Chapter 15 of 22

11. The Importance of Unity

11. The Importance of Unity

11

The Importance of Unity

The CNN program Crossfire, which boasted being about left versus right, black versus white, paper versus plastic, the Red Sox against the Yankees, had daringly invited comedian Jon Stewart on to the show after Stewart criticized them for their acerbic banter. Each week, two guests espousing opposing views were brought on to duke it out, and Stewart had denigrated the bloodshed. Although they were hoping, no doubt, for more sparks to fly, Stewart disarmed the hosts with words they did not expect: “Why do we have to fight?”

It was a good question. So good that shortly thereafter the show was canceled due to declining ratings, not altogether separate from repeated airings of Stewart’s appearance on YouTube. (However, CNN has recently revived the program with new hosts.)

So why do we have to fight?

Sociologist Deborah Tannen writes that we live in an “argument culture.” Her observation is that we no longer dialogue with each other, contending that there has been a system-wide relational breakdown in our culture. It is as if we approach everything with a warlike mentality, so we end up looking at the world—and people—in an adversarial frame of mind.

How do we explore an idea?

A debate.

How do we cover the news?

Find people who express the most extreme, polarizing views and present them as the two sides.

How do we settle a dispute?

Through litigation that pits one party against the other.

How do we begin an essay?

Oppose someone—for criticizing and attacking shows that you are really thinking.

The lack of civility in our world has become so pandemic that it is now widely chronicled as a cultural phenomenon. Consider a USA Today article titled, “Rudeness, Threats Make the Web a Cruel World,” or a New York Times article on the impolite side of Wikipedia. Peter Wood, in his book A Bee in the Mouth, speaks of this in terms of “anger in America.” Sadly, it is this anger that seems to mark the very people who should be most immune to such animus: Christians.

This was illustrated in what has been voted the best “religious” joke of all time. Comedian Emo Philips tells of walking across a bridge and seeing a man standing on the edge, ready to jump off. He ran over and said, “Stop! Don’t do it!”

“Why shouldn’t I?” the man said.

“Well, there’s so much to live for.”

“Like what?”

“Well, are you religious?”

The man said, “Yes.”

I said, “Me too! Are you Christian or Buddhist?”

“Christian.”

“Me too! Are you Catholic or Protestant?”

“Protestant.”

“Me too! Are you Episcopalian or Baptist?”

“Baptist.”

“Wow, me too! Are you Baptist Church of God or Baptist Church of the Lord?”

“Baptist Church of God!”

“Me too! Are you original Baptist Church of God or Reformed Baptist Church of God?”

“Reformed Baptist Church of God!”

“Me too! Are you Reformed Baptist Church of God, reformation of 1879, or Reformed Baptist Church of God, reformation of 1915?”

His new friend replied, “Reformed Baptist Church of God, reformation of 1915.”

To which Philips replied, “Die, heretic!” and he pushed him off.

I’ve Got Enough Problems in My Life

A recent editorial in Christianity Today discusses how no attribute of civilized life seems more under attack than civility. The author, David Aikman, notes the extent to which certain Christians have turned themselves into

the self-appointed attack dogs of Christendom. They seem determined to savage not only opponents of Christianity, but also fellow believers of whose doctrinal positions they disapprove. A troll through the Internet reveals websites so drenched in sarcasm and animosity that an agnostic, or a follower of another faith tradition interested in what it means to become a Christian, might be permanently disillusioned.

I once read of a large church that made the news due to a problem with a persistently caustic blogger. A former member, he had become disgruntled over various actions of the senior pastor, and he became further incensed that said pastor maintained the backing of the leadership. With nowhere to go with his frustration and no means to lobby for his cause, he started an anonymous blog to wage a one-person campaign of accusation and bitterness. It quickly disintegrated on both sides to such a degree that suits and countersuits began flying freely. What a godforsaken mess.

The article I was reading about this had links that led to other links, and before I knew it, I found myself exposed in a way I had never imagined possible to the sordid world of the bitter blog—blogs that seemingly exist for no other reason than to attack a particular Christian leader, church, ministry, or movement. More often than not, the divides were over nothing more than a disagreement about negligible points of theology, varying philosophies of ministry, or differing styles of leadership.

As mentioned in an earlier chapter, when I started Mecklenburg Community Church in the early 1990s, I commissioned a survey through the Barna Research Group to ask unchurched people who lived in the surrounding community a simple but direct question: “Why don’t you go to church?” The leading answers fell into categories you may expect:

“There is no value in attending.”

“I don’t have the time.”

“I’m simply not interested.”

“Churches ask for money too much.”

“Church services are usually boring.”

What surprised me most was the strength of one response in particular—so strong it was the second most common answer for being unchurched, representing six out of every ten people:

“Churches have too many problems.”

The assessment of the unchurched continues to follow suit: the typical Christian community is inflexible, hypocritical, judgmental, and just plain mean. Division and discord are perceived to be more present in church than in many other groups. Why would anyone want to become involved with something that, in his or her mind, is so obviously dysfunctional? As one man in the survey quipped, “I’ve got enough problems in my life. Why would I go to church and get more?”

Sadly, this is not new for American Christianity. I once read of a school president, who was also an evangelist, who made it clear that if any faculty or student attended a certain fellow evangelist’s crusade, they would be fired or expelled. If they wanted to pray for the evangelist, he suggested the following words:

Dear Lord, bless the man who leads Christian people into disobeying the word of God, who prepares the way for Antichrist by building the apostate church and turning his so-called converts over to infidels and unbelieving preachers. Bless the man who flatters the Pope and defers to the purple and scarlet-clothed Antichrist who heads the church that the word of God describes as the old whore of Babylon.

So much for Bob Jones Sr. of Bob Jones University and his relationship with the famed evangelist Billy Graham. I am sure Bob Jones Sr. was a good and godly man in many ways. Just not in this way. While sentiments of this kind have been brewing for some time, what’s new is the increasingly public nature of our vitriol, its widespread dissemination through the internet, and our growing comfort and even affirmation of its manifestation. As Francis Schaeffer observed toward the end of his life, it has almost become a matter of personal privilege: “We rush in, being very, very pleased, it would seem at times, to find other men’s mistakes. We build ourselves up by tearing other men down . . . we love the smell of blood, the smell of the arena, the smell of the bullfight.”

We may be pleased, but we are not being Christian—not to mention appealing, especially to the nones.

The Mark of a Christian

While we have already explained the importance of cause eclipsing community for arresting the attention of the nones, that does not relegate community to the backwaters of concern. While it may not be as important for attraction, it is paramount for affirmation.

In the Gospel of John we have the poignant final words and prayers of Jesus regarding his present and future disciples before he went to the cross. Between John 13 and John 17, Jesus poured out his heart. It is considered by many to be among the most moving sections of the New Testament.

What occupied Jesus the moments before his atoning for the sins of the world? Not surprisingly, he was concerned that the world would recognize his gift. And how would that happen? Christ’s torrent of prayer and pleading begins and ends with a passionate call for unity among those who did and would claim his name. The observable love between those who called themselves his followers was seen by Jesus to be everything. Why? Jesus said it would be this unity, and this unity alone, that would arrest the world’s attention in such a way as to confirm that he is from the Father.

We often marvel at the growth of the early church, the explosion of faith in Christ in such numbers and speed that in only a blink of history the Roman Empire had officially turned from paganism to Christianity. We look for formulas and programs, services and processes, strategies and techniques. The simpler truth is that first they shared the gospel like it was gossip over the backyard fence. But what did they subsequently observe in the communal life of the messenger who shared that gossip? As Tertullian notes, the awed pagan reaction to the Christian communal life was, “See how they love one another.”

As is often pointed out, when the Bible speaks about such loving unity, it doesn’t mean uniformity, which is everyone looking and thinking alike. The biblical idea of unity is also not to be confused with unanimity, which is complete agreement about every petty issue across the board—though within individual churches there should be unity of purpose and an agreement on the major issues related to doctrine and mission. By unity the Bible means first and foremost a oneness of heart—a relational unity. Being kind to one another, gracious to one another, forgiving of one another. It is not about assuming the worst, shooting the wounded, or being quick to be suspicious. Biblical unity is about working through conflicts, avoiding slander and gossip, and being generous in spirit. It is giving each other the benefit of the doubt, distributing ample doses of grace in the midst of our sin and imperfection, and demonstrating fierce loyalty.

Such unity matters—so much so that the Bible reserves some of its harshest words of discipline for those who sin against it. “Warn a divisive person once, and then warn them a second time. After that, have nothing to do with them,” writes the apostle Paul to Titus (Titus 3:10). And in one of the most overlooked passages of Scripture, Paul warns strongly against taking the Lord’s Supper—the sacrament portraying our vertical unity with Christ and then the horizontal unity with others that resulted from it—if you have unresolved relational conflict in your life. So strongly was God’s feeling on this that Scripture tells us that it could result—and indeed had resulted—in the death of those who so violated the sacrament.

This shouldn’t surprise us. As we take of the body of Christ, we are to be the body of Christ. Paul writes:

Is not the cup of thanksgiving for which we give thanks a participation in the blood of Christ? And is not the bread that we break a participation in the body of Christ? Because there is one loaf, we, who are many, are one body, for we all share the one loaf. (1 Cor. 10:16–17)

The symbolic act of sharing from one loaf symbolizes the unity of the body of Christ, the church, which has as its source of nourishment the bread of life. The very word companion is from two Latin words, com, which means “with,” and panis, which means “bread.” So the word companion literally means “with bread” or “breadfellow.” We are companions because we are together through the bread, which is the body of Christ. From this comes Paul’s charge:

In the following directives I have no praise for you, for your meetings do more harm than good. In the first place, I hear that when you come together as a church, there are divisions among you. . . . When you come together [in this way] it is not the Lord’s Supper you eat. (1 Cor. 11:17–20)

As Francis Schaeffer points out, such love is the mark of the Christian. Not just a feeling of love or an acknowledgment of love, but a demonstration of love. And it is not simply decisive to our faith, but also to our witness. As Schaeffer observes, drawing from the biblical witness:

Jesus is giving a right to the world. Upon his authority he gives the world the right to judge whether you and I are born-again Christians on the basis of our observable love toward all Christians.

That’s pretty frightening. Jesus turns to the world and says, “I’ve something to say to you. On the basis of my authority, I give you a right: you may judge whether or not an individual is a Christian on the basis of the love he shows to all Christians.”

It should be deeply convicting that the secular marketplace understands the importance of this more than many Christians do. It is understood that people expect great performance from products, services, and experiences. So what makes some brands inspiring while others languish? Saatchi and Saatchi, a leading marketing firm, coined the term Lovemarks to reveal the answer, calling it the “future beyond brands.”

When applied to business, the four quadrants in figure 11.1 are easily grasped and applied. Something in the lower left quadrant—the low love, low respect category—has little loyalty. It may be necessary, but it’s just a commodity. Think about the US airline industry. Something in the lower right quadrant—the high love, low respect area—is little more than a fad. Think Snooki and Jersey Shore.

Figure 11.1 Lovemarks

If you move into the upper left quadrant—the low love, high respect area—you have your typical brand. You may respect that brand, but if something better comes along, you won’t think twice about switching. Think Proctor and Gamble or General Electric.

But then you have the Holy Grail of branding. In the upper right area, you have both high love and high respect. Kevin Roberts, author of Lovemarks: The Future Beyond Brands, does not call this a product, a fad, or a brand; he calls it a Lovemark. Lovemarks deliver beyond expectations, sitting at the top of high levels of respect. They reach our hearts as well as our minds, creating an intimate, emotional connection that we don’t want to live without. Take a brand away and people will find a replacement. Take a Lovemark away and people will protest its absence. You don’t just buy Lovemarks, you embrace them passionately—you experience them. In the business world, think Apple when you think of Lovemarks. In American politics, think John F. Kennedy or Ronald Reagan.

Christianity is meant to be the ultimate Lovemark, and in light of our mission to the world, it must be. Schaeffer is right when he maintains that the world cares little for doctrine. One thing and one thing only, Schaeffer asserts, will confirm the truth of a message to a world that has disavowed the very idea of truth: “The love that true Christians show for each other and not just for their own party.” This is, Schaeffer concludes, the final apologetic. Unloving attitudes and words cause a “stench that the world can smell. . . . Our sharp tongues, the lack of love between us . . . these are what properly trouble the world.”

The dilemma is that it does not always seem to trouble us, and usually for two reasons: The first is that we simply do not see it as sin. It has become so commonplace, we no longer feel conviction. I recall talking to the president of a leading Christian seminary. He said that soon after his appointment, when he went to his first faculty meeting as president, he couldn’t believe the way the professors were talking to each other and the spirits that were being portrayed. The dialogue was negative, nasty, biting, vitriolic, and unloving. Afterward, sensing he was shocked at the interplay, someone said to him, “Don’t worry—that was normal—it’s just the way we talk around here.”

He couldn’t help himself. “Well,” he said, “it sure sounded like sin to me!” And he was right. It was sin.

The second reason it does not trouble us is this: It is not simply the acceptance of lovelessness that leads to its continued presence but our justification of it. Specifically, the warped theology that is often embraced says loving actions and attitudes are only warranted when you have nothing provoking you otherwise. It is as if disagreement, disapproval, and disenchantment sanction bad behavior. The bitter blog is justified because; the slanderous attack is warranted because; the angry accusation can be made because. A pastor friend of mine, drawn to it time and again, compared it to the lure of pornography.

And make no mistake. Like pornography, it doesn’t just sound like sin, or look like sin, or feel like sin. It is sin. And it is keeping the message of Christ from being confirmed in the hearts and the minds of those we are charged to reach.

Questions for Discussion and Reflection

  • We often find ourselves viewing the world and our culture with an adversarial frame of mind. Well-intentioned debates become caustic, blogs become bitter, and the cause we trumpet ends up being drowned out by our rhetoric. Think carefully about your approach to debate and discourse. Do you fall into the trap of the adversarial mindset? If so, how can you combat that tendency?
  • This adversarial frame of mind has crept into the very people who should be most immune to it—Christians. Have you seen this creeping effect in your own church, or perhaps another church around you?
  • A common perception of nones and other unchurched people is that the church is full of problems. Do you take that point of view seriously and take care to make sure you don’t prove their point?
  • Community is a powerful force for affirming the nones when they come through your doors. Not affirmation of their lifestyle, but of their standing as sinners and people in need of a Savior. Does your community welcome those outside the church? Would a none feel loved, accepted, and dignified by those in your community?
  • Just before his death on the cross, Jesus made a passionate plea for unity among believers because this alone has the power to arrest the attention of the world and confirm that Jesus was in fact God in human form. Is that plea for unity playing out in your church? Do you actively try to cultivate an environment of love and unity?
  • If your church does take this call to unity seriously, you should witness things like working through conflicts, avoiding gossip, and giving the benefit of the doubt. This is primarily what the Bible means by unity. It’s a relational unity that weaves between and inside a group of believers. Does that kind of unity emanate from your community?
  • Francis Schaeffer notes that Jesus gave a harrowing right to the world: “Upon his [Jesus’s] authority he gives the world the right to judge whether you and I are born-again Christians on the basis of our observable love toward all Christians.” If ten unchurched people show up at your church this weekend, what will their consensus be based on the love (or lack of love) they witness?
  • One of the most dangerous deceptions in the church today is that unloving attitudes are not sin. They have become so commonplace that instead of being recognized as the sin they are, they’re written off as “the way things are done.” Do you honestly see unloving attitudes as sin, or do you write them off as part of the process?
  • Another reason unloving attitudes seem to no longer trouble us is that the continued acceptance of that spirit leads to its continued justification. When an unloving spirit is tolerated, it’s considered to be justified. Not to say that is correct thinking, but that’s how it works nonetheless. Are you accepting of unloving attitudes in your staff, congregation, or teams? What can you do to address this immediately and move toward the unity Jesus pleaded with us to have?
  • ↑ Back to top

    ↑