Appendix A: Judged
Appendix A
Judged
The following is the transcription of a talk titled “Judgmentalism” that was delivered at Mecklenburg Community Church in 2012. It was the first installment of a series simply titled “Judged.” The intent was to address the perception among the nones that Christians are judgmental as well as the actual experiences some of them have had of being judged. The lead-in to the talk itself was a video produced by Worship House Media, also titled “Judged,” which can be viewed at www.worshiphousemedia.com/mini-movies/27317/Judged.
Introduction
Rejected.
Crushed.
Shunned.
Hurt.
Cast out.
Unloved.
Because of the way they look, the things they’ve done, the questions they’ve asked, the mistakes they’ve made.
By the very people they hoped would help them, accept them, get them back on their feet. People who call themselves Christians.
And it made them turn away, turn off, and tune out.
If that’s church, if that’s Christianity, you can count them out.
Ever felt that way? I’ll bet you have.
Judgmentalism
David Kinnaman and Gabe Lyons did a major study on people who had turned away from the Christian faith in a book called UnChristian. Biggest reason? When people who had given up on church and faith thought of Christians, all that came to mind was a bunch of people who were judgmental.
Prideful, acting morally superior, and from that, finding fault with everybody else.
People who lacked compassion, lacked understanding, and lacked grace toward other people’s screw-ups.
People who seemed more interested in condemning others than helping people.
So for instance, a single mother comes to a church looking for community and support, wanting to find God. She’s not proud she got pregnant. It wasn’t her plan A for doing life. But it happened, and she’s alone. So she turns to God’s people, hoping for a second chance. What do you think she’ll hear?
“You shouldn’t be a single mother. Shame on you.”
Or other examples:
You shouldn’t be an addict.
You shouldn’t be divorced.
You shouldn’t drink.
You shouldn’t be living together.
You shouldn’t be attracted to people of the same sex.
You shouldn’t have questions.
Bad, terrible, horrible you. You have no business being here among us “good” people.
Philip Yancey tells a story about a friend of his who works with the down-and-out in Chicago. A prostitute came to him in about as bad shape as you can be. She was homeless, her health was failing, and she wasn’t able to buy food for her two-year-old daughter. In fact, with tears streaming down her face, she confessed that she had been renting out her daughter to men in order to support her drug habit.
Yancey’s friend could hardly bear to hear the details. He sat in silence, not even knowing what to say. But in the end, he asked her if she had ever thought of going to a church for help. And he said he will never forget the look of pure astonishment that crossed her face.
“Church!” she said. “Why would I ever go there? They’d just make me feel even worse than I already do!”
And when she and others like her are asked why they feel that way, why they think that would be the reception, the answer is always the same: Because it happened to me.
Experience. Firsthand knowledge. Is that your story? Do people who need help feel from past experience that if they ever fell flat on their face, shipwrecked their life, screwed things up so royally that they couldn’t see daylight, that the last place they’d go running to would be God’s people?
Well, even if you don’t have that in your past—you know they would be right. A lot of churches, and a lot of Christians, are everything they fear and hate.
When it comes to their desire for grace,
that incredible commodity that sees us for who we really are, not just for our mistakes and failures and flaws,
that dispenser of forgiveness,
that spirit that restores those who have fallen,
that one who is so amazing that we sing songs called “Amazing Grace,”
that powerful force unleashed on this planet by Jesus himself,
. . . often the last place it’s found is with Jesus’s people.
So what happened? It’s simple. We’ve stopped being like Jesus—because he went out of his way to tell those who followed him not to judge!
Did you know that? Listen to his words from the most famous talk he ever gave—what’s called the Sermon on the Mount:
Do not judge, or you too will be judged. For in the same way you judge others, you will be judged, and with the measure you use, it will be measured to you.
Why do you look at the speck of sawdust in your brother’s eye and pay no attention to the plank in your own eye? How can you say to your brother, “Let me take the speck out of your eye,” when all the time there is a plank in your own eye? You hypocrite, first take the plank out of your own eye, and then you will see clearly to remove the speck from your brother’s eye. (Matt. 7:1–5)
That’s quite clear, isn’t it? Jesus said, “Do not judge.” Period. That’s God’s job, not ours.
Now, it’s very important to understand what Jesus means by judging others. It doesn’t mean we can never make a value judgment. Some things are wrong; some things are right.
This isn’t about never taking a stand. It isn’t about being a moral wimp. Some people think acceptance means mindless affirmation. Validating everything—every choice, every lifestyle. That’s stupid.
If someone came up to me and said, “I believe that the best way for you to optimize the performance of your laptop is to,
remove your antivirus protection,
take down your firewall,
open up every email attachment from people and companies you do not know,
download as much free software as you can from sites you have never heard of,
and respond to that long-lost Nigerian uncle who just left you ten million dollars and all he needs from you is your bank account number and password
I would say, “That is the stupidest thing I’ve ever heard.” Is that being judgmental? Of course not.
It’s not about refusing to believe something, hold to something, or stand for something.
It’s not about refusing to say you feel something is right or wrong, good or bad.
It’s not about giving up thinking, or discernment, or wisdom.
It’s not about never warning someone.
If someone I care about is living in a way that is destroying his or her life and I don’t say anything to him or her, I don’t love that person very much. If someone can’t see where he or she is walking and is about to step off a cliff, it’s not judgmental to say, “Stop!”
It’s not judgmental to tell someone reaching for a bottle of Visine for dry eyes that it is actually a bottle of carbolic acid. That’s not being judgmental; that’s caring enough for someone to tell him or her the truth.
So what is judgmentalism? Judgmentalism is the practice of personal condemnation. John Stott puts it this way: the judgmental person Jesus is talking about is someone who “is a fault-finder who is negative and destructive towards other people and enjoys actively seeking out their failings. He puts the worst possible construction of their motives, pours cold water on their [dreams], and is ungenerous toward their mistakes.”
A judgmental person makes sweeping assessments of other people. A judgmental person assigns them the worst possible motives without any real knowledge of what’s going on in their life or their context or their situation. A judgmental person has a pounce-and-denounce kind of demeanor.
If you are judgmental, you make yourself out to be God and take on God’s role as Judge. That’s why Jesus said that if you judge others, you will be judged, because the heart of a judgmental attitude is to assume yourself to be so morally superior that you can take over God’s role in someone else’s life.
Jesus says, “Fine—if you do that, then expect to be judged by those standards.” God will judge you on the basis of whether you measure up to the standard required for judging—which is being God yourself.
Anybody want to go through that test? I don’t, because I’m not God, and if I get judged like I am, it’s going to be epic fail time. Instead, I need to see myself the way I am:
a fellow screw-up
a fellow struggler
a fellow sinner
Look at how this is talked about in the New Testament book of Romans:
You may be saying, “What terrible people . . . !” But wait a minute! You are just as bad. When you say they are wicked and should be punished, you are [condemning] yourselves, for you do these very same things. . . . Don’t you realize how patient [God] is being with you? . . . Can’t you see that he has been waiting all this time without punishing you, to give you time to turn from your sin? (Rom. 2:1, 4 TLB)
So why do we do it? Well, one reason is that we are quick to take offense. Really, it’s like we’ve got a chip on our shoulder. We are so hypersensitive to other people and what they may do against us, or we disagree with or don’t like what they are doing.
You know, I’m going to be very candid in this series and share a lot of stories with you. And I remember one from a few years back.
Those of you who know my wife, Susan, know she is one of the kindest, sweetest, gentlest people on this planet. Well, there was a woman who got angry with her and wrote her a terrible note as to why she was angry. Here was her reason: “When you stopped me in the hall today and asked me how I was doing and said you had been praying for me and that you cared about me and you hugged me, well, you didn’t hug me long enough.”
“You didn’t hug me long enough”? I thought, Wow. What is up with that kind of judgmental spirit?
Another reason we rush to judgment with people? Let me tell you another story.
Back when I was in seminary, I was pastor of a little county-seat church outside of town. The church was very small, and the staff was basically—well, me.
One day a woman called up and asked for some help from the church because she was sick and had a lot of bills. So I went over to visit her and brought another woman from the church with me, to help me assess the situation.
When we showed up at the house, I remember thinking that this woman’s hair looked perfect. It was done up so fancy that it looked like she had just come from what in those days we called the beauty parlor. It looked really good—like expensive good.
Then as we walked into the house with her there was a door open to her room, and there on a shelf were some really, really nice-looking wigs. Again, expensive-looking wigs.
After talking for a bit, we left, and I said to the woman who had come with me, “Those were some nice wigs.”
She said, “Really nice wigs. Those were expensive.”
I instantly thought Man, she doesn’t need any help. If she can afford to spend money on those wigs, then she’s just looking for a handout and trying to hit on the church.
Well, I later found out that the woman had cancer and that part of her treatment involved chemotherapy. She had lost all of her hair, and a loving friend had purchased the wigs for her so she wouldn’t have to go around bald.
Sadly, that woman had a pastor who was a jerk because of a rush to judgment.
Why We Judge (Don’t Be a Hypocrite)
Do you know what’s the biggest reason that we judge others? Because it makes us feel better about ourselves. We act morally superior because we like feeling morally superior. That’s why we minimize our own faults and failures and exaggerate somebody else’s. It makes us feel better about ourselves. It’s how we build ourselves up.
When we highlight the way somebody else is screwing up and condemn them, we feel better about our own screwups. Then we can act like we don’t have any.
There’s a word for that: hypocrisy. The word hypocrite literally means “mask wearer.” It’s a Greek term that comes from Greek theater. Greek actors held up a mask and spoke from behind it. The mask was the hypocrite.
So religious hypocrites are people who deliberately set out to deceive other people about who they are. They live life behind a mask. Their spirituality is theater—make-believe, a role they’re playing for others. And the heart of the act is elevating themselves as if they are righteous, and tearing other people down as if they are the bad guys.
But when the mask falls and we see who these hypocrites really are, what do we find out? They are doing the very same things they condemn other people for doing:
the guy who condemned homosexuality is hooking up with guys,
the person who condemned porn is addicted to porn,
the person who said “don’t sleep around” is sleeping around.
That’s why Jesus hates hypocrisy so much. Take another look:
Why do you look at the speck of sawdust in your brother’s eye and pay no attention to the plank in your own eye? How can you say to your brother, “Let me take the speck out of your eye,” when all the time there is a plank in your own eye? You hypocrite, first take the plank out of your own eye. (Matt. 7:3–5)
All Sinners
I mentioned Philip Yancey earlier. In his book What’s So Amazing About Grace, he makes a telling observation. He notes that with Jesus, there were only two categories of people: (1) sinners who admit it, and (2) sinners who deny it. Sinners who admit it receive his grace, compassion, and forgiveness. Sinners who don’t get the very judgment they are dealing out on others. Or as many have observed, Jesus came to comfort the afflicted and afflict the comfortable.
So get this one straight: the Christian life isn’t about pretending you have it all together when you don’t.
It reminds me of something Will Campbell wrote. Known for his disarmingly earthy approach to spirituality and life, he was asked this question: “In ten words or less, what’s the Christian message? . . . Let me have it. Ten words.”
He said, “We’re all bastards but God loves us anyway.” And he was right.
If Christianity is about anything, it’s about serious imperfection that desperately needs forgiveness and grace. It’s not having our act together—it’s admitting that we don’t! Then it’s about coming to Christ for a relationship built on grace and forgiveness, and then becoming who we were meant to be.
So let me set something straight right here and now that you may have never heard before: this church is led by a sinner. Come spend a day with me and I guarantee I will disappoint you. I love my wife, but you will see how I fail daily in being the husband I’m supposed to be. I love my four children, but you will witness the countless times I am insensitive and impatient.
And those are just the easy ones to admit. I love God and urge others to do the same, but if you want to see someone who fails to consistently live in light of what he knows about how he ought to live, I’m your man.
But the truth runs even deeper. As a Christ follower, I remain a sinner who struggles with sin and often loses.
But all Christians do.
I remember reading something about the life of Alexander Whyte, a Christian leader in nineteenth-century Scotland. He was once approached by a woman who showered praise on him and his life. You know what he said to her? “Madam, if you knew the man I really was, you would spit in my face.”
But does that mean that all Christians are counterfeits? Or that the Christian life and faith are meaningless? No!
I screw up a thousand times a day, but I’m more like Jesus now than I was five years ago in so many areas of my life. And the life I would be living apart from Christ is almost unthinkable.
We’ve all got the same sickness, and we’re all in the same hospital for treatment. Some are further along the path of recovery than others, and some are better at following the prescribed treatment than others. But we all have the same disease. We’re all being treated for sin-sickness. We’re all in some kind of recovery.
So whatever baggage you brought with you today, you’re not alone. And we do not condemn you.
You are no different than any of the rest of us struggling with areas of temptation and desire. We’ve all failed in those areas. But Christ is working on all of us.
Mecklenburg Community Church is nothing but a colossal collection of moral foul-ups. Really—you’re in some bad company here. We have sins of pride, greed, pornography, self-righteousness, lying, stealing, adultery, insensitivity to others. But through the power of Christ, there is hope for all of us.
But here’s what else you need to know: we want to expose these areas in our life, not deny them or rationalize them away. Not in a way that condemns, but in a way that transforms. We want to discover them, go to God for forgiveness, and become increasingly changed people.
The Church
Someone sent me something about how one church decided to make this as clear as possible. Here’s what they have in their program each week:
We extend a special welcome to those who are single, married, divorced . . . filthy rich, dirt poor, no habla ingles. . . .
You’re welcome here if you’re just browsing, just woke up, or just got out of jail.
We welcome soccer moms, NASCAR dads, starving artists, tree-huggers, latte-sippers, vegetarians, junk-food eaters.
We welcome those who are in recovery or still addicted.
We welcome you if you’re having problems or you’re down in the dumps of if you don’t like “organized religion.” . . .
If you blew all your offering money partying, you’re welcome here.
We welcome those who are inked, pierced, or both.
We offer a special welcome to those who could use a prayer right now, had religion shoved down your throat as a kid or got lost in traffic and wound up here by mistake.
We welcome . . . seekers and doubters.
[We welcome] you!
You need to know that kind of grace is what marks this place. I can’t speak for every church, but I can speak for this one. And you need it. I need it.
The world tells us to play a big game of hide-and-seek. Everybody hide, because if you come out and are found, you will be rejected. Condemned. So hiding as long as you can is how you play the game.
Jesus wants the church to be the place where a huge, collective, “olly olly oxen free” is shouted at the top of our lungs. It’s time to be found. It’s safe to be found, because it’s time to come home and find acceptance, forgiveness, truth, and grace.
Don’t you want that? Well, around here, we do. It has marked us from day one. In fact, let me tell you a story that I got permission to tell.
A young woman and her roommate attended college here in Charlotte. These girls were the epitome of party girls, and one of them got pregnant.
It rocked their world; they didn’t know what to do. So they talked about it and said, “Why don’t we try going to a church?” So they randomly picked a church near campus (the University of North Carolina at Charlotte).
They attended that church for a few weeks. About the third week, the story finally came out that one of the girls was pregnant. Shortly after, they received a visit from the pastor, who told them, “You’re not welcome here. You’re not our type.”
The two young women walked away heartbroken. They were left thinking that God was not the answer, and God’s people clearly were not the answer.
A couple of weeks later they got a flyer in the mail about a new church that was starting up called Mecklenburg Community Church. The flyer invited them to its very first service on October 4, 1992.
They decided to give it one last shot, and they came to Meck that first service we ever held—back when we met in the Hilton hotel. And within six weeks both of them had given their lives to Christ, and I baptized those two women.
Later, the girl who had been pregnant moved away, but the other one stayed on. Later she was introduced to a wonderful, godly man, a friend of mine. And I had the pleasure of officiating at their wedding. Eventually I had the privilege to dedicate her three children and then later had the joy of baptizing each of them.
This young woman ended up joining our staff and becoming one of our senior leaders. She has been with me the whole time—this entire twenty-year run. And I can’t imagine what my life would have been like without her. She has babysat my children, and I love her as a daughter.
She was almost lost—all because of judgmentalism. She was almost lost because of everything Jesus is not about.
So why do I tell you all that? Because we are imperfect. There’s all kinds of stuff around here that people are dealing with. Beginning with their pastor.
But we’re going to love each other—and we do love each other. There is radical grace and acceptance here. You can come here with your junk and with your questions and explore what God has for your life.
You will not be condemned. You will be challenged, but you will be accepted and loved.
And who knows, maybe one day I’ll have the privilege of baptizing you, or even your children. How cool would that be?
Okay, let’s stand for a closing prayer.
