14 Doubt and Confirmation The Mentor as Co-doubter
ANDREW ROOT
had just graduated from high school weeks earlier when our family mini van approached the airport. As I entered the terminal, my anticipation gave me the feeling of floating, tethered to the polished floor only by the large bags of luggage I dragged behind me. My eyes scanned the space for a herd of fellow high-school students draped in the same blue T-shirts that read "missions trip '93." Our church, located in suburban Minnesota, was sending a handful of high-school students and their leaders to Trinidad and Tobago, the southernmost islands in the Caribbean. Not only had I never been out of the country, but neither had any member of my family, though we had traveled a lot: to Disney World once and the Florida panhandle most spring breaks. And my dad flew west a few times a month for work. But I would be the first one in our family to leave the U.S.
We gathered to check our luggage with our parents surrounding us; their apprehension and anxiety mixed with our adolescent excitement made the scene electric. I can remember the parents discussing with each other how such a trip never happened in their day and how thankful (though nervous) they were that the church was giving their child such opportunities to see the world. This was something only a stint in the military would have done a generation or two ago.
The trip itself was filled with dichotomies. We left the beautiful, modern Miami airport, where we spent our two-hour layover shoveling cheeseburg ers into our mouths, to laud in a little rundown airport in Port of Spain. That night we visited impoverished local churches; the next day we walked around the downtown mall. We traveled to a small village, almost untouched by modernization, to run a VBS, then spent the next day bodysurfing and eating shark sandwiches as we baked our upper Midwestern bodies in the Caribbean sun. We sang songs for the poorest of the elderly in the government nursing homes, and then spent our last two days on the resort island of Tobago, sipping (virgin) cocktails under beach umbrellas, buying souvenirs and wasting our parents' spending money. It was a mission trip, mixed with a vacation. It was global service mixed with global tourism.
The short-term mission trip has become a staple of contemporary youth ministry. While camp was the core activity of youth ministry in the 1970s, and the eighties to mid-nineties featured the concert-like big event, today the mission trip has become central. Of course, young people still go to camps-as Kenda's earlier chapter beautifully reflects on-and there are a number of concert-like events still going. But the mission trip, it appears, has become "the" youth ministry activity. Whether it is to Mexico, Chicago, Africa, Appalachia, India or South Dakota, every summer the church sends its adolescent children to the ends of the earth. But to do what? "To serve, to evangelize, to grow in their faith" are usually the answers we give as we raise money for the trips and justify their central place on our calendars. Service and mission seem more noble and, dare we say "holy," than stadium-filled Christian rock concerts sprinkled with funny speakers. And no doubt service and mission happen. But often, for most of us, these shortterm mission trips embody mind-spinning contradictions. In living with the poor for a while before hitting the water park, or serving the hungry a meal before shopping for souvenirs, kids learn how to pray together as well as surf; they see poverty and pain as well as the local sights. So why has the short-term mission trip become central to what youth ministries do? And why do these dichotomies exist?
The escalation of short-term youth ministry mission trips has much to do with our cultural and societal transformations, as our parents gave testimony to when my high-school group checked our luggage for Trinidad. It is connected to the arrival of globalization. Globalization has made its all into travelers across time and space. The mission trip appeals to us all because it allows its to enter the streams of a globalized world, to move physically as we do continually through the Internet, satellite television and cell phones. But moving in the strong currents of globalization also thrusts its into what sociologist Zygmunt Bauman calls moving as either tourists or vagabonds. And this might just be a problem, a problem that makes it difficult to extract the tourism from our youth ministry mission trips. So how should we theologically grapple with mission trips that so often can slide into global tourism?
MOVING WITH MOVERS
"Nowadays we are all on the move," Bauman asserts.' We are either moving our bodies across miles in our cars or planes, or, if we are not physically moving, the world is moving to its as our devices and technologies broadcast the world into our living rooms. We spend most of our time looking at windows that move us across time and space; with a flip of the channel or a click of the mouse we are moving, and moving quickly. Rarely are we still; our way of being in the world is one of motion, and motion across massive space in a short time. "There are no `natural borders' any more," states Bauman, "neither are there obvious places to occupy. Wherever we happen to be at the moment, we cannot help knowing that we could be elsewhere, so there is less and less reason to stay anywhere in particular." When time and space can be traversed with such speed, constant movement becomes operative.
But what is the fuel for this constant movement? What propels its and then keeps its moving? According to Bauman, it is consumption. Where past generations were bound to the land or the next turn of the conveyor belt, in our world we are pushed to want and want more, to crave and desire anew in the glare of a constantly available and changing world. Our society is a consumer society; it calls not for duty, service or loyalty, but only for its to want new things and to continue moving to get them. We must move to stay tip with fashion, to hear new music, to harvest new experiences, to see new films, to formulate new identities. Moreoever, as Bauman says, the compression of time and space due to technology "takes the waiting out of wanting." We can get whatever we want whenever we want it. Amazon, iTunes and eBay are always open; my credit card limit allows nie to get where and what I want now, even if I can't afford it. Thus, as globalization flattens out boundaries, pulling time and space together, consumption keeps its constantly on the move.
It is no wonder then that adolescents are drawn to mission trips. They are movers; every minute they are moving in and out of new space, and the mission trip offers these movers a chance to go, to move into a new space and there harvest new and unique experiences. It is therefore not unusual in youth ministry for kids who have had no interest in youth group, Bible study or confirmation to sign up for a mission trip. As constant movers they are adventurers, and little seems more adventurous than going to Mexico or Thailand. The mission trip is an opportunity to live into their cultural way of being; it is a chance to move, and an occasion to consume new experiences in new space. Bauman says it this way: "Consumers are first and foremost gatherers of sensations; they are [not just] collectors of things."3
It is not that young people are not fully invested in the experience; any good consumer is always fully invested in the moment of the experience. The problem is that the mission trip is just that-just an experience, a sensation. And it is here that the dichotomies that many of us feel reveal themselves. An adolescent fully moved by the poverty of a village, for example, quickly moves on to become the purchaser of a hot new purse. It is not that the moment of encountering poverty was not real and significant; indeed, it was. It is just that she has moved on; the experience of poverty has become just that, an experience. It cannot bog her down; she must keep moving. And while she may go home and start an initiative to help people in that village, she will do this also as a mover, harvesting the sensations of "doing something" and then moving on to prom, choir and SAT prep. After a while, her constant moving and acquiring of new experiences and sensations will encourage her to forget her experience on the mission trip. Again, it is not that it does not matter to her; rather, it has simply become an old experience. The sensation lacks the electricity or flavor it once had, like a piece of gum chewed for too long. She will need a new or similar sensation to remind her of the trip, or else she will spit it out and forget it altogether. For the adolescent mover, the mission trip becomes like the $150 pair of shoes she had to have last year that has now been abandoned. It is not her fault; it is just the way of constant moving in a globalized world of consumers.
TOURISTS AND VAGABONDS
Two kinds of movers. For Bauman, this constant moving has changed the very organization of social life. He contends that the days of bourgeois and proletariat (a rigid class system) have disappeared in the transformations of globalization; it makes little sense to speak of a working-class culture any more. Everyone, he explains, whether rich or poor, must always be moving. So in this consumer-saturated world, all young people are focused on having the same experiences; all desire sensation. A Latino adolescent in east L.A. and a white suburban adolescent in Illinois, for example, are chasing the same experiences (though in many ways, urban youth set the terms for what is "in" for suburban kids): they listen to the same music, idolize the same sports stars and laugh at the same movies. Their worlds are radically different but they are both movers.
Yet by no means does this constant state of movement lead to a kind of cultural equality or a culture without stratification; rather, it is that this stratification has been transformed, like everything else in a globalized world. Instead of seeing the world divided between aristocrats and the working class, Bauman sees our world divided between tourists and vagabonds. Both are propelled to move and keep moving, but their experiences of moving are very different. The tourists are those with means, those who are free to move and who are welcomed by others as they seek new experiences. The world is theirs. Vagabonds, on the other hand, are not welcomed by others. Forced to move, they must hide in the shadows and cross fences and boundaries to find work. Though they want to stay home (and no longer be a vagabond), the globalized world that allows tourists to keep moving and having new experiences and sensations forces vagabonds to go in seek of work and sanctuary, all with the hope that one day they too will have the means to be a tourist. And it is in the very places built for tourists-at resorts and airports, for example-that the vagabond finds work as a servant. So the existence of both tourist and vagabond is due to our constant state of motion, but one serves the other. All vagabonds really want, thanks to our shared consumer society, is to be tourists, while the deepest fear of tourists is that they might become a vagabond, an everpresent threat when tourism is achieved through credit.
For the tourist, space is liquid, and easily molded. A tourist can easily jump from one space to the next; it is time that she must concern herself with (hence the need for PDAs, iPhones and conferences on time-management skills). At any given time she knows that she could be in another place if she wished. She is at work, for example, but she could be at home; she is in Baltimore, but she could be with her sister in Baton Rouge.
The vagabond lives the reverse. Space contains him, and he cannot easily traverse it. Cemented in his village, borough or project, he is aware, through technology, of a world that could be reached, but he has no means to do so. Or, when forced to move to find work, he is aware of every step; every mile hurts. Time does not slip through his hands like it does for the tourist but rather is heavy, slow and often oppressive as he serves.
Tourists go and do things (jet ski, visit museums, get massages, rack tip frequent flier miles). Vagabonds go and bear things (the reality of serving tourists, being forced to move when their desire is to stay home, inhospitable places where they hope to find welcome, another long ten-hour shift). When space is easy to jump, doing becomes operative; we continue to move so we can do new and more things, so we can have new and unique sensations through new experiences. But when time is stagnant and heavy and space is a cage or a long desert road, we are forced to simply be, to yearn but to be left without. We may want new sensations but we are left with only the place we're in and the many experiences of impossibility.
The tourism trap. Our mission trips are immersed in contradiction (spending the morning serving the poor and the afternoon sipping cocktails) because at their core they carry out the dichotomy between tourists and vagabonds. The mission trip is a tourist event, but one that, most insidiously, uses vagabonds as its activities. We go and do things, like good tourists, but instead of those things being spas and surf lessons (things vagabonds facilitate for its as low-paid employees of our resorts), we enter the villages, homes and neighborhoods of vagabonds to do things for themthings that often seem to be done without conversation with the vagabonds themselves. They become passive and we become active, but we never really meet each other. When the mission trip is global tourism, it is always about doing. Our trip brochures therefore explain what we will do, how we will minister and serve, with details about the building project, Bible puppet program or soup kitchen volunteering. And when we come back, we report to the congregation what we did and often evaluate our success by saying, "It was a great trip! We built a wing on the church, delivered food, led three worship services, passed out fifty Bibles and put on a VBS for one hundred kids." We could just as easily say, "The vacation was excellent! I played two rounds of golf, saw two shows, rented one paddle boat and ate two porterhouse steaks."
Moreover, when our mission trips are about doing something, then like good tourists we are free to move on and eventually forget them; we did our part and can now keep on moving. The mission trip becomes locked in our digital photos, organized and presented as a great experience, and shown to the congregation through slide shows and music that give them the sensation of being there, of having had the experience themselves. But once the photos are on our hard drive they are labeled as old experiences, worthy of nostalgia but not subject to the judgment of our day-to-day life and our vocational call to open up our being to others.
FROM DOING TO BEING
If we want to avoid the tourist trap on mission trips, we must focus not on doing but on being. Adolescents and their parents ask, "What will we do?" But if our purpose for going is not first for doing but for being with, the question becomes, "Who will we be with?" "Who will we be encountering?" Our mission trips should be focused on simply being with people. They should be about seeing, hearing and sharing existence with othersothers who are living as unwanted vagabonds in our world of tourism.
The way to break the dichotomy of the tourist trap is to cater the perplexity and impossibility of the vagabond: in other words, it's to go to the cross. Global tourism as mission trip lives in the streams of what we do, but a mission trip that breaks the tourist cycle focuses on who God is and what God does. This does not mean there is nothing to be done. Rather, instead of our doing-seeking to solve problems which we are, if we are honest, too small to solve-we go and join a people to together yearn, hope and (yes) work for God's future.
In this view, the mission trip becomes as much about confession as action; it is recognizing the impossibility that confronts real people and seeing how we (the tourists) benefit from it. We then invite adolescents not to participate in the sensation of helping others but instead (in fear and trembling) to enter the perplexity and impossibility of others-which, if we're willing to admit it, is similar to the song of our own broken humanity. The mission trip is therefore an invitation to go and seek for God in the hidden, backward, incognito suffering of the vagabond; it's an invitation to go and suffer with others, not solve their problems. Instead of kids feeling empowered because they have done something (what a great experience!), they should return perplexed, recognizing how knotted the world is and how our own advantage as tourists is borne on the backs of vagabonds. They should go home having sought to understand another as near to God and therefore able to see their own lives and recognize their connection and disconnection from others who are forced to live as vagabonds.
At root, mission trips are about accompaniment, not activity. They're about seeing the thinness of our sensationalized, always-moving world through shared life with others. The mission trip, then, is not participating in global tourism but seeking to go and find the crucified Christ who is revealed in the suffering humanity of the vagabond. It is about being with.
WHAT NOW?
But how do we live into this? How do we escape the tourist trap of doing a nd instead help young people and ourselves simply but profoundly seek the God of the cross by being with others? Karl Barth, in an article called "The Community for the World,"4 offers three broad assertions about what the faithful community's inclination is to the world. These three dispositions that the church is to take toward the world can help its avoid the dichotomy often present in our mission trips and instead see them as accompaniment.
Barth's first point is that "the true community ... seeks to know the world as it is." He continues, "To know the world means concretely to know [humanity], to see with free and unclouded eyes who, what, where and how [humans] exist. It thus means to be constantly aware, both as a whole and in detail, both inwardly and outwardly, of what is involved in [humanity's] existence."6 We might then ask ourselves, How are we preparing young people to see? It is not unusual for us to teach them to pound nails or practice skits before going on our trips. But are we taking steps to prepare them to see? Are we asking them to read material from indigenous people, or watch a documentary on a similar village? How are we helping them understand the financial and political situations of the community? Do we do any work that prepares them to recognize their (our) own cultural place and stereotypes? It is more important that we seek to make them truly aware than that we make them sensitive travelers, so that they can bear reality with those we meet.
Second, Barth states, "The true community ... practices solidarity with humanity."7 It is not enough to just see and be aware. We must also find solidarity; we must find ways to wrap our own humanity around the humanity of these others. It is here that the sensation-seeking tendency is broken, for sensation can become aware but it cannot find solidarity. In finding solidarity our being is changed; because we have entered so deeply into the suffering of the other, our world looks different. How might we do this on our trips? It means going and actually living with the people we encounter. It means that the church enters into a partnership with a community and congregation so that, instead of going to do, we go to be with these partners to share their table, to enter their ministry. It means that we go with no packaged ministry (puppet shows, skits, etc.) but instead go to participate in the already active ministry of our partner. In essence, it means that the trip is about learning-learning about a people, learning about the ministry of the church in another place-not about the sensation of doing something.
Finally, Barth asserts, "The true community ... is given to humanity to be under obligation to the world."8 In our world of moving, where waiting has been stripped away from wanting, obligation is seen as destroying freedom, and thus tantamount to prison. But when we understand our obligation, we are kept from believing that we have already done our part and can therefore move on. This means there can be no "drive-by" mission trips. Rather, having gone and seen in solidarity, we are called to take these others into our own community and life. In other words, when the mission trip is over we must not only find ways to continue the partnership but must also work to keep bringing the trip back into the life of the community. This can be done by discussing political and cultural issues, and by inviting these others we have met to affect the way we read the Bible and the topics we discuss. It means taking on the obligation to be hospitable to all vagabonds, and seeking to make the world aware of their presence and treacherous movement.
CONCLUSION
As I stood with my youth group in the airport that day just after my highschool graduation, dressed in our matching blue T-shirts, no one mentioned anything like this. No one challenged its to go and for at least one week bear the suffering of others who live so differently from our suburban American way of being. No one told its that God is found on a cross, in places of brokenness and emptiness, or suggested that we go to be in these places, to stare them down and seek God in them. So I boarded the plane and embarked on my great global vacation, all sponsored and made possible by the church. But this church, the church, is a church of vagabonds as well as tourists, and it is time that the short-term mission trip think more theologically about what it is we are sending these (mostly) middle-class young people to experience. I hope we can help them to see!
• DISCUSSION AND REFLECTION EXERCISE
Critical Incident-Thinking Theologically
Think back over the last experience you had on a mission trip (you could have been a participant, a leader or a planner).9 Describe, in as specific, concrete and honest a fashion as you can, the following details:
1. The incident(s) on the mission trip that you recall as being the most theologically significant/important. In other words, what was the high of the trip? Why was it a high?
2. The incident that you recall as being the most distressing on the trip. Why was it distressing? Does it have any theological significance?
3. What characteristics or actions do you feel have been or could be the most theologically honest in relation to mission trips?
4. What experiences affirmed you on these trips? What experiences affirmed those in the location you served?
5. What did you learn about yourself, others, the church and God on these trips?
After answering these questions, look for themes. For instance,
• What are common themes about the mission trips we go on?
• What common themes arise in relation to our activity with and for other people?
• What common theological themes or issues do you see?
• What advice would you give others (or yourself) as they prepare for their next mission trip?
