6 Youth Ministry as Discerning Christopraxis A Hermeneutical Model
ANDREW ROOT
yan' had just finished his first semester of seminary classes. I was still in college, just a freshman. In our personal conversations he was brewing with insight, combusting with new information and thoughts. As we traveled together to the ninth-grade confirmation retreat, where we would be counselors, he spoke of the need to take kids deep, to get them to understand and dwell on the tradition of their faith. "Youth ministry is about theology. It's taking kids inside the Word," he asserted with great passion. I nodded; this sounded important. He mentioned that youth ministry had spent way too much time on activities, fun and programs; it was time to do theology with young people. I nodded again; deep within me I wanted this as well, though I had no idea what it would mean, since I had very little experience myself thinking theologically. I could barely spell the word and had no idea what he meant when he referenced exegesis, soteriology and covenantal theology. I just kept nodding to hide my ignorance. As the car pulled into the camp that would be the site for our retreat, he said, "I'm going to give it to them. I think young people are thirsting for it; I'm going to give them theology at this retreat." "Sounds great," I said as I slammed the door and entered the electric chaos of a ninth-grade retreat.
The next afternoon it was Ryan's turn to lead the teaching time of the retreat. He grabbed his Bible, pulled a stool to the front, sat down, breathed in deeply and began to teach. Ryan talked straight for fifty-five minutes, weaving in and out of conversations on redemption, Israelite sacrificial practice, theories of atonement and authorship of epistles. He even parsed a few Greek verbs. It was clearly not the programmatic, activity-centered youth ministry he had critiqued in the car. But as I sat there, trying myself to follow his explosion of facts, theories and musings, it was also clear that none of it (nattered to the ninth graders and that all of them were somewhere else, passing notes or simply daydreaming of times and locations beyond the theological oppression of this seemingly never-ending moment.
The session ended, and the ninth graders sprinted to their cabins in hopes that they could outrun the convoluted minutiae that seemed to ooze out of our meeting room and its theological focus. As the leaders gathered, Ryan stood among its painted with both confusion and confidence. He admitted that the young people seemed less than engaged, but he stood his ground, asserting that it was what they needed. "What is essential is that we provide them with theology," he continued to repeat. It was clear both that Ryan was unmovable and that he needed this perspective to keep him from facing the utter disappointment of the experience. Some of us tried to reassure him. "It was good. I'm sure they got something out of it," we said, knowing our words were false but hoping our encouragement would keep him from crumbling. "We just have to keep pushing," Ryan continued. "Right now they may not like theology, but it's important, so we just have to keep giving them theology, even if they don't like it."
As Ryan concluded, Joyce, a wise sixty-year-old grandma who had been a longtime volunteer in the youth ministry, piped up. So far in the conversation she had been quiet, but in that moment she said these prophetic words: "Maybe it's not that they don't care about theology, but maybe what we provided them tonight wasn't theology." That's all she said. We all turned to stare at her for a few seconds, wanting to ask for more but not sure what to say; it was clear her response was significant. And her words have remained with me.
In these pages we have been arguing that youth ministry has taken a theological turn, one to which we hope this book adds momentum. In this new turn, youth ministry has remained committed to cultural, psychological and pragmatic reflection, but it's the theological, the practical theology, as Kenda asserted at the end of the last chapter, that has begun to slide to the center of youth ministry thought. Both academics and practitioners seem to be awakening to the importance of theology for youth ministry.
In the four chapters above we've sought to free theology from confinement in libraries of academic institutions and instead return it to the place of concrete communities of faith. We've been pushing you to see the work you do in youth ministry as fundamentally a theological task.' The word ministry, after all, is a theological word; it no doubt has something to do with human action (the things that ministers-whether ordained, paid or lay-do), but it also has a great amount to do with what God does, as the One who ministers to the world for the sake of its salvation in the fullness of God's future.3 If theology's "task is to apprehend, understand, and speak of `God,"' youth ministry should follow this, seeking to apprehend, understand and speak of God in the lives of young people.4
But as my story above highlights, this thinking theologically is not easy, or at least, it has been easily confused for something else, something that in the end becomes meaningless to young people and frustrating for those in ministry, making theology seem always beyond reach. So if youth ministry is in the process of taking a theological turn, both in its thought and action, what does this mean? And if this theological turn is necessary and good, how should a youth worker go about thinking theologically in a way that avoids meaninglessness and frustration?
Ryan may have been right those many years ago about the need for young people to be drawn into thinking deeply about their faith, but in the end his form of theological reflection seemed disconnected from young people's reality and too uninteresting to capture their imagination. But if theology is ultimately about a God who enters our existence for the sake of life through death, then it's hard to label theological construction itself as meaningless and frustratingly boring. Thinking theologically is not necessarily about erudition and puking facts and big words on young people. As Joyce's words point its to, thinking theologically may, if we can conceptualize it correctly, not only become significant for our orientation as youth workers (seeing ourselves as local practical theologians), but may also in the end impact young people, drawing them into deep thought about self, world and, most importantly, God.
Therefore, what seems to be needed as youth ministry takes this theological turn is an understanding (a picture) of how theology itself is constructed, and how it is that you go about thinking theologically with and for young people. And, since theological construction is itself a practice of ministry, we're not only being theologians when we learn to articulate it; we're also doing ministry.
CRISIS OF REALITY
To do theological reflection, especially theological reflection that is connected to ministry, we must first ask, "What does theology start with?" or "What does theology look to address?" It's in answering these questionsthe first step of theological construction-that we perhaps make the biggest mistake. Too often we have assumed that theology begins with either dogma (especially if you're in a conservative context) or societal milieu (if you're in a liberal one). By confusing our very starting point, we thereby take a step that actually moves us away from the content of theological reflection.
Ultimately, theology starts with a crisis, the very crisis of reality itself. The crisis is the fact that you live, that you have a life to live. The crisis is the very fact that there is something instead of nothing. The crisis is the very mystery of our existence and the yearning for there to be some kind of meaning to it. But this crisis pushes us even further down this road. Theology is reflection and articulation of God's action, and God's very action in the world is a crisis. When God speaks, making Godself known, we find ourselves in the crisis of encounter. Theology seeks to speak of the crisis of an infinite God who encounters finite human beings, and does so in backwards ways (like the foolishness of the cross).'
Theology, then, begins with the crisis of God's action, which reveals that we are near death, that our reality (our very person) is opposed to or stands in opposition to the infinite God. To encounter God and God's Word is to encounter our limit (no one sees God and lives). The very fact that God has broken in to make Godself known is a crisis; it calls all that is into question. As Luther has said, "God first kills before God makes alive"6-but not because God is vicious; quite the opposite is true. God first kills because God's action of love stands over against all that is. In other words, his love-and therefore all love-kills because it calls us beyond all that stands in opposition to it. God's love, then, is a crisis that calls the regularity of reality into question. Out of love God's very being calls all that is back to God, thrusting all that is into question in relation to God's love. God's action is a crisis because out of love it seeks to address the crisis of human existence. Therefore, the crisis is God's love and our unbelief; the crisis is God's desire to be with its and our movement toward isolation, death and annihilation. And theology is reflection on God's action, which reveals our .7
Theological reflection therefore begins with giving attention to God in relation to the crisis of existence itself. Ryan's so-called theological exposition was irrelevant to the young people listening because it said nothing of the crisis of existence. Theology, in his mind, was not to address the crisis of existence-the crisis of death and limit in light of the love and grace of God. Theology was instead about facts and theories. It was meaningless to young people because nothing was at stake; it was frustratingly boring because it had nothing to do with the beauty and pain of our fundamental existence. Douglas John Hall points out, "For the most part the paradigm of prayer we are given in the Psalms and in other parts of the Bible suggests a spontaneous and utterly honest wrestling of the human spirit with the Spirit of God."8
Attention to crisis reveals that there is something universal that theology attends to. If theology begins with dogma or the societal milieu, it ultimately only has something to say to the believer, and only the believer that is beyond doubt. But when theology begins with our shared crisis, it speaks to the core of the human condition, to the crisis all of its (believer or not) face. From our perspective as the human knowers we can see the crisis of reality in two broad forms.'
Time and eternity. The first form of the crisis of reality is the problem of time and eternity. We are living but we are moving toward death, and there is no stopping it; life is to be lived in joy, happiness and fulfillment, but even at its greatest, it is ending. We now are, but soon we will not be. Theology begins with the assertion that there is a qualitative distinction between time and eternity? God and God's love are eternal, but we are like the grass on the field, passing away (1 Pet 1:24). We are caught within time and cannot escape it. This is a crisis because, though we can imagine eternity (at least as a category) and imagine living beyond the constraint of time, we cannot actualize it. We are stuck with the fact that (most) all things atrophy or move into something different: the innocence of childhood gives way to the pessimism of adulthood, our favorite shirt wears thin, our hairline recedes, our little children grow and move on. We are caught in the stream of time, and its currents are too strong for us to scramble for the riverbank.
Not only are we passing away, though; we're also infinitely small. It is a crisis to watch NOVA (the PBS science show) and discover that there are black holes in the universe that are even now eating entire galaxies. Our minds cannot even fathom the expanse of the universe. In the midst of time and space we are but dust, and yet God has acted. In love God has sought to place God's own being, which is eternal, with our beings that are so quickly fading to nothingness.
When we take young people on outdoor trips (backpacking in the mountains, canoeing, camping, etc.) we usually ignore this crisis, making the trip instead about beauty, about experiencing God's created beauty away from the rush of modern life. This is important, but we're missing the theological potential these trips offer. Being next to mountains, leaning against trees, thrusts its into the very crisis of time and eternity. We do theological reflection with young people when we say, "See these mountains? They've been here for millions of years and they may be here a million more. They've been here long before you and will be here still long after you're gone. Who is this God, then? And who are we that this is our state-that we are and exist but are also so quickly passing away?"
It is amazing how often adolescents have these thoughts and conversations with their friends, lying on a basement floor at sleepovers or sitting on the grass looking at the sky on a lazy summer night. Young people know the crisis, but too often we are too busy trying to give them theology (or something else) that we don't see that theology begins with the crisis of reality itself-with the fact that, though we can imagine a world without suffering and death, we can't escape the one we're in, where we are and will soon not be.
Our existence as social beings. The second form of the crisis of reality is the problem of existence as social beings. We are caught in time and infinitely small in comparison to the universe, but we nevertheless are-we exist-even if only for a fleeting amount of time. This problem of existing as a social being is encompassed within the question we face throughout our short, small lives: What is a lifetime and why do we live it? In a word, this is the problem of self-awareness, awareness that we have a life to live. As Kenda articulated so well in the last chapter, we are awakened to selfawareness in late childhood and early adolescence. It's in adolescence, then, that we begin to discover that there is a question mark wrapped around our very being. And it's in adolescence that we are still too much of a cultural neophyte to ignore how tightly the question mark is squeezing our diaphragm, making it hard to breath.
The crisis is that some are rich while others are poor, and that they're in this state, so it seems, by blind luck. The crisis is that we are aware of many who live broken, caught, oppressed, overwhelmed by impossibility. What is a lifetime and why do we live it when we so quickly are no more and when so many, even now in their short lives, are overwhelmed by poverty, isolation and pain? Even if we can avoid these things we must live wanting more, wanting to be known, loved and understood more fully than it seems possible for others to do. The crisis is that, though God is justice, we lack justice; that life seems so unfair; that we are always, it seems, left yearning. What is the future in the collision of brokenness-melting ice caps, shattered families, a decreasing job market, betrayal-and God's love? Douglas John Hall discusses this crisis in relation to his own journey of becoming a theologian.
I could not become a theologian in earnest until I had allowed myself to be plunged into the growing darkness of my own time.... As Tillich would have said, I could not really be trusted with "the theological answer" until I had learned for myself "the human question"in all of its specificity, its here-and-nowness.... Luther, too, understood this: "I did not learn my theology all at once," he declared, "but I had to search deeper for it-where my temptations took me!" We need to lose our "answers" if we are going to find an answer that actually engages the real question-which is not just the questions we ask, but the question that we are, individually and collectively."
So much of what we do in youth ministry is uninteresting, meaningless or (dare I say) boring because it doesn't start in the perplexity of the crisis. And we can't bear seeing the crisis as our starting point in ministry because it's a starting point that thrusts its into theology. We therefore tend to turn our attention to programs, thinking activity can provide the excitement that our uninteresting theology cannot. But constructing theology (especially theology in relation to ministry) means starting knee-deep in the crisis. Sunday school, VBS and ninth-grade confirmation retreats are boring and meaningless not because we haven't given students more theology but because we have often tried to do theology beyond the crisis. Theology is utterly meaningless, though, when it's too busy with other things to direct itself toward the very crisis of reality itself. A theologically engaged youth group or retreat is one that begins by inviting young people to face the crisis and begin to articulate their deep questions and experiences of being stuck, small or broken. In other words, a theologically rich ministry begins with inviting young people to articulate what haunts them.
Figure 5.1. The crisis of reality
Ryan, who sought to give young people theology, did not understand that theology is something constructed with others, not something we give. And it's constructed with adolescents, as Kenda asserted in the last chapter, because it's born next to the crisis that God is God and we are Hot; we are passing away and stuck in questions without answers. Theological construction that means anything to young people is theology that dwells in questions with no easy answers-not theology that simply provides answers, as Ryan believed. Indeed, to be a theologian as a youth worker is to walk into the crisis of reality, seeking God in the questions raised.
ADDRESSING THE CRISIS
Tradition. While theology begins with the crisis of reality, it doesn't stop there. Theology is not satisfied with simply articulating the crisis; it also seeks to address it. And the first move in addressing the crisis is turning to Tradition (with a capital T). By "Tradition" I mean the very core (the dogma) of Christianity (the triune God, the full humanity and divinity of Christ, the pouring out of the Spirit, the centrality of Scripture, the being and acting of the church, etc.). This very Tradition is what makes Christianity Christianity. When it's used as the starting point for theology, however, it's wooden and dead, because it calls its to ignore the crisis, to stop thinking and simply assimilate. What brings Tradition to life is the very thing that moved it from contemplation to dogma: its ability to address the crisis. In other words, the Tradition is the way faith seeks understanding in engagement with the crisis of reality.
The essentials of the Tradition are essentials because they have been seen to be true, but they have only been seen to be true because they have said something true in relation to the crisis of reality itself, not because they are rational or provable. Simply put, they have said something "real." In late modernity, when societies and people are no longer held together by some kind of shared tradition (Anthony Giddens), it is all the more important for us to recognize that our Tradition is authoritative because it's trustworthy, and it's trustworthy because it has been shown to be a faithful way to address the crisis of reality.12
As youth ministers who are theologians, we must see the Tradition as the beautiful treasure (dogma, the essential core of what makes the Tradition the Tradition, i.e., that Jesus Christ has borne the crisis) it is-a treasure that speaks of life in the midst of death and hope in a world of despair, that articulates the essence of the beliefs of those who trust in the life and the death of the One who has overcome death with life. Unfortunately, Ryan believed that doing theology meant simply passing on the Tradition-getting kids to swallow it and know it rationally. The Tradition was therefore meaningless to the adolescents because it was no longer living, no longer meeting them in the midst of their questions on the road of their human journey.
This approach to Tradition is what has made catechesis such a difficultand many times failing-effort in youth ministry. And I think it's the reason why so many Christian young people-even highly committed onesknow so little about their faith (as Christian Smith has documented ill Soul Searching). Catechesis has been a failure because we've been confused about its role; like Ryan, we've used it to assimilate adolescents into the Tradition, and have tried to get them to know it like they know their multiplication tables and to give it the same degree of importance as their sport, their friendship group and their grades. This, however, makes for boring and often meaningless Sunday school and confirmation classes for youth. Instead, we need to see theological reflection as placing the Tradition in conversation with the crisis of reality itself (there is something like Gadamer's fusion of horizons here). When Tradition is engaged through the crisis, little case needs to be made for its significance. Though it may still be judged as wrong or unhelpful, it cannot be judged as benign, irrelevant and uninteresting. To be a theologian in the context of ministry is to dwell deeply in the Tradition, to even kerygmatically confess and proclaim it, but to do so turned toward the crisis of reality itself.
Tradition and Scripture. There are three elements under Tradition that the youth-worker-as-theologian uses to address the crisis. The first is Scripture. Scripture and Tradition exist in a kind of dialectical relationship. The Tradition is considered normative because of Scripture. Scripture asserts that Jesus Christ is Lord; our very dogma is bound within Scripture itself. But we always read Scripture through Tradition, that is, we read it through the lens of thousands of readers who have cone before its and who have molded our dogma and our communities through their own reading. No one can read Scripture free or outside of the Tradition-indeed, it's a hermeneutical impossibility-because Scripture is the story of a people and the book of a people, and these people (Israel and the church) exist within the stream of a shared history, a shared Tradition. So, for example, when we read in the Gospels about Jesus teaching his disciples to pray, we are reminded of how and when we have prayed the sane prayer he taught them in our communities (before Communion, for instance). If we stop and reflect we'll realize that people of this Tradition have been saying the Lord's Prayer for over two thousand years.
But what makes Scripture normative? What has made it the essential material for constructing our Tradition is that it addresses the crisis of reality itself. It speaks of a God who enters reality, making Godself known as the One who enters this crisis to address it, to overcome death for the sake of new life with God's very self." We complain often about young people being biblically illiterate, but I think we have too rarely shown them how Scripture itself addresses our crisis. If we would do so we could help them see that Scripture is living.
There's a misconception in youth ministry that what makes something theological is how many bullet-pointed Bible verses the worksheet, talk or book contains. In truth, seeing Scripture theologically means seeing it as the story of God engaging creation in the midst of its crisis, and recognizing that we never read this sacred text alone but are always reading it within the community of Tradition. Ignoring these facts is just rigid biblicalism.
Tradition and traditions. The second element under Tradition is tradition (with a lowercase t). While there is a shared Tradition (dogma) that encompasses all of Christianity, there are also multiple traditions that make up a beautiful mosaic within the larger Tradition. This is more than denominationalism, which, with its bureaucracy, can lead to unneeded conflict and the stunting of the ministry of the church; indeed, too often these distinct traditions have seen themselves as in a battle for a piece of the religious market (in this sense they are unhelpful).
But another way to view these multiple perspectives (like Catholic, Lutheran, Pentecostal, Reformed and Wesleyan traditions) is to see them as particular ways of addressing the crisis of reality. In other words, these traditions are discrete ways that communities of thought and life have sought to articulate who this God is that has acted in the world-most fully through Jesus Christ-and what this God is tip to. When these distinct traditions become insular and have as their main goal the perpetuation and existence of their perspective, they have ossified into something unhelpful. But when they exist as the perpetuators of distinct thoughts and practices in relation to an interpretation of the crisis of reality itself, they are great treasures to the church.
I once had someone ask me if I knew of a book written on Presbyterian youth ministry. This person was thinking of writing a book on Lutheran youth ministry and was already aware of books on Catholic youth ministry. I asked if the book would have a theological focus or only a denominational one, to which he responded that he didn't see a difference. I have to admit that the more he talked, the more boring (and meaningless) I found his proposal. It made the tradition the end, rather than a vehicle to articulate, dwell in and address the crisis of reality. I suggested that he write a book on youth ministry drawing from the Lutheran tradition instead. The traditions are rich theological perspectives whose value lies not in being a world unto themselves but in being different ways of addressing the crisis of our social existence or finitude and God's action.
Tradition and dialogue partners. The third and the final element under Tradition is dialogue partners (we've already touched on this some in chapter two). As we seek to be theologians in youth ministry, it is essential that we start with the crisis and from there turn to the Tradition via Scripture and the theological depth of a tradition (or multiple ones), but it is also important for us to find for ourselves some dialogue partners-a theologian or two whom we can invite to journey with its. These dialogue partners may never be referenced directly when we're discussing the cross or baptism with young people, but being in conversation with one or two theologians by deeply reading their writings will make a great difference in our thought.
When Ryan was sitting before the ninth-grade confirmation class at the retreat, he had no big idea he was working from, Ho articulation of reality and God's action within it that could engage young people's imagination. He crisscrossed through multiple perspectives, leaving its with no real clue how they held together. A couple of dialogue partners could have given him a perspective on the Tradition (through his dialogue partner's reading of Scripture and own tradition) that then could have given him a sharper articulation of the crisis. Too often in youth ministry we spend our time reading how-to books or books on cultural analysis (which are all important), but it would benefit us greatly as theologians if we picked a dialogue partner or two and committed to reading and understanding their work.
Tradition, then, in its engagement of the crisis of reality, is an essential part of theological construction that fulfills the kerygmatic (proclamation) pole of theology (discussed in chapter three). When Tradition fails to address the crisis, it spirals into traditionalism, a dangerous viewpoint that sees theology as only about Tradition and ignores or avoids the crisis of reality itself. Figure 5.2 provides a map of how the church engages its Tradition, through its three elements, to address the crisis in a kerygmatic manner (to proclaim the gospel).
Figure 5.2. Tradition and the crisis of reality
Context. The understanding that theology itself is contextual has gained great momentum in the last few decades. Some argue that theology is always responding to issues within a context, but theology is also done in a place, which means its perspectives are always laced with contextual situations. This contextual reality should not be confused with the crisis of reality, however. Theology addresses the crisis, not primarily the context-or, better put, it addresses the context through the crisis. The crisis of reality is more than simply our contextual situatedness; all people (no matter the context) must face the limits of our existence. 14 But cultures have ways of providing practices and perspectives that give meaning to our crisis or even make its think we've transcended it. For instance, in the American context you can avoid the crisis by being a rich celebrity. So people go on reality TV shows, embarrassing themselves, not because they're stupid (not all of them, at least) but because this contextual creation promises the salvation of being a celebrity, someone hidden from the cold wind of the crisis.
In essence, theology is always contextual because it must engage its context's response to the crisis of reality itself (and it does so even if it doesn't intend to). Some may argue that the Tradition is a more trustworthy response to the crisis, and should therefore be given priority over context, because the Tradition (at its best) seeks to explicitly give language and vision to the crisis (even if it's scary-this is why over-positivity cannot be part of Christian theology, why a thing must be called what it is). But this does not eliminate the fact that the context itself seeks to address the crisis, and the fact that the Tradition, while more than the context, can only be known and lived out by those who live within the context and its response to the crisis. Moreover, the context's own operations that confront the crisis can, at their best, also challenge the Tradition with new perspectives that must be considered by it (see the arrow going from context to Tradition in figure 5.3).
On the other hand, every context also has much that seeks to pacify people, deceive people and keep people from reflecting too deeply on the crisis of reality. Indeed, our bureaucratic, economic, educational and even religious contextual structures often try to hold our attention and form our practices in ways that keep us from facing the crisis of reality. In these cases, the church, drawing on Tradition, must address the context and prophetically call it to at least see the crisis (while not necessarily calling it to assimilate to the church's perspective), and remind it that no matter how organized and productive its structures may be, it still has to face the crisis (see the arrow going from Tradition to context in figure 5.3).
The Tradition and context, then, are always in dialogue:" It is impossible for those doing theology to escape their context, and the Tradition must remind the context that the crisis exists and that it has responded to it, while the context calls the Tradition to deal with new and distinct perspectives and ideas that address the crisis of reality.
Because of all this, it's essential for us as theologians in ministry to engage context-not simply for relevance but because of the context's own engagement with the crisis of reality. Ryan saw little use in doing this to draw young people into theological contemplation. It seemed like a lightweight approach to him-like giving in to youth ministry's entertainment, activity-driven focus. What he failed to recognize is that theology is not simply about minds assimilating information; it's a way of living, a way of living that must be in dialogue with the context in which we live and its engagement with the crisis. In light of this, as we construct theology for ministry we must be conversant with the two broad ways that the context has sought to address the crisis of reality.
Art. The first way is art. Most often, art is an attempt to express something (even something nihilistic) about the crisis of time and eternity, about the constraints of our social existence, about the need for something transcendent. And it's usually loved or hated based on how it's interpreted: as being real, saying something real or making the participant feel something real.
In our time, especially in relation to younger people, art (at least as high culture) has been replaced by pop art or popular culture. Some may argue that pop culture is devoid of artistic expression, but that argument castrates art's function of addressing the crisis. (Besides, that is an old high culture argument.) Pop culture, with its popular form, may actually have much to say about the crisis of reality-so we should listen and engage it.16 Obviously, there are forms of it that seek only to distract people from the crisis; the church should oppose these, even the ones that are seemingly moral and benign but that actually seek to pacify us and keep us, through moral religion, from facing the crisis of reality (like Christian T-shirts, some Christian music, some children's entertainment). Overall, though, from a theological perspective, the context is seeking to address the crisis through (pop) art, and the church should honor these efforts, even if the church ultimately finds them (misguided or unhelpful.
Many young people listen to the music they listen to and watch the films they watch because of what they say about the crisis, and because of the ways the music and films give them meaning and practices for engaging reality. Thus, to do theological construction in ministry is to see (pop) art as making assertions about reality, which leads its into the dialogue between the context and Tradition as we seek to address the crisis. If Ryan had done this, theology could not have been judged as meaningless or frustratingly boring by young people. Difficult and perplexing, maybe, but not meaningless and boring if it was reflecting on the crisis of reality in conversation with the articulations of the Tradition and the students' deeply held artistic expressions of this reality.
The sciences. The second way the context has sought to address the crisis of reality is through science (whether social or hard). A misguided and ultimately idolatrous belief during high modernity was that science was king, that science would solve all human problems, that science would be our salvation. As we saw in the twentieth century, science can usher in the technology of hell as much as and maybe more than that of utopia. So while science can no longer be considered king-the unveiler of what is real and the solver of the crisis-it does nevertheless address the crisis and seeks to give its perspective on it. Physics, biology, sociology and psychology, for example, all confront the crisis of why there is something instead of nothing, of what a lifetime is and why we live it.
Of course, science can still become an idol when we think it possesses all the answers (as can Tradition if it has closed itself off from dialogue about the crisis), but when it's seen in its proper place, as seeking to explore the very crisis of reality through its instruments and perspectives, it is a valuable tool. Indeed, to tend to context in theological construction is to be in dialogue with science. The science, however, must be judged by its ability to say something to the crisis. If it can't, then it needs to be impounded and placed in the same lot as a theology that is more concerned with academic credibility than reality.
It is not unusual, at least for high schoolers, to feel like they're in conflict with science. For example, conservative young people often feel perplexed as they seek to make sense of evolution, while young people who are more liberal struggle with how to hold on to any authority within their Tradition in light of psychological studies. Unfortunately, though we as youth ministers may encourage conversation about these topics, we've often failed at providing young people in both groups times and venues where they can ask questions and talk with others about issues of science and faith and the crisis of reality.
What we need to do is place the crisis of reality as the starting point of theological construction. Then science (or art) cannot assume totality in its perspective, and the Tradition cannot ignore the context's (science's and art's) assertions about reality. And we can turn young people to reflect more deeply on the crisis not necessarily in an effort to find what is right (for "right" is a category of a rational epistemology that cannot bear the fullness of the crisis) but to discover what speaks with depth, hope and wonder about the crisis-in other words, what is true. Christianity, at its core, is not about rightness but about being encountered by truth. It is the call for faith to seek understanding next to a God who acts in the world of death, thinness and yearning.
Figure 5.3. Apologetics and the crisis of reality
In conversing with context this way-seeking to truly consider and understand the context's perspectives and situations-we honor the apologetic essence of theological construction (as Tradition honors the kerygmatic essence; see figure 5.3). But, just as there is a danger of the Tradition spinning into traditionalism when the crisis is not addressed, so too the context possesses its own dangers. If (pop) art and science believe that they can, in their operations, articulate the full totality of existence, and that they possess all truth, then they can spin into consumerism and positivism, respectively. Positivism clouds its from seeing the crisis because it believes that science knows all. And consumerism blinds its from the crisis by making its texts (movies, music) about numbing our minds instead of about opening its tip to see reality differently.
THEOLOGY AND PRAXIS
What all of the above asserts is that to make the crisis the focus of theological attention as we dialogue with the Tradition and the context is to see theology not as an academic exercise but as the very heart of ministry itself (see, in figure 5.4, the arrows moving to the heart of the picture, which is the praxis of ministry). In this light, the praxis of ministry comprises more than just defending a tradition or being culturally relevant. If the crisis is that God has acted and is acting, then ministry is confrontation with the crisis of reality and with God who is already there; participating in ministry is therefore participation with God where God can be found, in the crisis of reality in people's lives.
Figure 5.4. Practical theology and the crisis of reality
It's through this praxis of ministry in relation to the crisis, as the Tradition and context dialogue with it, that we have theology. In short, theology is the articulation of the crisis and God's act and being within it, so doing theology means turning to the crisis in ministry as we dialogue with the Tradition and the context (see the arrows in figure 5.4 that point from the praxis of ministry to theology).
Questions about existence, death and social location in relation to the possibility of God are asked from the core of our humanity and therefore call for theology that is done in ministry, in conversation and within the embrace of relational care." Ryan's talk that afternoon was not theology, as Joyce profoundly stated, but not because he didn't try or have the ideas right. It was not theology because it didn't mean anything; it didn't address the crisis that young people face, and it missed that theology is essentially a conversation (between Tradition and context) that leads us into ministry. Theology can only be constructed within the lives of people yearning for God in a world of death, life, love and brokenness. It was Luther, after all, who said, "It is by living-no rather, by dying and being damned-that a theologian is made, not merely by understanding reading and speculating."18
• DISCUSSION AND REFLECTION EXERCISE
Haunting Reflections Journal
The purpose of this journal is twofold.19 First, it can give you insight into your own existential reflections. In other words, you will become more aware of how you are confronting the crisis of reality in yourself and in the world. Second, it will help you discuss with others the theological significance of your own experiences with the crisis. Because theology is always done in community, you will be asked to share elements from the journal with others.
You should write about anything that haunts you and causes you to think deeply about the crisis of reality. However, it may help to frame it this way:
• Write one entry on a song (any song) that causes you to think deeply about your existence or the world.
• Describe in one entry a scene from a movie that haunted you, causing you to reflect on the question, What is a lifetime and why do we live it?
• Write one entry on a quote from a theologian (a quote that is not in this book) that has haunted you and caused you to think deeply about God and God's action in the world.
• Describe in one entry how a biblical text has haunted you and pushed you to see God, self, world and reality itself differently.
(Note: The leader should tell participants how many entries are required and the length they should be. For instance, participants could be asked to write three entries of four hundred words each over the week this chapter is read.)
