Chapter 5 of 20

3 Youth Ministry as an Integrative Theological Task Toward a Representative Method

3 Youth Ministry as an Integrative Theological Task Toward a Representative Method

ANDREW ROOT

he other day I was sitting with two fellow seminary professors, both talented biblical scholars, discussing the present and future of our seminary. I explained to them that those of its in the Children, Youth, and Family Department were planning on deepening our commitment to our Ph.D. program in the next few years. They both responded positively and encouraged the possible new endeavor. When it became clear that the conversation was about to shift topics, however, one of them turned to me and, with a half smile that said he knew his next comment would draw my ire, inquired, "My only question is, who is going to teach the Ph.D. seminar on group mixers?"

Despite youth ministry's long history, its practice has often been viewed by senior pastors and academics as lightweight. It has been assumed that the youth worker is a hyperactive person in their early twenties who prefers unserious kid stuff to the responsible practice of shared suffering and proclamation of the Word in pastoral ministry. So, while the theology, history and Bible people discuss rigorous theories, youth ministry people teach students how to do things like plan trips, play games and lead Bible studies-all important in practice, but low on the food chain of academic scholarship.

Is all this true? And if not, what is it that we are really tip to in youth ministry?

I believe, in fact, that the practice of youth ministry has been seen as lightweight both intellectually and ministerially because we have failed to see ourselves as theologians doing a fundamentally theological task. But what does that mean? What difference could it make to see ourselves as theologians? And how does theology work within the practice of youth ministry?

SINGING A NEW SONG: YOUTH MINISTER AS THEOLOGIAN

A frequent sight on the early episodes of American Idol (which I have to admit I'm addicted to) was profanity-laced tirades of some of the very worst singers when they left the audition room. Through their rage and tears they often asserted that they're great singers, and the judges were wrong. We as viewers know, of course, that the individuals are actually very bad singers, which makes their angry tantrums sadistically funny and so entertaining to watch (at least to me). Sure, the judges may be harsh, but they're not wrong when it comes to these contestants' singing ability.

Much like the American Idol candidates who can't sing, some of us have a conflated view of ourselves that has developed out of the imagined, or actual, perception of youth ministry as shallow. We aren't the problem, we assert; it's the uptight pastors or ivory-tower academics who judge wrongly. Our ministries are actually singing beautifully, or would be if our so-called ministry judges just understood us. But it may be that the genesis of the perceived thinness of our craft actually does rest more with us and our explicit or hidden insecurities about who we are and what we do.

Desiring to be respected but feeling a lack of acclaim, we've often fallen into two problematic traps. The first trap that our insecurity has led us into is the overwhelming need to justify ourselves. We have made arguments for why we are important and necessary to personnel committees and church boards. We have also spent a great deal of energy and ink explaining why youth ministry is important both as a ministerial office and as an academic discipline.

The second trap of insecurity is isolation. We have decided to spend all of our time reading, writing and participating in conversations solely about youth work. We have been slow to enter into crossdisciplinary or crossministerial conversations that would open up our understanding of our vocation to those in other fields. In staff or faculty meetings, rarely have we utnderstood the doctrine of reconciliation or the writings of a leading theologian as well as (or better than) the senior pastor or senior professor. We have networked ourselves with fellow youth workers but have been less willing to network with other pastors.

If youth ministry is to have a future that avoids these deadly traps of selfjustification and isolation, it must move boldly into deep theological construction. What I mean is that we must begin to see ourselves not primarily as youth ministry directors but as theologians who do constructive theology in the context of ministry with the adolescent population.

Truth be told, the theological legitimacy of the senior pastor is often based more on ordination credentials or years of past education or a pulpit to preach from than on constructive theological thinking in the practice of ministry. But this only makes things more difficult, giving senior pastors and others a reason to keep us youth workers theologically ignorant so that we might not see that all pastoral ministry needs a turn to the theological. I know this is cynical, but too often it plays out like this. And when it does, we youth workers find ourselves always scratching for some respect.

But seeing ourselves as theologians has the potential to move us beyond concern for de facto respect by drawing us into more meaningful and significant conversations with our colleagues in ministry, if they are willing. As we enter into mutually significant conversation beyond our isolation, they will recognize that we are not seeking to justify ourselves but rather are trying to construct deep theological articulations of how God is at work within the world. Claiming our place at the table of meaningful ministry will thus only be achieved by a richer theological imagination.' But to make such a move we must begin by understanding how theological reflection happens in the context of ministry (not just youth ministry) and what difference it might make.

THEOLOGY AS MINISTRY/MINISTRY AS THEOLOGY

In the first class session of my core children, youth and family course called "Theological Frameworks for CYF," I often set up my students by giving them a pop quiz. They're to circle all of the following phrases that they believe are true:

There is more than one right answer depending on how a person perceives the statements, but I assert that "good ministry leads to good theology" is the (most) correct answer. My point is this: that ministry always precedes theology and becomes the fodder for constructive theological thought because of our claim that God is living and active in the worldwhich means that God is a Minister.

By looking at God's Ministry of creation, covenant, incarnation (including crucifixion and resurrection) and Pentecost, it is obvious that God is not a theologian but a (the!) Minister. God has committed to be the Minister of creation, and theology is reflection on and articulation of God's Ministry. If we confess that God is active, that God is moving creation to its completion, then ministry is participation in God's own act of Ministry, and theology is nothing more than reflecting on God's action. And if it is true that God is alive and moving in the world as Minister, then all constructive theological work must be done in conversation and connection with this salve world to which God is in God's tri-unity. To be in contact with this world is to be in ministry, and therefore is to do theology.

Our own ministries in the world, then, are only truly ministries if they are connected to God's continued Ministry, and theology is only constructive (and helpful) if it is done in the context of God's continued Ministry in the world. Because youth ministry is ministry that seeks to connect not primarily to adolescents but to God's own Ministry as God ministers to adolescents, theological construction is demanded. To be faithful ministers we must begin to articulate how God is active in their (and our own) lives (by the way, it's this that makes us very different from the local after-school program). This means that the very humanity of each adolescent becomes significant to us, not because it is our job to love them but because God has so loved them, and to join God's Ministry we too must love them. Therefore, we love through the power of God in God's Ministry and not by our own ability.

This all leads me to assert that to do theology you must be in ministry. By this I mean you must be seeking to discover how God is active in the lives of concrete people in the world, and join that. Our actions in ministry with people whom God loves and stands with and for then become the material of original and deep theological thought. But our ministerial actions themselves also loudly assert theological truths. Stepping back from our actions in ministry allows us to both consider them theologically and begin to recognize the unconsidered theology present in them. For example: a youth director stands in front of a group of six eighth graders and says, "Hey, where is everyone?" What seems purely utilitarian is actually a claim laced with theology: "You six eighth graders do not constitute a faith community. You are not `everyone,' or really `anyone.' Bigger is better. We have failed to capitalize on our influence." In our failure to reflect theologically on our actions, to have a vision of God's own Ministry, we stumble in the dark, and sometimes we stumble onto paths that lead away from God's Ministry. This is all to make the point that in a real way, ministry is a theological task, for if it is ministry of the gospel it seeks to be faithful to God's own Ministry.'

WHAT DIFFERENCE WILL THIS MAKE?

But what difference will it make to see ourselves as theologians? Could this have any significant impact? I offer four ways it makes an important difference.

First, seeing youth ministry as a theological task moves youth ministry beyond utilitarianism and demands that we do real reflection on the practice of ministry and the young people to and with whom we minister. By understanding yourself as a theologian, you are freed to function as more than the congregation's program director. Rather, you are called to discern the multiple layers and nuances of God's activity and the actions of people, and then to seek creative ways to facilitate their understanding of and participation in God's action in the world.

For example, during a weekend retreat you may discover that five of the seven adolescents in your cabin come from families with parents who are divorced, separated or were never married. You must stop and reflect on this experience, evaluating it both theologically (What is God's desire for families and children? How do estranged and separated bonds between parents shape children's experience of their world and the way they see themselves? And how is God active in transforming their brokenness?) and psychosocially (How does such a family form psychologically affect a child? How does it affect the relational resources available for their development?' And what resources can I or the church provide to them?). If you are only a programmer you may be justified in ignoring an adolescent's deep suffering; your job is to provide meaningful events, and suffering throws wrenches into well-oiled programmatic machines. But if ministry is not about the utilitarianism of programming but about seeking to join God's Ministry in the world, then you cannot turn from the suffering adolescent, for with her stands the crucified Christ.

Second, I believe seeing ourselves as theologians helps its move past much of the fragmentation of ministries within the church. The Protestant Reformation stood, at least in part, upon the belief that all Christian believers were priests-the priesthood of all believers, in other words. In that Reformation context this worked out radically in the areas of prayer, Bible reading and confession; the Reformers asserted that all believers were priests, so all believers could pray, read the Bible and confess their sins without a priest standing between them and God. Almost all churches and traditions would affirm this strongly today. But what is interesting is that this conception of the priesthood of all believers hasn't continued on to its logical conclusion, which is that all believers are participants in God's Ministry and are therefore all involved in a theological task. In other words, anyone participating in any way in the ministry of God is swept up into a theological task.

What's often assumed instead is that the theologian on the church staff is the senior pastor; everyone else is just trying to keep things running smoothly. But from a constructive theological perspective, all those involved in ministry within the church are involved in theological reflection, and any individual who deliberately reflects on God's action in light of concrete people is involved in theological construction. I believe this perspective releases youth ministry from being merely an appendage, connected but not integrated into the church's ministry, and instead roots it within congregational life. Every staff member, every congregation member, is a theologian, and it is your job (as paid pastor) to help them see how and why this is so.

Third, embedding youth ministry in theology demands that we see the adolescent from a contextual perspective, as one who is affected by multiple forces. It is not enough to only be concerned with programming for the adolescent on Wednesday night or Sunday morning; as youth workers we are called to relate to youth within their families and cultures. Moreover, by giving direct attention to how an adolescent exists in multiple systems, we come to recognize that the young person's family is also affected by the forces of a pluralistic world. God is active in multiple contexts, not only in the church's youth ministry but also within the family and larger world. By understanding ourselves as theologians, our ministry is directed beyond the four walls of the church and into the familial, community and sociopolitical contexts in which students and their families live.

Finally, I believe that by seeing youth ministry as a theological task, theory and practice are held together. It is too often assumed that youth ministry is for doers and not for thinkers. Yet good doing demands good thinking. Understanding yourself as a theologian demands that you become astute at moving from experience to reflection and then to action by learning to discern and articulate the connections between God's action and human persons.

REFLECTING ON OUR EXPERIENCE OF GOD'S ACTION

To live as theologians in youth ministry we must learn to dance, in a senseto continually operate from three distinct, but connected, steps.

Experience. Imagine taking the seat behind two tenth-grade girls on your bus trip home from camp. Seeking to start a conversation you ask, "Are you both looking forward to getting home?" The one seated on the aisle turns to you and says, "I know she is," pointing to her friend who is leaning against the window. She continues, "She hasn't seen her boyfriend in a week and she can't wait to get some!" You spend the next forty-five minutes hearing stories and asking questions about high-school dating and sexuality. You've just had an experience!

Reflection. Now that you have had the experience, you begin to reflect on it. You may look at some social scientific research (maybe a book like to help you see why adolescents do the things they do. Could it be a psychological issue with their fathers? Could it be the effects of consumer culture? The Internet can connect you with other helpful sources as well; blogs and RSS feeds of articles can easily put information and ideas in your inbox. To do the kind of theological reflection that's desired, you have to do the work to really see the young person. This kind of reflection may not be theology proper (it may not immediately be bringing forth ideas of God's action) but it nevertheless helps you join in God's Ministry of loving solidarity with and for adolescents. As a constructive theologian, you're seeking here to understand, through reflection on experience, the concrete humanity of those with whom you are in ministry.

But reflection on our experience demands more if it is to be theological. It is here that the normative texts of the Christian tradition become essen tial. For instance, asking what Scripture says about our human sexuality and what other theologians in the tradition understood about this issue in their own time and place helps its have a broader and deeper vision of how our experience should be understood in light of God's Ministry. Scripture is not God, but it is, after all, a normative set of assertions about the shape of God's Ministry. We need Scripture and the Christian tradition (the thoughts of the theologians who went before us) to have a vision to see God's action in and through our experience.

Then, very practically, it will be helpful to have a theologian or two with whom you are in constant conversation through reading his or her writings. Drawing from the Christian tradition can feel overwhelming; no one can draw on the full breadth of it. We therefore have to pick dialogue partners to accompany us on this journey of seeking God's action. I have a circle of close dialogue partners, some living, others not, to which I always take my theological questions (Karl Barth, Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Eberhard Jungel, Douglas John Hall, Kathryn Tanner and Ray Anderson). In confronting the issue above, I would think through how it connects with what Barth has said about the imago Dci (image of God) in Church Dogmatics 3.2 or Bonhoeffer in Creation and Fall or Hall in Imaging God, and how the cross must lead nie into a compassionate response (Hall) that calls nie into deep solidarity (Anderson).

I don't agree with everything my theological dialogue partners have said (they don't all agree with each other, either), and I try to read as many other theologians as possible. But these five theologians are significant to me, not for getting everything right but for how they have helped nie see the beauty and wonder of God's Ministry in the world, which, in turn, helps nie make theological sense of my experiences in ministry (we'll discuss this all further in chapter five). When you take your experience on the bus and place it in conversation with social scientific research and theological discussions (which we'll discuss more in the next chapter), you've reflected on your experience!

Action. If reflection is born from experience it will blossom into action. So now, having reflected on your experience on the bus, you may decide to revamp the next month of Wednesday nights, making the topic sexuality, or you might decide that all-girl and all-guy retreats are in order. It's important to see that experience leads to reflection and then to action, but you also need to understand that the process doesn't end with action. In actual ity, once you have made your way through these three steps, the third (action) has a way of instantly sweeping you back to the first (experience). It is not a sweeping that means you must start all over but rather one that opens your eyes to see that all actions become new experiences and take you again (and again) into the three steps. After the all-girl and all-guy retreats, for example, you'll have new experiences to reflect on which will no doubt lead to new reflections and then new actions. This three-step process helps its do constructive theology that is grounded in the practice of ministry and that seeks to be faithful to God's continued Ministry in the world.

Figure 2.1. The process of practical theology

NEGLECTING THE STEPS

The theological academy has been accused (often rightly) of failing this three-step process. The perception is that we have locked ourselves in stuffy libraries far away from the experience of contemporary people in our context, and that many of us academics care little about action, about what the church actually does; we're more concerned with writing commentaries and articles for our guilds than producing work that will impact the church. The academy would do well to remember that our ultimate attention is to be given to the living God, as opposed to editorial boards and guild meetings.

Traditionally, youth ministry has also failed to hold to this three-step process, but in the exact opposite way as the academy. Our mistake in youth ministry is not that we have been closed to experience; youth workers are great at having experiences. And it is not that we have failed to move into action; our calendars are generally filled with planned actions, and we're often willing to do new and different things. The problem is that we have often failed to attend to deep, rigorous, reasoned reflection; we've been too anxious (rebellious) to slow down and think before doing.

Figure 2.2. The academy's neglect

I believe that this is the root of our insecurity and of the perception of youth ministry as lightweight and shallow. For this stigma to melt away we will most likely have to correct ourselves by spending more time and thought in reflection. And for youth ministry to see itself as theological in nature, we must learn to consistently and deeply move within the three steps of experience, reflection and action.

Figure 2.3. Youth ministry's neglect

CONCLUSION

It is my hope that in seeing ourselves as theologians, taking on a new theological rhetoric (to follow chapter one), we might be drawn more deeply into the continued Ministry of God in the world, which is to be with and for adolescents. I am confident that, by doing this, we can free ourselves from our stances of justification and isolation and become significant voices within the church for what God is doing in God's Ministry in the world, and for how human beings can faithfully join it.

• DISCUSSION AND REFLECTION EXERCISE

Role Model Profile
This exercise invites you to reflect on past youth workers, pastors or volunteer leaders you've known, examining how they sought to think theologically or how theology impacted their ministry and their persons

• As you look back, which youth workers, pastors or others best represent what a theologian in ministry should be (in your opinion)?

• What characteristics have you observed in these people that, in your mind, make them such good theological thinkers in ministry?

• As you think about how these people work, which of their actions most encapsulates and typifies that which you find so admirable about their theological reflection?

• As you think about what these people do well, which of their abilities would you most like to be able to borrow and integrate into your own ministry?

Our answers to these questions can give us a picture of the parts of ourselves and our practice that we yearn to develop. Review your responses and make a list of those areas.

↑ Back to top

↑