7 God's Hiddenness, Absence and Doubt
ANDREW ROOT
few days after the semester was over I received a letter in illy campus mailbox. It was addressed to the youth ministry faculty at the large seminary where I teach, and was sent by four of our top students. While appreciative of what they had learned together the last academic year, they were worried that they had not received enough practical "how to" material. I'm sure some of their anxiety was warranted; they would soon be leaving to take jobs in churches where fundraising, recruiting, planning and networking would be very important, so they were right to ask for some help in these areas. However, their letter reminded me how deeply immersed the practice and study of youth ministry are in pragmatic utilitarianism-and therefore why this nascent theological turn Kenda and I are advocating comes up against resistance.
Too often it is assumed that youth ministry is primarily about doing. Youth ministers do things, like visit school campuses, go on trips, plan barbecues, lead Bible studies and play basketball. But of course youth ministry is much deeper than this crust of constant activity. If youth ministry is ministry, it is so because it has joined God's own Ministry in the world. This means that all ministry (youth ministry or otherwise) is only ministry when it adheres to God's continued activity (of revelation, reconciliation and redemption) in the world; for our doing to be faithful, in other words, it must follow God's own doing. And this means that youth ministry is not ulti mately about pragmatic utilitarianism but about theological hermeneutics; it's not about doing so much as discerning: discerning God's will for individuals, communities and creation. So to do theology-to encounter God in the crisis of reality, as we discussed in the last chapter-and to practice faithful youth ministry-to discern God's activity in our own context and then join it-we need eyes to see the activity of God.
Such theological discernment is called for in both the creation and crisis of ministry. As youth workers organize the ministry they are to lead, they must seek to discern God's desire for the ministry, asking, What is God doing in this local context with these people and how might God use us? In addition, youth workers must discern God's desire in the crisis of ministry, in those moments where they seek for God in the crisis of reality: when an adult leader informs you that she is thinking of leaving her husband and asks for your advice, for example, or when a senior with a scholarship to a topflight university informs you that God has told him that he should move to L.A., live on the beach and become an actor instead.
This is all, of course, quite easy to say-that youth ministry is about discerning God's continued action in the world-but how do we do this in the midst of the complications of our contexts, our personalities and God's transcendent nature? If we are going to take this theological turn in youth ministry, a theological turn that is committed to the continued activity of God's Ministry, then we must begin to imagine how we actually go about discerning God's action with and for young people.
DOES JESUS STILL DO STUFF?
To see theology as reflection on the continued Ministry of God in the world is to confess that God, through the resurrected Christ, is still moving and acting in our world. This is what makes our experience and our wrestling with the crisis of reality so essential. Theologian Jurgen Moltmann and practical theologians Ray Anderson and Richard Osmer call this commitment to the continued Ministry of God through Christ Christopraxis.' The word refers to the praxis of Christ's Ministry, which was to serve the Father on behalf of the world. According to these theologians, Christ remains in the world (now as resurrected Lord who is to come), continuing the praxis of his Ministry, which is the restoration of relationship between God and humanity and between humanity and humanity in and through his own humanity. It therefore becomes the church's job, through empowerment of the Spirit, to seek out and then join in Christopraxis-Christ's continued Ministry in the world.
In essence, discerning Christopraxis is discerning God's will. What is God's will for our ministry? we ask. What is God's will for my future? What is God's will in this situation? Such questions are the heart of ministry and yet are difficult to answer. We need help to learn this process of discernment, to learn how we as youth workers might think our way into discerning Christopraxis (God's will) in our ministry context and in the lives of the young people with whom we minister.
THE HERMENEUTICAL SITUATION
The existential line of tragedy and death. Any hermeneutic that is going to be helpful in discerning God's action and our call to join it must be anchored in reality: the reality of our ontological state, cemented in Sein and Zeit (being and time), which finds its expression in tragedy.2 In other words, our hermeneutic must see things as they are ("calling a thing what it is," to quote Luther). And the truth, as we examined in the last chapter, is that we are all born and then moved forward by history to our death; there is no stopping the process. Along the way we will of course be confronted by paradoxes of pain and joy, violence and gentleness, evolution and atrophy, love and hate, but eventually all paradoxes will give way to the flow of history; death is our destiny. This fact makes all of life fundamentally tragic.
It is in this tragic flow of history that we need to discern God's action, that we contend that God moves, making one path, decision, action preferable to another. Therefore, all of its are forced into being interpreters of God's action, of God's will for our lives and action in history. If we are asking, Where is Christopraxis? we must also ask, Where is the interpreter?3 And what is his or her reality?
We start, then, with the assertion that the interpreter is embedded within an existential line of tragedy and death. While this may sound morbid and depressing, it is not completely fatalistic. It's true that this existential reality, while not reductionistic, does point most vividly (and frighteningly) to the judgment of God, which is non-being, or death. But the reality of being and time is still God's creation, even though it's infected with sin and perversion; it is tragic and dangerous but it is not Godforsaken, for in this reality the incarnate Christ dwells. And in the cross of Christ we see that God, in God's own being, suffers this existential reality of tragedy and death; it's significant that the cross appears on this line of history. The interpreter lives and moves in this reality of tragedy and death and must recognize his or her shared solidarity in this state with all of humanity.
Examining the existential. RudolfBultinann, the early-twentieth-century German Lutheran theologian and Bible scholar, is most well known for his project of demythologization, which stemmed from his desire for people to be confronted anew by the Word of God. Like many youth workers, Bultmann was less concerned with what happened back in the periods when the Bible was written, calling those times "mythological." Rather, his concern was with how people encountered the living Word of God now, in the contemporary moment.
Figure 6.1. The cross, the interpreter and existential reality
To support this position Bultmaiiii leans heavily on existential philosophy. Following Heidegger and others he states, "To understand history is possible only for one who does not stand over against it as a neutral, nonparticipating spectator, but [one who] stands in history and shares in responsibility for it. We speak of this encounter with history that grows out of one's own historicity as the existential encounter. The historian participates in it with his whole existence."4
The significance of Bultmann's position is that the interpreter never stands outside of this historical existence but rather must give him- or herself over completely to it. To escape wooden historical pontifications, then, we must be willing to be confronted anew by the living Christ in the present moment, to see anew the past, present and future in connection to him. As Bultmann says, "Indeed, the questioning itself grows out of the historical situation, out of the claim of the now, out of the problem that is given in the now. For this reason, historical research is never closed, but rather must always be carried further."5
Bultmann's existentialism points to Christopraxis because it assumes that Jesus' life is not just a past event to be exegeted. Rather, what Bultmann tells us is that any hermeneutic that looks to discover the reality of Christopraxis must concern itself with the present historical moment. The reality of the living Christ, the search for Christopraxis, the decision in ministry-these always confront its in the now, the now of our shared existence. So the interpreter-the youth worker, the Christian-can never make any decisions outside the reality of his or her personal and shared existence.
This historically bound reality should color all our interpretations and actions with compassion, since it means there is no elite status: none are outside of history seeing it "clearly," free from its tragic foundations. We all are making our way through history, making sense of the past and peering hazily into the future. What I hope youth workers can learn even more than theological erudition or practical skills is the ability to feel their way into our shared historical reality, into the crisis, to see the mutuality of our suffering.
To help others grasp this, I often use films in classes and presentations, asking people to enter the characters' stories, to recognize how multiple forces are impacting them and to feel the tragic nature of our historical reality-how death appears in rejection, fear, addiction, loneliness. For instance, I've both written about and showed clips numerous times from the movie Good Will Hunting. The film's scenes help people see that Will (played by Matt Damon) is the way he is because of the tragic situation of being an orphan and being let down by a number of people. I then help the group I'm with to look for God's presence and absence next to the depth of Will's existence. An exercise like this keeps people from avoiding the tragic reality of existence.
The interpreter has only reality to live in, and if we are honest, we have to admit that reality is tragic, that history has no answers for its and that we are in need of a future hope. Eschatology, a sense that history is moving somewhere, to sonic end, therefore holds great significance for Bultmann. Yet what Bultmanll fails to see is that the eschaton is not only on the horizon of time but is already breaking in from the future. This breaking in is what makes Christopraxis possible at all.
The eschatological line of hope and promise. The search for Christo praxis can never be found outside time and reality, outside the particularity of each new challenge, choice and action. But this cannot be the whole picture; the hermeneutical situation cannot be only existential. There must also be a christological scaffolding to any truly theologically orientated hermeneutic. In the existential line of tragedy and death we see Christ's connection to us. This reality of tragedy and pain, being in time, is taken tip fully by God in the incarnate humanity of God-taken tip but not triumphed over. It is taken tip and suffered. On the cross, fatalism, tragedy and death are victorious. But in the resurrection they are halted and a new reality is inaugurated. In the resurrected humanity of Jesus, the kingdom of God has broken into our existential reality; the eschaton has shown its colors in the empty tomb of Jesus, and they are more beautiful than we could have dreamed. Christopraxis is the in-breaking of the kingdom of God in history, the breaking in of eschatological hope.
In the existential line of tragedy and death, history moves from creation forward, from the past through the present and to some completion, an unknown future that is unforeseeable from the existential line itself (see the gap in figure 6.2 between the existential line and final/complete parousia). The eschatological line, however, moves from the future to the present situation and points back to its genesis in the life and resurrection of Christ.6 History will have its finale in the return of Christ, but even before this culmination the work of Christ is breaking into history.
The interpreter therefore must stand fully embedded in the existential line, but in faith and assurance give heed to the eschatological line. In other words, the interpreter stands in the reality of tragedy but has faith that history has a telos, that in each new challenge, choice and action, God is breaking in. And the hermeneutical situation, while fully existential and bound in history, stands at the same time within the breaking forth of the kingdom of God, which promises the final culmination of history in the hoped-for eschaton. It must stand within both an existential line and an eschatological one, balancing the seen reality of history with the unseen reality of hope. To choose one over the other is to give way to either hopeless fatalism or pious mysticism.
Moments before Dietrich Bonhoeffer was hanged in the concentration camp at Flossenbiirg, he reportedly said, "This is the end, for inc the beginning of life." These final words of his (and his life) demonstrate how to face the darkest realities and yet, in so doing, to utter "Nevertheless, the tomb is empty." A hermeneutic of Christopraxis must likewise see human history within God's history, never giving one up for the other and understanding that both are linked in the person of Jesus Christ. Theologian Jurgen Moltmann helps its understand how this is possible.
Figure 6.2. Existential reality and eschatological hope
The resurrection. The passion of Christ has initiated a new reality, binding the history of humanity with the history of God. Indeed, the resurrection of Christ has broken into history as a new possibility, asserting the claim that now in connection to the resurrected Christ there is new possibility for all humanity; now, though we cannot avoid history and must face tragedy and death, there is reconciliation of God with all humanity through the passion of Christ. Moltmann explains, "The resurrection of Christ does not mean a possibility within the world and its history, but a new possibility altogether for the world, for existence and for history."7 It is an eschatological event that has substantiated itself within history but has also transcended and transformed history, allowing the eschaton to dawn within history.' And this gives its hope-a true hope, because it is a hope that is outside of history but actualized within it.
And as Moltmann states, "The real question [is]: What can I hope for? It is only a future which we are permitted to hope for that gives any meaning to life in history and to all historical experience and action."9 For this reason the resurrection becomes essential to our hermeneutic, for it is the breaking in of God into history, through which the promise of new creation and new life within a future history is given. Just as meaning cannot be divorced from the existential locus of the individual and coimuwnity, the eschatological, that for which we hope, is necessary for a meaningful hermeneutic.
So, in our discerning of God's action, in our discerning of how we should act, hope itself confronts its with meaning. This means the interpreter must not only confront history, but also hope; he or she must face not only the historical reality of the present situation, but also the present eschatological reality of hope. Moltmann explains it this way: "We cannot then merely embark on a historical examination of the past that once was, nor yet merely provide an existentialist interpretation of present claims, but we must inquire into what is open, unfinished, unsettled and outstanding, and consequently into the future announced by this event [of resurrection]."10 Hence, the interpreter, the youth worker, is to stand within history, understanding its impact and force, but never allowing it to pin him or her down, to force him or her into submission. Rather, the youth worker is to feel the full weight of history, never turning from its tragedy, and yet proclaim the inbreaking of the resurrection, stating boldly and confidently, "Nevertheless ... God is before its, the tomb it is empty!"
As the interpreter discerns Christopraxis, he or she must feel the full weight of the existential situation, but in feeling it must point forward to a future that is on its way. The impact of history cannot be avoided, but in its midst the eschaton places another demand upon the interpreter: God is breaking forth, and the kingdom is dawning." The interpreter must see reality, see history, with the vision of the hope of resurrection, through the lens of the kingdom of God. The interpreter is accountable not just to empathy but also to the promise, not just to the seen reality but also to what is unseen, not just to sympathy in tragedy but also to obedience to the command of God. Without this eschatological understanding, history becomes an uiidefeatable monster, and emancipation and liberation are impossible. But in balancing these two realities, our eyes are opened to see suffering and evil and refuse to stand for it. For we see another reality that meets us from the future, where all are free from death and dehumanization in the arms of the resurrected Christ, in the kingdom of God. Thus, the interpreter is called to confront the present existential reality with the hope of eschatological reality.
Many years ago a dear colleague of mine lost his two-year-old son right before Christmas. And his son had died from an allergic reaction to medicine that he had given him. Drowning in grief and searching for answers, my friend approached his car one night to find a note under the windshield. The note read, "God needed a Christmas present so He took your boy home." This is a clear example of poor ministerial action. The individual who left the note clearly could not face the existential line and therefore defaulted to a kind of eschatological perspective that was disconnected from reality (and therefore could not really be called eschatological).
On the other hand, I know of a youth pastor who stood at the gravesite of a fourteen-year-old girl who killed herself after her boyfriend broke tip with her. The pastor, looking at her family and friends, said, "We don't know why Amanda did this, but we can be assured that she was hurting and that we too are hurting, hurting from her loss, hurting for so many reasons. Hurting is part of living. And we have a God who hurts, but a God who also promises us that our pains will not destroy its. They may kill its, but they will not destroy its. For we can be assured that no matter how dark things became for Amanda, there is no darkness, no distance that the light of the empty tomb does not reach." This youth pastor wrote his sermon aware of the hermeneutical situation, and conscious of the need to live between the existential line of tragedy and death and the eschatological line of hope.
THE HERMENEUTICAL METHOD
We have laid out the hermeneutical situation: both the history of humanity and the history of God confront the interpreter, and the interpreter must not give up one for the other. All discernment of Christopraxis must happen within this hermeneutical situation; it's the playing field on which we interpret ministerial action, the situadedness of the youth worker. But now we need some kind of henneneutical method, some kind of henneneutical operation. We've acknowledged where we stand (in between tragedy/death and hope), but how do we move in this place, where there are a multitude of possible actions? It is one thing to know that God has acted in such a world, but quite another to claim that your action is the will of God.
Our method must be fully planted within the soil of the reality but must provide direction through a bracketing of possibility and impossibility in discerning God's will and action. This starts with the assertion that God has given Godself both to the social/communal life of humanity and to the nonnative assertions of the Scriptures; both express God's history with humanity as covenant partner. This understanding, in turn, creates brackets for our action, helping its see a zone of possible Christopraxis. An action or position that falls outside of these brackets is an impossibility for God's will. But those actions or positions found within them can confidently (and yet with a wealth of humility) be asserted as the will of God.
You might feel that, in doing this, we are in some ways boxing in God, bracketing what is possible and what is not. I actually think, though, that this method is an open system that allows for God's complete freedom. It only claims what God asserts of Godself: that in the incarnation God has given Godself fully to humanity, and that in God's history with humanity God will never contradict God's own nature found in the history of God's self-revelation.
The bracket of social/communal experience. The first bracket confronting its in the hermeneutical situation that we will use in forming our hermeneutical method is the bracket of social/communal experience. As we move through history, denial or avoidance of relationship is impossible.'2 Relationship is fundamentally embedded within our humanity. And throughout God's covenant history with humanity, God has continued to call its to the actuality of our neighbor. Love of God and love for neighbor may be different in kind but are nevertheless inseparable.
As figure 6.3 shows, this bracket is grounded within the interpreter, and originates from the existential line of tragedy and death. The other that meets us (as individual or group) shares in a history of tragedy. But the other also, as we have mentioned above, shares in the coming of God, in the universal significance of the resurrection of Christ. Therefore, there is u11deniable solidarity between the other and the interpreter; they exist together in the existential line.
Figure 6.3. The first bracket in the hermeneutical situation
In the United States there are a handful of groups that travel around the country asserting that "God hates fags." Loudly shouting their messages outside of churches, funerals or other gatherings where they sense homosexuality is supported, and armed with biblical texts, they feel they are not only justified but actually obeying the will of God in their actions. But in so doing they deny any common humanity, and reject the fact that through the humanity of Christ all humanity is beloved and accountable to and for each other.
There is an undeniable responsibility for the other we meet, for the eschatological line penetrates through them by the power of the human God found in the resurrected Christ. This penetration assures us that the other, the neighbor, whether far from or near to us, whether similar or strange to its, confronts us with the very presence of God.
For the other, for our neighbor. In the final days of World War II, a truck headed deep into the Bavarian forest, loaded with prisoners on their way to the concentration camp at Flossenburg. In one corner sat pastor Dietrich Bonhoeffer; next to him was a Russian soldier. As they traveled, the Russian soldier and Bonhoeffer talked, becoming friends as the soldier taught the pastor some words and phrases in Russian. When the truck stopped for the night and it became clear that many of the prisoners would soon meet their demise, Bonhoeffer was asked to administer Communion. He agreed and stood to begin, but the Russian soldier remained sitting, explaining that he was a communist atheist and that it would therefore be hypocritical for him to partake. Upon hearing his response, Bonhoeffer sat back down and reportedly stated, "Then neither will I partake; for how can I be sure that in leaving you for the communion table I would not be leaving Christ?"
Emmanuel Levinas, a Jewish thinker who himself spent time in a Nazi concentration camp, had ideas similar to Bonhoeffer's. Having survived the war, Levinas saw how easily our philosophical and theological perspectives allow us to destroy our neighbor. In exploring this, Levinas put ethics at the forefront of all action, interaction and knowledge. Yet his ethics is not an ethics of absolutes and ideal principles. Rather, for Levinas, ethics is born in the relational connection of I and other. In responsible ethical action, I see the other as a mystery (an infinity) that cannot be captured by my own thoughts, desires or wants. And I experience this transcendent mystery in the other when I see the face of the other. It is in this confrontation that all is changed, for I am pulled from my self-obsession and forced to rearrange my reality; the other must find a place within it. This is most fundamentally a hermeneutical issue, for in every new interaction with an other, I must allow the other's humanity to confront me in such a way that I am forced to critically review what it is that I know and hold to be true.
For example, imagine sitting at a wedding, leaning over to your friend and whispering, "I have no idea what she sees in him." You have only known the groom as obnoxious and shallow. Yet, a few weeks later you are invited to the newlyweds' home for dinner. In their home, through a meal and conversation, you see him differently; you now see him alongside her, in connection to his relationship with her, which allows you to see the depth and wonder of his person. As a result, he escapes your simple categories for him.
But who, concretely, is an "other" to me? We have already mentioned the face as the criterion to see and hear the other. The other, then, is everyone I meet. You can hear in this echoes of the scribe's question to Jesus, "Who is my neighbor?" (Lk 10:29), and Jesus' answer, the parable of the good Samaritan (Lk 10:30-37).13 The neighbor is the one who confronts me in the now with his or her humanity, and it is in this confrontation that I must act on his or her behalf. When I see someone face to face I have confronted the other and must never turn from him or her. Response-ability is called for.
Even more, though, in the meeting of the other, in seeing him or her face to face, we encounter all of humanity and are confronted by its particularities. PhilosopherAdriaanPeperzak draws this out from Levinas: "Other others stand beside and behind this other who obliges me here and now through his/her presence. Since the obligation is not attached to a particular feature of this other but only to his/her entrance into my world, all others oblige me as much as this one. In this one's face, I see the virtual presence of all men and women."" The universal principle here is that we uphold the humanity of all by expressing local responsibility for the other we encounter.
What this means is that the Christian, the church, must never endorse or turn ignorantly from the suffering of anyone, far or near, familiar or strange, but must be attentive. Clearly, Christopraxis-the present action of Christ-will never oppose the humanity of another. We can never claim that oppression or abuse is God's will, for where humanity is destroyed and the neighbor beaten, God states only "No." The suffering of the world, however, is vast, and from a universal perspective we are defeated by its enormity. Its enormity must not be our focus, though; our focus is to be the unique particularity of the other that meets us, for it is in meeting him or her that a sacrament of liberation is given to all of humanity.
In this social relation where humanity is upheld and community is formed we can claim the presence of God. And we can claim it only through the life of Christ in which God binds Godself to humanity to be a vehicle of all wholeness and restoration within it. The Spirit of Christ (the work of Christopraxis) is the source of all restoration and healing, all wholeness and vitality. If we are to join in Christopraxis, if we are to claim the will of God, there must be shared relationship where we are free in our humanity to be met by another. The will of God can never be claimed where the other is made into a possession. Rather, all discernment must look to the human other, seeing, speaking to and hearing him or her, understanding that God has bound Godself to humanity in his own humanity. Our hermeneutical method cannot contradict the hermeneutical situation, a situation in which the eschaton breaks forth in shared relationship and humanity is upheld and healed.
In the mutuality of shared relationship, the other in his or her openness also confronts me in a way that upholds my humanity but calls me to lay all aside for the good of the other, who speaks to inc as Christ.IS It causes me to see from a new perspective things which I have never seen before, or things about me (my opinions, thoughts, perspectives, presuppositions) that must be changed. This bracket of social/communal experience thus allows our hermeneutic to be both constructive and destructive, productive yet critical.
The bracket of biblical/theological norms. With our first bracket planted in the soil of the hermeneutical situation, we now turn to our second bracket, the bracket of biblical/theological norms. This bracket asserts that there is continuity between the present action and work of Christ in the world and the recorded history of God's self-revelation found in the biblical text. Thus, all present action of Christ will find some continuity in, and cannot contradict, that which is given to the church in the canon of holy Scripture. Scripture itself becomes nonnative. This bracket has been called "biblical/theological," though, to avoid the misconception that this normative biblical stance allows for some kind of proof-texting, where verses can be interpreted and applied in a way that opposes the larger theological history of the biblical narrative (or the humanity of the other). It has also been called "biblical/theological" because the bracket must encompass within itself the interpretations of past theologians. This is not to say that a new interpretation is not possible, only that, in its possibility, there must be some continuity to the historical understanding of the text. But it must be stated that the text is story (narrative) and not hard principles.
This bracket, like the first one, is embedded within the interpreter as the one who addresses the text in his or her unique context. The existential line runs through it because it is written by human hands, and speaks of the reality of tragedy and death, and the eschatological line penetrates it because it is the Word of God and speaks of God's history with humanity which promises to overcome tragedy, death and sin. It is also embedded within the interpreter because it continues to speak and address the contemporary moment.
Figure 6.4. The second bracket in the hermeneutical situation
The Word of God as Jesus. Our first question with this bracket must be, What is the Word of God? Karl Barth understood the Word of God in a threefold form. First, the Word of God is Jesus Christ himself, the Word became flesh; the living Christ is the Word of God, moving in the world. Second, the Word of God is the canon of Scripture, which is the Word of God only as it leads to Jesus Christ, only as it witnesses to his lordship and directs the reader to confession. We will return to this shortly. Third, the Word of God is the preached event.
In Barth's threefold perspective, both the first and the third aspects encounter us in our present moment, within the present reality. The second, the Bible, is not free to confront us as directly, since it is a written document. However, because the Word of God cannot be understood outside this threefold perspective, we cannot separate the three movements. The written Word does meet us and confront us in our present reality, but only as it witnesses to the living Christ, only as it is open to the work of Christopraxis. In other words, the biblical narrative is thrust into our time and discernment not because it is a "playbook" of Christian action but because it witnesses to Jesus Christ, the One who is acting and calls its to follow.
Thus, by the biblical text's inseparability from Jesus Christ, it is given the power to speak to its in our present moments of decision." In its connection to Christ it is resurrected from being merely a lifeless text written in (many) dead languages, millennia ago, and allowed to speak anew; it is allowed to be not only a record of revelation, but revelation itself, found in our time and space. This is its uniqueness. In this understanding there is inseparable continuity between the revelation of the past and that of the present, for the same texts are given new relevance in new moments, not by the church or individuals but by Jesus Christ himself, who is the One at work.
Therefore, any present action of Christ can never contradict the biblical text." He is revelation proper, and revelation cannot oppose itself. The present situation may be critical of past interpretations, enlightening us to the deeper meaning and significance of a text, but it can never make a mockery or scandal of the text itself. The Word of God, Jesus Christ, is always pulling us forward, moving and acting in the world.
As the interpreter, then-the youth worker who is left to act in discernment-you can be confident that the present action of Christ will have an antecedent in the past biblical narrative. Ray Anderson explains, "By antecedent, I mean some aspect of God's earlier ministry that can now be seen in a new and liberating way through God's continuing ministry."18 In reflection on the first-century church, Anderson continues, "As nearly as I can see, for every case in which eschatological preference was exercised by the Spirit in the New Testament church, there was a biblical antecedent for what appeared to be revolutionary and new."19 In the same way, we can have faith that in every action of Christopraxis there will be a biblical antecedent linking this action of God with that found in the canon of Scripture. This has occurred, for example, in our changed understanding of the roles of women in ministry.
From a philosophical hermeneutical perspective, then, it is, as Paul Ricoeur famously says, "the life in front of the text that is of significance."20 By this he means that discerning how the text bleeds into our own time, into our own horizon, is the hermeneutical task.
The bracket of biblical/theological norms thus asserts that just as Christ is present in the social relational connection of Ito other through the incarnation, Christ is also present in our reflection on the biblical text, because he himself is revelation. Any reflection on the biblical text should therefore always be forward moving, for its vibrancy is found only in connection to Christ who is found in the world, in Christopraxis.
THE HERMENEUTICAL PROCESS: MOVING WITHIN THE BRACKETS
Now that we have placed both brackets within the hermeneutical situation, we can confidently (and yet with humility) assert that the will of God, the action of Christopraxis, will be found somewhere between these two brackets or poles. We'll call this area "the zone of Christopraxis." We've established that any action that would oppose, hurt or destroy the other cannot be the will of God. Any action that is found to be contradictory to the biblical narrative, that has no congruence with the reconciling work of Christ, must be ruled out as well. But we are still left to wonder how one operates within in this zone of Christopraxis. We understand what things are hermeneutical impossibilities, but how do we move hermeneutically within the possibility to finally land on some kind of understanding? Paul Ricoeur and his hermeneneutical arch will give its guidance on how to move within the brackets, therein allowing its to confidently work to discern the will of God in a given situation.
Figure 6.5. The zone of Christopraxis
Swing, swing and swing. Ricoeur, a master Christian philosopher on interpretation, has explained that the process of interpretation is moving back and forth between "understanding" and "explanation." You start with an initial guess of what this event may mean, and what action must be taken. This is what he calls the first naivete. You then move from this guess, from this hunch, to explanation. In explanation, the first naivete, the first guess, is placed in dialogue with something to see if validation can be given to the hunch or if it must be revised and then placed in dialogue with explanation again. This second movement (back to explanation) is the second naivete. This back-and-forth process, which has most helpfully been called "Ricocur's hermeneutical arch,"" continues until the hunch has evolved to a confident assertion. You must then complete the process by stating your interpretation.
Nancy Lammers Gross, in her book, If You Cannot Preach Like Paul, has revised this Ricoeurian arch, lifting it, flipping it on its back and calling it a "swing." She explains her reasons: "I propose the image of a swing [because] it has the advantage of the arch in terms of a tensive dialectic [the move from understanding to explanation]. But even more, it has movement, and it holds the possibility that when gathering enough momentum, the swing will go full circle." She continues, "[I]magine a gymnast on the high bar. The gymnast creates an arch, essentially the bottom half of the circle, as the gymnast swings. When enough momentum has been gathered, the gymnast completes `a giant,' a full circle around the bar."22 This tensive dialectic between understanding and explanation is what I propose should be our movement within this zone of Christopraxis. Let me explain.
We are always confronted by one of the brackets first. It may, for example, be the social/communal (interaction with the other) when the adult leader comes to your office to explain that she is thinking of leaving her husband and to seek your advice. Or it may be the biblical text when, in studying a passage, you are moved or drawn to the significance of a doctrinal position. From this first encounter, you, the interpreter, will be struck with either confusion or insight; then you'll be pushed from this initial understanding, which comes from confrontation with one of the brackets, to the other bracket, as if on a swing. It is here that you are in a dialogue with explanation. In the counseling situation, for example, you would swing from the social/communal bracket to the biblical/theological bracket; there you would place your understanding (first naivete), your encounter with the other, alongside the narrative of God's reconciling work of Jesus Christ. Your initial assumptions about the issues and actions must be in dialogue with the biblical/theological bracket. It may affirm that you are right in your thinking, deepening your understanding, or it may remind you of the beauty of the person's humanity and God's love for her.
In preaching or giving a youth talk, on the other hand, you would swing from the biblical/theological to the social/communal. As you prepare your sermon or talk on the text that has moved you, you have to take your understanding of it and put it in dialogue with the community that will hear it and with the larger world that God has given Godself to. You are not free to keep your nose stuck in your commentaries but rather must at least push yourself back from your desk and reflect on the suffering and joy of those who will hear your message.
In this swing from one to the other, the brackets balance and critique each other. After your initial experience with the other, the reading of a biblical text may take on new and different meaning, critiquing your past understanding and leading to new interpretation. In the same way, after reading a biblical text you may be given a new perspective from which to see your fellow human.
After you have swung to the opposite bracket, however, you must return to the first, either in affirmation of your original understanding or with new insight that directs you deeper or sends you in a new direction altogether. At this point you may realize that you must swing again, returning, say, to the biblical text to look deeper by using commentaries and following the discussion of other theologians. Or swinging again may mean returning to the social/communal, asking further questions, sharing more deeply in community, working to see the world through the eyes of another. This second swing would be your second naivete.
Eventually, the momentum will send you over the bar and you will come to your interpretation. You will make your decision, you will preach your sermon, you will give your diagnoses. When this happens, you will be participating in the will of God; you will have joined in Christopraxis. Through this Ricoeurian swing, then, we are moved from the zone of Christopraxis, from the possibility, to what in faith we assert is the actuality.
The one swinging back and forth from one bracket to the other is the interpreter. It is our responsibility to understand the hermeneutical situation and to be open and ready for movement within the zone of Christopraxis. But the force that moves us, the force that pushes the swing, is the Spirit of Christ. Christ himself confronts and meets us at each bracket, pushing its to the next. When we unite our willingness to swing (to look and look again, think and think anew, pray and pray once more) with our faith that God is acting and calling its to join with him, we participate in Christopraxis. The momentum swings its over and we assert, "It is the will of God."
Figure 6.6. Understanding and explanation
We may fear in this process that, upon mounting the swing, we may never get off, always feeling we need one more swing, one more back and forth, to be sure that this action is right, to land on the right interpretation. It may be helpful here to return to Ricoeur, who assures its that there is not one right interpretation, but rather that, within the swing, within the tensive dialectic, there is a surplus of meaning. This surplus of meaning does not lead to a free-for-all, though; the interpreter has mounted the swing, and in so doing, the plethora of possibilities available is reduced to only a handful. And this handful will never contradict itself. Rather, it will offer differing notes in the same song.
Note also that it is possible, and even common, for us to be confronted with a decision or choice that will give its no time to swing: we will have to act and act now. In these cases, we should feel no paralysis but simply act as best we can. After our actions are complete and the event has passed we will have to ask, "Was what we did the will of God?" or "How do we make sense of our action?" This reflection time is when we will swing, either seeing more clearly than at the point of confrontation that surely God was at work, or coming to realize that we chose wrongly and the action we performed was not right, and therefore an apology and confession is called for.
CONCLUSION
This chapter has sought to present a model or picture to help the minister discern Christopraxis (the will of God). Entering into dialogue with epochmaking theologians and philosophers, I presented a picture of the hermeneutical situation, the hermeneutical method and the hermeneutical process. My hope is that, through this picture, those doing youth ministry will begin to recognize that at its core youth ministry is not about programming events but about discerning God's continued Ministry in the world and then joining it, and that they'll be equipped to actually do this in their ministries.
• DISCUSSION AND REFLECTION EXERCISES
Taking Roles in Discussion
Break into small groups.23 Each person should be assigned one of the roles listed below. Groups should then discuss the relevance of this chapter for their ministry, exploring issues, perspectives and reasons for the model presented. Each person in each group should operate in their role during their group's discussion.
The roles are as follows:
• Problem, dilemma or theme poser. This person's responsibility is to frame the topic of conversation and to draw on his or her own experiences as a way of helping others enter into conversation about the theme.
• Reflective analyst. This person is responsible for keeping a record of the conversation's development. Every twenty minutes or so, he or she gives a summary that focuses on shared concerns and emerging common themes.
• Scrounger This person listens for resources, suggestions and tips that participants mention as having been helpful in their efforts to work through a situation or perspective. He or she keeps a record of these ideas and reads it to participants at least once before the discussion is over.
• Devil's advocate. This is the person who, as he or she senses a consensus emerging, expresses the contradictory view as a way of avoiding groupthink and helping participants explore a range of alternative interpretations.
• Detective. This person listens carefully for unacknowledged, unchecked and unchallenged biases that seem to be emerging in the conversation, such as cultural blindness, gender insensitivity, and coinments that ignore variables of power, class or theological perspective.
• Theme spotter. This person identifies themes that surfaced during the discussion but were left unexplored and that might therefore form a focus for the next discussion.
• Umpire. This person listens for judgmental comments that might offend communicative virtues and/or the ground rules understood by group members.
