and pray about how God was calling them to be in ministry with the unchurched youth in the community and to discern God’s leading for that ministry.
After several months of prayerful discernment, this group of adults began a ministry reaching out to youth on the streets of Red Bank. They spent time in skate parks, coffee shops, and malls getting to know the youth in their natural environments. Eventually, they began a Bible study in one of the skate parks and about fifteen youth joined four leaders in the first ORB event. From there, an intergenerational worshipping community developed as youth began inviting their parents and other adults in their lives to experience God’s grace as they had through this vital ministry.
Through observation and interviews, three distinct theological commitments of Outreach Red Bank emerge as central to their life and ministry: sin and grace, missional vocation, and hospitality. When asked about the theological commitments of the congregation, the founding pastor responded, “It begins with a clear understanding of our sinfulness and our desperate need for God’s grace. We truly believe that our need for grace levels the playing field. When every member of the community understands the depth of our own sin and our utter reliance on God’s grace, then there is truly a place for everyone.” Mandy, another emerging adult participant in the young adult group, concurs: “We learn here that God loves the real you, sins and all, not the fake person that you show yourself to be.”
Another key theological commitment framing the ministry of Outreach Red Bank is a deep awareness of individual and corporate missional vocation. For Christian, the lead pastor, missional vocation is at the heart of this community. “The heartbeat of this ministry is a sense that God is up to something here in Red Bank and has given us—as individuals and as a community—a role in carrying out God’s mission. It is the missio Dei that drives us to receive grace, live in grace, and extend grace. That’s our center.” The missional shape of the church inherently transmits an understanding that Christians are not here for themselves—but for a world in need of God’s grace. Thus, when youth begin to understand God’s grace and come alive to their identity in Christ they seek ways to be in ministry and carry out the mission of God in the world. Youth experience God’s grace and catch a fire to be a part of the ministry of ORB, not for institutional survival but because of a call to be a part of God’s mission in the world.
Finally, ORB is clearly marked by a deep theological commitment to divine hospitality. It is striking when one visits any of the ministries of Outreach Red Bank that there is a wide array of people from varied social, economic, and age cohorts. The basement during a Thursday night youth gathering, led entirely by emerging adult leaders, is filled with young people from myriad social clusters interacting freely among themselves and with the leaders. In a typical American high school these groups would be deeply stratified. Chris, one of the older youth in the group and a self-described “skate rat,” says freely, “This is the place where I came to love myself, to be okay with who I am and not be ashamed of who I am. When I came for the first time, the leaders and even the other kids, they just, well, embraced me. This place is so amazing because people are able to come and just be who they are.”
In their love for one another and their profound acceptance and welcome of all people, Outreach Red Bank stands as a contrast community within an area deeply imbued with economic stratification, social group stigmatization, and an active drug culture. At the same time, the alternative community experienced at ORB does not lead to impermeable boundaries that define the church as over and against the prevailing culture. Rather, in a beautiful and poignant way, the contrast community of Outreach Red Bank shines as a beacon of God’s radical welcome extended to all humanity.
A Church Willing to Lay Down Its Life: The Wine Cellar
The Wine Cellar, an outreach ministry of the Bloomsbury and Asbury United Methodist Churches in rural New Jersey, came into existence when a small, struggling congregation challenged themselves to invest significantly into the future of the church in the face of their pending closure. Facing the prospect of closure, the pastor of the church challenged the congregation to pursue life in the face of death. “I put the question before them,” she offered, “as to what type of legacy they wanted the church to leave and whether or not they wanted to go out swinging.” She invited a small group of key leaders to join her in dreaming of what the future might hold. They met together at the church for several months and dreamed together about possibilities for ministry in their community. Within a few months, the young people and the pastoral leaders approached the leaders of the congregation with a bold plan for a new ministry.
With the blessing of the church leadership and a commitment of significant financial and physical resources amounting to the majority of the church’s savings, the team secured additional funding and began converting the lower level of the church building into a “high-tech, low-key” facility complete with satellite television, high-speed internet, printing and computer services, café tables, comfortable seating areas, and a full-service kitchen. The transformation of the space was amazing in its own right, but the loving care of parishioners who donated additional funds, purchased furniture, painted walls and doors, laid new flooring, renovated the kitchen, made curtains and pillows, and prayed regularly in the space long before it opened, was even more striking. This new venture was not only the mission of a pastor and a few young people, it was truly the mission of two congregations, one of which knew that the birth of this ministry may very well lead to its own closure.218
The first theological pillar holding up the foundation of The Wine Cellar is a profound appreciation and awareness of God’s grace active in the lives of the young people in the community.219 For the pastor, an emphasis on prevenient grace lies at the heart of this vital ministry.220 “This ministry begins from a real awareness that God is already present and active in these young people’s lives. God is nudging them, and loving them, and stirring in them, long before they walk through the cellar doors. We see our role in this ministry as nurturing their awareness of this grace, and opening clear pathways of invitation leading to their acceptance of God’s gift of love poured out for them.”
The community of The Wine Cellar is also marked by a thorough commitment to a Wesleyan notion of sanctification as the growth in holiness of heart and life.221 As young people awaken to God’s activity in their lives, and open themselves up to receive that grace, there is an emphasis on learning to live as missional witnesses to that grace. That includes, for these young people, being formed and transformed through Scripture, prayer, and corporate worship and being sent into the world and empowered to live out our faith.”
It is clear that while a holistic Wesleyan understanding of grace runs throughout The Wine Cellar, prevenient grace lies at the heart of the ministry in its current form. This emphasis on prevenient grace, with a concentrated effort to invite all young people into the community to experience an awakening to the presence of grace that is already present in their lives, leads to a complementary theological pillar of the community, namely, divine hospitality.222 When asked to identify the one central feature of The Wine Cellar, most young people emphasized in different ways the profound acceptance one experiences when they walk through the basement doors. “From the moment I walked in,” Brandon offered, “I was accepted and welcomed. There was no judgment. There was no fear. There was no hatred. I was loved and I just felt it. Being gay, I haven’t really felt that way in church before.”
A Bishop with a Vision: Saint Laurence
In 2000, Anglican pastor Chris Russell received a call from the bishop of the Diocese of Oxford that changed his life and gave new direction to his ministry. Chris recalls, “The bishop called to ask if I would pray about a vision that God had laid on his heart for a revitalized parish church in Reading focused on building church with the young people of the community.” After significant prayer, encouragement from his peers and family, extended conversations with the vicar from another parish in the community, and further discussions with the bishop and archdeacon, Chris accepted the invitation and the ministry of St. Laurence in Reading was reborn with a vision “to see young people come to faith and build new forms of church with them.”223 Along with a small team of leaders, Chris moved to Reading and opened the church in 2001 under this new mandate.
Similar to Outreach Red Bank, St. Laurence’s is an intergenerational faith community that understands its missional vocation as living the gospel among young people in the community, calling young people to faith in Jesus Christ, and finding ways to build “fresh expressions”224 of church with them. While the primary focus of the church’s outreach efforts is with young people from the primary and secondary schools in Reading, numerous emerging adults have partnered with St. Laurence in living out this missional identity. The emerging adults participate in this mission as staff people of the church, volunteer leaders in the youth ministry, worship leaders and musicians, administrative personnel, and more.
There are three key theological commitments guiding the work of St. Laurence: invitational witness, missional vocation, and a theology of place. The ministry of St. Laurence is marked by a continual invitation for young people to respond to the love of God offered in Jesus Christ. “We want to always be clear,” Chris opines, “Christianity is more than just a worldview. It is a response to what happened in and through one person, Jesus Christ. It is not our intent to simply do youth work that serves the young people of Reading, it is our intent to see young people come to faith in Jesus Christ. What we do here is invitational at its core.” The invitation to follow Christ permeates the ministry of St. Laurence, from the Wednesday afternoon lunchtime club that meets in the public high school to Monday night youth club at the church.
The missional vocation of the church is centered in its ministry with youth in the community of Reading. Every member of the parish church understands and embraces the centrality of this mission in the church’s life and witness. The leaders of St. Laurence understand that the church is a living response to the work of God in Jesus Christ, and that the call of the faith community is to continue this story of God’s inviting, incarnational love.
The renovated twelfth century building standing in the heart of Reading at the gates of the Abbey serves as a central element of the church’s ministry. “We have a deeply rooted theology of place, to use John Inge’s term,”225 the Vicar explains. “In an age when so many people argue against the significance of buildings, we believe that the incarnational presence of the church and its history in Reading is truly significant to our ministry with young people.” As the largest provider of youth work in the city, St. Laurence’s location in the center of the town square provides young people with a clearly identifiable safe haven from the complexities and challenges of life.
Meaning, Belonging, and Being Open: Theological Commitments and Ministry Directions
Emerging from these case studies are three key threads of theological commitment weaving throughout each story that bind these communities together: a clear understanding of individual and corporate Christian vocation, or purposeful work; a strong sense of identity and belonging within the community of faith; and a posture of radical openness and hospitality to the community beyond the church.
Meaning and Purpose
It was interesting to discover in this research that all three ministries representing different theological heritages claim missional vocation as the guiding principle for the formation of their respective congregations, not simply for their ministries with emerging adults. Darrell L. Guder asserts that the missional nature of the church is chiefly to make known the joyful message of salvation to the world. “That is how God’s mission now continues. The center or core of the missio Dei is evangelization: the communication of the gospel. Carrying the good news across all borders and into all the world is an essential part of the kingdom message which Jesus brought and embodied.”226 Each of these communities calls emerging adults to be active agents of missional transformation rather than passive recipients of the church’s ministry programs.
Outreach Red Bank was developed as a missional community that understands its particular vocation as reaching out to unchurched youth in Red Bank; from the outset the stated mission was “becoming a community of grace where youth can come to know Jesus Christ.” In that way, they saw themselves forming a community that was striving to live faithfully as disciples of Jesus Christ and making the story of salvation known to the young people in their sphere of influence. The Asbury United Methodist Church wrestled with the question of how God was calling them to participate in God’s mission in the face of their imminent closure. Through an intentional process of prayer and discernment, the small congregation decided to invest a significant portion of their remaining savings as well as their limited people resources in the development of The Wine Cellar. At St. Laurence, the missional vocation of the congregation is bound in its preferential option for young people as they seek to be a parish church for the youth in Reading. The vicar explains, “While we are a parish church and serve an intergenerational community, we are clearly outward focused and we ask everyone in the church to support our ministry with the young people, whether in leading, serving, giving, or praying. This is our vocation as a church and it is what we have heard God calling and sending us to do in the world.”
Belonging in Community
All three congregations have worked hard to develop communities within which emerging adults can experience true belonging and from which a clear identity as members crystallizes. The words of Sidney, a self-identified “member” of the Wine Cellar, echo across each story: “Before I came here, I was sort of lost, you know? I knew . . . or at least thought I knew . . . that I wasn’t wanted anywhere near a church. But when Isaiah brought me here, I immediately felt like I belonged . . . like I was always meant to be here.” Whether sitting around the warm fireplace in the basement of the Wine Cellar, the old couches and comfy chairs in Red Bank, or the contemporary loft of an ancient building in Reading, England, scores of emerging adults have discovered authentic community and religious belonging. These churches have countered the trend that emerging adults do not experience authentic belonging in the church.227
A salient feature of the Christian identity formed through participation in the community of faith, as evident in all three cases, is a willingness to extend the grace received to others. Jill recalls her first meeting with Pastor Gina: “When I first met Gina, I was a mess! My life was falling apart and she welcomed me without judgment or condemnation. Through her, the church embraced me and I came to really put my life back together . . . Now my ministry here is to do the same thing for other kids who were a mess like I was.”
Radical Hospitality and Genuine Openness
This conspicuous presence of God’s deep welcome for all young people has clearly left a mark on the faith community of Outreach Red Bank. There is no doubt that this congregation understands its primary mission as being living witnesses to God’s grace so that all people can experience that gift of grace—regardless of who they are, where they have been, or what they have done. For the leadership of St. Laurence, radical hospitality stems from the longing to see young people come to faith in Jesus Christ and the continual invitation extended. Through invitational witness, the emerging adult leaders offer a message of acceptance and invitation for the youth of the community to join them in following Christ. Hospitality in this community is also deeply rooted in their theology of place, in the identification of the church as the parish church for the young people of Reading. As an incarnational presence in the community, and through the witness of the building’s restoration, there is a clear message to the young people of Reading that they are welcomed by the church, and by God.
In all three settings, there is a deep openness and receptivity of the people, particularly young people, who do not identify themselves as Christians. In their practice of welcome at the beginning of every corporate gathering, someone from the community of Outreach Red Bank will step forward and announce something like, “This is a place where we want you to feel and experience a deep sense of belonging. Here, you can be who you are and know that you are loved. Here, some of us are Christians, and it is our hope that you come to experience God’s love and grace as we did. But you don’t have to be a Christian to be here . . . or to belong here. You just have to be you.”
Stories of congregations such as these that are effectively reaching emerging adults and engaging them in community life fall like buckets of rain on the parched, dry land offering hope to struggling churches. Strikingly, the programmatic ministries offered in the three congregations we have explored do not differ greatly from other congregations who have attempted to effectively engage emerging adults. One cannot look here for “tricks of the trade” for effective evangelism with young people. What we can discern, however, is the work that led each of these congregations and their leaders to create such ministries. By undertaking the painstaking work of contextualization, by learning the unique developmental needs of emerging adults taking shape in their communities, and by identifying the particular gifts and resources that their congregations offer, these churches have effectively lived out their missional calling with and for young people. Not coincidentally, every church found bridge-building connective tissue between the congregation and emerging adults in their theological DNA, especially in Christian teaching around meaning, belonging, and openness to others.
Each of these case studies tells a unique story about a particular people who discerned that God was calling and equipping them to participate in the missio Dei by developing ministries that would invite young people into lives of faith and life in community. Once they discerned that calling, they each set about the difficult task of contextualization and developed ministries that flowed from their gifts and resources and were reflective of their unique context. The missional heartbeat of these congregations underscores the importance of recovering a revitalized and robust missional ecclesiology as the starting point for developing a faithful ministry of evangelism with and among emerging adults. Standing alone, each story is a powerful witness to God’s work of grace in and through a community of faith that offers hope for church’s attempting to reach “the invisible generation.” Seen together, these stories can point congregations towards more holistic, effective ministries of evangelism with emerging adults.
Bibliography
Arnett, Jeffrey Jensen. Emerging Adulthood: The Winding Road from the Late Teens through the Twenties. New York: Oxford University Press, 2004.
Barna, Geroge. “Most Twenty Somethings Put Christianity on the Shelf Following Spiritually Active Teenage Years.” The Barna Update, September 11, 2006.http://www.barna.org/barna-update/article/16-teensnext-gen/147-most-twentysomethings-put-christianity-on-the-shelf-following-spiritually-active-teen-years.
Creswell, John C. Qualitative Inquiry and Research Design: Choosing Among Five Traditions. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 1998.
Emmerson, Michael O., and Christian Smith. Divided By Faith: Evangelical Religion and the Problem of Race in America. New York: Oxford University Press, 2000.
Eglene, Ophelia. “Conducting Best and Current Practices Research: A Starter Kit.” SUNY Center for Technology Research Center. https://www.ctg.albany.edu/media/pubs/pdfs/conducting_best.pdf.
“Fresh Expressions Homepage.” Fresh Expressions, July 2, 2010. http://www.freshexpressions.org.uk/.
Guder, Darrell. The Continuing Conversion of the Church. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2000.
Grossman, Cathy Lynn. “Young Adults aren’t Sticking with the Church.” USA Today, August 6, 2007. http://www.usatoday.com/news/religion/2007–08-06-church-dropouts_N.htm.
Hoge, Dean R., et al. “Determinants of Church Involvement of Young Adults Who Grew up in Presbyterian Churches.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 32 (September 1993) 242–55.
Inge, John. A Christian Theology of Place. Burlington: Ashgate, 2003.
Martinson, Roland. “Spiritual but not Religious: Reaching an Invisible Generation.” Currents in Theology and Mission 29, (2002) 326–40.
“Mission.” St. Laurence ReadingAugust 21, 2010. https://www.stlreading.org/who-we-are-1/.
Oden, Amy. God’s Welcome: Hospitality for a Gospel-Hungry World. Cleveland, OH: Pilgrim, 2008.
Osmer, Richard R. Practical Theology: An Introduction. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2008.
———. “Evangelism in an Age of Religious Diversity.” Paper presented at the Princeton Lectures on Youth, Church, and Culture, Princeton, NJ, 2011. http://www.ptsem.edu/lectures/?action=tei&id=youth-2011–02
———. The Teaching Ministry of Congregations. Louisville, KY: Westminster John Knox, 2005.
“Millennials: A Portrait of Generation Next; Confident. Connected. Open to Change.” Pew Research Center, February 24, 2010. http://assets.pewresearch.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/3/2010/10/millennials-confident-connected-open-to-change.pdf.
Rakestraw, Robert V. “John Wesley as a Theologian of Grace.” Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society 27 (1984) 193–203.
Smith, Christian. American Evangelicalism: Embattled and Thriving. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1998.
———. Souls in Transition: The Religious and Spiritual Lives of Emerging Adults. New York: Oxford University Press, 2009.
Stake, Robert E. The Art of Case Study Research. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 1995.
Willits, F. K., and D. M. Crider. “Church Attendance and Religious Beliefs in Adolescence and Young Adulthood: A Panel Study.” Review of Religious Research 31 (1989) 68–81.
Wuthnow, Robert. After the Babyboomers: How Twenty- and Thirty-Somethings are
Shaping the Future of American Religion. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2007.
209. Osmer, “Evangelism in an Age of Religious Diversity,” 8.
210. Ibid.
211. Ibid., 7.
212. Ibid.
213. Ibid., 10.
214. The moniker “invisible generation” refers to the rapidly growing cohort of younger adults who have disengaged from active involvement in the Christian life in and through mainline congregations. See Martinson, “Spiritual but not Religious.” Also see Wuthnow, After the Babyboomers; Hoge et al.,“Determinants of Church Involvement of Young Adults”; Barna, “Most Twenty Somethings Put Christianity on the Shelf”; Willits and Crider, “Church Attendance and Religious Beliefs”; and Grossman, “Young Adults aren’t Sticking with the Church.”
215. According to Creswell, “a case study is an exploration of a ‘bounded system’ or a case (or multiple cases) over time through detailed, in-depth data collection involving multiple sources of information in rich context.” This research project began as three distinct “within-case analyses,” investigating the particular cases and creating a thick description of emerging themes. From there, it expanded into a “cross-case analysis,” linking themes that emerge from these exemplary cases and examining similarities and differences in order to provide different lenses through which to view the driving research question. Case studies allow the researcher to paint a picture, to tell a story that illuminates how a given phenomenon plays out in a given context. See Creswell, Qualitative Inquiry and Research Design, 61.
216. “Best practices” research enables the qualitative researcher to investigate cases that have proven exemplary in a given area to discern what empowered their success. In a cross-case analysis, best practices research identifies the “threads” that run through multiple cases to develop petite rather than grand generalizations. See Eglene, “Conducting Best and Current Practices Research.”
217 “The real business of case study is particularization, not generalization.” See Stake, The Art of Case Study Research, 7–8.
218. Eventually, the Wine Cellar closed its doors. Rather than pointing to a failed ministry, however, this serves to illustrate the fluid nature of ministry among emerging generations.
219. As a United Methodist ministry, The Wine Cellar is deeply rooted in its Wesleyan theological heritage and the distinctive way John Wesley understood the Christian doctrine of grace. See Rakestraw, “John Wesley as a Theologian of Grace.”
220. Prevenient grace, on Wesley’s view, was the critical doctrine that enabled him to affirm the total depravity of human kind. Essentially, prevenient grace is an expression of God’s grace that surrounds and indwells all of humanity prior to, and regardless of, their own awareness of that grace. It is the presence of God in the Holy Spirit that gently, and sometimes relentlessly, moves humans towards an awareness of their own sin, and into a saving relationship with Jesus Christ. Ibid., 196.
221. Wesley’s notion of sanctification as the growth of holiness of heart and life constitutes a “faith-response to God’s grace-initiative,” meaning that good works do not produce holiness, but rather God’s grace works in the person of faith through the means of grace to gradually form her in holiness on the road to Christian perfection. See ibid., 200.
222. Following Amy Oden, I use divine hospitality to refer to God’s welcome extended by communities of faith to all people as a means of welcoming people into God’s gift of abundant life, not simply a warm and fuzzy welcome into a community of friends. See Oden, God’s Welcome.
223. “Mission,” St. Laurence, Reading.
224 Fresh Expressions is a term coined by the Anglican Communion to call forth “new forms of church for a rapidly changing world.” See “Fresh Expressions Homepage,” http://www.freshexpressions.org.uk/
225. Inge puts forth the notion that the biblical paradigm for the sacramental human encounter with God occurs at the nexus of “place, people, and God.” See Inge, A Christian Theology of Place, x.
226. Guder, The Continuing Conversion of the Church, 49.
227. Smith, Souls in Transition, 152.
