Chapter 20 of 22

Appendix B: The Spirituality Grid

Appendix B: The Spirituality Grid

Appendix B

The Spirituality Grid

The following is the transcription of a talk delivered at Mecklenburg Community Church in 2013 titled “The Spirituality Grid.” It was the final installment of a series titled “Ultimate Life Coaching.” The intent was to address the “spiritual, but not religious” mindset of our day. It used a large axis prop on stage—illustrated below—that was filled in as the talk went on. As the final talk of the series, it also ended with a challenge to fully surrender to Christ.

Introduction

For the last few weeks we’ve been on a life-coaching journey. We’ve called it “ultimate” because it’s been a look at the kind of coaching the Bible brings on our life, on ultimate issues.

It has not been just tips and techniques about better workouts or financial planning. It has been life principles about the importance of waiting on God’s activity, instead of just our own; doing what we are made to do in terms of gifts, passions, and personality type; and finding and following the will of God through Scripture, prayer, circumstances, and counsel.

Today as we bring the series to an end, we’re going to look at the most important life-coaching principle of all. It’s the most important because it’s about optimally integrating your life at its deepest level. So let’s jump in.

When it comes to the deepest part of who you are, there are two dynamics at play. One has to do with spirituality, and the other has to do with religion. Let me explain both ideas.

Spirituality has to do with what you’re open to, sensitive toward, in your inner world. If you ask someone, “Would you consider yourself spiritual?” most would say yes. Because they believe in God, they pray, and they consider that part of their inner world important—so they want it open to being alive and real.

Then there’s religion, which has to do with how you have aligned your spirituality. That means how you have brought your spirituality into alignment with a set of beliefs, a particular faith tradition, a set of Scriptures revealed by a God.

Now, I know both of these have their warped definitions. You can define spirituality as being all gooey-eyed and sentimental, with “Praise the Lord this” and “Praise the Lord that” coming out of someone’s mouth. And you reject it.

You can define religion as everything organized and corrupt, legalistic and lifeless and dead. And you reject it.

But make no mistake—where you stand with religion and spirituality, at their best and purest and most authentic and real, is the key to organizing your inner world. So let’s see how to best do that, and we’ll use a vertical and horizontal axis to explain it and then look at the four places we can find ourselves.

Not Spiritual, Not Religious

First, your life may be not spiritual and not religious. If you’re in this category, you most likely call yourself an atheist. You don’t believe in God or anything else that is transcendent or supernatural. You don’t pray because you don’t believe there’s anyone, or anything, to pray to.

Not many people fall into this category. According to recent studies, at best only 6 percent of the entire U.S. population call themselves an atheist. Some studies show it as low as 3 percent.

That means that most of us—as high as 97 percent of us—fall into one of the other three categories. And for good reason. Not religious and not spiritual does not have much of an inner world, much less a place of hope or promise. Even those who put themselves there know that in the end it leads to despair.

It was Friedrich Nietzsche who famously said, “God is dead.” But in that famous essay, his next words are the most haunting: “We have killed him. . . . How shall we comfort ourselves, the murderers of all murderers?”

Religious, Not Spiritual

The next category is when you are religious, but not spiritual. This is when you have all the form and function, rules and ritual, dogma and doctrine, but not much else. At its worst, this is just being a Pharisee, a hypocrite.

Jesus had little regard for those in this category. This is his assessment of their position:

What sorrow awaits you teachers of religious law and you Pharisees. Hypocrites! For you are so careful to clean the outside of the cup and the dish, but inside you are filthy—full of greed and self-indulgence! You blind Pharisee! First wash the inside of the cup and the dish, and then the outside will become clean, too.

What sorrow awaits you teachers of religious law and you Pharisees. Hypocrites! For you are like whitewashed tombs—beautiful on the outside but filled on the inside with dead people’s bones and all sorts of impurity. Outwardly you look like righteous people, but inwardly your hearts are filled with hypocrisy and lawlessness. (Matt. 23:25–28 NLT)

And most of us would cheer Jesus on with those words, wouldn’t we? We hate religious hypocrisy. People who say one thing and do another; people who pose and posture as being spiritual, when they aren’t. It’s one of the reasons we hate anything related to religion.

Yet many people are in this category and don’t know it. They may not be Pharisees or hypocrites, but they have churchianity, not Christianity. They have religion but not relationship. They go by law but seldom by grace. They are members; their name is on the roll. They attend. They subscribe. But it doesn’t mean anything. It makes them feel good about themselves, but they aren’t any different than anybody else.

It’s dead. Lifeless. Meaningless. Ritual and form. And that’s how it’s played out in their life. You ask them about Christianity or faith and they say, “I’m Catholic,” or “I’m Baptist.” But you didn’t ask them about religion—you asked about relationship.

Jesus talked about those kinds of people too: “These people honor me with their lips, but their hearts are far from me. Their worship is a farce” (Matt. 15:8–9 NLT).

And he also said,

Not everyone who calls out to me, “Lord! Lord!” will enter the Kingdom of Heaven. Only those who actually do the will of my Father in heaven will enter. On judgment day many will say to me, “Lord! Lord! We prophesied in your name and cast out demons in your name and performed many miracles in your name.” But I will reply, “I never knew you.” (Matt. 7:21–23 NLT)

Or as Eugene Peterson paraphrases those verses,

Knowing the correct password—saying “Master, Master,” for instance—isn’t going to get you anywhere with me. What is required is serious obedience—doing what my Father wills. I can see it now—at the Final Judgment thousands strutting up to me and saying, “Master, we preached the Message, we bashed the demons, our God-sponsored projects had everyone talking.” And do you know what I am going to say? “You missed the boat. All you did was use me to make yourselves important. You don’t impress me one bit.” (Matt. 7:21–23 Message)

Spiritual, Not Religious

Next is by far the most popular category: being spiritual but not religious. For a lot of people, this is to avoid hypocrisy, to avoid wearing the Christian label, to avoid seeming to be something you’re not—but still holding on to God.

In fact, this is the fastest-growing religious demographic in the nation. It’s been called the rise of the nones. That’s n-o-n-e-s, not n-u-n-s.

When asked about religion, they didn’t answer “Baptist” or “Catholic” or any other defined faith. They said, “I don’t want to say I’m any religion.”

Between 1990 and 2008, the number of nones nearly doubled in size, from 8 percent to over 15 percent. Then between 2008 and 2012—just four years—it went from 15 percent to 20 percent. That’s one out of every five people. And for people under thirty, it makes up one out of every three.

The nones now make up the nation’s fastest-growing religious category. If you’re spiritual, but not religious,

you’re not an atheist,

you still believe in God,

you still whisper a prayer every now and then,

you’re spiritual—or at least open to spirituality,

you just don’t want to be tied to anything specific.

When it comes to content, dogma, orthodoxy—anything spelled out or offering a system of beliefs or membership—that’s what you’ve rejected. When pressed as to what you hold to, you say, “Nothing in particular.” You don’t want the label.

I recently read an interview with Marcus Mumford, the twenty-six-year-old lead singer of the phenomenally successful British band Mumford & Sons. One of my favorite bands, actually. Mumford is the son of John and Eleanor Mumford, the national leaders of Vineyard Church in the U.K. and Ireland, part of the international, evangelical Christian Vineyard Movement. He recently married actress Carey Mulligan, whom he’d met years earlier at a Christian youth camp.

Marcus is the main lyricist for the band, and their music is filled with the themes and imagery of faith—often drawing specifically on the Christian tradition. They “explore relationships with God and others; fears and doubts; sin, redemption, and most of all, grace.”

In a Rolling Stone interview, however, the reporter asked him whether he “still consider[s] himself a Christian.”

This is his answer:

I don’t really like that word. It comes with so much baggage. So, no, I wouldn’t call myself a Christian. I think the word just conjures up all these religious images that I don’t really like. I have my personal views about the person of Jesus and who he was . . . [but] I’ve kind of separated myself from the culture of Christianity.

While describing his spiritual journey as a “work in progress,” Mumford said that he’s never doubted the existence of God. Is that how you feel? If so, you’re not alone; it’s how a lot of people feel.

Many of us have rejected what’s wrong with religion. I have. I tell people all the time that Christianity isn’t about religion; it’s about a relationship. And it’s true. It is. But when I say that, I’m talking about the warped definition of religion. Not the real definition of religion. Because Christianity isn’t just about being spiritual. It’s about realities. It has content, substance, and specificity. There isn’t just a vocabulary that goes with it, but a dictionary. It’s about truth.

It’s fine to pray, but who, or what, are you praying to? Are you praying to a rock, a tree, a spirit, an angel, a god? It matters. If you’re praying to the one and only true God, who is that God? And if you like Jesus, well then who he is matters. If Jesus claimed to be that God in human form, come to planet Earth to show the way, where do you stand with that Jesus?

You can’t just “like” Jesus on Facebook. You can’t just follow him on Twitter, picking and choosing what you “favorite” or want to retweet. Either he was who he said he was, or he wasn’t. I mean, listen to what he said about himself: “I am the way, the truth, and the life” (John 14:6 NLT). Not a way, or a truth, or a life, but the!

As C. S. Lewis once wrote, you can write Jesus off as a lunatic or as the greatest con man in all of history, or you can fall down at his feet in worship. But you can’t just say he was a decent guy who occasionally said some things you like. He’s either Lord, a lunatic, or a liar. Liars and lunatics aren’t to be followed. Lords are meant to be worshiped.

Spirituality is not simply a feeling or a set of practices or a disposition. It’s either rooted in reality or it’s not. It’s like climbing up a rope—it matters what the rope is tied to. And it needs to be tied to something.

I know, I know—the big idea that we keep hearing is that there are lots of roads to God. There isn’t just one truth. There isn’t just one religion.

The idea is that searching for God is like climbing a mountain. Since everyone knows that there is not just one way to climb a mountain—mountains are too big for that—there must be any number of paths that can be taken. So we tend to look at all of the ideas about God throughout all the religions of the world as just different ways up the mountain, because God is too big to be thought of or worshiped in just one way.

Therefore all of the names of God in all of the world’s religions all name the same God. Jesus had one word in response: No.

That doesn’t mean there can’t be some good in other religions. There is nothing in the teaching of Jesus that says that to believe in the truth of Christianity you have to believe that every other world religion is completely wrong all the way through. You don’t have to deny the existence of some truth or goodness in other perspectives.

Think of it in terms of arithmetic. There is one and only one right answer to “two plus two”—and that’s four. But if you answered “6,” it would be a lot closer than answering “37.” While there is only one right answer, some answers are closer to being right than others.

But that doesn’t mean that all religions are basically the same, or offer the same path to God, or are on equal footing, or will land me in a right relationship with the living God. Even the Dalai Lama has said that the central doctrines of Buddhism and Christianity are not compatible. He has said himself that you cannot be a Buddhist Christian or a Christian Buddhist.

He is right. Christianity believes in a personal God; Buddhism does not even believe in a Higher Being. Buddhism is, essentially, an atheistic religion.

That’s kind of a divide, don’t you think? That’s not the two different ways up the same mountain—those are different mountains. And that’s the way it works across the board.

Christians believe there is one God; Hindus believe there are millions.

Christians embrace Jesus as God himself in human form; Muslims don’t even rank him at the top of the prophets, much less the Savior of the world.

Now, whenever you have divisions like that, you only have two options: (1) you can say that somebody is right in that particular area and everybody else is wrong, or (2) you can say that everyone is wrong in that area. But what you can’t say is that everybody believes about the same thing. That would be intellectually dishonest. Unless God is a senile, confused, muddled, schizophrenic, unbalanced being who isn’t sure what he stands for, then there is religious truth and religious falsehood.

The areas of disagreement are not trivial in nature. They deal with the very nature of God, the identity of Jesus, and how we enter into a relationship with God. So while being spiritual but not religious sounds good, when you really understand what religion is about at its best and most authentic and most clear, you will see that it’s not good. It’s deceptive. It means you believe in little more than yourself—that there’s no truth outside of you. And it’s your own little spirituality and your own little belief system, and what you’ve done is made yourself your own little god.

Spiritual and Religious

That brings us to our final category: spiritual and religious. This is when you get everything aligned: The head and the heart. Belief in God and belief in his Word. You pray, but you also listen. You know, and you do. You believe, and you live.

Jesus talks about this perfect integration in one of his most famous word pictures:

So why do you keep calling me “Lord, Lord!” when you don’t do what I say? I will show you what it’s like when someone comes to me, listens to my teaching, and then follows it. It is like a person building a house who digs deep and lays the foundation on solid rock. When the floodwaters rise and break against that house, it stands firm because it is well built. But anyone who hears and doesn’t obey is like a person who builds a house without a foundation. When the floods sweep down against that house, it will collapse into a heap of ruins. (Luke 6:46–49 NLT)

See how this works?

Conclusion

Now, let me tell you about my grid. I’ve been in every one of these categories. I started out in the not spiritual, not religious category. In fact, I drifted in and out of this one a lot in my early years.

My family of origin was, to say the least, inconsistent with church involvement. In fact, I don’t recall going to church at all during my high school years.

So there wasn’t much in terms of religion, even in the worst sense of the word, much less the best. And I wasn’t walking with Jesus at all. I mean, I had some beliefs, but they didn’t matter. I did what I wanted to do. That, I can tell you, wasn’t very Jesusy.

But then I developed a sense of religion—but the Pharisee, hypocritical kind. Meaning I began filling my head with knowledge, but my heart was far from God. I was always drawn to rational, intellectual, scientific kind of stuff. Theology to me was a mental game. An exercise. A chess match. And I was good at it. And like a lot of people, I was well-read, smart. And I liked boxing matches with people who I thought weren’t quite up to par. I at least wanted to see if I could win.

I remember when I went to college, my freshman roommate was a Mormon. In terms of a theological debate, he was low-hanging fruit. So one night after more than a few beers, I started slicing and dicing the Book of Mormon and Mormonism: the lack of an archaeological record for their claims, the ridiculous theology, their special underwear, and so on.

It was slick. And to be honest, it was true. He was lost, scrambling, outmatched. But then he said one thing that ended the conversation. He said, “Jim, how can you say anything at all to me with the way you live?”

There was nothing I could say. He was right. Christianity may have been true and right, but I wasn’t. All I had done was go from no religion, no spirituality, to the worst of religion without spirituality.

Well, then my life went into a serious tailspin. The details aren’t important, but I hit rock bottom in every conceivable way to the point that even I could see it.

I recall one night in particular—my life came into focus. This wasn’t who I wanted to be. This wasn’t the path I wanted to be on. For the first time in my life, I saw my trajectory. And it wasn’t a good one.

I had been living in a bubble of believing that how I was living didn’t matter or was no big deal. That bubble burst. I saw myself for who I was: lost, broken, empty.

And then I got spiritual. I dropped the pretense of religion and started hungering for God. Thinking about God. Praying to God.

But even that didn’t take me very far because I still wasn’t connected to living for him. Obeying him. Submitting to him. I was spiritual, but not religious—and I mean religious in the best sense of the word. It didn’t translate into something with muscle, strength, content, specificity. It wasn’t tied to Jesus—what he said, what he did. No obedience, no leadership.

A few months later some friends invited me to a campus gathering sponsored by a Christian ministry to college students. They had asked me a dozen times before, and I always blew it off. Not now. They asked; I went.

The speaker gave a talk about a simple idea: Jesus as Savior and Lord. Forgiver and Leader. Real religion and authentic spirituality—combined. I’ll never forget what part of the teaching of Jesus he read from:

Large crowds were traveling with Jesus, and turning to them he said: “If anyone comes to me and does not hate his father and mother, wife and children, brothers and sisters—yes, even their own life—such a person cannot be my disciple. And whoever does not carry their cross and follow me cannot be my disciple.

Suppose one of you wants to build a tower. Won’t you first sit down and estimate the cost to see if you have enough money to complete it? For if you lay the foundation and are not able to finish it, everyone who sees it will ridicule you, saying, “This person began to build and wasn’t able to finish.”

Or suppose a king is about to go to war against another king. Won’t he first sit down and consider whether he is able with ten thousand men to oppose the one coming against him with twenty thousand? If he is not able, he will send a delegation while the other is still a long way off and will ask for terms of peace. In the same way, those of you who do not give up everything you have cannot be my disciples.

Salt is good, but if it loses its saltiness, how can it be made salty again? It is fit neither for the soil nor for the manure pile; it is thrown out.

Whoever has ears to hear, let them hear. (Luke 14:25–35)

On that day, my ears heard. On that night, I became a Christian—a real one.

I remember talking to the person who brought me, and I kept saying, over and over again, “But so much will have to change . . . so much will have to change.”

I really got the fullness of it, the completeness of it. This was going to have to be a complete surrender. This wasn’t a game. This was about my life—on this earth and in the life to come after my life on earth was over.

It was about commitment. Real commitment. It was about finally surrendering everything I had, everything I was, to Christ. It was about giving up being religious without being spiritual, and spiritual without being religious. It was about going all the way. It was about embracing all of what Jesus meant for my life. As the way, the truth, and the life.

Where are you? More importantly, where do you want to be? Do you know why you’re here today, listening to this? It’s because you are being called, today, by Jesus, to make a decision about your life.

I’m not calling you; he is. And it’s not about raising your hand. It’s not about walking down an aisle. It’s not about checking a box on a card. It’s not even about mouthing a prayer that you may have mouthed a dozen times before. It’s about surrendering your life—all of it.

There’s only one of these four boxes your life can be in that will give you the life you long for, the life you’re called to, the life that is life. Only one.

You don’t need me to tie this with a bow and end in some trite, contrived, manufactured way. You don’t need me to lead you in a prayer or get you to do anything. You’re an adult. If you need to pray, you know what you need to pray. If you need to decide, you know what you need to decide.

My role is simple: to challenge you to do it—like someone challenged me.

So leave whenever you’re ready and you want to. But don’t leave before you’ve decided who you want to be and how you want to live—and have told God.

↑ Back to top

↑