Chapter 6 of 22

3. Lawyers, Guns, and Money

3. Lawyers, Guns, and Money

3

Lawyers, Guns, and Money

Have you ever heard the phrase, “the perfect storm”? The idea was first introduced through a book by Sebastian Junger, later made into a movie starring George Clooney, called The Perfect Storm. It was based on a true event.

In October of 1991, the elements all came together to create the most powerful storm in recorded history. It struck just off the coast of Gloucester, Massachusetts. It was really three storms in one: a hurricane, energy flowing from the Great Lakes, and a frontal system sweeping through New England. It created an almost apocalyptic situation in the Atlantic, with boats encountering waves of one hundred feet, which is the equivalent of a ten-story building.

It was the National Weather Service that called it “the Perfect Storm.” It took the lives of many people, including the six men aboard the swordfishing boat Andrea Gail, made famous through its Hollywood depiction.

Since then, whenever multiple dynamics come together to create an overwhelming impact, it is called a “perfect storm.” When it comes to modern assaults on faith, there have been two such cataclysmic events. The first was the combination of the ideas of Copernicus, Darwin, and Freud.

“The Perfect Storm,” October 1991, US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration

Copernicus initiated what can be termed the cosmological attack. In determining through his telescope that we live in a heliocentric universe, as opposed to an Earth-centered one, he challenged more than the centrality of human existence on planet Earth; he brought into question the trustworthiness of faith itself.

At the time, the official teaching of the Christian church considered anything other than an Earth-centered universe heresy. Of course, the church’s position was wrong. It wasn’t that the Bible was wrong, only their interpretation of obscure texts that had been skewed by the bias that Earth needed to be at the center of creation to uphold the special nature of God’s creation on Earth. No such assertion was necessary to the doctrine of creation, much less the doctrine of humanity, but the damage had been done. Religious pronouncements on matters of public discourse have been automatically suspect ever since, and modern cosmologists now speak to issues of faith and philosophy with greater authority than priests and theologians.

Darwin’s assault was not cosmological; it was biological—or perhaps more accurately, anthropological. In Origin of Species, this minister’s son contended that the origin of humankind could be accounted for in ways other than direct spiritual activity—namely, natural selection. No matter that the theory of macroevolution continues to have its fair share of detractors in regard to its failure to account for the actual origin of species (e.g., one of the pushbacks against naturalistic evolution is that you need self-reproducing organisms in place for natural selection to even begin), the very idea of an alternative explanation rooted in science proved compelling. And of course, few believers at the time considered the idea of theistic evolution. Nonetheless, the damage was done. Neither Earth nor human beings were pictured as the center of the universe.

Then Sigmund Freud used psychology to intimate that the idea of the soul itself is conditioned. God is nothing but a projection of our desires. We want there to be a God, so we imagine such a being. Or as Voltaire wrote in 1770, “Se Dieu n’existait pas, il faudrait l’inventer” (“If God did not exist, it would be necessary to invent him”). Forgetting that such an argument would war against the integrity of many of the intellectual achievements of civilization, including his own theory of psychoanalysis, Freud hit his target in the same manner as Darwin. There was now an option to explain spiritual conviction apart from faith but seemingly rooted in that which was intellectually apprehensible.

The first perfect storm was complete. But another was brewing, and it all started in the 1990s.

The Secular Boom

You remember the ’90s, right? It was a patchwork quilt of events and ideas, movements and personalities if there ever was one. Our headlines changed and moved with the fast-pace nature of a video camera.

In August of 1990, Saddam Hussein and his Iraqi troops invaded Kuwait. The United States and its allies issued an ultimatum for his withdrawal, setting a deadline of January 15, 1991, for Iraq to pull out. Iraq didn’t. So our armed forces gathered themselves together and turned loose an operation called “Desert Storm.”

Then four years later came Wednesday morning, April 19, 1995. At 9:02 a.m. an explosion ripped through the Alfred P. Murrah Federal Building in Oklahoma City, killing 168 men, women, and children.

But we didn’t have time to reflect on that one too much, because we were too busy watching a white Bronco make its way down the streets of Los Angeles. And we kept right on following it until Tuesday, October 3, 1995, at around 1 p.m. It seemed like everyone in America stopped what they were doing and gathered around a TV or a radio to hear the verdict on O. J. Simpson.

Then in 1997 stories related to the Space Station Mir and Hurricane Erica were pushed aside by the death of two women who had, in their own distinctive ways, touched the world. One was a young princess named Diana; the other was an old saint named Teresa.

If that wasn’t enough for us to take in a ten-year window, in 1998 we were introduced to a twenty-four-year-old White House intern by the name of Monica Lewinsky. And before you knew it, we had a scandal involving the president of the United States that led to a special prosecutor and impeachment hearings.

Tucked away between those headlines was:

the emergence of rap music

the videotaped beating of Rodney King

Clarence Thomas and Anita Hill

“safe sex”

mass murderer Jeffrey Dahmer

the Dream Team in basketball

the bombing of the World Trade Center

David Koresh and Waco

the Los Angeles earthquake

the Whitewater controversy

the suicide of Kurt Cobain

Newt Gingrich and the Contract with America

the Unabomber

Susan Smith

Ruby Ridge

the Million Man March

Bill Gates and Microsoft

the professional debut of golf phenomenon Tiger Woods

the murder of JonBenét Ramsey

the mass suicide of the Heaven’s Gate group

the home run chase between Sammy Sosa and Mark McGwire

the retirement of Michael Jordan

the conflict in Bosnia

the shootings at Columbine High School

the Y2K bug

And that is just from the news.

Our tastes ranged from Pokemon to Melatonin, minivans to the Harry Potter books, the internet to Starbucks. Musically we journeyed from Seattle grunge groups like Nirvana and Pearl Jam to, and I know it’s hard for us to admit it, the Macarena. Hollywood introduced us to Hannibal Lecter, Jurassic Park, and a young Darth Vader. And we spent time thinking about nothing at all on the show that said it was about nothing at all: Seinfeld.

And as we’ve learned, something else significant happened during that decade: the nones—those self-identifying as having no religious affiliation—began a staggeringly fast growth track in the United States. Harvard professor Robert Putnam agrees, tying it to a rebellion of sorts, particularly among the Millennials. He says:

It begins to jump at around 1990. . . . These were the kids who were coming of age in the America of the culture wars, in the America in which religion publicly became associated with a particular brand of politics, and so I think the single most important reason for the rise of the unknowns is that combination of the younger people moving to the left on social issues and the most visible religious leaders moving to the right on that same issue.

A new perfect storm was forming.

The New Storm

The latest storm is different in form but just as deadly in effect. Rather than issues related to cosmology, biology, and psychology, the new storm consists of perceptions and, in many cases, a tragic but true set of facts. Christianity is again under fire; not because it is intellectually untenable due to new arguments lodged by the heirs to Darwin or Freud, but because we are perceived to be overly entangled with law and politics, filled with hateful aggression, and consumed with greed. Or put another way, courtesy of the late Warren Zevon, “lawyers, guns, and money.”

Money

The money part is easy to understand. Whether through televangelist transgressions or megapastor materialism, money and religion have seldom been a productive pairing. The most famously egregious in recent history was Jim Bakker, founder and host of the now infamous PTL Club television ministry. The rumored extravagance of using donor money for air-conditioned dog houses and gold-plated faucets became emblematic of the widespread corruption present in the lives of many televangelists and Christian leaders. More were disgusted by Bakker’s materialism and the financial fraud that eventually sent him to prison than by his sexual mishaps, with PTL being lampooned as meaning “Pass the Loot” instead of “Praise the Lord.” The irony of the contest of his fated liaison wasn’t lost on biographers, such as Charles Shepard. He notes that on the day of Bakker’s sexual tryst with a secretary in Clearwater, Florida, he was in the midst of raising even more money through a telethon.

But less known and now even more telling, is how lawyers and guns have come alongside money to form a perfect storm, leading people away from religion altogether into the realm of the nones. As the research of the Pew Forum on Religion and Public Life found, “They think that religious organizations are too concerned with money and power, too focused on rules and too involved in politics.”

Lawyers

According to a team of sociologists from the University of California, Berkeley, and Duke University, the rise of the nones is directly tied to politics. “This is a product of the involvement of the religious right in American politics,” notes Claude Fischer, one of the researchers with UC Berkeley, “and the increasing connection in Americans’ minds, the minds of moderates and liberals, that religious equals conservative politics equals religion.” Going further, Fischer says, “Increasingly, people identify and link organized religion with antigay attitudes, sexual conservatism, a whole range of those kinds of social cultural values. One way you can think about it is, this is blowback.”

In his book To Change the World, sociologist James Davison Hunter critiques the dominant ways Christians have thought about culture and cultural change. He saves his most scathing critique for the use of power through politics, which he finds in almost every approach to cultural engagement currently being offered in American Christianity. All, he maintains, are “marked by a ressentiment”—a French word that includes our American idea of resentment but also involves anger, envy, hate, rage, and revenge as the motive for political action. “Ressentiment,” writes Hunter, “is grounded in a narrative of injury or, at least, perceived injury; a strong belief that one has been or is being wronged.” Christians, Hunter suggests, have given themselves over to this. We’ve politicized our faith and stake out our positions in ideological terms. This is as true of the Christian Right as the Christian Left, marking Jim Dobson as much as Jim Wallis. All have reduced the public witness of the church to a political witness.

I have previously written of the failed and faulty effort of Christians to “recapture” the culture. Much of this was rooted in the idea that ours was once a Christian nation, and we should actively work to return our governing bodies and laws to their original intent. And even among those who would not espouse a sense of returning, there is often a deep sense of fulfilling a Christian destiny. The idea of being “chosen” and receiving a “special blessing” from God has been a constant theme throughout the history of the United States, beginning with the Puritans and their desire that, in the words of John Winthrop in 1630, “wee shall be as a Citty upon a Hill.” As historian Conrad Cherry writes, “Throughout their history Americans have been possessed by an acute sense of divine election. They have fancied themselves a New Israel, a people chosen for the awesome responsibility of serving as a light to the nations. . . . It has long been . . . the essence of America’s motivating mythology.”

The vision of a Christian America was again popularized in the late 1970s by evangelical authors Peter Marshall and David Manuel in The Light and the Glory. Marshall and Manuel held that America was founded as a Christian nation and flourished under the benevolent hand of divine providence, arguing further that America’s blessings will remain only as long as America as a nation is faithful to God. In 1989 a team of evangelical historians (Mark Noll, Nathan Hatch, and George Marsden) attempted to lay this somewhat dubious thesis to rest, but it continues as a popular framework for viewing American history among American evangelicals.

The Moral Majority of the 1980s found its genesis in such sentiments, and it accordingly formed a top-down strategy for cultural change. If we could only have Christians in the White House, Congress, and the Supreme Court, or populating other leadership elites, then morality would be enacted and faith would once again find the fertile soil needed to establish its footing in individual lives. The Moral Majority won through the election of Ronald Reagan as president, and his subsequent Supreme Court appointments throughout the 1980s brought great anticipation for substantive change.

Yet there has been little real change to mark as a result. Even the prime target—the striking down of the Supreme Court decision Roe v. Wade, which legalized abortion—remains the law of the land to this day. Further, the culture wars of the 1980s and ’90s are now widely viewed as one of the more distasteful episodes in recent memory, and many younger evangelicals want nothing to do with what was often its caustic, abrasive, and unloving approach toward those apart from Christ. So the effort to recapture the nation failed as a strategy and alienated a younger generation.

Guns

And what of the guns dynamic? Many of those outside the Christian faith think Christians no longer represent what Jesus had in mind and that Christianity in our society is not what it was meant to be. We’re seen as hyperpolitical, out of touch, pushy in our beliefs, and arrogant. And the most dominant perceptions of all are that we are homophobic, hypocritical, and judgmental. Simply put, in the minds of many, modern-day Christianity no longer seems Christian.

In a video that’s been viewed half a million times on YouTube, songwriter and comedian Tim Minchin asks a Sydney, Australia, audience, “Are you up for a sing?”

Minchin begins to sing, “I love Jesus, I love Jesus.” Prompting the audience to join him, “Who do you love? Sing it!” Soon the whole crowd is involved, singing “I love Jesus, I love Jesus.” Then Minchin changes the lyrics: “I love Jesus, I hate faggots.”

The crowd stops singing along.

Minchin looks up from his guitar as if he doesn’t understand the nature of the problem. “What happened? I just lost you there,” he says. After a halfhearted attempt to get the group singing again, he gives up. “Ah, well.” He shrugs. “Maybe these are ideas best shared in churches.”

Much of that image has been earned. We’ve acted in ways, talked in ways, and lived in ways that have stolen from God’s reputation. All this and more has flowed from the research of Gabe Lyons and David Kinnaman on how people view the church and people in it. The heart of what they’ve found is that among young American “outsiders” (that is, those outside the church), the following words or phrases were offered as possible descriptors of Christianity along with the percent who affirmed their accuracy.

antihomosexual (91 percent)

judgmental (87 percent)

hypocritical (85 percent)

old-fashioned (78 percent )

too involved in politics (75 percent)

out of touch with reality (72 percent)

insensitive to others (70 percent)

boring (68 percent)

not accepting of other faiths (64 percent)

confusing (61 percent)

Twenty years ago I commissioned a similar study of people who were unchurched. I asked them a simple question: How did the church and those inside it lose you? I first published the research, done in coordination with the Barna Research Group, in my book Rethinking the Church. Comparing the two studies is interesting.

In 1992, the unchurched gave the following reasons for abandoning the church:

there is no value in attending church (74 percent)

churches have too many problems (61 percent)

I do not have the time (48 percent)

I am simply not interested (42 percent)

churches ask for money too frequently (40 percent)

church services are usually boring (36 percent)

Christian churches hold no relevance for the way I live (34 percent)

I do not believe in God; or, I am unsure that God exists (12 percent)

Such findings pointed to a culture that was saying, “God, yes; church, no.” That was twenty years ago. Now research shows the deepening crisis because it points to a culture that says, “God, perhaps; Christianity and Christians, no.” The idea of even considering church is seemingly off the table.

Questions for Discussion and Reflection

  • Both the ARIS report and the Pew report, which documented the rise of the nones, found that the secular boom actually happened during the 1990s. Did you sense this happening during that time period? What clued you in to it?
  • One study conducted by a team from the University of California, Berkeley, and Duke University found that the rise of the nones is directly related to politics. Individuals link religious affiliation with such sentiments as antigay attitudes and sexual conservatism. How did the role of Christianity in politics through the 1980s and ’90s lead to the reduction of the public witness of the church to nothing more than a political witness?
  • The culture wars of the 1980s and ’90s left an entire generation of young Americans wanting nothing to do with organized religion, especially if politics was involved. How can you reach out to those who were alienated by the bickering and abrasive language of the culture wars?
  • The biggest perception of Christians today is that they are homophobic, hypocritical, and judgmental. Basically, Christians without the Christ. Are you actively seeking to counter that perception in your life? Is it possible to do more to lower the protective walls of those in your community?
  • The final sentence in the chapter states, “The idea of even considering church is seemingly off the table.” What does that say to your heart, mind, and soul about how you approach evangelism today?
  • Do you encounter the “lawyers, guns, and money” mentality in your everyday life? How do you feel when that happens?
  • In the last twelve months, how many sermons or messages have been given in your church that addressed at least one of the perceptions of money, politics, or hate?
  • ↑ Back to top

    ↑