ANDREW ROOT
ANDREW ROOT
e were all sitting in a circle trying our best to do theological reflection on our concrete experiences in ministry-the issues and forces impacting the young people in our distinct contexts. We had articulated their pains, their moral failings, their family dysfunctions and the societal realities impinging on them. The energy in the small group was palpable. A contemplative silence came over us, but then someone finally said, "Well, then what should we or the church do? What programs or initiatives should be taken?" The group rustled with mounting energy, but as people cleared their throats and prepared to launch in, someone else asked, "But before we get there isn't there another question we should take up? Shouldn't we ask the distinctly theological question? Shouldn't we ask where is God?" The palpable energy disappeared, sucked up by the confusion over how (or even perhaps why) to answer, and the group of paid youth ministers and pastors again fell silent.
"Where is God?" Eberhard Jiingel explains, "Whether there is a God at all and what a God is, are decided for contemporary [people] by answering this question: Where can God be encountered and where can he be addressed as God?"' This question, Where is God? seems to be the very heart of ministry. Where do we and those we minister to encounter the living God? And yet while it is the heart of ministry, the answer seems to escape us. We desire for young people to know, trust and follow God, but few of us have thought about or can articulate where this God is to be found and how this God has made Godself known. Few have placed their actions in ministry in line with their theological conception of God's own action.
In the small group, someone finally spoke into the confused silence that descended after the "Where is God?" question: "Well, I think God is everywhere, so if God is everywhere then God is present everywhere." The group nodded. This nebulous answer seemed to appease its. No more thought was needed on the where question; we had decided where God was (everywhere), so now we were free to talk about programs, initiatives and things to be done.
Confusion never really left the group, though. "God is everywhere" seemed both right and yet unhelpful. For example, as we discussed young people's contexts we became very specific, providing concrete stories, examples and anecdotes for the issues they faced, but when it came to giving answers on the location of God in their lives, all we could muster was the very unspecific "everywhere." And in the light of the deep contextual realities of the young people we discussed, in the light of the deep pathos of their pain, to say God was everywhere was in effect to say God was nowhere-which is exactly how many of us in the group felt. "God is everywhere" became the escape hatch that freed us from having to really struggle with the presence of God (or lack thereof).
It seems that in youth ministry we tend to work from this perspective that God is everywhere. This is no doubt a legitimate theological assertion-but only if it is placed in paradoxical opposition. God is present and everywhere, but God is also absent and hidden. We have often been reluctant to allow this paradox to find its way into our theological conceptions of ministry. Sticking with God's omnipresence seems safe; it feels risky to discuss the absence and hiddenness of God. But unless we do so, our theological perspective on ministry doesn't allow for authentic experiences of suffering, yearning and loss.
RAMIFICATIONS OF THE EVERYWHERE-NESS
It was twenty minutes after his bedtime when my then three-year-old son, Owen, had beckoned me from my night of watching TV to his dark room, lit only by the faint blue glow of his nightlight which dimly illuminated the horde of stuffed animals surrounding his body. "Daddy, I'm scared!" he said to me. "I'm scared there is a nightmare in my closet. I'm scared."
Moved by compassion for his fear (and yet also wanting badly to return to the TV), I told him that he need not fear, because Jesus was with him and would protect him.
Frustrated, he shot back, "Where is Jesus? I don't see Jesus." I rambled something about Jesus always being with its, but he wasn't satisfied. With a worried quiver in his voice he said, "Jesus is not here."
I found to my shame that all I could do was provide polemics for my position of Jesus' everywhere-ness. "Yes, Owen he is," I asserted, but he stood his ground.
"No! He is not here!" The objective reality of his fear spoke louder than my Sunday school words.
"Jesus is here, Owen," I repeated, but he could only respond (loudly now, in fear and frustration), "Jesus is not here."
Again, I found myself replying, "Yes, Jesus is. Jesus is with you now."
"Where? Where?" he asked while choking back three-year-old tears. "Where is he? I'm scared!"
"If we pray, he will be here," I said, now starting to distrust myself. Up against his real fear, my affirmation of Jesus' presence was unhelpful. Owen could sense, I imagine, that I was more concerned with getting him over his fear and getting him to go to sleep than I was with acknowledging his deep terror.
It is not that the assertion that God is everywhere is wrong. Clearly God is not bound by time and space; as Creator, God possesses a unique interrelationship with creation itself (God is omnipresent, to use imported Greek thought). As the one who speaks being out of non-being, God is in a real way present in and through all that is. There is an everywhere-ness and above-ness to God's being and nature. It is from this above-ness that we have tended to articulate our theological conceptions about youth ministry, though, and as a result, three broad theological commitments have too often been overemphasized. This keeps its from being able to richly answer the "where" question.
1. An overemphasis on God as revealed. The church, the youth worker and youth groups as a whole tend to be seen and operate as the unveiler of God. Too often it is assumed that our actions, activities or words-whether the call for personal salvation or the work of social justice-summon or bring forth the unveiling of God. So we tell young people to pray, giving them models and acronyms, telling them that God will be present. But in so doing we never say anything about the silence or absence of God (a theological theme essential to the Reformation, as we'll see below).
Moreover, as part of discipleship, we often push young people to see God everywhere, to interpret every part of their lives as being in line with God. And we speak as if this is self-evident and obvious. Yet, though we have tried to convince young people that God has revealed Godself, our commitment to God's revealedness has not kept its from falling into broad abstract statements about the "where" of God. Like I did in my conversation with Owen, we continue to insist that God is here, that God is revealed, and like Owen, many adolescents ask (with or without words), "Where?" Up against fear, depression, longing and brokenness, they can only answer our repeated "God is here" with the heartfelt yearning of a three-year-old terrified of a bad dream: "Where is this God? God is not here."
2. An obsession with God as near. It is, of course, true that God is near. In the humanity of Jesus Christ, God is near to our humanity. But if God is person (as both trinitarian and incarnational perspectives claim), then God's nearness must be balanced by absence. We too often abstract God's nearness from God's personhood, talking about God's nearness as God always surrounding its in some amorphous way. Moreover, our clumsy statements about the "where" of God almost always ignore the absence of God. But the presence of a person is determined by absence. We know he or she is here because at other times he or she is not. The theology of Israel, the theology of the New Testament, assumes encounter and being encountered, being struck by presence, presence that is born from absence ("Surely, the LORD is in this place-and I did not know it!" [Gen 28:16]).
We tend to tell young people that God is near to them-that Jesus is like their best friend ("Jesus is just a prayer away!") and God their personal therapist-so faith means living as though God is always near, always watching and surrounding you. But when assertions about God's nearness do not take into consideration God's absence, answers to the "where" quickly lose solidity. When God is always near, God can no longer be one who acts and moves because God can no longer encounter us. Encounter itself demands presence puncturing absence-impossible if God is a substance, a metamorphic reality that is always around but hard to notice, like radio waves. So we explain to young people that if they do what it takes to tune themselves to God's frequency, they will recognize God, for God is near; God surrounds us; God is everywhere. However, just as we are unsure of where radio waves come from and how and when they get through our walls, we're not sure specifically "where" God is either. All we can say is, "God is near." But still, we encourage them to pray more, go to church more, read their Bible more, giving the impression that doing more will finally lead them to an understanding that God is on any frequency they tune to-everywhere.
But this can only work if God is found as a substance, as a frequency humming that is nevertheless hard to encounter. My three-year-old's fear, his nightmare, was in his closet. It was concrete; it was somewhere in the sense that, even though there wasn't really a nightmare in his closet, he could, without a doubt, name its location. In other words, his nightmare possessed a "where." Knowing exactly "where" his fear was, then, he sought a very concrete location for the "where" of Jesus. But my assertions about the presence of Jesus could not match the concreteness of his fear. I was unable to provide anything other than "Jesus is near," and with no concrete location, he was right to assume that his fear was more real than Jesus.
Like the nightmare in the closet, the suffering, broken hope and yearning of young people are often bound in a concrete "where" (the divorce of my parents, the rejection from my dream school, the shape of my body). We can assert all we want that God is near, but our assertion will be meaningless unless we can help them imagine the "where" of God as concretely as the "where" of their nightmares.
3. A fixation on God as a rational reality and therefore faith as something you must come to know or believe. When God is bound in God's everywhere-ness, then faith is bound in rationality. In other words, when we say God is everywhere but cannot say concretely "where," we clothe God in a rational system; we must defend that God is somewhere and fight to provide rational ground that God is not gone, that God exists. Thus, when young people assert that their nightmare is more real than Jesus, we too often seek to defend God and prove God's everywhere-Hess, instead of seeking God in the real-Hess/reality of fear and brokenness. We make artificial rational systems for God the ground of faith-and, having made these rational systems (or at least living with the residue of them), we then make doubt antithetical to faith.'
In his bedroom, though, my three-year-old doubts deeply: "Jesus is not here. I don't see Jesus. He is not here." The tenaciousness of his doubt, alongside the concreteness of his fear, witnesses to a yearning for faith. He wants to believe but has no idea what I am calling him to believe, for though his imagination has revealed the reality/realness of his fear, I cannot articu late to his imagination "where" Jesus is. He wants to believe, but I have given him only a rational ultimatum in which to believe. What he desires is some kind of framework in which to make sense of his experiences, but I have not provided one; I have not provided any way for him to understand "where" God is.
So we fight over who is right, and what's more real: his fear or my assertion that Jesus is here. They seem in opposition, with Jesus standing outside fear and doubt. I'm calling Owen away from what he knows is truethat he is scared-to trust in something else outside the fear he concretely experiences. And he is not ready to do that. His fear is irrational, but it is real; if Jesus cannot be found in his irrationality, then he cannot be real. Owen's fear and my position have thus become opposing views. As such, only the more rational view can will (at least, that is the mantra modernity sells us). I therefore turn on the light, open his closet door and show him that there is no nightmare there, and he agrees that he can rationally see nothing. But when the light goes off again, rationality has no say; his fear is more real than his rationality-the nightmare is there again.
Frustrated, I say, "Owen, be logical. There is no nightmare in your closet, so don't be scared. Jesus is here" (as if "be rational" is an incantation that sends fear, hurt and loneliness running). In actuality, rationality cannot battle the reality of fear, for rationality stops at the head, but fear and suffering are borne in the heart (and what is more real in the end, the head or the heart?). My plea for rationality alone to set the terms for reality forces Owen to either deny his fear in order to hold onto rationality and therefore have Jesus, or embrace his fear and therefore lose the everywhere-ness of God that I present to him.
With no concrete way of speaking about "where" God is, we must defend God, and defend that God is everywhere. Moreover, in asking young people to commit to God's everywhere-Hess, we are essentially trying to extract doubt from them. Often we treat doubt like a tumor, fearful that, if it's left in adolescents, it will grow and compound like a cancer, eventually killing their faith. But to extract doubt, the vital tissue of suffering, yearning and brokenness must be extracted with it, as though it were all meaningless waste. Doubt, however, may not be a tumor but the very organ of faith surrounded by the tissue of fear, brokenness and suffering. If this is true, we will have to imagine the "where" of God as somewhere other than in rational systems, for suffering, depression, yearning and brokenness do not bow to rationality but, rather, show the folly of rationality's pursuits for the throne of authority.3
WHAT IS A TEENAGER? THE ADOLESCENT'S ONTOLOGICAL STATE
We have often overemphasized the revealed, obsessed about nearness and become fixated on the rational because, at least in part, we believe that this is what adolescents need; our interpretation of their ontological state pushes its to articulate these theological overstatements. We have tended, for example, to view adolescence as a developmental time when advancement, preparation and growth are central, particularly intellectual, spiritual and biological growth. So we see it as a time when the young person is revealed to him- or herself as he or she grows toward adulthood, and a time when they advance their identity by discovering their gifts and abilities. It is about young people discovering themselves and making themselves known. Moreover, we assume it is a time for them to be near to themselves and others, and that the nearness of friends and lovers, in particular, becomes vital. In addition, we see it as a period of preparation. Education and learning are important, as youth are pointed toward the future. It is no longer enough for them to just be; it is a time for them to achieve and become and develop into something. We perceive adolescence as a time for the young person to rationally (through school and achievement) prepare for the future.
Some of these things are no doubt true culturally, but when we assume them ontologically-when we assume that growth, advancement and preparation are the pattern stamped on the fabric of adolescents' being, inseparable from their existence-we easily take on a theological perspective that forecloses and therefore overemphasizes the revealed, near and rational. So as youth workers we try to become the one who reveals God, brings God near and makes a rational case for faith. And the "where" of God itself becomes locked in the growth of the adolescent's faith, in the adolescent's achievement in the Christian life and in the adolescent's participation in godly activities. In other words, the "where" of God becomes bound in adolescent development. God is everywhere, as long as you keep developing and don't acknowledge the nightmare in your closet.
Yet there is a nightmare in our closet, a nightmare that we experience throughout the converging and diverging stages of life, a nightmare that cannot be disentangled from our ontological state.4 We must always be wrestling with the reality of non-being, with the truth that nothingness is our destiny, as nothingness even now exists within us; we are always pulled into crisis (as we examined in chapter five). Three-year-olds have bad dreams, fathers go through midlife crises and infants yearn for the face of their mother because to live, to be, is always to be close to non-beings We cannot be (and sooner or later will cease to be), but nevertheless, we are. If there is anything distinctive about the adolescent's developmental location it is that he or she confronts forcefully the dichotomy and struggle between nothingness and possibility.6
The journey of adolescence is not ontologically about growth, advancement and preparation but rather about recognizing (in head and heart) the possibilities for being and yet the thinness of it. Indeed, adolescence may be the time when we become sensitive to (and able to contemplate) our ontological state; we are aware both that there is possibility before us and that this possibility floats on the treacherous rapids of nothingness.? For example, the thought and experience of love is rich and the electricity is kinetic in adolescence, making the world's colors brighter. But the possibility of love conies with the awareness and experience that human love so often fails, and when it fails it brings with it a rush of annihilation. Bright colors give way to the gray, overcast burden of death. Life is to be lived, but life must be lived next to death, love must be lived next to hate, hope next to despair, dreams next to disappointment. The reality of truth cannot be avoided: to live is a great joy, but to live is also to encounter death and all its friends around every corner of possibility.'
Even more than being the time when we become sensitive to our ontological state, adolescence may be the period when the non-being that is true for us all throughout life seems closest to the surface, as the armor of denial, the armor of societal (and religious) avoidance of nothingness, is still too new, too big and too awkward to protect its from all the arrows of nothingness that never stop their onslaught on our being. As adults, mortgages, careers and 401(k)s have the power to distract its from the nearness of nothingness; they can deceive its into thinking that all that exists is possibility, that we need not dwell on nothingness. Adolescents, no doubt, have their own armor (SAT scores, friendship groups, sports and new jeans), but the young person's armor can feel ever so flimsy in the constant flow of change, with the cultural reality that possibility is ahead and their future is still to be written, yet they are dependent on others. A bad look, a bad grade, a break-up, family chaos and the nightmares in the closet show their face and whisper their threat: "Possibility may be before you, but you will never escape the nothingness."
When we assert that God is everywhere and this everywhere-ness is bound in the revealed, near and rational, then God can only be discovered in growth, advancement and attention to preparation. The perfect shiny kids (those growing, advancing and attentive to their preparation) are the poster children of serious faith. We give them the belief that if they do everything right, then their faith must be strong and true, and they will get what they want in life; in other words, we imply that they can control life. It then becomes our job as youth workers to get young people to grow, advance and be attentive by seeing God, being near to God and thinking correctly about God.
When we do this, though, we ignore that our very ontology is beingtoward-death. We ignore that adolescence at its core is an awakening to the fact (the fact that is true for us all) that life is the journey between possibility and nothingness. When God is everywhere, there is possibility (though admittedly abstract), but there is no room for nothingness. And without encountering nothingness, we have little to say about "where," concretely, God is found; all we have are abstractly fluffy words like "everywhere," "here" and "near." In essence, when we say that God is everywhere we refuse to see reality, and fail to stand between possibility and nothingness, to do ministry and theology between them, to name God's "where" alongside possibility and nothingness. And we fail to see that the God of Israel is a God who brings possibility out of nothingness.
In the process, we ignore that young people are exposed to the stiff winds of nothingness, and that a God who is everywhere provides no shelter. For in the end, this God who is everywhere is nowhere; this God who is everywhere has not known annihilation and nothingness and death. So he cannot be here in the swirling fear of a three-year-old, because this everywhere God has not known a moment when nothingness wraps itself around your being and suffocates it in fear, loss or dread.9 In short, up against suffering, yearning and brokenness, a God that is everywhere is no help, for this God has yet to know, from the inside, the suffering, yearning and brokenness of our humanity.
If God cannot be here in fear, then youth ministry is only for those kids who are positive, optimistic and whole. Young people who cannot meet this checklist are inevitably led to believe that, if they can't get better, God is not for them. And there are few (very few) who can meet this checklist and make it through adolescence without experiencing fear or pain. On the contrary, most young people are acutely aware of it. Yet we're not providing theological and practical perspectives that help them confront and seek God in the midst of suffering. Instead, their yearnings are often peripheral, not central, in our ministries. And in relegating their suffering, yearning and brokenness to the periphery, we may be keeping them from a faith that can help them face the rest of their lives.
THE EARLY REFORMATION AND THE VIA
In many ways the early Reformation revolved around the question, "Where is God?" Was God, for instance, found in the bureaucratic operations of the church? Was God, and was God's forgiveness, found in the church's sanctioned indulgences? In the period of late scholasticism on into the early Reformation, theological construction of the "where" of God was worked out in dialectics. True statements made about God's "where," like God being revealed, near and rational (or able to be thought of), had to be balanced by looking at their opposites. In other words, you had to go the way of the negative (via negativa) to step into the inner reality of the rich theological meaning of these assertions of God's "where."Io Following this, then, to claim that God is revealed, we must be able to claim that God is hidden; to claim that God is near to us, we must be able to claim God's absence; to claim that faith is a possibility for us, we must claim that it is absurd."
The early Reformers had to do this, for in their context, the revealed, near and rational perspective clearly put the human being in charge of God: it was human action that initiated divine action, the human agent was in control of God, and God was everywhere the church was, even in its corruption. In other words, God was present whenever the coffers of the pope rang with the sound of another coin.
But there was more than just this reason. Luther particularly understood that working the negative, or the opposite, pushes our theological construct into the ontological reality of nothingness. If God is hidden, absent and absurd, then not only can God not be caged in human systems, but also we are directed toward a God who stands between possibility and nothingness, bearing both.'2
If we take on the via negativa-saying outright that God is absent, hidden, not there, and that our faith is not rational but absurd, which therefore allows its to hold together the seeming opposites of revealed/hidden, near/ absent, rational/absurd-then we have a theological imagination that can speak to our ontological struggle between possibility and nothingness." Jungel says it this way: "The presence and absence of God are no longer to be thought of as alternative in the word of God. Rather, God is present as the one absent in the word."14 In the midst of the dialectic of nearness and absence, we are forced to look concretely for God's "where" not as a final destination but as an encounter. As Jurgen Moltmann explains, "It is the dialectical knowledge of God in his opposite which first brings heaven down to the earth of those who are abandoned by God, and opens heaven to the godless."" It is between possibility and nothingness that we encounter otherness, and it is between possibility and nothingness that we encounter ourselves. And if adolescence is the time when we are sensitive to this reality, sensitive to the possibility that is before its but also oh-so-aware that with possibility comes many forms of nothingness, then working with this dialectic may be how we begin to articulate the "where" of God in young peoples' lives."
The cross. Where thou is God, if God is not everywhere? Jiiugel reminds its, "Theology can do its assigned task only when, in answering the question `Where is God?,' it does not refer solely to `above us.' God is also below its. And that is the very way in which he is According to Jiiugel, following Luther, God is on the cross. God is on the cross as revealed and hidden, near and absent, rational and absurd. It is God, a crucified God that takes death into Godself, who sinks deeply into nothingness; God as the fullness of possibility completely takes on nothingness, bringing possibility itself out of nothingness. As Moltmann has argued, the fullness of the nothingness of death comes upon the Son, as the soul-tearing loss of one loved swallows the Father.'8 After the crucifixion, nothingness exists in the inner life of the Trinity itself, and it is out of this nothingness that God has made new possibility. It is out of the nothingness and through the nothingness of death that God forms the possibility of community between God and humanity and (as we will see) humanity and humanity.'9 The Trinity, then, exists between possibility and nothingness, and the crucified God reveals that it is out of nothingness that God creates all possibility. Jiiugel says it like this: "The fundamental aspect of the victory over death is not the `standing outside of nothingness' (extra nihilum sistere) which flees from nothingness, but rather the creative `standing into nothingness' (in nihilum sistere)."20
When we say that God is everywhere we have lost the concreteness of the encounter of God. In other words, we do not have a God who acts. But in the cross, God acts as God encounters death for life; God takes on nothingness for the purpose of new (redefined) possibility.21 It is the Creator who enters hell and creates out of it. It is the Creator as Reconciler who enters hell and nothingness to bring life and redemption.
The cross, then-the cross as concrete encounter in history-stands between possibility and nothingness and holds in tension the revealed, near and rational with the hidden, absent and absurd. God is revealed through the hiddenness of the peasant from Nazareth;22 God is near through the absence of death on the cross; God is worth following in the absurdity of his power being born in powerlessness and his kingdom being won in suffering, in the first being last and the last being first.23 Moltmann states, "When the crucified Jesus is called the `image of the invisible God,' the meaning is that this is God, and God is like this. God is not greater than he is in this humiliation. God is not more glorious than he is in this self-surrender. God is not more powerful than he is in this helplessness. God is not more divine than he is in this humanity."24 God is revealed in God's hiddenness through the incognito of humanity, and God is near in his absence in the suffering and nothingness of the cross. In paradoxical nature, then, hiddenness, absence and absurdity are pathways to speak of God's concrete "where," because they directly touch our ontological state-a state that God, through Christ, now shares.25
The revelation of God cannot be held within the everywhere-ness of creation or moral orders. It is found instead in the specificity (and yet universality) of suffering, the suffering of hiddenness and Through the cross, God turns suffering and nothingness into the location of God's presence. Thus, it is not growth, advancement and preparation that bring its close to the crucified God (this is the very theologia gloriae that Luther opposes). Rather it is in suffering, despair and nothingness that we encounter the actuality of God. But this cannot be a fabricated or produced suffering and despair, or a kind of acetic masochism.27 It can only be the suffering and despair of the nothingness that exists in our world and touches so deeply the ontological reality of nothingness within us.
In our work with young people, then, we have a clash, because on the one hand we want to hold tip and celebrate those youth who are role models of good citizenship, those seen as engaged students and successful leaders. But in truth they are not necessarily role models of faith, for our faith calls its to search for God between possibility and nothingness, between hope and despair (between the existential and eschatological, as we sketched out in the last chapter). In this theological perspective, the supposed loser young people-those invisible adolescents-are the ones where, in fact, God is at work, tip against their brokenness and yearning. The incarnate and crucified God calls its to search for God not in the fullness of success but in the emptiness of honest yearning.
So when Owen asks me where Jesus is, I can only answer that Jesus is here if I am able (and willing) to say that he is on the cross, that he is being overwhelmed with the same nothingness that threatens Owen's being. I must answer that God is not here like good thoughts, a poem or a word of encouragement; God is absent to such conceptions of Godself, for God is being crucified by death and all its friends, the same friends that now scare Owen.
And what about the cross in youth ministry? The cross has not been something that we have forgotten in North American youth ministry. Indeed, we discuss it often, explaining that our sins are forgiven through Jesus' death, and calling young people to claim the significance of the cross for their own lives. They, in turn, wear crosses on their T-shirts, as jewelry or as tattoo art, which somehow makes them representatives for God (their actions become, and can even control, God's presence). Our focus on the cross, however, has rarely set the terms for how we discuss God's "where." Rather, we have seen the cross solely as a sign of victory, as a static reality that provides something-not as the very state of God's being and acting in the world. The problem with viewing the cross as a static sign of victory is that the cross becomes a declaration of control, finality and certainty: God, through the cross, achieves complete control of the sinful world, finally conquering it, and becomes ultimately supreme. In this perspective, the cross is a sign of God's abstract everywhere-Hess and has nothing to do with hiddenness, absence and absurdity-which means that, in the end, the cross has little to do with the nothingness of our ontological state, and little to do with a God who joins God's very person with our nothingness.
In truth, the cross is only a sign of victory in that it is a sign of limit and death. It is in resurrection that we see victory and hope, that we see the full Hess of possibility-a possibility made actual by going through death. It is in the cross that we see nothingness, that God and God with us comes nose to nose with death and all death's friends. jt ngel explains this powerfully: "Talk about the death of God would then imply that God is in the midst of the struggle between nothingness and possibility. It corresponds to God's deity, and certainly does not contradict it.... Of course, the essence of God can no longer be put outside of this struggle, and one can no longer define God as an essence `above us' (supra nos). Rather, the essence of God is to be thought as being absolutely identical with his existence."28
The cross does achieve something. It is the backward battle with nothingness, the battle that overcomes nothingness, by being enveloped by nothingness. And it is a witness to God's economy where nothingness is only beaten by taking on nothingness. Indeed, the cross reveals "where" God is: in places of nothingness, making possibility out of impossibility, making life out of death. God does this making by taking on death so fully that nothingness is drawn into God's history. The cross is the sign that God will make life out of death, but it is just as much a sign that God makes Godself known in the hiddenness and absence of suffering, loss, yearning and brokenness. As Moltmann says, "If one describes the life of God within the Trinity as the `history of God' (Hegel), this history of God contains within itself the whole abyss of godforsakenness, absolute death and the non-God."29 When the cross is a sign of limit and death, it is a sign that God has entered fully into our ontological state, that God can now be found between possibility and nothingness.30 That is God's very "where"-in those places where the heaviness of nothingness is borne and yet out of the backwardness of bearing comes possibility.31
So then, Where is God? Where do we encounter concretely this God who stands between possibility and nothingness? It is in our suffering and despair; it is within the negation in ourselves and the world that we find the God of the cross; it is up against our ontological reality of nothingness that yearns from the same ontological core for possibility. Hall states, "So, Luther's Christ forever returns to his cross; to his grave, to hell, in order to be `with us.' He can be for us only insofar as he is with us."32 Youth ministry, then, can never be about avoiding or ignoring suffering, yearning, loss and brokenness. It can never be about creating a group of model adolescents for our own glory. Rather, youth ministry that seeks to encounter the crucified God seeks for God within nothingness, and stands with young people between possibility and nothingness.
Where is God? God is not everywhere, but specifically there, there tip against our pain, there tip against our questions, there tip against our broken dreams. And in that particular sense God is "everywhere"-everywhere there is pain and suffering. Anna Madsen writes, "Luther was eager to explain that Christ is where any sorrow or suffering exists, both of which ... concerns death."33 It is when we encounter the fear, loss, yearning and brokenness that we have encountered concretely the crucified God.
Moreover, when we (you and I) bear our nothingness together, God works to bring possibility out of our despair. God is here when I encounter you. In my bravery to stand with you in fear, longing and brokenness, I speak of God's hiddenness, absence and absurdity by bearing with you your suffering. But in standing within it and sharing it we recognize that God is revealed and near in our shared life.
So where then is Jesus, Owen? Jesus is there; Jesus is found at the location of your fear; Jesus is bearing your fear. To claim that Jesus is concretely located next to Owen's fear is to assert that Jesus is on the cross; it is to place the "where" of God at the level of what is concretely real to him, at the place of his suffering, fear, yearning and brokenness. Jesus is here hidden within it, for he is suffering it, so that out of Owen's fear might spring possibility.
Even to this response Owen would have rebutted, "But I don't see Jesus!" And I would respond, "No, but you see Daddy. Look at your Daddy; I see your fear. I feel your fear." When he looks at me, his fear no longer determines his reality, though its actuality is heavy. Rather, our shared life becomes his reality, for I see his suffering, and it is in our bearing of each other's nothingness that we encounter the God of possibility. What Owen was searching for was another to see the nothingness that surrounds him; he was seeking for nie to first deny the everywhere God so that a space might be opened to encounter God not beyond, around or outside his fear, but within it. And only after I have joined him in his despair am I ready to see the location of God.
God is found concretely at the place where persons share deeply in the nothingness of each other, for in so doing we follow the One who was crucified and made nothingness. But in shared life through suffering, we also witness beyond the nothingness of crucifixion to the possibility of resurrection, to the hope of restoration, healing and peace. When your suffering is shared in my person-when I see it, name it and open my person to your fear-it has become the suffering of the cross, for I witness in my person that your suffering is shared suffering: God is found in your suffering, bringing life from death.
WHAT DOES THIS MEAN FOR US?
Answering the "where" question in this way forces us to see our ministries and our very selves in ministry differently. We begin to see young people as similar to us in that they, too, have their being between possibility and nothingness. And the nothingness of existence becomes the curriculum for our youth ministry, because it is both the call to seek the "where" of God and the way to join deeply in adolescents' lives. Through our shared life, then, we encounter the "where" of God-but only as far as our lives are really shared, only as far as we are willing to see and be near to their nothingness. This can only occur if we see our vocation not as revealing God, bringing God near to them and making faith rational but ultimately as walking near the nothingness of adolescents by being in relationship with them. When we truly share in their lives in this way, we witness to a God who is revealed in hiddcmicss, who is near in weakness and suffering, and who calls us into the absurd backwardness of following a God who brings possibility out of nothingness.
Ministry, then, becomes seeking God as we share in the longings, fragile hopes and deep doubts of young people. These longings, hopes and doubts are not problems that we need to solve for then so that we can move on to something else. Rather, when God is found between possibility and nothingness on the cross, longings, fragile hopes and doubts become the very curriculum and direction of our ministries. The questions-not answersborne from our ontological state become the focus of our ministries. asks a helpful question that can easily be directed specifically to youth workers: "Too many Christians seen to feel that their primary calling is to provide answers. Might it not be that our better service is to give a language and a spiritual vantage point from which to explore the great questions of our age? The trouble with most answers ... is that they are usually provided by persons who have not lived long enough with the questions."'
When we share in nothingness as we long for possibility, ministry becomes focused on seeking for the hidden/absent God in the brokenness of our being. Making young people right no longer becomes the goal. Rather, the goal is to share in their impossibility as we await God's possibility, which conies only through nothingness. So we call them to search for God in their wounds and through their doubts. We speak about the absence of God with them, inviting them into a community of shared suffering where they can explore the perplexing nothingness in our societal structures and ourselves. We help them name the absence of God, and see the nothingness within themselves and around them. For only when they can see the absence of God can God become an actual subject to them; only then does God have a "where."
When ministry becomes about proclaiming and joining the "where" of God, we are freed from being either sellers of the faith or the moral police. If God is everywhere, if adolescence is about growth, advancement and preparation, if the Christian faith is about control, finality and certainty, then the practice of ministry revolves around convincing young people to somehow trust in and seek this nebulous God by avoiding things that would hamper their growth, advancement and preparation and by committing to the control, finality and certainty of Christianity. But when the "where" of God is encountered in the nothingness of the cross, which joins our own suffering, yearnings and brokenness, then ministry is, at its core, about being someone who can bear reality with young people. Then it is about being able to "call a thing what it is," being able to see suffering, loss and hurt and not turn from it and, indeed, even join young people in it as we seek for God's possibility.
When we train volunteers and new youth workers we are often concerned about giving them techniques and perspectives that can help them do good ministry and be successful. What is central instead is to help budding youth workers be bearers of reality, to help them be able to see, feel and attend to nothingness. We must encourage them to use their theological imagination to become comfortable with the existential anxiety that plagues most of us (themselves included) rather than fleeing from it. We may even need some theological perspective ourselves-perspective that touches our person enough to lead its out to search for God in the heavy nothingness of existence, and that helps its to be people always searching for the "where" of God alongside adolescents. And to see that this is the most beautiful thing that has ever been!
This means that we are the ones who must be able to speak of God's absence, hope with young people in darkness and search with you ng people through their deepest doubt. And in the paradoxical nature of the cross, by doing this we are able to speak concretely of the "where" of God. For we communicate with our words and with our presence in the adolescent's nothingness that God is there, that God is found in the feelings and actuality of Godforsakenness, that God is near in the midst of yearning that's up against impossibility, that God is found at the place of the struggle between possibility and nothingness.
• DISCUSSION AND REFLECTION EXERCISE
A Quote to Affirm, a Quote to Deny
Choose from within this chapter one quote that you wish to affirm and one quote that you wish to challenge.35 A quote may be chosen, for example, because you find it insightful or wrong or simply confusing. Then present these quotes in small groups, allowing for discussion after each person presents theirs.
The exercise will help you start reading theology in a way that doesn't demand that you be able to comprehend every element of the argument. Rather, this approach honors ideas, asking each person to find an idea (quote) or two that draws them into thinking more deeply.
