Chapter 19 of 20

Notes . . . . . . . . . . . .

Notes . . . . . . . . . . . .

ANDREW ROOT

WITH BLAIR D. BERTRAND

eleased from its long incubation as a subdiscipline under Christian education, where it received its essential theoretical nourishment from the social sciences, American academic youth ministry has slowly matured over the last two decades. Like coming out of a cocoon, youth ministry scholarship has begun not only to recognize its limbs and its ability to create and move in new directions, but also to see that it has wings, and colorful ones at that. And it is realizing that these beautifully colored wings are its essential theological nature, that reflection on the practice of youth ministry is a fundamental theological task. Thus, recognizing its freedom from the incubating cocoon and the colorful theological wings it possesses, youth ministry scholarship has begun to see itself as a practical theological activity.

This has led to a fresh theological turn for youth ministry; drawing from practical theological and missiological perspectives, youth ministry scholarship has sought to give attention to the activity of God in distinct local communities of practice. Therefore, youth ministry, like many of the practical theological disciplines, has turned to ethnography and other qualitative research methods, seeking to thickly describe and interpret contexts as places of theological action. In addition, youth ministry has followed (and therefore placed itself within) the larger field of practical theology by seeing its core activity as reflecting on concrete/present situations for their theological depth.

Yet something has been missing in this significant turn, and missing not only in youth ministry but in practical theology more broadly. I contend that this something is essential for helping those preparing for (and already in) ministry think theologically about their actions and identity. In all the constructive work in youth ministry and practical theology, there has been little systematic attention given to how divine action and human action (or divine praxis and human praxis) relate one to another, to how and where they actually associate. So while we have sought to articulate theological issues and perspectives in connection to concrete communities and practices, we have not yet sought to articulate how to go about discerning the activity of God from the place of human action or how human action is participation in the action and being of God in the world. And though we have turned our attention to local practice for its theological depth, we have not articulated clearly how our actions are associated with our conceptions of how God acts and moves in human history-at least, not clearly enough to impact local practitioners' views of how their action is associated with divine action. Yet it seems, at least to me, that this association is the heart of ministry itself. Ministry at its core is human action that participates in divine action.

If practical theology, and youth ministry following it, is concerned with the theological activity of local communities of action, then youth ministry imbedded within practical theology is fundamentally about the articulation and association of two distinct forms of action (praxis): God's and humanity's. James Loder called this "the generative problematic of practical theology." It is problematic because divine and human actions are distinct and different-or, at the very least, we must admit that divine action is hidden directly from the human knower. But it's also generative, because although these forms of action (praxis) are distinct, they nevertheless do relate. God does act with and for its within our local communities, as our ethnographic studies have uncovered. But how do we understand this, and how can it help us do ministry and practice our faith in a way that is congruent with our understanding of how divine and human actions associate in our local concrete histories?

This postscript explores this question. Drawing from the work of Richard Bernstein and his book Praxis and Action, I will seek to articulate how certain forms of human reflection have understood how the divine and human forms of action find association. In Praxis and Action Bernstein shows how four significant philosophical streams of thought have all pro vided unique ways of understanding action (praxis) within human history. All four streams, Bernstein believes, find their energy in conflict with Hegel's system. I will push Bernstein's thesis beyond its philosophical perspective into the theological, asserting that the forms of human action he teases out have been methodological pathways of relating divine and human action for theologians.2

This article will thus place the philosophical in conversation with the theological. While twentieth-century theology has warned its against the dangers of doing so (dangers that I consider significant), Dietrich Bonhoeffer, a great proponent of revelation-centric distinctiveness, nevertheless maintains that philosophy cannot be obliterated from the theological. Rather, if God has not only entered into human history through act but also through action has impacted our very being-in-the-world (as Bonhoeffer argues in Act and Being), then the philosophical must be considered as helping to give perspective as the human seeks to discern and participate in divine action.

Bernstein contends that Marxism (critical theory), pragmatism and Kierkegaardian existentialism (the three streams from Bernstein that I will consider) can all be understood as philosophical projects about action or praxis. In opposition to a Hegelian method, each of these philosophical perspectives seeks to reconceptualize human action. But because of Hegel's extensive and all-encompassing approach (e.g., Geist not only being the flow of history but also the activity of God), Bernstein contends that these perspectives give attention to ultimacy (communism's political perspective shows the form of ultimacy in Marxism, even in relation to its atheism).3 Therefore, due to their attention both to action (praxis) and to ultimacy, it is no wonder that these philosophical streams have provided intuitive direction in practical theological methodological construction. Clearly, critical theory, pragmatism and a Kierkegaardian existentialism are not the onlyphilosophical perspectives worth considering, but as I will argue, they have been the most consistently and generatively drawn upon by practical theological perspectives on ministry. Bernstein, however, did not give attention to all the significant philosophical perspectives drawn on within practical theology. Rather, more recently a recovery of Aristotle through the lens of the work of philosopher Alasdair MacIntyre has pushed forth a neo-Aristotelian perspective in practical theology.

This postscript will examine each of these four perspectives (neo-Aristote lianism, critical theory, pragmatism and a Kierkegaardian perspective) to explore their understanding of praxis/action, how this understanding has been appropriated within practical theology, and where divine and human action find association from within this perspective. To give these conversations flesh, I will then provide an example from within youth ministry of how a thinker has drawn from each of these perspectives. We will see Kenda Creasy Dean as an exemplar of the neo-Aristotelian perspective, David White in relation to critical theory, Chap Clark in light of pragmatism and myself (through the writing of Blair D. Bertrand) in connection to Kierkegaardian existentialism. While some of these thinkers work explicitly from these perspectives and others more intuitively, I will seek to show how their understanding of divine and human action leads them to argue for a distinct understanding of where and how human agents encounter the activity of God.

Each thinker makes a case that youth ministry should revolve around certain actions, because each thinker believes that divine and human action come together in certain ways. While I have placed myself (through the hand of Bertrand) in this article, I will not make the case that one perspective is better than the others; I leave evaluation to the reader. Like Osmer's description of practical theology, this article provides a heuristic or descriptive map.' In addition, the fact that I have placed a thinker in one stream does not mean that they do not also drink from others. For instance, while I will argue that Dean is deeply imbedded in a neo-Aristotelian perspective, she does at many points drink from Kierkegaard,' and White much more than superficially draws from the practices discussion of a neo-Aristotlianism. Nevertheless, I will argue that each of these thinkers draws mostly from one stream in constructing their commitments to how young people encounter the action of God in their concrete lives.

This, then, is the ultimate significance of this postscript for the reader, to explore the essence of ministry: to understand and articulate how concrete people encounter the action of God, and to therefore construct their ministries in such a manner.

FORMS OF DIVINE AND HUMAN ACTION

Neo-Aristotelian. If there were a father of "praxis" as a concept, it would be Aristotle. Aristotle sought to tease out how the actions of praxis were different from those of poesis. Poesis is an action that has its telos, or end, as a final product, but in praxis the telos is in doing the activity well in itself. Therefore, the practical life has its own telos and therefore its own distinct form of knowledge. These forms of knowledge were essential for life in the polis, Aristotle believed, contending that the practical life resulted in a good political life for the polis. Praxis as practical forms of knowledge was participated in through practice or action itself. As one engaged in praxis, one did practices that held within them knowledge and virtues that transformed individuals. And if these practices were practiced together, which most practices demand both in their operation and historical form, then communities themselves would be transformed. These practices, because they were grounded in praxis, were not about utilitarian function-getting to some simple end-but about being in community. So praxis was lived out as a set of communal practices performed by members of a group for the sake of being in community well. The understanding was that people form excellence not by seeking a final goal but by reflecting on their journey, on the practices that they use to form their life together.

Alasdair Maclntyre has revived Aristotle's philosophical perspective, applying it to our late modern post-industrial times. Seeking to move past frozen principles as the ground for ethics, Maclntyre turns to virtue. He argues that it is through habits and knowledge of a good life-thus, through character and virtue-that one learns to act ethically. However, character and virtue are learned through the practices of a community. As one lives in a community of practice, one is drawn into the community's habits, taking on its virtues. It is therefore through practice that we learn how to act in the world.

This perspective has been ripe for practical theological reflection. Dorothy Bass and Craig Dykstra have been two of the greatest proponents of reflecting deeply on the practices of communities as the task of practical theology. They define Christian practices as "things Christian people do together over time to address fundamental human needs in response to and in the light of God's active presence for the life of the world."6 This rich definition reveals that a neo-Aristotelian perspective sees divine and human action coming together in the practices of a community of faith. When a community engages in the practices of faith they encounter God. The human action of practice aligns the community with divine action. However, it is not just any practice that matters; rather, it is practices that have been built up over time, practices that are imbedded in the tradition of Christian faith. These practices connect reflection on faith with experience and action, making faith a passionate engagement with self, world and community and, through this, passionate engagement with God. Therefore, we encounter God as we practice our faith together.

In Practicing Passion Kenda Creasy Dean richly places youth ministry within a neo-Aristotelian perspective. While her overall argument pushes beyond one category, when it comes to the connection between divine and human action she proposes that practices in a passionate church are the place of encounter with God. Dean is adamant about the independent and dynamic activity of God; she returns repeatedly to this reality. Nevertheless, Dean also seeks to explore how human beings, particularly young people, encounter this dynamic action. She contends that this action of God is so dynamic that it can be understood as pure passion; God acts in the world from God's passion for God's creation. The goal of her project is to articulate how the human agent can encounter this passion. Dean asserts that adolescents are the perfect people to make the central focus of this pursuit, because adolescents, in her definition, are ontologically passionate, though she sees their present passionate action as misdirected toward consumer over-attention. She doesn't necessarily blame adolescents for this (nor the system, as some of our thinkers below will); she blames the church. Dean grieves that the church has lost passion and as such is unable to connect to the ontological passion of young people. The church, in her view, has ceased expecting to encounter God, has ceased placing a theological emphasis on a lived experience of soteriology as the natural extension of God's passionate engagement with the world. This loss of passion, she believes, has much to do with misdirected human action. The church has failed to make God's passionate action central to its life. Her book, then, is ultimately about a church that is failing to engage the ontological passion of people, which is seen most directly in the apathy of young people toward it.

How, then, do we encounter this dynamic action of the passion of God in the world? Dean turns to human action, believing that the church can reignite its passion by reviving its practices, thereby inviting young people to also passionately practice their faith in a passionate community. Thus, in neo-Aristotelian form (though Dean pushes the dynamic independent activity of God more than most), she asserts that it is through practices that the passion of human action is taken into the passion of the activity of God.7 "Spiritual practices," Dean states, "did not eliminate human passion, but refocused it on its proper object: God. Especially among inexperienced Christians, spiritual disciplines became the tools that loosened young people's grip on lesser loves so they could freely accept and respond to the passion of God."8 As human agents take on the practices of faith-the practices embedded in the tradition of the faithful community-they encounter the activity of God. Dean notes, for instance, that "in worship, our lives become signs of God's passion as we take part in holy practices, human actions that God uses to infuse creation with grace, wonder, and love."9

Thus, we engage the passion of young people by inviting them into practice, into taking on the virtues and habits of the faithful community-but these practices, for Dean, are only virtues, and are therefore only transformative because they are infused with God's very presence. The ultimate objective of youth ministry is to ignite young people's passion in Godself, but the way to do this is to move them into practice. Practice is the ground of divine and human encounter. It is through practice that young people are given an identity as Christian, an identity that invites them to passionately practice their faith in the activity of God, to practice their faith in passion as opposed to giving their action and their identity to other cultural realities. Dean asserts, "In spiritual disciplines that imitate Christ [in practices], God imparts the grace that `detaches' adolescent passions from the therapeutic gods of consumer culture."10 Holding to the dynamic activity of God, she continues, "Christian practices form identity in Christ not because of what young people do in these practices, but because of what God does in them."" Practices in good neo-Aristotelian perspective form young people, transforming their very action in the world, as they are invited deeper into the practices of the life of a community.

Therefore, a youth worker's job is to form his or her ministry around faithful and rich practices, not only because they lead to virtue and Christian habits (a Christian identity, Dean would assert), but more importantly because they are the place young people are drawn into the passion of God. She explains, "What I ani suggesting ... is that the practices of the Christian community should comprise the core of Christian curriculum for young people."" Young people are drawn into this passion not as an individual reality, however, but as a communal one. Practices engage the young person in the presence of God within and through a community of action, and therefore young people are immediately called out into the world as they practice their faith with others over time. Dean sees this as the heart and soul of passionate action-action that is missing in most churches. The human action of practice is the container God fills with God's very presence; the practice itself becomes the place to encounter God.13

Critical social theory. It is commonly cited that there are two Karl Marxes, the early one and the mature one. While the mature Marx of the Capital is known for his economic theory and political ideas, which served as the soil for communism, the early Marx is considered to be a philosopher and thinker. After Aristotelian praxis lost its magnetism within philosophical reflection, it was the early Marx who revived and added to the concept of praxis. Having studied Hegel, the early Marx contends that it is not the philosopher's job to simply describe the world (Hegel had done a good job of this) but to change it. Therefore, the job of philosophy is not found in simply constructing theory but in propelling people out into action, to change what is wrong with the world. And the young Marx, writing from a nascent industrialized nineteenth century, believed there was much wrong with the world.

Marx felt that it was wrong, for example, that people were disconnected from their labor, and not engaged in their own action-that people were no longer in control of what they produced-which meant that what they produced was no longer an expression of their self but rather dominated them. This happened because of the system, because the structure of society embedded in its intuitions functioned (acted) to estrange people from themselves for the sake of their own power. Marx believed that society is therefore constructed in a manner that leads to alienation." For Marx, people are what they do, so if their work estranges them from themselves, if their action has nothing to do with their very person, then people are alienated by the very structures they live in. In other words, people are alienated because they have become objectified, turned into cogs laboring, which keeps them from participating in their own action. Marx asserted that the very structures and institutions of society are wrapped together in such a manner that people are estranged from their own action, which therefore means that people are forced into contradictions: they are free (ontologically) but bound practically and societally." As Bernstein explains, "At the heart of Marx's theorizing is a `radical anthropology' which seeks to overcome the dichotomies that have plagued modern thought and life.""

This estrangement is not an ontological reality but a historical one, since people are not meant to live in contradiction, to be alienated as objects from the world. Rather, they are meant to be agents, to be actors, to be people of praxis. They are meant, from their ontological core, to live beyond contradiction. Much like Hegel, Marx sought to overcome all contradictions, but unlike Hegel, Marx believed that what is needed to overcome contradiction is action to rework the historical flow of society and its institutions. Hegel interpreted the world, but Marx sought to change it, to rework and remodel the structures of society by tearing down the old. Thus, for Marx, the only way to overcome contradiction is to engage in revolutionary praxis, to overcome the estranging, alienating systems with new ones.

The chief task to bring forth revolutionary praxis, Marx believed, is educating the people, and awakening their consciousness so that they might see and understand the alienating conditions of their world that thrust them into contradiction. It is, in other words, about educating them to recognize that they are being exploited for the gain of the structures of society. For revolutionary praxis to happen, people must be taken to a place of consciousness raising. While the historical system seeks to wash our very selves from our action, revolutionary praxis places consciousness back within our action, leading its to act beyond contradiction and in unity of ourselves. But for this to reach its needed end, the telos of its praxis, the systems and institutions themselves must change. Revolutionary praxis is thus praxis with the goal of changing the historical unfolding of the world from within human action. Consciousness raising begins, for Marx, with "`relentless criticism of all existing institutions.' A criticism that demands a correct theoretical analysis of existing institutions and the contradictions inherent in

A number of practical theologians, especially those in education, have drawn from the wells of Marx, most often following thinkers who have constructed theories and praxis from within Marx's theory (Paulo Freire would be an example of a Marxist thinker who has had great impact on practical theologians in education). As Bernstein notes, "Marx's [and those like Freire who follow him] fundamental conviction ... is that the situation in which we find ourselves is not ultimately an ontological or existential one from which there is no escape. It is an historical state of affairs, which while it has its `own necessity,' is nevertheless the resultant of human activity and can be changed by revolutionary praxis.""

The praxis of practical theology that follows from this, then, is engaging historical alienating forces of society and opposing them with actions of liberation. The practical theologian seeks to raise people's consciousness of their estrangement and oppression by criticizing deeply the societal functions that they live within. In so doing, human action participates in divine action by pushing out the oppression of the present historical structure and replacing it with God's reign of humanization, freedom and wholeness. Divine and human action thus find association (often through the motif of God's reign) as an alternative historical reality that can be brought forth through human action. Where oppressive systems are put down for the sake of liberation, God is active. God can be found in acts of liberation. Therefore, divine and human action come together through the critique of systems that oppose us in which our consciousness is raised so that we might act beyond our bondage and toward unity of self and world. God stands on the side of the oppressed, so in acting for them we encounter the action of God in the world, and our action ushers in the reign of God.

In the context of youth ministry, David White and his book Practicing Discernment with Youth is a good example of a social critical perspective on divine and human action. Throughout the first chapters of the book, White makes the argument that adolescence is a social construction that itself thrusts contradiction on young people, alienating them from their true selves by disconnecting them from family in peer units that quickly become infused with consumerism. White states, "The social institution of adolescence, like Frankenstein's monster, is not natural. It was constructed from a conglomeration of ideas and practices that served the interests of marketers, employers, labor unions, educators, politicians, and the middle classyet remained oblivious to the yearnings of youth to contribute their gifts to the common good, and the church that sought to call forth these charisms."'9

Much like for Marx, the very structures of society are the enemy for White; a consumerist fetish has kept young people from recognizing that they are agents, that they can act.20 And, like Marx, White gives sharp attention to the historical, asserting that "over the last thirty years the opportunities that once made adolescence bearable have become limited, leaving young people with fewer ways to act upon In other words, in the flavor of social critical theory, White sees the structures as opposing and alienating young people from their true selves, which is the ability to act upon history. According to White, adolescents have been estranged from acting upon history by becoming overly concerned with commercial and popular culture. These systemic realities subvert the adolescent's greater will.

In the second half of his book White provides a way for adolescents to raise their consciousness and escape the contradiction by engaging in reconstructing a historical reality beyond the oppression of their condition. The youth worker becomes their teacher a nd model for revolutionary praxis, or what White would call "the reign of God."22 In this, then, the youth worker's job is to take adolescents into a process of discernment, leading them to see how the system thrusts them into contradiction and how their action is estranged from them through the alienating forces of society. White explains, "Youth do not need more activity or more entertainment; they need (ministers who dedicate whatever resources they already have to understanding and resisting the distortions of culture and living into the way of Jesus-and helping youth to do the sa111e."23

For White, adolescents themselves are oppressed peoples,24 meaning that divine action can be encountered when these oppressed people act for the sake of their liberation. This also means that, when these oppressed people are alienated and silenced, God's reign is opposed. White states, for instance, that "when youth's gifts are not respected and cultivated, the beauty of God is limited and the reign of God is postponed."25 Moreover, when these oppressed people find unity in their action by overcoming oppressive structure, they are participating in the action of God. White has a potent understanding of divine action, which is that human action can participate in divine action and that human action is essential for the dynamism of divine action.

Therefore, youth workers who want their young people to participate in God's action in the world would, according to White, call young people into the historical to engage the structures (most directly consumerism). In other words, they would help young people (move beyond their oppression by practicing all new actions in the world, actions that are congruent with God's own action of liberation. White sums tip what he sees as discipleship-how he sees divine and human action coming together in the life of young people-this way: "Discipleship requires attentiveness to the holy, that is, to God's ongoing activity in the world. It requires prophetic social critique, engendered by seeing the world as God sees it and speaking out for that vision. Discipleship in its fullest sense also requires justice-seeking action in the world on behalf of `the widows and orphans' and the neediest of God's

Pragmatism. American pragmatism was a philosophical position born through the work of William James, Charles Sanders Peirce and John Dewey (to name a few). At its core, pragmatism sought to make philosophy a practical force for change within society. Moving beyond what it saw as the abstract epistemological obsessions of continental thought, it gave total attention to action. John Dewey, for instance, believed that philosophical attention on education could produce a greater democratic society.

Like Marxism, pragmatism gives attention to the social and historical, but unlike Marxism, it refuses to see the systems and structures of culture as fundamentally corrosive. So, while human action in Marxism seeks to overcome oppression by ushering in a new historical epoch, pragmatism sees human action as a way to convert certain elements in society to function for the greater good. In other words, it sees no real reason to overthrow the present system but rather seeks to work within it, believing that the present historical situation can be transformed with proper inquiry; human action is an operation of reflection rather than revolution. Indeed, the heart of pragmatism is the belief that "a primary characteristic of human experience is its purposiveness. We are creatures who can imaginatively construct new possibilities and by intelligent inquiry we can reconstruct our experience so that the goods that we most deeply desire can be achieved and made stable."27

For Peirce, this form of action is contingent on a community of inquirya community that gives attention to the present situation by turning to the tradition of thought for resources to lead the community into inquiry that can bring about changing praxis.28 As Bernstein elucidates, "The community of inquirers, which is ultimately the basis for distinguishing the real from the unreal, and the true from the false, functions as a regulative ideal in Peirce's philosophic Therefore, human action in pragmatism has much to do with moral/behavioral ethics: with seeking what the necessary or needed action is within the existing systems of history to bring about the greater good. Thus, it is not only action that matters, but action that has connection to conduct, action that has reflected upon and therefore impacted our very behavior in the world. The action desired here is action that is primarily about how we "behave" in the world. It seeks a new horizon for the historical (like Marxism) but sees this new horizon in continuity with-not in opposition to-the present historical reality, believing that with the right action that affects our conduct and behavior, much can change.

Practical theologians working from a pragmatist perspective give significant attention to the community of inquiry, seeing communities as places of investigation, places to discern and hone human action by influencing conduct and behavior. To discern divine action, the practical theologian turns to the tradition, with its wealth of knowledge for action in the now. Thus, the community of inquiry reflects on the tradition to discern the necessary actions to take. Don Browning, perhaps the most famous practical theologian working explicitly from a pragmatist understanding of divine and human action, sees the job of the practical theologian as mining the tradition in communities of inquiry to formulate new ethical actions of practice within our present historical situation.

In youth ministry, one of the greatest implicit pragmatist thinkers may be Chap Clark. His work has a significant ethical dimension. For instance, he sees a considerable piece of youth ministry as working to "right wrongs,"30 and in his most methodological piece, "Youth Ministry as Practical Theol he presents the sexual practices of students as his central problem, asserting that practical reflection must help students (and young people) make good decisions for behavior and conduct through appropriate information. We can see how deeply this runs in his interpretation of practical theology as a whole when he says, "As practical theology has developed, virtually every model is designed to ultimately influence behavior."32

While Clark is more conservative than Browning or even than pragmatism in general, his understanding of divine and human action and their association is deeply pragmatist in nature; he attempts with his work to bring forth change within the existing system. Like White, he sees a number of threatening cultural realities confronting young people, but unlike White, he is less willing to wipe away the system that is. Where White is happy to abandon technology and return to a premodern concept of young people, Clark seeks to bring reform by abandoning only some of the elements of the system (not the whole thing), and converting other elements toward the goal he seeks.

The goal he seeks, the telos of human action, is aligning oneself with the biblical text. He asserts, "The goal of our teaching must be to equip our students ... to guide the believing community where they are called to serve in making kingdom-driven decisions and choices as they live in a complex and changing world."33 Keeping, then, with the pragmatists who seek to acquire new action in the present historical moment through reflec tion on the classic tradition, Clark turns to the Bible, not as the witness to God's story and continued action but as a tradition that sets the terms for action (conduct and behavior) in itself and therefore demands complete assimilation to its perceived wishes.34

Thus, in pragmatist fashion, divine and human action come together as the human agent reflects on the classic (God-given, even) tradition and then applies it to the case at hand for changed conduct and behavior. From Clark's perspective, the divine and human come together when the human acts, through his or her behavior, in congruence with the Bible, specifically, for he believes the Bible is God's action in the world (for Clark, God's kingdom and the Bible are nearly inseparable). While Clark has room for other traditional elements as resources for reflection, it is ultimately the Bible and the way the Bible directs its that bring divine and human action Clark says it this way: "What practical theology offers is a focused and deliberative process for discerning how biblical and theological insights apply to the challenges of applied faithful action in a changing culture. Practical theology begins with a specific reality, or context, and moves from there to a reflexive conversation with the Scriptures that leads IS to new action."36

Like in social critical theory pragmatism provides a significant theological motif to think about divine action (White likes "the reign" and Clark "the kingdom" of God). But for both what is important is attending to the historical; human action possesses the power to bring forth the very activity of God, either through consciousness-raising action against the system (White) or by attending to biblical truth and applying it to conduct and behavior (Clark). For both, divine action can be thwarted if young people are oppressed or ignore (deny) biblical truth. In Clark's words, "The goal ... of practical theology is to arrive at a biblical theology of an issue (and related questions) in order to determine an applicable biblical theology, or theologically-derived and biblically-defined praxilogical response to the context and issue at hand."37

Where Clark may have the most resonance with pragmatism is in the function of commmmunal decision-making. He understands that his biblicalcentric perspective, his reflection on the classic for molding present action in behavior and conduct, holds within it hermeneutical problems; he recognizes, for instance, that the human knower may get the biblical meaning wrong and therefore miss divine action. So, like Browning, who seeks a rich conversation with hermeneutical theory (mostly Gadamer) to assist his re flection on the tradition, Clark provides a hermeneutical perspective. In pragmatist fashion, he places a community as central.38 For Clark, the community functions like Peirce's community of inquiry, attending to the classic (the Bible) by reflecting on actions in the present historical. Thus, he holds up the Bible and the colnlnunity as leading to human ethical actions that participate in God's activity. Yet, unlike pragmatism in general, Clark has little discussion on how the colnlnunity itself could be sinful or prone toward evil. Rather, for him, the colnlnunity alone serves as an antidote for corrupt (or simply wrong) biblical interpretation.

For Clark then, the job of the youth worker is to help young people act in a manner congruent with the Bible so that they might, in their individual lives and for the good of society, glorify God. Their actions assimilate them to the classic as they trust the biblical perspective. Therefore, divine and human action come together in the pragmatic activity of the human agent; the human agent encounters divine action not necessarily in its independent dynamism but in the human agent's assimilation to the biblical through the community, which points toward correct action through behavior and conduct.39

Kierkegaardian. Soren Kierkegaard wrote in opposition to the Hegelian system. Hegel had seen great possibility for human action to bring the world, through the unfolding of history, to a great synthesis. Kierkegaard was never convinced. He believed there existed within persons and within society as a whole far too much impossibility to take any hope in the idealist vision of the unfolding of history that Hegel and others presented. Kierkegaard contended that human action itself was bankrupt because human action existed next to an abyss: the abyss of infinite freedom, a freedom that forced human action to crash on the rocks of anxiety.4o

Kierkegaard showed that all forms of action, whether aesthetic (seeking beauty), ethical or even religious, fall short of reaching their objective.41 And it takes little jostling to connect Kierkegaard's three failed actions with neo-Aristotlianism, pragmatism and Marxism: all these forms of action ignore the fact that there exists an ocean of impossibility in the human condition, that suffering and death are operative realities. No matter how we might act, no action can save us from a world in which we die and return to non-being. All actions that don't take this into consideration ignore that our actions are always actions near death.

Kierkegaard believed that his perspective followed the tradition of Luther, who saw human action as an impossibility to save itself, and sought for God, the very activity of God, in and through impossibility (the cross) as our hope. Therefore, Kierkegaard contends that divine and human action are completely distinct, one in heaven and the other on earth. The only action that the human agent can take is to face the abyss, to admit the impossibility of action and, in the midst of the impossibility, to trust in the utterly absurd.42 Trusting that God has acted, and acted in the absurd paradox of being human, places the action of heaven within reach of the human. Therefore, the only action possible from the human side is the action of the knight's move: the action of faith; it is to trust in God's action in the midst of the futility of human action.

There are few practical theologians who have worked from a Kierkegaardian perspective. Because practical theology is fundamentally reflection on human action within the scope of divine action, it is no wonder that most have found little help in Kierkegaard's position of the impossibility of human action itself. James Loder is the practical theologian who has most robustly turned to Kierkegaard, constructing a method of practical theology which sees divine action and human action coming together in negation. He contends that the Spirit of God negates the negation (death and the abyss) in the human spirit, therefore allowing human action to be taken up into divine action.

While Loder's work has deep wells of significance for ministry in general, he mainly sticks with Kierkegaard himself. In Revisiting Relational Youth Ministry, Andrew Root43 pushes past Kierkegaard back to Luther and through Luther to the early Moltmann, Eberhard Jiingel and Douglas John Hall. Specifically, Root draws on the words of German Lutheran theologian Dietrich Bonhoeffer to tease out what it means to be in relationship with another human in light of the absurdity of the human condition. Following Kierkegaard, Root contends that human action is an impossibility; it cannot be a means of transformation or salvation. Human action is too close to death and death is too operative in our realities to maintain that practices, critical engagement or corrected behavior can mediate the presence of God. None of the above perspectives contend with death and suffering directly; none place being as central within human activity, let alone being-towarddeath. As opposed to seeing adolescents as fundamentally passionate, oppressed or in need of ethical conversion, then, Root contends that adolescents are awakening to the existential state of their existence-awakening to the tragic core of human existence-and seeking to discover who they are next to impossibility and limitation. They are confronting the reality that their own actions cannot give them answers to the question, "What is a lifetime and why do we live it?"44

Yet unlike a strictly Kierkegaardian perspective, as a practical theologian Root still believes that humans need to act. The human action that is needed, though, is action that reveals and dwells in impossibility, a human action that unveils what we already know: that we are stuck and that death is operative in our lives. This action of articulating and facing a reality of impossibility, Root contends, is where divine and human action associate. When we invite young people to face their impossibility, the God of the cross encounters them. Divine action envelops them, calling them to a new and whole life that seeks God in death and brokenness, a new life that seeks God's future in backwardness and brokenness, a new life that goes out into the world in search of God in the brokenness of existence as God is near in the brokenness of our own being. It is going out into the world to proclaim that we can find God on the cross, always with those facing suffering and death. And it is through bearing this paradoxical impossibility that human action and divine action are associated. In Root's view, God is concretely present in the human action of facing impossibility, for in facing impossibility we encounter the God who brings life and possibility out of death and impossibility by taking on the cross and overcoming it through resurrection.

This impossibility becomes most clear for Root "within personal encounter, shared relational bonds of I and other."45 Jesus Christ, as the one who has taken the impossibility of the human condition into himself and negated the negation, stands with its and for us; as fully human and fully divine, Jesus Christ stands with each person. Therefore, "to be in relationship with another is to encounter Jesus Christ who is beside and for us."46 Over and against any conception of relationship that denies the very presence of the fully human and fully divine Christ, Root proposes that Christians must encounter each other in our reality.

This means that we should not cajole each other into participating in practices, educate so that we might change the world or debate about ethical action, because each of these actions denies the human condition in some subtle way. Practices purport to get it right, to actually make something other than humanity the vehicle of God's presence in the world. Yet practices still deny the fact that no action that we take can ever get it right enough to act as a vehicle for God because each action is an action at the edge of an inescapable abyss. Education, in turn, does not go deep enough to reveal that not only are systems oppressive to its but also the very human condition is absurdly oppressive. And ethical action in the pragmatist tradition can descend to mere utilitarianism, treating humans as ends unto themselves; even at its best, it does not fully take into account the depths of our mortality. The "good enough" action, the stable system that promotes the good for many are ways of denying the absurdity of the human condition by putting a thin veneer of respectability over the truth. Each of these approaches attempts to move a person away from the truth of the matter.

Real relationship then, for Root, is a relationship that fully acknowledges and in fact reveals the human condition by fully acknowledging and revealing the living Christ. In encountering the other as other, we begin to see the absurdity of our common condition; as we see others, hear them speak, delight in their existence and serve them with our actions, we see the human condition-and we also see that God in Jesus Christ has worked to redeem us. We are not trying to influence each other but rather to see the reality of God in the relationship. This reality will prompt its to do certain things together-it will spur its on to help others and will suggest ethical ways of acting-but the relationship itself always remains the primary place of divine and human encounter. At times, this reality will call us simply to share the place of the other, to sit in the absurdity of the human condition without the intention of doing, freeing or fixing anything. This place-sharing itself can be a moment of revelation when we gain a glimpse of the placesharing that God accomplished on the cross through Jesus Christ.

The objective of the youth worker, then, is to be a bearer of reality, to walk deeply into the suffering, doubts and yearning of young people, being with and for them in the midst of their impossibility. The youth worker thus claims the presence of God, the encounter of divine and human action, in being found deeply in the lives of young people, in being their place-sharers.

SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION

All four of these conceptions of divine and human action have their advantages, and each has its own overlap and nearness to one or two other perspectives. For example, a neo-Aristotelian perspective, like a Kierkegaardian one, sees divine action as connected to the core of the human agent. Yet, like pragmatism, neoAristotelianism sees the function of the community as essential. Pragmatism, in turn, seeks the historical, just as social theory does. These perspectives should therefore be interpreted not as fundamentally opposed but as distinct, though related, fields of reflection on divine and human action.

In this postscript, I did not seek to state that one perspective is better than the others. Nor did I want to imply that any of these thinkers can be completely bound in only one of these perspectives. Indeed, placing myself in one of the categories made me aware that I work from more than just the Kierkegaardian perspective. Yet, with that said, I am arguing here that each of these thinkers has a particular primary understanding of how divine and human action come into association. This descriptive offering may therefore be of help to youth workers as they read youth ministry texts and seek to understand the author's position. But more importantly, it may help them begin to conceptualize for themselves how and where human action connects to divine action, so that they might then mold their ministries in ways that fit their theological perspectives.

• DISCUSSION AND REFLECTION EXERCISE

Critical Debate
After you've taken some time to discuss the differences and tensions in the understanding of divine and human action as a large group, pick the one that you are most convinced by.47 The leader will then frame a statement that has some tension to it, like, "When it conies to how pop culture functions in young people's lives, only a perspective is worth considering in youth ministry, for it articulates that God meets young people by
At this point, participants should take on a different perspective than the one they relate to most. For example, the leader may ask those identifying with neo-Aristotelianism to take the perspective of a social critical Marxist, the social critical Marxists to take on pragmatism, the pragmatists to become Kierkegaardians and the Kierkegaardians to become neo-Aristotelians.
Break into small groups with others who've been assigned the same perspective as you. Fill in the blanks of the statement, but in discussing why your group's position is most helpful, also explain why the others are not. This will allow you all to try to defend a position that you do not hold emotionally, which will get you to indwell the ideas more fully.
The objective is not to get to one right perspective but to try on each of these perspectives, whether in affirmation or critique.

Introduction

'L. Gregory Jones, "Learning Curve," The Christian Century, May 18,2010 <www. christiancentury.org/article.lasso?id=8444>.
2See Kenda Creasy Dean, Practicing Passion: Youth and the Quest for a Passionate Church (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2004) and Almost Christian: What the Faith of Our Teenagers Is Telling the American Church (New York: Oxford University Press, 2010); also see Andrew Root, Revisiting Relational Youth Ministry: From a Strategy of Influence to a Theology of Incarnation (Downers Grove, Ill.: IVP Books, 2007) and The Children of Divorce: The Loss of Family as the Loss of Being (Grand Rapids: Baker, 2010).
3See Christian Smith with Melinda Denton, Soul Searching: The Religious and Spiritual Lives of American Teenagers (New York: Oxford University Press, 2005), and Christian Smith and Patricia Snell, Souls in Transition: The Religious and Spiritual Lives of Emerging Adults (New York: Oxford University Press, 2009).
4C. S. Lewis, "Christian Apologetics," in God in the Dock: Essays on Theology and Ethics (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1970), p. 101.

Chapter 1: The New Rhetoric of Youth Ministry

'Scholars who overlook the church or religion as possible responses to adolescent problems include Kenneth Kenniston, The Uncommitted: Alienated Youth in American Society (New York: Delta, 1960); Francis lanni, The Search for Structure (New York: Free Press, 1989); Joy Dryfoos, Adolescents at Risk: Prevalence and Prevention (New York: Oxford University Press, 1990); Reginald Jones, ed., Black Adolescents (Berkeley, Calif.: Cobb and Henry, 1989); Mary Piplter, Reviving Ophelia (New York: Ballantine, 2002); Lyn Mikel Brown and Carol Gilligan, Meeting at the Crossroads (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1992); Patricia Hersch, A Tribe Apart (New York: Fawcett Columbine, 1998); Thomas Hine, The Rise and Fall of the American Teenager (New York: Perennial, 2000); and Ron Taffel, The Second Family (New York: St. Martin's, 2001). Two important exceptions were the Carnegie Corporation's research and the ongoing research of Search Institute (cf. A Matter of Time [Washington, D.C.: Carnegie Corporation of New York/Carnegie Council on Adolescent Development, December 1992]; Dale Blythe and Eugene Roehlkepartain, Healthy Communities, Healthy Youth [Minneapolis: Search Institute, 1993]).
'See Stuart Cummings-Bond, "The One-Eared Mickey Mouse," YouthWorker Journal 6 (Fall 1989): 76-78; Mark Senter, The Coming Revolution in Youth Ministry (Wheaton, Ill.: Victor, 1992); Milton J. Coalter et al., "A Re-Forming Agenda," Presbyterian Survey 82 (July/August 1992): 12-13.
'Albert van den Heuvel, The New Creation and the New Generation: A Forum for Youth Workers (New York: Friendship Press, 1965).
4Kenda Creasy Dean, "A Review of the Literature on, and a Descriptive Overview of, Protestant, Catholic, and Jewish Religious Youth Work in the U.S." (technical paper, Washington, D.C., Carnegie Council for Adolescent Development, 1991), p. iv.
5Ronald White, "History of Youth Ministry Project" (unpublished midproject report submitted to the Lilly Endowment, Indianapolis, Ind., August 20, 1994), p. 7.
6As of this writing (March 2003), Lilly funds implementation grants for youth and vocation in eighty-eight U.S. colleges, for youth and theology programs in fortyeight U.S. seminaries, and for seven multi-institution research projects on youth ministry, youth and religion, and related subjects.
'See Peter Berger, "Epistemological Modesty: An Interview with Peter Berger," The Christian Century, October 29, 1997, pp. 972-78.
'These themes are not new in adolescent research; G. Stanley Hall's tone Adolescence (1904) gave a prominent place to conversion, defined psychologically (Adolescence [New York: Arno Press, 1969]), and Erik H. Erikson's research on adolescent identity formation in the 1950s and 1960s describes the adolescent search for ideology in explicitly religious terms (see Youth Identity and Crisis [New York: W. W. Norton, 1968]). For approaches to secular research that reclaim a place for spirituality in the healthy development of children, see Robert Coles, The Spiritual Lives of Children (Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1990); Robert Kegan, In Over Our Heads (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1994); and James Gabarino, Lost Boys (New York: Free Press, 1999), to name a few.
9Thanks to Dave Zimmerman for this anecdote. Personal correspondence, January 26, 2011.
10The first of these won small but influential followings as early as the 1960s; Sara Little's Youth, World and Church (Richmond, Va.: John Knox Press, 1968) and later David Ng's Youth in the Community of Disciples (Valley Forge, Penn.: Judson Press, 1984) stand out in this regard. Attempts to couch youth ministry in terns of practical theology have been uneven, in part because no consensus exists on the nature of practical theology itself.
"Laying much of the intellectual groundwork for this perspective were Sara Little at Union Theological Seminary, William Myers at Chicago Theological Seminary, Michael Warren at St. John's University, Robin Maas at Wesley Theological Seminary, Richard R. Osmer at Princeton Theological Seminary and, above all, Craig Dykstra at the Lilly Endowment.
"See Miroslav Volf, "Theology for a Way of Life," in Practicing Theology, ed. Miroslav Volf and Dorothy C. Bass (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2002), pp. 250-51.
"James Coleman, The Adolescent Society (New York: Free Press, 1961).
14For examples of this new rhetoric's approach to culture, see Tom Beaudoin, Virtual Faith (San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1998); Tony Jones, Postmodern Youth Ministry (El Cajon, Calif.: Youth Specialties, 2000); Evelyn Parker, Trouble Don't Last Always: Emancipatory Hope Among African American Adolescents (New York: Pilgrim, 2003); Pete Ward, Liquid Church (Peabody, Mass.: Hendrickson, 2003).
15Once again it was the Lilly Endowment that helped translate this renewed interest in Christian practices into ministry with young people. Thanks in large part to a fertile partnership between Christian educator Craig Dykstra at Lilly and church historian Dorothy Bass of Valparaiso University, multiple efforts to make the practices of the church the primary curriculum for youth ministry sprang up in the 1990s and 2000s (see Dorothy Bass's Practicing Our Faith [San Francisco: jossey-Bass, 1997] and the subsequent volume for teenagers, Dorothy Bass and Don Richter's Way to Live [Nashville: Upper Room, 2002]).
16This exercise is greatly adapted from Stephen Brookfield and Stephen Preskill's Discussion as a Way of Teaching (San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1999), pp. 77ff.

Chapter 2: God Is a Minister

'As a side note, this has been true for mostly all of the meaningful theological perspectives that have moved the church in a new direction; the monk, Luther, and the pastor, Barth, were far from the center of respected academic work, but through their construction the church responded with attention.
'Understanding and reflecting on the Scriptures and tradition of the Christian faith no doubt takes some work and skill. But this reflection is done with the conviction that it will point us to the living God, who gives us the Scriptures and tradition in order to understand and join in his continued Ministry today. We'll get into much of this shortly.
'See Sara McLanahan and Gary Sandefur, Growing Up with a Single Parent (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1994); Robert Putnam, Bowling Alone (New York: Simon & Schuster, 2000); and Don Browning et al., From Culture Wars to Common Ground (Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 1997).
4Laura Sessions Stepp, Unhooked: How Young Women Pursue Sex, Delay Love and Lose at Both (New York: Riverhead Books, 2007).
5This exercise is adapted front Stephen Brookfield's Becoming a Critically Reflective Teacher (San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1995), p. 77.

Chapter 3: Youth Ministry as an Integrative Theological Task

'Karl Barth elicits further what I mean (though perhaps with harsher rhetoric than is helpful): "If [theology] is ranked as a science, and lays claim to such ranking, this does not mean that it must allow itself to be disturbed or hampered in its own task by regard for what is described as science elsewhere. On the contrary, to the discharge of its own task it must absolutely subordinate and if necessary sacrifice all concern for what is called science elsewhere. The existence of other sciences, and the praiseworthy fidelity with which many of them at last pursue their own axioms and methods, can and must remind [theology] that it must pursue its own task in due order and with the same fidelity. But it cannot allow itself to be told by them what this means concretely in its own case. As regards method, it has nothing to learn from then" (Church Dogmatics 1.1, trans. Geoffrey Bromiley and Thomas F. Torrance [Edinburgh: T & T Clark, 1936], p. 8).
"Theology cannot be classed under a `universally valid' concept of Wisseuschaft but, like other subject matters, has its own internal logic, or, as Barth put it, its own consistent path to knowledge in accord with its own specific object of knowledge" (Hans Frei, Types of Christian Theology [New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 1992], p. 104).
3Douglas John Hall, Thinking the Faith (Minneapolis: Fortress, 1991), p. 402.
'Ibid., p. 412.
5Hall provides a full summary of why theology is contextual, which, because of space constrictions, cannot be unpacked above. Here's a very brief synopsis: "We must How attempt to say why this theology is contextual, that is: what is the rationale of theological contextuality? Three fundamental reasons can be adduced: (1) Theology is a human enterprise, (2) theology attempts to speak of the living God and of God's relation to a dynamic creation, and (3) theology exists for the sake `of the church's confession"' (ibid., p. 93).
6 Ibid.
'Even Barth, with his heavy rhetoric on the needed distinction between theology and all other systems and fields of thought (as we will see below), agrees that theology must be contextual: "The [theologian] ... must think and speak in a particular age and should thus be a man of his age, which also means a man of the past that constitutes his age, i.e., an educated man" (Cllurc h Dogmatics 1.1, p. 284).
8Hall, Thinking the Faith, p. 91.
9"The church [or the theologian] has the function of answering the question implied in man's very existence, the question of the meaning of this existence" (Paul Tillich, Theology and Culture [London: Oxford University Press, 1959], p. 49).
10Tillich's correlational method was picked up and revised by David Tracy who, while holding to the same Tillichian unity of theology and culture, pushed the task further, allowing culture not only to ask questions but also to provide answers. Instead of theology and culture in a one-way conversation, where culture asked and theology answered, from Tracy's perspective both culture and theology could ask and answer, allowing for a true dialogue. According to Tracy, then, not only did culture need theology but also theology needed culture in order to exist at all. See David Tracy, Blessed Rage for Order (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1996).
"James McClendon, Witness (Nashville: Abingdon, 2000), p. 37.
"Hall, Thinking the Faith, p. 358.
13See George Hunsinger's How to Read Karl Barth (New York: Oxford University Press, 1993) for a discussion on how Barth's theological method is constructed around the divine/human perspective.
14See also James Loder's The Logic of the Spirit (San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1998) as an example of this method. Loder uses the same Chalcedonian pattern, though with a number of distinct Loderian contributions. See also "Normativity and Context in Practical Theology" in Practical Theology: International perspectives, ed. Friedrich Schweitzer and Johannes van der Ven (Berlin: Peter Lang, 1999).
15See Deborah van Deusen Hunsinger, Theology and Pastoral Counseling: A New Interdisciplinary Approach (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1995), p. 65, for a nice definition of these three terms.
16See the epilogue of Hunsinger's How to Read Karl Barth for a discussion of secular parables of the truth.
17`Chalcedon's resolution of this biblical problem, insightful as it was in some respects, created other, lasting problems for the church whenever it applied to its theology the rule of Scripture; for it substituted for the relational language of the Bible a substantialistic language that, while perhaps comprehensible within the Hellenistic framework, is no longer helpful even if it can be made to overcome the basic ontological leap-which is doubtful. We have seen that the `two natures' Christology never has been an adequate positive statement of the biblical witness to the Christ, and today it is usually falsely scandalous and a barrier to faith" (Douglas John Hall, Professing the Faith [Minneapolis: Fortress, 1993], p. 513). Hall continues, "What I mean is that the historic church's adherence to Chalcedon, while it has made possible a modicum of consensus with respect to the central figure of Christian belief, has also encouraged a faith that is more nearly assent to doctrine . .. than trust in the one to whom doctrine tries feebly to testify.... The internal question in the process leading to and following Chalcedon is whether it does not signify a quite different kind of interest in the Christ-different, that is to say, from what is present in the witness of the newer Testament itself" (ibid., p. 401).
""For Luther, the sole authentic locus of [humanity's] knowledge of God is the cross of Christ, in which God is to be found revealed, and yet paradoxically hidden in that revelation" (Alister McGrath, Luther's Theology of the Cross [Malden, Mass.: Blackwell, 1985], p. 149).
"'Representing the God of the Scriptures, Jesus moves toward humanity in unqualified commitment and love. Representing humanity, Jesus moves toward God in trust, obedience, and expectation" (Hall, Professing the Faith, p. 526).
20Ibid., p. 514.
"This representative perspective, I believe, also opens up conversations about ecclesiology. Neither the correlationalist nor the Chalcedonian method give much attention to the church. Hall explains how a representative Christology does this: "The church is not a substitute community but a representative community. It does not take the place of the world, it exists in behalf of the world. It is not an elite but an elect community: that is, it is chosen for service and as a means, not an end. It is the world that God loves and wills to engage, embrace, and heal. The church as means to that end is brought to appear before God, in and through Jesus Christ, to represent creaturely being" (ibid., p. 524).
22This exercise has been greatly adapted from Stephen Brookfield and Stephen Preskill's Discussion as a Way of Teaching (San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1999), pp. 57-60.

Chapter 4: Proclaiming Salvation

'Lance Morrow, "Just a Routine School Shooting: Special Report," Time, May 31, 1999, p. 110. Citations front J. D. Salinger, The Catcher in the Rye (New York: Back Bay Books, 2001), p. 30.
'Mark DeVries, Sustainable Youth Ministry (Downers Grove, Ill.: InterVarsity Press, 2008), p. 92. For a more extended discussion of professional trends in youth ministry, see Kenda Creasy Dean et al., OMG: A Youth Ministry Handbook (Nashville: Abingdon, 2010), pp. 107-27.
3These statistics may be found in Dean R. Hoge et al., Vanishing Boundaries: The Religion of Mainline Protestant Baby Boomers (Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 1994), p. 75; Richard R. Osmer, Confirmation: Presbyterian Practices in Ecumenical Perspective (Louisville: Geneva Press, 1996), p. 4; Peter Scales et al., The Attitudes and Needs of Religious Youth Workers: Perspectives from the Field (Minneapolis: Search Institute, 1995), p. 13; Philip J. Murnion et al., New Parish Ministers (New York: National Pastoral Life Center, 1992), p. 52, cited by MarkA. Lamport, "The Professionalization of Youth Ministry," The Edge 3 (April 1999); Kenda Creasy Dean, "Overview of Protestant, Catholic, and Jewish Religious Youth Programs in the U.S." (technical paper, Washington, D.C., Carnegie Council for Adolescent Development, 1991).
'Walter Kirn, "The Danger of Suppressing Sadness," Time, May 31, 1999, p. 48.
s"Mass Shootings at Virginia Tech," Report of the Virginia Tech Review Panel, April 16, 2007, p. 33 <www.governor.virginia.gov/TempContettt/techpaneI report.cfm>; also, Amy Gardner and David Clio, "Isolation Defined Cho's Senior Year," The Washington Post, May 7, 2007 <www.waslhingtonpost.conl/wp-dyn/ content/article/2007/05/05/AR2007050501221.html>.
'Salinger, Catcher in the Rye, p. 204.
'James E. Loder, The Logic of the Spirit (San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1998), p. 204.
'For a full explanation of Loder's theory of adolescence and the relationship between theology and the gain and loss of self, see Logic of the Spirit, chaps. 9-11.
Erik H. Erikson, Identity, Youth and Crisis (New York: W. W. Norton, 1968), p. 233, italics mine. Erikson called the search for "fidelity" the most urgent striving of youth, and believed that the ability to give and receive fidelity marks the conclusion of adolescence (p. 265). Feminist psychology has nuanced Erikson's theory by noting that girls tend to develop identity in the context of relationships. Erikson describes a pattern more common to boys in which autonomy may precede intimacy. Feminist psychology does tend to avoid virtue theory; however, fidelity is the signature strength (virtue) to be developed by both boys and girls during adolescence if identity is to be achieved. For theories of identity formation in girls, see Carol Gilligan, In a Different Voice: Psychological Theory and Women's Development (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1982); Judith V. Jordan et al., Women's Growth in Connection (New York: Guilford Press, 1991). For a theological interpretation of theories of girls' development, see Carol Lakey Hess, Caretakers of Our Common House (Nashville: Abingdon, 1997).
"Roberta C. Bondi, To Pray and to Love: Conversations on Prayer with the Early Church (Minneapolis: Fortress, 1991), pp. 121-22.
"The story of Christian martyrs at Columbine quickly became exaggerated urban legends; still, no one disputes the fact that many students responded in the crisis with courageous Christian conviction and charity. Two girls who were fatally shot, Rachel Scott and Cassie Bernall, were explicitly held up by their families and friends as Christian martyrs. Cassie's life was chronicled by her mother, Misty Beruall, in She Said Yes: The Unlikely Martyrdom of Cassie Bernall (New York: Plough, 1999).
12Patricia Hersch, A Tribe Apart (New York: Ballantine Readers Circle, 1999), pp. 10-30.
13,Joh11 Cloud et Al., "Just a Routine School Shooting: Special Report," Time, May 31, 1999 <www.tinte.cont/time/magazine/article/0,9171,991076,00.hnul>.
t4Author unnamed, Life, July 1999, p. 18.
15See Kenneth j. Gergen, The Saturated Self.• Dilemmas of Identity in Contemporary Life (New York: Basic, 1991).
16Janies Fowler, "Perspectives on Adolescents, Personhood, and Faith," in Christ and the Adolescent: A Theological Approach to Youth Ministry, 1996 Princeton Lectures on Youth, Church and Culture (Princeton, N.J.: Princeton Theological Seminary, 1996), pp. 1-12.
I7Coninunitarian responses to youth work span secular as well as theological sources. See for example cognitive psychologists David Elkind, The Hurried Child: Growing Up Too Fast Too Soon (Reading, Mass.: Addison-Wesley, 1981) and All Grown Up and No Place to Go (Reading, Mass.: Addison-Wesley, 1984); James Fowler, Stages of Faith (San Francisco: Harper & Row, 1981); Robert Kegan, The Evolving Self: Problem and Process in Human Development (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1982) and In Over Our Heads (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1994); sociologist Francis X. J. lanni, The Search for Structure: A Report on American Youth Today (New York: Free Press, 1989); and public policy advocates the Carnegie Corporation, A Matter of Time: Risk and Opportunity in the Nonschool Hours (Washington, D.C.: Carnegie Corporation of New York/Carnegie Council on Adolescent Development, 1992); Peter Benson, The Troubled Journey (Minneapolis: Search Institute/Lutheran Brotherhood, 1990); and Dayle Blyth and Eugene Roehlkepartain, Healthy Communities, Healthy Youth (Minneapolis: Search Institute, 1993). A journalist's account of adolescence that has received enormous media attention is Patricia Hersch's A Tribe Apart (see it. 35). To sample a range of theological perspectives that cone together around conimunitarian concerns for youth ministry, see David Ng, Youth in the Community of Disciples (Valley Forge, Penn.: Judson Press, 1984); Duffy Robbins, The Ministry of Nurture (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1990); and John H. Westerhoff, Will Our Children Have Faith? (New York: Seabury Press, 1976). Ng, for example, belonged to the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.); Robbins is United Methodist; Westerhoff is Episcopalian; Maas is Roman Catholic.
18Like their communitarian colleagues, liberating individualists have supporters across the disciplines of social science as well. Feminist psychology, for instance, despite its emphasis on the centrality of human relationality, seeks to develop skills of resistance in young girls so that they are not co-opted by patriarchal communities (see Lyn Mikel Brown and Carol Gilligan, Meeting at the Crossroads: Women's Psychology and Girls' Development [Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1992]; Hess, Caretakers of Our Common House). See also Ronald L. Koteskey, "Adolescence as Cultural Invention," in Handbook of Youth Ministry (Birmingham, Ala.: Religious Education Press, 1991); sociologists Mihaly Csikzentmihalyi and Reed Larson, Being Adolescent: Conflict and Growth in the Teenage Years (New York: Basic, 1984); and educator Paolo Freire, Pedagogy of the Oppressed (New York: Seabury Press, 1973). A recent journalist's account of American adolescence from this perspective that has received much attention is Thomas Hine, The Rise and Fall of the American Teenager (New York: Avon, 1999). Again, the range of theological perspectives clustered around the liberating individualist approach to youth ministry is impressive. See World Council of Churches publications Albert van den Heuvel, The New Creation and the New Generation (New York: Friendship Press, 1965); Arsj. van der Bent, From Generation to Generation: The Story of Youth in the World Council of Churches (Geneva: World Council of Churches, 1986); Sara Little, Youth, World and Church (Richmond: John Knox Press, 1968); Mary-Ruth Marshall, "Precedents and Accomplishments: An Analytical Study of the Presbyterian Youth Fellowship of the Presbyterian Church in the United States, 1943-1958" (Ph.D. dissertation, Presbyterian School of Christian Education, 1993); William R. Myers, Black and White Styles of Youth Ministry: Two Congregations in America (New York: Pilgrim Press, 1991); Maria Harris, Portrait of Youth Ministry (New York: Paulist, 1981); and Michael Warren, Youth Gospel Liberation (San Francisco: Harper & Row, 1987). Little, Marshall and Myers belong to the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.); Harris and Warren are Roman Catholic. For a more detailed summary of both the communitarian and liberating individualist approaches to youth ministry as we enter the twenty-first century, see Ketida Creasy Deaii, "Research Report: Practical Theology and Adolescence in America," International Journal of Practical Theology 2, no. 1 (1998), pp. 132-54.
19H. Richard Niebuhr, The Meaning of Revelation (New York: Collier, 1941), pp. 52, 59.
20Ibid., p. 57.
21This exercise is almost completely taken from Stephen Brookfield's Becoming a Critically Reflective Teacher (San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1995), p. 150.

Chapter 5: Walking into the Crisis of Reality

'This anecdote has been significantly changed from what really happened, and "Ryan" is not this person's real name.
2RayAnderson says it like this: "As a theological discipline, the hermeneutical task of the Church is to continue to search out and seek to be conformed to the hermeneutical structure of revelation itself, as given in Holy Scripture. Thus, the ministry of the Church necessarily involves theological reflection and a correction of its own inevitable tendencies to create ministry for its own justification" ("A Theology for Ministry," in Theological Foundations for Ministry, ed. Ray Anderson [Edinburgh: T & T Clark, 1979], p. 19).
'hi the postscript of this book I present a deeper understanding of divine and human action and articulate how different youth ministry thinkers (sonietinies innately) bring divine and human action together in their thought. If you really want to see how Kenda and I are different, turn to the postscript.
'Karl Barth, "The Place of Theology," in Theological Foundations for Ministry, ed. Ray Anderson (Edinburgh: T & T Clark, 1979), p. 22.
5"Theology itself is a word, a human response; yet what makes it theology is not its own word or response but the Word which it hears and to which it responds. Theology stands and falls with the Word of God, for the Word of God precedes all theological words by creating, arousing, and challenging then. Should theology wish to be more or less or anything other than action in response to that Word, its thinking and speaking would be empty, meaningless, and futile" (ibid., p. 30).
6See Robert Kolb's "God Kills to Make Alive: Romans 6 and Luther's Understanding of Justification (1535)," Lutheran Quarterly 12 (1998): 33-56.
DDouglas John Hall says it this way: "Revelation is not ... the communication of ideas about God and the things of God, even though ideas are included in the experience of revelation, as they are included in the experience of meeting another human being. Revelation, however, is the `divine-human encounter' (Emil Brunner)" (Thinking the Faith [Minneapolis: Fortress, 1991], p. 407).
'Ibid., p. 286.
9Even Karl Barth, who is known for his tenuous assertion that theology is speaking of God by the way God has acted, reveals the need to attend to the crisis people confront in existence as a place for theological fodder: "There is no man who does not have his own god or gods as the object of his highest desire and trust, or as the basis of his deepest loyalty and commitment. There is no one who is not to this extent also a theologian. There is, moreover, no religion, no philosophy, no world view that is not dedicated to some such divinity.... There is no philosophy that is not to some extent also theology" (Barth, "The Place of Theology," p. 23).
10This is Kierkegaard's move against the Hegelian system.
"Douglas John Hall, Bound and Free: A Theologian's Journey (Minneapolis: Fortress, 2005), p. 45.
"Anthony Giddens argues that we are not so much in a postmodern time, but a time of late modernity, a time when tradition has collapsed. He contends that if we are "post" anything we're post-traditional people. See his argument in Runaway World: How Globalization Is Reshaping Our Lives, rev. ed. (New York: Routledge, 2002) for a short discussion of this point.
13Hall says, "The substance of belief, in other words, is not that the Bible is true, but rather that that towards which the Bible points us is true. The truth as such is incapable of containment in words, even the inspired words of the Bible." He continues, "Certainly neither Zwingli nor Calvin were prepared to equate the Bible-with revelation. For them, too, revelation is a dynamic and personal encounter. All the same, their humanistically grounded respect for `the sources' led then to place much more faith in the Word written than the still-medieval man Martin Luther could ever have done" (Thinking the Faith, pp. 120, 406).
14There is an element (maybe even a significant one) of critical realism in illy perspective.
15Hall says it this way: "What is important ... is neither a priori approval nor a priori disapproval of society but (as we have put it in the foregoing) the engagement of society. It is dialogue that is called for-a dialogue in the course of which the disciple community may learn to `discern the signs of the times,' and thus be able to bear testimony to a hope which both incorporates and transcends the possibilities and rini possibilities inherent in the situation" (ibid., p. 115).
16"Meanwhile, a great many novelists, dramatists, and filmmakers showed pie our world in nonideological terns, causing me to remember Tillich's dictum that Art can depict three states: hope, false hope, and hopelessness (and, he said, art in our time overwhelmingly depicts hopelessness). I learned more from the artists and writers of novels than from the social scientists, whose testimony has always seeped to me too easily tainted by ideological interests" (Hall, Bound and Free, p. 47).
17 Ray Anderson, maybe more than any other theologian, has sought to articulate how ministry precedes and produces theology. He says, "One fundamental thesis will control this discussion-the thesis that ministry precedes and produces theology, not the reverse. It rust immediately be added, however, that ministry is determined and set forth by God's own ministry of revelation and reconciliation in the world, beginning with Israel and culminating in Jesus Christ and the Church." Anderson continues, "Theology, thus, serves as the handmaid of ministry, proclaiming it as God's ministry and making known the eternal being of God. This knowledge of God, as Calvin reminds its in the opening paragraphs of his Institutes, leads us to a knowledge of ourselves. We cannot contemplate the nature of God in his revelation without contemplating our own nature and purpose" ("A Theology for Ministry," p. 7).
1SMartin Luther, Werke (Weimar: H. Bohlaus Nachfolger, 1883-2009), 5.163.28. See also Douglas John Hall, Remembered Voices (Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 1998), p. 42.
19This exercise drew slightly on Stephen Brookfield's "learning journal" idea in Becoming a Critically Reflective Teacher (San Francisco: jossey-Bass, 1995), p. 97.

Chapter 6: Youth Ministry as Discerning Christopraxis

'See Jurgen Moltnann, The Way of Jesus Christ (Minneapolis: Fortress, 1990); Ray Anderson, "Cliristopraxis: The Ministry and the Humanity of Christ for the World," in Christ in Our Place: The Humanity of God in Christ for the Reconciliation of the World (Essays Presented to James Torrance), ed. Trevor Hart and Daniel Thiniell (Exeter, U.K.: Paternoster, 1989), and The Shape of Practical Theology (Downers Grove, Ill.: InterVarsity Press, 2001); and Richard Osmer, The Teaching Ministry of Congregations (Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 2005).
2Moltmann powerfully points to this reality: "`The tragic sense of life' is a fundamental existential experience, for it is the experience of the death of human existence. `Life is a tragedy, and a tragedy is a perpetual struggle without victory or hope of victory-simply a contradiction"' (The Trinity and the Kingdom [Minneapolis: Fortress, 1993], p. 36).
'For the remainder of this chapter, I will be using "the interpreter" to refer to not just an individual but also a group or community who functions as the interpreter. I have chosen the singular construction for grammatical flow only.
4Rudolf Bultmann, "Hermeneutics and Theology," in The Hermeneutics Reader, ed. Kurt Mueller-Vollmer (New York: Continuum, 1994), p. 246.
5Ibid.
6"God's future is Hot that he will be as he was and is, but that he is on the move and coming towards the world. God's Being is in his coming, not in his becoming" (Jurgen Moltmann, The Coming of God [Minneapolis: Fortress, 1996], p. 23).
Jurgen Moltmann, The Theology of Hope (Minneapolis: Fortress, 1993), p. 179.
8"Christ's resurrection is therefore not a historical event; it is an eschatological happening to the crucified Christ and took place `once for all' (Rom. 6.10)" (ibid., p. 69). My point here is that it is an eschatological event, yet one that took place within history.
9Jurgen Moltmann, God for a Secular Society (Minneapolis: Fortress, 1999), p. 11.
10Moltmann, Theology of Hope, p. 188.
""The hope of resurrection does not overcome the deadliness of death by regarding living and dying as mere summary expressions for the transience of all things and as such important, but by proclaiming the victory of praise and therewith of life over death and over the curse of godforsakenness, by announcing the victory of God over the absence of God" (ibid., p. 210).
i2Moltmann highlights the systemic nature of our humanity: "For nothing in the world exists, lives and moves of itself. Everything exists, lives and moves in others, in one another, with one another, for one another, in the cosmic interrelations of the divine spirit. So it is only the community of creation in the Spirit itself that can be called `fundamental"' (God in Creation [Minneapolis: Fortress, 1993], p. 11). He continues pointedly, "To be alive means existing in relationship with other people and things. Life is communication in communion. And, conversely, isolation and lack of relationship means death for all living things, and dissolution even for elementary particles. So if we want to understand what is real as real, and what is living as living, we have to know it in its own primal and individual community, in its relationships, interconnections and surroundings" (ibid., p. 3).
13See Luke 10:25-37.
14Adriaan Peperzak, To the Other: An Introduction to the Philosophy of Emmanuel Levinas (West Lafayette, Ind.: Purdue University Press, 1993), p. 31.
15"God or the Holy Spirit joins the concrete You; only through God's active working does the other become a you to me from whom my I arises. In other words, every human you is an image of the divine You" (Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Sanctorum Communio [Minneapolis: Fortress, 1963], pp. 54-55).
"Anderson, drawing from Moltniann, adds to this point: "Jurgen Moltmann suggests that a `hermeneutics of origin,' which grounds theology in scripture alone (sola Scriptura) must understand that Scripture is grounded in Christ, not only historically but eschatologically" (Shape of Practical Theology, p. 37).
17 Barth continues this thought: "The witness of Holy Scripture to itself consists simply in the fact that it is witness to Jesus Christ. And the knowledge of the truth of this self-witness, the knowledge if its unique authority, stands or falls with the knowledge that Jesus Christ is the incarnate Son of God" (Church Dogmatics 1.2, trans. Geoffrey Bromiley and Thomas F. Torrance [Edinburgh: T & T Clark, 1956], p. 485).
18Ray Anderson, The Soul of Ministry (Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 1997), p. 22.
19Anderson, Shape of Practical Theology, p. 109.
20"You will recall my insistence on defining the hermeneutic task not in terns of the author's intention supposedly hidden behind the text, but in term's of the quality of being-in-the-world unfolded in front of the text as the reference of the text" (Paul Ricoeur, Essays on Biblical Interpretation [Philadelphia: Fortress, 1980], p. 108).
21See Theodoor van Leeuwen, Surplus of Meaning: Ontology and Eschatology in the Philosophy of Paul Ricoeur (Amsterdam: Rodopi, 1981).
22Nancy Lammers Gross, If You Cannot Preach Like Paul (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2002), p. 115.
13 These roles are taken from Stephen Brookfield's Becoming a Critically Reflective Teacher (San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1995), p. 153.

Chapter 7: God's Hiddenness, Absence and Doubt

'Eberhard Jungel, God as the Mystery of the World (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1983), p. 49.
2Douglas John Hall drives this point deeper, saying, "In short, there has been little space for not-knowing (agnosis) and for `existential doubt' (Tillich) in the dominant traditions of the faith concerning the knowledge of God. Or, to speak more accurately, these traditions have too categorically celebrated the victory of knowledge and certitude over ignorance and unbelief. They have not been content to engage in an ongoing dialogue with the antithesis, but have presented the knowledge of God as a finished accomplishment for those who could profess the faith" (Professing the Faith [Minneapolis: Fortress, 1993], p. 93).
'Hall explains this overemphasis and points us in the direction we will be headed: "As we have seen, all three conventional paths to the knowledge of God have stressed the positive element to the virtual exclusion of the negative: (1) God is Self-revealing, but few have explored the depths of the concealment that is entailed in every profound self-revelation. (2) God is the counterpart of our human being and quest, but few of those who formulated for the church the normative outlines of its Theology have pondered how such knowledge of God is affected by our real alienation, our sense of being-alone and being-against. (3) God is the conclusion our minds must reach if they observe the cosmos rationally, but few have struggled with the irrational, the absurd, the contradictory and chaotic dimensions of our human experience of the cosmos, which, at least today, can hardly be ignored." Hall, continues, "Thus (1) the revealing God has been presented too consistently as one in whom the (negative) dimension of concealment is lacking; (2) God as counterpart of the human spirit has taken too little account of the human sense of `being alone'; and (3) God as the reasonable consequence of thought about the world has not been sufficiently cognizant, at least for our epoch, of the unreasonable, disjointed, and absurd world, the world that would hardly lead anyone to the splendid conclusion that it is the beloved of a Creator" (ibid., pp. 93, 136).
4This is the very argument that James Loder makes in his book The Logic of the Spirit (San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1998). Loder seeks to explain how negation is a driving force in human development-or to say it another way, how the human spirit seeks for the Spirit of God as the human spirit recognizes its negation.
5Hall explains this using Tillich: "Children, as Paul Tillich never tired of insisting, instinctively ask ontological questions. It is instinctual with them because, in their earliest stages of self-awareness, their very survival and growth depend upon their coming to terns with the consciousness of their own being-and with the prospect of not being. What Tillich called `the shock of non-being' is perhaps a greater shock to the five-year-old than to the thirty-year-old, who has already learned subtle psychic techniques for repressing it. Very young children have been known to be so obsessed with death, despite the relative absence of actual death from their experience, that they could overcome it only with the help of skillful and sensitive adults" (Professing the Faith, p. 315).
61 am borrowing this struggle between possibility and nothingness from Eberhard Jungel. It will be a theme throughout this chapter. John Webster further explains Jungel's position: "Jungel seeks to suggest that transience is `in being': it is not itself nihil but rather it demonstrates `a tendency towards nothingness.' Transience as it were straddles being and non-being: `Transience is the struggle between possibility and nothingness, the struggle between the capacity of the possible and the maelstrom of nothingness.... And insofar as we have understood possibility as ontological more primary than actuality, we may also say: transience is the struggle between being and non-being.' If the negativity of transience is its `tending towards nothingness,' its positivity consists in the possibilities it contains; for possibility is not merely that which is unrealised (and so lacking in `being'), but much more `the capacity of becoming"' (Eberhard Jungel: An Introduction to His Theology [London: Cambridge University Press, 1986], p. 70).
"Becoming is suffering. One must `suffer' one's becoming ... from childhood to adolescence," Hall says (God & Human Suffering: An Exercise in the Theology of the Cross [Minneapolis: Fortress, 1986], p. 65).
'Hall beautifully states my point here: "Because in this social context people have lost the sensitivity to recognize the sometimes subtle ways in which children and adolescents (as well as the aged and the dying) raise ontological questions, such questions are regularly transmuted by parents and teachers (and by physicians and others who serve humanity at the other end of the life-span) into technical questions. For example, the child asks, `How did I get here, Daddy?' and the modern father, elated at the precocity of his offspring, proceeds with his son's first sex lesson. But the child is not asking for technical information about the intricacies and delights of reproduction, most of which lie could not possibly grasp anyway; he is asking about `being-here.' He wants someone to explain, or at least to listen to, his new and unsettling sense of existing, of being different from other existing things, of being, however, like the dead bird he discovered among the flowers, impermanent, subject to overwhelming change, the plaything of tine" (Professing the Faith, p. 316).
9For clarity, I am arguing that hiddenness is part of God's very being. I am not arguing that absence is, however. Absence is not part of God's nature, but because God has gone to the cross, absence is a part of God's being (and therefore good), as we will see, in the sense that God being absent to Godself assures us that God will meet us in our own experiences of absence.
101 ani using the via negativa in a very specific way. Late scholasticism tended to use it as a method to help then more faithfully speak of God's nature. Luther, drawing on this perspective, used the dialectic to speak of how God encountered us. He knew God was present; his great breakthrough was how. So, recognizing that the "where" question is a question born after modernity, I an following Luther in his articulations, but doing so by placing them alongside the "where" question.
""Martin Luther, who understood well this dialectic of revealing and concealing Deus revelatus/Deus absconditus-regarded it as the cornerstone of the theologia crucis. Luther learned this dialectic, not only front the Scriptures of Israel and the church, but from the whole submerged tradition of Christian mysticism" (Hall, Professing the Faith, p. 140). Jurgen Moltmann continues, "The dialectical principle of `revelation in the opposite' does not replace the analogical principle of `like is known only by like,' but alone makes it possible. In so far as God is revealed in his opposite, he can be known by the godless and those who are abandoned by God, and it is this knowledge which brings them into correspondence with God and, as l John 3.2 says, enables then even to have the hope of being like God" (The Crucified God [Minneapolis: Fortress, 1974], p. 28).
""If the mode of knowing God is one that discourages the contemplation of God's actual hiddenness and inaccessibility, this already contains a decisive statement about the nature of the Deity. What it precludes is the ineffable otherness of God. Only faith-that is, faith understood as trust within the context of relationshipenables the disciple community to preserve a Theology that takes seriously the mystery and livingness of God" (Hall, Professing the Faith, p. 95).
13"The hddenness of God under its opposite, as Luther called it, cannot however mean that in this particular hiddeiiiiess God contradicts himself, but rather must mean that God corresponds to himself in this hiddeiiiiess. Even in the greatest of all imaginable contradictions, even in the contradiction of eternal life and earthly death, God corresponds to himself. The being of God is capable of this contradiction. Indeed, God's being is realized in this contradiction without being destroyed by it. God endures it. And this endurance of the contradiction of life and death is God himself, it is the depth of God's glory" (Eberhard Jungel, "The Revelation of the Hiddenness of God: A Contribution to the Protestant Understanding of the Hiddeneness of Divine Action," in Theological Essays II [Edinburgh: T & T Clark, 1994], p. 130).
14Jungel, God as the Mystery of the World, p. 166.
15Moltmann, The Crucified God, p. 28.
16Jungel asserts, "Based on the word of the cross, which emphatically proclaims that the one who was raised from the dead is the Crucified One, we answer that the being of God is first revealed as creative being in the struggle with the annihilating nothingness of nothing" (God as the Mystery of the World, p. 218). Jungel continues, "God's being does not first become love because love is necessary to counter nothingness. Rather, because God is love as he is himself, lie counters nothingness and its power. Because God is love, this is then God's being: to be related to nothingness" (ibid., p. 222).
i'Jungel, God as the Mystery of the World, p. 197.
18This is the very argument of Moltmann's beautiful book The Crucified God, in which he states, "In the passion of the Son, the Father himself suffers the pains of Abandonment. In the death of the Son, death conies upon God himself, and the Father suffers the death of his Son in his love for forsaken man. Consequently, what happened on the cross must be understood as an event between God and the Son of God" (p. 192).
19One of the major advantages of this perspective is that it keeps Christology and soteriology together. Too often, both in theological discourse and ministerial conceptions, Christology and soteriology fall into distinct categories. The cross achieves some soteriological effect, but it has little to do with the very person of Jesus Christ. Here, the very person of Jesus as incarnation God who comes to its as hidden, absent and absurd achieves our salvation by so being. Salvation is won not by beating nothingness but by being overtaken by nothingness.
20Jiingel, God as the Mystery of the World, p. 224.
"We could call this vocation.
22Alister McGrath says it this way: "God is revealed in the passiones et cruceniand yet he is hidden in this very revelation. In the very things which human wisdom regards as the antithesis of deity-such as weakness, foolishness And humility-God stands revealed in the humility and shame of the cross" (Luther's Theology of the Cross [Malden, Mass.: Blackwell, 1985], p. 149).
23Jiingel (as Luther) argues that this theology of the cross is Pauline: "For Paul, the Crucified One is weak, subject to death. But Paul does not celebrate this thought with melancholy, but rather thinks of it as the gospel, as a source of joy. What is joyful about the weakness of the Crucified One? The weakness of the Crucified One is for Paul the way in which God's power of life is perfected (II Cor. 13:4). Weakness is then not understood as a contradiction of God's power. There is, however, only one phenomenon in which power and weakness do not contradict each other, in which rather power can perfect itself as weakness. This phenomenon is the event of love" (God as the Mystery of the World, p. 206).
24Molt1iiann, The Crucified God, p. 205.
25So then there is not an analogia entis between humanity and God, but an analogy of nonbeing. Humanity is bent toward nonbeing, and in God's freedom (for encounter with humanity), Godself takes on completely nonbeing.
2e"What, then, is the theology of the cross? The theology of the cross announces that God is found in death, for it is there that boundaries disappear. In the death of sin, of suffering, of uncertainty, and marked by service, Christians are assured that God is present. The theology of the cross is therefore a theology of grace, a theology of freedom, and a theology of trust. These are words of hope and promise that are vital and indispensable regardless of history or context" (Anna M. Madsen, The Theology of the Cross in Historical Perspective [Eugene, Ore.: Pickwick Publications, 2007], p. 241).
27`It is not a heroic suffering to which we are called, but only a suffering that be longs to our creature hood. We have long been acquainted with it-though we have avoided, repressed, and resented its reality" (Hall, God & Human Suffering, p. 133).
2SJungel, God as the Mystery of the World, p. 217.
29Moltmann, The Crucified God, p. 246.
""What is most significant for our present concerns in all of this is that the theology of the cross as Luther elaborates it is a theology that determines to take its stand within the experience of negation" (Douglas John Hall, Lighten Our Darkness: Toward an Indigenous Theology of the Cross [Linea, Ohio: Academic Renewal Press, 2001], p. 114).
31"For this theology, God and suffering are no longer contradictions, as in theism and atheism, but God's being is in suffering and the suffering is in God's being itself, because God is love. It takes the `metaphysical rebellion' up into itself because it recognizes in the cross of Christ a rebellion in metaphysics, or better, a rebellion in God himself: God himself loves and suffers the death of Christ in his love. He is no `cold heavenly power,' nor does he `tread his way over corpses,' but is known as the human God in the crucified Son of Man" (Moltmann, The Crucified God, p. 227).
32Hall, Lighten Our Darkness, p. 116.
33Madsen, The Theology of the Cross in Historical perspective, p. 155 (italics mine).
34Ha11, God & Human Suffering, p. 90.
35This exercise is adapted from Stephen Brookfield and Stephen Preskill's Discussion as a Way of Teaching (San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1999), p. 74.

Chapter 8: Is Jesus Magic?

'This exercise is adapted from Stephen Brookfield and Stephen Preskill's Discussion as a Way of Teaching (San Francisco: jossey-Bass, 1999), p. 73.

Chapter 9: Talking About Sin with Young People

'Karl Barth, Epistle to the Romans (London: Oxford University Press, 1933), p. 167.
'Ibid., p. 169.
3This exercise is taken from Stephen Brookfield and Stephen Preskill's Discussion as a Way of Teaching (San Francisco: jossey-Bass, 1999), pp. 68-69.

Chapter 10: Holding On to Our Kisses

'Augustine, Confessions, trans. Henry Chadwick (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1992), p. 24. G. Stanley Hall, whose 1905 tone Adolescence more or less christened the twentieth century as the "age of adolescence," viewed psychology as a new theology and based his theory of adolescent psychology around the close relationship between sexuality and spirituality during adolescence. Hall hypothesized (incorrectly) that puberty signaled a period of "storm and stress" caused by budding sexual maturation and that this turbulence was best resolved by adolescent "conversion" (defined not as reconciliation with God, but as a harmonization of drives and instincts). See G. Stanley Hall, Adolescence: Its Psychology and Its Relations to Anthropology, Sex, Crime, Religion, and Education, vols. 1 and 2 (New York: D. Appleton, 1908).
'Dag Hantntarskjold, cited in Urban T. Holmes, A History of Christian Spirituality: An Analytical Introduction (New York: Harper and Row, 1980), p. 150. I am indebted to Christian educator Korey Lowry for pointing out this excerpt.
3Ibid., pp. 150-51.
'Ibid., p. 151.
'Information provided by the guides at the Amish Farm and House, Lancaster, Pennsylvania, via phone interview (August 30, 1999).
"According to Christianity Online, 12 percent of pastors have had sexual intercourse outside of their marriages, and 18 percent have had other sexual contact with someone besides their spouse. Cited in "Avoiding an Affair," Vital Ministry (September/October 1999): 19.
'UNAIDS/World Health Organization, "Global Facts and Figures 2009" <www .unaids.org/en/dataanalysis/epidemiology/2009aidsepidemicupdate>.
'Robert Wuthnow, "Religious Upbringing: Does It Matter and If So, What Matters?" in Christ and the Adolescent: A Theological Approach to Youth Ministry (Princeton, N.J.: Princeton Theological Seminary, 1996), p. 79; also Peter L. Benson and Carolyn H. Elkin, Effective Christian Education: A National Study of Protestant Congregations-A Summary Report on Faith, Loyalty, and Congregational Life (Minneapolis: Search Institute, 1990), p. 38. For the relationship of this research to youth ministry, see Mark DeVries, Family-Based Youth Ministry: Reaching the Been-There, Done-That Generation (Downers Grove, Ill.: InterVarsity Press, 1994), and Kenda Creasy Dean and Ron Foster, The Godbearing Life: The Art of Soul-Tending for Youth Ministry (Nashville: Upper Room, 1998).
9Star Wars creator George Lucas told Bill Moyers that Luke Skywalker, the Star Wars protagonist, must learn "not to rely on pure logic, not to rely on the computers, but to rely on faith. That is what `Use the Force' is, a leap of faith. There are mysteries and powers larger than we are, and you have to trust your feelings in order to access theme" (Bill Moyers, "Of Myth and Men," Time, April 26, 1999, p. 94).
"Mark Bego, "The Madonna/Pepsi Controversy," The Eighties Club: The Politics and Pop Culture of the 1980s (New York: Cooper Square Press, 1992) <http:// eiglttiesclub.tripod.cont/id135.htni>. The popularity of the video remained unabated; more than twenty years later, producer Ryan Murphy reintroduced the song to a new generation of listeners on the teen TV series Glee-and explicitly recalled the 1989 version by placing a gospel choir in the performance in ways reminiscent of the original video.
"For a provocative and slightly different exposition of the Like a Prayer video, see Tom Beaudoin, Virtual Faith: The Irreverent Spiritual Quest of Generation X (San Francisco: jossey-Bass, 1998), pp. 74-75 and 90-92. I think Beaudoin overexegetes the video; for instance, he cites media analysis suggesting that Madonna's natural brunette tresses in the video symbolize a return to her Catholic "roots" (M. Rettenmund, Totally Awesome 80s [New York: St. Martin's, 1996]). This may be more likely than Beaudoin's suggestion that Madonna's hair color honors the Afro-Peruvian saint portrayed in the narrative, Martin de Porres, patron saint for the poor, interracial justice, daily work and (according to Beaudoin) hairdressers. My own exposition of the video is more cynical, but no less admiring, than Beaudoin's: I maintain that Madonna's artistic decisions, like those of other commercially distributed musicians, are ultimately made for marketing more than for symbolic reasons. Obviously, seamless storytelling is an element in good marketing.
"Beaudoin, Virtual Faith, p. 82.
13See Neal Gabler, Life the Movie: How Entertainment Conquered Reality (New York: Knopf, 1998), reviewed by Nicholas Lemann, "Lost in Post-Reality," Atlantic Monthly, January 1999, pp. 97-101.
"Beaudoin, Virtual Faith, pp. 157-58.
15Michael Casey, A Thirst for God: Spiritual Desire in Bernard of Clairvaux's Sermons on the Song of Songs (Kalamazoo, Mich.: Cisterician, 1988), pp. 63-64.
16Ibid., p. 72.
17 For example, see Bernard of Clairvaux, "Sermons on the Song of Solomon," in The Love of God and Spiritual Friendship, abridged, edited and introduced by James M. Houston (Portland, Ore.: Multnomah, 1983), especially pp. 169-75.
18Homiletician Anna Carter Florence's exegesis of the Song of Songs offers the intriguing thesis that these texts may have been intended for the religious instruction of young people in the Hebrew community. See "E1ihu: Job's Unexpected Prophet," "To Dwell in the Gardens," "Wise in the World" and "Bread on the Water," unpublished sermons on the Song of Songs, presented at the Princeton Forum on Youth Ministry, St. Sinion's Island, Ga. (January 11-14, 1999), audiotape from Media Services, Princeton Theological Seminary, Princeton, N.J.
'Bernard of Clairvaux, The Love of God and Spiritual Friendship, pp. 169-75.
20See Catherine of Siena, The Prayers of Catherine of Siena, trans. Suzanne Noffke, O.P. (New York: Paulist Press, 1983), pp. 112-13. Cited in Robin Maas, Crucified Love (Nashville: Abingdon, 1989), p. 58.
21See Teresa of Avila, The Way of Perfection, trans. E. Allison Peers, from the critical edition of P. Silverio de Santa Teresa, C.D. (New York: Image, 1964), especially chap. 6.
22J owe this observation to an untitled presentation by Susan Neder, Sinipsonwood Retreat Center, Atlanta, Ga. (March 6, 1999).
23This exercise is adapted from Stephen Brookfield and Stephen Preskill's Discussion as a Way of Teaching (San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1999), p. 72.

Chapter 11: The Eschatological Significance of Summer Camp

'These results are part of the findings of the National Study of Youth and Religion. For the extended report, see Christian Smith with Melinda Denton, Soul Searching: The Religious and Spiritual Lives of American Teenagers (New York: Oxford University Press, 2005), p. 54.
'About half of American teenagers (49 percent) believe in life after death. Nine out of ten (91 percent) black Protestant teenagers, and 88 percent of conservative Protestant teenagers, believe in a judgment day when God will reward sonic and punish others. Only 63 percent of mainline Protestant young people believe this-and mainline Protestant teenagers were the least able to articulate what they believed and why. Understandably, Jewish youth ranked the lowest, with only 25 percent believing in a final judgment (Smith, Soul Searching, pp. 41-43; on the inarticulacy of mainline Protestant youth regarding their faith, see pp. 131-32).
3Martin Robinson, Sacred Places, Pilgrim Paths: An Anthology of Pilgrimage (London: Marshall Pickering, 1997), pp. 1-2.
4M ark Ralls, "Reclaiming Heaven: What Can We Say About the Afterlife?" The Christian Century, December 14, 2004.
5Jurgen Moltmann, Theology of Hope (San Francisco: Harper & Row, 1967), p. 16.
'Smith, Soul Searching, p. 157.
7These characteristics are part of a theological disposition of teenagers that Smith describes as "moralistic therapeutic deism." Smith concludes that "most religious communities' central problem is not teen rebellion but teenagers' benign `whateverism"' (ibid., p. 266).
'Margaret Miles, "The Recovery of Ascetism," Commonweal, January 28, 1991, p. 41.
9This exercise is adapted from Stephen Brookfield's Becoming a Critically Reflective Teacher (San Francisco: jossey-Bass, 1995), p. 78.

Chapter 12: What Are We Doing in These Mountains?

'This exercise is adapted from Stephen Brookfield and Stephen Preskill's Discussion as a Way of Teaching (San Francisco: jossey-Bass, 1999), pp. 70-71.

Chapter 13: The Mission Trip as Global Tourism

'Zygmunt Bauman, Globalization: The Human Consequences (New York: Columbia University Press, 1998), p. 77.
'Ibid., p. 77.
'ibid., p. 83.
'Karl Barth, "The Community for the World," in Theological Foundations for Ministry, ed. Ray Anderson (Edinburgh: T & T Clark, 1979), pp. 499-532.
5Ibid., p. 503.
'Ibid., p. 504.
7Ibid., p. 507.
'Ibid., p. 511.
9This exercise is adapted from StephenBrookfield's The Skillful Teacher (SanFrancisco: jossey-Bass, 1990), pp. 32-33.

Chapter 14: Doubt and Confirmation

'This exercise is adapted from Stephen Brookfield's The Skillful Teacher (San Francisco: jossey-Bass, 1990), pp. 119-21.

Chapter 15: Ascension Deficit Disorder

'See J. R. R. Tolkien, Tolkien on Fairy-Stories, ed. Verlyn Flieger and Douglas A. Anderson, expanded ed. (London: HarperCollins, 2008).
2Bettelheim maintained that fairy tales help us overcome the "existential predicament" that unites us as a species-i.e., formless, nameless anxieties about death, abandonment and meaninglessness-by giving those fears concrete form, allowing children to master them symbolically before they have to confront them personally. See Bruno Bettelheim, The Uses of Enchantment (New York: Vintage, 1989). Other developmental theorists have developed similar theses; Martin Lubetsky notes that telling fairy tales "is one way to elicit a child's inner thoughts and frustrations, reduce anxiety, and gain mastery over developmental tasks" ("The Magic of Fairy Tales: Psychodynamic and Developmental Perspectives," in Child Psychiatry and Human Development [June 1989]: 19, 245). Bettelheim's scholarly reputation has been called into question since his suicide in 1990, though most critics agree that The Uses of Enchantment remains a useful example of psychoanalytic insight. Still, as Australian educator James Parson points out, parents should be judicious about taking Bettelheim's verdict on fairy tales to heart: "Presumably, Bettelheim himself was told such tales as a child. It did Hot stop him from suffering acute depression all his life or from committing suicide" ("Fairy Tales and the Existential Predicament" <littp://parentingmethods.suitel0l.com/article.cfni/fairy_tales_and_tlie_ existentia 1_predica meat>).
"Joseph Pearce, "The Catholicism of The Lord of the Rings," in Celebrating MiddleEarth: The Lord of the Rings as a Defense of Western Civilization, ed. John G. West (Seattle: Inkling Books, 2002), p. 88; J. R. R. Tolkien, The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien, ed. Humphrey Carpenter (Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 2000), p. 147.
4 4 Frederick Buecliner, Telling the Truth: The Gospel as Tragedy, Comedy, and Fairy Tale (San Francisco: HarperOne, 1977).
51 ani retaining the term "kingdom of God" for historic and literary reasons, though I admit it can invite problems in a gender-sensitive culture. The genderneutral phrase "reign of God" could be substituted for the "kingdom of God" throughout this essay.
'This is in spite of a renaissance of academic interest in the subject, starting in the 1960s with Jiirgen Moltmann's Theology of Hope and continuing today.
71 an1 borrowing this phrase, with permission, from youth pastor and cartoonist Cuyler Black; see <www.inheritrhemirth.com>.
8Ann Morisy, Bothered and Bewildered: Enacting Hope in Troubled Times (New York: Continuum, 2009). 1 read Morisy's book after delivering this lecture, but the parallels are striking.
'See the excellent British Christian spirituality site Re:jesus <www.rejesus.co.uk/ spiritua lity/celtic_spirituality/index.httnl>.
"See Morisy, Bothered and Bewildered, p. 21.
112004 "Beliefs and Values Survey," cited by Albert Winseman, "Eternal Destinations: Americans Believe in Heaven, Hell," Gallup Commentary (May 25, 2004) <www.gallup.conl/poll/11770/eternal-destinations-americans-believe-lheaven- liell.aspx>.
"Results from an ABC News poll, reported by Dalia Sussman, "Poll: Elbow Room No Problem in Heaven," ABC News (December 20, 2005) <http://abcnews.go .com/US/Beliefs/story?id=1422658>.
13Christian Smith with Patricia Snelling, Souls in Transition: The Religious and Spiritual Lives of Emerging Adulthood (New York: Oxford University Press, 2009), p. 154.
14Don Peck, "How a New Jobless Era Will Transform America," The Atlantic (March 2010), p. 9 <www.tlleatlantic.com/magazine/print/2010/03/ltow-a-new- jobless-era-will-transform-america/7919/>.
15ibid., p. 5.
16Cited in ibid.
17Christian Smith with Melinda Denton, Soul Searching: The Religious and Spiritual Lives of American Teenagers (New York: Oxford University Press, 2005), p. 263.
"Byron R. Johnson, "Religion and Delinquency: A Systematic Review of the Literature," presentation for the Coordinating Council for Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention, Washington, D.C. (December 5, 2008).
19Kate Zernike, "Generation OMG," New York Times, Week in Review, March 7, 2009; also see Glen Elder, Children of the Great Depression, anniv. ed. (Boulder, Colo.: Westview, 1998).
20Morisy, Bothered and Bewildered, p. 13.
21Smith, Souls in Transition, p. 67.
22See Robert Wuthnow, After the Baby Boomers: How Twenty- and Thirty-Somethings Are Shaping the Future of American Religion (Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 2007).
"Rhonda van Dyke Colby, unpublished D.Min. thesis (Wesley Theological Seminary, 2000).
"Peter L. Steinke, cited in Morisy, Bothered and Bewildered, p. 75.
25William Meek, "Generalized Anxiety Disorder Prevalence Rates Based on Age," About.com Guide <http://gad.about.coni/od/prevaleiicerates/a/prevage.htni> (accessed July 6, 2010). Information cited from the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (Washington, D.C.: American Psychiatric Association, 2000); also D. H. Barlow, ed., Clinical Handbook of Psychological Disorders, 3rd ed. (New York: Guilford Press, 2001).
`Jonathan Reed, "Lost Generation" <www.youtube.com/watch?v=42E2fAWM6rA> (accessed July 5, 2010).
27Morisy, Bothered and Bewildered, p. 18.
"Studs Terkel, Hope Dies Last (New York: The New Press, 2003).
"Jurgen Moltmann, In the End-The Beginning: The Life of Hope (Minneapolis: Fortress, 2004), p. 27.
30lbid., p. 28.
31Morisy refers to a similar phenomenon in her J-curve analysis, in which decline must be anticipated and prepared for as an antecedent to growth (Bothered and Bewildered, pp. 41, 60).
32Jacques Ellul, Hope in Time of Abandonment, trans. C. Edward Hopkins (New York: Seabury, 1973), p. 89.
"John Wesley, The Heart of John Wesley's journal, ed. P. L. Parker and A. Birrell (New York: Fleming H. Revell, n.d.), pp. 35-36.
34These questions were posed in the book I coauthored with Ron Foster, The Godbearing Life: The Art of Soul-Tending for Youth Ministry, rev. ed. (Nashville: Upper Room, 2009), p. 17.
35Pope Benedict XIV, quoted in Morisy, Bothered and Bewildered, p. 18.
36Wikipedia describes Improv Everywhere as a "comedic performance group" based in New York City; the Improv Everywhere website (http://improvevery where.com) describes the group as a long-form improvisation troupe whose mission is to "cause scenes of chaos and joy in public places." Created in August of 2001 by Charlie Todd, Improv Everywhere has executed over one hundred "missions" involving tens of thousands of "undercover agents," usually random citizens pulled together for the sake of executing a short stunt. They have been featured on numerous media outlets and recently completed a public service stunt fort he New York Public Library based on Ghostbusters.
17 Thanks to the Reverend Stephen Cady, who sent me the link. All Improv Everywhere "missions" are captured on YouTube (www.youtube.com/user/IniprovEverywhere).
"This exercise is taken from Stephen Brookfield and Stephen Preskill's Discussion as a Way of Teaching (San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1999), p. 83.

Postscript: Reflecting on Method

'See "Normativity and Context in Practical Theology," in Practical Theology: International Perspectives, ed. Friedrich Schweitzer and Johannes van der Ven (Berlin: Peter Lang, 1999).
2Bernstein explains the point of his project, a point which clearly has significance for practical theology: "The guiding principle of this study is that the investigation of the nature, status, and significance of praxis and action has become the dominant concern of the most influential philosophic movements that have emerged since Hegel. The essential aim of this study is to understand what each of these philosophic movements has been telling us about action, how it is to be characterized, what issues must be confronted in coming to grips with action, and what is the significance of action in the attempt to understand what man is" (Richard J. Bernstein, Praxis and Action [Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1971], p. xiii).
'Bernstein points to ultimacy in Hegel: "When Hegel speaks of Geist in this manner, he is thinking of Geist as God who does not abandon the world to chance and accident but guides it by Providence." Bernstein continues, "Hegel is claiming that if we take a world historical perspective, we will see that there is an inner logos to the seemingly chaotic multiplicity of events. This logos has a teleological form. There is a narrative or `story' to be discovered in history-this is the epic of the devious ways in which Geist is realizing itself, moving from freedom and selfdetermination as an abstract idea to its concrete embodiment in human institutions" (ibid., p. 18).
'See Richard R. Osmer, Practical Theology: An Introduction (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2008).
5Especially through her conversations with James Loder.
'Craig Dykstra and Dorothy Bass, "A Theological Understanding of Christian Practices," in Practicing Theology, ed. Miroslav Volf and Dorothy C. Bass (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2002), p. 18.
7"The practices of the Christian community provide the human framework for faith, not its substance. At the same time, Jesus Christ, who knows better than to trust our sense of direction in trying to reach him, indwells these human actions and conies to us through them-and consequently, comes to the world through us. In the church, the Spirit moves and breathes through communities that imi rate Christ in these practices, supporting us as we wobble toward God" (Kenda Creasy Dean, Practicing Passion: Youth and the Quest for a Passionate Church [Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2004], p. 151).
'Ibid., p. 58.
9Ibid., p. 22.
10Ibid., p. 63.
"Ibid., p. 174.
"ibid.
""The church viewed the practices of faith as the Holy Spirit's chosen vehicle for conforming human passions to God's passion in order to construct a `new creation' around the core of divine love, and to redirect human desire toward the One whose love we truly seek" (ibid., p. 58).
"Bernstein asserts, "Alienation is clearly, for Marx, a social category-a category for understanding `political economy,' not an ontological category rooted in the nature of man" (Praxis and Action, p. 48).
15Bernstein explains Marx's view: "When man exists in a social situation where the objects that he produces and the `system' in which these are exchanged is such that his products gain a mastery over him and dehumanize him, then this form of objectification is alienation" (ibid., p. 46).
161bid., p. 307.
17 Ibid.
"ibid.
19David White, Practicing Discernment with Youth: A Transformative Youth Ministry Approach (Cleveland: Pilgrim Press, 2005), p. 15.
20As I mentioned in the introduction to this article, just because these thinkers draw primarily from one form of action does not mean that they are not appropriating others as well. Here we see White's interaction with a neo-Aristotelian perspective: "To gain a sense of place, congregations need to engage their young people in practices that resemble the discernment practiced by Christian communities throughout history, engaging the gifts and problems of their context through experience, reflection, discussion, and prayer, bringing their lives more fully into partnership with God's work" (ibid., p. 6). Because White locates human/divine interaction in history, his understanding of discernment is radically different from, say, Ignatius. Discernment itself is a tricky word; as it can mean putting episodes, contexts and experiences into discrete categories of human (the world, etc.) and divine, it is critical to state up front where the divine actually works. White isn't discerning within practices; he is using practices to discern God's work in history. In some ways, practices do not have a telos of their own for White because all of human history is the telos of human/ divine interaction.
"Ibid., p. 21 (italics nine).
22"These theological ideas and biblical clues help us to focus on often forgotten dimensions of youth ministry. Youth are not merely to be exploited by marketers, ignored or diminished by theorists, demonized by police, or patronized by adults with a status quo in view. Embraced by congregations seeking God's reign, the energies of youth can become something different than in the domesticated contexts of adolescence in which they are restrained, placated, distracted, or channeled for a productive adulthood" (ibid., p. 30).
231bid., p. 58.
24"Iu addition, youth ministry as it has evolved over these decades lacks significant critique of the shift in the social roles of young people in the second half of the twentieth century and into the twenty-first century, in which youth are increasingly ghettoized as passive consumers rather than treated as agents of faith influencing the common good" (ibid., p. viii).
251bid., p. 33.
26Ibid., p. vii.
27Bernstein, Praxis and Action, p. 213.
"Bernstein explains this perspective further: "Man from this perspective is seen as an active inquirer, and Peirce's theory of inquiry stands as one of the great attempts to show how the classic dichotomies between thought and action, or theory and praxis, can be united in a theory of a community of inquirers committed to continuous, rational, self-critical activity" (ibid., p. 199).
"Ibid., p. 190.
30See Chap Clark and Kara Powell, Deep Justice in a Broken World (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 2007).
31Chap Clark, "Youth Ministry as Practical Theology," Journal of Youth Ministry 7, no. 1 (2008).
"ibid., p. 14 (italics mine). I contend that this statement is a kind of transference. Clark believes from his pragmatist perspective that practical theology is about behavior, but he has failed to read even his own sources. Anderson's project seeks to place practical theology in the revelation of God, somewhere very different from behavior or conduct.
331bid.
34"The way to maintain the integrity of a practical theology model or method is to ensure that the Bible is the final definitive and authoritative source of truth, and all other data sets help to contextualize, understand, and align that truth in the service of God's kingdom" (ibid., p. 17).
"Clark really wants a process of inquiry to get to the right action, believing the right action can do touch. Some pragmatists may feel his biblical obsession breaks down inquiry, which is anathema for a pragmatist. I can therefore understand how some may be uncomfortable with Clark as a pragmatist, but in other ways it seems to fit. In other words, I ani not saying that Clark is a good pragmatist in the eyes of other pragmatists, only that lie is a pragmatist.
36ibid., p. 15.
37ibid., p. 29.
38"[A] communal process of reflection and discernment ... can go a long way in diffusing the limiting impact of our theological and cultural blinders" (ibid., p. 19).
39This is the way Clark's use of Christopraxis in "Youth Ministry and Practical Theology" seenis to be a misappropriation of Anderson's very point. Anderson constructs this theory to avoid rigid biblicalism. Anderson is working from a touch more Kierkegaardian existentialism than Clark can see. Clark mistakes Anderson's focus on the community of cohumanity to be the same as the coutnruttity of inquiry.
lucidly saw that his investigations led to a single terrifying conclusion: life is a form of despair from which there is no escape.... The thrust of Kierkegaard's dialectic is to show its the absolute absurdity of Faith and Christianity. This is the most absurd of all human thoughts" (Bernstein, Praxis and Action, p. 161).
41"Kierkegaard is not telling its to stand before our existential possibilities and courageously and authentically choose what we are to become. He is not telling its that we are free to choose the aesthetic life, the ethical life, or even the religious life. On the contrary, Kierkegaard seeks to show us that all choice, decisiveness, and action leads to despair" (ibid., p. 117).
41"Ironically, Kierkegaard's point of view does not lead to a celebration of acting inwardly, but rather to the utter despair that overcomes one when he realizes the impossibility of this situation. There is no escape from this despair except a `miracle'-the miracle of faith, but faith itself is only given to those who are saved by God's grace" (ibid., p. 118).
43The remainder of this section has been written by Blair D. Bertrand, which is why the third-person style of the above sections continues here.
44See James Loder's Logic of the Spirit (San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1998).
`"Andrew Root, Revisiting Relational Youth Ministry (Downers Grove, Ill.: Inter- Varsity Press, 2007), p. 107.
46Ibid.
"This exercise is adapted from Stephen Brookfield's The Skillful Teacher (San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1990), pp. 129-30.

↑ Back to top

↑