Chapter 10 of 22

6. Making Cars

6. Making Cars

6

Making Cars

This may be the most paradigm-shifting chapter in the book. Here’s the essence of what I want to say: It used to be 130, but now it’s 108.

As in the fact that the median worship attendance at a typical congregation has declined—again—from 130 to 108. According to Faith Communities Today, a Hartford Seminary study, the percentage of congregations with an average weekly worship attendance of one hundred or fewer moved from 42 percent to 49 percent. More than a quarter of all congregations had fifty or fewer people in attendance.

And the megachurches, defined as congregations with two thousand or more weekly attendees? While the number doubled, they make up only 0.5 percent of all congregations. As David Roozen, author of the report “A Decade of Change in American Congregations, 2000–2010” and director of the Hartford Institute for Religion Research notes, “While it is true that the number of megachurches roughly doubled during the decade . . . and they are attracting an ever bigger slice of the religious attender pie, it is a bigger slice of a shrinking pie.”

Now, let’s state the obvious: attendance is far from being the only metric that matters. Much has been said about the church’s true effectiveness being much more than butts, bricks, and bucks (attendance, buildings, and giving). The greater question is what is happening to those people, and the greatest question is whether God is being glorified through the church as both community and mission.

Yet attendance does matter. The Great Commission has teeth; either you are reaching people for Christ or you are not. If you are reaching people, you’ll grow numerically; if you’re not, you won’t.

So a number like 108 is concerning. But that isn’t why this chapter is so important. It’s because of the answer to a single question: Why is it so low?

The most glaring reason, and most indicting, is simple. When we think about growth, we are not thinking about conversion growth. We are thinking about biological growth, transfer growth, or perhaps prodigal growth. Until we think about conversion growth as the way to grow our churches, we won’t make a dent in the fastest-growing religious demographic of our day.

Biological growth occurs when a child of existing believers with ties to a church comes to faith in Christ through his or her involvement in the church. Essentially, this is winning your own. For example, in the southern state of Kerala, India, where Catholics have long been a large minority group, church authorities believe the state’s overall Christian population could drop to 17 percent this year, down from 19.5 percent in 1991. Worried about their dwindling numbers, the Roman Catholic Church in southern India announced a campaign to increase attendance by asking its flock to have more babies. It even went so far as to offer free schooling, medical care, and even cash bonuses for large families.

Another way of growing is transfer growth. This takes place when a Christian moves into a new area and chooses to join a church, or when a locally churched Christian makes the decision to move to another church home. Such a person does not come to a church as a nonbeliever, nor does this person come from an unchurched background. At most, he or she is temporarily unchurched due to relocation or some other life issue. This type of growth, then, results from nothing more than the migration of existing believers. Translation: sheep swapping.

I recall many years ago reading an article about a large church that was experiencing financial difficulty. When asked why the church was stalled in its growth, the pastor replied that when they started, they were the only evangelical church around. Now there were several good Bible-teaching churches. So people had a choice. That is why, he said, they weren’t growing.

Even when churches see evidence of reaching the unchurched or marking high numbers of baptisms, it is often prodigal growth. A prodigal is someone without a recent church background or church involvement. This person previously embraced Christian beliefs and, in some cases, maintained a certain level of spirituality. For one reason or another, however, this person left the church and may have lived his or her life outside Christ’s leadership. At the very least, a prodigal has certainly left the life of Christian community. Prodigal growth occurs when such a person returns to the church. Renewal and rededication may take place as part of the return and, at times, even rebaptism.

But missing in so many churches’ thinking is conversion growth. This type of growth occurs when a church reaches a non-Christian. Consciously or not, such a person has never accepted the truth and claims of Christianity. Growing through conversion is reaching a person who has not entered into a life-changing, personal relationship with Christ as Savior and Lord.

If this emphasis doesn’t change, small churches will keep getting smaller; big churches will keep attracting larger numbers of the already convinced (often at the expense of the smaller churches); the Christian population as a whole will remain in decline; and the nones will remain nothing.

Car Assembly Line

Think about a car assembly line. At the beginning of the line are the raw materials and parts needed to make a car: wire, engine, tires, chassis. Then, as those materials progress down the assembly line, a car is made. At the end of the line, the vehicle is rolled off for service (see figure 6.1).

Figure 6.1 Car Assembly Line

The dilemma is that many churches are specializing in one short segment of the assembly line (see figure 6.2). There is no effort to collect the raw material needed to build cars, and there is little effort to roll finished cars off the line for actual service and use on the road. The mission of these churches seems to be simply to keep new cars that have already been built well-tuned and polished for the showroom floor.

Figure 6.2 Car Assembly

This brings a foundational challenge on two levels. First, for the mission to be pursued, existing Christians must die to themselves for the sake of the cause. No longer can the mission be about us—it must be about those who have yet to darken our doorsteps.

But there’s a second challenge that this brings to bear. If our mission is going to be the Great Commission, it will force us to grapple with the difficulties of the task. The mission cannot be simply to keep Christians happy and growing. Nor can it be about attempting to lure believers from other churches by having glitzier services and better programs. Our mission will actually have to target the nones.

Think of it this way: It is one thing to try to convince people wanting to fly from Charlotte to Atlanta to consider using Delta’s services over US Airways. It is another thing altogether to get someone on board who has no desire to fly. Switching airlines would be akin to transfer growth—attracting the already convinced to your church. But getting someone averse to flying to step into the concourse, much less walk down the boarding ramp, is something altogether different. That’s conversion growth.

I’ve often told people that if Meck had been focused on transfer growth, we would be much, much larger than we are now. Transfer growth is so much easier. These people want to fly! They are just looking for the best airline: best service, best seats, best flight times, best flight attendants, best pilots, best price. They are making a consumer decision; but make no mistake, they are ready to buy.

Conversion growth is much, much tougher. These are people who don’t even like airports. And getting them past security, through the concourse, down the ramp, and into seat 15C? That’s difficult. But understandably difficult, at least if you put yourself in the shoes of a none.

Learning from CarMax

I hate buying cars. I hate how the sales staff waits like vultures out front, descending on you before you even get out of your car. I hate how they push to get information about you—what you want to spend, are you going to trade in anything—all going into a plan to “work” you. I hate how they steer you away from what you really want to what they are trying to “move.” I hate how hard it is to get straight answers. I hate how pushy they are to get you to decide then and there and won’t let you walk away without getting as much contact information as possible. I hate haggling over a price: the back and forth, the mind games, and the manipulation. I hate having to bone up on the car’s actual price, being coy about whether I’m going to trade in anything, and getting my guard up about the second salesperson who poses as a finance person but only wants to sell me more add-ons.

Did I mention I hate buying cars? So I didn’t. For a long time. As in “two cars with over 200,000 miles each” long time. But at some point, life—and mileage—catches up. So I broke down and bought a car. Ready for a surprise? After my experience, I am actually looking forward to going back and, when needed, doing it again.

Why? Because of CarMax. (No, I don’t work for them, get kickbacks, have family involved, or own stock.) Their slogan is simple: “The way car buying should be.” And they’re right. They have changed my entire attitude toward buying cars because they gave me an entirely different experience.

I could skip the lot, go online, and select exactly what I wanted in a car—type, mileage, price, features. Then a search engine showed me all the cars that fit my parameters. There was a no-haggle policy about the sticker price. The idea was simple: they set what they felt was a reasonable and competitive price, but there were no negotiating games. I could explore financing through the site, and if so desired, I could have it completed online before I went to the lot. The specific car I selected was ready for me to test drive when I arrived on the lot, even if it meant getting it there from fifty miles away. There was no bait and switch when I arrived or pressure to look at other cars. Because of the online process, when I bought the car, they even had my tags ready.

So a reluctant, even hostile customer became a raving fan. All it took was a different process. Same transaction, same product, same goal, but a radically different experience.

Now think about someone interested in exploring the Christian faith through a church. Yes, like me with a car, there will be times when even the most reluctant nones will find themselves walking through the doors. Whether because of a cultural event such as Easter or Christmas Eve, a milestone in life like the birth of a baby, a marriage, the loss of a loved one, or the invitation of a friend; even the most entrenched nones can find themselves in a church.

But let’s face it. They dread it. As we’ve seen, many people are open to God but hate church. They hate having to dress up on a Sunday morning. They hate having to listen to music that is outdated, poorly performed, or just weird (what’s up with building an Ebeneezer?). They hate feeling hit on for money, being assaulted by the ten-week sermon series titled “Tithe or Burn,” or being forced to stare at a thermometer on the wall charting the latest fund drive. They hate being recognized as a first-time visitor, being made to stand out and feel more conspicuous than they already do, and then being forced to share contact information they aren’t ready to give. They hate pushy, plastic, preachy types who say the word God as if it has three syllables. They hate being bored out of their skull for an hour or more. They hate feeling judged and being looked down on for their lack of regular attendance. They hate not knowing when to stand, when to sit, and what to recite.

They hate—the experience. But they don’t hate God, just like I didn’t hate new cars. I actually wanted a new car, just like many people truly want a relationship with God. So perhaps the first thing to consider for the mission, and the death of self involved in it, is a new way of doing church. Not a different product, as some mistakenly assume. It’s not about watering things down, airbrushing out the tough parts on sin and repentance, or capitulating to cultural mores. After all, I didn’t want a moped.

Just a new way of doing church, and doing it along the lines of what CarMax apparently did. Namely, listening to customers and finding out what it is they hate about the experience. No, not letting surveys create a consumer-driven theology or anything else that would compromise the gospel. But simply letting the feedback speak to the experience of attending—an experience that is often mired in practices, manners, and methods that can create an alienating and off-putting experience.

So is that all it takes for a new emphasis on conversion growth to take hold? No. The CarMax idea is simply suggestive of the kinds of changes that may need to be considered if you want to reach outsiders. The real paradigm shift is internal. It’s how you felt about my CarMax example.

Spiritual Narcissism

The names say it all: YouTube, MySpace. And of course, the i’s: iPod, iTunes, iMac, and iPhone. Each year Time magazine selects a “Person of the Year” who is the individual most central to current history and culture—filled in the past with presidents, dictators, business moguls, and religious leaders. When they searched for the person of the year for 2006, they made a selection that had never been made before: the word You on a mylar mirror so that the reader could see his or her reflection. If there is a theme to our day, it is: “It’s all about me.” Tom Wolfe had earlier labeled the 1970s the “Me Decade.” In her book Generation Me, Jean M. Twenge writes that compared to today’s generation, “They were posers.”

“Narcissus” by Leonardo da Vinci

In Greek mythology, Narcissus is the character who, on passing his reflection in the water, became so enamored with himself that he devoted the rest of his life to his own reflection. From this we get our term narcissism, the preoccupation with self. The value of narcissism is the classic “I, me, mine” mentality that places personal pleasure and fulfillment at the forefront of concerns. Historian Christopher Lasch went so far as to christen ours “the culture of narcissism,” saying that this is the new religion—a religion in which we don’t actually want religion proper but instead, personal therapy. And it is just this spirit that has invaded our thinking and gone to war against the church.

Eavesdrop, for a moment, on our rhetoric: “I want to go where I’m fed”—not where we can learn to feed ourselves, much less feed others. “I need to be ministered to”—as if ministry in the life of the Christ follower is something that happens to us instead of something we make happen through us for others. We walk out of a worship service and say, “I didn’t get anything out of it,” as if its purpose is our edification instead of our worship of God.

Such a consumer mindset only looks at the church in terms of how it caters to specific felt needs. This from a people whose Savior said, “[I] did not come to be served, but to serve, and to give [my] life as a ransom for many” (Matt. 20:28). A Savior who said, “Anyone who wants to be first must be the very last” (Mark 9:35). A Savior who said, “Whoever wants to become great among you must be your servant” (Matt. 20:26). A Savior who said to the Father, “Not my will, but yours” (Luke 22:42). Yet a spiritual narcissism has invaded our thinking to the point that the individual needs and desires of the believer have become the center of attention. And it is precisely this spirit that is turning us away from conversion growth and doing whatever it may take to reach the nones.

Consider the first two questions any organization must ask itself, courtesy of management expert Peter Drucker: (1) What is our mission? (2) Who is our customer? The second of these involves crass language, I know, for any church. But let’s consider these questions for a moment.

First, what is our mission? Few would deny that it is to seek and save the lost. So clear were our marching orders from Jesus in this regard that the passage in which he gives us our mission is called the “Great Commission.” So how can we have a mission other than the one Christ entrusted to us as the church? Yes, the Great Commission also involves discipleship, but we cannot pursue discipleship apart from having someone to disciple. If you never reach anyone for Christ, who, exactly, will you be discipling? Evangelism must be in the vanguard, which is why Jesus says we are to first make disciples and then teach them to obey everything he commanded.

From this comes the second question: Who, then, is our primary customer? The answer is inescapable. If our mission is to seek and save (and then disciple) the lost, then our customer is the one who is lost. Yet here is the point of the breakdown. Most churches have as their primary focus reaching and then serving the already convinced. So the mission isn’t making disciples but rather caring for them. From this, services rendered to the believer become paramount. Existing Christians are the customer in a consumer-driven mission. As a result, conversion growth is given lip service, while biological growth and transfer growth become the defining reality.

The Truth about (Many) Christians and Evangelism

Here is the uncomfortable truth. Almost everybody who follows Christ, and almost every gathering of those Christ followers constituting a church, says the same thing: “We want to reach the world for Christ.” Yet most don’t do it. So where’s the breakdown?

It’s not strategy. There are vast numbers of churches who are successfully penetrating the culture of the nones, growing through conversion growth, and who willingly offer their tried-and-true strategies to any and all who wish to learn.

It’s not theology. As mentioned earlier, almost every Christian church has evangelism as part of its core values and integral to their mission statement.

It’s not the new generation of leadership. Most young leaders got into the game to see a lost world won to Christ. They are sold out and ready to rock.

It’s not the new generation of Christians. If you want to meet an evangelistic animal, spend time with a new believer. They are, in the best sense of the word, shameless with enthusiasm.

So what is the problem?

Jesus knew. When challenged about his own missional emphasis toward those on the outside of faith, he responded: “Who needs a doctor: the healthy or the sick? Go figure out what this Scripture means: ‘I’m after mercy, not religion.’ I’m here to invite outsiders, not coddle insiders” (Matt. 9:12–13 Message).

The problem? Seemingly long-term insiders. Countless leaders and members of churches have given in to a Christian consumerism. They embrace a mentality that gives ample rhetorical support to evangelistic intent but resists violently at the point of implementation because—at the point of actually doing it—it costs them. In other words, scratch the surface of a sacrificial, pick-up-your-cross, to-die-is-gain, eat-my-flesh and drink-my-blood Christian, and you find an it’s-all-about-me, spiritually narcissistic, turned-inward, meet-my-needs, feed-me consumer.

Again, listen to how we talk: Of course I want to reach lost people,

but I’m not going to let the music change

but I’m not going to lead a capital campaign to raise the money

but I’m not going to park far away

but I’m not going to risk stirring things up right now in the church

but I’m not going to attend at a different service time

but I’m not going to start a new church

but I’m not going to stand for the pastor dressing casually

but I’m not going to give money to launch a new site or relocate

but I’m not going to watch someone on a video

but I’m not going to put in fifty- or sixty-hour weeks

but I’m not going to let them start playing drums

but I’m not going to change how I preach

but I’m not going to give up my favorite seat

but I’m not going to turn things over to a bunch of twentysomethings

but I’m not going to attend on Saturday night

but I’m not going to . . .

You fill in the rest.

I’m not even suggesting this list is what a church should do. But it does betray our spirit. The problem with outreach today is that the very people who say they want unchurched people to come and find Jesus resist the most basic and elemental issues related to building a relationship with someone apart from Christ, then engaging in spiritual conversations, and then inviting them to an open, winsome, and compelling front door so they can come and see, come and hear, come and experience.

Why? Because it would call for sacrifice or inconvenience of some kind. A leader would have to work harder or invest in vision-casting and face potential opposition. Attendees would have to be part of a church that no longer exists solely to serve them but now serves those who have yet to enter the doors. This means that evangelism is fine in theory but not in practice, because in practice evangelism almost always involves death-to-self—the complete anticonsumer state of mind.

So can we change? Sure. But only when we look in the mirror and own the truth about our consumerism: we say we want them in heaven—but we act like they can go to hell.

Questions for Discussion and Reflection

  • Church membership continues to decline. Last Sunday more than a quarter of all congregations had fewer than fifty people in attendance. What do you think is contributing to the sustained drop?
  • When growth is discussed, it often doesn’t center around conversion growth—growth coming from those previously unchurched or nonbelievers. Does your church distinguish between transfer and conversion growth? On which do you put more emphasis?
  • If we think about disciples of Christ as being on a car assembly line, we need to shift our focus from the “finished product” to the “raw materials,” meaning the unchurched who are far from Christ. Is part of your mission, personally and in your church, to reach the nones and help them down the assembly line?
  • In the CarMax example, we saw someone who hates buying cars be converted into a raving fan. But just like someone who finds himself or herself in need of a new car, a none will sometimes find himself or herself in a church. If a none sat in your church this weekend, how would he or she interpret the experience?
  • Spiritual narcissism has crept into American Christianity, where the needs of the believer have become the center of attention. Think carefully about your own church and its programs, its weekend services, and how it spends its energy and money. Does it reflect a spiritual narcissism or a missional strategy to reach those like the nones?
  • “We want to seek and save the lost” is a common thing to say in church, but there’s far more to this than simply uttering the phrase. It takes a willingness to change music, shift focus, reshape ministries, and inconvenience believers. Do your actions as a church affirm your intentions to seek and save the lost? If not, what’s holding you back?
  • Read this statement about the lost: “We say we want them in heaven—but we act like they can go to hell.” How did you feel? Did it convict you? Were you offended? And if so, why do you think you were?
  • ↑ Back to top

    ↑