Chapter 7 of 20

5 Walking into the Crisis of Reality How Theology Is Constructed

5 Walking into the Crisis of Reality How Theology Is Constructed

KENDA CREASY DEAN

Ott could almost hear the sigh of relief when the ball dropped in Times Square announcing January 1, 2010: America's decadus horribilis had come to a close. Already the twenty-first century was known for terrorist attacks, economic disaster and-especially chilling-alienated teenagers who fingered society by opening fire on their schoolmates. After one of the most shocking shootings, Columbine High School in the spring of 1999, Time columnist Lance Morrow reminded us that the writing had been on the wall for some time. He pointed to "one of the founding documents of American adolescence," Catcher in the Rye. In a prescient passage, Holden Caulfield-expelled from prep school-is wearing a red hunting cap. A pimply kid named Ackley mocks him, calling it a "deer shooting hat." "Like hell it is," Holden retorts, closing one eye as if taking aim. "This is a people shooting hat. I shoot people in it." Morrow added quickly: "Holden is kidding, of course."

Youth ministry carne of age during Holden Caulfield's adolescence, a time when teenagers were still kidding when they took aim at one another. The fellowship groups, parachurch clubs, summer camps, mass rallies and teen programs-modules of peer culture that came to characterize mainstream (mostly Anglo-European) "youth ministry" by the mid-twentieth century-all promised moral fortitude and a measure of protection from the demands of adulthood. The widely touted objective of youth ministry was to claim youth for "the church of tomorrow" by socializing them into the ecclesial mores of the church of today.

By the 1960s, however, the "church of tomorrow" was being sent to Vietnam with orders to kill. Summer camp and Bible Bowls paled beside emerging claims on the adolescent soul-the civil rights movement, "flower power," even rock and roll-that sought immediate involvement from youth who, in essence, had been put on hold by American institutional life. Reacting to the hyper-institutionalism of postwar America (and responding to the World Council of Churches' admonition that youth be integrated into the total mission of the church), mainline churches in the 1960s and 1970s dismantled denominational support systems for youth ministry and released adolescents from their destiny as "the church of tomorrow." At the same time, youth began to vanish from the ecclesial radar screen like disappearing ink.

We're now in a new millennium-but intense interest in spirituality still fails to translate into adolescent church involvement in most Protestant congregations. Confirmation, the rite of initiation into lifelong church participation, more often than not serves as a graduation ceremony for bored adolescents and weary parents; more than half of those confirmed as adolescents leave the church by age seventeen. Girls tend to exit congregational life around age fourteen or fifteen, boys somewhat sooner. Meanwhile, youth ministers practice disappearing acts of their own. By the turn of the century, the average tenure for a full-time youth minister was 3.9 years (a dramatic increase from the widely cited "eighteen-month to three-year" expiration date of youth ministers a decade before), no doubt thanks to the field's increasing specialization.2 Still, four out of five youth leaders are volunteers, and more than one-third of full-time youth pastors stay in their placements one year or less. As one researcher noted, "Even when remaining in the profession, youth ministers may rank just behind migrant workers in length of time staying in one place."3

ADOLESCENTS AS A SIGN: PROCLAIMING SALVATION IN SPITE OF THEMSELVES

By now American Christianity's well-intentioned impotence with young people has been analyzed to death, scattering blame on everything from budget cuts to training deficits to demographic cycles. Beneath these issues, however, lies the question of theological credibility: does the God presented by American churches pacify adolescents with pizza and youth groups, or does this God satisfy their deepest longings and deliver them from their most profound dreads? If nothing else, the events of the last decade force its to repack our theological gear for youth ministry, beginning with a doctrine of salvation in which human development and divine action intersect.

Acknowledging God's role in existential rescue represents a shift in youth ministry's self-understanding. For most of the past hundred years, youth ministry relied on psychology, sociology and education-not theology-to justify its existence. Even evangelicals, who tended to use the language of salvation more readily than their mainline and Catholic counterparts, were pragmatists when it came to youth ministry, frequently equating young people's salvation to quantifiable conversion "experiences." Especially among mainline Protestants, who borrowed pedagogics from social sciences where adolescence was often viewed as an occasion for therapy, these rationales drove churches' ministries with young people for the better part of a century. The need to connect what adolescents must do developmentally (achieve an enduring sense of identity) with what Jesus does theologically (accomplishes YHWH's salvation) was chronically overlooked by the church, although not necessarily by adolescents themselves, who "acted out" the human need for salvation, often implicitly or inappropriately. Christians understand identity to be given, not "found"-ours by redemption, not human development. Adolescents, despite being mired in a distinctly modern search for self, demonstrated this profound connection between theology and identity formation. In other words, the adolescent search for self implicitly represented, in the individualistic West at least, humanity's effort to recover the imago Dci given in creation but lost to sin.

INTUITING THEOLOGY: I KNOW IT'S IN HERE SOMEWHERE

Christians have always maintained that the search for self is simultaneously a search for God. Human beings are "hardwired" to seek salvation, even if they cannot articulate "salvation-from-what." Human development need not go according to plan to reveal the divine imprint, but each life stage nonetheless predisposes its toward certain theological moorings. Adolescents in the throes of identity formation, for instance, must daily choose between being and non-being, between the relationships that are self-creating and the isolation that leads to self-disintegration. For teenagers, "salvation"-from disintegration, if not from sin-is a daily and persistent request.

All of this makes salvation a central if implicit motif during adolescence. A brief channel-surf through primetime makes the point (think True Blood or any J. J. Abrams project). Moreover, salvation in adolescence always seems to come in the form of a "relationship," that sacred and zealously guarded "in-between-ness" with others that allows youth to develop friendships and intimacies that confirm their existence. The problem is that these identity-forming relationships are pocked by sin, making human identity an incomplete, distorted, even false view of the self given to us by God. Like teenage acne, sin clogs the pores of the soul that simultaneously longs to reveal (even to ourselves) our true identity as God's beloved and forgiven children.

Yet, improbably-while sin obliterates most of the clues pointing to our holy imprint-the imago Dci in human beings remains perceptible, if impossibly distorted. During adolescence, the desire for love and fidelity points always to the passionate love of God (despite myriad forces that attempt to subvert it). The God who desires its also created our desire for others; consequently, the passion that is acute during adolescence (but present in all of us) points us to the One whose friendship restores us, redeems us and re-creates its into the person God made its to be in the first place. Whether we recognize Jesus Christ's re-creating friendship or not, in Christ, all things are made new-including teenagers.

The connection between the psychosocial dynamics of adolescence and the ontological significance of salvation ought to have positioned the twenty-first-century church as a hotbed of possibility for adolescent faithbut so far, this has seldom been the case. Apart from the youth group, most churches have given tip on being a hotbed of any kind where teenagers are concerned. In the absence of theological guidance from the community of faith, then, adolescents are left to intuit salvation's trajectory through peer relationships. So they turn to-well, to most anybody, trying various "hit and miss" avenues to intimacy in hopes of finding someone who can love them into being.

"Intuitive" theology inevitably yields questionable ethics (intuition, after all, has the advantage of openness and the disadvantage of boundlessness), but it is far from new. For example, in Acts 16, a local slave girl with a loud proclivity for fortune-telling day in and day out proclaims her intuition that Paul and Silas are bearers of salvation. For days on end she cries: "These Ines are slaves of the Most High God, who proclaim to us a way of salva tion!" (v. 17). Annoyed, Paul finally orders the "spirit" out of her. Luke writes, "When her owners saw that their hope of making money was gone, they seized Paul and Silas and dragged them into the marketplace before the authorities," whereupon Paul and Silas were summarily stripped, flogged and thrown into jail (vv. 19-24)-all because Paul put a stop to adults' exploitation of a teenage girl.

The more familiar part of the story follows: ever optimistic, Paul and Silas sing and pray in prison throughout the night until an earthquake releases their chains. The startled jailer-certain that prisoners have escaped on his watch-sets out to commit suicide, but Paul shouts, "Do not harm yourself, for we are all here!" Apparently amazed as much as frightened, the jailer falls down and asks, "Sirs, what must I do to be saved?" "Believe in the Lord Jesus," is the reply, "and you will be saved-you and your household" (vv. 25-31).

A detail worth noting: it is the girl, not Paul or Silas, who proclaims that salvation is afoot. The presence of Jesus' salvation unhinges her sanctioned exploitation, frees her identity from her earning potential and sets in motion a series of chain-shattering events. Because they liberate a slave girl from the profitable "spirit" possessing her, Paul and Silas are imprisoned. When an earthquake sets them free, we learn that it is the jailer who is bound-by duty, not by chains, but he prepares to fall on his sword nonetheless as penance for irresponsibility. Paul spares him the trouble by redefining liberation. The prisoners have not escaped-yet they are free! The Holy Spirit then delivers apostles and jailer simultaneously. The jailer, however, asks a curious question for someone whose life has been spared: "What must I do to be saved?" Clearly, in this passage salvation-deliveranceimplies something more than physical life and death. Deliverance always ushers in new life (we say we "deliver" babies for a reason). The jailer becomes beholden to Jesus Christ instead of to the magistrates. He can no longer view himself, or anyone in his household, apart from the salvific work of God.

Adolescents, of course, seldom articulate the human desire for salvation as pointedly as the jailer: "What must I do to be saved?" The adolescent in this story is the slave girl, a youth who intuits the possibility of salvation before she can say what it means, and whose proclamation is inappropriate, unwelcome-and unavoidable. She "smells" salvation in the air, and gropes for a way to lay claim to it. The adult, on the other hand, practically misses God's deliverance right under his nose. Like so many of us, the jailer confuses his identity with his professional competence, and is so ready to fall on his sword that he almost misses the crucial point: No need! He has been delivered! Youth and adult balance one another in this story: the jailer needs the slave girl's bold proclamation of possibility, while the slave girl needs the jailer's ability to ask for salvation by name-specifically, Jesus' name.

THE SIGNIFICANCE OF SALVATION IN THE FORMATION OF SELF

Historically, Western societies have viewed adolescence as an anomaly, with "diagnoses" ranging from a lack of conversion to a form of mental imbalance. Today, the line between medication and ministry is no less fuzzy. School shootings inevitably focus public attention on mental illness. After Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold's infamous shooting rampage at Columbine High School in April 1999-a story rife with both horror and testimonies to faith-Channel One and the National Association for Mental Illness posted a webpage listing symptoms of teen manic depression, including "increased talking-the adolescent talks too much," "distractibility," "unrealistic highs in self-esteem-for example, a teenager who feels specially connected to Long before twenty-three-year-old Seung-Hui Cho killed thirty-two people at Virginia Tech in April 2007, his mother had turned to a church, hoping that involving her son in religious formation would modify Cho's troubling behavior. The pastor deemed Cho in need of "spiritual power" (whether the Chos also sought psychiatric help for their son is unclear).'

Though the media may dismiss it, teenagers themselves often intuit salvific significance-not mental illness-in a divine-human connection, a connection that they sense counters death with life. Following the Columbine massacre, many young people saw a "special connection to God" as something teenagers their own age had been willing to die for. Salvation is never an eschatological category for adolescents; it is a near and present hope. The onset of formal operational thought allows them, for the first time, the luxury of existential reflection. Teenagers realize with new force that they could live or they could die, and they do not want to live or die "for nothing." So they act out a deeper question: "What must I do to be saved?" Ministry geared to such questions sets out to shape the soul, not merely modify behavior; it traffics in Christian practice and doctrine, not miniature golf. Soul-shaping ministry knits together the developmental and cultural questions that he at the hub of adolescent experience and places them in the service of Christian tradition. Youth ministry that transcends the "church of tomorrow" helps youth put away their identities as slaves and jailers in favor of their freely given identities in Christ.

Salvation and identity formation: Trying not to disappear. Every adolescent engaged in the life-work of identity formation senses the ease with which he or she could vanish, especially given the magnetism of other, stronger identities and pseudo-identities that easily absorb the developing self into their powerful orbits. Without skills of resistance, youth frequently resort to outlandish and obnoxious behavior to escape absorption by powerful others. The slave girl described in Acts-who made Paul "very much annoyed" (16:18)-points her finger at Paul and Silas's message of salvation until Paul literally must stop and take notice. In Salinger's account, Holden Caulfield bolts from the magnetic pull of prep school, friends, family and his one remaining mentor, but his jarring search for autonomy leaves him with (literally) barely enough strength to cross the street:

I had this feeling that I'd never get to the other side of the street. I thought I'd just go down, down, down, and nobody'd ever see me again.... Every time I'd get to the end of a block I'd say [to my dead brother], "Allie, don't let me disappear. Allie, please don't let me disappear. Allie, don't let me disappear."6

During adolescence, writes James Loder, "all previous solutions to the major issues of the first ten years of life undergo an upheaval that thrusts the developing person into the abyss of nothingness underlying the ego, and calls that person into transformation."' As formal operational thought dawns during early adolescence, so too do new capacities for faith, for possibility, for dread. For the first time, youth recognize that they are dying a thousand deaths they cannot stop-a condition that Christian tradition chalks tip to sin, and developmental theorists attribute to identity diffusion. The upshot, either way, is the startling realization that "the me I know" is going to vanish.

Loder believes that the lurking possibility of the "void" that youth sense yawning beneath them-the possibility of disappearance-gives adolescence its theological potential. Encountering the void spurs young people to move out into the unknown futures to which they are biologically, socially and culturally called. In order to avoid vanishing into the abyss, as Loder calls the existential loss of self, youth begin building bridges-relationships that move them closer to others, closer even to God-as they seek a hand that can save them, that will keep them from falling into the darkness.8

In recent years, however, some youth who have felt themselves disappearing into this void have turned tip the volume on Holden Caulfield's mantra by punctuating it with gunfire. Desperate for clues about motivation, reporters from school shootings invariably pump classmates for character studies. The striking observation, again and again, is how little observation took place. "You just didn't notice them," classmate after classmate reports. Adolescent assassins like Eric Harris, Dylan Kliebold and SeungHui Cho, in incomprehensible and grandiose ways, took it upon themselves to be noticed. They demanded that someone, everyone listen. For one terrible day, they decided not to disappear.

Erik Erikson, whose theory of identity formation eventually framed the twentieth-century search for self, believed that identity-the consistent, durable sense of self that gives youth confidence that they will not disappear-enables adolescents to live for something worth dying for. For Erikson, achieving identity required being strengthened by the enduring virtue he called "fidelity," the strength of a "disciplined devotion." For Christians, disciplined devotion is the ongoing work of grace, not a static developmental strength we achieve on our own; fidelity-literally, faithfulness-is made possible by God's sanctifying grace, and its ultimate test is marturia: "witness," or literally, martyrdom. Yet Erikson's psychosocial definition of fidelity hints at the salve connection: Fidelity, said Erikson, is "the vital strength which [a youth] needs to have an opportunity to develop, to employ, to evoke-and to die for."9

To be sure, martyrdom makes mainline Protestants nervous. We confuse it with the desperate quest not to disappear-a quest that too often leads to violence, not sacrificial love. We lack Catholicism's confidence in beatification, and we do not share conservative evangelicalism's enthusiasm for cosmic drama. In fact, we tend to refer people with martyr complexes to psychologists, and our preaching has been known to devolve into a studied avoidance of death and its pesky theological companion, sin. Atonement theories in particular have received more than their share of theological corruption over the centuries, leading some theologians to want to banish them altogether for seeming to promote divinely sanctioned abuse or the celebration of suffering. But as Roberta Bondi rightly observes:

The early church does not teach that the most basic quality of God's love is a suffering self-sacrifice. What first engages God with its is not a duty or need or self-sacrifice or obligation or the need to be right or good but delight in us as the beloved.... Delight makes the lover extravagantly eager to make sacrifices for the beloved. The cross, which is the occasion for God's own terrible pain, is very real, but it is God's delight in and desire for its that calls God to do it.io

Of course, adolescents' interest in martyrdom, especially when twisted into a quest for recognition, is justly worrisome. Psychologists remind us that the adolescent predilection for excess, when coupled with an unformed self, tends to makes youth vulnerable to "totalism," an uncritical fusion of a permeable, "soft" identity with a newly claimed ideology. In totalism, the ideology, in effect, claims the youth instead of the other way around. Although most significant faith claims involve a period of totalism, youth ministers have a special obligation to allow adolescents the freedom to refuse our ideologies, lest we inadvertently manipulate them into "identity foreclosure" rather than disciple them into genuine commitments to Jesus Christ.

At the same time, neither adolescent development nor theology permits youth ministry to avoid passion-a love "to die for"-or its consequences. Identity is forged in the tension between the possibility of gaining a self and the possibility of losing the self, which occurs in the absence of being known intimately and loved unconditionally. In Christian tradition, the consequence of God's passion is salvation, as Christ offers divine love so true that he willingly suffers on behalf of the beloved; likewise, sanctification (and especially martyrdom) is always the consequence of a self so identified with Christ that it willingly gives itself for another. True love, as any teenage moviegoer will tell you, is always worth dying for. Youth intuit that salvation lies in finding someone who loves them enough to die for them, and the whole of adolescence is directed toward this end.

The totalistic vision of adolescents, then, makes the ultimate sacrifice of martyrdom appealing, if not for its gory glory then for its passion-for its affirmation of a worthy life, a love worthy of life and death, not just a Sunday night. Far from a form of mental instability, adolescence challenges the church to the kind of passionate self-sacrifice to which all Christians are called, born out of disciplined devotion that is not made possible by upbringing, education, psychological precocity (or instability) or even sheer determination. It is only possible by God's grace. The Columbine myth included not just two disturbed teen killers but also a lost girl who dabbled in drugs and witchcraft, turned to Jesus, joined a mission to gang members, grew her hair out for children with cancer, and allegedly declared her faith at gunpoint before being fatally shot." The word "witness" literally translates to "martyr" in Greek-and it is part and parcel of the radical faith to which teenagers searching for something "to die for" respond.

Salvation and identity formation: On their own. Add to adolescence the shifting sand of global postmodernity, and the theme of salvation stands out in bas-relief. Adolescents today grow tip with less adult contact than any generation in human history, forcing teenagers into what journalist Patricia Hersch aptly describes as "a tribe apart."" Although youth pull away from adults at more or less the same rate they have for generations, the adult abandonment of youth in the late twentieth century reached new and unprecedented proportions. Parents, for instance, spend 40 percent less time with their children than a generation ago.13

Not only has cultural fragmentation atomized communities and isolated institutions from which identities once were gleaned, but adults-traditional contributors to identity-are just plain hard to come by these days. Fifty years ago, adults controlled access to society's primary decisionmaking, education and earning power, and they functioned as gatekeepers for information necessary to participate fully in American middle-class institutions. In short, it served young people's best interest to eventually identify themselves as grown-ups. Today, however, standing alone in the shadow of the self-esteem movement, adolescents conclude that identity is tip to therm. Take this example, written for a school assignment by a teenage boy:

I Am an Adolescent

The problem is more subtle than working parents and stressed-out social schedules. Conflict requires relationship. The much-maligned adolescent "rebellion" of the 1960s allowed youth to remain connected with significant adults while at the same time distancing themselves from them. Except in its most destructive varieties, rebellion actually serves identity formation by helping one generation establish autonomy from the generation that has gone before-while at the same time acknowledging the older generation's presence and influence. Today, the adult-youth relationship critical to identity formation is threatened by adult invisibility as much as absence. Postmodern culture views adolescence less as a life stage than a lifestyle, a choice available to adults as well as youth. Advertisers blur the lines between generations by pitching adult toys and child makeup. Adults strive to prolong their adolescence while teenagers face daily decisions that potentially shortcircuit theirs.

Coupled with the unmitigated relativism of postmodern culture and its relentless insistence on choosing between options, adolescents often give up on investing in a coherent, governing life-view (what Erikson called an "ideology"). Facile, piecemeal role-taking along with the hapless compartmentalization of life into distinct, even contradictory, categories encourages a "self" cobbled together through bricolage, not integration. Instead of directing youth toward a center that holds, postmodern culture encourages adolescents to reinvent themselves for each of their proliferating social roles."

WHY YOUTH MINISTRY NEEDS THE CROSS

If youth ministry is to address fragmented, overwhelmed teenagers as human beings, and not as objects to be won and counted for the church, then we must orient twenty-first-century youth ministry unapologetically toward the cross. God's fidelity in Jesus Christ, demonstrated by the cross, is a sign of love. As developmental theorist and ethicist James Fowler ar gues, the cross of Christ is crucial to adolescents precisely because it shows the extent to which God goes in order to be with them."

In the twentieth century, the cross often served as a backdrop for youth ministry rather than as its raison d'etre; it was a rallying point for Christian nurture and prophetic witness, but one that became increasingly devoid of meaning as the theological memory of many Christians began to go the way of the poodle skirt. Instead of stressing the lengths God goes to in order to be with young people in the life, death and resurrection of Jesus Christ, youth ministry has vacillated between two teleological objectives: protection and empowerment-poles that seem increasingly unable to bear the weight of ministry for a generation of youth longing to find not new ways to do church or influence policy, but a person, a God, an ideal worth dying for-which, of course, is what makes it worth living for as well.

To be sure, the poles of religious nurture and social praxis preserve important aspects of Christian tradition and must neverbe discarded. Churches that approach youth ministry from a "communitarian" perspective seek to protect youth so their faith can mature and be shaped in the context of Christian communities. Comnwnitarian ethics are sometimes associated with conservative Protestantism, but in youth ministry communitarian praxis actually unites certain strands of evangelical Protestants, mainstream Catholics and so-called liberal Protestants with strong sacramental histories. Generally, communitarians view adolescence as a late form of childhood, not adulthood, making it incumbent upon institutions like the church to provide youth with the care, boundaries and resilience they need via the practices of Christian community-a community that defines itself as an alternative to the life and practices of the broader culture.'7

On the other hand, those who generally champion youth empowerment over protection-we might call them "liberating individualists"-encourage adolescents' interaction with the broader culture, believing that adolescents possess prophetic voices necessary for transforming culture. Since liberal Christianity tends to view adolescence as an early form of adulthood, emphasizing teenagers' relatively advanced biological and cognitive development, liberating individualists are optimistic about youth's capacities. If the communitarian concern is that youth are growing up too fast, the liberating individualist concern is that they are not growing up at all, and are therefore denied a public voice critical to the transformation of the adolescent as well as society."

Despite their different emphases, liberating individualist and communitarian Christians actually do share substantial common ground where youth are concerned (making youth ministry a promising point of rapprochement between these two theological perspectives). Liberating individualists concede the central importance of identity during adolescence, just as communitarians recognize the value of social praxis. Both of these approaches have much to commend them-but neither helps adolescents live into a doctrine of salvation capable of offering resilience against "disappearing" in the twenty-first century. The liberating individualist may misread the prophetic voice of adolescence, treating teens as voices in the wilderness when, in fact, they are canaries in the mines who sing out humanity's need for salvation amid toxic cultural conditions, songs that sound benign to an undiscerning ear. Like the slave girl in Philippi, adolescents call on the church to stand behind the gospel's most radical claims to redeem and deliver God's people-not to "fix" them. Communitarians, on the other hand, may tempt adolescent conformity rather than transformation, and socialize youth into community practices that may or may not point to the cross. In so doing, communitarians risk replacing holiness with wholesomeness, and youth risk falling for an ecclesiology that is benignly "nice" rather than dangerously loving.

The psychological and cultural realities facing adolescents in the twentyfirst century require a theological perspective in youth ministry that takes seriously the questions of salvation that dominate the adolescent experience: What is worth living for, and what is worth dying for? In the face of imminent destruction, who will save us? If the quest for salvation is fundamental to being human and not just to being sixteen, then youth ministry's contribution to the twenty-first-century church may be its unapologetic witness to the salvific relationship available in Jesus Christ. Christians believe that we humans are homo religiosus, creatures whose very existence depends on our relationship with something, or someone, whom we believe will save its. The impetus toward this relationship is so strong, in fact, that when we fail to recognize our relationship with the triune God capable of salvation, we invest our faith in lesser gods instead. "To be a self is to have a god," wrote H. Richard Niebuhr-although Niebuhr conceded that humans are fickle in their divine loyalties, living sometimes for the God of Jesus Christ and sometimes for the god of country, job or school_19 Without faith, Niebuhr noted, humans might exist, "but not as selves."20 In short, becoming fully human-having a self or identity-is impossible apart from the God who saves its, apart from the relationship that transforms who we are in light of who God is. As we bring our sin-twisted lives into the presence of Jesus Christ, we behold and reflect the imago Dci. In conforming to Christ's identity, we become new-people whose "selves" reflect not who we are, but who God is in us.

PRACTICAL THEOLOGY: FRESH STREAMS FOR YOUTH MINISTRY

For a century, youth ministry has been conceived of as a junior partner in the Christian education enterprise rather than as a pastoral calling-and certainly not as a colony of practical theologians whose engagement in and reflection on ministry is for the sake of the church, not youth alone. Clearly, Christian education is a critical component of mindful Christianity, but it is not the only component, nor is it the primary one. Indeed, no practice of Christian ministry exempts youth or youth ministry if God calls all of its into lives of passionate obedience. Youth are practical theologians by virtue of calling, not proficiency; their inexperience at using theological categories to understand the longings of themselves and others, coupled with the unparalleled spiritual openness of the adolescent life stage, requires adults to engage in careful and intentional pastoring of these intuitive theologians.

The doctrine of salvation remains the church's most practical doctrine. The practices of Christian life find their origins in the life, death and resurrection of Jesus Christ and are the saving work of God enacted, in human form, as Christ enters the world again and again through those who love him. Engaging youth in these practices of faith provides a way to colonize both the church and the world with practical theologians-young people who have a theological consciousness that "who they are" is both sinful and redeemed. It also strengthens adolescents' identification with the practicing faith community (the communitarian concern). Meanwhile, since practices of faith inevitably lead to practices of ministry, engaging youth directly in these practices strengthens and empowers teenagers for ministry in their own right (the liberating individualist concern). In the historic practices of Christian community, youth dialectically encounter the imago Dci in Jesus Christ, since, on the one hand, practices of the church help its become conformed to Christ. And on the other hand, it is in practicing our faith that we become transformed by Christ-re-created even as we claim, critique and re-create these practices for the faithful ministry of God's people.

In the absence of serious theological reflection on youth ministry, we have missed important opportunities to connect the doctrine of salvation with the developmental and cultural exigencies of being adolescent, and to experience doctrine's overall potential for shaping the soul. Developmentally predisposed to form relationships, in search of the One whose fidelity will not fail, whose desire will not fade, whose love will save them from disappearing, youth still require faithful adults to cast out the spirits of lesser gods that possess them. These faithful adults are those who can say, on behalf of awkward adolescents who are still enslaved by sin: "What must I do to be saved?"

OF MARTYRDOM AND MINISTRY

Standing at the brink between being and non-being, teenagers' loud denunciation of phoniness and clumsy stabs at truth call the church to proclaim salvation, even when we would rather not. We don't know why the slave girl's herald so annoyed Paul, but in the end, the truth she proclaimed could not be ignored. The proclamation that Christ's salvation is near demands an audience, and if the church will not proclaim it, adolescents-simply by being adolescents-will proclaim it in our stead. Like Holden Caulfield or the slave girl in Philippi, their voices can be grating, their announcement untimely, their presence jarring. But in their struggle not to disappear youth cling to the hope that yes, somewhere, someone can save them-and they enact this conviction brazenly. Those of its in ministry are called to put words on their intuition, to name what they hope: that they have not disappeared, or come apart, or gone unnoticed, because the God who loves them is in our midst, and salvation is at hand.

But our ministry with youth in the twenty-first-century church must do more than this. The church must also help teenagers recognize that salvation has come to them, and that as a result God calls them to leave behind their schoolboy or slave girl egos and take on new identities as disciples, empowered for ministry through the practices of Christian faith. God calls youth to become "practical theologians" in their own right, not for the sake of the youth in the church basement, but for the sake of the church. Teenagers reorder their lives daily according to what they think will save them (this week). Often they do not even know the gods to whom they pay homage. Yet youth cannot be faithful to that which is only implied. Fidelity-fidei, or "faith"-is the stuff of martyrdom, not of youth groups or even "the church of tomorrow." Indeed, authentic witness may jeopardize tomorrow as we expect it to be, for the sake of living faithfully today.

• DISCUSSION AND REFLECTION EXERCISE

Circular Response Technique
Have each person select a theme from this chapter that they would like to discuss.2' Have the first person speak for two minutes on her chosen theme. The person to her left goes next, paraphrasing the first speaker's comments, and explaining how his own comments spring from them. After two minutes, the next person to the left continues the process, and so it goes.
No one may be interrupted while speaking. No one may speak out of turn. Each person is allowed only two minutes to speak, and must begin by paraphrasing the comments of the previous person. Each person, in all comments, must strive to show how his or her remarks spring from, and are grounded in, the comments of the previous person.
After each person has been able to speak, the floor is open for reactions and further discussion.

↑ Back to top

↑