Chapter 12 of 20

10 Holding On to Our Kisses The Hormonal Theology of Adolescence

10 Holding On to Our Kisses The Hormonal Theology of Adolescence

ANDREW ROOT

i here's nothing like a theological conversation with an eighth grader to alert you to the gap in your doctrinal understanding. All of us who have worked with adolescents have had the experience of sitting in a cabin or around a campfire as the discussion progresses from casual and light to an in-depth theological dialogue for which we soon realize we are not prepared. The pimpled-face skater who hasn't sat still for more than two seconds throughout the conversation now seems to take on another personality as he asks intensely, "What really is sin? When do I know I've sinned? How do I keep from sinning? And if I am a sinner, and that's my nature, how is it possible to keep from sinning?"

If you're like me, you may have balked in the face of such questions, perhaps quoting a Bible verse in the hopes that it will distract (or rather "redirect") from the significant questions being asked. Surely we all have some foundational comprehension of what sin is, some scripts to fall back on that we learned in Sunday school (e.g., "All have sinned and fall short of the glory of God" and "All sins are equal"-though note that one of these is a Bible verse while the other is not). But if we are honest we must admit that many of those scripts sound hollow and, for the intense inquisitor and his handful of skeptical on-listeners, no doubt banal.

We may assuage our guilt over our ignorance and justify our confusion by claiming that such deep theological conversations are helplessly complex and abstract, and that good youth workers keep abstraction and adolescence in distinct corners-so we are therefore free to ignore the directness of the inquiry.

Yet as theologian Reinhold Niebuhr is credited as saying, "Sin is the only empirically provable Christian doctrine." All it takes is an honest look at society or ten minutes in front of the local news to verify that sin is a real thing. And while acknowledging its empirical existence does not help us-or the young people with whom we work-to understand it, if it is true that "all have sinned" (Rom 3:23) and that Christ died for its "while we were still sinners" (Rom 5:8) then there is great significance in grasping what this opaque doctrine is all about.

So how should we think about sin in light of ministry with young people? Hopefully reflecting on this question will equip its with something to say to our fervent young questioners beyond our old scripts and empower them to see the doctrine's relevance in their lives and the world.

SIN VERSUS SINNING

Original sin, or what has grossly (but no doubt rightly) been called the "total depravity" of humanity, has been a tenet of the Christian faith since the time of Augustine, with strong antecedents going back to Pauline theology, especially the letter to the Romans. This doctrine, rightly understood, makes it clear that there's a difference between sin (the state of our being) and sinning (the bad or wrong things we do).

We commit sins, of course, but this is because we live in a state of sin. Far too often, what adolescents understand about sin is only their actions of sinning. They fail to recognize that all humanity is under the shadow of sin, no matter how good or bad; if you are human, you live in the reality of sin, the reality of brokenness. Sin is the name used to describe the state of the broken relationship, at its most fundamental, between God and humanity. Therefore, while sin left unchecked call lead to deep and radical evil, it is primarily a reality born in tragedy.

Adam and Eve were created to be with God and to be for one another, but they chose against God and blamed one another. This destroyed their communion with God, leaving them alone in the world. The rest of humanity, in turn, chose sin over God too-chose to define itself apart from its Creatortherefore tragically breaking relationship with its very source of life.

Karl Barth explains the difference between sin and sinning this way: "Particular sins do not alter the status of a [person]; they merely show how heavily the general dominion of Sill presses upon him [or her]. Sill is the sovereign power in the world as we know it; and it is wholly irrelevant what particular form it takes in the life of each individual."I According to Barth, then, we are not sinful because of the bad or wrong things we do; we do bad, wrong and (sometimes) evil things because we live in a reality of sin. Too often in youth ministry we confuse adolescents by making sin a riddle to solve ("How can I live without sinning?") and a problem around which to maneuver rather than a tragic reality of brokenness that is both detrimental and unavoidable. I have sat in small groups with adolescent boys, both as an adult leader and as an adolescent participant, where the conversation centered around Jesus' words in Matthew 5:27-28 that looking on a woman with lust in your heart is sin (adultery). Rather than focusing on how we can live in ways that uphold the integrity and humanity of the women we meet in a culture that frequently objectifies women, we dwelt on the impossible quandary of how to "avoid lusting"-in other words, how to avoid having sexual desire toward women.

When we confuse sin with sinning, adolescents often interpret our message as a reminder of their helpless, constant failure. It rattles around in their ears like the many other messages of failure they hear as they seek to discover who they are ("You're a bad soccer player," "You're weak," "You're fat," "Your grades are not tip to snuff," "Those thoughts you have make you a sinner!"). Confusing sin with sinning also often pushes young people deeper into isolation, in an attempt to hide their sinfulness, and rarely toward salvation-confessing their sinfulness and finding grace and forgiveness. This happens because they are told of their sinning (lust, theft, cruelty, bitterness, disobedience, etc.) rather than of the tragic reality of sin, which impacts its all-a reality that reveals our shared participation in tragedy and culpability. If the larger reality of sin, for example, is that we live in a culture that objectifies women, then simply chastising young boys for lusting, or giving them tools or devices to avoid lusting (such as mental gymnastics, prayers, bracelets and accountability partners), never confronts the real reality of sin and its impact on them. Instead it creates cycles of guilt and failure, all the while perpetuating the reality of sin-boys objectifying women by making women something to avoid in order to maintain their own purity.

SIN AS DEATH

What then is the concrete, historical and, dare we say practical, reality of sin? It's nothing other than death itself. We see the universal, shared pres once of sin in all humanity through the reality of death; we know all are sinners for all will die.

There is nothing more concrete than death, nothing more substantive than the tragic reality of relationships and communities broken by accidents, crime and disease. Death undeniably reveals that humanity is frail and weak, that humanity is not in control or in charge. It is in death that we understand the depth of our broken community with God; it is in death that we see the full weight and consequence of sin. God is life and complete being, but humanity's destiny is death and the sure promise of sliding back into non-being: dust to dust. As Barth says, "Death is the divine command-`stop'-and we cannot disobey it. Through its narrow gate we must pass."' This omnipresent reality of death concretely reveals the universal reality of sin.

Death also discloses the great difference between humanity and God. In death we hear God's "No"-a No that places again a boundary between us and God, a boundary transgressed in the beginning through the disobedience of Adam and Eve. Their violation was not in eating the fruit (that would be a moralistic example of sinning, and a weird one at that: "eating fruit!"). Rather, by eating the fruit, participating in sinning and inaugurating a reality of sin, they ignored and denied the concrete command of the personal God who established a boundary (see Bonhoeffer's Creation and Fall).

So then when the adolescent asks, What is sin? we must reply, it is death. And what is death? Death is non-being. It is living and operating in the No of God. It is ignoring and denying life, which is found only in God's Yes. Death, no doubt, is the end, the finality of life, but death nevertheless makes itself present, walking on the stage of our lives many times before the curtains are down. It rears its ugly head in moments of depression and disappointment, and may be most fully experienced (before the end) in isolation and rejection. (Ask any adolescent being bullied, rejected or abused if such experiences feel like death.) Death breathes down the neck of the child whose father moves to another state after her parents' divorce, only to send an occasional check on her behalf. Death stares into the face of the boy who can't find a seat in the lunchroom, turned away from table after table while everyone watches him shuffle along with his food tray. Death grips with a cold fist the heart of the girl who leaves the slumber party early because she is mocked by those she had called friends. Death is the reality of sin and death is the consequence of sin because death promises (and never fails) to end community (relationship). Death puts final and complete separation between God and humanity and humanity and humanity (parents from children, friends from friends, lovers from lovers).

SINNING AS DEHUMANIZATION

Sin is not only concrete because it means death (nothing is more certain, they say, than death and taxes) but also because this death terror leads us, whether explicitly or implicitly, into acting on its behalf. In other words, actions that isolate, reject and dehumanize others and its come from the fear of death. This is where sin moves into sinning. For instance, I knew of a straight-A student who was so afraid of being rejected from her college of choice, disappointing family and friends, and losing her stellar reputation that she cheated on her SAT test. I also knew an eighth-grade boy who, to those who encountered him at school, was the frightening guy who lied all the time and incessantly tortured the underclassmen. When he disappeared we found out that he was sent away when his elderly grandmother, with whom he lived, became ill, and that he had been living with her because his mother had abandoned him when he was young. Sin is real because death surrounds us and promises to envelope us, and because death does this, we attempt out of fear to protect our own being, our own humanity, even if it means dehumanizing another. When we take such actions we are sinning. But it is important to see that any single action of sinning has been engendered from fear and from the deeper reality of death (Sin).

Sinning, then, is those things I do that deny God (the source of life) and dehumanize my fellow human being or myself. My sinful actions are not wrong because they deny some perfect law of right and wrong. Rather, my actions are wrong and maybe even evil because they ignore or destroy my connection to God and neighbor in an attempt to maintain myself. In this vein, the Ten Commandments are not simply rigid dos and don'ts but are for covenant living, for loving God and neighbor. We see Jesus himself disobey the fourth commandment when he heals a man on the Sabbath, explaining to the Pharisees, "The Sabbath is made for humanity not humanity for the Sabbath" (Mk 2:27). In this act he reminds its that the commandments exist not to make people "good" or to keep people from being "bad" but to facilitate life in the love of God and neighbor. Actions like cheating, lying, stealing and gossiping are wrong because they presume that by hurting another I can restore my own being (was this not the motive for Cain to kill Abel?). Dietrich Bonhoeffer reminds its in Ethics that it is not moral absolutes that put a demand for obedience on us but the concrete humanity of our neighbor. This is why Jesus summarizes all the Law of the Torah to the rich young ruler with one phrase: "Love the Lord your God with all your heart, soul, and mind and your neighbor as yourself" (Lk 10:27).

SIN AND SINNING AS BROKEN COMMUNITY

This all means that we can see the reality of sin most clearly in broken community; we can taste death most fully and painfully in estrangement. Persons were made for God and each other, for community. The reality of the sinful world is the tragedy of broken community with both God and neighbor.

Sinning, then, is not a spiritual state in the sense of there being some kind of metaphysical moral rule book we failed to keep, but rather is a social reality, born from the ever-present reality of impending death. It makes our neighbor a tool for our own use; it causes its to ignore the No of God and act instead as though we are God seeking to save ourselves from our own existential state. Sinning breaks down community, thwarts freedom, and sets people in opposition or estrangement, neglecting their responsibility; it makes death (the state of sin) operational and therefore denies that we are accountable to the God of life and to others who live with its. We do dehuilia nizing things (sinning things) because we fear! We fear death in its myriad faces and thus seek to protect our being from its promised strangling. Yet the fear of death will not release its even if we sacrifice the humanity of our neighbor to it.

SO WHAT DOES THIS ALL MEAN?

When discussing the doctrine of sin with adolescents we must point them not to their subjective inner state to show the reality of sinning, for this can be manipulated. It is not difficult to make adolescents feel guilty or bad about themselves, to make them feel the need for a savior. Rather we must point them to the objective social reality of dehumanization and broken community that they feel and in which they participate: the state of sin and death. How do we know we are sinners? Not because we don't measure tip when we try to compare ourselves to a standard of good and find ourselves falling short (having bad thoughts, not praying enough, lying or disobeying). We know we are truly sinners in the moments when we confront a deep fear and find ourselves acting on death's behalf.

One of the moments in my life when I was painfully aware of my own sinfulness happened one night while I was eating dinner in my college cafeteria with some friends and a few acquaintances. An attractive girl whom I had a crush on walked by our table. My friend elbowed me and gestured to her, teasing, "Hey, there she is!" A girl at our table, mistaking her for someone else, asked, "Is that Tami?" Feeling deeply embarrassed, and terrified of being exposed, I answered, "No! I would never like Tami. She's ugly!" A minute later, someone stood up to leave from the table behind me. To my horror, it was Tami, who turned to me with a penetrating gaze before walking away. I was flooded with shame and with the awareness that, because I felt threatened, I was willing to sell Tami out to maintain my own standing among my friends. Because I feared the reality of sin-death, estrangement, humiliation-I sinned. In my own weakness and attempts at self-preservation, I dehumanized another person.

Convincing adolescents that they are sinful and have committed many actions of sinning is unnecessary if we free the doctrine from its opaque theological baggage and see sin as death and sinning as dehumanization. What is needed (and perhaps more difficult to do) is for us to invite young people to face death (sin), recognize their weakness and brokenness, and confess their participation in dehumanization (sinning). We need to be talking honestly about the deep pain in the crevices of human experience, both the pain we feel and the pain we inflict on others.

Seeing the doctrine of sin this way means we free it from abstraction and place it in the consciously concrete reality of the adolescent. There is no hidden mystery about sin and sinning then: sin is death and sinning is that which dehumanizes and breaks relationship with God and neighbor. When we proclaim this message the adolescent is not pushed further into shame and estrangement but rather can find solidarity with its. We too have been dehumanized and have dehumanized others; we too are struggling to confront our own death(s); we too are in need of new community that can extend beyond death.

It is this new community that Jesus Christ offers all humanity by taking death unto himself, suffering its wrath all the way to hell and bearing the dehumanizing actions of his contemporaries. The good news of the gospel is only good news if Jesus is the Christ of God who is at the same time the poor weak human Nazarene who was betrayed, dehumanized and put to death by humanity, only to overcome death with life, thereby breaking the power of sin and sinning, of death and dehumanization.

Sin is not a disease and Jesus' atonement a preventative immunization. It cannot be overcome by its, not by praying or trying or striving to be holy and good. Acknowledging sin (death) and our own participation in sinning leads its beyond pointed fingers and labels of who is righteous and who is not, for none are. Instead it pushes its into the arms of a suffering God and a strong Christ who is only so in weakness and who promises us life beyond death (sin) in his own life.

Christ provides its with a community where dehumanization (sinning) has no value, for death (sin) has lost its power. As Paul wrote, "0 death, where is thy victory? 0 death, where is thy sting?" (1 Cor 15:55). We can only find freedom from sin through community with Jesus Christ who overcomes our sinfulness by bearing it.

I never spoke to Tami about what happened after I saw what my comments had done to her. It would have been so easy for me to have avoided the situation, to simply say, "No, that's not Tami," and leave it at that. But I didn't. I was deceived into thinking that I had to fight to defend myself at her expense, so I betrayed her humanity. And I never had the courage to seek her forgiveness. I wish I had been able to go to her and apologize to her for what I said. It would have required me to admit my own weakness, to tell her that I had felt embarrassed and spoke to protect myself without thinking of anyone else. It would have required me to ask her forgiveness. And it would have invited both her and me into the community of broken, sinful, forgiven people whose life is in Christ. Followers of Christ are not sinless, and are not commanded to be sinless. Rather they are those who by the strength of the Spirit are able to ask forgiveness for their participation in sin and seek reconciliation with those whom they've sinned against. They are those who struggle against that urge to protect themselves and seek to resist the pull to dehumanize others. They are those who strive to live in awareness of their own and others' weakness and share the forgiveness and restoration that God offers its in Christ.

So what is sin? And how do I talk about it with young people? Sin is the tragedy of death and estrangement from God that we must bear. And we talk about sin with young people by acknowledging its inescapable reality in the world, and then sharing together in the hope of a human God who bears this tragic reality with its and promises us life beyond it.

• DISCUSSION AND REFLECTION EXERCISE

Imagine
Imagine at home before the session that the author of this chapter will be with your group the next time you meet.3 Write down your top three questions that you'd like to ask the author.
Participants should then share their questions on a class LISTSERV, bulletin board or chat room so that the group can begin (at least mentally) to cluster the questions. Right before the discussion time, work together to cluster certain questions (combining or eliminating duplicates). Then break up into small groups, with each one taking a cluster of questions to discuss.

↑ Back to top

↑