12 What Are We Doing in These Mountains? The Outdoor Trip and the Theology of the Cross
KENDA CREASY DEAN
hen our son was sixteen, we informed him that he had to give one tenth of his summer to Jesus. Without batting an eye, he chose the Young Life camp over the high-school mission trip sponsored by our church. This decision had nothing to do with Young Life and everything to do with the fact that Louie was going to camp. Louie, when he was not living at our house, lived three doors down. His parents have unofficially made the care and feeding of Young Life leaders in our area into a tentmaking ministry, and one of them invited Brendan to camp.
"Are you sure you don't want to go on the mission trip?" I asked, with just a little too much concern in my voice. It dawned on inc that maybe altruism skips a generation.
"No, Mom. I hate helping people," came the unrepentant reply. "I did that last year. I'm not doing it again." I noticed that, in the brochure, the Young Life camp quite convincingly described itself as a "vacation."
THE ESCHATOLOGICAL SIGNIFICANCE OF SUMMER CAMP
Forget Left Behind, which despite record-breaking book sales is mostly lost on American teenagers (whose intrigue with the end of time is far more likely to be fueled by fantasy novels like The Hunger Games and TV shows like LOST and Survivor). My money is on Christian camps, retreats and conferences as teenagers' introduction to eschatology, though I have never been to one that admitted it. Nearly half (45 percent) of U.S. teenagers have attended religious youth retreats, conferences, rallies or congresses; 39 percent have gone to religious summer camps, and nearly one out of three has been part of a religious mission team or service project.' This means that whether we claim, or even recognize, the eschatology informing our approach to these events, they nonetheless leave an impression on significant numbers of American young people who-potentially, anyway-go home with a sense that God's promise includes them.2
I have a long history with summer Christian youth programs; I'm in ministry largely because of one of them. That was where, it seemed to me at fifteen, Jesus leapt off the pages of Scripture and into my life, really, for the first time. Call it adolescent, call it manipulative, call it finding "my heart strangely it was, I went to Lakeside Reach Out as a blase church kid and came home with a sense of divine purpose that, thirty years later, I have not been able to shake. The revelation that God gave Martin Luther reading Romans in the privy, and John Wesley at the Bible study on Aldersgate Streetnamely, the joyous insight that I, myself, am destined for God, that Jesus died for me, and me personally, and therefore has some kind of bizarre confidence that I can contribute to God's work in the world-God seems to give teenagers, somewhat reliably, in the context of summer camps and conferences.
Why? Why do religious camps and conferences, more than congregations and even more than mission trips, give young people a glimmer of their destiny in God? I have a theory. These events end. Mission trips (and let me go on record as a cautious fan) end too, but they end in a radical awareness of here and now, whereas Christian camps, retreats and conferences, by definition and design, traffic in hope. What is left when camp is over is hope-hope for a return next year, hope for a new way of life on the return home, because now we live with a glimpse of what the future holds. These events are marked, from the outset, by a radical finality. The liminal character of camps, retreats and conferences (typically, held in a liminal location like an idyllic patch of nature or a college campus enclave) reminds young people that they are momentarily "suspended" between daily life and eternal promises, and that their time in this place where "the membrane between this world and a reality beyond is especially thin" is temporary.3 The Christian camp, retreat or conference is less an experience than a pilgrimage. These youth travel together, literally or figuratively, toward a holy destination: life in God.
THE TELOS OF THE CHRISTIAN YOUTH EVENT: THE LAST NIGHT OF CAMP
Consequently, Christian youth events that have existential traction do not meander aimlessly. They aim for a conclusion, with everything structured to honor the event's culminating moments. The "end time" of the event (ordinarily the last night's worship service) ritualizes our understanding of the "end times" described by Christian theology. It is decisive. One chapter closes and another begins. Decisions are made, preparations ensue for a different world-the world that is Not-Camp. In the closing rituals of the last night of camp, we expect Jesus to come. We expect God to act. Furthermore, having had a foretaste of glory divine, young people are sent out from the religious camp or conference, like John of Patmos, as apostles of hope. In short, the condensed week of a summer youth camp or conference enacts an ordu salutis (order of salvation), not to manipulate God's saving activity but to dramatize it. Christians are story people, and every story-even God's story with its on earth-has a final chapter. What we do on the last night of camp says a lot about how we think the story ends.
This surprises its. Many of us aren't even aware that we even have a governing eschatology, much less that we enact it with young people. "End time" rhetoric conjures tip images of heaven, hell, rapture and the second coming of Christ that have been treated as "the theological equivalent of Timbuktu" in the Protestant church for most of the twentieth century, according to Mark Ralls, writing in The Christian Century. "Like a lot of mainline Protestant pastors I know," confesses Ralls, "I'm caught between honest belief and embarrassment."4 Our way out has been to sidestep any overt discussion of eschatological issues altogether, leaving them to our more literally ininded conservative Christian friends. We mainliners prefer transitions to endings, rehabilitation to judgment, regeneration to apocalypticism, phases to finality. But there is a cost to this. Our silence on the subject of eschatology, our reluctance to speak of God's future for fear of boxing in God's expansive grace, has the effect of muting the telos of Christian theology. Youth are thus left to conclude, quite understandably, that the church is literally going nowhere.
BACK TO THE FUTURE: RECLAIMING CHRISTIAN HOPE
Eschatology offers teenagers-and us-the one resource we need in the face of radical finality: hope. This is not an optional doctrine at the end of the Christian story; rather, it is the reason for the Christian story. As Jurgen Moltmann writes, "The eschatological is not one element of Christianity, but ... the key in which everything in it is set, the glow that suffuses everything here in the dawn of an expected new day."' In the Christian view of the end of time lies God's unshakable promise that, though the towers fall, though the economy falters, though the world ends, Christ has died, Christ is risen, and Christ will come again-not in some abstract sense, but to be with us. By taking seriously its own "ending," the last night of camp insinuates God's embrace of all of time-the beginnings and the ends. In spite of a radically terminated present, on the last night of camp we enact our belief that Jesus is truly among its, and the finality of the moment does not stop his, or our, return. Through the prayer, sacraments and other means of grace typically offered during the closing worship service of these events, the heavenly life-as-it-should-be briefly merges with the life of a teenager, and young people glimpse, momentarily but significantly, the inbreaking of God.
This is no small thing. According to the National Study of Youth and Religion, many American teenagers inhabit a "morally insignificant universe," in which they perceive no telos, no larger story in which they play a part, no sense that their actions play a notable part in moving the world forward. This was especially true for mainline Protestant, Roman Catholic and Jewish young people in the study, who showed less religious vitality, understanding and hope for the future than their Mormon, conservative Protestant or black Protestant peers.6 While the majority of the 3,370 teenagers interviewed considered religion "benignly positive," very few could articulate what they believed, or how or why religion made a difference in their lives. Most of them thought about the future in terms of college, marriage or recycling-no further. With rare exceptions, the absence of a meaningful eschatology cut across religious traditions. The study found that even teenagers who attend church regularly live in a world where no ultimacy is assigned to our life together, where God is invoked vaguely and where Jesus primarily wants us to feel good about ourselves.?
LIFE BEYOND LEFT BEHIND
There is a logic to pilgrimages: altered physical conditions produce an a1tered-a more alert and sensitive-consciousness.8 The Left Behind series offers one way for teenagers to imagine the end times, but the small, tempo rary, God-conscious communities of religious camps, retreats and conferences offer another, and far more young people respond. In these events, teenagers glimpse a future into which they are invited, in which they play a part, in which their actions matter because they live in a morally consequential universe. And in the culminating finality of the last night of camp, we ritualize the way God lays claim to them, and we expect Jesus to actnot because this is the way camp is, but because this is the way the story ends. Come, Lord Jesus, come.
• DISCUSSION AND REFLECTION EXERCISE
Survival Advice Memo
Imagine it is your last day as a camp counselor or leader.9 Your replacements are coming next week. You are asked to write these incoming counselors and leaders a memo that articulates what you have learned theologically from your experience.
Drawing from your own experience (and this chapter), tell the newcomers what theological significance camp can have and things that might move it in this direction. The memo should have four parts: (1) what young people experience at camp, (2) how God is active at camp, using a theological motif (e.g., incarnation, Trinity, eschatology), (3) how young people experience God's activity at camp, and (4) what actions camps and leaders should take in light of the other three questions.
After writing this memo, pick what you perceive to be your most insightful remark and construct questions or discussion starters for it. Then, in small groups, each person should share either their memos or their further reflection on the original remark to lead the group into conversation.
