8. The Importance of Cause
8
The Importance of Cause
The rise of the nones calls for not only a renewed commitment to conversion growth and a rethinking of evangelism as both process and event, but also a new understanding of strategic effectiveness. Simply put, there has been a seismic shift in outreach that few church leaders are understanding, much less pursuing.
From the 1950s to the 1980s, the vanguard of evangelistic outreach was direct proclamation of the gospel. Whether the crusades of Billy Graham or the creative approach of Willow Creek Community Church, presentation led the way. This resulted in the unchurched joining a community and eventually being discipled into participation with the cause of Christ.
From the 1990s thru the 2000s, community took the strategic lead. People wanted to belong before they believed. Skepticism was rampant, and trust had to be earned. Once enfolded into that community, Christ was often met in its midst. Cause, again, was the last to be manifest.
From the 2010s forward, cause—think campaigns to rescue girls from sex trafficking or food drives to end hunger—became the leading edge of our connection with a lost world, and specifically the nones, in terms of both arresting their attention and enlisting their participation in community and relationship. Consider the recent Passion Conference in Georgia. What captured outside media attention was not the sixty thousand students in attendance, much less the messages related to the Christian faith; what attracted the media was their commitment to eradicate modern-day slavery—in a word: cause. Then and only then did community come into play. After exploring that community, Christ could be—and was—introduced.
As the Pew Forum’s study reveals, the nones believe religious organizations are too concerned with money and power, rules and politics. And many believe that religious institutions do very little to help protect morality. Only 28 percent say that belonging to a community of people with shared values and beliefs is important to them. Yet they do believe that churches and other religious institutions benefit society by strengthening community and aiding the poor. Three-quarters say religious organizations bring people together and help strengthen community bonds (78 percent), and a similar number say religious organizations play an important role in helping the poor and needy (77 percent). In other words, we may have lost the opportunity to talk to them and do life with them, but we haven’t lost the opportunity to do good to them, before them, and with them—good that will then open their ears and hearts to the message of the gospel.
Think of this shift in terms of moving people through stages of introduction:
1950s–1980s
Unchurched → Christ → Community → Cause
1990s–2000s
Unchurched → Community → Christ → Cause
2010s–
Nones → Cause → Community → Christ
I know some of you will be uncomfortable seeing how far the message of Christ is down the strategic line. It’s not that the church should bury the lede in terms of intentionally putting Christ at the end of the line, and it’s certainly not implying some kind of bait and switch. Remember, we’re talking strategy. Leading with Billy Graham’s simple, “The Bible says,” was effective for people in a different place spiritually than most are today.
Reflect on the ground we’ve already covered. The more post-Christian a person is, the more evangelism must embrace not only event/proclamation, but also process and event/proclamation. Earlier models were almost entirely event/proclamation-oriented, such as revivals, crusades, or door-to-door visitation. This is only effective in an Acts 2, God-fearing Jews of Jerusalem context. Process models are needed in Acts 17, Mars Hill, nones/skeptical contexts.
The presentation of Christ must remain central to our thinking, to be sure. It would be tragic to buy a pair of shoes from Tom’s Shoes as an act of social concern but not witness to Tom. That is the only reason we are even talking about strategy; the goal is to present Christ and him crucified. But is that where we start? On Mars Hill, the spiritual illiteracy was so deep that Paul had to begin with cultural touchstones, lead into creation, and work his way forward. It took him a while to get to Christ.
And community? It matters, but the average person has tastes of that already. Maybe not a particularly functional community, but people don’t seem as drawn to it as they once were. Perhaps it is because of the lure and illusion of social media, or because they’ve simply given up on it, or because they have grown suspect of its authenticity in any place or form. Community does not seem to have the great attraction it once did. Instead, there has been a great seismic shift. Today it is cause that arrests the attention of the world.
That brings us to the challenges: first, to recognize the seismic shift and begin to strategize accordingly; second, to realize how difficult this will be. If cause is in the lead and community close behind, the church is at a deficit. In the minds of many, our causes have been mundane (let’s raise money for a fellowship hall) or alienating (Moral Majority). And as mentioned in the chapter “Lawyers, Guns, and Money,” being on the wrong side of cause can be as detrimental—if not more so—as not having a cause at all.
For example, a United Methodist minister who runs a Christian coffee shop in Dallas was interviewed on the rise of the nones by National Public Radio. He offered the following lament on the immigration issue:
If the church was known more for our efforts to welcome the stranger than keep them out, I think the church would have greater credibility with rising generations. For example, on immigration policies, we’ve taken the wrong stance on that, and they know. The thing is they’re smart enough. A lot of them have grown up in the church and then rejected it. They’ve read the Scriptures that talk about the importance of welcoming the stranger; they’ve read the Scriptures about the importance of caring for the poor; and when they see that no longer on the lips of those who are in religious authority, they see that the God we present is bankrupt, and that we’re theologically thin in our ability to even speak our own story.
There is great irony in the challenge. Jesus wed mission and message together seamlessly, proclaiming the kingdom that had come while healing the leper and feeding the hungry. He mandated concern for the widow and orphan, the homeless and naked, the imprisoned and hungry while speaking of the bread of life and a home in heaven. In other words, we should have been nailing this all along.
But what is it we are after with cause? If we are attempting to be counter-cultural agents of change through the creation of the common good, what is the common good? Mark Galli, editor at Christianity Today magazine, has written that our goal is not cultural transformation as much as it is personal obedience and service. As has often been noted, neither Jesus nor Paul seemed particularly concerned about addressing the immediate and most obvious (to the people of that day) cultural challenges of the Roman Empire. Jesus did not seem as interested in altering that kingdom as much as he was in ushering in an altogether new one; and when questioned, he as much as told Pilate exactly that. We know we are to be witnesses; we are to make disciples; we are to do justice, love mercy, feed the hungry, and care for the widow and orphan. This is obviously far from pursuing a privatized faith. We know we are called to be present in culture as salt. That, of course, can and often should lead to transformation—but more to the point, it can lead to renewal. But what does renewal mean?
Andy Crouch, in his book Culture Making, refers to it as the title suggests: the practice of making culture, drawing on the biblical ideas of creation and cultivation. Too often, he writes, we have settled for condemning, critiquing, copying, or consuming culture. All have their place, but they pale in comparison to the deeper ideas of creation and cultivation. Sociologist James Davison Hunter argues similarly, maintaining that cultural transformation only occurs through cultural renewal, such as “compelling artistic and intellectual works produced by a movement of cultural visionaries and the networks they build.” Once such visionaries gain a foothold in society, their words galvanize a culture. Our tools for such an effort have never changed: prayer, evangelism, example, argument, action, and suffering.
But again, the dilemma is that we too often do not know what making culture is supposed to make. We know to act, but where? We are willing to suffer, but for which cause? We are to embody faith, hope, and love, but to what end? As T. S. Eliot notes, “It is not enough simply to see the evil and injustice and suffering of this world, and precipitate oneself into action. What we must know, what only theology can tell us, is why these things are wrong. Otherwise, we may right some wrongs at the cost of creating new ones.” So what is the cultural target on the wall? Yes, God’s kingdom, but what does the reign of that kingdom entail?
What actually constitutes kingdom culture? Truth, goodness, and beauty have been called the three fundamental values because the worth of anything can be exhaustively judged by reference to these three standards. Everything that is is related to whether it is true or false, good or evil, beautiful or ugly. Truth, goodness, and beauty constitute what it is that we are trying to achieve through our efforts to renew this culture as followers of Christ. But that simply begs the question: What are the true, the good, and the beautiful?
Here are some pictures that may help.
The True
During a recent trip to Washington, DC, I met with a group of highly influential Christians involved in public policy, including lobbyists, lawyers in the Justice Department, and presidential appointees. To a person, they voiced two things: (1) a clear sense of calling to their role, and (2) a strong frustration that other followers of Christ were often critical about how they were pursuing that calling. Some Christians outside Washington insisted that the only appropriate way to be a Christian in Washington was to share Christ on every elevator, make speeches littered with Scripture on the congressional floor, and insist on biblical language in every policy. Instead, these Christians I met with expressed a desire for fellow believers to understand how their calling is rooted in the dynamics of common grace, finding its most effective expression in the appeal to natural law.
Common grace is grace that is extended to all human beings through God’s general providence (see Matt. 5:45; Heb. 1:2–3; John 1:1–4). For example, consider the nurture of rain and sun and the resulting bounty of a harvest. This should not be confused with prevenient grace, meaning the specific grace that runs before (the meaning of the Latin preveniens) and enables a decision for Christ, affording individuals the ability to respond to God’s call for salvation. Instead, common grace, writes theologian Stanley Grenz, “speaks of God’s extension of favor to all people through providential care, regardless of whether or not they acknowledge and love God.”
And what has this to do with Christians in Washington and the creation of what is true? The Anglican scholar Philip Edgcumbe Hughes writes that “common grace is evident in the divine government or control of human society. It is true that human society is in a state of sinful fallenness. Were it not for the restraining hand of God, indeed, our world would long since have degenerated into a self-destructive chaos of iniquity, in which social order and community life would have been an impossibility.” For those who attempt to honor Christ within the nation’s capital, it is the active participation in and working for the extension of common grace that fills their waking hours. We should be glad for such commitment. As Charles Colson writes, “Understanding Christianity as a worldview is important not only for fulfilling the great commission but also for fulfilling the cultural commission—the call to create a culture under the lordship of Christ. God cares not only about redeeming souls but also about restoring his creation. He calls us to be agents not only of his saving grace but also of his common grace. Our job is not only to build up the church but also to build a society to the glory of God.”
And on what basis do they pursue this common grace? Most often through an appeal to natural law, such as the law of gravity, the principles of which can be found in nature itself. For those Christians engaged in public policy, natural law provides the basis on which an appeal to conscience about the good (and the evil) can be made. It is how a Christian in a secular setting can make an appeal to what is right among those who do not share a conviction that biblical revelation is a source of truth yet still will allow that Christian to lead them to that truth source. The appeal to natural law provided the foundation for the moral philosophy of Thomas Aquinas and, with important modifications, was employed by Luther and Calvin. More recently, the arguments of C. S. Lewis in Mere Christianity made ample use of this idea.
So rather than finding a model in Peter speaking to the God-fearing Jews in Jerusalem (Acts 2), those in Washington find a clearer model for their vocation in such Old Testament lives as Joseph, Daniel, and Esther. Such figures served public policy in very secular settings, working within the system in obedience to God, and through that obedience, they affected the system for God. This is renewing culture toward the true.
The Good
For over fifty years, Michael Haynes served as pastor of the historic Twelfth Baptist Church in the Roxbury district of downtown Boston. Twelfth Baptist Church is a direct descendant of the First African Baptist Meeting House on Beacon Hill, founded in 1805. In 1840, a band of dissenters from the church felt led of the Holy Spirit to become involved in the Underground Railroad, an organized means of smuggling slaves from bondage in the South to freedom in the North. They became known as the Twelfth Baptist Church of Boston.
When I first met Michael, I asked him what he did. He said he was a pastor of a church. “Just a little church in Roxbury. That’s my ministry. Just three or four city blocks.” One of the first persons on those blocks that he had a chance to serve was a young man named Martin. Michael gave this young man his first ministry opportunity in a local church. A young man named Martin—as in Martin Luther King Jr.
Michael kept serving those few city blocks, always with a vision for changing them. And they needed change; it was a world of drug dealers, pimps, and gangs, poverty, homelessness, and racism. He knew from the beginning that any real change would rest on leadership. Not just his leadership, but a generation of leaders. Leaders like Martin. But even more to the point, though he never made such a claim, leaders like himself who would take up residence on their own few blocks in areas around the country and around the world where nobody naturally wanted to reside. Blocks that needed truth to set up residence so that it could spread into lives and situations, changing things from the inside out.
So Michael began talking about training leaders, praying about training leaders, casting vision about training leaders, until finally he witnessed its reality. First with a few classes at Twelfth Baptist, then as an extension center of a seminary, and finally as a full-fledged urban campus.
Today you can travel to Roxbury, Massachusetts, and visit the Center for Urban Ministerial Education (CUME) campus. Today, CUME has become one of the leading urban training centers in the United States, teaching each week in six languages, developing hundreds of leaders for urban ministry. Fittingly, it meets in the Michael E. Haynes Academic Building, one block down from Twelfth Baptist, one of Michael’s “just three or four city blocks.”
Three or four blocks of the good.
Beauty relates to enjoyment and aesthetics, and of the great values, including truth and goodness, it is perhaps the most overlooked. And in a truly decaying culture, it is often the first to lose its moorings. All the more reason to be alarmed by a recent social experiment staged by essayist Gene Weingarten and the Washington Post. At 7:51 a.m. on a Friday in the middle of the morning rush hour at the L’Enfant Plaza station of the Washington, DC, Metro, a nondescript, youngish white man in jeans, long-sleeved T-shirt, and Washington Nationals baseball cap removed a violin from a small case. Placing the open case at his feet, he threw in a few dollars to seed the giving and began to play.
But this was no ordinary performer. The fiddler standing against the wall was thirty-nine-year-old Joshua Bell, one of the finest classical musicians in the world, playing some of the most elegant music ever written on a $3.5 million Stradivarius. During the next forty-three minutes, as the violinist performed six classical pieces, 1,097 people passed by.
Did they have time for beauty? Did they even recognize it? No, they did not. Bell was almost entirely ignored. From over a thousand people, only six or seven even took notice.
This goes even deeper than our loss of beauty because of our busy lives. One of the great breaks from the flow of the history of Western thought is our modern tendency to reduce the idea of beauty to a matter of subjective preference as opposed to an objective value. Or even further, a glimpse of the divine. Consider David’s great desire to “gaze on the beauty of the LORD” (Ps. 27:4), or the declaration, “From Zion, perfect in beauty, God shines forth” (Ps. 50:2). This was not a subjective assessment—God is beauty, and true beauty, wherever it resides, is a glimpse of God himself. And we need more glimpses.
The Power of Cause
I’ve seen the power of cause in the hands of our church. People intuitively know the effectiveness of speaking first about our work helping to rescue young girls from the sex-trafficking brothels in the Philippines, and from that to faith in Christ. They lead with telling about our work with local food banks or funding the immediate needs of the working poor, single-parent moms, and the elderly in our city by providing money for bus fare, rent, or heat. It is easy to speak of serving orphans who are among the poorest of the poor in Argentina, building homes for the homeless in Jamaica, or visiting the lonely in a nearby nursing home.
Even if it takes a while to get to talking about Christ, they get there. And they do it with integrity and, most of all, credibility. I’ve watched the listener soak in Jesus raw and unfiltered along with the scandal of the cross in all of its glorious specificity. Later I’ve seen those nones enfolded into our community and before long, bursting through the waters of baptism. And that’s the very best picture of all of the true, the good, and the beautiful.
Questions for Discussion and Reflection
Nones → Cause → Community → Christ
