12. Opening the Front Door
12
Opening the Front Door
When Bill Clinton ran for the presidency in 1992, eventually scoring an upset victory over incumbent George H. W. Bush, his political strategist James Carville made it very clear what their overarching strategy would be. Hanging in every office was a singular sign for all to see: “It’s the economy, stupid!”
And that really was the issue of the election. It determined who won and who lost. Thanks to Carville, Clinton focused relentlessly on that issue.
Bush didn’t. Clinton won.
I once made a sign for our staff that you can still see hanging on cubicles and office walls around Meck. It too is simple. It reads: “It’s the weekend, stupid!” And in many ways, it is.
I almost didn’t include this chapter, but the more I thought about it, the more I was convinced it was worth the risk. The risk is that it will be dismissed as passé in terms of outreach strategy or relevance to reaching the nones.
During the 1980s and ’90s there was an approach to outreach that could be caricatured as “the big show,” as in large, highly produced, glitzy services that were presentational in nature. There was professional music, clever drama sketches, and Disneyesque light displays. A reaction of sorts set in during the 2000s that shifted toward a more stripped-down, communal, “authentic” approach that was often labeled “missional,” meaning moving from “come and see” to “let’s go and be.”
But this is where it matters that a practitioner is writing this instead of an academic. Those who discounted the presentational approach threw out the baby with the bathwater. Quick—name one church that stripped everything down, went totally with a “let’s go and be” approach (as opposed to having a service or event that allowed individuals to invite their friends) that experienced breakout growth among the nones.
Exactly.
Many got some serious press for being uber-hip, but not much happened in terms of numbers. The truth is that there is a need to be incarnational in the world as individual followers of Christ. There is also enormous power in pulling together our resources and gifts as a community of faith for intentional outreach where singers sing, communicators communicate, those gifted with children work with the young, and so on. In other words, it is strategic for the individual witness of believers to join forces with the collective work of the church to penetrate our culture for Christ. It’s true in terms of cause, meaning pulling together for large-scale efforts that arrest the attention of the world, but it’s also true in terms of the actual activity of evangelism.
Am I arguing for a return to the old “seeker service” strategy? Yes and no. No in regard to its 1980s form, but yes in terms of how it has manifest itself for over two thousand years. Don’t forget: it wasn’t invented in South Barrington, Illinois, in 1975. Jesus had an individual and a crowd-based approach to evangelism. So did the apostles. So did the early church. So did the Reformers. So did individuals such as Charles Wesley, D. L. Moody, and Billy Graham.
If the church has a “front door,” and it clearly does, why shouldn’t it be opened wide and then strategically developed for optimal impact for any and all nones who may venture inside? I already hear you: “But isn’t that your point? They aren’t going to venture inside? So why bother?” That is why I’m including this chapter. They will venture inside, just not on their own. There’s one thing that 82 percent of all unchurched people can’t seem to resist. It cuts through their defenses and penetrates their barriers. According to surveys at LifeWay Research, 82 percent of them seem to have a single weakness: if a friend, or someone they know, invites them to church. Reread that: 82 percent of all unchurched people would come to church this weekend if they were invited by a friend. And if you could get them there, imagine what you could achieve. They could be exposed to the collective energies, gifts, resources, and influence of your church at its best.
But how should your church be positioned, optimally, for the nones? How do you open the front door to someone you have invited who may actually come? We’ve talked about the message conveying grace and truth, but there is so much more, beginning with something as simple as friendliness.
Friendliness
In an interesting study, the Technical Assistance Research Program study for the White House Office of Consumer Affairs found that 96 percent of unhappy customers never complain about rude or unfriendly treatment, but 90 percent of those unhappy customers will not return to the place where that unfriendliness was manifest. Further, each one of those unhappy customers will tell nine other people about the lack of friendliness and courteousness, and 13 percent will tell more than twenty other people. A later study by the same organization discovered that the number one reason individuals do not return to a particular establishment is an indifferent, unfriendly employee’s attitude.
Now, we all know that every church thinks it’s friendly. I’ve never met a church yet where the people said, “Yeah, we’re mean and proud of it!” No! Every church thinks it’s friendly. But what that means is:
they are friendly to each other
they are friendly to people they know
they are friendly to people they like
they are friendly to people who are like them
That’s not friendliness; that’s a clique or, at best, a club.
To prove the point, another recent LifeWay Research survey found that while three out of every four churchgoers say they have significant relationships with people at their church, they admit they don’t make an effort with new people. In fact, only one in every six even try. That’s not very friendly.
This needs to be a cultivated part of your DNA. At Meck, we’ve worked very hard to be intentional about something that many may feel can only be left to chance. We’ve built an entire ministry around it called Guest Services, and it oversees greeters, ushers, hospitality, and much more—all geared toward the experience of first impressions and friendliness. It’s one of our largest and most strategic efforts.
But friendliness holds more than a smile and a welcome. It has to do with an atmosphere of acceptance. Two words are key here: atmosphere and acceptance.
First, atmosphere. Churches have cultures—a DNA if you will. The goal is to cultivate one that is accepting. If you are going to reach the nones, they are going to come to you as a none. That means they will come as couples living together, as gay couples, pregnant outside of marriage, addicted, skeptical. Is that going to raise an eyebrow? Or is it taken in stride in a way that makes the person feel instantly at ease? At Meck, it’s just another day of normal.
Then there is the acceptance itself. Acceptance is not affirmation, but it is an embrace. It involves starting where people actually are, warts and all, and then loving them, caring for them, and enveloping them into the community. This is more key than you may think. It is one thing to create a welcoming atmosphere; it is another to actually wrap your arms around someone who is sin-stained and sin-soaked in an effort to lead him or her to the cross. In other words, it’s ministry in the trenches. It means talking about marriage to those who are living together; it means helping teenagers involved in cutting or hooking up; it means working with a Christian wife who has a non-Christian husband who wants them to enter an “open” marriage; it means going as pastors to a house that seems to be demonically influenced because of the occupants’ past occult activity; and so much more.
All to say, an atmosphere of acceptance is also a culture of involvement and investment in the trenches of lives that have been lived and ordered apart from Christ. It’s time to get a church life of little more than potluck dinners out of your head.
Children’s Ministry
When our kids were young, my family and I went to a church while on our summer study break; it was a new church, very small, that was meeting in a movie theater. How can I say this? It was one of the most programming-challenged services I’ve ever attended. It was so bad that we were looking at our watches five minutes after the service started. When the service mercifully ended, we wanted to get out of there and never return. I know, that isn’t very gracious, and I should have been focused more on worshiping Jesus—but you would have wanted to leave too.
But when we went to pick up our kids, they were having an absolute blast. They didn’t want to leave! There was a couple who poured themselves into that ministry and made it really, really good. I still recall how they had transformed a meager space into a time machine with special-effects music that took the kids back into Bible times. New kids, such as ours, were treated extra special and taken to a treasure chest full of small toys from which they could choose, just for coming the first time.
We went to some of the best churches in the area that summer, but our kids pleaded with us to take them back to the one we could barely stand.
Now, if I lived there and felt compelled to find a church home as a father of four, do you think I would have at least given that church another try? You can count on it. Most parents would.
Here’s the lesson: You can drop the ball in the service, but ace it with the kids and you’ll still have a chance that they will return. But no matter how good the service is, if the children’s ministry is bad, they won’t come back—unless they don’t have kids.
Too many pastors treat children’s ministry as a necessary evil. It’s severely underfunded, understaffed, and underappreciated. Wake up. Children are the heart of your growth engine. If nones ever come to your church uninvited, it will probably be for the sake of their kids. And if nones come because they are invited, what you do with their children could be a deal breaker.
In other words, you live and die by the strength of your children’s ministry. I know; you’re thinking they shouldn’t make such consumer decisions. But you’re forgetting that they aren’t Christ followers; all they have is consumerism. And meeting their needs in this way isn’t compromising the gospel one bit. It’s being strategic. And, I might add, it is bringing the message of the gospel, in age-appropriate ways, to the lives of those kids.
Music
I loved Sister Act. I know, it’s really, really dated; but what a fun flick.
When the character played by Whoopi Goldberg, a “nun on the run” if there ever was one, puts contemporary music into the struggling parish’s services, the crowds pour in. The priest, confronting the Mother Superior’s concerns about such outlandish tunes, admonishes her by simply saying, “That music. That wonderful music. It calls to them.”
And music does. It always has.
Let’s not get into the worship wars stuff. But let’s do be savvy. There is no such thing as traditional music. All music was, at one time, newfangled, contemporary, cutting-edge, and probably too loud. The great hymns of Martin Luther are considered traditional and sacred to our ears, but they were anything but traditional and sacred to the people of Luther’s day. Many of the great hymns written during the Protestant Reformation, such as “A Mighty Fortress Is Our God,” were based on barroom tunes that were popular during that period. Luther simply changed the lyrics and then put the song into the life of the church. The result? People were able to meaningfully express themselves in worship—or at least connect with it stylistically.
Charles Wesley also borrowed from the secular music of his day, and John Calvin hired secular songwriters to put his theology to music, leading the Queen of England to call them “Geneva Jigs.” Bach provides a similar pattern, as he used a popular form of music known as the cantata for weekly worship music. He was also known to seize tunes from “rather questionable sources and rework them for the church.” Even Handel’s Messiah was condemned as “vulgar theater” by the churchmen of his day for having too much repetition and not enough content.
That last line is worth rereading. The point? Throughout history you’ll find a connection between church growth and contemporary music. Sorry if that’s too crass for you, but it’s true. Don’t ever downplay music—remember, there’s an entire book of the Bible that is almost nothing but lyrics you can work from. So here are two words that will serve you well: music matters.
Just as the deeper issue with friendliness is an atmosphere of acceptance, the deeper issue with music is cultural translation. Let’s retire such words as relevant and contemporary, shall we? The heart of it all is a missionary enterprise: learn the language of the people, the music, the dress, the customs—and then translate the gospel for them.
Chase this with me for a moment. If we were dropped into the deepest reaches of the Amazon basin as missionaries of the gospel to reach a specific unreached tribe of people, we would attempt to learn the language, dress in a way that is appropriate, craft a worship experience that uses indigenous instruments and styles, and work tirelessly to translate the Scriptures into their language. No one would argue with that approach. It’s Missiology 101. Now realize that your mission field is the West. Are you doing the work of a missionary?
Building
As the familiar phrase goes, “You don’t get a second chance at a first impression.” Your guests’ first impression begins long before the service ever does; it begins the moment they drive into the parking lot. It is at that moment—when they first view the church and its grounds—that the initial impression is made. Physical surroundings convey strong messages: if the lighting is inadequate, the message is unfriendly; if the equipment and facilities are out of date, the message is irrelevant; if the upkeep is poor, the message is you haven’t got it together, or even worse, this God you serve must not deserve better.
So let’s get real practical. What is the parking lot like? Are the stripes clearly painted, or are they faded with age? Is there trash strewn around? Are bushes and hedges trimmed? Is the grass neatly mowed? Is the church sign on the front lawn by the street in good shape, with letters neatly arranged with an appealing message or interesting information?
But physical surroundings includes far more than the external appearance of the facilities; they are the internal state of the facilities as well. Years ago when my wife and I moved from Louisville, Kentucky, to Nashville, Tennessee—having left the pastorate for a denominational position—our family experienced what was for us a rare and interesting phenomenon: church shopping. At the time, my wife and I had three young children. As you may guess, the room of greatest interest to us was the nursery.
We were stunned by what we found: sheets on cribs that hadn’t been changed in weeks; paint peeling off the walls; toys in ridiculous disrepair and condition; poor lighting and ventilation; insufficient supervision. One church nursery was so bad that we could not in good conscience leave our youngest child in order to participate in the worship service. The church we eventually joined, however, was vastly different. The sheets were changed after every use; toys were in excellent condition and disinfected between sessions; a teacher-child ratio was provided that was more than adequate; there was excellent lighting and ventilation; the carpet was immaculately cleaned and vacuumed; security procedures were followed. We left our kids and said, “Here they are—we’ll see you in six months!”
Just kidding. We picked them up in three.
The principle of cleanliness extends to all areas of the church, such as the restrooms, vestibule, classrooms, and of course, the front of the auditorium or sanctuary. I have been in numerous churches where the front part of the sanctuary, where the eyes of all in attendance are focused for an hour or more, was anything but impressive.
After a seminar I led on such issues, a pastor came to me and said he didn’t think that he had ever sat in one of the pews in his church and examined the appearance of the front of the sanctuary. He later wrote me and shared that when he did, he was horrified at what he saw: hymnbooks strewn haphazardly all over the top of the piano and organ, old Sunday school quarterlies beside the pulpit, corners of the carpet frayed and worn, chipped wood on the furniture, and several burned-out light bulbs. He wrote, “To think that our visitors were staring at that mess for over an hour!”
It has been said that familiarity breeds inattention, and this is certainly true in terms of the physical appearance and cleanliness of our churches. If you discover a crack in the mirror of your bathroom, your immediate reaction is a resolve to see to its speedy repair. After a few busy weeks, you notice it again, and make a mental note to see that it receives attention. After six months, you simply don’t see it anymore. But your guests do.
It brings to mind the time Ray Kroc, the founder of McDonald’s, paid a surprise visit to a Winnipeg franchise. It is reported that he found a dead fly in a condiment jar. The franchisee lost his McDonald’s franchise two weeks later. Another tale of Kroc’s commitment to cleanliness tells how on his way back to the office from lunch, Kroc asked his driver to pass through the parking lots of several McDonald’s. In one of those parking lots, Kroc spotted some papers caught up in the shrubs along the outer fence. Immediately Kroc went to the nearest pay phone and called the office, got the name of the local manager, and then called him to offer his help in picking up the trash in the parking lot. Later, both Ray Kroc and the young manager of the restaurant met in the parking lot and got down on their hands and knees to pick up the paper. If that commitment exists in the secular world for the sake of profit, how much more should the commitment of God’s people be for the sake of first impressions for the gospel?
Of course, as the other areas have deeper issues at play, so does a building—as in what kind of building is best. Some may wonder whether a traditional church-type building is important at all, if not detrimental. Would it be better to invite a none to something less intimidating, or more to the point, less churchy? If they have rejected the idea of church and labels and denominations, could that setting be best? Perhaps.
Many churches in the eighties began dropping denominational labels from their name, becoming community churches. Now the move is to drop the tag church altogether. So churches become “spiritual communities” or “gatherings.” This is now moving to how we think about buildings. Rather than meet in traditional church buildings, the preferred place to meet is a movie theater, community center, high school, warehouse, or coffeehouse.
But even if you keep to the idea of a church building, is it best to have the typical stained glass and pews? When we recently expanded one of our campuses, we installed seating that was more like you would find in a theater or performing arts center. Large atriums with a bookstore and coffee shop were put in place, and the children’s ministry was upgraded with special one-way windows for parents to see their children and decor with themes like you would find in a children’s store or children’s park.
Does all this matter? It depends on whether or not you are expecting company. We are.
The Importance of the Visual
The Lindisfarne Gospels, a 1,300-year-old manuscript, is revered to this day as the oldest surviving English version of the Gospels. Lindisfarne is a small island just off the Northumberland coast of England. It is often referred to as Holy Island. Tidal waters cut it off from the rest of the world for several hours every day, adding to its mystique as a spiritual pilgrimage.
Page from the Lindisfarne Gospels
Produced around AD 715 in honor of St. Cuthbert, largely by a man named Eadfrith, the Bishop of Lindisfarne, the Lindisfarne Gospels presents a copy of the four Gospels of the New Testament. But it isn’t revered simply for its age. Its pages reveal curvy, embellished letters, strange creatures, and spiraling symbols of exquisite precision and beauty. During the eighth century, pilgrims flocked to St. Cuthbert’s shrine where it was housed, making the Lindisfarne manuscript one of the most visited and seen books of its day. Its artwork and symbols helped convey its message to those who could not read.
Professor Richard Gameson from Durham University sees it as a precursor to modern multimedia because it was designed to be a visual, sensual, and artistic experience for its audience. Michelle Brown from the University of London notes that the book’s impact was similar to those of films and electronic media today. As Gameson adds, “The emphasis was to reach as many people as possible.”
This is the final, and increasingly crucial, element to an open front door: be visual.
I have written in other places that there are striking parallels between our day and that of the Middle Ages. But if we are entering a new era that is similar to the earlier medieval era, what does that mean? If we are following the medieval pattern—and I believe that in many ways we are—there will be at least five dynamics:
That is why the term neomedieval, first offered by Umberto Eco in regard to Western society, seems appropriate.
But it is the visual element that churches neglect to their peril. Over the last twenty years, we have decisively moved to a visually based world. The most formative influences are not books, theater, or even music. They are films.
Throw in videos and the rise of YouTube, and you have the essence of a cultural revolution—not to mention something of a return to the medieval. For example, during the Middle Ages there was widespread spiritual illiteracy, as well as actual illiteracy. People couldn’t read. This is why pilgrimages mattered so much to the pilgrims. Beyond the relics and holy places they thought might bestow grace, usually the cathedrals they visited held relics that told the story of faith through a medium they could understand: stained glass, pictures.
So while people couldn’t, or didn’t, read, they couldn’t help but see, and from seeing, understand. It’s no different today. We are spiritually illiterate and are visually oriented and visually informed. Only now, instead of stained glass, we have film. At Meck, there is very little we don’t try to convey visually, whether it’s a song during worship or a point during a message. It’s simply how people best receive information and meaning, content and context. And because it is part of the arts, it has a way of sneaking past the defenses of the heart. And nones need a lot snuck past them.
Questions for Discussion and Reflection
