4. A Post-Christian World
4
A Post-Christian World
When America’s second president, John Adams, and America’s third president, Thomas Jefferson, both died on the same day in 1826—and that day being none other than the Fourth of July—it was seen as a sign of God’s favor on the United States. As historian David McCullough notes in his widely acclaimed biography of Adams, it “could not be seen as a mere coincidence: it was a ‘visible and palpable’ manifestation of ‘Divine favor,’ wrote John Quincy in his diary that night, expressing,” McCullough adds, “what was felt and would be said again and again everywhere the news spread.”
As mentioned in the previous chapter, the idea of being “chosen” and receiving a “special blessing” from God has been a constant theme throughout the history of the United States, beginning with the Puritans and their “city on a shining hill.” Yet however you view America’s spiritual history, one thing is certain: today, America is not a Christian nation. This does not mean it is non-Christian or anti-Christian, simply that it has joined the ranks of many other Western countries and is post-Christian. To be post-Christian means that the very memory of the gospel is becoming nonexistent.
Recent research by the Barna Group has tried to define and quantify Americans’ various stages of nonbelief. In other words, Who is post-Christian? Digging deeper than what people may label themselves (e.g., nones), they wanted to also account for belief and behavior. This is critical since more than seven out of ten Americans describe themselves as “Christian,” and more than six out of every ten say they are “deeply spiritual.”
As a result, the Barna Group employed the following fifteen measurements:
To be deemed “post-Christian,” the person had to meet 60 percent or more of the fifteen factors. To be deemed “highly post-Christian,” the person had to meet at least 80 percent (twelve or more) of the factors. Examining these fifteen measures of nonreligiosity, they found that 37 percent of Americans are generally post-Christian, and one in four (25 percent) are highly post-Christian.
Cause or Effect?
Does this play into the rise of the nones? Is the ever-deepening post-Christian reality of America causing the rise, or is the rise itself the cause of the growing post-Christian milieu? Or neither?
The Pew Forum study suggested that one of the forces behind the rise of the religiously unaffiliated is generational replacement. This simply refers to the gradual supplanting of older generations by newer ones. While true, it is not a causal connection. It simply explains why the numbers are on the rise. For example, only one in twenty members of the World War II–era Greatest Generation—or 5 percent—could be classified among the nones. Compare that to younger Millennials (those ages eighteen through twenty-three), who were minors during earlier studies and thus not able to be interviewed. Of this younger demographic which is now being folded into national averages, a full one-third (34 percent) are religiously unaffiliated.
So what is causing later generations to enter the ranks of the nones in such large numbers? Yes, generational replacement is affecting the numbers, but why the generational disconnect with religion?
A further reason to look to wider cultural dynamics is that Gen Xers and baby boomers also have become more religiously unaffiliated in recent years. In 2012, the Pew Forum found that 21 percent of Gen Xers and 15 percent of baby boomers (a 3 percent increase among each generation from 2007) placed themselves among the nones. Further, the overwhelming majority of all of the nones were brought up in a religious tradition.
No, what is at hand is something more. Sociologist Peter Berger, among many others, has long suggested that the modern world is being shaped by three deep and fast-moving cultural currents: secularization, privatization, and pluralization. Big words. Even bigger ideas. But it’s within these words and ideas that we find the wider cultural key to the rise of the nones.
The Process of Secularization
The English word secular is derived from the Latin saeculum, which means “this present age.” The contemporary term secular is descriptive, referring to that which is divorced from religious or spiritual sensibility. Looking back to the ancient Latin usage, it instead enthrones that which is of this world. Secularization is the process by which something becomes secular. It is the cultural current making things secular.
And it is raging through our world like a flash flood.
Berger defines secularization as the process by which “sectors of society and culture are removed from the domination of religious institutions and symbols.” The effect of this process is that the church is losing its influence as a shaper of life and thought in the wider social order, and Christianity is losing its place as the dominant worldview. Richard John Neuhaus writes that we live in a “naked public square,” meaning that religious ideas and mores no longer inform public discourse. Christianity has ceased to be the motivating center of Western life; the religious question is consciously or unconsciously pushed from the heart of human concerns, and the institutional forms of Christianity have, and are, undergoing revision at the hands of the world.
In his Guide for the Perplexed, author E. F. Schumacher relates his experience of getting lost during a sightseeing trip to Moscow during the Stalinist era. Trying to get his bearings, he found himself standing with several large churches within his line of sight. Yet none of these churches were found on his map. An interpreter came to assist him and explained, “We don’t show churches on our maps.”
Schumacher contradicted the interpreter by quickly pointing out a church that was clearly marked on his map.
“That is a museum,” the interpreter said, “not what we call a ‘living church.’ It is only the ‘living churches’ we don’t show.”
That, Schumacher goes on to conclude, was the cultural point. Those things that mankind has most believed in are no longer on the map of reality, or if they are, they are relegated to a museum. In reflecting on Schumacher’s story, Huston Smith notes that our world “has erased transcendence from our reality map.” Or as C. S. Lewis observes, “Almost all our modern philosophies have been devised to convince us that the good of man is to be found on this earth.”
Yet a full-blown secularization thesis has been challenged. Not the reality of the process itself; Christian Smith notes that no matter where one stands on its impact, “Something real at the level of macrosocial change . . . has actually happened in history.” What is debated is the degree to which the process of secularization can redirect a person away from a belief in God. This argument is clearly in question in the United States, for while the process of secularization is clear, it has yet to produce an overwhelmingly secularized population. German philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche may have proclaimed God dead, but it could be contended that few in America attended the wake. Our day is, as Peter Berger himself observes, “as furiously religious as it ever was, and in some places more so than ever.”
But that is where Berger is wrong. We may not be losing our belief in God, but we are losing our religion. While we may not be turning into atheists, we seem quite content to accept the idea of faith being privately engaging but culturally irrelevant. And yes, this is because of the process of secularization.
Consider the secularized subculture currently resting at the top of the American educational system, the media of mass communication, and the upper echelons of the legal system. These are the epicenters of culture and the means by which values and ideas come into being and are disseminated. While their forces may be “relatively thin on the ground,” Berger observes, “they are very influential, as they control the institutions that provide the ‘official’ definitions of reality.”
Think about how faith itself is tended. It needs support. Apart from a Christian community, we quickly wither. We need a context of encouragement. Beliefs don’t exist in a vacuum; they need to be nurtured, reinforced. A secularized world no longer offers the deep religious socialization and the frequent reaffirmation of beliefs necessary for a distinctive faith to flourish. The declining social significance of religion will inevitably cause a decline in the number of religious people and the extent to which those people are religious. When society no longer supports religious affirmation, the difficulty of maintaining individual faith increases dramatically. “To be sustained and kept intact, [a religion] must be cultivated and guarded. When it is very widely shared and thoroughly embedded in everyday life and in powerful social institutions, there is little danger it will disappear,” sociologist Steve Bruce observes. “The problem arises when the surrounding society is becoming secular.”
As a result, we should not be surprised at the rise of the nones—or when their ranks continue to swell.
The Process of Privatization
Ray Kroc, the man who turned McDonald’s into a fast-food franchise, has said, “I believe in God, family, and McDonald’s. And in the office, that order is reversed.”
Not many in our world would find fault with his approach. Privatization is the process by which a chasm is created between the public and the private spheres of life, and spiritual things are increasingly placed within the private arena. So when it comes to things like business, politics, or even marriage and the home, personal faith is bracketed off. The process of privatization, left unchecked, makes the Christian faith a matter of personal preference, trivialized to the realm of taste or opinion. This trend was evident to historian Theodore Roszak who, after traveling to America, remarked that Christian faith in America was one that was “socially irrelevant, even if privately engaging.”
The influence of privatization is profound. Faith does not simply have a new home in our private lives; it is no longer accepted outside of that sphere. More than showing poor form, talk of faith has been banished from the wider public agenda. As historian and educator Page Smith sarcastically observed, in our day “God is not a proper topic for conversation, but ‘lesbian politics’ is.” But privatization goes further. Once placed solely within our private world, faith becomes little more than a reflection of ourselves. Spirituality has become anything an individual desires it to be—a private affair to be developed as one sees fit.
It is precisely this context that has compelled so many to move into the nones. Religion is, if anything, a public sphere manifestation of faith, and yet we don’t want faith in the public sphere. Further, if we subscribe to a defined set of beliefs or historic links to orthodoxy, our private world faith is held accountable—which is exactly what is least desired. So privatization is at war with what the establishment of religion requires, which is why the rise of the nones has benefitted so much from this current’s coursing.
The Process of Pluralization
I’m a fan of the old Andy Griffith TV series. Near my home in Charlotte is Mt. Airy, North Carolina—the real hometown of Andy Griffith and the inspiration for Mayberry. The small hamlet annually holds a Mayberry Days festival that attracts thousands. One year my family and I went, and we could readily see how the little town had shaped the series. The quaint downtown, the diner—there was even a Floyd’s Barber Shop.
If you’ve ever watched the series, still in heavy syndication, you know that when Andy’s deputy, Barney Fife, asked his longtime girlfriend, Thelma Lou, out for a date, more often than not it was, “Want to go to the picture?” This meant the movie at the movie theater. Which movie would they see? The movie. There was only one. It changed from time to time, causing an excited stir among the residents and an occasion for another outing, but there would only be one film showing.
Barney and Thelma Lou would have a time of it now. We go to a Cineplex and choose from twenty or more films—each one assaulting our senses through marketing and promotion. Then there’s Netflix, which offers thousands more, streaming via the internet. The simple “Want to go to the picture?” isn’t so simple anymore. It’s not even the right question. This is the heart of pluralization. The process of pluralization occurs when individuals are confronted with a staggering number of ideologies and faith options competing for their attention. Pluralization is that process by which the number of options for our private sphere to consider multiplies explosively—particularly at the level of worldviews and faith. Peter Berger speaks of the traditional role of religion as a “sacred canopy” covering the contemporary culture. Religion, at least in terms of the idea of there being a God whom life and thought had to consider, blanketed all of society and culture. Today that canopy is gone, replaced instead by millions of small tents under which we can choose to dwell.
There can be little doubt that the fuel that powered this process, at least in the United States, was immigration. One visit to Ellis Island will drive this home, as inside the main visitors center is a visual display of the tidal wave of immigration that struck upon the shores of our country. Between 1901 and 1910, nearly nine million immigrants were admitted to the United States, the majority from Southern and Eastern Europe. Nearly six million more came during the following decade. By 1910, 40 percent of the population of New York City was foreign-born. And they brought their religions with them.
But the process of pluralization means far more than a simple increase in the number of faith options. The sheer number of choices and competing ideologies suggests that no one perspective or religious persuasion has the inside track about the spiritual realm. Theologian Langdon Gilkey is correct when he observes that “many religions have always existed”; what is different is a “new consciousness” that “entails a feeling of rough parity, as well as diversity, among religion.” By parity, Gilkey means “the presence of both truth and grace in other ways.” Harold O. J. Brown adds that such pluralism is actually “value pluralism,” meaning that “all convictions about values are of equal validity, which says in effect that no convictions about values have any validity.”
Ellis Island
This has fostered a smorgasbord mentality in regard to the construction of personal beliefs. Malise Ruthven calls America the “divine supermarket.” The technical term is syncretism, the mix-and-match mentality of pulling together different threads in various religions in order to create a personal religion that suits our individual taste. Christianity becomes one of many competing boutique worldviews, no better or worse than another, that have set up shop in society’s mall for people to sample as a matter of personal preference.
So while Christianity used to be rejected by Enlightenment intellectuals because they thought its central beliefs had been disproven by science or philosophy, today orthodox Christianity tends to be disqualified on the grounds that it argues for a truth that is unchanging and universal. A particular faith used to be wrong on the basis of what one perceived to be truth; now a faith is wrong for claiming there is truth. As Allan Bloom wryly notes, “The true believer is the real danger.” Again, this is fueling the rise of those who hesitate to say they believe in any specific religion.
Is this all that has happened? No. While culture has become more secularized, privatized, and pluralized, so has religion itself.
In what I consider an overlooked book, Without God, Without Creed: The Origins of Unbelief in America, James Turner argues that unbelief is not something that has happened to religion. Instead, he argues, religion has helped cause unbelief. “In trying to adapt their religious beliefs to socioeconomic change, to new moral challenges, to novel problems of knowledge, to the tightening standards of science, the defenders of God slowly strangled Him.” Specifically, many who believed decided “to deal with modernity by embracing it—to defuse modern threats to the traditional bases of belief by bringing God into line with modernity.” In so doing, they forgot that
God’s purposes were not supposed to be man’s. . . . They forgot, in short, that their God was . . . radically other than man. . . . Unbelief emerged because church leaders too often forgot the transcendence essential to any worthwhile God. They committed religion functionally to making the world better in human terms and intellectually to modes of knowing God fitted only for understanding this world.
Mark Silk, director of the Greenberg Center for the Study of Religion in Public Life at Trinity College, seems to be in agreement with Turner’s thesis, noting that there is a “considerable softening of the edges in doctrine, politics and social values” contributing to the rise of the nones. So little wonder that a study by the Rasmussen Reports polling, released on Good Friday of 2013, found that only 64 percent of Americans believe that Jesus Christ rose from the dead, down from 77 percent only a year before.
This has created the spiritual without being religious mentality that sounds very good on the surface but translates into a pseudospirituality that is without content and is filled with little more than our personal meaning. Paul M. Zulehner, dean of Vienna University’s divinity school and one of the world’s most distinguished sociologists of religion, maintains that a “false spirituality” is rising that will prove to be “a more dangerous rival to the Christian faith than atheism.”
Questions for Discussion and Reflection
