Chapter 11 of 22

7. If You Build It, They Won’t Come

7. If You Build It, They Won’t Come

7

If You Build It, They Won’t Come

Another one came this past week. A flyer arrived in my mailbox from a new church plant, promising me relevant and practical messages, contemporary “urban” music, and great coffee. The idea behind the mailer seemed to be, “If you build it, they will come.” Or more to the point, “If you offer it, they will come.” Meaning that if you spruce church up a bit musically and stylistically, and if the unchurched are informed, those same unchurched people will suddenly stream in your doors and fill your seats.

No, they won’t.

Not if they are truly unchurched, part of the growing number of religious nones that make up our modern milieu. Yes, it worked in the movie Field of Dreams. A man built a baseball diamond in the middle of a cornfield having been promised, “If you build it, he will come”—meaning Shoeless Joe Jackson and other members of the 1919 Chicago White Sox. Eventually crowds of people do come to watch baseball there. Sounds strange, but it’s a fun film.

But don’t ever think that’s all there is to reaching an unchurched person who isn’t even looking for a defined faith, much less a church. It’s a subtle and enticing temptation. All we have to do is encourage casual dress, offer Starbucks coffee, play rock music, and then deliver a “felt needs” message in a style similar to the popular speakers of the day, and we will automatically grow. And if you want to guarantee your growth comes from a younger demographic, just throw in skinny jeans, designer T-shirts, and a noticeable tattoo. It will instantly turn the most middle-aged pastor into a Millennial magnet.

The only problem is that it isn’t true. Yet it persists as one of the great urban legends of the ecclesiastical world.

Some will say, “But wait. I know of a new church plant that went uber-contemporary, and they exploded in growth!” Yes, I know of several too. But look hard at those churches. How much of their growth is transfer growth and how much is truly conversion growth? And even if they claim a high number of baptisms, who are they baptizing? In many cases, even the baptism numbers are those rededicating their life (rebaptisms) or Presbyterians getting dunked as adults. Or it’s kids and teenagers—meaning, reaping the work of already existing Christian families.

One of the least publicized research projects of the 1990s, but easily one of the most significant, discovered that more than 60 percent of adults baptized in Southern Baptist churches that year had been baptized before. And of those who were rebaptized, nearly 40 percent were receiving their second immersion in a Southern Baptist church. Overall, rebaptisms of Southern Baptists accounted for one out of every five Southern Baptist baptisms.

Hear my heart; I’m not putting down such churches. I just want to make sure we understand our models. And specifically, that if we want to be a church for the unchurched—which today increasingly means a church of the nones—we understand what that means. Because even if a contemporary church plant grows rapidly from the unchurched, and many do, those people didn’t come first and foremost because it was contemporary.

Let’s go back to the mailer I received. It promised contemporary music, casual dress, and good coffee.

Stop. Think.

People already have those things. They do not need to go to church to find them. If they want Starbucks, they’ll go to Starbucks; if they want to hear contemporary music, they have iTunes and their iPod. They may appreciate those things once they attend, but it is not what will get them to attend. This approach may have worked back in the 1980s and ’90s, but that was because the typical unchurched person was a baby boomer who had been raised in a church and was just starting to have kids. They had the memory and the experience; once they had kids, they actually wanted to find a church. When churches took down the cultural barriers associated with attending (eliminating stuffiness, boredom, irrelevance, empty ritual, outdated music), boomers were attracted. And yes, back then if you built it, they came.

But this is no longer our world, and it hasn’t been for quite some time. Think of it this way: In today’s paper, there were probably dozens of ads for new cars. In fact, there was probably an entire section devoted to nothing but car ads. If you read the paper, did you notice them? It’s doubtful—unless you are in the market for a car. (These days, it’s doubtful you even read a newspaper—but let’s play this out.) If you’re not in the market for a car, it doesn’t matter to you if a dealer is having a sale, promises a rebate, has an on-site radio broadcast, hangs out balloons, says they’re better than everyone else, promises that they will be different and not harass you or make you bargain over the price, or sends you a brochure or an email.

Why? You’re not in the market for a car.

It’s amazing the degree to which outreach strategies rest on a single, deeply flawed premise that people want what you have to offer. More often than not, they don’t.

As uber-marketer Seth Godin notes, “The portion of the population that haven’t bought from you . . . is not waiting for a better mousetrap. They’re not busy considering a, b and c and then waiting for d. No, they’re not in the market. . . . As a result, smart marketers don’t market to this audience by saying, ‘hey ours is better than theirs!’”

It’s no different with a church. The vast majority of those who are unchurched are not actively seeking a church home. Further, they are divorced from seeing it as a need in their life, even when they are open to and interested in spiritual things. They no longer tie their spiritual interest and longing to the need to find a particular faith, much less a particular church. If anything, they are antichurch.

So direct mail efforts that offer casual dress and Starbucks coffee, contemporary music and practical messages, are offering cars to those who aren’t in the market for a car. These promos are simply positioning themselves as an alternative to other churches when the people in question are not interested in church at all. Godin is spot-on when he writes, “No, they won’t respond to a better-than-them pitch. Instead, they’re much more likely to respond to a new statement of their problem and a new statement of the solution. Don’t ask them to announce that they were wrong when they decided that they didn’t need a tablet, a survival kit or an anti-impotence drug. Instead, make it easy for them to make a new decision based on new information.”

Rethinking Evangelism

Picture an imaginary scale from 1 to 10. On the left end of the scale, at the 1, we have someone who is completely divorced from a relationship with or knowledge of Christ. On the other end of the scale, at the 10, is that point in time when the spiritual journey of an individual results in coming to saving faith in and knowledge of Christ. I know, this is a crude and overly simplistic scale, but let me try to illustrate the point.

Let’s begin by using this scale to evaluate the typical unchurched person of the past. Speaking in broad terms, where on the scale would such a person living in the United States in 1960 have been?

Few would deny that the typical unchurched person of that time was far from a none. More than likely their spiritual résumé included

an acceptance of the deity of Christ

a belief that truth exists and that the Bible is trustworthy

a positive image of the church and its leaders

a church background and experience that was relatively healthy

a foundational knowledge of the essential truths of the Christian faith

a built-in sense of guilt or conviction that kicked in when he or she violated the basic tenets of the Judeo-Christian value system

Whew!

So on a scale of 1 to 10, this person can be placed at 8.

The top evangelistic strategies of 1960—revivals, door-to-door visitation, Sunday school, and busing—were well oriented to this context. For example, revivals were productive because people who needed Christ would actually attend them due to the cultural pressure to be present.

Door-to-door visitation was effective because people opened their doors to church folk and gladly invited them into their home. Regardless of a person’s spiritual convictions, failure to have done so would have been considered rude.

Sunday school was evangelistically fruitful because individuals were not too intimidated to begin their exploration of a church through a small group experience. Sunday school enrollment campaigns also benefited from the cultural pressure to open one’s door, the positive image of the church, and the built-in sense of conviction that resulted from not being involved in church. Once enrolled, there was a strong sense of obligation to attend; it was, after all, the church.

And bus ministries? They were supported by parents who willingly allowed their children to board a vehicle driven by a stranger, be transported to some building in another part of the city for a religious event to be implemented by more strangers, and then be returned to them later that day.

Yeah, right. But it was effective because that is precisely how it worked.

With each of these efforts (because unchurched people were already at an 8 on the scale), a one-time, cold-call presentation of the gospel was effective. After all, they did not need to move very far up the line—just from an 8 to a 10. All it took was a bump.

One of the most pressing questions for the church in today’s world is this: Are the conditions and attitudes that created such a successful context for those strategies still in place today? Are the people we are trying to reach today the same as they were in 1960?

The answer is no. Today the typical unchurched person is not simply unchurched, but as charted earlier, more than likely he or she is in the none category.

A few years ago, sensing the sea change that was afoot, I began speaking of something I called (borrowing from C. S. Lewis) “The Great Divorce.” I was attempting to describe a separation between spiritual longing and desire and the embrace of a particular religious faith. It wasn’t that people were far away from Christ and his church in their life and knowledge; instead, they no longer saw their spiritual desire and search as involving the discovery of a faith or religion. There were too many roads to God, so they were no longer even looking for a road. If the current malaise was simply about belief in Christianity as “the way,” our challenge would be creating deeper levels of understanding. If the impasse involved doubt that Christianity is the way, that would take an effort toward convincing. Today, people reject that there’s even a way, so the challenge is to show that there is even a need for Christianity itself.

So where does the contemporary unchurched person rest on our imaginary scale? One could theorize that he or she is best placed at a 3.

Now reflect on the implications this may have on traditional evangelistic approaches. In a day when reports of child molestation and sexual abuse by religious leaders make headlines and when confidence in religious leadership is so low, it is highly doubtful that many parents will allow their children to participate in a traditional bus ministry. Door-to-door visitation of any kind has been declared unlawful in many areas and impossible in the ever-growing number of closed, guarded, gated communities. More to the point, few people today enjoy an unannounced visitor knocking on their door and will not risk opening it to a stranger. Revivals no longer have the cultural support they once enjoyed as a community event, and as a result, they have very few non-Christians in attendance. Church members are finding that many people are too intimidated to begin their spiritual journey with a small group experience such as Sunday school and that traditional enrollment campaigns suffer for the same reasons as door-to-door visitation.

Even if a Christian does get a foot in the door or manages to get a friend to a revival, the impact of a one-time, cold-call type presentation is greatly diminished because the typical nonbeliever is no longer at an 8 on the scale. It takes time for someone to move up the scale. And while there are clearly some Saul-to-Paul experiences, they are the exceptions, not the rule.

It is time to rethink evangelism, and that begins with capturing a new understanding of evangelism—one that sees evangelism as both process and event.

Evangelism as Process and Event

In my relationship with my wife, Susan, there was a process of dating and courtship that preceded the actual event of our marriage. It is rare for people to become engaged, much less get married, on their first date.

It is no different with Christ. When someone comes to saving faith in Christ, there is both an adoption process and an actual decision event. Yet for the last several decades, evangelism capitalized on a unique state of affairs, namely a culture filled with people who were relatively advanced in their spiritual knowledge and, as a result, able to quickly and responsibly consider the event of accepting Christ as Savior and Lord.

In light of today’s realities, there must be fresh attention paid to the process that leads people to the event of salvation. The goal is not simply knowing how to articulate the means of coming to Christ (the 10 moment); it is learning how to facilitate and enable the person to progress from a 3 to a 7 or 8, where he or she is able to even consider accepting Christ in a responsible fashion.

When I was in elementary school, one of my teachers brought an incubator to class. We learned that an incubator maintains the kind of environment that is necessary for the birth of a baby chick. If it became too cold for the eggs, the baby bird inside the egg would die. In order for the egg to hatch, there had to be a certain degree of warmth. When it comes to evangelism, the efforts of the church need to be like an incubator. Every approach, every program, every service furnishes a particular environment that will either serve the evangelistic process or hinder it.

Let’s use our term none to represent a person who may be open to spiritual things but is at a 3 on the scale. This person is in desperate need of someone or something to facilitate the process of moving him or her up the line toward being able to even consider the life and message of Christ. The following types of environments are among those that a church can present.

None Hostile

The first environment a church can manifest is none hostile. A church can be openly antagonistic toward nones who may venture in to attend its services.

Michelle was trapped in the demeaning world of prostitution, drug addiction, and alcoholism. Wanting to escape this life, Michelle disguised herself and hid from her pimp for several days while going through chemical withdrawal. She was discovered and dragged into the chambers of the raging man, where she was beaten until unconscious while the other prostitutes watched and learned.

Next Michelle tried suicide—anything to escape the nightmare of her existence. A relative found her body, hours from death, and rushed her to the hospital, where her life was saved.

This time Michelle turned to the only place she could imagine there might be hope—a local church. She had no sense of self-worth. Used by men, rejected by the world, she turned to God’s people. She knew she deserved punishment but hoped against hope that she might find mercy. Halfway through the church service, the pastor recognized her from her life on the street. Before the entire congregation he pointed her out and then lectured her for defiling the house of God with her filthy presence. Then he ordered her out.

An extreme case? Perhaps. But it is all too common in lesser forms.

Kristina and her roommate decided to go to church because they had hit on some rough times. Kristina’s roommate had become pregnant outside of marriage. They decided to search a little deeper for purpose and meaning. High on their list for investigation was Christianity.

They decided to try a church near their apartment. They went, attended faithfully, and tried to build some relationships. They both wanted to turn from the lifestyles they had been living and seek God. After just a few weeks, however, it became known in the church that the baby carried by Kristina’s roommate was conceived out of wedlock. Suddenly people wouldn’t sit by them and stopped talking whenever they approached. No one smiled at them when they entered the church. It wasn’t long before the pastor asked them not to return because of the nature of their situation. As you can imagine, Kristina and her roommate never wanted to darken the doorstep of a church again.

The pastor’s explanation? “You’re just not our type.”

None Indifferent

A second environment can be termed none indifferent. This church climate is not hostile but merely apathetic. The questions, concerns, and exploration process of a person who may be at a 3 on the scale and is interested in moving up the line are simply overlooked.

While in New England for a speaking engagement, I recall meeting a pastor of a Baptist church who shared his frustrations regarding the growth of his church. I asked him what he thought the problem was and he responded, “Well, there just aren’t any more Baptists in my area.” Cultivating an atmosphere for someone who was not a Baptist, much less a Christian, had never entered his mind. He was not hostile to those outside the church; he was just oblivious to them.

None Hopeful

A church that creates a none hopeful environment wants to see nones come and meet Christ, but they have never thought about the nature of the church’s climate. Altar calls are extended with great hope and fervor, revivals are held, Sunday school campaigns are enacted, but the warmth of the incubator has not been adjusted. The internal environment has not been changed for years, and as a result, nothing has been done that will effectively bring in nones, much less serve their pilgrimage toward Christ. This type of environment is like a fishing expedition in which people put bait on a hook, place it in the middle of the boat’s deck, and then join hands to pray for the fish to jump in and grab the hook.

None Sensitive

A fourth environment a church can offer is none sensitive. This atmosphere exhibits some concrete efforts to draw and encourage the nones. While the overall orientation of the church is still directed toward the growth and maturation of the already convinced, the thermostat has clearly been adjusted to allow all eggs to receive some of the warmth and care they need in order to hatch.

None Targeted

The fifth atmospheric category is best termed none targeted. This is preferable to being none driven, which would mistakenly intimate that the whim of the nones is what determines the theology and direction of the church. In truth, a none-targeted environment is one in which church members place a high priority on the needs of the nones and, like CarMax in the previous chapter, make every effort to remove any and all barriers that could impede the exploration process. Every barrier, that is, except the scandal of the cross. This is not about an abandonment of orthodoxy in an effort to cater to the sensibilities of those alien to the Christian faith. A none-targeted climate is just that—targeted on facilitating the process of evangelizing nones. The growth and maturation of believers is certainly cared for, but there is a conscious attempt to be an evangelistic incubator that is set at just the right temperature in regard to the front door or entry points of the church.

But there is still one more environment, and it is arguably the most subtle of all.

No Man’s Land

I grew up with Wheaties, the cereal known as the “Breakfast of Champions.” You knew an athlete had arrived on the cultural scene if his or her picture landed on the front of one of its boxes. But Wheaties has fallen onto hard times of late. There are many reasons for this, but industry insiders say that the heart of the matter is simple: Wheaties is in no man’s land.

That’s my terminology, but here’s what the pundits are saying: Wheaties isn’t healthy enough for the Fiber One crowd, and it isn’t unhealthy enough for the Frosted Flakes crowd. That’s no man’s land. By not positioning itself firmly in any camp—not quite the health food, not quite the junk food—it reaches no one.

It’s not just cereal that can fall into this category. The heart of no man’s land for a church is not being targeted enough to reach the unchurched but being too targeted to the unchurched for the churched. Such churches are too tilted to those exploring the Christian faith to have their weekend services attract large numbers of traditionally minded, church-is-for-me believers, yet too caught in the cultural trappings of traditional church to attract explorers—or at least have their members feel comfortable inviting their unchurched friends.

Why is it so common for churches to find themselves in no man’s land? It’s because many churches get the surface issues of connecting with those outside the church but little more. They get the music, the dress, the style. Yet they don’t go far enough in leading the church to have a missional heart to reach out to those outside the church and invite them in; and they don’t have culturally informed and culturally sensitive messages and environments that address the questions and concerns of our day. In other words, they have style but not substance, décor but not decorum. They’re trying to stand on Mars Hill with an Acts 17 vibe, but they’re doing it with a Jerusalem/Acts 2 DNA. So they end up reaching neither group.

They know about Mars Hill, talk about Mars Hill, even yearn for Mars Hill; but they don’t really know, in an intuitive sense, how to stand on Mars Hill. They are cultural critics, even cultural students, but not cultural apologists. A real Mars Hill person could spend ten minutes in their church service and see a mindset oriented toward those already convinced of Jerusalem playing out all over the place.

You pick where your church should stand—Mars Hill or Jerusalem. Of course I would argue for Mars Hill. But whatever you do, there’s one place you don’t want to find yourself: no man’s land.

Questions for Discussion and Reflection

  • Have you fallen into the trap of “if you build it, they will come”?
  • If so, it may stem from a false belief that people want what you are selling. More often than not, they don’t. They don’t want religion—especially not the caustic brand of Christianity they think is being offered. Are you assuming people want what you have to offer? Are you providing something they can already get elsewhere?
  • Are the conditions and attitudes of the religiously unaffiliated the same today as they were in the 1960s? Does your outreach strategy look any different than that of a church in the 1960s?
  • An important thing to remember about evangelism is that it takes time, especially when those outside the faith are openly hostile to it. Is your church paying attention to the process leading up to the event of salvation? What would that even look like?
  • This chapter detailed several different church environments from the perspective of the nones. If you had to pick one to describe your church, which would it be: none hostile, none indifferent, none hopeful, none sensitive, none targeted, or no man’s land?
  • Why did you rate it that way?
  • Which would you like to be?
  • What strategic steps do you need to take to get to that environment?
  • ↑ Back to top

    ↑