Chapter 11 of 20

9 Talking About Sin with Young People

9 Talking About Sin with Young People

ANDREW ROOT

s we read through the syllabus together on the first day of class, it became clear which topic was most significant to Natalie. I had just explained that on Friday of this one-week intensive course we would look at a case study in which someone prays for healing but never receives it. "Great! I can't wait to talk about that," Natalie said. And she said it with a force and engagement that demonstrated that her interest was much more than just intellectual; there was something personal about the topic that she was carrying with her into the course.

That Friday afternoon we began to look in-depth at the case study. It told the story of a high-school girl who was paralyzed at gymnastics camp. As she sat in the hospital unable to move, her father continued to pray for her, convinced that through deep prayer his daughter would be healed. After weeks of (what he interpreted as) failed prayers, he blamed his daughter, rationalizing that she simply didn't have enough faith that God would heal her. At the end of the case study, the students were told that the girlwhose father now refused to see her until she had enough faith-has phoned them and wants to talk. She desires a theological response to her father. Is he right? Does she lack faith? How and why does God heal some and not others?

Halfway through our conversation that Friday, Natalie couldn't contain herself any longer. "Why? Why does God not answer some prayers? I just don't get it! My friend Amanda is just struggling in life. She suffers from crippling depression and nothing helps. She really loves God and my friends and I have prayed constantly for her, but nothing helps. I don't get it! She feels like a failure, and so do we because we can't help her."

Acknowledging Natalie's deep pain and her friend Amanda's as well, I invited the class to look again at Matthias Grunewald's Crucifixion, a painting we had been using all week as a window into God's Ministry for the world through the church. We often forget to whom we pray for healing, I explained to them. Too often we imagine we are praying to the Jesus of Sunday school curriculum pictures, one who is clean and powerful, strolling through Galilee as confident as an all-pro football player and as powerful as a ruling politician. But it isn't the powerful, dominating Jesus that we pray to for healing, for this is not the Jesus of the Gospels. Rather, the Jesus to whom we pray is the beaten one; the crucified is the healing Lord. He who hangs on the cross, praying himself for God's rescue and yet hearing nothing, is the God that we come to asking for healing. We plead to the Jesus who himself pleads vigorously for the cup to be removed from him but whose request is met only with silence. The Jesus abandoned on the cross, whose father is witnessing the loss of his beloved son into the dark night of death, is the Jesus we pray to. Amanda and her friends pray to the Jesus who begs for God's intervention and yet is left to die in the vacuum of God's absence.

MAGICAL JESUS

Sometimes I think we imagine that the crucifixion is a ritual (maybe right out of Hogwarts) that earns Jesus the magic to free its from having to live in a world of suffering, a world where pain, brokenness, atrophy and death surround us and cannot be escaped. Or we may believe that Jesus provides a kind loophole of shelter that we can enter when safety from suffering and tragedy is needed. When my wife was a child, the media was, at one point, covering a number of cases of small children being kidnapped. Somehow she came to believe that if she was kidnapped, all she had to do was say to the culprit, "Unhand me in the name of Jesus!" and like a magical incantation, the culprit would release her and she would be safe. After all, she was told in her congregation that "the name of Jesus is powerful." But what kind of power are we talking about: the power of the cross or the power of magic?

A few years ago the comedian Sarah Silverman released a stand-up act in theaters and on DVD called Jesus Is Magic. Silverman, both inappropriately crass but also hilarious, explains in one of the early bits of her act how she would explain to her future children the difference between her Jewish religious background and that of her Christian boyfriend. In her deadpan manner she says, "We'll just be honest. We'll say `Mommy is one of the chosen people, and Daddy believes that Jesus is magic."' I think Silverman's commentary is right: most Christians do believe that Jesus is magic. Yet if Jesus is magic, then Natalie and Amanda are right to feel abandoned and neglected by God. If Jesus has the potion to shrink the tumor, repair the spine or erase the depression but refuses to use it for its and those we love, then we are left with few conclusions: either we have failed in the technique of our faith or God is a monster (or, at the very least, inconsistent, arbitrary and uncaring).

But Jesus isn't magic. Jesus is human. Jesus is the very incarnation of God; he's God with us-to bring its not magic but accompaniment, not "healing" (a quick solution to a problem) but salvation (intimacy with God and one another). Any healing that is more than a temporary solutionthat is, in other words, transformation (and therefore feels like or is salvation)-demands deep accompaniment. It demands that another enter into my world and bear my suffering not to magically take it away but to die with me if needed. In my darkest moments, what my heart yearns for more than a solution is a companion, someone who will link their heart to mine and assure me that no matter how ugly or scary things might get, I am not alone. The cross reveals this Jesus: not a magical one but a suffering one, not a God who takes away pain but a God who joins us in it.

WHAT ABOUT THE MIRACLES IN THE GOSPELS?

Stories in the Gospels maybe the reason why most people believe that Jesus is magic. Turning water into wine, multiplying fish and bread, raising dead children and friends, and casting out demons all seem like magical acts. The second-to-last act of the story then seems shockingly out of place as this magical Jesus hangs pathetically on a cross.

But most biblical scholars tell its that miracle stories are not stories of magic but rather stories which preview God's future. Jesus proclaims in word and act the future of creation in the future of God. In other words, Jesus declares and then represents in his actions what this future will be, what the world will be like in the end (this end has been called the eschatos and the study of it eschatology, as I already subjected you to in part one). Every miraculous act of Jesus is therefore a proclamation, a momentary and episodic lifting of the curtain to reveal the future of creation. Jesus states with such acts that in the end, in the future of God, death will have no place, everything will be in its right mind, hunger will be unknown, and all humanity will feast and celebrate without end in the presence of a loving father.

Of course, these acts are only a picture, a representation of the end (the eschatos), not its fulfillment. For instance, the raising of Lazarus reveals that one day all will be called from death to life to be embraced by Jesus, but of course Lazarus did die again. In the same way, the bread that was multiplied provided strength and joy to empty stomachs, a sign that one day stomachs will never be empty, but just hours later, poor children who were fed on the hillside returned home with stomachs that ached for more bread. And though the best wine was brought last, pointing to a future where feasting, laughing and worship will never end, that party ended, and the jugs of the best wine made from water lay empty. The miracles of Jesus are not the thing; the acts that look magic are not what is important. What is important is what these miraculous healing acts point to and reveal: they show its who Jesus is; they disclose that he is the fulfillment, that he is the end, that in his person is the future of humanity in the future of God. The miracles are not the thing; Jesus is the thing.

This then leads its back to Jesus on the cross, the beaten one, the one forsaken by God. When we pray for healing we are asking not for magic but for a glimpse, a hint, a limited experience of the end, of what will be in the eschatos. We acknowledge that it is only a taste, that even the child cured will one day be the adult buried. And we recognize that in this world (which is not the end), healing, safety and peace are not normative. Rather, the norm-the regular-is sickness, atrophy, danger and violence. Because this is our norm, we need a God who bears it. Because this is the world in which we must live, we need a God who enters it. Because death cannot be escaped, we need a Jesus who is not magic but rather is present, bearing the normative suffering of a dangerous world in his own body. We need a Jesus who pleads for healing and hears only silence.

The beaten and crucified Jesus has entered and made himself known in a world where the norm is suffering and death. Therefore we cannot solely equate healing and health with God's presence and suffering with God's absence. For if those who are suffering and receiving prayer experience nothing from God, they may feel like the exception and be led to assume that they have done something wrong spiritually; so many other Christians testify to healing and health, they reason, so their suffering must be abnormal, or somehow their fault. But the God of the cross reveals that it is normal to suffer. God's presence is found first not in acts of healing but in suffering and feelings of abandonment.

As youth workers we must therefore first acknowledge the presence of God not with those who've been healed but with those who are suffering. To be healed in this world is to be abnormal (even in the economy of God). It is neither earned nor normative but rather is simply a gift to the community, a small window into the future. Healing is wonderful, but weird; it is to be celebrated but not glorified; it is to be deeply appreciated, but not overly examined. To suffer, however, is to be embraced by the crucified God; to hear no answer to your pleas for help is to find community with One crucified. So when someone is healed we can be thankful, but when someone suffers without healing, their perceived Godforsakenness is the very thing that assures its that they are with God and God is for them.

One of my theological mentors, Dr. Ray Anderson, used to describe the following scenario:

When you're a pastor and someone stands and says, "Last night our daughter was driving home in the pouring rain. She hit a slick spot, slid into the ditch and flipped her car three times, totaling it, but she walked away without a scratch. The officer on the scene said it was a miracle she was alive! We just want to thank God for protecting her," what should you say? You should go over to the couple in the corner who lost their son in a hiking accident two months ago, and standing next to them, you should say, "We praise God that your daughter is okay, but we also reimeimber Jan and Tim, and know that God is with them also as they grieve the loss of Eric."

We might do the same with young people. When Matt stands and announces that his prayers have been answered and he has been accepted to his dream school, we should go and stand with Beth, who has received several rejections, and say, "We praise God for this, Matt, but we also know that God is at work and is with others who have suffered so much disappointment lately." Of course in doing this, we are not desiring suffering, and never should, but suffering, as those not healed know full well, cannot be avoided in this world.

FOR THE COMMUNITY

When someone is healed the community must celebrate, thanking and praising God for it. But our praise and thanks is never simply for the individual person, or for the purpose of receiving more healing, as if it were a commodity to be bargained for. Rather, in witnessing healing we thank and praise God and plead with God to bring God's future, to bring the end, to make what is abnormal normal for all people. And we can be confident that this future is on the way because the One who was crucified and forsaken by God has passed through death and has been resurrected by God. Jesus was not healed but resurrected; he was not given an extension to his life but new (everlasting) life, and not a repaired body but a new body. Through him this will be our future also: a life beyond all that threatens us.

This is what I tried to say to Natalie that day-that Amanda's feelings of Godforsakenness are the very sacraments of God's presence. And even in the hell of depression she can be assured that she is never alone and that she is embraced by the crucified God who promises a future where depression will evaporate in God's presence. But for now, her struggle and lack of healing do not make her abnormal or point to failed prayers or weak faith. Indeed, in this world suffering and brokenness are the norm. The good news is that her struggle is with the absence of God, which leads right to God's very presence-a presence that accompanies her now and promises a future where her struggles will cease forever in the ceaseless love of the God who overcomes this world by suffering it.

• DISCUSSION AND REFLECTION EXERCISE

Find an Illustrative Quote
Divide into small groups.' Each person should read to the group a quote or two they found in their reading of the chapter. These might be quotes they found challenging or helpful, or ones that they see as the key thesis of the chapter. The idea is to get the discussion to focus on the text itself. Therefore, each person should refer directly to the page and place of their quote. Any response to a quote must also refer back to the text itself.
It is important that this time not frustrate participants or keep them from adding their own personal connections, critique or affirmation. Rather, this exercise helps the discussion focus on the text at hand and not become lost (as too often happens) in anecdotal or tangent perspectives. After each person has had the opportunity to read a quote and responses that refer directly to the text have been shared, allow for more free-flowing conversation and connection.

↑ Back to top

↑