Chapter 9 of 22

An Interlude

An Interlude

An Interlude

So there you have it. The rise of the nones, why they have risen, and what marks their thinking. But what can be done to reach them? That is what the second part of this book will explore. But first we must ground ourselves in the most significant shift of missional paradigms that has taken place in our day: we have moved from an Acts 2 missional context to an Acts 17 missional context.

Both scenes from the New Testament portray a classic engagement of contemporary culture. In Acts 2, you have Peter before the God-fearing Jews of Jerusalem. His message is easily paraphrased and summarized:

You know about the creation, Adam and Eve, and the fall; you know about Moses and the Law; you know about Abraham and the chosen people of Israel; you know of the prophets and the promised coming of the Messiah. So we don’t need to waste time on that. What you need to know is that Jesus was that Messiah, you rejected him, and now you are in deep weeds and need to repent.

That was it. And three thousand did!

Peter was able to speak to a group of people who were already monotheists, already buying into the Old Testament Scriptures, and already believing in a coming Messiah. Now move to Acts 17:22–31. Paul is on Mars Hill speaking to the philosophers and spiritual theorists of Athens. This was a spiritual marketplace where truth was relative, worldviews and gods littered the landscape, and the average person didn’t know Abraham from an apricot. He knew he wasn’t in Kansas—I mean Jerusalem—anymore. So he didn’t take an Acts 2 approach, much less give an Acts 2 message. He had to find a way to connect with the culture, and the people in it. So he looked around and found a touchstone—an altar to an unknown God. The culture was so pluralistic that the only thing they could agree on was that you couldn’t know anything for sure.

The Temple in Jerusalem (Wikimedia Commons)

“What if I could tell you that God’s name?” Paul offered. “Would that be of interest?”

Paul then went all the way back to creation and began working his way forward—laying a foundation for an understanding and subsequent engagement of the gospel. He had to. They didn’t have any knowledge of the Christian faith to start with.

Like today.

But there is something even beyond the Acts 17 context to consider. With the original Mars Hill, there was rampant ignorance about Christianity, not to mention Judaism. Paul was able to start with a blank slate. In our context today, our culture is post-Christian, not non-Christian. This is a significant difference. In a post-Christian context many believe they do know about Christianity—even though it’s often a caricature of its true nature—and thus they feel it has been tried and found wanting. Further, the current context continually lampoons the Christian faith while dismissing it as intellectually bereft of weight. There’s a been there, done that attitude that is often more difficult to overcome than when engaging a pristine mission field. So we have a culture that is post-Christian, yet the people think they know Christianity. Consider it the worst combination of Acts 2 and Acts 17 imaginable.

It is just as important to note what an Acts 17 approach is not. It is not simply becoming more hip and trendy, mirroring our culture in ways that make us fit in. As Marc Yoder writes in a blog that went viral titled “Top 10 Reasons Our Kids Leave Church,”

We’ve taken a historic, 2,000 year old faith, dressed it in plaid and skinny jeans and tried to sell it as “cool” to our kids. It’s not cool. It’s not modern. What we’re packaging is a cheap knockoff. . . .

In our effort to be “like them” we’ve become less of who we actually are. The middle-aged pastor trying to look like his twentysomething audience isn’t relevant. Dress him up in skinny jeans and hand him a latte, it doesn’t matter. It’s not relevant, it’s comically cliché.

In another book I have written of this mistaken approach as the attempt to reflect culture; like a mirror we reflect culture and its values. Rather than trying to influence culture, we allow culture to influence us. The spirit of this is the attempt to “become all things to all people so that by all possible means” we may save some, as Paul suggests (1 Cor. 9:22). There can be little doubt that evangelical Christianity has been captive in a cultural ghetto of its own making. To break free of such bondage, many have made the effort to build bridges of understanding and relationship. Whether through the use of contemporary music or film, secular venues or vernacular, the goal has been to create a means for connection. So rather than railing against pornography through presidential commissions, there are booths set up at the AVN Adult Entertainment Expo in Las Vegas with the message: “Jesus loves porn stars.”

While laudable and often necessary, some efforts at reflection have slid into mere mirroring. Rather than working in and through culture in the form of, for example, Paul on Mars Hill, or creating a Mars Hill culture of dialogue and openness, there is a growing movement that seems to reflect the values of Mars Hill itself in order to gain a hearing—actually becoming the people we are attempting to reach and creating cultures that reflect our world rather than building bridges to reach it. Consider the recent blog post of one young Christian leader who, articulating his stance on homosexuality, felt himself

drifting toward acceptance that gay persons are fully human persons and should be afforded all of the cultural and ecclesial benefits that I am. . . . I now believe that GLBTQ [Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual, Transgender, and Queer] can live lives in accord with biblical Christianity (at least as much as any of us can!) and that their monogamy can and should be sanctioned and blessed by church and state.

Yes to being fully human persons; no to GLBTQ who embrace such lifestyles, even in monogamy, living in accord with biblical Christianity and being blessed by the church. Such blessing is not reaching into a culture with the love of Christ; it is becoming that culture. Paul’s suggestion to “become all things” was never behavioral in its intent—reflecting culture in such a way that we have its values and ideas mirrored in our own values and beliefs. Paul’s intent was to build bridges of understanding upon which the two parties could meet. It is one thing to reach out to porn stars; it is another to embrace pornography.

Much of this flows from our cultural insecurities. We want to be accepted by culture, not simply because we want a hearing, but because we long for cultural standing. In our efforts to distance ourselves from such enterprises as the Moral Majority, we seem fixated on fitting in—and not just fitting in, but being seen as just as “hip” as the next person. We have seemed to succumb to what some have called the “celebrification” of culture—an awkward term, perhaps, but like “industrialization” and “bureaucratization,” it speaks to a broad and historical trend: the increasing centrality of celebrities to the culture. Movie and television stars, professional athletes and musicians, business moguls and journalists have captured our attention as never before. Joseph Epstein writes that “a received opinion about America in the early twenty-first century is that our culture values only two things: money and celebrity.” From this, celebrities have become our cultural commentators, charity spokespersons, role models, and political candidates. They have become the arbiters of taste, morality, and public opinion. Richard Schickel, who has written for Time magazine since 1972, reflects, “No issue or idea in our culture can gain any traction with the general population unless it has celebrity names attached to it.”

As a result, there is a seduction to move from building bridges in and through such a celebrity culture to reach the world, to building bridges in and through celebrity culture in order to be accepted by the world—or to become celebrities ourselves. The cultural goal often seems to be to get in the culture rather than remain on its outskirts, leading some Christians to cling to Bono more than Bonhoeffer. Playing off the many motivational posters, one tongue-in-cheek blogger phrased it, “Cultural Awareness: Following Bono to the Pub, to the Concert, and to the Uttermost Parts of the Earth.”

No, an Acts 17 approach is not about reflecting culture; it is about seeing America as the mission field. As an Episcopalian priest from South Carolina recently offered, “A couple came into my office once with a yellow pad of their teenage son’s questions. One of them was: ‘What is that guy doing hanging up there on the plus sign?’”

It’s time we tell him.

↑ Back to top

↑