Chapter 17 of 22

13. Reimagining the Church

13. Reimagining the Church

13

Reimagining the Church

I’ve saved the most important for last. If the church is going to reach out to a group of people who have given up on the church, not to mention membership and labels, then one thing is clear: we must renew our own commitment to the very thing they have rejected—the church.

This is the enterprise that Jesus himself declared would be “so expansive with energy that not even the gates of hell will be able to keep it out” (Matt. 16:18 Message). Jesus made this staggering claim because the church would be his ongoing incarnation on planet Earth. It would be his body, his presence, his life. It would be the means for his ongoing ministry to the world. This is not simply as the universal body of believers around the world, but as concrete communities of faith gathered together in the name of Christ as mission outposts to the world. And it’s needed.

Reflecting on a lifetime of study in the social sciences, Peter Berger suggests that the key to resisting the secular culture of our day is for communities of faith to self-consciously and determinedly stand against its onslaught. As critical as the process of secularization may be to understand, it pales in comparison with grasping the church’s mandate to engage in the process of “counter-secularization.” Famed missiologist Lesslie Newbigin would agree: “I have come to feel that the primary reality of which we have to take account in seeking for a Christian impact on public life is the Christian congregation. . . . [Jesus] did not write a book but formed a community.”

Steve Bruce gives the analogy of a garden in the midst of a wilderness, noting that “as the wilderness grows and the size of the cultivated area shrinks, the gardeners need to work harder.” We do not live and breathe in a neutral environment but in the midst of a hostile conflict, and we are behind enemy lines. The god of this world has been named, and he is firmly on his throne. There is only one domain beyond his control that stands in the way of total dominion. As a result, the body of Christ is under constant assault, for it stands alone against the night. It demands constant reinforcement and steadfast commitment. The church is not simply in the vanguard of kingdom advance, it is the entire assault force.

Ecclesiology 101

The word church, from the Greek word ecclesia, literally means “the called-out ones.” It is a word that was used in Jesus’s day for any group that was gathered together for a specific purpose or mission. Jesus seized the term to speak of a group with a specific purpose or mission, setting it apart from every other group or mission. This is where ecclesiology, the theological term for the doctrine of the church, finds its origin. The church of Christ, however, is anything but a man-made organization; instead it was founded and instituted by Jesus himself (Matt. 16:18).

The Bible has three primary understandings of this church, the body of Christ: (1) the local church, (2) the universal church as it exists around the world, and (3) the church as it exists throughout time and history, incorporating all of the saints that will one day be gathered together in heaven. Without question, the dominant biblical use is in reference to a local church or collection of local churches as defined bodies of believers that were gathered with both intent and order. Think of how the letters of Paul were written: “to the church of God in Corinth”; “to the churches in Galatia”; “to the church of the Thessalonians”; and at the beginning of John’s Revelation, “to the seven churches in the province of Asia.”

The local church was to serve as the ongoing manifestation of Christ himself on earth, being called his “body”—an idea of profound significance throughout the New Testament. As the apostle Paul writes:

Just as each of us has one body with many members, and these members do not all have the same function, so in Christ we, though many, form one body, and each member belongs to all the others. We have different gifts, according to the grace given to each of us. (Rom. 12:4–6)

Later in the New Testament, Paul reiterates this idea: “Now you are the body of Christ, and each one of you is a part of it” (1 Cor. 12:27). And if the point hadn’t been made clearly enough, Paul writes the following words to the church at Ephesus: “And God placed all things under his feet and appointed him to be head over everything for the church, which is his body, the fullness of him who fills everything in every way” (Eph. 1:22–23; see also 5:23; Col. 1:18, 2:19). Beyond the interconnectedness this suggests, it means that the church is the locus of Christ’s activity and he works through the church now as he worked through his physical body during his thirty-three-year life. In the New Testament there is no ministry outside of the church, or at least its umbrella.

But what is this local church that functions as the body of Christ?

One, Holy, Catholic, Apostolic

During the next few centuries, the church defined itself by four very important words: (1) one, (2) holy, (3) catholic, and (4) apostolic. Each word carries great significance. First, as we explored in an earlier chapter, the church was to be one, or unified. Jesus, in his great and grand final prayer recorded in John’s Gospel, prayed fervently for unity among those of us who would embrace his name in years and centuries to come. Second, it was to be a holy church, meaning set apart for God and separate from the world, for God himself is holy. The church was to reflect this holiness to the degree that it can be identified with God as holy. Third, the church was to be catholic, which simply means universal. The church was meant to be a worldwide church that includes all believers under its umbrella. So the word catholic was used of the church long before any kind of institution within Christianity used it for its own. Finally, the church was to be apostolic, which means committed to the teaching handed down by Jesus through the apostles.

Beyond being one, holy, catholic, and apostolic, local churches were entities that had definition and form, structure and purpose. They were not simply doing community in the broadest sense, much less simply pursuing ministry. In the Bible, the church was a defined, purposeful gathering of believers who knew they were coming together to be a church. There were defined entry and exit points to the church; clear theological guidelines navigating corporate and community waters; the responsibility of stewarding the sacraments; specifically named leadership positions; and, of course, a singular mission. One often hears that the church is where “the Gospel is rightly taught and the sacraments rightly administered.” This is taken from the Augsburg Confession (1530), the primary confessional statement of the Lutheran church courtesy of Martin Luther and Philipp Melanchthon. Calvin said much the same thing in his Institutes. But sensing the inadequacy of such a definition, in 1539 Luther wrote On the Councils and the Church, adding five more distinguishing characteristics, including church discipline, ordination, and worship through prayer and singing.

The Bible speaks of defined organizational roles such as pastors, elders, bishops, and deacons, as well as corporate roles related to spiritual gifts such as teachers, administrators, and of course, leaders (see Romans 12; 1 Corinthians 12; Ephesians 4; 1 Peter 4). These corporate dynamics allowed money to flow from one group to another (see 2 Corinthians 8); decisions to be made by leaders as to doctrine and practice (see Acts 15); and the setting apart of some individuals for appointed tasks, mission, and church plants (see Acts 13). Paul talks of those “inside” the church and those “outside the church,” and he speaks of the importance of expelling those who are wicked and unrepentant (1 Cor. 5:12–13), intimating membership or at least official associations.

There are often disparaging quips made about organized religion, but there was nothing disorganized about the biblical model. Those who intimate that the idea of the church in the New Testament is either so embryonic or so ethereal that there is a license to define the church in any way desired are simply misguided or misinformed.

Radical Revisionism

Tragically, Christ followers are notorious for being dismissive of the church, as if it is a disposable institution created by human beings as an option on the Christian front rather than the front itself—particularly among evangelical Christians. And no wonder.

Carl F. H. Henry, the founding editor of Christianity Today magazine, wrote a masterful six-volume systematic theology that set the stage for evangelical thinking for his generation. God, Revelation and Authority insightfully explores the nature of theology and theological method; revelation, inspiration, and the canon of Scripture; and the existence and attributes of God, including the Trinity. It pursues issues related to creation and providence; human nature; as well as original and actual sin. It moved on to investigate the person and work of Christ, predestination, conversion, justification, sanctification and the work of the Holy Spirit, perseverance, and in the end, eschatology. Every major doctrine save one: the church.

Six volumes, the summa of evangelical thought, and not a single section on ecclesiology. This is nothing against Carl Henry; I studied under him as a graduate student, and he was a gracious and generous man, and we became friends. But he didn’t seem to have a vision for the church. Few American evangelicals have. Not simply because our theologians have not led us, but because our enterprising spirit has numbed us to the primacy of the church—particularly through the explosion of the parachurch movement, aptly described as “religion gone entrepreneurial.” Missions and ministries, crusades and campaigns litter the American religious landscape—most without relation to the local church. Embraced as a way to enlarge the boundaries of God’s work beyond the traditional church, for many it has become a substitute entity, often competitive and occasionally antagonistic.

To celebrate this as a paradigm shift from being church-centered to kingdom-centered is terrible theology. The church is the divinely instituted and appointed vehicle of kingdom ministry. The very meaning of the word parachurch is “that which is to come alongside [para] the church.” It does not mean beyond the church, as some have suggested, just as the word paracletos for the Holy Spirit does not mean “beyond us” but “beside us” as Helper or Advocate. Misunderstanding the nature and role of the parachurch has led some to actually speak of the “potential partnership” of the church and parachurch, as if it could be a nice option. This devaluation of the church in terms of theology, attitude, commitment, and participation is a startling compromise of Christ’s vision and intent. So let it be said that the church is not optional for the Christ follower; there is no ministry found in the New Testament that is not firmly planted under its canopy.

But that is not what others are saying, much less believing.

Near the beginning of my rather short tenure as a seminary president, I sat in the boardroom of a prominent Christian business leader to try to pitch a vision for contributing to theological education, specifically student scholarships. Instead of listening to the opportunity or asking pertinent questions as to the value of such an investment, he was determined to boast of his company’s identity as a Christian enterprise. He told of the mission trips he had taken with his employees, the investments the company had made from its profits in select boutique parachurch ventures, and the Bible study offered on campus for employees. Throughout his self-congratulatory spiel he took more than his fair share of shots at local churches and pastors who were not as “alive” as he and his company were in their faith. Forgive me, but he was insufferably full of his own spiritual self-importance and virtue, as if he had drunk a bit too deeply from the fawning of countless pilgrims who had come to his corporate offices to laud his beneficence and ask for his generosity.

At the time, as a new seminary president facing an inherited budgetary shortfall of over one million dollars, I was willing to endure almost anything—or anyone—for aid. I smiled and nodded, affirming his many self-ascribed accolades. Then in the midst of one of his personal asides about the sorry state of the church as compared to the pristine missional nature of his business, he maintained that it was for this reason that he wasn’t involved in a local church. They were, he intimated, beneath his own theological vision. “And after all,” he added, “we’re the church too.”

Everything within me wanted to leap from my seat and shout, “Enough! No, you are not!” A company is not the body of Christ instituted as the hope of the world by Jesus himself, chronicled breathtakingly by Luke through the book of Acts, and shaped in thinking and practice by the apostle Paul through letter after letter as divinely preserved in the New Testament. A marketplace venture that offers itself on the New York Stock Exchange is not the entity that is so expansive with energy that not even the gates of hell can withstand its onslaught. An assembly of employees in cubicles working for end-of-year stock options and bonuses is not the gathering of saints bristling with the power of spiritual gifts as they mobilize to provide justice for the oppressed, service to the widow and the orphan, and compassion for the poor.

But it is not surprising that an evangelical, Bible-believing follower of Christ would think that it is. The research of D. Michael Lindsay on the leaders of evangelical Christianity found that among Christian presidents and CEO’s, senior business executives and Hollywood icons, celebrated artists and world-class athletes, more than half had low levels of commitment to their congregations. Some were members in name only; others had actively disengaged from church life.

With jaw-dropping vigor, ignorance, and at times unblushing gall, increasing sectors of the evangelical world are abandoning two thousand years of ecclesiology as if the church is some malleable human construct that can be shaped, altered, redefined, or even disposed of as desired. This, coupled with a radical revisionism in terms of biblical interpretation and ecclesial history that would seem more in line with The Da Vinci Code than Christian theology, the doctrine of the church is being reformulated apart from biblical moorings, or simply dismissed as if not a part of biblical orthodoxy at all. How can we blame the nones for doing any less?

Primacy for the Christian Life

The critical importance of the church goes well beyond strategic primacy. The church is decisive for the Christian to fulfill the Christian life. Consider what has been entrusted to the church for the sake of the Christian: the very confession of the gospel through proclamation; corporate worship; the stewarding of the sacraments; the dynamics of the new community in Christ; the use of and benefit from spiritual gifts; and spiritual care and protection through pastors. If you say this is meant to be afforded to us outside of the church, you haven’t read the New Testament.

Far beyond the church’s central role as the means by which this world is to be engaged and transformed, the church is the very body of Christ, one that every member of his body is meant to embrace. So penetrating was this understanding at the beginning of the Christian movement that it led the early church father Tertullian to maintain, “It is not possible to have God as Father without having the Church as mother.” Saint Cyprian echoed this sentiment with the dictum, “Nulla salus extra eclesiam” (“apart, or outside, the church, there is no salvation”). As Philip D. Kenneson writes, “To be a Christian is inseparable from what it means to be the church.”

Idea and Ideal

I know that many, if not most, Christians have become disillusioned with the church. As Katie Galli once noted about her fellow twentysomethings, “We’re disillusioned about almost everything—government, war, the economy. . . . We’re especially disillusioned with the church. Somewhere between the Crusades, the Inquisition, and fundamentalists bombing abortion clinics, we lost our appetite for institutionalized Christianity.” I understand.

But it is an institution, and needs to be. And while “the church can indeed be bureaucratic, inefficient, and, at times, hopelessly outdated,” Galli wisely adds, “it has also given us a 2,000-year legacy of saints and social reformers, and a rich liturgy and theology—the very gift twentysomethings need to grow into the full stature of Christ.” But this is far from a generational challenge. Baby boomer Philip Yancey writes of his estrangement from the church, noting how the hypocrisy of the members and the cultural irrelevance of its experience kept him away for years. Why did he return? “Christianity is not a purely intellectual, internal faith. It can only be lived in community.”

Ironically, the real dilemma facing the church is not the church itself but the staggering power of the biblical vision for the church. Christ’s dream for the church is so strong, so compelling, so vibrant that the pale manifestations on the corner of Elm and Vine can breed disdain. As Sarah Cunningham writes, “I have been and continue to be frustrated when Christian religious systems seem to fall short of the community God intended his followers to experience. However, my belief in the ideal of church—in God’s design for those who align themselves with him—is uncompromised.” But the telling statement comes later when she owns the rampant idealism that pervades her generation’s approach to all of life: “It’s no surprise, then, that twentysomethings tend to apply these same idealistic ideas to a search for the perfect church. When we don’t find perfection, we can start to get a bit antsy.”

Any ideal can act in one of two ways: (1) it can drive you toward its fulfillment, or (2) it can drive you away from its pursuit entirely in disappointment. Sadly, many are choosing to leave the vision in disappointment. They remain loyal to the idea of church but not its practice, citing the chasm between the vision and the reality as their rationale. But this is precisely what must not happen.

Theologian Jürgen Moltmann reminds us that the church does not have a mission; rather, the mission has us. And it is the mission of Christ that creates the church. God has sent himself, and he now sends us. This is the missio dei, the “sending of God.” Or as Christopher J. H. Wright contends, our mission “means our committed participation as God’s people, at God’s invitation and command, in God’s own mission within the history of God’s world for the redemption of God’s creation.” So to engage the mission of God is to engage his church; they are inextricably intertwined.

A Final Word

In his book Courageous Leadership, my friend Bill Hybels talks about having a defining moment on the place of church in his life. It was the mid-1980s. He’d been out of the country for several weeks on a speaking trip and was returning to the U.S. through San Juan, Puerto Rico. He’d been outside of CNN range for most of the trip, so at the airport he was eager to grab a cup of coffee and a copy of USA Today and catch up.

Then it began. Two young boys—who looked like brothers—started squabbling with each other. The older kid appeared to be seven or eight, the younger one around five. Bill watched them a few seconds over the top of his paper, kind of irritated at how they were disturbing him and everyone else. But he said to himself, Boys will be boys.

Then he heard it. Whack!

He put down his paper because it was obvious that the older boy had just slapped his younger brother—hard—right across the face. The smaller boy was crying, and you could already see a nasty welt rising on his cheek. Bill looked around for a parent or two—anybody responsible for these kids who could stop the mayhem.

Then the entire gate area was silenced by a sound that none of them would forget for a very long time. It was the sound of a closed fist smashing into a face. While the little boy was still crying from the first slap, the older boy wound up and belted him again, literally knocking the little guy off his feet.

That was more than Bill could take. He blurted out, “Where are these kids’ parents?”

No response.

As he raced over to the boys, the older boy grabbed the little guy by the hair and started pounding his face into the tile floor. Bam! Bam! Bam!

Bill then heard the final boarding call for his flight, but he was too sickened by the fight to abandon his mission. He grabbed the older boy by the arm and hauled him off the younger one, then he held them as far apart as he could. With one arm extending out to a kid with a bloody face and the other straining to stop a boy with murder in his eyes, he knew he was holding a human tragedy in his hands. Just then the ticket agent came up and said, “If you’re Mr. Hybels, you’ve got to board this plane immediately. It’s leaving now!” Reluctantly, he loosed his hold on the boys, gathered his things, and rushed down the gangplank, shouting out to the ticket agent, “Keep those kids apart! Please! And find their parents!”

He stumbled onto the plane and managed to find his seat, but he was badly shaken by what had happened. He couldn’t get the sights and sounds of the violence he had witnessed between those two young boys out of his head. He grabbed a magazine and tried to read, but he couldn’t concentrate. Then he looked in the entertainment magazine to see what movie was going to be shown, hoping it would be something that could distract his thinking. But then he sensed the Holy Spirit telling him not to purge his mind so quickly. He sensed a prompting:

Think about what you saw. Consider the implications. Let your heart be gripped by this reality.

So he did. He began to dwell on what he had seen, and his mind became flooded with thoughts about the older kid’s life. He wondered where his parents were. He wondered what kind of experience he was having in school. He wondered if there was anybody in his life offering him love, guidance, and hope. He wondered what the boy’s future held.

If he’s throwing fists at the age of eight, what will he be throwing at eighteen? Knives? Bullets?

Where will he end up? In a nice house with a good wife and a satisfying job? Or in a jail cell, or an early grave?

Then Bill felt prompted to consider what could change the trajectory of that boy’s life. He scrolled through the options. Maybe, he thought, if we elect some really great government officials who will pass new legislation, maybe that will help a kid like this. But will it?

No doubt, what governments do is very important. Writing legislation for the good of a society is a noble and worthy task. But politicians, no matter how sincere their motivation, can only do so much. They can rearrange the yard markers on the playing field of life, but they can’t change a human heart. They can’t heal a wounded soul. They can’t turn hatred into love. They can’t bring about repentance, forgiveness, reconciliation, or peace. They can’t get to the core problem of the kid Bill saw in the airport and the millions of others like him.

Bill began to scroll through every option he could think of. Businessmen can provide sorely needed jobs. Wise educators can teach useful knowledge of the world. Self-help programs can offer some occasional methods of behavior modification. Advanced psychological techniques can aid self-understanding. And all of that is good—but can any of it truly transform the human heart? No.

Then it came to him like never before: Only one power exists on this planet that can do that. It’s the power of the love of Jesus Christ, the love that conquers sin and wipes out shame and heals wounds and reconciles enemies and patches broken dreams, and ultimately changes the world, one life at a time. And the radical message of that transforming love has been given to the church. That is why the church is the most beautiful, the most radical, the most dangerous, the most glorious enterprise on the planet. There is nothing more worthy of throwing our lives into.

This is how Bill gathers his final thoughts:

There is nothing like the local church when it’s working right. Its beauty is indescribable. Its power is breathtaking. Its potential is unlimited. It comforts the grieving and heals the broken in the context of community. It builds bridges to seekers and offers truth to the confused. It provides resources for those in need and opens its arms to the forgotten, the downtrodden, the disillusioned. It breaks the chains of addictions, frees the oppressed, and offers belonging to the marginalized of this world. Whatever the capacity for human suffering, the church has a greater capacity for healing and wholeness.

This is what we have been called to give our lives to, and in order to change the world, we must give our lives to it. Until we have this vision coursing through our veins, we will never be able to cast it before a watching world of nones who dismiss it as irrelevant at best and harmful at worst.

Questions for Discussion and Reflection

  • The church is spurned in many ways these days, even among Christians. But it will take a renewed and reimagined approach to church for us to reach the nones. The church is inseparable from the mission and teaching of Jesus. As missiologist Lesslie Newbigin notes, Jesus “did not write a book but formed a community.” That community is the assault force for the kingdom of God in this world. Do you think of the church like this? Do you need to reinvigorate your vision of what church is doing here on earth?
  • The local church is the very body of Christ manifested to serve his cause. It is connected to Jesus in a way nothing else is, which means no other manifestation of Christ can be as effective and as powerful in the march against hell as the church. Is this the notion you wake up with each morning? Is it the feeling you get when Sunday morning comes?
  • The local church is to be one, holy, catholic, and apostolic. One is the sense of being unified, as we read about in an earlier chapter. Is your local church embodying that call to unity?
  • The church is to be holy, meaning set apart so that the world will see the very holiness of God represented in the church itself. Will the world see the holiness of God reflected in your church body?
  • The church is meant to be catholic, which simply means universal or worldwide in scope and including all believers. Is your church part of the larger church of believers? Does it alienate, isolate, or insulate itself from the rest of the believers?
  • The church is to be apostolic, or devoted to the teaching of Jesus handed down by the apostles. Is this commitment to the teachings handed down by Jesus evident in your own teachings or the ways that you’ve been taught?
  • Beyond being one, holy, catholic, and apostolic, the church has always had definition, structure, and purpose. The biblical model of the church was never disorganized. Do you have a structure that is built to allow ministry to thrive in your community?
  • Have you been viewing the church and its existence, form, and substance as something open to interpretation? Are there any examples in the New Testament of ministry being done outside the canopy of the church?
  • ↑ Back to top

    ↑