4 Proclaiming Salvation The Ministry of Youth for the Twenty-First-Century Church
ANDREW ROOT
Bather is fifteen and has attended Grace-Trinity Church since she was in third grade. She seemed like a normal, average kid who almost disappeared into the background, until six months ago. In a small group discussion, Heather shattered the perceived ordinariness of her life by revealing, almost matter-of-factly (as if no one would care anyhow), that she had missed quite a few days of school recently (which she figured few people had noticed). Most mornings she felt so depressed she could barely get out of bed. Her mother, she said in an aside, was unavailable to her because she had a drinking problem, and her stepdad had enough to worry about; she disclosed that he had recently lost his job at the local factory, forcing her family to go on food stamps while he searched unsuccessfully for another job.
Sara, the youth director at Grace-Trinity, stared back at Heather, stunned. She was moved both by the depth of suffering Heather was experiencing and by the fact that she chose to share it. In the weeks preceding this confession, Sara had found it impossible to get Heather to share anything at all. The multiple layers of the issues affecting Heather became instantly obvious, but Sara feared that confronting any of them would move her far from her expertise (whatever that expertise might be).
Sara finally returned her gaze to the open Bible in her hand. As the late chapters of Mark's Gospel stared back at her, she wondered what difference it made. How would another poorly planned Bible study have any impact as Heather faced poverty, abuse, addiction, isolation and depression?
Could theology assist Sara in ministry in this situation?
As I stated in the last chapter, youth ministry is fundamentally a theological task, a task that seeks to participate in God's own Ministry by moving from experience to reflection to action. Or, to broaden and deepen this, we could say that youth ministry attends to divine action: it aims to do its work in a manner that is faithful to (and that strives to articulate) God's action in the world. Our job, then, is not to simply apply Bible verses to research on adolescent behavior; when we do this we overlook our theological calling. Rather, youth ministry is in the unique business of constructing theology itself by examining how divine action connects to human beings in the first third of the human lifespan.
But here sits Sara, overwhelmed with the issues impacting Heather, issues that are clearly more than theological. They're psychological and economic too. How can theology help? And how can theology enter into conversation with other areas of knowledge to help us reflect deeply on our experience, so that our action might touch the broken humanity of those like Heather?
WHAT IS THEOLOGY?
Proclaiming God's revelation: The kerygmatic emphasis of theology. The words theos and logos have been scribbled on the blackboard of almost every introductory class to the study of theology. Students are told that theos means "God" and logos means "logic" or "study," and that theology is therefore the study of God, like sociology is the study of society, psychology the study of the psyche and biology the study of the organic body. When explained this way, theology, like its comrades, is a science, the science of God.
Yet it is at this point that we confront a gigantic problem. For while the other sciences look to unveil what is hidden within a phenomenon (why the economy works like it does, why childhood trauma reappears in later life, why certain drugs can shrink a tumor), theological study looks beyond what can be known in the natural world. Indeed, theology can unveil nothing of its subject of study, for its subject-the eternal God of Israel-traiiscends time and space and any human tool that could be created or imag fined to unveil God.' In this way, theology is fundamentally different from the other sciences. The process of unveiling is God's own work; it is God who chooses to make Godself known to a world that God is completely other than.'
This process of God's unveiling is called revelation, and revelation is what we're talking about when we assert (as I did in the last chapter) that God is a Minister. God's revealing of Godself (revelation) is God's Ministry; it is God's coming near to its to overcome that which keeps its from God (our death and sin). Douglas John Hall states, "Christian faith does not base itself on general observations about the world, human beings, nature, divinity, and so forth.... It begins with revelation. That is, its point of departure is a disclosure, an `unveiling' of something not otherwise accessible to human knowing."3 Theology, then, is not the process of unveiling God to the world but rather the process of articulating how God has unveiled Godself in the world-in other words, it's kerygma, the proclamation of God's Ministry.
As Sara sits with her small group of young people she must acknowledge that she does not control God's unveiling. No matter how prepared, talented or equipped she may be, it is not her job, or even in her power, to make God known to these young people, as though with the right questions or moving story she could pull God from her pocket to offer God to her small group, like a pack of gum. Rather, as a theologian it is Sara's job to seek to articulate (as best she can) how God is making Godself known in the life of this community.
Making a case for God's revelation in context: The apologetic emphasis in theology. While God is other than the world and is the one who does the unveiling, this unveiling (revelation) nevertheless happens within time and space. In other words, revelation may come from outside of human history and be out of our control, but it nonetheless breaks into and penetrates human existence. Moreover, there is no such thing as generic revelation, for revelation is not a concept but the event of revealing a person (God's very self). Revelation as personal being therefore always encounters persons, whether through covenant, burning bush or (in its fullest form) child born unto a virgin. It's "the movement of a loving presence towards world and self,"4 Hall says.
Thus, while theology proclaims that God is unveiled, the theologian must argue for how God is unveiling Godself in this time, in this contexts While God in God's being is other than the world (making revelation necessary), God nevertheless makes it clear by being Emmanuel (God with us) through creation, covenant, incarnation and re-creation that we can know God only in the world. Therefore, as Hall explains, "Faith is the grace-given courage to engage that world. Theology is a disciplined reflection and commentary upon faith's engagement. Theology therefore is contextual, and that by definition."6
This means theology must work in dual directions.? It must proclaim the gospel, the kerygma, of God's unveiling in the world through its Scriptures (the normative articulations of God's unveiling) and its tradition (its trusted commentary on the articulations of God's unveiling). But because theology confesses God's continued action, it must also work in an apologetic spirit, observing and then searching to articulate what God is tip to now, in specific times and places, and how human persons and communities can be faithful. Hall puts it this way: "Theology lives between the stories-God's story of the world, and humanity's ever-changing account of itself and all things. Theology is what happens when the two stories meet."8 Thus we-as theologians in ministry-must each work to understand our context and the (young) people within it.
THEOLOGY AND INTERDISCIPLINARITY
It is in this dual movement of attention to revelation and attention to context that theology can (must) engage in conversations with those in other disciplines of the social and hard sciences. But theology makes the claim that revelation gives individuals a distinct vision of reality that cannot be perceived outside of God's unveiling love. In other words, encountering God's revelation lightens our darkness, causing its to see reality differently. It is dangerous, then, to simply jump from one discipline to another as we pursue answers to questions (placing theology on a shelf in the meantime, which too often youth workers do), with no reasoned method that keeps theology in the conversation. Yet to maintain a true dialogue, we also cannot force another discipline, such as sociology, to be molded around theological or ministerial needs; this would prevent our work from being truly interdisciplinary or our research from being sociologically valid. Instead, theology, with its different kind of subject (the eternal God, as opposed to phenomena in time and space), must enter into these conversations in such a manner that the distinct scientific pursuits of each (the articulation of God's unveiling or the unveiling of certain phenomena) are upheld. We therefore need a method for relating theology and other fields.
Interdisciplinary methodologies (the twentieth-century classics). We'll look at two well-known methods (the correlational and Chalcedonian) before I present my own. The correlational and Chalcedonian perspectives have been very popular within theology. We find their positive and negative implications not only in our interdisciplinary methods, but also in our very perspective of ministry.
Correlational method. The correlational method is divided into two distinct actions: asking questions and providing answers. It allows the social sciences, hard sciences or arts to provide questions from their distinct locale and logic; theology, then, joins these asked questions with answers drawn from its own tradition and commitments. For the correlationalists, the unveiling of God happens in the apologetic moment where deep questions are asked and ultimate answers are given.
In Sara's situation, then, a correlationalist theologian would give attention to the implicit or explicit questions being asked by Heather and her peers. The poverty, dysfunctional family and depression Heather faces raise deep questions of ultimacy. To understand these questions in their fullness, Sara would have to dig deeply, using multiple disciplines. She might call a local psychologist, for example, or read a sociological article on the breakdown of the working class. Once she understands what questions are being asked, Sara would then bring theological answers to them. As adolescents' deep questions are faced and correlated with answers from theology, God is unveiled and students like Heather are given ultimate answers to their many questions.
The method of correlation was constructed by the great German American theologian Paul Tillich during the swirling change of a post-World War II society, which is when he wrote his Systematic Theology. Tillich believed that (post)modernity had wrestled away from the church its ability to hold together the many diverse segments of human existence and religious experience. Science had dethroned theology and the state had dethroned the church. This allowed for a dualism that he believed separated theology completely from public life. For Tillich, theology could no longer focus only on the church but needed instead to turn toward culture (and thus away from a dualistic perspective) so that people could see society and theology as unified in a correlating whole.
Tillich's method was both profound in its application and simple in its construction. He sought to enter into meaningful conversations with depth psychology and existential philosophy to show the innate and nascent religious propensities within culture itself. In that vein, the job of the correlating theologian is to peer deeply into the cultural life of society, looking for the religious theological questions that are seeking answers.9 Upon discovering these questions, theology, in an apologetic spirit, delivers explanations. For Tillich, the theologian is both detective and relief pitcher, hunting for unanswered questions and then entering the game to give closure with theological answers of ultimacy.10 As James McClendon notes, "Thus theology's task was ... the discovery of implicit religion lurking in society's crevices.""
While there is much to be admired in the apologetic focus of Tillich's correlational method (e.g., its openness and desire to face the deep questions of existence), it nevertheless leaves itself open to a number of problems. First, though it contends that revelation (God's unveiling) is other than cultural realities, it is bound to them, for correlationists believe that revelation is only present after the questions have been discerned. Revelation plays no part (or little part) in enlightening your understanding of the questions themselves.
The second concern is that innate within the correlational perspective is the fundamental belief that all questions can be easily and harmoniously correlated with answers. The attempt to find a happy harmony between question and answer, culture and gospel, however, denies theology the uniqueness of its own questions and ignores the fact that some perspectives may be, in their very essence, antithetical to God's unveiling in the world, such as questions rooted in corruption or evil. For instance, Dietrich Bonhoeffer saw no possibility of finding correlation with the ideologies of national socialism. The church, he believed, could only deny and refuse these perspectives. Moreoever, a commitment to God's unveiling in the world (such as stating that the gospel illustrates nonviolence, or declaring that the last shall be first) will be offensive to other disciplines or to culture. To think that those who are offended will always be willing to listen to and accept correlationists' answers is naive; correlation is unlikely in those instances. As Douglas John Hall comments, "There appears to be little awareness here of a gospel which, while it may indeed be the `right answer,' is offensive precisely for that reason."" So, in Sara's quest to address Heather's situation, for example, Sara may become so concerned about understanding the questions that the need to proclaim the gospel is compromised. The gospel, however, doesn't need or seek harmony with the questions. And indeed, this was not Tillich's desire-but in the end the otherness of God's unveiling becomes lost or dependent on what is happening within culture.
Chalcedonian method. Those using this method assert that the way to relate theology and other disciplinary perspectives can be drawn from the Council of Chalcedon's definition and understanding of Jesus' divine and human natures. The Chalcedonian model enters constructive theological work through Karl Barth's use of the divine and human natures of Christ, in
What makes this position distinct from the correlational method is that it holds strongly to the belief that theology should never abandon its own subject matter, and should only appropriate the findings of other perspectives in a second-order manner. Therefore, intrinsic within this perspective is a kerygmatic thrust. Where Tillich's method is essentially apologetic (putting questions and answers together to make a case), the Chalcedonian method is constructed around proclamation (the confession of the faith) and the transformation that occurs in the moment of profession when the Word of God is encountered.
Deborah van Deusen Hunsinger uses the Chalcedonian pattern in her book Theology and Pastoral Counseling to associate theology and psychology so that the pastoral counselor can use both in his or her work.14 Thus, she first asserts in a kerygmatic style that there is no way from psychology to theology, but there is a way from theology to psychology. The pastoral counselor must therefore learn to be bilingual, she goes on to explain, able to speak psychologically but with an understanding that this psychological language has its true etymology in theology. She also shows that this relationship between theology and psychology must be governed by three terms that are at the core of the Chalcedonian pattern: indissoluble differentiation, meaning the two fields must be related without being confused and without changing one into the other; inseparable unity, meaning that the fields must be related as a whole, without separating or dividing them into parts; and indestructible order, meaning that the theological has asymmetrical control over the other, for it has a wider vision."
If Sara is a theologian that uses the Chalcedonian method, then, she will work to speak in a bilingual fashion to her small group. She may use a psy chological perspective to help her understand Heather's situation, and she may even enter into a conversation with Heather and a local psychologist. But in doing this, Sara is not looking for answers to deep questions of existence per se. Rather, she's searching for ways that psychology and its theories are secular parables of the more encompassing reality of God's action through God's Word.16 So while Sara may use a number of different perspectives for a time, her work will ultimately be concerned with providing her small group with moments of proclamation where they can both individually and corporately be transformed.
The problem with the Chalcedonian model of interdisciplinarity is that it may succumb to the very problem of the doctrine itself. Douglas John Hall has made a convincing case that Chalcedon was not only constructed under Constantinian political pressure but was also ultimately constructed around the logic of a Hellenistic-Athenian perspective of substance rather than a Hebraic-Jerusalem understanding of relationship." Therefore, instead of being based on the relational life of God in the person of Jesus Christ for other concrete persons (i.e., relationships, which draw its into the suffering of our neighbor), the method focuses on the substantive structure of each field and its ability to relate (or witness) to God's Word. As a result, God's unveiling gets placed outside the construct of human relationality (outside of being representatives or place-sharers for and with young people, as we'll see below) and attending to the substance of the moment of proclamation becomes primary-making the kerygma potentially more important than the humanity of concrete persons in the world and thereby eclipsing our need to concern ourselves with human action.
Both of the above perspectives are insightful but deficient; they've both given direction to the practice of ministry but have ultimately been more concerned with how to relate the substances of multiple academic perspectives. So let me try to offer my own perspective. We'll turn to Luther's theologia crucis for a method that is open to the suffering humanity of the other as both apologetic and kerygmatic, and that therefore offers a meaningful way to do theology as the practice of ministry (as we began in chapter two).
A representative method. At the center of the great turn that would lead to the Reformation, Martin Luther made the assertion that human beings can have no knowledge of God that doesn't begin with God's own unveiling on the cross of Christ.18 Luther believed that theology within the Christendom of his time had failed to follow Paul's desire to "to know nothing ... except Jesus Christ, and him crucified" (1 Cor 2:2) and had fallen into what Luther called a theologia gloria, which he defined as "calling evil good and good evil." Or, to say it less dramatically but just as forcefully, the Christendom of Luther's day had made theology something other than reflecting on and then articulating the cross of Christ and the weak and hidden truth of God's revelation in the peasant Jesus "who had nowhere to lay his head" (Mt 8:20). Rather, in the theologia gloria the cross was used as a logo of triumph and power, divorced from the humanity of Jesus.
Luther sought to correct this error by returning theological attention to "Christ and Him Crucified," creating what he called the theologia crucis ("the theology of the cross"). Unlike the theologia gloria, the theologia crucis "calls a thing what it is." Because it is a theology that seeks God's unveiling in the grittiness of the broken humanity of Jesus, there is no fear in speaking about sin or evil, or in facing the crushed or mangled humanity of another. The theologia crucis can call a thing what it is because it bravely enters into the darkest corners of human hells, claiming God's presence there through the cross of Christ. The place of God's unveiling (and, as such, our salvation) is in the place of suffering-ours and Christ's.
The theologia crucis claims that Jesus Christ is our representative (our place-sharer, as I have developed in other places). A representative is one who stands fully in the place of the other, not overcoming the other but (in both differentiation and identification) standing beside and for the other, sharing the other's reality even to the point of shared culpability. By being incarnate, crucified and resurrected, Jesus Christ shares our place (Stellvertretung). But he also, bybeing incarnate, crucified and resurrected, is shown to be the fullness of God.'9 Therefore, Jesus stands simultaneously as the true representative of God and the true representative of humanity; it is in this dual representative nature that salvation is achieved. Hall says it this way: "Jesus is with its so unreservedly that he may represent us before God; and Jesus is with God so unreservedly that he may represent God to us."20
How might this representative perspective on theologia crucis help us understand how to go about doing interdisciplinary work in youth ministry? By starting with the humanity of "Christ, and him crucified," a representative perspective immediately draws us into the deep suffering of the human condition that our neighbor experiences. Through the cross, God in Christ stands with and for all humanity as our representative; as followers of Christ, we share in his life by becoming representatives ourselves. So, unlike starting somewhere other than Christology (correlational) or starting in christological doctrinal theory (Chalcedoiiiaii), a representative perspective begins with the living God who is known in the crucified humanity of Jesus (it starts with God's Ministry).
This means two things for our purposes. First, it means that the cross and resurrection are an invitation to live in the deep relational life of God, who gives Godself for the love of humanity. The theologia crucis claims that our neighbor is no longer lost but forever found in the suffering humanity of Jesus; stranger is made friend and enemy is made beloved. But, second, to love the other in relational solidarity, the representative nature of the theologia crucis demands that we face the concreteness of reality (calling a thing what it is). The followers of the cross must be brave enough to make their way deep into the gullies of human suffering. The cross is not solely a spiritual reality but a concrete historical event that occurs in time and space. Representation in the image of theologia crucis therefore demands that we pay attention to concrete historical reality and its effect on human persons. But the theologia crucis also demands that this entering into suffering not be done over against the other but with and for the other in such a manner that we recognize the other as our brother or sister through the humanity of God in Christ. Thus, through the representative humanity of Christ on the cross we are led to relate the social sciences and theology to one another. But what would this look like?
Figure 3.1. Interdisciplinarity from the representative perspective
Figure 3.1 shows three points that make tip a triangle in an interdisciplinary position from the representative perspective. At the top is the con tinued ministry of Christ as the weak Lord who rules in love and solidarity. God's rule of love and solidarity through Jesus the representative means that the neighbor, the other, becomes the center of our attention, for God is found unveiled in the world as the representative for this other. At the two corners rest "the concrete" and "relationship," two points we drew from the theologia crucis. "The concrete" refers to the work that must be done to understand the fullness of the other's reality and discover how and why their world is impacting them like it is. By "relationship," I mean that the other has become dear to us-which is what causes its to do "the concrete" and seek to understand who they are within the multiple systems and situations that impact their person.
This then means we use the social sciences (or any other form of knowledge) to answer two questions that are bound to the humanity of the other that is taken tip and represented by the cross of Christ. The first question is, "What is happening with this other?" This question is governed by the cross of Christ and by my call to be a representative for the other. It is more than scientific-it's pastoral-but if I'm going to love and care for the other, I must seek the assistance of multiple disciplines in answering the question. This question is also more than existential-it's social too, in that it attempts to understand how large cultural and societal structures are impacting the adolescent. For example, it desires to know how a lack of health insurance, the community the adolescent lives in and the education they are receiving play a role in their situation. Therefore, while representation gives significant attention to the individual, it knows that to care for the humanity of the individual-to really be able to understand what's happening with the other-it must engage (through the social sciences) the multiple contexts the adolescent lives in.
The second question that must be asked, also born from relationship, is, "Who is this other?" We ask this question too as representative and not as scientist, in order to know how to minister and care for the adolescent's very humanity. The use of other disciplines in this process is governed by the humanity of the other. In other words, the other disciplines are used only as they are needed alongside the other's humanity and only in a utilitarian, de facto manner to assist the representative in caring for the other. And we use them within the bound reality of Jesus Christ who stands with its, participating and healing through his own representative humanity.
The use of any discipline must serve to bring its close to the other. All disciplines are free to be used in assistance of my ministry as long as they exist only in a christologically bound reality of representation and never distract me from concrete action as the representative for my neighbor. I may have a good handle on Freudian psychology, for example, but if the issue at hand is economic, or if a Freudian perspective is found (in this context) to be detrimental, I must abandon it. It is the ministry of Christ for the humanity of the other that sets the terms for interdisciplinary work. And seeking answers to the questions, "What is happening with the other?" and "Who is the other?" is the action of representation which connects back to the representative ministry of Christ in the cross.
As Sara sits across from Heather, then, she is not struck by the multiple theories and disciplines that come into vision. Rather, what strikes Sara is Heather: her suffering humanity and her bravery to speak of her suffering in front of her peers. Sara had thought she loved Heather; she wasn't one of her favorites, but she had believed that she loved them all. But now, hearing Heather speak of her suffering, Sara is drawn to her broken humanity, drawn to be Heather's representative-and so she must ask again, Who is she? To answer this Sara might turn to family-systems theory in an effort to discover how alcoholism affects the youngest child, or she may look at object-relations psychology. But the use of these disciplines, and any others Sara uses, will be governed by her desire to be a representative to Heather, to love her by being with her. Therefore, the interdisciplinary conversation partners will be determined by Heather's humanity and will therefore be used de facto-in other words, they will be used only to help Sara love and care for Heather.
In addition to the who question Sara must also ask, What is happening? This question too is connected to Heather's humanity-her humanity in her place, in the concrete location of time and space. So Sara might use educational theory to understand why Heather is failing in school, or she may use sociology to understand why factories and mills are closing in small towns. But again, these questions are explored with and for Heather. The multiple disciplines are not used for apologetic or kerygmatic purposes solely but rather for ministry in the shared suffering of the other which seeks to call a thing what it is!
Seeing interdisciplinarity from this representative perspective keeps the person of Christ (Christology) and the work of Christ (soteriology) connected. The two other theories above seem to unknowingly divide Christol ogy and soteriology. The Chalcedonian perspective uses Christology as an organizing principle for multiple disciplines but seems to care little about how the use of these disciplines participates in Christ's work of soteriology. Participation in Christ's soteriological work is left solely to the moment of proclamation. The correlationalists, on the other hand, desire greatly to find the apologetic pulse of culture so that they might make a soteriological dent, but they do so to the detriment of Christology. Significant conversation about the person of Christ takes a backseat. The representative perspective provides its with a way to hold Christology and soteriology together, connecting Jesus' identity as representative and his work of representing.2I
Like the Chalcedonian method, the representative perspective begins with God's action of unveiling in the person of Jesus Christ. However, it uniquely claims, following Luther, that God's action of unveiling is seen in its fullest in the hiddenness of the beaten peasant of Nazareth. In other words, the Word unveiled is seen in the weak One of the cross and nowhere else (at least intentionally). Also in congruence with the Chalcedonians, a representative perspective claims that God's action (in the cross of Christ) is an incomparable reality and therefore cannot be correlated with any other occurrence in culture or society. But the representative method asserts that God's action in the cross of Christ penetrates the depths of the brokenness of humanity and creation: estrangement, dehumanization and death. Thus the deep questions of human existence, to which the correlationists point, are taken up and borne in the weakness of the crucified. In this way, both the kerygmatic and apologetic emphases are connected in the representative perspective by the suffering humanity of God in Christ.
Representative interdisciplinarity is born from and practiced within concrete relational ministry. But how do we teach others to be representatives for adolescents? How do we draw from this perspective in intentional interdisciplinary work in the congregation? Douglas John Hall has offered five points that frame representative action in a way that can direct its in the ministry of Christ. For each point, I've added a question or two specifically for youth workers.
• A representative is qualified. Jesus was qualified to be our true representative by incarnation, crucifixion and resurrection. Have we helped our volunteers and young people do deep theoretical reflection on human action (social sciences) and divine action (theology)? Or have we settled for a programmatic focus?
• A representative must regularly face in two directions. Jesus, as the church confesses, was simultaneously the Son of Man and the Son of God, human like us and also completely other. Youth workers and volunteers are told to identify with adolescents, but have we also taught them the importance of differentiation?
• A representative must suffer. God in Jesus suffered the fullness of the human condition. Have we understood that (youth) ministry demands suffering? Are we aware that youth ministry is more than fun and games, that it is a call to bear the suffering of the adolescent as one follows the suffering Christ?
• Representation flows from a vocation. Jesus could not be distracted from his vocation of the cross that bore the suffering love of the Father for the world. Can youth workers articulate how suffering love in youth ministry is about doing but also about thinking? Have we seen our vocation as local theologians, reflecting and articulating God's continued unveiling in the world?
• Those who are being represented know themselves as being involved in the representational event or act. Jesus calls his disciples to love the world as he does; discipleship (as Bonhoeffer has asserted) is the invitation to follow Christ to the cross. Have youth workers helped adolescents see and participate in representation? Do youth workers see their part in helping adolescents themselves become representatives of Christ for the world?
CONCLUSION
Youth ministry is no doubt an integrative endeavor, requiring an interdisciplinary approach. For youth ministry to live into the theological turn it will be essential for us to have some conception of how to relate to different disciplines. After all, as the case of Sara and Heather shows, this interdisciplinarity is often inevitable. But what their situation also shows is that relating these disciplines should always be governed not by the rigor of the university but by the Ministry of God, by a pastoral vision. Sara is sent on a journey of theological reflection because she experiences Heather's broken humanity. And in experiencing it she is called to act for the Ministry of God by seeing and understanding the depth of Heather's person and situation. Sara leans on other disciplines in her theological action of care for Heather, but the use of these other disciplines is only to connect her heart to her hand so that she might be with and for Heather as God is with and for its all as his very Ministry in the world.
• DISCUSSION AND REFLECTION EXERCISE
A Protocol for Critical Reading
Critical reading often is assumed to have three elements:22
1. The epistemological: What schools of knowledge is the author coming from or looking to bring together?
2. The experiential: How do these schools of knowledge relate to you? Do you find them helpful in articulating your reality or the reality you perceive?
3. The communicative: What do you find helpful in this author's argument? What do you find unhelpful or underdeveloped?
Each participant should answer these questions for the three elements of critical reading and then present the answers to each other, allowing ample time for discussion.
