5. Bad Religion
5
Bad Religion
In Ross Douthat’s book Bad Religion, the New York Times columnist offers a synopsis of the core beliefs of America’s wave of “spiritual but not religious” teachers such as Deepak Chopra, James Redfield, Eckhart Tolle, Paulo Coelho, Neale Donald Walsch, Oprah Winfrey, and Elizabeth Gilbert. According to Douthat, their “creed” shares four beliefs.
1. All organized religions offer only partial glimpses of God (or Light or Being). Thus, we must seek to experience God through feeling rather than reason, through experience rather than dogma, through a direct encounter rather than a hand-me-down revelation. As Neale Donald Walsch writes in his book Conversations with God, “Listen to your feelings. Listen to your Highest Thought. . . . Whenever any of these differ from what you’ve been told by your teachers, or read in your books, forget the words.”
2. God is everywhere and within everything—especially within you. You can encounter God by getting in touch with the divinity who resides inside your very self and soul. At the climax of his book, The Alchemist, Paulo Coelho writes: “The boy reached through the Soul of the World, and saw that it was a part of the Soul of God. And he saw that the Soul of God was his own soul.”
3. Sin and evil are largely illusions that will ultimately be reconciled rather than defeated. There is no hell save the one we make for ourselves on earth—no final separation from the Being within whom all our beings rest. Elizabeth Gilbert assures her readers, “There is no such thing in this universe as hell, except maybe in our own terrified minds.”
4. Perfect happiness is available right now. Heaven is on earth. Eternity can be entered at any moment, by any person who understands how to let go, let God, and let himself or herself be washed away in love. James Redfield writes, “At some point everyone will vibrate highly enough so that we can walk into heaven, in our same form.” And Coelho adds, “I do believe in life after death, but I also don’t think that it’s that important. What’s important is to understand that we are also living this life after death now.”
I have written similarly of the “Church of Oprah-Wan Kenobi” and the rise of a new New Age movement that is based largely on popularized Hinduism, which is what Douthat has described. But what Douthat, myself, and others have actually detailed is the official religion of the cultural epicenters, namely media. It is not the official religion of the religiously unaffiliated. At least not yet.
The Pew Forum study, among others, has found that the ranks of the unaffiliated are not predominantly composed of New Age spirituality or alternative forms of religion. Generally speaking, the unaffiliated are no more likely than members of the public as a whole to have such beliefs and practices. That means that approximately three in ten say they believe in spiritual energy in physical objects and in yoga as a spiritual practice. Around a quarter believe in astrology and reincarnation. Six in ten say they have a deep connection with nature and the earth. About three in ten say they have felt in touch with someone who is dead, and 15 percent have consulted a psychic. All of these figures closely resemble the public as a whole.
The importance of knowing the “bad religion” advertised through popular culture is the effect it will inevitably have on the religiously unaffiliated as they separate from religion itself. Right now they do not seem to be any more affected than people of defined faith, but that is arguably the strength of their, largely, Christian memory. Most of the newly unaffiliated were part of a Christian faith tradition that was anything but Eastern in orientation. Once untethered from these moorings, whether Catholicism or Protestantism, they will be more susceptible to the prevailing views of culture. Our inner worlds abhor a vacuum; we will fill it with something.
But while pop-Hinduism may not have made inroads into the unaffiliated as yet, there is another bad religion that is firmly entrenched: a truthy, wiki dogma for mistakers.
Truthiness
The first headline related to the belief system of the nones is that the unaffiliated tend to believe there is a lot of truth to go around. There isn’t just one truth out there; there are multiple truths.
I once read a children’s book, supporting a PBS series, written by a Jewish rabbi and a Catholic monsignor. In it they wrote that searching for God has become like climbing a mountain. Since everyone knows that there is not just one way to climb a mountain—mountains are simply too big for that—there are any number of paths that can be taken. So, the rabbi and priest concluded, all of the ideas about God throughout the religions of the world are like different ways up the mountain, and all of the names of God in all of the world’s religions all name the same God. The Dalai Lama, who wrote the foreword to the book, agreed.
But it’s not simply the idea of multiple truths; it’s also about what that idea produces. If you believe that truth is everywhere, making truth mean very little, what does that leave you with? A word first introduced by comedian Stephen Colbert: truthiness. Here’s how Colbert described it:
And that brings us to tonight’s word: truthiness.
Now, I’m sure some of the Word Police, the “wordanistas” over at Webster’s, are gonna say, “Hey, that’s not a word.” Well, anybody who knows me knows that I’m no fan of dictionaries or reference books. They are elitist. Constantly telling us what is or isn’t true, or what did or didn’t happen. Who’s Britannica to tell me the Panama Canal was finished in 1914? If I wanna say it happened in 1941, that’s my right. I don’t trust books. They’re all fact, not heart.
The idea behind truthiness is that actual facts don’t matter. What matters is how you feel, for you as an individual are the final arbiter of truth. Truthiness is the bald assertion that we are not only to discern truth for ourselves from the facts at hand, but also to create truth for ourselves despite the facts at hand. We so felt the truth of Colbert’s satire that truthiness later became Oxford American Dictionary’s word of the year. That brings us to another word, and once again, courtesy of Mr. Colbert: wikiality.
Wikiality
Among the internet’s most popular sites is Wikipedia, the online encyclopedia that is written entirely by unpaid volunteers. Though praised for “democratizing knowledge” by such luminaries as Stanford University law professor Lawrence Lessig, Wikipedia has more than its fair share of detractors. In 2006 the site drew unwanted attention when journalist John Seigenthaler exposed gross errors and fabrications in the biographical entry on his life. Numerous scholars have voiced concern that the encyclopedia is an unreliable research tool and lament students’ use of the resource. A paper by a University of California at Merced graduate student revealed many of Wikipedia’s flaws, including often indifferent prose and some serious problems with accuracy.
Yet it seems Wikipedia is here to stay. In 2013 the ninth annual Wikimania conference—a five-day discussion of the Wikimedia Foundation’s various projects—was held in Hong Kong. In addition, the English-language version of Wikipedia has surpassed four million articles; there are over twenty-six million articles across all languages; and it is consistently one of the Web’s twenty most popular destinations.
Regardless of the accuracy of certain articles, and separate from the movement advocating free access to information online, Stephen Colbert has put his finger on the real issue in his play off of the word reality. Wikiality is defined as “reality as determined by majority vote,” such as when astronomers voted Pluto off their list of planets. Colbert notes that with Wikipedia, any user can log on and make a change on any entry, and if enough users agree, it becomes true. Colbert muses about a wikiality where this could apply to the entire body of human knowledge. “Together we can create a reality we can all agree on. The reality we just agreed on.” So through a new “wikiality,” we can take our collective “truthiness” and make it “fact” for all through majority vote.
With such democratization of knowledge comes the democratization of truth, resulting in an evolution from the idea that “what is true for you is true for you, and what is true for me is true for me” to the new belief that “what is true for us is true for us.” And there would be no reason not to hold to its corollary: “and what is true for them is true for them.” In a “wiki” world, there is no truth outside of what the majority determines. Fifty-one percent become the final arbiter of reality. The idea of truth finally becomes divorced from any kind of mooring—it simply drifts along the breezes of cultural mores. Or as Marshall Poe observes in the Atlantic, “If the community changes its mind and decides that two plus two equals five, then two plus two does equal five.”
This is reflected comically in the movie Talladega Nights during a prayer before family dinner led by race-car driver Ricky Bobby (played by Will Ferrell), who decides he wants to pray to Jesus as a baby. This opens the door to an interesting theological discussion between Ricky Bobby; his two sons; his wife, Carley; her father; and Ricky Bobby’s best friend, Cal:
Ricky Bobby: Dear Tiny Infant Jesus—
Carley: Hey, umm, you know, sweetie, Jesus did grow up. You don’t always have to call him “baby.” It’s a bit odd and off-putting praying to a baby.
Ricky Bobby: I like the Christmas Jesus best and I’m saying grace. When you’re saying grace, you can say it to grown-up Jesus, or teenage Jesus, or bearded Jesus, or whoever you want.
(returning to his prayer) . . . Dear Tiny Jesus, with your golden-fleeced diapers, with your tiny little fat, balled-up fists—
Carley’s father: He was a man; he had a beard!
Ricky Bobby: Look, I like the baby version the best. Do you hear me? I win the races and I get the money . . .
Cal: I like to picture Jesus in a tuxedo T-shirt, ’cause it says, like, I want to be formal, but I’m here to party too. ’Cause I like to party, so I like my Jesus to party.
Walker (son): I like to picture Jesus as a ninja fightin’ off evil Samurai.
Cal: I like to think of Jesus with, like, with giant eagles’ wings singin’ lead vocals for Lynyrd Skynyrd with, like, an angel band. And I’m in the front row and I’m hammered drunk . . .
Ricky Bobby (continuing to pray): Dear eight-pound six-ounce, newborn infant Jesus, don’t even know a word yet . . . thank you for all your power and your grace, dear baby God. Amen.
Such pick-and-choose approaches to truth are not without their cultural critics. Consider the recent release of Malcolm Gladwell’s book David and Goliath. In his bestselling titles such as The Tipping Point, Blink, and Outliers, Gladwell’s approach has been to popularize various research projects and draw counterintuitive conclusions. Now, I am a fan of Gladwell and find that his writings offer interesting challenges to conventional wisdom. Yet reviews of his work point out that the research he reveals is often small, unverified, or contradicted by larger and more established studies. Further, the conclusions he draws as the “only” conclusion are far from it.
For example, he writes how a disproportionate number of eminent people lost a parent in childhood, and he draws the conclusion that such adversity strengthens someone for success. Yet in another section, Gladwell notes that prisoners are also far more likely than the general population to have suffered that blow as children. So which is it? Do early wounds create winners, except when they don’t? Gladwell’s approach is said to involve telling “just-so stories and cherry-picking science to back them” and starting off with “the fallacy of the unexamined premise.” More to the point, what “he presents are mostly just intriguing possibilities and musings about human behavior, but what his publisher sells them as, and what his readers may incorrectly take them for, are lawful, causal rules that explain how the world really works.”
It’s a wiki approach, to be sure, which may be why it’s made him one of the biggest selling authors of nonfiction in the Western world. After all, it’s a wiki world.
Mistakers
So what does all this mean for the unaffiliated and how they view their moral world? Once you get rid of true and false, you also tend to get rid of right and wrong.
This was first forecast back in 1973 when psychiatrist Karl Menninger published a book entitled Whatever Became of Sin? His point was that sociology and psychology were beginning to avoid terms like evil, immorality, and wrongdoing. Menninger then detailed how the theological notion of sin became the legal idea of crime and then slid further from its true meaning and became nothing more than the psychological category of sickness.
Now it’s gone even further. We’re not sinners at all anymore. As many have observed, we’re just mistakers. And we’re even starting to lose that. Lately, we don’t even want to call a sin a mistake. We want to turn everything we do into a virtue. So lust becomes “sensuality,” and anger just means “being honest with your emotions.” Even when we apologize, we say things like, “I’m sorry you were offended by what I said or did.” No admittance that we did anything wrong—just sorry that the other person wasn’t mature enough to handle it. The latest edition of the Oxford Junior Dictionary for children went all the way and made it official. The compilers removed the word completely. They don’t even have the word sin in the dictionary anymore.
As a result, morals are seen as almost entirely relative. There are no absolutes when it comes to right or wrong. If it doesn’t hurt anybody else and it makes you happy, then it’s okay. Morality has become a personal choice. It’s personal, private, subjective, and a matter of personal decision or opinion. Consider the following interview with Nick Cassavetes, the director of such films as The Notebook and John Q. His latest film, Yellow, debuted at the Toronto Film Festival. It’s about an incestuous relationship between a brother and a sister. Speaking of incest, Cassavetes offered these thoughts:
This whole movie is about judgment, and lack of it, and doing what you want. Who gives a [expletive] if people judge you? I’m not saying this is an absolute but in a way, if you’re not having kids—who gives a d—? Love who you want. Isn’t that what we say? Gay marriage—love who you want? If it’s your brother or sister it’s super weird, but if you look at it, you’re not hurting anybody, except every single person who freaks out because you’re in love with one another.
This mindset is documented in sociologist Christian Smith’s massive study of emerging adults—people between the ages of eighteen and twenty-three. He found that a relativistic attitude marks six out of ten (60 percent) emerging adults. They said morality is a personal choice, “entirely a matter of individual decision. Moral rights and wrongs are essentially matters of individual opinion.” One out of every three said they didn’t even know what makes anything right or wrong.
Here it is in their own words:
“I have never heard anybody else that has anything like it [my moral outlook] and I just don’t know where it came from. Like just kinda things that I thought up, that I decided was right for me.”
“What’s a moral rule, though? A personal thing? Well then I would say that sometimes breaking a moral rule may be all right, depending on the situation.”
“Wrong are the things that change things for way worse than they were before—and I kinda think again it’s totally relative to the person, it depends on where you wanna go and what you wanna do.”
“I don’t think lying is wrong necessarily. It’s life. People lie. That’s my view on the whole thing. Everyone’s done it. It’s not going to go away.”
“I will do what I can to get ahead in this world while I’m here.”
“I would do what I thought made me happy or how I felt. Because I have no other way of knowing what to do but how I internally feel. That’s where my decisions come from. From me. My decisions come from inside of me.”
So while the definition of nones is that they believe “nothing in particular,” in truth, they believe something very particular. It just isn’t a belief in truth. Instead, it’s more of a belief in themselves. It brings to mind an older study, conducted by sociologist Robert Bellah, that featured an interview with a woman named Sheila, who said, “I believe in God. I’m not a religious fanatic. I can’t remember the last time I went to church. My faith has carried me a long way. It’s ‘Sheilaism.’ Just my own little voice.”
Questions for Discussion and Reflection
