10. A Christian Mind
10
A Christian Mind
One of the most overlooked areas related to engaging the culture for Christ, and specifically for engaging the rising numbers of the religiously unaffiliated, is the importance of a Christian mind. This is ironic since it certainly wasn’t overlooked by Jesus. When he was confronted by a teacher of the law in Mark 12:28–32, he summarized the great commandment from Deuteronomy 6:4–5: we are to love God with all of our heart, all of our soul, and all of our strength.
But he added, “And with all your mind” (Mark 12:30). It is as if he wanted there to be no doubt that when contemplating the comprehensive nature of a life commitment to God, we should not forget our intellect. But don’t reduce that to intellectualism—it’s deeper than that.
This is about having a mind developed enough in Christ and for Christ that it is able to contend for Christ in the culture. The biblical vision of the role of the mind is at the heart of the renewal of character and culture. In his manifesto to the Romans, Paul makes this declaration: “Do not conform to the pattern of this world, but be transformed by the renewing of your mind” (Rom. 12:2). The verbs are in the present imperative, which speaks to the challenge to continually go on refusing to conform to the patterns of the world and to continually go on letting ourselves be renewed by the transforming of our mind. The Phillips paraphrase puts it this way: “Don’t let the world around you squeeze you into its own mould” (Rom. 12:2 Phillips). Even better is Eugene Peterson’s paraphrase, which reads, “Don’t become so well-adjusted to your culture that you fit into it without even thinking” (Rom. 12:2 Message).
Yet Harry Blamires goes so far as to say that “there is no longer a Christian mind . . . a Christian ethic, a Christian practice, a Christian spirituality.” As Mark Noll dryly notes, the scandal of the evangelical mind is that there is not much of an evangelical mind. Worse, there is even a bias against the intellect. Richard Hofstadter, in his Pulitzer-prize-winning book, Anti-Intellectualism in American Life, identifies “the evangelical spirit” as one of the prime sources of American anti-intellectualism. Hofstadter points out that for many Christians, humble ignorance is a far more noble human quality than a cultivated mind.
Having a Christian mind is thinking in light of God’s existence and his self-revelation. Or as Flannery O’Connor referred to herself, it is being a “Christian realist,” which reflects her conviction that she lived in the presence of certain theological truths, such as the doctrines of creation, the fall, and redemption. These were not simply matters of subjective belief for her; they were part of the nature of reality, as solid as the laws of physics.
This is at the heart of the challenge. Most of us tend to succumb to a kind of compartmentalization over and against an integrated worldview that addresses the entirety of life. A compartmentalized mind is one that separates the investments of life into distinct categories, such as job, family, HBO, a Bible study, a favorite blog, and a Google search—all without integration. Our thinking about one area never informs our thinking about another. So we can be Christians but not reflect about science or technology in light of our faith. Or even worse, never even have the thought of reflecting about science or technology in light of our faith come to mind. So issues related to something like bioethics are seldom met with a reasoned reflection on the Scriptures in light of the nature of humanity or the doctrine of creation. It’s the same with the worlds of film, literature, economics, politics; many never integrate these areas with thoughtful reflection in light of a Christian worldview.
And worldview is a key word. The term itself suggests more than a set of ideas by which you judge other ideas. For example, think of the question, “Where did we come from and who are we?” Only a limited number of answers are at our disposal: we came about by chance (the naturalist contention); we don’t really exist (the Hindu response); or we were spoken into existence by God. For the Christian, the answer to that question gives us a foundation for our thinking that no other answer gives. Because we were created, there is value in each person. There is meaning and purpose to every life. There is someone above and outside our existence who stands over it as authority.
Because of this answer, Martin Luther King Jr. could write these words from a Birmingham jail:
There are two types of law: just and unjust. . . . A just law is a man-made code that squares with the moral law or the law of God. An unjust law is a code that is out of harmony with the moral law. . . . Any law that uplifts human personality is just. Any law that degrades human personality is unjust. All segregation statutes are unjust because segregation distorts the soul and damages the personality.
King’s argument was based on the worth of a human being bestowed by God regardless of what other humans may have to say. King laid claim to a law above man’s law. No other worldview would have given him the basis for such a claim.
A Battle of Ideas
Make no mistake about the nature of our contest. As John Stott writes, “We may talk of ‘conquering’ the world for Christ. But what sort of ‘conquest’ do we mean? Not a victory by force of arms. . . . This is a battle of ideas.” This was the concern of Paul when he reminded the Corinthians, “We do not wage war as the world does. . . . We demolish arguments and every pretension that sets itself up against the knowledge of God, and we take captive every thought to make it obedient to Christ” (2 Cor. 10:3, 5). This is the double-edged threat of our day: apart from a Christian mind, either we will be taken captive by the myriad of worldviews contending for our attention or we will fail to make the Christian voice heard above the din. Either way, we begin to think or we lose the fight.
It brings to mind Thomas Cahill’s provocatively titled book How the Irish Saved Civilization. “Ireland,” contends Cahill, “had one moment of unblemished glory. . . . As the Roman Empire fell, as all through Europe matted, unwashed barbarians descended on the Roman cities, looting artifacts and burning books, the Irish, who were just learning to read and write, took up the great labor of copying all of Western literature.”
Then missionary-minded Irish monks brought what had been preserved on their isolated island back to the continent, refounding European civilization. And that, Cahill concludes, is how the Irish saved civilization. But there is more at hand in Cahill’s study than meets the eye. Beyond the loss of Latin literature and the development of the great national European literatures that an illiterate Europe would not have established, Cahill notes that something else would have perished in the West: “the habits of the mind that encourage thought.”
Why does this matter? Cahill continues his assessment, writing that “when Islam began its medieval expansion, it would have encountered scant resistance to its plans—just scattered tribes of animists, ready for a new identity.” Without a robust mind to engage the onslaught—and a Christian one at that—the West would have been under the crescent instead of the cross. And while Islam still poses this threat in various places around the world, it is the advance of secularism that looms largest. If we do not form a Christian mind to engage the world, we will have little to offer, and nothing on which to stand. All that to say, never before have the “habits of the mind” mattered more.
The first step in the development of a mind for God is regaining the lost art of thinking itself. Specifically, thinking in relation to how the Christian faith intersects with life and thought.
I read recently that the United States Army has instituted a complete overhaul of its basic training regimen—the first such revision in three decades. Largely as a result of what they learned from Iraq and Afghanistan combat veterans, the army is dropping five-mile runs and bayonet drills in favor of zigzag sprints and exercises that hone core muscles.
Why? Because soldiers need to be prepared for what really happens in war. And in today’s world, the nature of conflict has changed, and it demands a new kind of fitness. Modern combatants must be able to dodge across alleys, walk patrol with heavy packs and body armor, and haul a buddy out of a burning vehicle. Soldiers need to become stronger, more powerful, and more speed driven. They have to know how to roll out of a tumbled Humvee. They have to know how to crawl for their weapons. “They have to understand hand-to-hand combat, to use something other than their weapon, a piece of wood, a knife, anything they can pick up.”
It brings to mind how seldom we rethink our own battle strategies, particularly in evangelism—and perhaps most of all in the field of apologetics. If used at all, more often than not we cling to Enlightenment-era approaches that attempt to answer Enlightenment-era questions. This is all well and good, and the challenges of the Enlightenment are not as absent from our cultural landscape as many may think. After all, anyone who has even the most rudimentary knowledge of intellectual history knows such questions didn’t originate with the Enlightenment. And even more to the point, anyone who actually dialogues with those who are exploring Christianity knows that they remain alive and well, particularly in the early stages of investigation. Just remind yourself of the popularity of the writings of Christopher Hitchens, Bart Ehrman, and Richard Dawkins, the novels of Dan Brown, and the media assaults of Bill Maher.
But I am far from alone in noting that the questions nones are asking of Christianity, if they bother to ask at all, have changed significantly in recent years. For example, I do not encounter very many people who ask questions that classical apologetics trained us to answer, such as questions related to the existence of God. Instead, the new questions have to do with significance and meaning.
One common question is, “So what?” As in, “So what if Jesus rose from the dead?” You thought you were done once you demonstrated that there was an empty grave and that no other explanation—save a resurrection—could account for the absence of a body. You thought the goal was winning a logical, empirically driven argument.
Think again. People need common intellectual barriers removed, but it quickly progresses to the heart of the matter: meaning. They have seen few, if any, lives that have truly had their deepest needs intersected by Christ. They do not know the difference a life in relationship with Christ really makes.
There are also a great many questions about the character of God. “What kind of God is the God of the Bible?” It is not uncommon to find direct challenges such as, “Is this God of yours really that good? Is he really that moral?” I recently read of an outreach pastor who has come to similar conclusions: “The questions [people are asking] have changed quite significantly in the past thirty years. It used to be, ‘Is there a God?’ and now it’s ‘What I know about God I don’t like.’ Their biggest complaint is that God acts in morally inferior ways compared to us.”
Granted, pointed questions are not new. This is not the first generation to claim that God is a bully, sounds vengeful and angry and over-anxious to consign people to hell, or seems a bit too worked up over sexual ethics. This is far from the first era of human history during which people have wondered aloud why God becoming a human and dying for our sins was necessary, much less why he allows human suffering to go on. What is new is the kind of questions being asked and the importance of answering these questions with an openness and transparency that acknowledge the worth of the question. Like never before, we are being called to defend and explain God’s character, clear up misunderstandings of who the God of the Bible actually is, and explain the Christian faith in ways that people in a post-Christian world now need it explained. If we don’t, we will lose people. And some of those people will grow up and influence a lot of other people to get lost along with them.
Consider Dan Brown, author of The Da Vinci Code. In an interview to promote a new book, he was asked, “Are you religious?” Here is his answer:
I was raised Episcopalian, and I was very religious as a kid. Then, in eighth or ninth grade, I studied astronomy, cosmology, and the origins of the universe. I remember saying to a minister, “I don’t get it. I read a book that said there was an explosion known as the Big Bang, but here it says God created heaven and earth and the animals in seven days. Which is right?” Unfortunately, the response I got was, “Nice boys don’t ask that question.” A light went off, and I said, “The Bible doesn’t make sense. Science makes much more sense to me.” And I just gravitated away from religion.
This was a question that should have been immediately affirmed as worthwhile and then quickly sorted out in relation to the biblical materials. It simply wasn’t that difficult to sort out. God could have certainly used the Big Bang to create the universe. The Bible tells us that God did it, not how. But it wasn’t answered. So a young boy went looking for a better God. One who would be open to questions, and hopefully, would offer some answers. What’s tragic is that he actually had that God. But nobody told him.
Mere Christians
One intriguing idea is that the entire rise of the nones will prove to be the seedbed for renewal. Krista Tippett, the Yale Divinity School grad who hosts On Being on public radio, is one such proponent. When asked about the nones in an interview, she answered, “On the ‘nones,’ I actually take a little bit of a radical view: That some of them may be a crucible of renewing and reforming religion in the coming period.” After noting the small number that are actually atheists, she added:
I think a lot these days about Dietrich Bonhoeffer in Germany in the mid-twentieth century. . . . He had seen the [church] cease to be the carrier of its own heart and soul and its virtues and its theology. . . . He started thinking about this notion of a religionless Christianity. His idea was that Christianity brings truths into the world that will survive and be resurrected even as the institutions and the structures and the words fail.
I don’t know this for sure, but I do believe there is something in that [nones] movement that, fifty or one hundred years from now, we may look back and say that was a crucible in renewal.
I actually find this an intriguing idea, but one that is contingent on authentic Christian faith actually being preserved during the rejection by the institutional alliance. It would be akin to the “mere Christianity” argued for by C. S. Lewis. The dilemma is that a robust orthodoxy, rising above and beyond institutional religion, is not being preserved as part of the spirituality of the nones. It’s not even preserved within those who profess to hold to the Christian faith. Consider the U.K., where the rise of the nones has a few years’ head start on our own escalation. A 2012 survey by the Theos think tank found that only 31 percent of all professing Christians in the U.K. believe Jesus rose from the dead; 41 percent believe in life after death. One out of every four prefer the very un-Christian idea of reincarnation.
The passion of C. S. Lewis was thoughtfully translating the Christian faith into language that everyone can understand. He was driven to have people know what Christianity is about. It was through a series of radio addresses given over the BBC during World War II that the evidence of his intellectual labors—along with his conversational style, wit, intellect, and rough charm—first revealed Christianity to millions. The initial invitation was for four fifteen-minute talks. The response was so overwhelming that they gave him a fifth segment to answer listeners’ questions.
Then a second round of talks was requested and given. The clarity of thought, along with his ability to gather together a wide range of information and make it plain, led one listener to remark that they “were magnificent, unforgettable. Nobody, before or since, has made such an ‘impact’ in straight talks of this kind.” The BBC asked for a third round of talks, this time stretching out for eight consecutive weeks. Lewis consented, but made it clear it would be his last. His goal throughout his writings was simple. It was “to expound ‘mere’ Christianity, which is what it is and was what it was long before I was born.”
His talks were eventually gathered together in a single work titled Mere Christianity, and the book continues to make Christianity known to millions. You may have heard of this book. Its appeal rests on two levels. The first is as a first-rate work of apologetics, meaning a case for the Christian faith. But on a second level, it is because of the dynamic inherent within the title. The twentieth century’s most accomplished apologist for the Christian faith had little desire to stake out narrow theological ground. He wanted to map out a vast territory on which individuals could gather. Rather than being less intellectual, in many ways it was more. It was scholarship, not academics, and scholarship is always more winsome and compelling.
If you are like me, you probably desire “mere Christianity.” It is a phrase first coined by the seventeenth-century Anglican writer Richard Baxter. Baxter lived through the English Civil War and, as a Puritan, threw his support behind Oliver Cromwell and the Parliamentary forces. It was Cromwell who summoned Baxter from his church in Kidderminster, Worcestershire, to help establish the fundamentals of religion for the new government. Baxter complied, but Cromwell complained that Baxter’s summary of Christianity could be affirmed by a Papist. “So much the better,” replied Baxter.
As Alan Jacobs writes in his exceptional biography of Lewis, Baxter’s challenge was his refusal to allow Christianity to succumb to the spirit of fashion and sect. He was convinced that there was a core of orthodox Christianity that Puritans, Anglicans, and Catholics all affirmed and that should have been a source of peace among them.
“Must you know what Sect or Party I am of?” he wrote in 1680. “I am against all Sects and dividing Parties: but if any will call Mere Christian by the name of a Party, . . . I am of that Party which is so against Parties. . . . I am a CHRISTIAN, a MERE CHRISTIAN, of no other religion.” . . . If the danger in Baxter’s time had been warfare among various kinds of Christians, the danger in Lewis’s time was the evaporation of Christianity altogether. Yet Lewis felt that the remedy for the first crisis was also the remedy for the second: if Christianity is embattled and declining, it is all the more important for Christians to put their differences aside and join to sing the One Hymn of the One Church.
Mere Christianity is not a reduction of orthodoxy—truth on the lowest level, as it were—but the distillation of Christianity so that it is fermented to its fullest potency. It is the essence of Christianity, stripped of all matters unrelated to its pulsating energy.
Statue of Richard Baxter at St. Mary’s Kidderminster, Worcestershire, England
In a day marked by the rising of the nones—those who claim no religious affiliation and, in fact, detest any and all labels—it is perhaps time to renew ourselves to what Baxter and Lewis championed. Because a mere Christian may be the only kind that can get through to a none world.
Questions for Discussion and Reflection
