Chapter 15 of 20

13 The Mission Trip as Global Tourism Are We OK with This?

13 The Mission Trip as Global Tourism Are We OK with This?

ANDREW ROOT

s we entered Banff National Park I could feel my breathing quicken and my eyes widen. For a boy from the flat Midwest, the sight of majestic mountains reaching to the sky and covered in snow in late July was breathtaking. The beauty was almost more than I could take. I spent the first few days just staring at them, refusing to take my eyes from them. Little, other than TV, had captured my attention as much as those mountains. As we finished our preparation for our youth ministry backpacking trip into the Canadian Rockies, my high-school anticipation was as high as the mountains themselves. We loaded our packs, parked our vans in some dirt lot and started on the trail, trudging our way into the beauty of creation.

Three hours in, the beauty began to fade, though not objectively, I suppose; the mountains, trees and rocks continued to possess some kind of beauty. But it was the kind of beauty that came with harshness. Three hours in, a tenth-grader had blisters, a junior was dehydrated, and a senior was exhausted from carrying the food pack. We camped the first night next to a glacier-fed pond; it too was beautiful, but unsympathetic. When the sun went down the temperature fell quickly, leaving its shivering in our sleeping bags. In addition, we were told we had to filter the water from the stream, and when getting the water we needed to go in teams, in case we met a bear. The first thing I learned on that trip was that nature was beautiful but harsh.

We spent each morning with our journals, encouraged to depart into creation by ourselves to pray, read Scripture and commune with God. Our morning silence started with the warning not to go too far and ended with its all back together to read Scripture, discuss God's presence in nature and say a final prayer. I began to wonder what it was we were doing out there. It clearly was about being in God's creation, but for what purpose? I guessed that we needed the exercise of hiking, and that the time spent outdoors was a good correction to our hours of playing video games and watching TBS reruns. And the time on the trail did allow us to get to know our leaders better. The God stuff seemed weird, though; we were told that by soaking in God's creation we would meet God, but we were given as many warnings as encouragements: watch out for this, make sure you drink enough water, don't leave any food in your tent, don't slide down the snow on the side of the mountains. We were supposed to meet God in nature, but stature was rugged, dangerous and unforgiving, even in its beauty.

So what arc we doing in youth ministry when we take young people on outdoor trips? Do youth encounter God in creation? Is God knowable in the creation? What are we hoping young people will experience on these trips? If, as Kenda has asserted, summer camp has an eschatological dimension, what about youth ministry nature trips? What goes on theologically here?

FOR PERSONAL IMPROVEMENT?

Outdoor trips in youth ministry seem to most often be about a mix of personal improvement and seeing God in nature. We hope that backpacking, canoeing and rock climbing will challenge young people, helping them see what they are capable of doing, so we put them in (controlled) situations that push them beyond what they thought they were capable of. These experiences can no doubt be transforming and significant for a young person's personal development. Overcoming their fear of heights by ziplining, or pushing themselves to walk six miles when they never thought they could, call be very empowering. I don't think we should shy away from admitting that these trips do such things.

But there is a not-so-fine line between bringing together a community of friends who encourage a fellow friend to stretch him- or herself and contending that God will use these trips and their challenges to make young people into what they need to be. I once heard about a youth worker who would tell his young people, in the midst of the exhaustion of building a house or carrying their packs, that God had them on the anvil, insinuating that God was using the experiences, using the heat and pressure of their exertion, to pound them into what God wanted them to be. While these trips provide opportunities for young people to grow into their humanity by challenging themselves physically and departing from their normal distractions in the quiet of nature, we may create a problem when we imply that such experiences are the activity of God and therefore reveal who God is. Like the youth pastor above, we give young people pictures of a God who is like a personal trainer or Pilates instructor-concerned for them to be all they can be, for them to make themselves into something. When we blend the personal challenge with the direct presence of God on these trips, we not only make self-improvement the goal of God's activity but also, ironically, diminish God's action at the same time, giving young people the idea that it is up to them, up to their effort, to make themselves into something God would be pleased with.

THE GOD OF NATURE

Yet what we most often assume about these outdoor trips is that they will open young people's eyes to see God. We imagine that the beauty of nature can persuade young people of God's presence in the world and therefore of God's presence in their lives; we hope that, as they're away from distractions, nature will reveal God to them. In other words, we anticipate that through these trips young people will know and experience God. So we say things like, "Seeing the beauty of the forest, ocean or mountains, how can you deny that God exists and that God is good?"

Nature is, without a doubt, beautiful. It does possess within it something we might call transcendent; we confess that it is God's good creation. But nature, as my own experience in the story above shows, is just as harsh as it is beautiful. We can experience the beauty of mountains, but if we get lost in those mountains we will die. So while many of us have experiences of dwelling in nature, can we assume de facto that they are experiences that usher in communion with God? After all, nature in itself cannot communicate knowledge of God, and nature in itself gives its experiences of both transcendent mystery and grueling hell.

This may diminish the activity of God, because these trips become about knowledge and experience outside of encounter, outside of God's own ac tion. Nature, in itself, is inert; it cannot encounter its. It can give its moving experiences, experiences that are good and wonderful, but it does not put a direct demand on us and does not encounter us as a person might. Yet when we take young people into nature hoping it will reveal to them that God exists, we tend to imagine that nature itself will mediate knowledge of God. We assume that if young people look deeply at the beauty of nature they will see the fingerprints of God. But even in a bush that burns but is not consumed (a reality that is other than nature since, in nature, all burning bushes are consumed) God calls out, God acts, God speaks with God's Word that, while spoken within nature, is also other than it. It was not the beauty of the bush that Moses attested to but the fact that God spoke to him, acting by revealing to Moses God's very name. God is agent, not a passive reality to experience, which is what God too often becomes in our nature trips. We don't assume God's own action (that God acts to reveal Godself). Rather, we assume that by dwelling in nature we can see God, and though we may not mean to imply it, this assumption can give the impression that God remains passive-something we experience-but does not encounter us. For God to truly encounter its, God would have to be other enough from nature to act for and with its.

In both perspectives (seeing these trips either as opportunities for adolescent self-betterment or as times of nature revealing God) we have conceptions of God that are disconnected from love itself, for love can only be in action; it is never passive but is always an active reality. With the first perspective, we provide pictures of a God who cares about personal betterment, about its stretching ourselves toward excellence, not a God who acts to be near to its in impossibility. There is a fine line between encouraging kids to do things that push them and insinuating that God desires that they work to improve themselves. And with the second perspective, we give pictures of a God who is known through nature, which, though beautiful and good, is inert and just as harsh as it is beautiful. Nothing in nature itself engages its out of grace and love. Indeed, nature hides God as much as it reveals God. There is no grace if you fall off the mountain, no forgiveness through the teeth of a bear if you leave an open bag of beef jerky in your tent. When we put these outdoor trips on our calendars, we justify them by claiming that they provide young people with opportunities to challenge themselves and to experience God through nature, but is this even in line with our theological commitments?

THE HEIDELBERG DISPUTATION

In 1518 Luther presented his Heidelberg Disputation to defend his theological breakthrough that would be the impetus of the Reformation. The document not only raises the problem that Luther saw (that all action of the human agent that seeks to justify and make him- or herself good is futile and perilous), but also presents his constructive reimagination of theology beyond the dead end of seeking for God in our own activity and in that which can be easily seen and discerned (like through nature itself).

Luther's constructive reimagination of theology is his theology of the cross (theologia crucis, which we focused on a great deal in this book), a theology that asserts that it is God who acts. But this God who acts does so in backward ways, making life out of death and bringing hope from despair by entering death and being found in despair. All theology for Luther therefore begins and ends with the crucified Christ. This does not eliminate for him the importance of the Old Testament or the outpouring of the Spirit; these too are realities that demand deep theological reflection. But, in the end, the crucified Christ is the hinge of history, the hinge of existence itself. The cross of Christ becomes the hidden and backward way that God seeks to act for us, revealing that God's action is never determined by the potency of human action but only by human suffering and impossibility. It is in the crucified Christ, for Luther, that we see the fullness and depth of God's own action for us; it is in sharing our suffering in the cross that God reveals Godself. As Paul says, "The message of the cross is foolishness for those who are perishing, but to us who are saved it is the power of God" (1 Cor 1:18).

For Luther, the cross is the way God reveals Godself most fully, for it is in the cross that we see how fully God seeks to be with and for us. This means the road to encountering God is not in our own action or experience in nature but in God's act of taking on the cross. While nature is good and God is the Creator, nature in itself cannot be with and for us. God chooses to enter the natural world as the God of a people (Israel) and in the fullness of humanity in the incarnation, but in itself nature cannot possess direct knowledge of God, for nature alone meets us as a non-personal reality, not as person encountering persons. By becoming the God of a people, however, by revealing Godself in Jesus Christ, God unveils Godself in the reality of personal encounter, through agency.

Nature can captivate us, can touch some transcendent impulse within us and mediate true beauty, but it has no agency. It can unfold through natural processes and can even adapt to stimulus and threat in the environment, but it cannot encounter our person as person. Nature cannot be with us; it cannot be near to its in our brokenness. And in fact, it can, and indiscriminately will, destroy its. The water that quenches our thirst as a gift can also push our air from our lungs, taking our life.

Thus, God unveils Godself most directly not in nature but in the crucified Christ, Luther believes. To know who God is and where God is found we don't look to nature (or reason, for Luther) but to the peasant man dying on a cross outside the city. The crucified Christ reveals that God is found not in nature, but next to the suffering and longing of persons, next to places of broken searching.

OUTDOOR TRIPS ARE ABOUT SMALLNESS

This, then, is what nature trips are about: not experiencing God in nature but experiencing our own longings and brokenness. Why take kids into the mountains or canoeing? What is the point? The point, at least from the place of the early Reformation's theology of the cross, is not because nature mediates who God is or because in overcoming our limitations we become better (better people, better Christians). No, the reason we take kids on these outdoor trips is so that they might experience what is most true for us: that we are caught in discontinuity. In other words, outdoor trips may be one of the most helpful ways to encourage young people to think about the crisis of their very existence. The point of looking at mountains that have been here for a million years and may be here a million more is not to see God in them but to recognize the thinness of our being in their shadow. Outdoor trips are about helping kids ask, What is a lifetime and why do we live it? Who is this God that creates a whole universe of such depth, size, beauty and tragedy and yet cares for me, seeks me? And seeks inc not in the majesty and power of the created order, but in the nearness, smallness and closeness of human suffering and love, the cross. We could say that nature is like the Law: it is good and it's a gift, for it reveals to its our limitations. But God in Godself has acted for its in our limitations, taking our brokenness and suffering on God self through the crucified Christ.

These trips have the power of reminding the ego that it is small, that the self is but a minuscule blip on the screen of time and space. So outdoor trips should call adolescents and their disproportionately large egos to consider their own smallness (like the psalmist in Psalm 8). Where is God present in these trips? If you follow the theology of the cross, God's presence is not in the experience of nature in itself; rather, through experiencing nature, we recognize our own yearnings, longings and brokenness, and next to these yearnings, longings and brokenness, God is found. God is made known as acting through the cross (and now through the Spirit) for its.

Outdoor trips are not, then, about improvement (whether spiritual or personal) but about death, and if they are about death then they are about the cross. Spending time in the harshness and beauty of nature, away from our technological day to day, we witness how near death is to life, how life and death are inevitability connected. The psalmist looked at mountains and realized that he is small, that he is finite, and that beauty and hell are so close together; that which is so beautiful can be so harsh, and that which is so appealing to the eye can destroy us. Sitting with young people on the last day of a trip as the sun comes up over the evergreens, lighting the lake in gold that spreads before our feet, we become aware that our life is so thin, and that in its thinness is beauty. God is there, for God has acted through the thinness of death and brokenness to make our realities of thinness the place of God's very action.

This means that nature is our great gift, a gift we must steward and care for. Not because it possesses knowledge of God, but because it is God's. We care for nature because, in experiencing both its beauty and its harshness (which cannot be untangled from each other), we are reminded that we are dying but also that, in our death, God acts to be near to its. And we care for nature because it is our friend; we are bound to it, for we, like it, are caught in the cycles of moving from life to death. We seek its good not because it reveals God but because, like its, it seeks for new life beyond death through God's own action.

We take young people on outdoor trips not to challenge them to be better or experience God through creation but to help them face the crisis of reality itself, to help them recognize that they are small and near death, that they are in need of a God who acts to cross the abyss to meet them. Outdoor trips have real potential to lead not to personal betterment but to deep reflection on why there is something instead of nothing, on my need, on my questions that have no answers. And when we are willing to face these realities, when we are willing to face the thinness of what is and to reveal our suffering and admit that we are near to death, then the God of the cross stands before its, for the God of the cross has acted for its to be with its by entering our beautiful but harsh world for the sake of love.

• DISCUSSION AND REFLECTION EXERCISE

Sentence Completion
Each person should get a page with the following half-sentences on it.' Take a few minutes and complete at least one of these statements. Flesh out as much as possible the one or two half-sentences that you choose.
What most struck me about this chapter for the discussion today is ...
The question that I'd most like to ask the author of the chapter is ...
The idea I most take issue with in the chapter is ...
The most crucial point in the chapter was ...
The part of the chapter that I felt made the most sense to me was ...
The part of the chapter that I felt was most confusing was ...
After taking time to reflect and write on at least one of the halfsentences, break tip into small groups to share your thoughts with others.

↑ Back to top

↑