Chapter 5 of 22

2. Snapshots

2. Snapshots

2

Snapshots

Now that we’ve documented the nones as the fastest-growing and now third-largest religious constituency in the United States—constituting one of every five Americans—who are they? Studies reveal that they are not made up of seekers who are looking for a spiritual home but simply haven’t found it yet (more on that later). Nor are they products of a hostile college system intent on a secular indoctrination, real as that may be. Surveys show that religious affiliation is declining among Americans who do not have college degrees as well as among college graduates.

Here’s the real snapshot of who a none is.

1. Male. Though fewer than half of Americans are male, 56 percent of nones are male. The gender divide among nones who are atheists or agnostics is even more pronounced: 64 percent of this group is male.

2. Young. The older the American, the more likely he or she is to be affiliated with a religion. One-third of Americans under thirty say they have no religious affiliation, compared to 9 percent of those sixty-five and older. This is mostly due to “generational replacement” as a younger generation assumes the place of an older one that is decidedly more religious.

3. White. Of all nones, 71 percent are white, 11 percent are Hispanic, 9 percent are black, and 4 percent are Asian. If you narrow the pool to just agnostics and atheists, the group is even whiter: 82 percent.

4. Not necessarily an atheist. The largest group of nones (68 percent) say they believe in God or a universal spirit. Within that group, 30 percent of them are certain God exists. Only 27 percent of nones say there is no God.

5. Not very religious. This may sound obvious, but it makes the distinction between a person who has no religious affiliation, and one who is not religious. There are some nones who do consider themselves religious—just outside the confines of a religious organization. Nearly three-quarters of nones (72 percent) seldom or never attend religious services.

6. A Democrat. Nones are among the most reliably Democratic of voters. In 2008, three-quarters of them voted for Barack Obama and 23 percent for John McCain, making them as strongly Democratic as white evangelicals were Republican. More than six in ten of those who are registered voters are Democrats or lean toward the Democratic Party.

7. In favor of abortion and same-gender marriage being legal. Big gaps separate nones and Americans in general on these issues. While 53 percent of the general public say abortion should be legal in all or most circumstances, 72 percent of the unaffiliated do. And while at the time of the study 48 percent of the general public favored same-sex marriage, 73 percent of nones did.

8. Liberal or moderate—and not just on the issues above. More than three-quarters of nones describe themselves as generally liberal or moderate, compared to the one in five who call themselves conservative.

9. Not necessarily hostile toward religious institutions. He or she just doesn’t want to belong to one. More than half of the nones (52 percent) say religious institutions protect and strengthen morality, though an even greater proportion (70 percent) believe these institutions are too concerned with money and power.

10. Most likely a westerner. In the U.S., nones are most concentrated in the West and least concentrated in the South. While 23 percent of Americans live in the West, 30 percent of nones do.

Spiritual but Not Religious

What is most important to understand about the average none is that most are not atheists. In truth, most still believe in God, and many pray on a daily basis. They consider themselves spiritual, or at least open to spirituality.

The real mark of a none is not the rejection of God but the rejection of any specific religion. When it comes to content, dogma, orthodoxy—anything spelled out or offering a system of beliefs—they’ve gone from “I believe” to “Maybe” to “Who knows?” When pressed as to what they do hold to, they collectively answer, “Nothing in particular.” Simply put, they are spiritual but not religious.

They may not want to say “I’m a Baptist,” but that does not equate with “I don’t believe in God.” In other words, there is a strong reticence toward labels of any kind. It may help to visualize it in terms of a religious axis and a spiritual axis, creating four quadrants.

The caricature of a none places him or her in the “Not Religious, Not Spiritual” category—but that is inaccurate. The vast majority belong in the “Spiritual, Not Religious” quadrant.

Consider Marcus Mumford, the twenty-six-year-old lead singer of the phenomenally successful British band Mumford & Sons. Mumford is the son of John and Eleanor Mumford, the national leaders of the Vineyard Church in the U.K. and Ireland, part of the international, evangelical Christian Vineyard Movement. He recently married actress Carey Mulligan, whom he’d met years earlier at a Christian youth camp. As the main lyricist for the band, he has lavished the music of Mumford & Sons with the themes and imagery of faith, often drawing specifically on the Christian tradition. As Cathleen Falsani has observed, they “explore relationships with God and others; fears and doubts; sin, redemption, and most of all, grace.”

Yet in a Rolling Stone interview, Mumford declined to claim the “Christian” label as his own. The reporter asked Mumford whether he “still consider[s] himself a Christian.” Mumford replied:

I don’t really like that word. It comes with so much baggage. So, no, I wouldn’t call myself a Christian. I think the word just conjures up all these religious images that I don’t really like. I have my personal views about the person of Jesus and who he was. . . . I’ve kind of separated myself from the culture of Christianity.

Describing his spiritual journey as a “work in progress,” Mumford said that he’s never doubted the existence of God and that his parents are not bothered about his ambivalence toward the Christian label. Before anyone makes a rush to judgment, Falsani suggests that we “consider why he chose to answer the way he did.”

She continues, “What I heard in his reticence to label himself a Christian was not a denial of faith, but instead something that falls between Dorothy Day’s famous ‘Don’t call me a saint—I don’t want to be dismissed so easily,’ and Søren Kierkegaard’s, ‘Once you label me you negate me.’” She also hears echoes of another rock star whose own Christian faith has been a topic of conversation. When Bono was the same age Mumford is now, he shied away from Christian labels and stopped talking about his faith in public forums. When asked about his faith in a 1987 interview in Rolling Stone, Bono said, “I am a Christian, but at times I feel very removed from Christianity. The Jesus Christ that I believe in was the man who turned over the tables in the temple and threw the money-changers out.” Fifteen years later, in 2002, Bono told Falsani, “By the way, I don’t set myself up to be any kind of Christian. I can’t live up to that. It’s something I aspire to, but I don’t feel comfortable with that badge.”

Such statements by Mumford and Bono, and the legions of nones like them, are not disavowals of faith or beliefs. Instead, they are the rejection of a label related to faith or belief. In years past, an unchurched individual might still claim to be Baptist or Catholic; now there is great cultural freedom to drop the label entirely. The speed at which this has happened supports an old thesis of church historian Martin Marty, who wrote a book half a century ago on varieties of unbelief and who has long thought that religious cohesion “has long been overstated.”

This follows how John Green, a senior research adviser at Pew, breaks the religiously unaffiliated Americans into three groups:

  • Those who were raised totally outside of organized religion
  • Those who became unhappy with their religion and left
  • Those who never really engaged with religion in the first place, even though they were raised in a religious household
  • Green says, “In the past, we would describe those people as nominally affiliated. They might say, ‘I am Catholic; I am a Baptist,’ but they never went [to services]. Now, they feel a lot more comfortable just saying, ‘You know, I am really nothing.’”

    No Longer Seekers

    But it’s more than simply being nothing. Perhaps one of the more disconcerting marks of typical nones is that they are very content with holding their “nothing in particular” stance toward religion. Among those who say they believe in “nothing in particular,” 88 percent are not even looking for a specific faith or religion.

    Think of their stance like this:

    Spirituality? “Yes.”

    God? “Probably.”

    A specific religion? “Not for me.”

    But at least seeking? “No, not really. Not a priority.”

    The detrimental effect for a church or denomination could not be more complete. It is akin to having a world full of people being open and even interested in coffee, but purposefully driving past Starbucks with complete disinterest.

    The significance of this cannot be overstated. For the last few decades, the key word in most conversations about evangelism and church growth has been the word seeker. As in “seeker churches,” being “seeker-targeted” in strategy, and in talk about reaching “seekers,” or what a “seeker” may think about our service. And let’s not forget the widespread embrace of being “seeker-driven” and “seeker-sensitive.”

    All things “seeker” came onto the scene during the late seventies and were vibrant until the mid-nineties. It is now irrelevant at best and terribly misleading at worst. The term seeker was used to refer in a general way to the unchurched who were turned off to church but open to both spirituality and religion. Think back to the flood of baby boomers who wanted to find a church for their kids but felt freedom from the religious and denominational moorings of their youth. They weren’t rejecting religion per se; they just felt the freedom to explore other traditions. For example, consider the number of Catholics who explored nondenominational, evangelical megachurches. These were people who were truly seeking, open to exploring the Christian faith for their life, and often in active search mode for a religious faith, and even home, in order to plant themselves. They had rejected the religion of their upbringing (often Catholicism), not religion itself.

    As the ARIS report concludes, “The challenge to Christianity . . . does not come from other religions but from a rejection of all forms of organized religion.” Barry Kosmin, co-researcher for the survey, adds, “They’re not thinking about religion and rejecting it; they’re not thinking about it at all.” Or as the research of the Pew Forum on Religion and Public Life found, “The unaffiliated say they are not looking for a religion that would be right for them.”

    So much for seeking.

    Jonathan Rauch, in an article for the Atlantic Monthly, coined a term to describe his own spiritual condition. After a couple of glasses of Merlot, someone asked him about his religion. He was about to say “atheist” when it dawned on him that wasn’t quite accurate. “I used to call myself an atheist,” he finally responded, “and I still don’t believe in God, but the larger truth is that it has been years since I really cared one way or another. I’m”—and this was when it hit him—“an . . . apatheist!” Rauch went on to describe his state as a “disinclination to care all that much about one’s own religion, and an even stronger disinclination to care about other people’s.”

    He’s not alone. According to the 2011 Baylor University Religion Survey, 44 percent said they spend no time seeking “eternal wisdom.” And in a study by LifeWay Research, 46 percent said they never wonder whether they will go to heaven. So when it comes to matters related to God, religion, or even atheism, millions simply shrug their shoulders and say, “So what?”

    A Land of Swedes

    In his book Society Without God, sociologist Phil Zuckerman chronicles his fourteen months investigating Danes’ and Swedes’ feelings about religion. His conclusion? Religion “wasn’t really so much a private, personal issue, but rather, a non-issue.” His interviewees just didn’t care about it. As one replied, “I really have never thought about that. . . . It’s been fun to get these kinds of questions that I never, never think about.” It brings to mind how sociologist Peter Berger once quipped, “If India is the most religious country on our planet, and Sweden is the least religious, America is a land of Indians ruled by Swedes.” What we must now realize is that we are increasingly becoming simply a land of Swedes.

    But that does not mean they do not have an “unofficial” dogma. Because they do.

    Questions for Discussion and Reflection

  • Nearly three-quarters of nones (72 percent) seldom or never attend a religious service. This means you cannot continue investing only in those who are already in your seats. Has the outreach strategy of your church changed, or how does it need to change, to reach those 72 percent of nones?
  • One of the biggest complaints nones have against organized religion is that it is too concerned with money and power. How can your church work to disprove their perception? Are you actively doing so already?
  • One of the most important things to understand about nones is that most of them are not atheists. Their defining characteristic is not the rejection of God but the rejection of a specific religion. They are spiritual but not religious. What does that mean for how they interpret the world and for how they view religion?
  • A glaring statistic that points to a specific change in missional strategy is that 88 percent of those who believe in “nothing in particular” are not actively looking for a specific faith or religion. Translation: they are not seekers. Much of our outreach strategy since the 1970s has been based on a seeker-driven America. How does your church’s outreach strategy need to change based on the fact that those you are called to reach are not even looking for you?
  • One of the most thought-provoking quotes from the ARIS study is from Barry Kosmin. He says, “They’re [the nones] not thinking about religion and rejecting it; they’re not thinking about it at all.” Does that correspond with your perception of the unchurched?
  • As noted earlier, when it comes to matters related to God or religion, millions simply shrug their shoulders and say, “So what?” How does that change how you interact with the unchurched in your community?
  • One thing nones reject is the thought of being labeled or being marked with any specific brand. Why do you think that is?
  • Were you surprised by the description of a typical none at the beginning of the chapter?
  • ↑ Back to top

    ↑